paper: define BriskSeed reuse evidence boundary

paper/advisor_review/.gitignore

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+main.aux
+main.bbl
+main.blg
+main.out

paper/advisor_review/BUILD.md

@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+# Build
+This independent advisor draft preserves the student manuscript unchanged.
+```text
+PATH=/home/shuhao/.conda/envs/neuromem/bin:$PATH make pdf
+```

paper/advisor_review/BUILD_TRANSCRIPT.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+note: Running TeX ...
+note: Running BibTeX on main.aux ...
+note: Rerunning TeX because bibtex was run ...
+note: Running xdvipdfmx ...
+note: Writing `main.blg` (191 B)
+note: Writing `main.bbl` (1.0244140625 KiB)
+note: Writing `main.out` (910 B)
+note: Writing `main.pdf` (50.376953125 KiB)
+note: Writing `main.log` (11.8564453125 KiB)
+note: Writing `main.aux` (2.05078125 KiB)

paper/advisor_review/MANIFEST.md

@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+# Advisor review artifact manifest
+
+- Canonical carrier: `DataSysResearch/CANDOR-Bench`, base branch `BriskSeed`
+- Source base: `4cde3b3f079ad9b1e4c98b10c2dfa7edf405f07a`
+- Artifact commit: `f9661a4f6bddd08c18b51a279c17ff1ac904a82e`
+- Build: `PATH=/home/shuhao/.conda/envs/neuromem/bin:$PATH make pdf`
+- Tectonic exit: `0`; pages: `2`; warnings: none
+- Visual check: both pages rendered at 110 DPI and inspected; no clipping,
+  overflow, broken glyphs, or unintended blank page.
+
+## SHA256
+
+| Artifact | Digest |
+|---|---|
+| `main.tex` | `ddb2aef8c6b6f04ab44507183b8eb92a46c13aa1044aff1adbd26d53b9669be6` |
+| `references.bib` | `5a62eb8ce80a3534178aa7942cfb322ed65de5e90aacbcd15ef85fbe171c3b9e` |
+| `main.pdf` | `4377bce0988855392623ec4290edcf2b35e66b793fb2a0c147dff83c11cc8ad7` |
+| `main.log` | `ca39b46db1ebe2ded23fc46133b918502a0d6169eeefbe029e35207807605d65` |
+| `BUILD_TRANSCRIPT.txt` | `bd7b5bc03ba154fb5754bbc937e2de2ce031e10006fc0279baf198f982669e30` |
+
+## Test and evidence boundary
+
+- `git diff --check`: pass.
+- Full host suite, Python 3.11: collection stopped with seven missing-dependency
+  errors (`numpy`, `yaml`).
+- Full host suite, Python 3.10: collection stopped with four errors because
+  `h5py` is absent.
+- Dependency-light subset: 7 passed, 2 failed. Existing failures are
+  `random-xs` returning no ground truth and a test shell invoking unavailable
+  bare `python`; this paper-only branch changes no mechanism or test code.
+- Existing formal student manuscript was preserved unchanged. Its Tectonic
+  build fails because the `algorithm` environment is undefined and citation
+  `Gong20251593` is absent from its bibliography.
+- Existing plots/CSV files remain historical branch evidence. No raw-to-claim
+  manifest binds them, so no numerical result is promoted here.
+- Manual semantic audit: `paper/advisor_review/main.tex` is an independent
+  formal advisor entry, not a generated fragment. Its Q1--Q7 list explicitly
+  names problem, importance, cited related-work gap, mechanism, feasibility,
+  matched evaluation, and takeaway; all four bibliography entries are cited.
+- Implementation, environment, experiments, and results remain student-owned.

paper/advisor_review/Makefile

@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+TECTONIC ?= tectonic
+.PHONY: pdf clean
+pdf:
+	$(TECTONIC) --keep-intermediates --keep-logs main.tex
+clean:
+	rm -f main.aux main.bbl main.blg main.log main.out main.pdf