docs(archicad): add guarded structural DWG sync - #131
Open
Archwiz-boss wants to merge 1 commit into
Open
Archwiz-boss wants to merge 1 commit into
Archwiz-boss wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
Archwiz-boss
added a commit
to Archwiz-boss/BIM_MCP_study
that referenced
this pull request
Sep 8, 2026
兩個缺漏，都是我先前新增 domain 檔時沒做完，由另一條工作線（PR shuotao#131）改到 同一批檔案時才浮現。 **一、卡片放錯 section。** 我把三張卡片插在 domain-index.html 的 wall-check 之後，而那整段屬於 `id="compliance"`（法規與 compliance SOP），等於把 Archicad 的轉譯邊界、名詞對照與可攜性矩陣歸成了法規檢核。 正確歸屬是 ops。索引裡所有同性質的 meta-reference——tool-capability-boundary、 skill-authoring-standard、frontmatter-standard、session-context-guard、 core-reload-boundary、lessons——都在 ops（維運、QA 與 authoring 標準）。 references section 不適用，它的定義是「非本專案產出的 SOP，引用外部規範本文， 放在 domain/references/ 子目錄」，只收 building-code-tw.md。 三張卡片改置於 ops section，compliance 回到 11，ops 由 11 改為 14 （cat-summary 與 section 標題同步）。 **二、hero 圖的分類計數沒改。** scripts/gen-hero-grains.mjs 帶有 domain 的 五分類計數，加總即總數。我先前把總數從 83 改到 86，卻沒有改這裡，因此 domain__hero__grains.svg 仍畫著 83。QAQC 的 claim-pattern 不涵蓋 .mjs 與 .svg， 所以沒有被擋下來。 維運 11 改為 14、console.log 的總數 83 改為 86，並重跑 gen-hero-grains.mjs 重新產生 domain__hero__grains.svg。skills__hero__grains.svg 的內容不變，僅行尾 差異，已還原不納入。 scripts/verify-qaqc.ps1 -SkipBuild -SkipDeploy：61 PASS / 0 FAIL。 Refs shuotao#98 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Document evidence-graded workflows for per-story structural CAD comparison, unit normalization, safe property marking, and human review boundaries. --- 分支重建說明（收尾時補，非原作者內容）--- 原分支自 feat/archicad-domain-specs 開出，因此 PR 連同該分支的 commit 一併帶入， 並改到 23 個超出 fork PR 允許路徑的檔案。CI 的 check-files 明確界定：fork PR 只允許修改 domain/*.md 與 GEMINI.md。 現改為自 upstream/main 重建，只保留本工作線自己的兩個檔案： - domain/archicad-structural-dwg-sync.md（新增，299 行） - domain/README.md（分類登記一行，數量 18 → 19） 計數同步、CLAUDE.md 關鍵字表、docs/BIM_MCP 索引與 hero 圖等連帶更新，依維護者 既有作法由收編時處理（見 5dad238 的訊息：「Domain(79)／Skills(54)／Tools(180) 皆不變」，是維護者自行核算後落地），不在 fork PR 範圍內。 與 PR shuotao#130 的關係：兩者現在各自獨立，唯一交集是 domain/README.md 的分類表—— shuotao#130 加三行、本 PR 加一行，先後收編時需合併該表，數量取合併後的實際值。 Refs shuotao#98 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Archwiz-boss
force-pushed
the
feat/archicad-structural-dwg-sync
branch
from
September 8, 2026 15:38
9e630b5 to
2d78296
Compare
This branch has not been deployed
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary
domain/archicad-structural-dwg-sync.mdfor per-story structural DWG/DXF alignment, new-column pilot, existing Column/Beam/Slab comparison, guarded Property marking, and human reviewverified,approximate mapping, orunsupported, with the 2026-09-08 version and test/inherited basisdomain/README.mdcategory tableScope（分支重建後補述，非原作者內容）
原本這條分支自
feat/archicad-domain-specs（#130 的 head）開出，因此 PR 一併帶入 #130 的 commit，並改到 23 個超出 fork PR 允許路徑的檔案。CI 的check-files明確界定：fork PR 只允許修改domain/*.md與GEMINI.md。分支已重建為自
main起算，只保留本工作線自己的兩個檔案：domain/archicad-structural-dwg-sync.md（新增，299 行，內容未更動）domain/README.md（分類登記一行，數量 18 → 19）計數同步、
CLAUDE.md關鍵字表、docs/BIM_MCP索引與 hero 圖等連帶更新已全部移出。依維護者既有作法，那些由收編時處理——5dad238的訊息載明「Domain(79)／Skills(54)／Tools(180) 皆不變」，是維護者自行核算後落地的。與 #130 的關係：兩者現在各自獨立，不再有先後依賴，任一先合併都可以。唯一交集是
domain/README.md的分類表——#130 加三行、本 PR 加一行，先後收編時需合併該表，數量取合併後的實際值。Evidence boundary
verified: live Archicad 28 build 3001 + Tapir MCP 0.5.3 pilot on 2026-09-08, or explicitly labelled inherited runtime-facts evidence from that date/versionapproximate mapping: View Map creation, F5-like review chain, Favorite application, Beam Element ID, linked-DWG primitive extraction, and DXF/AutoCAD fallback where no end-to-end pilot existsunsupported: the known-broken detail/classification read paths and untrustworthy tool-level success for batch Property writesValidation
referenced_by: []intentionally remains unconnected;scripts/backfill-domain-metadata.pywas run and skipped the existing frontmatter, so no contributor was hand-filled.mcp.json,.vscode/mcp.json, and.vscode/settings.jsonare excluded from the commitverify-qaqc.ps161 PASS / 0 FAIL 是在含連帶更新的舊分支上跑的。重建後本 PR 不再改動計數與索引，那部分的一致性由維護者收編時驗證；domain 檔本身的 frontmatter 與related指向檢查（Phase 6）不受影響。Refs #98