You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
What. On the overview's "Catch rate per season", blacktip catch rate drops in 2018-19 while sicklefin lemon catch rate jumps (and stays high in 2019-20).
First look (aggregate, real data)
Not a change in sampling: the same nurseries and months were sampled, in similar proportions to the seasons around it.
The swing survives adjustment. In a negative-binomial model with nursery and day of the season:
seasons differ more than chance for lemons (p < 0.001) and blacktips (p ≈ 0.03);
2018-19 lemons ≈ 2.3× the average season (95% CI ≈ 1.7–3.1), and 2019-20 ≈ 2.0×;
2018-19 blacktips ≈ 0.76× (≈ 0.59–0.97).
Where it happened: the lemon high is concentrated in the lemon nurseries (above all Vaiane, also Tiki), but lemons were above their usual rate elsewhere too.
No sign of displacement: across seasons at the same lemon nursery, lemon-rich seasons are not significantly poorer for blacktips (Spearman ρ −0.15 to −0.35, all p > 0.25).
PR #122 adds the adjusted season test to the overview's "Catch rate per season" chart. The chart now names the seasons whose 95% interval excludes the average, computed live: 2018–19 for both species, and 2019–20 for lemons. This issue stays open for the lab's answer: did anything change in the 2018–19 or 2019–20 fieldwork (net placement at Vaiane or Tiki, nets, timing)?
@JodieRummer, two questions about the 2018-19 swing. PR #122 now names 2018-19 (both species), plus 2019-20 for lemons, as seasons that differ beyond chance once nursery and day of the season are accounted for.
Would you expect sicklefin lemon pups to rise for two seasons running? Possible reasons include a biennial breeding cycle, or a few females returning to pup at Vaiane.
If the fieldwork didn't change, the overview will keep calling these unusual seasons and won't suggest a cause.
Activity
Luen commentedon Nov 3, 2026
PR #122 adds the adjusted season test to the overview's "Catch rate per season" chart. The chart now names the seasons whose 95% interval excludes the average, computed live: 2018–19 for both species, and 2019–20 for lemons. This issue stays open for the lab's answer: did anything change in the 2018–19 or 2019–20 fieldwork (net placement at Vaiane or Tiki, nets, timing)?
Luen commentedon Nov 3, 2026
@JodieRummer, two questions about the 2018-19 swing. PR #122 now names 2018-19 (both species), plus 2019-20 for lemons, as seasons that differ beyond chance once nursery and day of the season are accounted for.
If the fieldwork didn't change, the overview will keep calling these unusual seasons and won't suggest a cause.
Charts: statistics behind every trend and difference (#119, #118, #120)…