You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Biology: should the blacktip sex ratio differ between nurseries? #130
What. PR #121 (for #117) fits a binomial mixed model of sex: the first capture of each tagged shark, with nursery and season as random effects. On the current data:
Blacktips: nurseries differ more than chance would explain. The between-nursery SD is about 0.19 on the log-odds scale (boundary-corrected likelihood-ratio test, p ≈ 0.006). For example, about 58% of first captures are female at Papetoai, against about 44% at Tiki. Seasons don't differ (SD ≈ 0).
Sicklefin lemons: no detectable difference between nurseries (p ≈ 0.42).
Would you expect blacktip sex ratios to differ between nurseries? Possible reasons include one sex moving between nurseries more than the other, or one sex being easier to catch at some sites. Is there a paper the page should cite?
Was sex recorded the same way throughout, with claspers checked at every capture by every crew?
The model treats nursery and season as separate effects. Would it help to also ask whether a nursery's ratio changes from season to season (a nursery × season effect)? Some nursery-seasons have few sharks, so that estimate would be rough.
Acceptance
The /morphometrics wording reflects the answer.
Any extra model term gets its own follow-up issue.
no reason there should be differences. no paper to cite. it's interesting though.
yes, same always.
yeah, it would still be interesting.
in sea turtles, temperature affects sex ratios, but nothing has been done with that in sharks, so we don't know if there should be any reason for different sex ratios.
Thanks. #167 adds your answer to /morphometrics. When the model finds that nurseries differ, the page now says:
sex was recorded the same way throughout, so the difference isn't down to recording;
the lab knows of no reason to expect it;
temperature sets sea-turtle sex, but nobody has tested whether anything similar happens in sharks.
The nursery × season question is filed as #165. How it's built depends on whether the sex-ratio model should use fixed or random effects, which I've asked about on #132.
Activity
JodieRummer commentedon Nov 5, 2026
in sea turtles, temperature affects sex ratios, but nothing has been done with that in sharks, so we don't know if there should be any reason for different sex ratios.
Luen commentedon Nov 8, 2026
Thanks. #167 adds your answer to /morphometrics. When the model finds that nurseries differ, the page now says:
The nursery × season question is filed as #165. How it's built depends on whether the sex-ratio model should use fixed or random effects, which I've asked about on #132.
Lab answers: chart statistics conventions (#132); sex-ratio wording (#…