Skip to content

feat: bind host intents and execution history to independent continuity - #316

Draft
stringsofthemind-oss wants to merge 4 commits into
mainfrom
feat/silent-chicken-host-authority
Draft

stringsofthemind-oss wants to merge 4 commits into
mainfrom
feat/silent-chicken-host-authority

Conversation

@stringsofthemind-oss

@stringsofthemind-oss stringsofthemind-oss commented Oct 20, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Planner-generated operation IDs and replaceable local history can authorize a second external effect after an ambiguous first attempt. This draft adds an opt-in trusted host admission profile beneath the existing Once kernel: immutable intent bindings, a shared execution store, and an independently durable witness of revision plus operation/intent state content. UNKNOWN remains blocking, including a crash before the first provider effect.

The original T06/T07 counterexamples remain intact. Their maximum-one-effect protection check fails RED with two provider effects; H01/H02 require one effect and deny substituted IDs, partial history replacement, locally rehashed replacement state and coherent rollback. A separately admitted identical action still executes. Review also found and reproduced a revision-only partial-restore defect; the stronger v2 profile is required by MCP rather than silently accepting that earlier candidate.

Validation on Windows / Node 24.19.0 / two disposable PostgreSQL 18.6 clusters:

  • 12 hostile-recovery scenarios passed (13 Node tests), with built-in-only independent provider-journal checks.
  • 105 affected SDK regressions passed, zero skips; 26 installed candidate MCP tests passed.
  • Packed MCP with unchanged published SDK 0.1.25: 25 compatibility tests passed; new intent mode denied before callbacks.
  • Actual Summa42 efc6794ea79a4be5b2f60e376833a1d03cba053c services: kill after provider commit/lost acknowledgement, three fresh workers blocked before replacement Attempt, then authoritative CONFIRMED_EFFECT / SETTLED and replay; one POST and one provider effect. Independent checker reads the saved Summa42 SQLite state.

Reproduce with npm --prefix mcp run package:hardening -- /absolute/new-evidence-directory, then follow the generated README. See docs/SILENT_CHICKEN.md and examples/summa42-host-integration/ACCEPTANCE.md for protocol, SQL privileges, migration, negative cases and acceptance mapping. CI repeats the hostile cases and actual pinned Go-service proof.

Review/merge/release gates: this ports the unmerged PR #303 store seam, so coordinated security/design review remains necessary. Full Box/LLM/global-scheduler integration, production TLS/credentials, physical failure-domain separation, production recovery and scale qualification are incomplete. v2 scans the full namespace on each short transaction and sacrifices availability after ambiguous cross-store commit. No automatic migration of existing uncertain history is supplied. The revision-only v1 API remains a documented draft/control surface and is not accepted for host-intent v2.

SDK 0.1.27 / MCP 0.2.3 are source-built unpublished candidates. MCP's default SDK pin, public-current metadata and plugin pins remain unchanged. Do not merge, release or treat this as universal exactly-once execution on the strength of fixture CI alone. No real payments, customer orders or production credentials were used.

Final head aeed7d7: 37 CI checks succeeded, 2 publication/submission jobs intentionally skipped. The full SDK release chain passed locally; corrected Evolution campaign and isolated trial passed. Linux hostile-recovery CI (39440167766) passed Go race tests, all hostile scenarios and actual Summa42 proof; downloaded artifacts were rechecked using the built-in-only checkers. Exact installed evidence dependency audit found zero vulnerabilities. No merge or publication was performed. The authorized factual Summa42 #35 update is SofiaFlux/summa42#35 (comment) .

@cloudflare-workers-and-pages

cloudflare-workers-and-pages Bot commented Oct 20, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Deploying onceexec with  Cloudflare Pages  Cloudflare Pages

Latest commit: aeed7d7
Status: ✅  Deploy successful!
Preview URL: https://c0969bd2.onceexec.pages.dev
Branch Preview URL: https://feat-silent-chicken-host-aut.onceexec.pages.dev

View logs

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant