Skip to content

Method zoo: 36 per-method cards (M1–M14) + key references#59

Open
GiggleLiu wants to merge 10 commits into
model-zoofrom
method-zoo
Open

Method zoo: 36 per-method cards (M1–M14) + key references#59
GiggleLiu wants to merge 10 commits into
model-zoofrom
method-zoo

Conversation

@GiggleLiu

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Method zoo — the method-side parallel of the model zoo (#58)

Adds a method zoo: 36 per-method cards under .knowledge/methods/<name>/METHOD.md, one per distinct method in method-survey.md, each with a structured M1–M14 property table, cost & accuracy classes, recommended models, one key reference, and verified benchmarks.

Stacked on #58 (model-zoo). Based on model-zoo because the method cards cross-link the model cards and the prerequisite knowledge files committed there, and main doesn't yet have them. Retarget to main once #58 merges. The diff here is only the method-zoo work.

What's new

  • .knowledge/method-property-checklist.md — the new M1–M14 axis schema (M-I Capability, M-II Applicability gates keyed to model A1–D16, M-III Cost, M-IV Limits), the method-side companion to model-property-checklist.md.
  • .knowledge/methods/_TEMPLATE.md — the card template.
  • 36 cards in 7 families: Exact (ed-full, ed-lanczos, ftlm-tpq, kpm, fci) · Classical-MC/RG (metropolis-mc, cluster-mc, mcrg) · Ground-state TN (dmrg, peps-ipeps, trg-hotrg, mera) · TN dynamics/finite-T (tebd, tdvp, mps-finite-t, ltrg-xtrg, dmrg-x) · Quantum MC (vmc-nqs, sse, dqmc, afqmc-cpmc, dmc-gfmc, pimc, diagmc) · Embedding/perturbative (dmft, dmet, nrg, frg, coupled-cluster, mbpt-gw) · Mean-field/circuit/certified (hartree-fock, spin-wave, slave-particle, vca-cluster-mf, circuit-sim, sdp-nctssos).
  • .knowledge/methods/INDEX.md + shared ref.bib (55 entries).

References — discover-first

Each card's key reference was reused from the existing .knowledge/literature/ tree where present (20 cards: cite keys copied verbatim, full text linked in place) and downloaded only when absent (the rest). 4 honest bib stubs for paywalled/pre-arXiv classics (fci, cluster-mc, coupled-cluster, slave-particle). The pre-existing literature/ tree is untouched.

Quality gates

  • Each of the 7 waves passed an independent physics-accuracy review (subagent) + fixes; a final whole-zoo cross-card consistency review (APPROVED) checked every M9 cost against the survey master table, taxonomy consistency, and cross-card agreement.
  • Reviewers caught real errors that were fixed: ED dense-vs-Lanczos 48–50-site frontier attribution, AFQMC constrained-path bound direction (E_CP ≥ E_0), fRG Γ⁽⁴⁾ vertex, DMFT Mott U_c2/D units, MERA S=(c/3)lnL prefactor, HOTRG O(χ^{4d−1}) (not ATRG), stabilizer-rank α≈0.396, TEBD quench entanglement linear growth, plus 3 wrong arXiv IDs caught and corrected.

Test plan

  • 36 cards, each with all 14 axes M1–M14
  • every [@key] resolves in methods/ref.bib; no duplicate keys
  • every Rendered: path exists (downloaded next to card, or linked into literature/)
  • no .raw//.figures/ blobs staged
  • literature/ tree unmodified (download-ref collateral damage reverted)
  • all 7 per-wave physics reviews + final cross-card review APPROVED

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant