Skip to content

Fast scrolling with double tab #88

Closed as not planned
Closed as not planned

Description

@mrtngamper

What would you like?

The option to enable scrolling by first letter through lists, by double tapping and then moving on the click-wheel. This would require some rewrite of the click-wheel driver. If this feature is of interest, I could provide a POC.

So to summarize, the idea is:

  • normal list scrolling, if the finger is pressed on the click-wheel once and then turns.
  • scrolling by first letter, if the finger double taps on the click-wheel and then turns.

Why?

Currently, the scrolling works fine per se, but in very long lists it sometimes isn't very useful. E.g, when one scrolls to letter M and there are 300 entries starting with M. If one then wants to scroll to the 150th element of M, one has to scroll very slowly from that point onwards to not accidentally trigger fast scrolling. This proposal would solve that by making the letter scrolling a bit more predictable.

Where would you look for it?

No response

Version

No response

Activity

  1. MickEventide commented on Nov 2, 2026

    @MickEventide

    I'm not a maintainer but I am curious what you mean by "double tap"? You mean tapping the wheel in the same place while not sliding one's finger around it? You do not mean "double clicking" right?

  2. mrtngamper commented on Nov 2, 2026

    @mrtngamper
    ContributorAuthor

    The idea is something like this, so yes, tapping and not clicking (click is already used). The feature is only relevant though, if the library exceeds a certain size.

    Image
  3. Som-2-One commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    This is very cool! I didn't even know tapping the scroll-wheel was a possible control-interface!

    This could well be a solution to the ongoing discussion around how to refine fast-scroll / letter-scroll delineation!
    SchulzCode/Y2Linux#64

  4. mrtngamper commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @mrtngamper
    ContributorAuthor

    Technically, the wheel is a 15 zone touchpad and the rotation is calculated just by checking in which direction the pads are being tapped. So there is quite a few things that can be done with it (but it is quite bad for small direction changes)

    In theory it can also be used as a joystick 🙃.

    Grim.Fandango.mp4
  5. MickEventide commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @MickEventide

    I just want to express support for this. Since 9.2.13 scrolling has felt too fast for me. Especially in cover flow and album view.

    In cover flow and album view I want to browse visually, so letter assisted scrolling is annoying for two reasons in addition to what you shared. First the visual obstruction. When the letter pops up, it covers part of my album art. Also, the letter is animated. The letter changing makes it hard to focus on the art underneath. Second is pure speed. While I understand the acceleration of letter assisted scrolling is great for 5000 songs or 500 albums. I only have 60 albums and once letter assisted scrolling activates they rush by so fast that I can't distinguish my album art.

    I was considering making a feature request to have the option to disable letter assisted scrolling entirely (or at least in cover flow and album view). That typed, I remembered your idea here and I think it is a better solution.

    I would like letter assisted scrolling and the very fast scrolling speed that was inaccessible before 9.2.13 locked behind a double tap. Without a double tap, the scrolling curve reverted to before the 9.2.13 change.

  6. SchulzCode commented on Nov 5, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Sorry for the late answer, and thanks a lot for the offer: yes, I'd like to see a proof of concept!

    Where it would go: the wheel driver is kernel/platform/apt32f-wheel.c in Y2Linux. Today it only handles class-3 frames (rotation) and turns them into KEY_UP/KEY_DOWN/KEY_PAGEUP/KEY_PAGEDOWN; every other frame is dropped, and the five buttons come through gpio-keys. A tap gesture would need the driver to pass something new up (for example its own key code or a touch event), and Reborn would then switch a list into letter mode until the finger lifts.

    What I'd ask for, so it fits:

    • Normal scrolling and the buttons must behave exactly as now; the tap mode is an addition.
    • The controller's sleep/wake handling in the same driver stays as it is (it was hard to get right for battery life).
    • A setting to turn it off, so people who tap the wheel by accident aren't surprised.

    If you can show which frames the controller sends for a tap (a short log of raw frames would already help a lot), I can tell you quickly whether it fits. The scrolling speed that MickEventide describes since 9.2.13 is a separate point I'll look at as well.

  7. Som-2-One commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    Oh yeah I forgot about this idea!
    Sorry, I've just bumped the same problem under SchulzCode/Y2Linux#64

    This would also be a great solution - not sure which solution is easier / better to implement but one or the other would make navigating large lists that bit easier :)

  8. SchulzCode commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks again for the offer and the discussion! I'm closing this. A double tap needs a new wheel driver that tells taps apart, and like the centre button's double tap (#98), every single touch would have to wait to see whether a second one follows, which makes the wheel feel slower. Fast scrolling already steps by letter when you spin quickly. It's on the list of ideas that won't be built.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    enhancementNew feature or request

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions