Skip to content

Record verified manual Notion and Grok Bot handoff trials - #51

Merged
sdcarlson merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
docs/manual-bot-evidence-current
Sep 6, 2026
Merged

sdcarlson merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
docs/manual-bot-evidence-current

Conversation

@sdcarlson

@sdcarlson sdcarlson commented Sep 6, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Closes #50.

Updates README and REVIEW with two dated manual handoff trials: the fictional native-Bot copy/paste round trip at 7cfec262, and the later three-record connected-Notion/installed-Bot trial at e9e6030. Returned drafts staged without saving; explicit save/reload preserved exact text. The three-record trial also verified stale-result rejection and repeat-import deduplication. Records stayed Held and unaccepted. Earlier assisted-trial evidence remains linked and every historical REVIEW snapshot is unchanged.

The newer records came from historical Notion research fetched read-only through the connected tool. Bot replies were observed and manually transcribed into JSON files. These results do not validate automatic transport, the standalone Notion command connector, current role availability/fit, deployment, or submissions. No private identities, job names, drafts, source URLs, record IDs or local paths are published.

Validation: independently compared the added claims with both private QA reports and their exact tested commits/times; git diff --check and project public-copy validation pass; historical REVIEW content is prefix-identical. Implementation used fresh sessions whose init records identify Cursor Grok 4.6 Extra High, followed by independent diff review. Final scope is two documentation files, sixteen added lines, with no application, test, workflow or canonical product-fact changes. Full application suites were not rerun locally for prose-only edits; required GitHub checks apply to the final head.

Prior head 5fc73b8 passed all required jobs after exactly one fresh CI rerun; its initial synthetic 503 failure is preserved on #22. That result and the earlier approval do not approve the new head. #22 remains a separate investigation. Scope is now frozen for fresh exact-head review and merge.

@sdcarlson
sdcarlson requested a review from sykosyber as a code owner September 6, 2026 02:28

@cursor cursor Bot left a comment •

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Stale comment

Read-only review of head 5fc73b80857b2c566600954191d0211d187e1fb0 (still current at post time). No prior review threads to reconcile.

No actionable defects. Two-file prose append (README.md +4, REVIEW.md +4). No application, schema, test, workflow, or public-copy source changes.

Issue #50 acceptance holds: the new REVIEW section records the fictional packet→Bot→pasted-JSON trial on 7cfec262e02a2d255e233b0f335e056cab24a13e (unique, ancestor of origin/main), distinguishes paste-staging from explicit save/reload, and keeps Held / unaccepted / unsubmitted plus unverified automatic transfer and Bot VM commands. README links the earlier 3b1efd7 / 59ec7ac assisted-trial heading. Historical REVIEW bytes are prefix-identical to the merge-base; only an append was added. Public relay:public:* section is untouched. Wording does not claim production, adoption, or #20 (still open).

Adjacent contracts inspected (not re-executed): loadPastedDraft → onDraft → applyLoadedDraft updates editor state only; save(current.status) does not accept or promote Held.

Ran: gh pr view / reviews GraphQL; git diff + git diff --check (clean) on e9e6030...5fc73b8; commit existence/uniqueness/ancestry; REVIEW prefix equality; issues #50 and #20 titles/state.

Inspected only: AGENTS.md + docs/threat-model.md; paste/save/acceptance functions above; integrations/GROK_BOT.md limits; public-copy markers. Did not run pnpm test / lint / public-copy:check / e2e, replay private QA, or exercise the claimed 2026-09-06 trial.

Human approval remains mandatory. This review does not approve, merge, or deploy.

Open in Web View Automation 

Sent by Cursor Automation: RELAY pull request review

@sykosyber sykosyber left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Comment on exact 5fc73b80857b2c566600954191d0211d187e1fb0. Extra High independently traced the unique two-file, eight-line delta. It does not change app, auth, schema, workflow, or docs/public-copy.json. The README additions sit after <!-- relay:public:end --> in Integration boundaries, so they are outside the managed public-copy block; Quality on this head succeeded, including that check.

REVIEW.md only appends a new section. Historical snapshots (6f88ea2, assisted trial 3b1efd7/59ec7ac, round 2, PR24 integration) are unchanged. The new text names exact tested commit 7cfec262e02a2d255e233b0f335e056cab24a13e, distinguishes paste-without-save from explicit save/reload, keeps Held/unaccepted/unsubmitted, and leaves automatic Bot file transfer and the Bot VM command environment unverified. It does not close #20, leak private QA payloads, or claim application sending.

Holding last-push APPROVE: required Integration (production) failed on this head (job 101414756801). Assertion is scripts/ci/run-production.mjs:253 via expectStatus at line 148: owner-a save returned 503 after the intentional 403. Diagnostic body is Wrangler text/plain;charset=UTF-8 Your worker restarted mid-request..., retry-after: 0, process exit=null/signal=null. That is the open #22 pattern, not this prose delta. Extra High will APPROVE this same SHA only after required checks including production and aggregator CI are green. Extra High is not merging and is not closing #22.

sykosyber
sykosyber previously approved these changes Sep 6, 2026

@sykosyber sykosyber left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Approve exact 5fc73b80857b2c566600954191d0211d187e1fb0. Extra High independently re-read this unique two-file, eight-line prose delta (README.md + REVIEW.md). No app, auth, schema, workflow, or docs/public-copy.json change. README additions remain after <!-- relay:public:end -->. Historical REVIEW snapshots are unchanged. The new text names 7cfec262e02a2d255e233b0f335e056cab24a13e, distinguishes paste-without-save from explicit save/reload, keeps Held/unaccepted/unsubmitted, and does not close #20 or claim application sending.

Required hosted checks on this head are now green, including Integration (production) rerun job 101415218484 and aggregator CI job 101415271126. The earlier owner-a save 503 on job 101414756801 remains open #22 evidence and is not closed by this approval. Extra High is not merging and is not deploying.

@sdcarlson sdcarlson changed the title Record the verified manual Grok Bot draft round trip Record verified manual Notion and Grok Bot handoff trials Sep 6, 2026
@sdcarlson
sdcarlson requested a review from sykosyber September 6, 2026 02:39

@sykosyber sykosyber left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Request changes on exact 5fc73b80857b2c566600954191d0211d187e1fb0 for an operational merge-link, not a code defect. Extra High previously APPROVED this SHA (review 5123843962) after required CI went green. The unique two-file, eight-line README/REVIEW append is still clean: no app, auth, schema, workflow, or docs/public-copy.json change.

GitHub currently treats this PR as a closer of #22. GraphQL closingIssuesReferences on #51 lists both #50 (intended via Closes #50.) and #22. Issue #22's timeline has a CrossReferencedEvent from this PR at 2026-09-06T02:31:19Z with willCloseTarget: true. The PR description currently ends with "this pass does not resolve #22." GitHub closing keywords include resolve/resolves/resolved; the surrounding negation does not prevent auto-close. Squash-merging would close #22 the same way #40 did; Extra High already reopened #22 because a diagnostic capture and a green production rerun do not establish a runtime cause.

Please remove every close/fix/resolve keyword aimed at #22 from the PR title and body before merge (for example, say the production 503 remains an open investigation on issue 22). Extra High will re-APPROVE this same SHA only after closingIssuesReferences no longer includes #22. Extra High is not merging and is not deploying.

@cursor cursor Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Read-only review of head 8f7ee2c16958e903e114f81d672477098ddbedbd (still current at post time). Prior automation review of 5fc73b8 is superseded. No prior inline threads to reconcile.

No actionable defects. Subsequent push appends one README paragraph and one REVIEW section (two files, +16 lines). No application, schema, test, workflow, or docs/public-copy.json changes.

The earlier Extra High merge-link concern is gone on this metadata: closingIssuesReferences lists only #50; #22's CrossReferencedEvent from this PR has willCloseTarget: false; the body no longer uses a close/fix/resolve keyword for #22.

#50 still holds via the unchanged first REVIEW section on unique ancestor 7cfec262e02a2d255e233b0f335e056cab24a13e. The new section names unique e9e6030cae4c413ffde9ab83615bac7955de10bb (origin/main). Historical REVIEW bytes are prefix-identical to the merge-base and to 5fc73b8. Public relay:public:* is untouched. Added prose has no job names, drafts, URLs, IDs, or paths. #20 stays open. Text does not claim automatic Bot transfer, the standalone Notion command connector, production, adoption, or submissions.

Adjacent contracts inspected (not re-executed): file load draftFromResult → onDraft → applyLoadedDraft stages editor text only; packetMatchesStarted rejects version/key mismatch; import INSERT OR IGNORE observations plus job conflict keeps Held and does not accept.

Ran: gh pr view / GraphQL reviews and closingIssuesReferences; git diff + git diff --check (clean) on e9e6030...8f7ee2c and 5fc73b8...8f7ee2c; SHA uniqueness/ancestry; REVIEW prefix equality; issues #50, #20, #22 state.

Inspected only: AGENTS.md + docs/threat-model.md; functions above; public-copy markers; gh pr checks (listed green at review time). Did not run pnpm test / lint / public-copy:check / e2e, replay private QA, or repeat the claimed trials.

Human approval remains mandatory. This review does not approve, merge, or deploy.

Open in Web View Automation 

Sent by Cursor Automation: RELAY pull request review

@sykosyber sykosyber left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Approve exact 8f7ee2c16958e903e114f81d672477098ddbedbd. Extra High independently re-read this unique two-file, sixteen-line README/REVIEW append against e9e6030 and against prior head 5fc73b8. No app, auth, schema, workflow, or docs/public-copy.json change (0ca6850b identical to main). README additions remain after <!-- relay:public:end -->. Historical REVIEW snapshots are prefix-identical; only two dated sections were appended.

The first REVIEW section still names unique ancestor 7cfec262e02a2d255e233b0f335e056cab24a13e, distinguishes paste-without-save from explicit save/reload, and keeps Held/unaccepted/unsubmitted. The added three-record section names e9e6030cae4c413ffde9ab83615bac7955de10bb, keeps connected Notion read-only plus hand-transcribed installed-Bot JSON, and does not publish identities, job names, drafts, URLs, record IDs, or paths. It does not close #20, claim automatic transfer, the standalone Notion command connector, production, adoption, or application sending.

Adjacent contracts inspected on current main (not re-executed): draftFromResult / packetMatchesStarted in lib/integration-files.ts reject version or key mismatch; applyLoadedDraft in lib/editor.ts updates editor text only when fileLoadApplies; app/api/workspace/route.ts import uses INSERT OR IGNORE observations and the job conflict keeps existing status rather than accepting; save writes accepted_draft only when status === 'Ready'.

The earlier Extra High REQUEST_CHANGES (review 5123853770) was about GitHub auto-close of #22 from the previous description. Current GraphQL closingIssuesReferences lists only #50. #22 remains a separate investigation.

Required hosted checks on this head are green, including Integration (production) job 101416045400 and aggregator CI job 101416170584. High Fast COMMENT 5123855346 is not Extra High approval. Extra High is not merging and is not deploying.

@sdcarlson
sdcarlson merged commit ad4bb8f into main Sep 6, 2026
10 checks passed
@sdcarlson
sdcarlson deleted the docs/manual-bot-evidence-current branch September 6, 2026 02:54
cursor Bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 6, 2026
Co-authored-by: sykosyber <sykosyber@users.noreply.github.com>
sdcarlson pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 6, 2026
<!-- CURSOR_AGENT_PR_BODY_BEGIN -->
## Problem and result

Closes #47
Closes #48

The cleanup queue that deferred closed PR #26 has landed. Open PR #46
already contains #26, but it cannot merge: it conflicts with current
`main` on `README.md`, `app/globals.css`, `integrations/connectors.mjs`,
and `package.json`, and it still carries a stale toolchain.

This PR reconciles that work onto current `main` (`ad4bb8f`, including
#44, #45, and #51). After merge, a signed-in applicant can:

- Keep a verified fact ledger and learned style rules that **refuse**
unsupported agent claims at the API (nothing invented reaches the review
queue).
- Review logged drafts in batches; staging is not acceptance and never
sends an application.
- Set preferences by choosing between real postings, then get a weekly
plan that maximises the expected value of the **best single offer**
under an attention budget.
- Pull public Greenhouse and Lever boards onto existing job identity
(read-only, no credentials).
- Record outcomes with a **receipt** before a submission counts toward
reply rates, including an explicit Track action for a newly accepted
Ready job. Ended applications cannot be reopened by import.

Who needed this: people using assistants at volume, and anyone whose
Live loop currently has no honest terminal/receipt model. What failed
before: #26 was closed as deferred-not-rejected; #46 was blocked on
conflicts. What they can do afterward: use `/profile`, `/review`,
`/preferences`, `/plan`, and `/track` on current `main` without dropping
session expiry, dirty-editor navigation, null-URL packet identity,
recruiter-facing copy, dual-builder credit, or public-copy generation.

Supersedes reopening #26. Do not merge conflicted #46 directly. PR #46
commits can stay until this replacement is accepted.

## Evidence

- Prior `3e081b4` blockers remain cleared: Offer-to-Accepted,
Held-to-Accepted empty draft, empty `delta:[]` 400, stale outcome 409
with versioned Track caller.
- Review 5123899043 merge blockers, fixed on `49ff152` (ponytail list
not applied):
1. `POST /api/preferences` no longer persists a client `delta`. Winner
and loser job keys are the record; the comparison is recomputed from
owned Held posting features. `delta: []` and four repeated `[1e308,…]`
payloads return 400 and leave `answered` unchanged. The preferences UI
sends only those two keys.
2. `numberIsAboutEmployer` is deleted. Every digit in a non-question is
a claim. Mixed-subject sentences and `I read your 2024 post on storage
engines.` refuse `validateDraftLog` with `cited: []`.
3. Track GET prep includes Ready jobs. Ready rows expose a receipt field
and **Record submission** (`kind: 'submitted'`, `version`, `receipt`)
through `app/track/page.tsx`. Playwright covers that caller. Seth
independently verified the receipt UI on `179df12` and resolved those
threads. Overflow on `179df12` was also resolved as bounded `[-1,1]`
components.
- Review 5123907359 on superseded `179df12`: nearest-subject still
missed `I bring your team 15 years of experience.` and `I offer your
company 12 years of experience.` Those sentences reject on `49ff152`
(exemption deleted). `91e7e57` adds those two strings as regressions.
The parser was not expanded.
- GitHub Integration (production) on `91e7e57` failed at `owner-a save`
with Wrangler `worker restarted mid-request` (503, process still
running). Same tree passes `pnpm test:production` locally. `e5c00b3`
retriggers required CI only; #22 stays a separate investigation.
- Checks run and result (local, including `e5c00b3` production re-run):
`pnpm lint` clean; `pnpm typecheck` clean; `pnpm test` 174/174; `pnpm
public-copy:check` current; `pnpm build` succeeded; `pnpm test:api`
passed; `pnpm test:calibration` passed; `pnpm test:orchestration`
passed; `pnpm test:e2e` 8/8; `pnpm test:production` passed including
migrations `0000`–`0004`.
- Review re-requested on this head. Do not reopen #26 or merge #46. Do
not wait on hosting #3.

## Review

- [x] One issue owns this scope; unrelated changes are separate.
- [x] Tests exercise the changed behavior, including failure paths.
- [x] No credentials, personal applications, or private research are
included.
- [ ] Agent findings are fixed or answered with evidence.
- [ ] A maintainer other than the author will approve.

- [x] Public capabilities, integration limits and lead-engineer credit
match `docs/public-copy.json`; run `pnpm public-copy:check` and follow
`docs/PUBLIC-COPY.md` when these change.

### Landing notes for review

- Merged `origin/main` (`ad4bb8f`) and resolved public copy in favor of
#45 wording and credit, plus this PR's capabilities.
- Kept current `package.json` (Apache-2.0, React 19.2.8, Vinext beta.9,
Node 24). Did not restore unused UI-kit deps from #46.
- Dirty-nav confirm on `/profile`, `/review`, `/preferences`, `/plan`,
`/track`.
- Terminal statuses are workspace filters and protected saves; they are
not import statuses. Offer can still be accepted as an outcome.
- Live suites `tests/api.test.mjs`, `tests/calibration.test.mjs`, and
`tests/orchestration.test.mjs` each run on a dedicated freshly migrated
D1 in required CI.

Standing instruction for agents: #47 and #48 must not be deferred behind
hosting #3 or experiment #5.
<!-- CURSOR_AGENT_PR_BODY_END -->

<div><a
href="https://cursor.com/agents/bc-3877d527-b5e4-46d7-8c5f-573418309ece?cursor_ref=pr_footer&cursor_cta=open_in_web"><picture><source
media="(prefers-color-scheme: dark)"
srcset="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-web-dark.png"><source
media="(prefers-color-scheme: light)"
srcset="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-web-light.png"><img
alt="Open in Web" width="114" height="28"
src="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-web-dark.png"></picture></a>&nbsp;<a
href="https://cursor.com/background-agent?bcId=bc-3877d527-b5e4-46d7-8c5f-573418309ece&cursor_ref=pr_footer&cursor_cta=open_in_cursor"><picture><source
media="(prefers-color-scheme: dark)"
srcset="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-cursor-dark.png"><source
media="(prefers-color-scheme: light)"
srcset="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-cursor-light.png"><img
alt="Open in Cursor" width="131" height="28"
src="https://cursor.com/assets/images/open-in-cursor-dark.png"></picture></a>&nbsp;</div>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com>
Co-authored-by: sykosyber <sykosyber@users.noreply.github.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Record the verified manual native-Bot draft round trip

2 participants