docs: remove README Important security admonition (#207) - #209
Conversation
|
Implementation for #207 is complete at exact HEAD Verification:
No security-policy, runtime, Protocol, Vault, release, Device, or Web behavior change. |
miso-develop
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review disposition: READY_FOR_INTEGRATION
Reviewed exact PR head 89aa0fa45b3d5ec643830bd2c703d4cc582c6ec4 against Issue #207 and the #192 product-facing README baseline.
No blocking finding identified.
Scope verification:
- Effective diff is exactly two files:
README.mdREADME.ja.md
- Each README removes exactly the opening three-line GitHub Markdown Important admonition block.
- No empty blockquote/admonition shell remains.
- No unrelated README section was rewritten.
AGENTS.mdis unchanged, as required.
Security-policy continuity:
- The prominent README warning is removed without weakening the authoritative repository policy.
README.mdstill referencesSECURITY.mdin:- the authoritative security-contract section;
- the Security Policy documentation entry;
- the development/contribution reminder.
README.ja.mdpreserves the equivalent threeSECURITY.mdreferences.AGENTS.mdindependently continues to requireSECURITY.mdin multiple normative places, including:- credential-like value handling;
- bootstrap/read requirements;
- security-sensitive change review;
- completion/security gates.
SECURITY.mditself is untouched.- No secret-handling requirement, Product/Protocol/Vault/crypto/Device/Web runtime/release-policy behavior is changed.
EN/JA parity:
- Both languages remove the corresponding opening admonition.
- Heading hierarchy and product-first README structure remain unchanged/equivalent.
Exact-head evidence:
- Security #935: SUCCESS, including repository security scan and existing security-contract checks.
- Foundation #932: SUCCESS, including Web, Windows Chrome, firmware regression/security contracts, isolated ESP-IDF build/package validation, and dependency-lock verification.
Staleness/collision:
- Handoff HEAD matches current PR HEAD.
- PR is open, non-draft, and mergeable.
- Current
mainremains exact PR base40f7061eb89dcc676599d7f74f1b45037e589ea2. - Compare is 2 commits ahead / 0 behind.
- Open PR #206 is Web Serial lifecycle work and does not touch README/AGENTS.
- Open PR #210 is Web presentation/layout work and does not touch README/AGENTS.
- No ownership or file collision exists.
No additional Security review or Human Gate is required for this documentation-only change.
READY_TO_MERGEHEAD: Integration reconstruction:
STATE: READY_TO_MERGE |
INTEGRATEDPR: #209 Integration evidence:
STATE: INTEGRATED |
Closes #207
Scope
[!IMPORTANT]public-repository warning block fromREADME.mdREADME.ja.mdSECURITY.mdreferences in both READMEsAGENTS.mdunchanged because current main already explicitly requires agents to read/followSECURITY.mdVerification
HEAD:
89aa0fa45b3d5ec643830bd2c703d4cc582c6ec4README.mdandREADME.ja.md[!IMPORTANT]or an empty warning blockquoteSECURITY.mdreferences remain in both READMEsAGENTS.mdremains unchanged and still contains multiple explicitSECURITY.mdrequirements40f7061eb89dcc676599d7f74f1b45037e589ea2; branch is behind 0No Product, Protocol, Vault, Device, Web runtime, release-policy, or
SECURITY.mdbehavior changes.