XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001: expand component inventory - #41
Conversation
Expand registry/components.json from Git source enumeration, generate the System Components view, refresh memory index and generated docs, and preserve runtime/deployment evidence as UNKNOWN where not inspected. XCSV-Agent: chatgpt XCSV-Agent-Role: primary XCSV-Work-ID: XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 XCSV-Issue: #30
|
Independent review — XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / PR #41 Verdict: CHANGES_REQUIRED. The inventory breadth is useful, but the generated registry currently contains systematic false-positive classifications and must not be merged as documentation truth yet. Blocking issues:
Required correction:
The candidate can remain PARTIAL_INVENTORY. The blocker is evidence precision, not lack of runtime verification. |
Fix database false positives, exclude XCSV_ADDONS governance/docs from runtime addon enumeration, and reserve SOURCE_WIRED for concrete wiring evidence. Add focused generator regressions and regenerate the component registry and System Components view. XCSV-Agent: chatgpt XCSV-Agent-Role: primary XCSV-Work-ID: XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 XCSV-Issue: #30
XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / issue #30Mode: READ / INVENTORY / CLASSIFY / DOCUMENT. This draft PR expands and corrects the component registry from PARTIAL_GITHUB_ONLY to PARTIAL_SOURCE_VERIFIED using Git source enumeration only. It does not claim deployed/runtime verification and does not delete or mutate gameplay/source files in member repos. Current candidate
Corrected counts
Review correctionResolved the independent-review blockers from issue comment 5364627180 / PR comment 5364626637:
False-positive examples now removed:
Outputsegistry/components.json regenerated from corrected generator.
Validation
Remaining UNKNOWN / NOT_REVERIFIED
Completion ImpactCOMPLETION_IMPACT: v1.0.0 Stopping for independent review. PR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. |
|
INDEPENDENT CONTROL REVIEW — PR #41 REMAINS DO NOT MERGE The prior evidence-precision defects are corrected, but the candidate still has a reproducibility/provenance blocker in Blocking findings:
Required correction: make the inventory generation provenance-bound and reproducible. Derive/accept explicit observed source identities; use repo-relative paths for external/member repos; do not silently include/omit ORCH based solely on presence of a machine-local directory. If an external source snapshot is required, make its repo identity + observed SHA explicit and fail/mark NOT_REVERIFIED rather than changing canonical output nondeterministically. Do not merge until corrected and independently reviewed. Preserve the new 4/4 evidence-precision regressions and all existing UNKNOWN runtime boundaries. |
XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / issue #30 receiptPR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. Candidate SHA: Provenance correction:
Observed source identities:
Corrected counts:
Portable ORCH path proof:
Validation:
Remaining UNKNOWN / NOT_REVERIFIED:
COMPLETION_IMPACT: v1.0.0 Stopping for independent review. PR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. |
|
Independent review — PR #41 Verdict: CHANGES_REQUIRED (narrow reproducibility correction). The provenance/path corrections at candidate 49ca90f materially improve the generator: hard-coded XCSV/date provenance is removed, ORCH is explicit/verified when supplied, ORCH canonical paths are repository-relative, absent ORCH is explicit, and SOURCE_WIRED wording is corrected. Remaining blocker: member-submodule source identity is not bound. Most inventory data is read from the
Therefore the same XCSV superproject HEAD can still generate different Required narrow correction:
Do not broaden into runtime/gameplay work, member-repo mutation, #31, or deletion. PR remains draft/unmerged pending independent review. |
XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / issue #30 member-submodule provenance receiptPR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. Candidate SHA: Implemented only the remaining member-submodule provenance/reproducibility correction requested in PR comment Source Observations
Behavior Added
Corrected Counts
Validation
Remaining UNKNOWN / NOT_REVERIFIED
Completion ImpactCOMPLETION_IMPACT: v1.0.0 Stopping for independent review. PR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. |
|
Independent review — candidate The member-submodule correction is sound: One final reproducibility blocker remains. The generator also reads XCSV superproject source ( Required narrow correction: apply one source-observation invariant to every repository whose files are read. Preflight XCSV and explicit ORCH for identity + HEAD + relevant cleanliness before generation; dirty source must fail closed or be explicitly dirty/fingerprinted, but must not be represented as clean-HEAD truth. Perform XCSV preflight before generated outputs make the worktree dirty. Add regressions for dirty XCSV source and dirty ORCH source. Preserve all existing precision, member-gitlink, provenance, and runtime-UNKNOWN behavior. PR #41 remains draft/unmerged pending independent review. |
XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / issue #30 generalized source-cleanliness receiptPR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. Candidate SHA: Implemented only the final generalized source-observation cleanliness correction requested in PR comment Source Observations
Behavior Added
Corrected Counts
Validation
Remaining UNKNOWN / NOT_REVERIFIED
Completion ImpactCOMPLETION_IMPACT: v1.0.0 Stopping for independent review. PR #41 remains draft/open and unmerged. |
|
Independent control review — XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / PR #41 Verdict: PASS_ACCEPTED_CANDIDATE_FOR_MERGE. Accepted candidate: Independent review confirms the source-inventory tranche now closes the provenance/reproducibility class previously blocking merge:
Validated evidence reported by the candidate:
Important boundary: this acceptance is for PR #41 is approved to proceed through the normal merge + documentation publication/reconciliation transaction. Do not reinterpret this as authority for gameplay mutation, member-repo mutation, deletion, or runtime claims. |
|
Final merge/publication/reconciliation receipt — XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / issue #30 Verdict: Merge:
Post-merge validation from merged main:
Inventory counts:
Publication:
Canonical
Per-source freshness/observation result:
Completion impact:
Issue #30 remains open for the remaining live/deployment/runtime evidence lane. No issue #31 work was started. |
|
Independent post-merge review — XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / PR #41 Verdict: PASS_ACCEPTED_MERGE_PUBLICATION_RECONCILIATION. Canonical GitHub state independently confirms:
This accepts the bounded source-inventory merge/publication/reconciliation transaction. It does NOT promote live server/deployment/DB/BattlEye/RPT/player truth; those remain NOT_REVERIFIED / UNKNOWN under issue #30. Documentation modernization may now proceed under issue #31 using the merged registry as evidence input, while #37 remains owner of permanent audit/CI guardrails. |
1 participant
XCSV-REFACTOR-INV-001 / Issue #30 Source-Inventory Candidate
Final accepted candidate:
d2373eabbdb6f35ce312eb2c4df546049f9078ab.Merged to main as normal merge commit:
09e4b61168904e9fd04e001f7f10d44917d2cc82.Final observation-only follow-up on main:
0cb610d8430543a5474191c466d1439b5479a1d8.Verdict:
PARTIAL_INVENTORY / PARTIAL_SOURCE_VERIFIED.Final inventory counts:
Final source-observation model:
VERIFIED_AT_OBSERVATIONtruth.Final validation matrix:
Publication/reconciliation:
WIKI_SYNCHRONIZED,XCSV.wiki.git@f55184f0bf71e366e29db2bb454ae7136692fb12, 17 tracked wiki pages matched published wiki by SHA256.6015372598at merge SHA09e4b61168904e9fd04e001f7f10d44917d2cc82, status success, served System Components content confirmed.D:\XCSV: reconciled to0cb610d8430543a5474191c466d1439b5479a1d8; safety branch retained;tools/local-aipreserved untracked.Runtime/deployment/live DB/live BattlEye/RPT boot/player-runtime truth remains
NOT_REVERIFIED/UNKNOWN. Issue #30 remains open for that evidence lane.