Skip to content

some m4b files not recognized #84

Closed as not planned
Closed as not planned

Description

@gionnigio39

I have all the Harry Potter books as separate files, which play perfectly complete with chapter markers. However, I also have a single file containing the entire saga, for some reason, it isn’t being recognized, even though it’s also an M4B file. My guess is that it might be due to the file size.

Activity

  1. SchulzCode commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks for reporting this! A few details will help find out why this one file is left out:

    1. Version: which Beta is installed? (Settings → System → About)
    2. The file: how big is it (in GB), and about how long (hours)? Roughly how many chapters does it have?
    3. Where it is: on the SD card or on Internal Storage? If it is on the SD card: is the card formatted exFAT or FAT32?
    4. How you copied it: over USB to the player (MTP), or with the SD card in a card reader? After copying, does the file on the player show the same size as on your computer?
    5. What "not recognized" looks like: is the file missing from Audiobooks only, or also from Songs and Folders? Did you run Settings → Library → Scan for Music after copying it?
    6. On a computer: does this same file (the copy on the player or card) play to the end there?
    7. Error report: right after a Scan for Music, go to Settings → System → Error Reports → Send Report Now and post the Install ID shown on that page here. Without Wi-Fi, use Save Report and attach the file from the Error Reports folder (how). Reports hold no titles or file names.
  2. gionnigio39 commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @gionnigio39
    Author

    version: 1.0 beta 9.291.3
    file: 3.1gb 118h 206 chapters
    sd: i trided exFAT and FAT32 same resault
    I used a USB adapter, and the file doesn't show up in the player at all; however, the storage settings indicate that space on the SD card is being used

    error reports: 3A1F5AFC

  3. SchulzCode commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Thanks for the report! The problem isn't the file size or the card format: it's the length. An M4B keeps a table with one entry for every tiny piece of audio, and for 118 hours that table is larger than the player currently allows itself to read while opening a file, so the file is skipped. Your separate books are well under that limit, which is why they work.

    For now, please keep using the separate files (or split the saga into parts of up to about 30 hours each). I'm looking at how to support very long single files properly.

  4. gionnigio39 commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @gionnigio39
    Author

    Okay, thanks, I hope you manage to resolve it. Because, apart from that, this is the best firmware I’ve ever tried on the Y2.

  5. SchulzCode commented on Nov 9, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    A small step for this one in the next update (Beta 9.3.20): a file the library can't open is no longer left out without a word. Settings → Library now says, for example, "1 file couldn't be read (damaged, or an audiobook too long for one file), so it isn't in your library."

    The real fix, playing a 118-hour book as one file, needs its own way of reading the book's index without loading all of it into memory, and isn't done yet. Until then, splitting the saga into parts of up to about 30 hours each works. I'm leaving this open for that.

  6. SchulzCode commented on Nov 10, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    That step is out in Beta 9.3.20: Settings → Library now counts a file too long to read, so it's no longer missing without a word. Playing such long single files needs a bigger change; until then, splitting the book into parts of up to about 30 hours works.

  7. SchulzCode commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Closing this one. Playing a single audiobook file of more than about 30 hours would need a new way of reading the book's index in pieces, and files that long are rare. Since 9.3.20, Settings → Library says when a file is too long, so nothing goes missing without a word. Splitting the book into parts of up to about 30 hours works (your Harry Potter books as separate files play fine, with chapters). It's on the list of ideas that won't be built. Thanks for the report!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions