[PM seat] domain:skills · seat 2 — 🟢 os-steve · session_017ETYWqMQD4qMtZzAGovWNi · R1 in seat · batch 5 · seat-assessed takes · landed 13 (#18892 · #18957 · #19096 · #18891 · #18902 · #19255 · #19132 · #19256 · #18901 · #19274 · #19108 · #19177 · #18017) · queued 1 (PR #19435 #19152) · accepted 1 (PR #19378 #19211 Tier H — maintainer's merge) · in flight 1 (#19160 → draft PR #19436, report awaited) · re-laned 1 (#16949 → devx) · released 1 (#19127) · parked 1 (#19240) · decision box 0

[os-steve]

This post is the single authoritative registration of the skills lane's SECOND seat (domain:skills#2). Four-section template; the job description is versioned at .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/skills.md — ⛔ not copied here. Seat 1's post is #7623 (os-tesla); this seat does not touch seat 1's cards or ledgers. Body r1t, written 2026-09-20T20:50Z (PR #19427 (#19177) MERGED at 2026-09-20T20:17Z as c337079 and PR #19426 (#18017) MERGED at 2026-09-20T20:36Z as bed7188 — the FALSE OPEN (reopened) arm and the counted H26 sentence on origin/main by content; both cards closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off — the TWELFTH and THIRTEENTH landings. In flight: #19160 and #19152 (both branches pushed, reports awaited). PR #19378 (#19211, Tier H) still awaits the maintainer's merge. The seat's assessed high-value queue is exhausted after the two in flight: the remaining lane cards are auxiliary — taken only if nothing higher appears. r1s (2026-09-20T20:14Z): #18017 DELIVERED at 2026-09-20T20:06Z: PR #19426 (e0e0be0, +59, not governed; H26 now says the block has NO SCHEDULED OR DECLARED RELEASE with the counted census in the row, the devx lead merged forward, #19255's stand-down intact) reviewed in seat — PASS 5752350446, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5752350820 — readied + armed on green CI, added_to_merge_queue 2026-09-20T20:10Z. Next takes by the seat's assessment, both real operational defects rather than wording: #19160 (H52 re-fires every sweep on a held card whose questions the seat already answered — no clearing act a held card can perform) and #19152 (the producer-side fix for #19108's class: post-stamped.mjs refuses a claim's malformed keyed lines at write time instead of three readers catching them hours later) — CLAIMED (5752362870 · 5752364802) and DISPATCHED at the default tier; regions H52 (check-half-states.mjs, disjoint from the two queued rows) and the --comment path of post-stamped.mjs (no open PR on the file; seat 1's chain on it has nothing in flight and seat 1 is vacant). r1r (2026-09-20T20:07Z): PR #19423 (#19108) MERGED at 2026-09-20T19:32Z — CLAIM_SEAT_DECLARATION_ANYWHERE on origin/main by content; #19108 closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off — the ELEVENTH landing. #19177 DELIVERED at 2026-09-20T19:30Z: PR #19427 (30caf75, +29, not governed) reviewed in seat — PASS 5752130812, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5752131196 — readied + armed, added_to_merge_queue 2026-09-20T19:52Z. #18017's dev has opened draft PR #19426 (e0e0be0, the released lead 9180b90 merged forward with origin/main at 2026-09-20T19:44Z) and is running its gate battery — report awaited, probe at the 20:50Z check-in if silent. #16949: triage answered the re-applied pm:retriage at 2026-09-20T18:53Z — 「the seat is right」 — and moved the card to domain:devx; it leaves this ledger. PR #19378 (#19211, Tier H) still awaits the maintainer's merge. r1q (2026-09-20T19:03Z): PR #19416 (#19274) MERGED at 2026-09-20T18:58Z — director.md :15 「未回字 = 不在 = 停」, SKILL.md :766 and core-rules :147 by content on origin/main; #19274 closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off — the TENTH landing. #19108 DELIVERED at 2026-09-20T18:57Z: PR #19423 (a62389c, +35 net, not governed) reviewed in seat — PASS 5751928105, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5751928432; ready + auto-merge follows its last checks. Next takes by the seat's assessment, both real false statements the patrol emits every sweep: #18017 (H26 「can never CLOSE」 asserted, counted refutes it; the devx seat's released lead 9180b90 conflicts with today's H26 and is the dev's first read) and #19177 (H59 calls a deliberately reopened card a FALSE OPEN) — CLAIMED (5751939507 · 5751941158) and DISPATCHED at the default tier, region-disjoint on check-half-states.mjs (H26 :6883–:7010 · H59 :14208–:14500 · PR #19423's claimSeatNumber :9199–:9215) under ruling 甲, the later lander merges once. r1p (2026-09-20T18:30Z): #19274 DELIVERED at 2026-09-20T18:23Z — PR #19416 (33d8403, Tier S: seven in-place rewrites, net 0 at 72 / 72 · 813 / 813 · 151 / 151, every line ≤ 120 B; the charter now says 未回字 = 不在 = 停, 一次只开一批, 索引只呈一次) reviewed in seat — PASS 5751738177, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5751738552; ready + auto-merge follows its last check. Next takes by the seat's assessment: #19108 CLAIMED (5751750707) and DISPATCHED at the default tier (an inline Seat: line read as seat 1 ⇒ a false H38 row on another seat's post; fix = present-but-unreadable ⇒ null, region claimSeatNumber in check-half-states.mjs, ≤ +40); #16949 NOT taken — the Director's ruling E (5749112950, maintainer 「同意」) lands the remedy in scripts/check-changeset-no-major.mjs + pr-automation.yml (a CI gate reusing the carrier check's exports), which is not the skills row (SKILL.md :251 「非门禁的 scripts/pm/**」); triage had dropped pm:retriage on the pre-ruling answer, so the seat re-applied it with the request 5751758156 — the lane is triage's to re-read by the landing file. r1o (2026-09-20T17:44Z): post-reset resume. The account's 5-hour usage window read 95 % at 2026-09-20T14:52Z (the maintainer's own reading, pasted into this session) — the seat paused its hourly patrol Routine from 2026-09-20T15:03Z to 2026-09-20T17:41Z, took no new card, and landed on notifications only: PR #19303 (#19256) MERGED 2026-09-20T15:12Z as a88a973 (director.md 72 / 72 with the two banner lines by content), PR #19356 (#18901) MERGED 2026-09-20T15:37Z as a3f3c48 (the Seam: rule on os-dev.md :42–:43, H68 in the patrol reader, roster floor 8 by content) — both cards closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off; PR #19378 (#19211, published skill + reconciling gate) reviewed in seat during the window — PASS 5750629600, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5750629985 — Tier H, awaiting the maintainer's merge (still draft, no review, at 2026-09-20T17:41Z). After the reset (get_session: five_hour / allowed, served tier = CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER on both fields): patrol re-enabled (next fire 18:23Z); #19274 (p1) CLAIMED (5751502396) and DISPATCHED at the mandatory tier — director.md 职责二 / 授权与形态 / 职责三 in place + SKILL.md :766 in place (+ core-rules twin only if the line exists), net 0 everywhere, the maintainer's two sentences quoted verbatim, hotlong's 3′ (the director seat does not run while the maintainer is absent) as the rule. Patrol: anchor #9857 0 rows naming this seat; lane 80 open / 38 pm:queue, the only pm:queue p1 is #19274. r1n (2026-09-20T14:48Z): PR #19353 (#19132) MERGED at 2026-09-20T14:30Z as 3270826 — parseAdrDecisionSectionUnits on origin/main by content; #19132 closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off at 2026-09-20T14:35Z. PR #19356 (#18901): the seat's roster-merge commit ef8358d is PUSHED at 2026-09-20T14:47Z after GitHub's queue lock refused it eight times (a draft bounce did not release the lock; a re-enqueue did, once the queue built and dropped the conflicting group) — a second ## Contract review PASS 5750522921 names the merge head, --pair 0; CI re-runs on it (31 checks) and the queue entry follows a green run at the 15:15Z check-in. PR #19303 (#19256, ACCEPTED) waits on Lint & Repo Gates only. r1m (2026-09-20T14:34Z): PR #19351 (#19255) MERGED at 2026-09-20T14:28Z as 231283a — unlockLabelExits / h19DeclaredExitFired and SKILL.md :128 by content on origin/main; #19255 closed completed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off at 2026-09-20T14:28Z. PR #19303 (#19256) patch round 2 delivered at daacc87 (72 / 72, :22 retired as the seat decided) — reviewed in seat: PASS 5750434994, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5750438817; ready + auto-merge once its last checks finish. PR #19356 (#18901) now CONFLICTS with main on the self-test roster (both PRs raised the floor 6 → 7): the seat resolved it in a scratch worktree (both rows kept, floor 8, every floor pin 8; self-test 5118 cases / 8 batteries, ratchet 403 / 403, trailer gate clean) but the push is refused by GitHub's queue lock (「Branches that are queued for merging cannot be updated」) — converting the PR to draft at 2026-09-20T14:31Z has not released the lock yet; the seat pushes the moment the queue ejects it, then re-posts the record on the new head and re-enqueues. r1l (2026-09-20T14:23Z): the #19351 demotion is RESOLVED: the domain:spec seat 4 (session_01AmH9bKvGoLjiY86Q4Z3og2) converted it to draft at 2026-09-20T14:16Z on a mis-framed 「0 approvals on a governed PR」 challenge, measured the register itself, found Tier S (0 approvals is the resting state), restored ready at 2026-09-20T14:18Z and posted its own correction 5750378122 on the PR; this seat re-set the landing on it at 2026-09-20T14:21Z (the draft bounce drops queue membership; the re-entry is read at the next check-in) and released the hold on PR #19356 — landed into the queue at 2026-09-20T14:21Z. r1k (2026-09-20T14:20Z): ⚠️ PR #19351 (#19255, Tier S, was in the merge queue since 2026-09-20T14:02Z) was converted back to DRAFT at 2026-09-20T14:16Z by an act under the shared identity that is not this seat's — no comment, no review, no automation in the tree does it (merge-queue-triage.yml only comments; every run in the window skipped), no board mention — read as the maintainer's own act and ⛔ not reversed; PR #19356 (#18901) reviewed in seat on 5033c4d — PASS 5750369816, --pair 0, ACCEPT on the card — and its ready flip HELD in the same window; #19256's dev pushed patch round 2 (PR #19303 at 14:15Z: 「retire a restated pointer so the charter lands at its ceiling」 — report awaited). r1j (2026-09-20T14:15Z): the maintainer's second order in this session, verbatim 「你应该自己评估哪些issue适合优先处理。」 — the take order is the seat's own VALUE assessment, not the priority:* label nor the mandate list; the assessment is recorded under 「Next takes」 below and applied: #19211 claimed and dispatched at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER (the published skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md top-level key enumeration omits four legal keys and nothing reconciles it — the maintainer's stated top value is published-skill accuracy); #19256 unparked by the seat's own decision — no ceiling raise, patch round 2 retires one more provable duplicate (:22) so director.md lands at 72 / 72; #19274 (p1, the maintainer's own token-waste card) is next on director.md, hard-serial behind PR #19303 under 甲 (same 职责二 region). r1i (2026-09-20T14:07Z): the maintainer's standing order in this seat's session, verbatim 「当前任务处理完就只处理高优先级任务。」 (2026-09-20, ~14:00Z) — recorded and applied: the in-flight items are landed, then only high-priority work is taken, ⛔ no new p2 / p3 dispatch; PR #19317 (#18891) and PR #19321 (#18902) MERGED at 2026-09-20T13:20Z, both cards closed by Fixes; PR #19353 (#19132) reviewed in seat — PASS, --pair 0, ACCEPTED — and readied + armed with PR #19351 (#19255), both added_to_merge_queue at 2026-09-20T14:02Z; #18901 delivered PR #19356 (5033c4d, Tier S) — substance reviewed in seat, the record waits for the roster merge with PR #19351 (both raise SELF_TEST_BATTERY_FLOOR 6 → 7; the later lander sets 8), which the seat resolves itself because the dev's run ended on the tier's usage limit right after its hand-back and its worktree is gone; #19127's claim RELEASED under the order (never dispatched; release note 5750293509 on the card). r1h (2026-09-20T13:13Z): #19255 ACCEPTED with in-seat PASS — PR #19351 awaits CI; #19202 CLOSED completed on a premise re-read: fe36a40 / PR #19167 already landed the explicit yield at os-dev.md :285 and check-commit-card-trailers on pre-push is the enforcer the card could not find; #19127 claimed fable-first ⑤). r1g: after the account's 5-hour usage wall (HTTP 429 from ~11:35Z, reset 12:40Z; the seat's two patrol fires at 11:23Z / 12:23Z and the flip 定点 at 11:31Z were consumed by it — handled at 12:41Z on the maintainer's 「Try again」): three PRs MERGED (#19298 → #18892 · #19304 → #18957 · #19305 → #19096; cards closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched removed); PR #19317 (#18891) readied + armed; PR #19321 (#18902) ACCEPTED with in-seat PASS, readied + armed; the three devs the wall killed mid-run (#19132 · #19255 · #18901) RESUMED by SendMessage onto their surviving worktrees (all three worktrees intact, clean, fully pushed — ⛔ no second worktree, no re-dispatch). r1f: #18891 ACCEPTED — rendering A, the one-word 同区域 narrowing, PR #19317; #19256 parked at 73 / 72 pending the maintainer's ceiling word; #18901 dispatched fable-first ④; PR #19298 in the merge queue, PR #19304 readied and armed). r1e: three deliveries ACCEPTED with in-seat ## Contract review PASS and awaiting CI → ready → queue: PR #19298 (#18892) · PR #19304 (#18957) · PR #19305 (#19096); #19256 in a patch round for its ratchet count; #18891 · #18902 · #19255 dispatched fable-first). r1d: the maintainer's 「后续优先派需要fable 的任务」 recorded: from the next free slot, cards whose surface mandates CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER (SKILL.md · os-dev.md · skills/**) are taken first; ruling 甲 on #18891 (region-level concurrency, 2026-09-18) re-read and applied to this seat's region declarations; seat 1's #19048 landed as f93beea). r1c: concurrency 5 filled with #19132 · #18957 · #19096. r1b: batch 5, #19256 dispatched, #19240 parked, a served-tier fallback noted; r1a corrected r1's PR #19284 mis-attribution; r0 was the creation placeholder.

Current PM

🟢 os-steve · session_017ETYWqMQD4qMtZzAGovWNi · seated 2026-09-20T09:45Z on the maintainer's /pm-dispatch skills and the summons in that session, verbatim 「你是 skills 车道的第2 个项目经理」 (round-open marker: the first comment on this post). Served at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER (get_session at 2026-09-20T10:06Z: session_context.model = last_served_model = configured_model = the constant's model id, spelled by the constant name here per AGENTS.md's no-model-identifier rule; effort xhigh). Write identity: REST GET /user → os-steve (User, id 317605050; ⛔ not in GOVERNED_APPROVERS); the session ID is the attribution. Patrol Routine trig_018i44nWZqd11cF6rNkGJcuV (hourly at :23, self-bind, created 2026-09-20T09:47Z). Mutex readings, charter touches (origin/main e6a03e6 at seating: SKILL.md e872ef44b · core-rules.md e15870f7a · lanes/skills.md 4d1d9d9f9) and the harness reading (CURRENT) are on the marker.

Mandate (verbatim, the maintainer in this session, 2026-09-20): 「你优先处理以下任务:第二层——第一层落地后接着派(协议正确性缺口,约 12 张)」, then three lists: 「dispatch-gates 串行队:#19070 → #19104 → #19105 → #19106」 · 「check-half-states 串行队:#18901 → #18017 → #19129 → #19108 → #19177 → #19160 → #19203 → #19255」 · 「认领/裁决读者:#19240(死认领无法回收)、#19152(键值行写时无读者)、#19256(裁决落评论正文相反)、#18892」; then 「并发保持3」 and 「并发保持5」 (the batch ceiling, now 5); then 「刚才你在处理哪个任务,可以先跳过,触发了整个规则:Fable 5.1's safeguards flagged this message … Switched to Opus 4.8. Details: [cyber]」 (read as: park #19240, whose retraction-reader region the seat was re-reading at that moment); then 「我要并发5 你看看本车道其他还有哪些任务可以派」 (read as: the lift of 北极星「优先级」第 3 条 extends to lane pm:queue cards this seat picks to fill the ceiling); then 「后续优先派需要fable 的任务」 (read as the take order from the next free slot: CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER-mandated cards first — the mandate is the three globs in dispatch-gates.mjs MANDATORY_TIER_GLOBS — then everything else by 取卡全序). Ruling in force on same-file work: #18891 batch #157 item 2 letter 甲 (5727164406, 2026-09-18, 「其他同意」): 「同区域(认领申报的文件面重叠)单跨轮硬串行;同文件不同区域是普通并发,后落地方解冲突」 — SKILL.md :441's text has not yet been narrowed (that text change IS #18891, queued); this seat applies the ruling: claims declare regions at line / function level, tests go beside the row's existing cases (⛔ never at selfTest()'s tail), the later lander merges origin/main once, and 「拿不准就串行」 still holds. Read as the maintainer's lift of 北极星「优先级」第 3 条 for exactly these 16 cards, ⛔ not for any other card; and as ordering — each chain dispatches AFTER the first tier's cards on the same file reach MERGED (first tier = seat 1's: #19260 · #19172 on dispatch-gates.mjs; #19191 · #19230 on check-half-states.mjs; #19048 → #18995 → #19238 on post-stamped.mjs; #19211 independent). A file with no first-tier card on it dispatches now. In flight 5 / 5. Under 甲 the tier-2 chains on check-half-states.mjs are region-parallel with seat 1's #19191 (PR #19288: hunks at :961 · :1048 · :4563 · :13709–:13722 · :18674–:18704 · :20740 · :20936 · :22398 and self-tests :29099 · :34144 · :36031 — none of this seat's rows) and with each other except where two cards touch one row (#18017 and #19255 both touch H26 ⇒ serial, #19255 first under fable-first); the dispatch-gates.mjs four all sit in one block ⇒ serial among themselves (a fold needs the maintainer's word), region-parallel with #19260 (:5886–:5983, :17145) and #19172.

Inherited + running ledger

• Landed this shift: 5 — finding(tooling): check-clause2-carriers 在通过消息里断言「认领评论未被编辑」—— 它没有读编辑的仪器，而那两个字段就在它已经在读的对象上 #18892 → PR fix(pm): the clause-2 correction note READS the claim comment's two stamps instead of vouching it was never edited #19298 (84a7e9e, MERGED 2026-09-20T11:27Z) · finding(skills): dispatch-runbook.md :61 paraphrases reading three NARROWER than SKILL.md :80 declares — it drops ∪ pm:queue and 同席号, so a seat following the runbook can miss a Claim: on a pm:queue card and fail to self-retire (the two-writer seat, by a second route) #18957 → PR docs(skills): runbook reading three carries the declared population and 同席号 #19304 (58ac824, MERGED 2026-09-20T11:29Z) · finding(.claude/agents): os-dev.md:279 tells every dev to copy a Clause-②: line into the PR body for a reader objectui does not have — and an objectui claim has no such line to copy #19096 → PR docs(agents): os-dev.md — the Clause-② copy line is conditional on the claim carrying one #19305 (81e12e1, MERGED 2026-09-20T11:34Z) · [finding] SKILL.md gives two opposite serial rules for the same shared file — SINGLE_CLAIM_PATHS has exactly ONE entry, so 「普通并发」 and 「同文件单跨轮硬串行」 collide on every path but .objectui-sha #18891 → PR skills(pm-dispatch): hard serial across rounds applies to the same claimed region, not the same file — SKILL.md :441 and its core-rules twin #19317 (547b9ab, MERGED 2026-09-20T13:20Z; SKILL.md :441 「同区域单跨轮硬串行」 by content) · pm-dispatch: a Seam: card routes by the seam — vertical dispatch by default inside objectstack (file surface names both ends; acceptance = the consumer reads it or the key retires with its ledger row), and rule 2's parent + per-repo sub-issues trigger on a spec↔objectui seam, not only on a feature (item ② of #18900) #18902 → PR skills(pm-dispatch): a Seam: card routes by the seam — spec seat, vertical dispatch by default; rule 2 splits a spec↔objectui seam into parent + per-repo sub-issues #19321 (9120837, MERGED 2026-09-20T13:20Z; :241 「Seam: 卡归 spec 席」 by content) — every card closed completed by its Fixes line, pm:dispatched off. Landed this shift: 13 — the thirteenth finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017 → PR fix(pm): H26 claims no SCHEDULED or DECLARED release, not "no mechanism" — counted, not asserted #19426 (MERGED 2026-09-20T20:36Z; H26 counted, not asserted; card closed, pm:dispatched off), the twelfth finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177 → PR fix(scripts/pm): H59 reads state_reason so a deliberately REOPENED card is not called a platform failure #19427 (MERGED 2026-09-20T20:17Z; the reopened arm; card closed, pm:dispatched off), the eleventh [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108 → PR fix(pm): a present-but-unreadable Seat: declaration reads as null, never as seat 1 #19423 (MERGED 2026-09-20T19:32Z; a present-but-mislaid Seat: line now reads null, never seat 1; card closed, pm:dispatched off); the tenth skills(pm-dispatch/director): 上一批决裁未回字 = 维护者不在 ⇒ ⛔ 不开下一批、巡检静默 —— 本场批 #179–#191 违反了这条,浪费了维护者的 token #19274 → PR docs(pm-dispatch): the director seat stops while the maintainer's reply is missing (未回字 = 不在 = 停) #19416 (MERGED 2026-09-20T18:58Z; the charter's 未回字 = 不在 = 停 by content; card closed, pm:dispatched off); the ninth os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 → PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356 (a3f3c48, MERGED 2026-09-20T15:37Z; the seat's roster-merge commit resolved the floor to 8), the eighth [finding] a ruling that lands in a COMMENT leaves the card body asserting the opposite, and nothing reconciles them — two cards sat dispatchable for 11 and 15 days telling every reader not to take them #19256 → PR docs(pm-dispatch): the ruling procedure writes a banner onto the card body #19303 (a88a973, MERGED 2026-09-20T15:12Z; 72 / 72), the seventh check-prior-rulings: objectui’s 10 ADRs parse to zero decision units, so every objectui decision card is stuck on Prior rulings read: unresolved #19132 → PR fix(pm): check-prior-rulings parses the ## Decision shape and names the corpus repo #19353 (3270826, MERGED 2026-09-20T14:30Z); every card closed by Fixes, pm:dispatched off; the sixth [finding] a pm:blocked card whose Blocked-by target is a needs-user-decision card can never be released — the unlock predicate is "closed", and Unlock-action recognizes exactly one PR-shaped spelling #19255 → PR feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 (231283a, MERGED 2026-09-20T14:28Z after spec seat 4's erroneous dequeue and its own correction 5750378122; card closed, pm:dispatched off). ACCEPTED, awaiting its last checks → ready → queue: 1 — PR docs(pm-dispatch): the ruling procedure writes a banner onto the card body #19303 ([finding] a ruling that lands in a COMMENT leaves the card body asserting the opposite, and nothing reconciles them — two cards sat dispatchable for 11 and 15 days telling every reader not to take them #19256, Tier S, daacc87; PASS 5750434994, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5750438817). In the merge queue: 0. ACCEPTED, Tier H — the maintainer's merge: 1 — PR fix(skills): enumerate every authorable top-level stack key in the platform skill, and gate it #19378 ([finding] 已发布的 skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md 顶层键枚举漏了 devHint / devLogins(以及早就漏的 onEnable / packages)—— 无门禁对账,AI 作者按它写就看不见这些键 #19211, d8c67e2: the published skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md key enumeration 40 → 44 keys within the token ceiling + scripts/check-skill-top-level-keys.mjs wired as a required lint step; PASS 5750629600, --pair 0, ACCEPT 5750629985; one open question recorded for the maintainer — hold out vs list the two machine-written keys; the seat's reading is A). In the merge queue: 0 (check-prior-rulings: objectui’s 10 ADRs parse to zero decision units, so every objectui decision card is stuck on Prior rulings read: unresolved #19132, scripts/pm, not governed; PASS 5750053225 on the PR, --pair 0; ACCEPT on the card; readied + armed, added_to_merge_queue 2026-09-20T14:02Z). PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356's record: os-dev.md :42–:43 net 0 at 403 / 403 with :53 retired, + H68 report-only row +120 on check-half-states.mjs; merge-tree vs c334ba0 clean, CI 37 / 37 green; the shared SELF_TEST_BATTERY_FLOOR line (6 → 7 in both feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 and feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356) is resolved by whichever lands second — the queue orders them, and the later lander's merge sets the floor to 8 with both roster rows (this seat does it if the dev is gone). Closed on a spent premise: 1 — finding(skills): .claude/agents/os-dev.md requires a model-free commit trailer while the harness-injected attribution block prescribes one that names the model — a dev receiving both cannot satisfy either without breaking the other #19202 (completed at 2026-09-20T13:10Z). Record of the earlier list: PR fix(pm): the clause-2 correction note READS the claim comment's two stamps instead of vouching it was never edited #19298 (finding(tooling): check-clause2-carriers 在通过消息里断言「认领评论未被编辑」—— 它没有读编辑的仪器，而那两个字段就在它已经在读的对象上 #18892; review 5749305307) · PR docs(skills): runbook reading three carries the declared population and 同席号 #19304 (finding(skills): dispatch-runbook.md :61 paraphrases reading three NARROWER than SKILL.md :80 declares — it drops ∪ pm:queue and 同席号, so a seat following the runbook can miss a Claim: on a pm:queue card and fail to self-retire (the two-writer seat, by a second route) #18957) · PR docs(agents): os-dev.md — the Clause-② copy line is conditional on the claim carrying one #19305 (finding(.claude/agents): os-dev.md:279 tells every dev to copy a Clause-②: line into the PR body for a reader objectui does not have — and an objectui claim has no such line to copy #19096) — each with its review on the PR and --pair 0.
• In flight (dev): 2 (batch 5, all mode:subagent): finding(scripts/pm): H52 has no clearing act on a pm:on-hold card — the only three null-exits are close, needs-user-decision (which the row itself forbids here) and a newer dev report a held card can never get #19160 → claude/issue-19160-h52-answer-on-thread-clears (claim 5752362870 at 2026-09-20T20:12Z; default tier; dispatched 2026-09-20T20:50Z; region H52 :11906–:12260 + its pins; net ≤ +60) · [finding] a claim's keyed lines are exact-value fields enforced only AFTER the write — one seat, one shift, five half-state rows from three different keys #19152 → claude/issue-19152-keyed-lines-refused-at-write-time (claim 5752364802 at 2026-09-20T20:12Z; default tier; dispatched 2026-09-20T20:50Z; post-stamped.mjs --comment keyed-line reader; net ≤ +120). finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017's dev handed back done at 2026-09-20T20:06Z (PR fix(pm): H26 claims no SCHEDULED or DECLARED release, not "no mechanism" — counted, not asserted #19426, queued); finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177's at 2026-09-20T19:30Z (PR fix(scripts/pm): H59 reads state_reason so a deliberately REOPENED card is not called a platform failure #19427, queued); [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108's at 2026-09-20T18:57Z (PR fix(pm): a present-but-unreadable Seat: declaration reads as null, never as seat 1 #19423, landed); skills(pm-dispatch/director): 上一批决裁未回字 = 维护者不在 ⇒ ⛔ 不开下一批、巡检静默 —— 本场批 #179–#191 违反了这条,浪费了维护者的 token #19274's at 2026-09-20T18:23Z (PR docs(pm-dispatch): the director seat stops while the maintainer's reply is missing (未回字 = 不在 = 停) #19416, landed); [finding] 已发布的 skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md 顶层键枚举漏了 devHint / devLogins(以及早就漏的 onEnable / packages)—— 无门禁对账,AI 作者按它写就看不见这些键 #19211's at 2026-09-20T15:05Z (PR fix(skills): enumerate every authorable top-level stack key in the platform skill, and gate it #19378). Every earlier dev of this shift has handed back (check-prior-rulings: objectui’s 10 ADRs parse to zero decision units, so every objectui decision card is stuck on Prior rulings read: unresolved #19132 → PR fix(pm): check-prior-rulings parses the ## Decision shape and names the corpus repo #19353 · os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 → PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356 · [finding] a pm:blocked card whose Blocked-by target is a needs-user-decision card can never be released — the unlock predicate is "closed", and Unlock-action recognizes exactly one PR-shaped spelling #19255 → PR feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351). [finding] the maintainer ruled 「contract-surface cards first」 and it lives only in one seat post — the charter take order says nothing about it, and its arrival caused a same-minute claim race between two seats #19127 RELEASED at 2026-09-20T14:05Z (claimed at 2026-09-20T13:14Z, never dispatched; pm:dispatched → pm:queue, assignee cleared; the seat's reading stays on the card as evidence for the next taker).
• Parked (maintainer order, ⛔ not dispatched until re-authorised): 1 — the dead-claim reclaim (SKILL.md :496, a Release: with cause by the reclaiming seat) is invisible to the claim reader, which retracts only by the SAME login — a card whose claimant's login is gone cannot be re-claimed without a judged C9 red #19240 (still pm:queue · p2 · bug; the seat's premised direction 5749059143 stands; the park note is 5749143566, the newest comment on the card).
• Next takes — the seat's value assessment (the maintainer's 「你应该自己评估哪些issue适合优先处理」, 2026-09-20; re-read at every take), ranked by: does the defect make a reader ACT wrongly today (a taker, an AI author, the maintainer's tokens) — over report-only patrol rows and wording; the maintainer's stated values weigh first (published skills/** accuracy 2026-08-21; token waste 2026-09-20; 「契约面卡先」 2026-09-18). ① [finding] 已发布的 skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md 顶层键枚举漏了 devHint / devLogins(以及早就漏的 onEnable / packages)—— 无门禁对账,AI 作者按它写就看不见这些键 #19211 — TAKEN (published skill omits four legal top-level keys; an AI author following it cannot write them). ② [finding] a ruling that lands in a COMMENT leaves the card body asserting the opposite, and nothing reconciles them — two cards sat dispatchable for 11 and 15 days telling every reader not to take them #19256 — FINISHING (a ruling in a comment leaves the body asserting the opposite; two live cards mis-advertised for 11 and 15 days). ③ skills(pm-dispatch/director): 上一批决裁未回字 = 维护者不在 ⇒ ⛔ 不开下一批、巡检静默 —— 本场批 #179–#191 违反了这条,浪费了维护者的 token #19274 (p1; the director seat burned the maintainer's tokens for 13 batches while he was away; his own instruction 「立skills卡」) — next on director.md, serial behind PR docs(pm-dispatch): the ruling procedure writes a banner onto the card body #19303 (same 职责二 region under 甲); its SKILL.md :766 pointer is in place (813 / 813) ⇒ CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER. ④ [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108 — TAKEN; [finding] the Clause-②: declaration lives in the PR body, so any unrelated body edit destroys it silently — measured: three runs of one check on one head SHA #16949 — RULED (letter E); its remedy is a CI gate outside the skills row ⇒ returned to triage with pm:retriage (5751758156); triage agreed at 2026-09-20T18:53Z and re-laned it to domain:devx — off this ledger. ⑤ finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017 and finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177 — DELIVERED (both real false statements the patrol emitted every sweep). ⑥ finding(scripts/pm): H52 has no clearing act on a pm:on-hold card — the only three null-exits are close, needs-user-decision (which the row itself forbids here) and a newer dev report a held card can never get #19160 and [finding] a claim's keyed lines are exact-value fields enforced only AFTER the write — one seat, one shift, five half-state rows from three different keys #19152 — TAKEN (an unclearable row that re-fires on every sweep; the write-time refusal that stops the whole keyed-line class at its producer). Still held as auxiliary: check-half-states H9: a node -e Restart-when predicate classifies prose (unfireable) because node is not a recognised command head #19129 · finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states.mjs reports its own MEASURED_MERGES_PER_DAY pin has drifted to a factor of 0.40 (observed ~54.7/day against a pinned 137.5/day, measured 28d ago), so every page-capped window OVER-states the days it covered #19203 (patrol rows without a false statement), the dispatch-gates.mjs roster four ([finding] a gate leaves the labelled Artifact-rosters block by DECLARATION ROT, not only by gaining a population — one stale literal drops it into the unlabelled residue and it loses the warning #19070 · [finding] dispatch-gates 的 Artifact-rosters 块对它印出的 53 行断言同一条补救,而那句话对其中 29 行为假 —— 它推荐的 no-path-population 标记对这个块机械无效,placeFamily 从不读它 #19104 · [finding] check:console-injection 的 population 是 packages/console/dist —— 一个生成目录,任何基于已跟踪路径的声明都写不出它,而 Artifact-rosters 块正照此向作者处方 #19105 · [finding] Artifact-rosters 块给 check-ci-filter-parity --self-test 印的 checker-health only — NOT a PR verdict 是假的 —— 它的 rollback pin 判的是活表,读者会把真红读成 fixture 噪声 #19106 — the roster block prints false remedies; taken next only if nothing higher appears), finding(skills): the English-only invariant's four sanctioned Chinese channels do not name the seat post's 说明 section — and this seat broke it seven times in four hours reading it the other way #19239 · finding(pm-dispatch): 认领评论的「门禁反向要求的派生物」开放臂能把 skills/** 长进实际文件面 —— 档位裁定与净增行数预算都按一个不含它的面定,事后无任何闸比对 #18665 · [finding] listOpenPulls in check-clause2-carriers.mjs pages to a bare literal cap of 10 and, when page 10 comes back FULL, returns the 1,000 rows it has — a TRUNCATED board listing the sweep then reports as 「swept COMPLETELY」, exit 0; the same fail-open class #18683 closed, one level above the pool #18807 · finding(skills): the seat's claim-time serial check reads open PRs' file lists only, so a sibling card already claimed and pushed but not yet opened as a PR is invisible to it — one git ls-remote --heads origin | grep <file stem> would have shown #18314's branch before #18844 was claimed #18964 · [finding] the ownership near-miss census still lists Release-landed: … report-line labels as refused release records — four separator lines on two cards, the largest remaining class of the kind #18926 narrowed #19043 · skills: re-key the three 事实层 = references/ spellings the Tier S ruling leaves false (os-dev.md :286–:287, landing-operations.md :27–:28, H48) #19146 · pm:done has writers (seats apply it at close; 44 + 2 carriers) but no reader in either tree — retire it or name a reader #19231 · skills(pm-dispatch): references/contract-review.md states that the exports map is a package's published surface — an entry-unreachable, exports-unaddressable .d.ts is shipped bytes, not an accept set (ruling on objectui#9733) #19068. ⑤ HELD as auxiliary (report-only rows, counts, wording): the check-half-states.mjs chain (finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017 · check-half-states H9: a node -e Restart-when predicate classifies prose (unfireable) because node is not a recognised command head #19129 · [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108's H-row half · finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177 · finding(scripts/pm): H52 has no clearing act on a pm:on-hold card — the only three null-exits are close, needs-user-decision (which the row itself forbids here) and a newer dev report a held card can never get #19160 · finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states.mjs reports its own MEASURED_MERGES_PER_DAY pin has drifted to a factor of 0.40 (observed ~54.7/day against a pinned 137.5/day, measured 28d ago), so every page-capped window OVER-states the days it covered #19203), the dispatch-gates.mjs roster block four ([finding] a gate leaves the labelled Artifact-rosters block by DECLARATION ROT, not only by gaining a population — one stale literal drops it into the unlabelled residue and it loses the warning #19070 · [finding] dispatch-gates 的 Artifact-rosters 块对它印出的 53 行断言同一条补救,而那句话对其中 29 行为假 —— 它推荐的 no-path-population 标记对这个块机械无效,placeFamily 从不读它 #19104 · [finding] check:console-injection 的 population 是 packages/console/dist —— 一个生成目录,任何基于已跟踪路径的声明都写不出它,而 Artifact-rosters 块正照此向作者处方 #19105 · [finding] Artifact-rosters 块给 check-ci-filter-parity --self-test 印的 checker-health only — NOT a PR verdict 是假的 —— 它的 rollback pin 判的是活表,读者会把真红读成 fixture 噪声 #19106 — they mislead a dev reading the roster, but no landing depends on that text), [finding] a claim's keyed lines are exact-value fields enforced only AFTER the write — one seat, one shift, five half-state rows from three different keys #19152 · finding(skills): the English-only invariant's four sanctioned Chinese channels do not name the seat post's 说明 section — and this seat broke it seven times in four hours reading it the other way #19239 · finding(pm-dispatch): 认领评论的「门禁反向要求的派生物」开放臂能把 skills/** 长进实际文件面 —— 档位裁定与净增行数预算都按一个不含它的面定,事后无任何闸比对 #18665 · [finding] listOpenPulls in check-clause2-carriers.mjs pages to a bare literal cap of 10 and, when page 10 comes back FULL, returns the 1,000 rows it has — a TRUNCATED board listing the sweep then reports as 「swept COMPLETELY」, exit 0; the same fail-open class #18683 closed, one level above the pool #18807 · finding(skills): the seat's claim-time serial check reads open PRs' file lists only, so a sibling card already claimed and pushed but not yet opened as a PR is invisible to it — one git ls-remote --heads origin | grep <file stem> would have shown #18314's branch before #18844 was claimed #18964 · [finding] the ownership near-miss census still lists Release-landed: … report-line labels as refused release records — four separator lines on two cards, the largest remaining class of the kind #18926 narrowed #19043 · skills: re-key the three 事实层 = references/ spellings the Tier S ruling leaves false (os-dev.md :286–:287, landing-operations.md :27–:28, H48) #19146 · pm:done has writers (seats apply it at close; 44 + 2 carriers) but no reader in either tree — retire it or name a reader #19231 · skills(pm-dispatch): references/contract-review.md states that the exports map is a package's published surface — an entry-unreachable, exports-unaddressable .d.ts is shipped bytes, not an accept set (ruling on objectui#9733) #19068. ⛔ Not this seat's: the dead-claim reclaim (SKILL.md :496, a Release: with cause by the reclaiming seat) is invisible to the claim reader, which retracts only by the SAME login — a card whose claimant's login is gone cannot be re-claimed without a judged C9 red #19240 (parked by the maintainer's 「先跳过」), Retire the in-seat clause-② contract review — the rule, its gate label, and the 9k-line checker's gate role #19061 (a proposal to retire the clause-② review — the maintainer's), [Decision] PM 席位被权限分类器判 Self-Approval 拦住落地动作 —— 章程要求席位入队,通道却不允许(三张全绿 PR 今天为此停摆) #19362 (needs-user-decision), Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292 / Published-skills factual sweep: verify every behavioral claim in skills/** against the implementation — program anchor #13658 / PM corpus audit (maintainer-directed): classify every instruction line — keep / duplicate / demote / delete — then rewrite and re-lock every ratchet #13597 (program anchors held by a human assignee or awaiting decomposition — Skills catalog optimization program (maintainer-directed): audit every skill on both roots, then optimize — program anchor #14292's audit-every-skill program is the highest-value long-running work in this lane and is NOT started under a throttle order without the maintainer's word).
• Tier-2 queue (11 remaining, all pm:queue, this lane; HELD by the standing order — recorded, not taken), per hot file in dispatch order, each behind the card(s) named:
  • scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs (first tier: [finding] dispatch-gates 的排除词表不认 DEFERRED —— 一张排除表被读成扫描面,.changeset/** 因此被告知它「触发」check-issue-citations(挡住 #18224) #19260 in flight — branch pushed, no PR at 2026-09-20T09:43Z — then [finding] dispatch-gates 不枚举 type-check lane,却印出两个 typecheck 命名的门禁家族 —— grep 到「有」的读者会以为这一面被兜住了(PR #19168 实测:82 家族全绿而 CI 红) #19172; seat 1's): [finding] a gate leaves the labelled Artifact-rosters block by DECLARATION ROT, not only by gaining a population — one stale literal drops it into the unlabelled residue and it loses the warning #19070 → [finding] dispatch-gates 的 Artifact-rosters 块对它印出的 53 行断言同一条补救,而那句话对其中 29 行为假 —— 它推荐的 no-path-population 标记对这个块机械无效,placeFamily 从不读它 #19104 (option C excluded by triage 5747209415) → [finding] check:console-injection 的 population 是 packages/console/dist —— 一个生成目录,任何基于已跟踪路径的声明都写不出它,而 Artifact-rosters 块正照此向作者处方 #19105 → [finding] Artifact-rosters 块给 check-ci-filter-parity --self-test 印的 checker-health only — NOT a PR verdict 是假的 —— 它的 rollback pin 判的是活表,读者会把真红读成 fixture 噪声 #19106.
  • scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs (first tier: finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states reads the LOCAL checkout with no cwd, so a cross-repo sweep validates H17's trigger-file index against the wrong repo's git ls-files and H57 never runs at all #19191 in flight, then check-half-states: the anchor's trim notice says the omitted rows are 「in the workflow run log」, but they are only in the step summary — unreachable from a seat, so trimmed H rows naming a lane go unworked #19230 — seat 1's): os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 (DELIVERED, PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356) → finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017 (UNVERIFIED lead: branch claude/issue-18017-h26-counted-not-asserted @ 9180b909, one commit, +92/−30, no PR, no report — the devx seat's aborted dispatch, released 5734287720) → check-half-states H9: a node -e Restart-when predicate classifies prose (unfireable) because node is not a recognised command head #19129 → [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108 → finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177 → finding(scripts/pm): H52 has no clearing act on a pm:on-hold card — the only three null-exits are close, needs-user-decision (which the row itself forbids here) and a newer dev report a held card can never get #19160 → finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states.mjs reports its own MEASURED_MERGES_PER_DAY pin has drifted to a factor of 0.40 (observed ~54.7/day against a pinned 137.5/day, measured 28d ago), so every page-capped window OVER-states the days it covered #19203 → [finding] a pm:blocked card whose Blocked-by target is a needs-user-decision card can never be released — the unlock predicate is "closed", and Unlock-action recognizes exactly one PR-shaped spelling #19255 (DELIVERED, PR feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 in the queue). ⛔ The chain is HELD by the standing order (high priority only). [finding] a ruling that lands in a COMMENT leaves the card body asserting the opposite, and nothing reconciles them — two cards sat dispatchable for 11 and 15 days telling every reader not to take them #19256's row shape, if the dev's report says the procedure text cannot close the defect, re-enters this chain last.
  • scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs (first tier: finding(scripts/pm): post-stamped.mjs exits 4 "NOT STORED" when the platform's footer re-anchor COLLAPSES a blank line — a case its own refusal text says cannot happen ("takes nothing away either way") #19048 LANDED as f93beea 2026-09-20; then [finding] post-stamped sanctions {{WAS:…}} on the opening line and H56 files a row on the result — the parity the tool claims in its own header is falsified, measured twice #18995 → [finding] post-stamped stamp contract is one-way on long-lived bodies: a bare stamp inside a quoted span can neither stay nor be declared, so the artefact can never take a now-token write again #19238 — seat 1's): [finding] a claim's keyed lines are exact-value fields enforced only AFTER the write — one seat, one shift, five half-state rows from three different keys #19152.
• Decision box (this seat): 0. Findings awaiting this seat's first-touch grading: 0. Seat items (⛔ not cards yet): os-dev.md :284 could name check-commit-card-trailers as its reader when a later card rewrites that line (finding(skills): .claude/agents/os-dev.md requires a model-free commit trailer while the harness-injected attribution block prescribes one that names the model — a dev receiving both cannot satisfy either without breaking the other #19202's residue); the account's rate-limit readings: seven_day / allowed_warning at 2026-09-20T12:42Z, then the mandatory tier's own limit reached at about 2026-09-20T13:25Z (the os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 dev ended on it right after its hand-back), five_hour / allowed again at 2026-09-20T14:04Z — the maintainer's throttle order followed; references/decision-analysis.md :45 now documents a strict prefix of the real Prior rulings read: line (PR fix(pm): check-prior-rulings parses the ## Decision shape and names the corpus repo #19353 appends ; repo: <owner/name>; H62 tolerates it) — a one-line Tier S follow-up; the check-prior-rulings.mjs ## Decision anchor regex is broader than its docblock's four spellings (measured harmless on both corpora); two seam vocabularies coexist after PR skills(pm-dispatch): a Seam: card routes by the seam — spec seat, vertical dispatch by default; rule 2 splits a spec↔objectui seam into parent + per-repo sub-issues #19321 (「缝卡」 vs 「Seam: 卡」, rider for os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901's landing); three sites still NAME the serial discipline by file after PR skills(pm-dispatch): hard serial across rounds applies to the same claimed region, not the same file — SKILL.md :441 and its core-rules twin #19317 (SKILL.md :120 p0 row · core-rules.md :36 · lanes/services.md :26 — references, not definitions; rider on this seat's next SKILL.md card); a census of every repo-conditional clause in os-dev.md (triage's suggestion on finding(.claude/agents): os-dev.md:279 tells every dev to copy a Clause-②: line into the PR body for a reader objectui does not have — and an objectui claim has no such line to copy #19096, three cards of that shape so far) — decide after finding(skills): .claude/agents/os-dev.md requires a model-free commit trailer while the harness-injected attribution block prescribes one that names the model — a dev receiving both cannot satisfy either without breaking the other #19202 lands; finding(os-dev.md): the labelling clause says CI does not label, but objectui runs actions/labeler with sync-labels: true on every push — a whole-set replace the clause does not name #19052's premise re-read (the labelling clause was rewritten by 87f776b); the check-half-states.mjs first-tier card finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states reads the LOCAL checkout with no cwd, so a cross-repo sweep validates H17's trigger-file index against the wrong repo's git ls-files and H57 never runs at all #19191 — PR fix(pm): check-half-states takes the checkout that SERVES the board, and refuses a foreign one #19288 was ready and queued at 2026-09-20T10:29Z, landing read each round.
• Cross-seat (⛔ not this seat's): every first-tier card above; seat 1's skills(pm-dispatch/director): 上一批决裁未回字 = 维护者不在 ⇒ ⛔ 不开下一批、巡检静默 —— 本场批 #179–#191 违反了这条,浪费了维护者的 token #19274 (p1) · [finding] 已发布的 skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md 顶层键枚举漏了 devHint / devLogins(以及早就漏的 onEnable / packages)—— 无门禁对账,AI 作者按它写就看不见这些键 #19211; everything else on the lane's pm:queue stays held by 北极星「优先级」第 3 条 and is seat 1's to take when the board allows.

Hot-file serial queue

• scripts/pm/check-clause2-carriers.mjs: finding(tooling): check-clause2-carriers 在通过消息里断言「认领评论未被编辑」—— 它没有读编辑的仪器，而那两个字段就在它已经在读的对象上 #18892 (in flight — the --pair green line :6491–:6496 + comparator + pin) → the dead-claim reclaim (SKILL.md :496, a Release: with cause by the reclaiming seat) is invisible to the claim reader, which retracts only by the SAME login — a card whose claimant's login is gone cannot be re-claimed without a judged C9 red #19240 (PARKED by the maintainer's 「先跳过」, 2026-09-20; claimRetractions :1743 / CLAIM_RETRACTION_RULE :1716 / the C9 remedy sentence + self-test) — one file, serial, ⛔ not a family (different defect, different fix; [finding] SKILL.md gives two opposite serial rules for the same shared file — SINGLE_CLAIM_PATHS has exactly ONE entry, so 「普通并发」 and 「同文件单跨轮硬串行」 collide on every path but .objectui-sha #18891 names the charter's two colliding serial rules — the stricter one, serial, is what this queue applies); [finding] listOpenPulls in check-clause2-carriers.mjs pages to a bare literal cap of 10 and, when page 10 comes back FULL, returns the 1,000 rows it has — a TRUNCATED board listing the sweep then reports as 「swept COMPLETELY」, exit 0; the same fail-open class #18683 closed, one level above the pool #18807 (p3, held) stays behind both.
• scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs: seat 1's [finding] dispatch-gates 的排除词表不认 DEFERRED —— 一张排除表被读成扫描面,.changeset/** 因此被告知它「触发」check-issue-citations(挡住 #18224) #19260 (no PR yet) → [finding] dispatch-gates 不枚举 type-check lane,却印出两个 typecheck 命名的门禁家族 —— grep 到「有」的读者会以为这一面被兜住了(PR #19168 实测:82 家族全绿而 CI 红) #19172 → [finding] a gate leaves the labelled Artifact-rosters block by DECLARATION ROT, not only by gaining a population — one stale literal drops it into the unlabelled residue and it loses the warning #19070 → [finding] dispatch-gates 的 Artifact-rosters 块对它印出的 53 行断言同一条补救,而那句话对其中 29 行为假 —— 它推荐的 no-path-population 标记对这个块机械无效,placeFamily 从不读它 #19104 → [finding] check:console-injection 的 population 是 packages/console/dist —— 一个生成目录,任何基于已跟踪路径的声明都写不出它,而 Artifact-rosters 块正照此向作者处方 #19105 → [finding] Artifact-rosters 块给 check-ci-filter-parity --self-test 印的 checker-health only — NOT a PR verdict 是假的 —— 它的 rollback pin 判的是活表,读者会把真红读成 fixture 噪声 #19106 — one block (artifactOnlySilence :8094–:8097 · placeFamily :7931 · the roster render :14284 / :14697 · the checker-health label :8229–:8260), serial, ⛔ not a family (fold gate ① fails: four different defects, four different fixes). Open PRs revert(spec): take back the declaration-text snapshot, restore the 27 signature hashes #19024 (the revert, −16 in selfTest()) and fix(ci): derive a gate's population through composite actions, not just workflows #19284 (the devx seat's Six gates root at .github/workflows and none reads .github/actions/** — a composite action's run: steps are audited by nothing while every scope line claims coverage #19229, +428/−14, population through composite actions) touch the file — every taker reads both diffs first.
• scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs (region-level under 甲): seat 1's finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states reads the LOCAL checkout with no cwd, so a cross-repo sweep validates H17's trigger-file index against the wrong repo's git ls-files and H57 never runs at all #19191 (PR fix(pm): check-half-states takes the checkout that SERVES the board, and refuses a foreign one #19288, ready) and check-half-states: the anchor's trim notice says the omitted rows are 「in the workflow run log」, but they are only in the step summary — unreachable from a seat, so trimmed H rows naming a lane go unworked #19230 hold their declared regions; this seat's rows — [finding] a pm:blocked card whose Blocked-by target is a needs-user-decision card can never be released — the unlock predicate is "closed", and Unlock-action recognizes exactly one PR-shaped spelling #19255 (PR feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 in the queue) · os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 (PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356, H68 beside H63; shares SELF_TEST_BATTERY_FLOOR with feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 — the seat resolves the roster merge and sets 8) → finding(pm-gate): H26's "can never CLOSE" premise is asserted, not counted — counting refutes it, and objectui's ported copy cannot be fixed without this one moving first #18017 (H26 six sites, same row ⇒ after [finding] a pm:blocked card whose Blocked-by target is a needs-user-decision card can never be released — the unlock predicate is "closed", and Unlock-action recognizes exactly one PR-shaped spelling #19255) · os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 (new row) · check-half-states H9: a node -e Restart-when predicate classifies prose (unfireable) because node is not a recognised command head #19129 (:3010 / :3131 + H9 tests :25956–:26014) · [finding] a claim whose Seat: line is not line-initial is silently read as seat 1 — three claims in one round misattributed, producing a false H38 stale row on another seat post #19108 (:9112) · finding(scripts/pm): H59 calls a deliberately REOPENED card a FALSE OPEN — state_reason: 'reopened' is on the payload it already reads, and H22 in the same file reads it #19177 (:14259) · finding(scripts/pm): H52 has no clearing act on a pm:on-hold card — the only three null-exits are close, needs-user-decision (which the row itself forbids here) and a newer dev report a held card can never get #19160 (:12089) · finding(scripts/pm): check-half-states.mjs reports its own MEASURED_MERGES_PER_DAY pin has drifted to a factor of 0.40 (observed ~54.7/day against a pinned 137.5/day, measured 28d ago), so every page-capped window OVER-states the days it covered #19203 (:21269) — pairwise disjoint, parallel as slots allow; shared line SELF_TEST_BATTERY_FLOOR :24727 is resolved by the later lander.
• scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs: seat 1's finding(scripts/pm): post-stamped.mjs exits 4 "NOT STORED" when the platform's footer re-anchor COLLAPSES a blank line — a case its own refusal text says cannot happen ("takes nothing away either way") #19048 (landed f93beea) → [finding] post-stamped sanctions {{WAS:…}} on the opening line and H56 files a row on the result — the parity the tool claims in its own header is falsified, measured twice #18995 · [finding] post-stamped stamp contract is one-way on long-lived bodies: a bare stamp inside a quoted span can neither stay nor be declared, so the artefact can never take a now-token write again #19238 (seat 1 vacant, nothing in flight) — [finding] a claim's keyed lines are exact-value fields enforced only AFTER the write — one seat, one shift, five half-state rows from three different keys #19152 (in flight; region = the --comment keyed-line reader) under 甲.
• .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/director.md (72 / 72, ceiling STAYS): [finding] a ruling that lands in a COMMENT leaves the card body asserting the opposite, and nothing reconciles them — two cards sat dispatchable for 11 and 15 days telling every reader not to take them #19256 (PR docs(pm-dispatch): the ruling procedure writes a banner onto the card body #19303, patch round 2 → 72 / 72 by retiring :22) → skills(pm-dispatch/director): 上一批决裁未回字 = 维护者不在 ⇒ ⛔ 不开下一批、巡检静默 —— 本场批 #179–#191 违反了这条,浪费了维护者的 token #19274 (p1; the 未回字 = 不在 = 停 rules into 职责二 + SKILL.md :766 in place; hard-serial behind docs(pm-dispatch): the ruling procedure writes a banner onto the card body #19303 — same region; every added line paid by a retired duplicate, the dev names each with its surviving home).
• skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md (published, Tier H, token-ratcheted): [finding] 已发布的 skills/objectstack-platform/SKILL.md 顶层键枚举漏了 devHint / devLogins(以及早就漏的 onEnable / packages)—— 无门禁对账,AI 作者按它写就看不见这些键 #19211 (in flight; the enumeration :72–:80 + a new scripts/check-skill-top-level-keys-class gate); no other open PR on the file at 2026-09-20T14:12Z.
• scripts/pm/check-prior-rulings.mjs (1,652 → 1,771): check-prior-rulings: objectui’s 10 ADRs parse to zero decision units, so every objectui decision card is stuck on Prior rulings read: unresolved #19132 (PR fix(pm): check-prior-rulings parses the ## Decision shape and names the corpus repo #19353 in the merge queue; the paste line names the corpus repo, the ## Decision fallback shape).
• .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/dispatch-runbook.md (241 / 241): finding(skills): dispatch-runbook.md :61 paraphrases reading three NARROWER than SKILL.md :80 declares — it drops ∪ pm:queue and 同席号, so a seat following the runbook can miss a Claim: on a pm:queue card and fail to self-retire (the two-writer seat, by a second route) #18957 LANDED (:61) → finding(skills): the seat's claim-time serial check reads open PRs' file lists only, so a sibling card already claimed and pushed but not yet opened as a PR is invisible to it — one git ls-remote --heads origin | grep <file stem> would have shown #18314's branch before #18844 was claimed #18964 (p3, held).
• .claude/agents/os-dev.md (403 / 403): region-level — finding(.claude/agents): os-dev.md:279 tells every dev to copy a Clause-②: line into the PR body for a reader objectui does not have — and an objectui claim has no such line to copy #19096 LANDED (:279) · os-dev's three-class filing rule: a class-(b) finding names its seam — a Seam: line (producer → consumer, consumer: none allowed) on the card, and the half-state patrol reports a class-(b) card that lacks one (item ① of #18900) #18901 (PR feat(pm): a class-(b) finding names its seam — the Seam: line on os-dev.md rule 3, and the H68 patrol row for a (b) card without one #19356 delivered, rule-3 (b) band :42–:43, :53 retired); finding(skills): .claude/agents/os-dev.md requires a model-free commit trailer while the harness-injected attribution block prescribes one that names the model — a dev receiving both cannot satisfy either without breaking the other #19202 closed; seat 1's skills: re-key the three 事实层 = references/ spellings the Tier S ruling leaves false (os-dev.md :286–:287, landing-operations.md :27–:28, H48) #19146 (:286–:287) is another region.
• .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md (813 / 813, zero slack): region-level — PR skills(pm-dispatch): hard serial across rounds applies to the same claimed region, not the same file — SKILL.md :441 and its core-rules twin #19317 (:441) and PR skills(pm-dispatch): a Seam: card routes by the seam — spec seat, vertical dispatch by default; rule 2 splits a spec↔objectui seam into parent + per-repo sub-issues #19321 (:214 / :241–:243) LANDED; PR feat(pm): second Unlock-action: value — a label-transition exit on a named card (#19255) #19351 (:128) in the queue; [finding] the maintainer ruled 「contract-surface cards first」 and it lives only in one seat post — the charter take order says nothing about it, and its arrival caused a same-minute claim race between two seats #19127 RELEASED (the 候选与批次 take-order lines, back in pm:queue); the dead-claim reclaim (SKILL.md :496, a Release: with cause by the reclaiming seat) is invisible to the claim reader, which retracts only by the SAME login — a card whose claimant's login is gone cannot be re-claimed without a judged C9 red #19240 (parked) would rewrite :496 in place; seat 1's queue ([finding] the protocol names Release: as the act that takes a card out of a seat's hands, but a claim RETRACTED before work starts is written as prose — the arbiter now reads that prose (PR #18770), and whether the protocol should REQUIRE the Release: spelling for a retraction is a governed-text question nobody has ruled #18773 :485–:486 → skills: re-key the three 事实层 = references/ spellings the Tier S ruling leaves false (os-dev.md :286–:287, landing-operations.md :27–:28, H48) #19146 :608 → skills(pm-dispatch): grading reads the checklist ITEM, not the area — Path: carries the item id, the card inherits the item's P, and 「有人在等」 is not a test #19155 :362 → finding(skills): the English-only invariant's four sanctioned Chinese channels do not name the seat post's 说明 section — and this seat broke it seven times in four hours reading it the other way #19239 :99 → [finding] the maintainer ruled 「contract-surface cards first」 and it lives only in one seat post — the charter take order says nothing about it, and its arrival caused a same-minute claim race between two seats #19127) holds its own regions; the merge queue arbitrates textual overlap.

Notes

Job description: references/lanes/skills.md. Standing facts (re-verified at seating): content writes go through the REST proxy only (⛔ no MCP write tool); labels / assignees through scripts/pm/label-write.mjs; seat artefacts through scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs (every full stamp {{NOW}} or a declared quoted reading; a bare full stamp is refused even inside backticks, and a {{WAS:…}} token INSIDE backticks is rendered as the token, not the time — declare stamps outside quoted spans; both measured once at seating); every REST write carries Content-Type: application/json. batch 5 (the maintainer, 2026-09-20, superseding #18125's 3 for this seat). Liveness baseline: a status probe at 45 min without remote output (one-shot accelerator armed for #18892, fires at 10:37Z). mode:subagent for every tier-2 card (S / M, none needs a browser). Clause-② review is owed in this lane every round and is done in-seat at tier — served-tier discipline: the harness signalled one turn-scoped fallback to a lower model at about 2026-09-20T10:04Z (a safeguard flag, per the maintainer's message); get_session at 2026-09-20T10:06Z reads last_served_model = the constant's model id again; the seat re-reads get_session immediately before every act that produces a ruling or a ## Contract review, and a fallback reading at that moment voids the act (an at-tier isolated subagent is the fallback route, per references/contract-review.md). Harness reading at seating: CURRENT on e6a03e6; re-read each fire, noted here if STALE, picked up at the next natural shift boundary.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-steve]

Round-open marker — session_017ETYWqMQD4qMtZzAGovWNi (os-steve, domain:skills#2) · fire 2026-09-20T09:48Z (seating on the maintainer's summons in this session; no Routine fire) · charter touches on origin/main e6a03e6 read at 2026-09-20T09:38Z: .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/SKILL.md e872ef44b · references/core-rules.md e15870f7a · references/lanes/skills.md 4d1d9d9f9 — the first reading for this seat (no previous marker to differ from), all three read in full this act. Harness: scripts/pm/check-harness-current.mjs CURRENT on e6a03e6. Mutex readings at 2026-09-20T09:38Z: no prior seat-2 brief or marker; the lane's open pm:dispatched claims (#19260 · #19191 · #19048) all carry Seat: domain:skills#1; the lane's 15 newest CLOSED cards carry seat-1 or default-seat claims only; the maintainer's explicit summons is the arbiter. Anchor #9857 (swept 2026-09-20T07:48Z, next by 13:37Z): no rendered H row names this lane's cards, PRs or this post; the trimmed rows are unread here (#19230), ⛔ not a clean reading.

---

Generated by Claude Code