Skip to content

Fast scroll is quirky, often activates too easily and it is very difficult to scroll line by line but fast #64

Closed

Description

@just4747

When scrolling large arist/song/album lists, the fast scroll is great to get through large lists fast or get to a certain part of the list fast, but at the same time it makes it very difficult to scroll incrementally/line by line without going very very slow (otherwise, fast scroll activates way too easily).

I don't want to lose the ability to scroll large lists fast since we have to use the wheel, but also we need to be able to scroll fairly quickly line by line without it going right into fast scroll too easily. Is there any way to tweak this so it's a bit more balanced, or maybe give a sensitivity slider for how easily fast scrolling activates?

Also, or alternatively, if you could simply dial back how easily fast scrolling activates by just a little bit, that alone might fix the issue.

Or maybe implement how iPod touches did it where fast scroll only goes between A-Z letters instead of the whole list/every line. That would be great actually if it behaved similarly to that.

Activity

  1. SchulzCode commented on Oct 31, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Tuned in Y2Linux 1.0 Beta 9.2.2: a quick, steady turn now moves row by row, and the letter jumps (like the iPod's) start only when you really spin the wheel. Update with Settings → About & Updates → Update Now, and tell me if it feels right now.

  2. just4747 commented on Oct 31, 2026

    @just4747
    Author

    Hi Schulz - thank you. While finer scrolling line by line works well now and I can get to all lines without accidentally skipping them, I am now unable to get fast scroll to activate at all, even when scrolling so fast my finger hurts. I don't see any skipping of letter by letter no matter what I try. Unfortunately now takes quite long to get to any lower part of the lists. Have tested in Artist and Song lists. I have installed both FW updates today btw.

    Also, are you able to allow scrolling up from the start of these lists to instantly get to the bottom (Artists, Songs, etc lists)?

    Thanks!

  3. Som-2-One commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    @just4747 Settings -> Customize -> Browsing -> Lists Wrap Around: Everywhere will enable scrolling up from start to get to bottom 👍

    As for the letter scroll: I second this. Original request was spot-on, the sensitivity to slip into Alphabet scroll was just a bit too touchy, but now I also can't get it to activate at all

  4. SchulzCode commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    @Som-2-One the Wheel Hardware is so shit, it's impossible to tune correctly xD I will try to adjust it again tomorrow!

  5. just4747 commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @just4747
    Author

    @just4747 Settings -> Customize -> Browsing -> Lists Wrap Around: Everywhere will enable scrolling up from start to get to bottom 👍

    That works, thanks!

  6. SchulzCode commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @SchulzCode
    Owner

    Adjusted again in Y2Linux 1.0 Beta 9.2.13. 9.2.2 started the letter jumps only at the wheel's very fastest speed, which, as you both found, a hard spin never reached. They now start at a real spin, while a quick, steady turn still moves row by row as in 9.2.2.

    Update with Settings → System → Software Update → Update Now. Let me know how it feels. If it's still off in either direction, I can tune it further.

  7. RockinProjex commented on Nov 1, 2026

    @RockinProjex

    This is just a suggestion, not a reason to reopen BUT as mentioned I too think scrolling could be configured better based on song or folder count.

    If the folder has many subfolders or songs, alternatively the artists/albums/songs menu, then could the scrolling be done by 2 letters? This would probably only be for English letters only not other languages, but having it go # > Aa > Ab > Ac > Ad etc would be better for huge libraries

  8. Som-2-One commented on Nov 2, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    @SchulzCode Thanks mate, I'll fiddle a bit more but initial impression is that the scroll/fast scroll/alphabet scroll is pretty good now. I'll let the muscle memory adapt for a bit then should be right 🤙

    @RockinProjex I could see that being useful with very large libraries... Maybe it could be triggered only when list-size > 10,000 or something?

  9. just4747 commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @just4747
    Author

    Scrolling is still a bit finnicky/quirky for me. Something about it is just weird, hard to explain. Like now, yes you can scroll slower without it activating fast scroll but it still happens too easily and also not easy enough at the same time sometimes - lol i know, that doesn't really make sense.

    And it seems like once it gets locked into fast scroll, it stays locked in it unless you lift your finger off of the wheel for a sec and go back on it. Did you want it programmed that way? I know that iPods aren't like that but not sure if you wanted that specifically. I feel like, similar to an iPod, it's best if you could get back to normal slow scroll without having to lift your finger off to "cancel" the fast scroll, and just slowing down to a certain speed alone will deactivate it.

    Another negative seems to be on the skin side. For example, the Neon Night and Zune ones do not show letter popups as you fast scroll through letter to letter, but some other themes like Reborn that DO have the popups. I really wish that all themes could have the letters show up, as it is very helpful like iPods have, but I guess I guess it's theme dependent. Are you also the creator of the themes or are those made by others? Who can do updates to them?

    EDIT: I checked the fast scroll again and I guess it does deactivate without lifting your finger if you just pause a second or two after stopping. It was hard to tell this was happening with themes that do not show letter popups, but clearer with ones that do. So maybe the lifting finger thing is a non-issue.

    Thanks!

  10. Som-2-One commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    @just4747 agreed about alternative skins not showing the letter pop-ups (they should) but there's also a fair bit of minor jank with the alt skins (historically: icons missing, scroll-smoothness, timers displaying, etc) Periodically they get birthdays but it seems that it takes extra effort once new functionality is implemented, to roll it out to display cleanly on the other skins so might just be a matter of waiting for the next "skins update" to catch these minor bits.

    As for the delay to drop back from Letter-Scroll into normal scroll: as you found, you don't have to lift your finger but there is a delay. The delay is intentional so if you overshoot the letter you're looking for, you can step back to it without dropping out of letter scroll and starting the process over. This delay also allows the user to scroll fast to engage letter-scroll, but then slow down to gently step through letters, rather than having to maintain the same scroll-speed to stay in letter scroll (it was originally like this and felt very rushed and hard to use)

  11. just4747 commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @just4747
    Author

    I think my main issue is that it still goes into fast scroll a little too easily and then even after you pause and allow it to drop back to slow scroll, it is again way too easy for it to begin fast scrolling again right after.

    I think maybe the sensitivity needs to be dialed back a little more on the separation. i.e. it is just difficult to keep it at slower scrolling when you want it to, in my opinion.

  12. Som-2-One commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    Fair shout there may be room for finer tuning to really polish the feature but something else I found which may also be of some help to you: I found that if you're trying to fast-scroll (but not letter scroll) if you start by scrolling just slightly slower, then ramp up your scroll speed, you can scroll quite fast without entering letter-scroll. From there, the threshold to active letter-scroll is quite high (not unattainable, just noticeably high). Whereas if you scroll fast to begin with, you slip into letter scroll easier.

    Basically what I'm saying is, I think there's two different activation speeds: stationary -> letter-scroll, and fast-scroll -> letter-scroll, with the second being a higher setpoint; the practical effect being that if you want letter-scroll, you scroll fast to begin with and you easily step into it. However, if you want fast-scroll but not letter-scroll, you scroll slightly slower, enter fast scroll, then speed up and can scroll at quite a rate of knots without stepping up into letter-scroll (but it remains possible if that's what you want)

    Actually... In writing this out; perhaps that's the answer we're looking for?
    If it was changed so that your options are ONLY stationary -> fast-scroll or stationary -> letter-scroll (i.e. entirely remove the fast-scroll to letter-scroll transition)
    That way:

    • if you want letter-scroll you scroll very fast (imo the current threshold works well for activating that) and then you can slow down to gently step through letters; that much works great as-is.
    • on the other hand, to remove the limitation on fast-scroll, you start by scrolling not so fast as to enter letter-scroll and then once you're moving you can speed up as much as your little thumb will take you. There's no need for an upper limit on the speed of fast-scroll because it will never transition to letter-scroll unless you stop, then scroll fast to enter letter-scroll directly!
  13. just4747 commented on Nov 3, 2026

    @just4747
    Author

    Fair shout there may be room for finer tuning to really polish the feature but something else I found which may also be of some help to you: I found that if you're trying to fast-scroll (but not letter scroll) if you start by scrolling just slightly slower, then ramp up your scroll speed, you can scroll quite fast without entering letter-scroll. From there, the threshold to active letter-scroll is quite high (not unattainable, just noticeably high). Whereas if you scroll fast to begin with, you slip into letter scroll easier.

    Basically what I'm saying is, I think there's two different activation speeds: stationary -> letter-scroll, and fast-scroll -> letter-scroll, with the second being a higher setpoint; the practical effect being that if you want letter-scroll, you scroll fast to begin with and you easily step into it. However, if you want fast-scroll but not letter-scroll, you scroll slightly slower, enter fast scroll, then speed up and can scroll at quite a rate of knots without stepping up into letter-scroll (but it remains possible if that's what you want)

    Actually... In writing this out; perhaps that's the answer we're looking for?
    If it was changed so that your options are ONLY stationary -> fast-scroll or stationary -> letter-scroll (i.e. entirely remove the fast-scroll to letter-scroll transition)
    That way:

    • if you want letter-scroll you scroll very fast (imo the current threshold works well for activating that) and then you can slow down to gently step through letters; that much works great as-is.
    • on the other hand, to remove the limitation on fast-scroll, you start by scrolling not so fast as to enter letter-scroll and then once you're moving you can speed up as much as your little thumb will take you. There's no need for an upper limit on the speed of fast-scroll because it will never transition to letter-scroll unless you stop, then scroll fast to enter letter-scroll directly!

    If I am understanding that correctly then I think I'd agree that it might be good to have it that way.
    How exactly does it work on a newer gen iPod? I don't have one handy to test but wouldn't that be the gold standard?

  14. Som-2-One commented on Nov 4, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    No idea how it works on an iPod with a scroll-wheel: I've never owned one 🤣

  15. Som-2-One commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @Som-2-One

    @SchulzCode bumping this one; as my library grows I'm seeing more of the issue with wanting to scroll faster within a letter, without jumping up into letter-scroll.

    Any thoughts / updates on this idea?
    _
    If it was changed so that your options are ONLY stationary -> fast-scroll or stationary -> letter-scroll (i.e. entirely remove the fast-scroll to letter-scroll transition)
    That way:

    if you want letter-scroll you scroll very fast (imo the current threshold works well for activating that) and then you can slow down to gently step through letters; that much works great as-is.
    on the other hand, to remove the limitation on fast-scroll, you start by scrolling not so fast as to enter letter-scroll and then once you're moving you can speed up as much as your little thumb will take you. There's no need for an upper limit on the speed of fast-scroll because it will never transition to letter-scroll unless you stop, then scroll fast to enter letter-scroll directly!_

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions