Skip to content

Provider Dependencies: implementation and qualification tracker #1575

Open

Description

@skevetter

Provider Dependencies rollout tracker

One accumulating core draft PR: #1588. User-authorized implementation continues with fresh ChatGPT codex/gpt-6.1-sol workers; coordinator reviews and integrates. Open/closed duplicate search completed; this is the canonical tracker. Separate provider repositories still require linked adapter PRs/releases. No merge without user approval.

Current state

  • Functional passive inspection is published in accumulating draft #1588, head 0609cee23bc5a0a7afb1ecf7925c3e0885ad6629. Command: devsy dependency inspect <tool> --for-provider <installed-name> --json, bounded to trusted installed Docker, Podman, Apple and Kubernetes records/manifests. No dynamic resolution, process/network, acquisition, authentication, elevation or runtime start. Executable metadata remains compatibility-unknown and unexecuted; actions/managed support remain disabled.
  • Actual-main Linux PTY matrix passed all 36 cases including strict fresh-root preservation, errors/help/deletion/config cases and ordinary positive controls. Four generated reports passed unchanged frozen validators. Native macOS focused races/patch lint and Linux patch lint: 0 issues; Linux/Windows normal-vet compilation only. Separate unfiltered scoped lint retains 42 findings in unchanged lines.
  • Coordinator and independent source reviews CLEAR within their documented scopes. Credential-parent P1 reproduced red then green: default explicit Save restores missing 0700 category roots, import stays passive, custom/existing modes preserved; 20 Unix child cases under two umasks. Upstream mechanical identifier corrections retain legacy disk/env literals.
  • Fresh exact-head CI PENDING; completion/failure monitor active. Original 9eb CI failures are historical renamed-test-reference failures, now corrected. Completed Greptile >= 4/5 then completed CodeRabbit, all actionable threads and signatures still gate readiness. Local CLI CodeRabbit retry remained rate-limited (no completed review; no credits used). PR stays draft, no merge without user approval.
  • Earlier foundations remain published: contracts/guards/roots, disabled catalog, passive lookup/Survey, strict metadata/private writer, built-in adapter, read-only loaders/home/deletion fence, root policy and static saved/preview inputs. External trust, selections/reconciliation, probes, installer/ownership, other CLI and Desktop work remain.
  • Recipes/ranges empty; G01-G09 NOT RUN. Native Windows/managed runtime/hardware qualification absent. Constructor BindEnv fatal errors, profile-tag init, completion and synchronous filesystem limits remain outside the passive guarantee. Snapshot fingerprints confer no file identity, selection, ownership or CAS authority.

Implementation checkpoints

Tasks Current bounded result Remaining work
T00 Contract fixtures and senior guard helpers published Wire guards into future effectful production operations; no blanket completion
T01a / T01b NOT RUN Artifact digest/inventory/direct relocation; released-adapter SDK/full lifecycle
T02 Disabled catalog/source matching published Qualified adapter ranges/recipes remain absent
T03 Roots, strict codecs/private writer, read-only path/loading prerequisites published Reconciliation, store/reference integration; Windows writer unsupported
T04 Passive lookup/Survey, strict4built-in adapter and static saved/preview preparation published External adapter trust, saved selection/runtime parity
T05 NOT RUN Fixed-argv probes; transport seam separately reviewed or deferred
T06 NOT RUN Digest-before-parse download, malicious archive extraction, atomic publication
T07 NOT RUN G/liveness, authoritative references, select transaction, receipt-safe remove/tombstone and each mutation/launch integration
T08 NOT RUN Adapter manifest/path-pair/runtime-check implementation and released identity
T09 NOT RUN Senior-owned lifecycle/lock brief and bounded integrations
T10 Root policy, formatter and functional inspect published Fresh CI/reviews; other CLI operations/capabilities/status
T11-T13 NOT RUN Trusted IPC/nonce/input guards, wizard and Settings inventory/select/remove
T14 NOT RUN Lima/OrbStack guidance and provider regressions
T15 Deferred Updates/cohort/GC require separate scope approval
T16-T17 NOT RUN CI/native qualification, packaging/docs/support/release

Execution gates

Fixtures and compilation never enable managed support.

Gate State Missing evidence
G01 Published adapter NOT RUN Released path-pair/runtime-check contract and reproducible artifact identity
G02 Relocation NOT RUN Pinned archive, flat msb + firmware inventory, direct and SDK relocation
G03 macOS NOT RUN Named human, notarized candidate, Apple Silicon packaged lifecycle
G04 Linux NOT RUN ABI/current-user KVM and full Devsy-managed install/select/lifecycle
G05 Updates NOT RUN Two qualified versions and runtime-home compatibility; activation deferred
G06 Concurrency/removal NOT RUN Held flock liveness, authoritative references, crash/race/ownership evidence
G07 Effective environment/host NOT RUN Discovery/CLI/SDK/runtime agreement across configurations/hosts
G08 Desktop/CLI skew NOT RUN Capability fallback and wire compatibility
G09 License/distribution NOT RUN Release-owner review of terms/notices for exact artifact

Linux amd64 is first managed candidate; real isolated KVM job is required. macOS arm64 stays guided/disabled pending named-human notarized-candidate qualification; hosted macOS lacks nested virtualization. Linux arm64 remains BLOCKED pending bare-metal/self-hosted KVM. Windows is framework/fixture coverage only. Native tests must isolate both DEVSY_HOME and MSB_HOME under a new temp directory and prove the real MicroSandbox tree unchanged. Evidence identifies exact recipe, adapter/digest, Devsy candidate/package/architecture, OS/runtime and harness versions.

Release cuts remain: no staged updates/cohort engine, destructive GC, broad offline/local archive, prompt|managed add/init integration, Settings update UI or risky connection-probe refactor without separate approval. Provider add/init default stays never. External data are never owned/deleted. Passive operations perform no process/network/elevation/runtime effects. Full pinned digest precedes extraction. No core schema bump, Runtime Protocol change or Electron downloader. Lock order remains G -> global config -> short metadata, init TryLock outside G, artifact released before G, held flock liveness instead of PID authority.

Related distinct prior work: #1519, #1516, #1518. Keep final readiness separate from implementation progress and all managed qualification gates.

Activity

  1. skevetter commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @skevetter
    ContributorAuthor

    Checkpoint: core draft #1588 at af5e26f is mergeable and adds passive Desktop inspection; managed actions remain disabled. Linked adapter draft devsy-org/devsy-provider-microsandbox#35 at f4ee657 adds paired MSB_PATH/MSB_LIBKRUNFW_PATH and a bounded runtime-check. Its exact-head CI passed pinned v0.7.7 Linux amd64 archive relocation through the CLI, SDK and adapter. That is direct relocation evidence, not a released adapter or a Devsy-managed KVM lifecycle. The v0.7.7 archive has only msb and libkrunfw.so.5.6.1; upstream MicroSandbox source is Apache-2.0, while the firmware project documents LGPL-2.1-only library code and GPL-2.0-only bundled kernel/source obligations. Release-owner license/notices review remains required before managed enablement. Core removal is still blocked: SaveWorkspaceConfig writers do not coordinate with G, import holds config lock while writing live workspace data, and rename moves directories before saving. No merge or release performed.

  2. skevetter commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @skevetter
    ContributorAuthor

    Implementation checkpoint: core draft PR #1588 at 57ec879 has the current main merge, passive Desktop inspection, and a separate race-enabled CI stage for the passive-process helper. Local focused stage, lint, Desktop check, and 1,461 Desktop tests passed. Native Windows unit tests passed at the preceding head. Exact-head core CI run 41673672448 is pending. The prior core run failed in macOS cmd while compiling a nested helper under concurrent package tests and in the license job while proxy.golang.org downloads returned stream errors; neither failure was hidden.

    Linked adapter draft devsy-org/devsy-provider-microsandbox#35 at 777b1218a0726574d6f0dec50afbf6d00023e3ca passed 12 GitHub CI checks, including pinned Linux archive relocation, with 0 failed checks. Exact-head Greptile scored 5/5 with no new comments. Exact-head CodeRabbit was rate limited and did not complete.

    Core managed install, selection, and removal remain disabled: the adapter is not released; generation sidecars, authoritative writer fencing, leases, and safe removal are not integrated; full managed KVM qualification and release-owner review of LGPL/GPL firmware source and notices remain outstanding. No merge or release performed.

  3. skevetter commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @skevetter
    ContributorAuthor

    Checkpoint: core draft PR #1588 at fb202c7 passes exact-head core CI run 41711209236 and Desktop CI run 41711209264. The native Windows and macOS unit jobs, full E2E matrix, Desktop packaging, Go lint, precommit, and third-party license check passed. The installed provider icon-revision defect found in review was reproduced on Docker, Podman, Apple, and Kubernetes, fixed, and regression-tested. An isolated built CLI added and inspected Docker successfully. The addressed review thread is resolved; fresh final-head Greptile is running.

    Linked adapter draft devsy-org/devsy-provider-microsandbox#35 remains at 777b1218a0726574d6f0dec50afbf6d00023e3ca with CI and Greptile passing. Exact-head CodeRabbit was rate limited. The adapter is not merged or released. Current-user KVM qualification and release-owner firmware source/notices review remain outstanding.

    The owner chose no enforceable old-client cutoff. Because old clients with alternate DEVSY_CONFIG paths can publish a managed reference after a new client's removal scan, managed installation, selection, and destructive removal remain disabled. Both PRs stay draft; no merge or release.

  4. skevetter commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @skevetter
    ContributorAuthor

    Final-head checkpoint: core draft PR #1588 at fb202c7 passes core CI run 41711209236 and Desktop CI run 41711209264, with native macOS, Windows, Linux unit jobs and packaging. Greptile scored 5/5, added zero final-head comments, and all actionable threads are resolved. The installed built-in icon revision issue was reproduced red, fixed, and validated through normal installs and an isolated built CLI. CodeRabbit explicitly skipped the full review because this one accumulating PR changes 117 files, exceeding its 100-file limit.

    Linked adapter draft devsy-org/devsy-provider-microsandbox#35 at 777b1218a0726574d6f0dec50afbf6d00023e3ca passes CI and Greptile, but exact-head CodeRabbit was rate limited. It is not merged or released. Current-user Linux KVM qualification and release-owner review of firmware source/notices are outstanding.

    The owner selected no enforceable cutoff for older Devsy clients. Since an old client using another DEVSY_CONFIG can publish a managed reference after removal scans, managed installation, selection, and destructive removal remain disabled. Both PRs remain draft. No merge or release.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    provider-dependenciesProvider Dependencies rollout and evidence-gated implementation

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions