Skip to content

Y2 stuttering over Bluetooth with Bush SR210-12 Bluetooth Soundbar when Y2's WiFi enabled #99

Closed as not planned

Description

@Iron-Wolf-23

Version

9.3.16

Output

Bluetooth

Headphones or speaker model

Bush SR210-12 Bluetooth Soundbar

What do you hear, and when?

My Skullcandy Dime 2 Bluetooth Earbuds and my SONRU Bluetooth Audio Receiver work as expected, but my Bush SR210-12 Bluetooth Soundbar has been stuttering, as in the clip attached to my Reddit reply.

I'm still having an issue after 9.3.16 and I've discovered it could be linked to the Y2's WiFi being on. If I turn WiFi off and reconnect the soundbar via Bluetooth, it seems to play normally

Link to Reddit comment:
https://www.reddit.com/r/innioasis/s/9uMof59Vrr

File type

No response

How often?

Every time

Since when?

It always did this

Error report

Will send report today and add ID here if GitHub allows

Anything else

No response

Activity

  1. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 7, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    Report sent

    This could be to do with whatever happens when my Y2 first starts playback after connecting to the Bush soundbar via Bluetooth
    It could also relate to distance from the soundbar, because it was less likely to skip when on my desk right next to the soundbar

  2. RockinProjex commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @RockinProjex
  3. kchiem commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @kchiem

    OP, I think you failed to submit the report ID.

  4. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    Does this work?

    Install ID is 90B5ABF3
    y2linux-report-20261108-190934.tar.gz

    I tried the soundbar this evening via Bluetooth with WiFi off and the sound was still cutting out

  5. SchulzCode commented on Nov 9, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks for the reports and the clip, and sorry for the wait.

    What the reports show: on the player's side the stream is clean: no gaps, no codec errors, and the soundbar runs SBC at its highest setting (the player's lowest SBC choice is "High"). The soundbar dropped the link twice, and it took several attempts to connect at first. Both fit a weak radio link between the player and the soundbar, which also matches what you noticed about distance. One small thing: in the report you sent after the "Wi-Fi off" test, Wi-Fi was on at that moment, so that test may not have been fully without Wi-Fi.

    New in the next update (Beta 9.3.20): an SBC Auto Rate switch. With it on, the player lowers SBC's data rate whenever the link can't keep up, and raises it again once it can. The setting is in the service menu: Settings → System → About, tap Version seven times, then SBC Auto Rate. Restart the player after changing it.

    After the update, could you try with SBC Auto Rate on, first with Wi-Fi off (Settings → Wi-Fi off), then on? A report after a stutter with it on would show how often it had to step down. I'm leaving this open until we know whether it helps.

  6. SchulzCode commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    SBC Auto Rate is in Beta 9.3.20: Settings → System → About, tap Version seven times, then Diagnostics → SBC Auto Rate. It's off by default. If you can, please try your soundbar with it on, with Wi-Fi on, and tell me whether the stuttering changes.

  7. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    I've sent an error report now within the Y2 over wi-fi

    The new update seems to have helped with BT playback, especially if I let the player sit untouched in front of the speaker. It will still stutter if I pick it up to check the screen or if I press the side screen on/off button. Is that shown in the error report?

  8. SchulzCode commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks for the report. With SBC Auto Rate on, the player stepped the rate down twice in under two minutes and the connection never dropped, so it is doing its job. What the report couldn't tell me is when a stutter happened.

    Beta 9.3.24 changes that: it records each rate step with its time, so a report sent right after a stutter shows what the link did at that moment.

    To separate the two things you noticed, could you update and try these (answering by number is fine):

    1. Player lying still in front of the soundbar, you only press the screen button: does it stutter? [yes / no]
    2. Screen left alone, you only pick the player up: does it stutter? [yes / no]
    3. The same two tests with Wi-Fi off (Settings → Wi-Fi): any difference? [yes / no / not tried]

    Then please send an error report right after a stutter.

  9. added
    needs-infoWaiting for the author's answer; comes off when they reply
    on Nov 11, 2026
  10. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    The error report I've just sent is unrelated to the Bluetooth/stuttering issue. I sent it because Windows Explorer kept closing on me while I was trying to copy the system.img file for FM radio. Eventually, I got system.img copied over using a different USB port on my PC

    I will check the Bluetooth/stuttering and send a further error report after that if needed

  11. removed
    needs-infoWaiting for the author's answer; comes off when they reply
    on Nov 13, 2026
  12. SchulzCode commented on Nov 17, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    A friendly nudge: did you get a chance to try the three tests from my last comment (screen button only / picking it up only / both with Wi-Fi off)? Since 9.3.24 a report sent right after a stutter shows what the link did at that moment.

    If I don't hear back in about a week I'll close this, and you can reopen it any time.

  13. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 17, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    I've just had a look now, but the menu options seem to have changed in one of the latest updates.
    Is the SBC Auto Rate settings one of these in Diagnostics > Bluetooth?

    PXL_20261117_191042232 RAW-01 MP
  14. Iron-Wolf-23 commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @Iron-Wolf-23
    Author

    The 2 error reports I've just sent aren't a test of SBC Auto Rate, but I hope they'll show you where the player stuttered, which I fixed temporarily by restarting my Y2

  15. SchulzCode commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks for all the testing. Your two reports from today settle it: at 09:47 SBC Auto Rate stepped the rate down six times in 20 seconds, and Wi-Fi was off the whole time (you switched it on at 09:48 to send the reports). So it isn't Wi-Fi. It's the radio link to the soundbar, which gets worse when the player is picked up or moved. There were no gaps or errors on the player's side.

    Where we are: Y2Linux already does what a phone does: it lowers the data rate when the link struggles, keeps Bluetooth off the Wi-Fi channel, lets Wi-Fi rest while music streams, limits the catch-up after a dropout and fills gaps with silence. I've worked through every Bluetooth report again, and the player's side is clean in all of them. What's left is the hardware: the Y2 has one small radio that shares its antenna with Wi-Fi, and it just can't hold a link the way a phone can. We've reached the ceiling of what software can do here.

    Honestly, if you want music without dropouts on the Y2, I'd recommend wired headphones.

    Beta 9.3.34 adds one last thing: each stall of the Bluetooth link is now written down, so if something new ever shows up, a report will say when and how long. More in the 9.3.34 report. I'm closing this; thanks a lot for the reports and the patience.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    soundSound, Bluetooth, playback

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions