docs(community): refresh verified ecosystem relationships - #5529
Conversation
Signed-off-by: huangruiteng <huangrt01@163.com>
loopx-agent
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewer: model_agent · gpt-6.1-sol · OpenAI · runtime_reported · xhigh
精确 head:7c83348fc04ae0bad4cb0e1d851ac4e18c552660;完整差异:两篇文档,+66/-0。
动机
查阅生态记录、判断是否值得集成的开发者需要可追溯的采用证据。此前遗漏公开评估、比较引用和下游 fork 的具体记录;新增五项后,读者可直接追溯来源,并区分提案、报道与下游代码。五项新增记录与九个公开引用逐一吻合,中英文分类一致,已确认集成表和首屏内容保持不变。本次不认证第三方运行效果,不把报道或公开提案计入运行采用,也不发布上游新版本。
改动思路
沿用原文的提案、社区报道、衍生项目三个分类,把新增事实写入原页面,而不另建采用计数或目录。每项同时提供状态、来源和范围。判断来自独立读取的公开 issue、评论、合并记录与固定提交内容,不依赖 PR 作者宣告。
具体改动
关键内容讲解
- MilkSU 的 issue #189 仍为开放的设计评估;ai-skills 的 issue #468 和 9月23日评论 明确保留 hook/上游设计工作,不能当作已交付采用。
- General Loop 固定 README 确实做了项目比较。GitHub-Michelin 的 已合并 #128 与 固定编辑页面 支持编辑报道这一分类;页面自身是9月27日快照。
- 下游固定 changelog、michaelx1993 #27、foolzzz #18 支持下游代码与发行准备的描述。GitHub 的 fork parent 读回为 michaelx1993/loopx,因此按一个家族记录;未认证其性能结论。
验收依据为既有 Evidence boundary 与分类契约,spec_revision:bb5ceadf2e884f5cce5548afa3b826e1c1e968ca。EVIDENCE-BOUNDARY、CATEGORY-SCOPE、DATED-EVIDENCE 均 implemented:不把提案/报道转成运行采用,保留原分类,并限定检查日期与编辑快照。两种语言增加的九个 URL 完全一致,逐项意义一致。
对主干的风险
主要风险是第三方状态变化以及读者误读成熟度。当前 primary-source 读回与全部新增表述吻合,范围限定也足够明确。独立对照证明首屏、已确认集成表及标题顺序未改动;git diff --check、两文件公开边界扫描及 DCO 签署检查通过。没有运行、权限或配置变化,因此不需运行后端或浏览器验证。按当前配置未获取、轮询或等待 CI;也没有据此宣称 CI 通过。
我的整体评价
APPROVE,这次文档维护切片达到 goal_achieved。长期维护 improved:固定来源与 scoped 日期减少重复调查;阅读体验 improved:沿原分类就能查明来源和成熟度。未来变更检查认为现有分类 owner 已足够,另建 schema 或采用目录会增加重复维护。第三方部署与性能没有独立验证,也不在本次文档结论内;若来源变化,应局部更新相应记录。
English verdict: APPROVE — exact head 7c83348; all nine new primary references, merged/open states, fork lineage and bilingual boundaries independently verified. Two-doc privacy/whitespace checks pass; existing opening and confirmed integrations are unchanged. No CI queried and no third-party runtime qualification claimed.
Goal And Delivered Outcome
Maintainer-requested refresh of the bilingual ecosystem inventory. Newly observed relationships were missing, and a literal mention or a related fork could be mistaken for an independent runtime adopter.
This change adds five scoped entries: MilkSU and ai-skills proposals; General Loop comparative reference; GitHub-Michelin editorial coverage; one michaelx1993/foolzzz derivative family. It preserves the existing integration entries and opening, and does not increase a runtime-adopter count. The historical codex-demo source is currently unavailable and was not promoted.
Intended base:
main. Complete within this documentation scope; merge remains pending maintainer review.Author Declaration
bb5ceadf2e884f5cce5548afa3b826e1c1e968ca.Validation
7c83348fc04ae0bad4cb0e1d851ac4e18c552660.git diff --check origin/main...HEAD.loopx check --scan-path docs/community/ecosystem-adoption.md --scan-path docs/community/ecosystem-adoption.zh-CN.md: two files clean; unrelated pre-existing Goal projection warnings remain outside this diff.loopx canary premerge --from-git-diff --tier quick: selected public-boundary check and three direct hygiene checks passed. Exact-scope change-quality review also recorded.Frontend / Visual Evidence
UI impact: none. Existing Markdown inventory only; opening, navigation and product UI are unchanged.
Boundary Checklist