Record approved ITEM5-B-UPDATE-03 local execution

[topij]

Records the operator-approved ITEM5-B-UPDATE-03 local retained update with exact authority, before/final checkpoints, complete verification output, and rollback evidence. Updates the living handoff and parity plan to the separate fixture PR continuation decision.

The accepted inherited special-file-root limitation and incomplete field-exit status remain explicit. The execution record preserves the source/installed verification distinction, historical packet inputs, and the limit of grouped skip-summary comparisons. Fixture publication remains excluded.

make test at ae6f11c4646c1a666e7049fed20b30b88c73e850 on 2026-09-11 (UTC), in /Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit, printed 1 failed, 2529 passed, 1 skipped in 450.87s (0:07:30). The failed node was scripts/tests/test_pr_followup_hook.py::test_a_payload_too_deep_for_json_load_still_exits_zero, the disclosed #393 case. Make exited 2; the committed r4 wrapper exited 1. Separate bash -n invocations for the recipe inputs and sh -n init.sh exited 0 at the same revision/date/directory, accounting for #561’s syntax-check gap. Full output and hashes remain in the local evidence archive.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Review skipped

Auto reviews are disabled on this repository. Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the .coderabbit.yaml file in this repository. To trigger a single review, invoke the @coderabbitai review command.

⚙️ Run configuration

Configuration used: Path: .coderabbit.yaml

Review profile: CHILL

Plan: Advanced

Run ID: 7269341b-3f94-4b23-a72b-21738221703d

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

Use the checkbox below for a quick retry:

• 🔍 Trigger review

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[topij]

make test at a414535da717434f6e853cfd054c8e972156dbaf on 2026-09-11 (UTC), in /Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit, printed 1 failed, 2529 passed, 1 skipped in 458.22s (0:07:38). The failed node was scripts/tests/test_pr_followup_hook.py::test_a_payload_too_deep_for_json_load_still_exits_zero, the disclosed #393 case. Make exited 2; the r4 command runner exited 1. The unmodified full logs remain local.

Separate bash -n invocations for scripts/dev_session.sh, scripts/reconcile_sessions.sh, scripts/lib/repo_root.sh, and scripts/hooks/pre-push, plus sh -n init.sh, exited 0 at the same revision/date/directory. These account for #561's recipe gap without repairing it.

The retained installed/source runs are separately stamped in the execution record. Their complete evidence is committed with this PR. The packet, ledger, binding and preserved historical-artifact hashes were checked after the record edits. The configured handoff archive helper ran; the operator's parked friction-sweep decision remains in force.

Local kit-run log SHA-256:

• kit-make-test.stdout.log: a04d20f3e040d3fce1dd1f4520606da1ae6e1947968bdc8b3a529d0fa2236d7b.
• kit-make-test.stderr.log: bed17b2cb9b869f40a538eb5d8b0a54859b3e4190ad035b087114a56b35fe2cb.

[topij]

Public-input review of a414535da717434f6e853cfd054c8e972156dbaf against e8c9afb5baeb54680e451eab630e93143f418756 for PR #736.

The configured adversarial and correctness lenses ran in fresh contexts using public GitHub clones. Rollout readback confirmed gpt-6-astra and effort high; the argv carried -c model_reasoning_effort=high with no model override. Private local repositories were excluded from review inputs.

Correctness finding: P3/LOW imprecision. Grouped SKIPPED [...] summaries do not identify skipped test nodes. A synthetic probe swapped the skipped node while preserving the normalized grouped summary, then restored the original probe bytes. This does not show that this installation changed skipped nodes; it bounds what the existing comparison proves.

Disposition: the comparison defines how an operator interprets the verification boundary, so its qualification is treated as executed prose. The record will qualify both the summary claim and the historical assessment-field meaning while preserving original evidence. The full panel will review the resulting head. No tracker payload or retained update is part of this correction. The adversarial lens established no actionable defect in the changed records.

make test at a414535da717434f6e853cfd054c8e972156dbaf on 2026-09-11 (UTC) failed in the reviewers' runs. Correctness reproduced the disclosed #393 node. Adversarial also encountered blocked process inspection; its focused diagnostic rerun with inspection allowed passed those failed nodes, including the nondeterministic deep-JSON case. Those diagnostics do not replace its failing full-suite result. The independent evidence-consistency probes and synthetic controls completed; full reports and command evidence remain local.

Original report SHA-256:

• adversarial: c4fea6cc3db167824bc2df733fccad38d7e922cf6997654b9e5ecd02a2f85b15.

• correctness: b718f37f3020aa4cfb2bb5b6f2bf62dcde59559d0b070e2b4a4d96b00a0e2e7d.

No clean-review receipt for merge is claimed by this pre-correction report.

[topij]

Review disposition — ae6f11c

• reviewed head: ae6f11c4646c1a666e7049fed20b30b88c73e850
• review source: fallback:panel
• lenses: adversarial, correctness

The full adversarial and correctness reviews of ae6f11c4646c1a666e7049fed20b30b88c73e850 against e8c9afb5baeb54680e451eab630e93143f418756 completed on 2026-09-12 (Europe/Helsinki; 2026-09-11 UTC) with no actionable findings in the named documentation/evidence diff. Fresh contexts used only public GitHub clones and the raw revision comparison. Rollout readback confirmed gpt-6-astra at effort high.

Findings and disposition:

• The initial grouped-skip claim was qualified in cad466ff3025e9187a77340edf0242673f328dd9. The comparison bounds verification interpretation, so that correction was treated as executed prose. The original assessment bytes remain preserved; grouped equality does not identify skipped nodes.
• The archival location reference was removed in 2b7962f7e73e1c2bb4e7ec154618f8c7082e4e9d. Fresh review found that the underlying historical overstatement remained without its qualification. ae6f11c4646c1a666e7049fed20b30b88c73e850 deletes that record-prose claim; the separate narrowed-rule delivery account remains. The changed record prose is outside the safety-critical code paths.
• An interim prompt supplied author framing. The final reviews used newly launched contexts without carry-forward framing or author classification. Interim reports remain local and do not supply this receipt.

The final reviewers executed independent public-evidence audits and semantic negative controls for altered retained-byte claims and fabricated source-suite success. They checked target diffs and byte restoration, then reran the unmodified audits. These checks validate the review probes, not repository behavioral mutation coverage. Their make test attempts stopped at Ruff dependency acquisition because PyPI DNS resolution failed; pytest did not start in those review attempts.

make test at ae6f11c4646c1a666e7049fed20b30b88c73e850 on 2026-09-11 (UTC), in /Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit, printed 1 failed, 2529 passed, 1 skipped in 450.87s (0:07:30). The failed node was scripts/tests/test_pr_followup_hook.py::test_a_payload_too_deep_for_json_load_still_exits_zero, the disclosed #393 case. Make exited 2; the committed r4 wrapper exited 1. Separate bash -n invocations for the recipe inputs and sh -n init.sh exited 0 at the same revision/date/directory, accounting for #561’s syntax-check gap.

Complete reports, probe outputs and verification logs remain local. Report SHA-256:

• adversarial: d6d42122899f0d305d26968fdd11058c402fc3d76a76d28a7ee0b291160ab292.
• correctness: e6bafae29a5a8af2ff8fa83169ed2c8ab2c5f731c22223b0de1c93dafab44a0a.

Cockpit verification log SHA-256:

• stdout: b015c2260d35fb360b03107584ce7b6b032863932ad755945918182f7d160638.
• stderr: a19710a5608d10cdb98653bfa675e8416a19c500f0af4c485ebe3c856d862458.

The accepted inherited special-file-root limitation remains. Ownership acceptance is not functional verification or field-exit completion. Item 6 and replay evidence remain preserved. No fixture publication/PR action, new source repair, tracker payload or friction sweep is part of this disposition.