From faecf05153ab55a370f678a4ca72d8664112a504 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Thu, 24 Sep 2026 22:37:56 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 1/9] fix(comparison): name the gated tier by its code, and correct the holdout's stated history MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit rd-gate scores tier code 1, the 32-byte default, but its header, its measure() doc, the baseline note it writes, the mise task comment and the CI step name all said "tier 0", the pre-reorder numbering. holdout-images named a Wikimedia fallback its URL list does not hold. holdout-candidates described the holdout as Kodak24 + 4 curated photos; it is + 8. The two v07-holdout configs called themselves the single, run-once holdout validation, which the split's history does not support. Config descriptions change here, before the §6 re-run, so every committed result records one config digest. --- .github/workflows/ci-comparison.yml | 5 +++-- .mise.toml | 2 +- tools/comparison/src/holdout-images.ts | 4 +++- tools/comparison/src/rd-gate.ts | 13 +++++++------ tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json | 2 +- 7 files changed, 17 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/.github/workflows/ci-comparison.yml b/.github/workflows/ci-comparison.yml index 3185f7c..e04a0f6 100644 --- a/.github/workflows/ci-comparison.yml +++ b/.github/workflows/ci-comparison.yml @@ -250,7 +250,8 @@ jobs: # The comparison report below proves the harness still runs; it does not # prove the format still performs. This gate (spec/EXPERIMENTS.md U18) - # encodes a handful of content-pinned corpus photos at tier 0 and fails if + # encodes a handful of content-pinned corpus photos at the 32-byte default + # (tier code 1; EXPERIMENTS.md's old numbering calls it tier 0) and fails if # mean ΔE00 has drifted from tools/comparison/baselines/rd-gate.json, so a # silent rate-distortion regression cannot land unnoticed. It needs a # release build — the debug encoder is the same bytes but far slower. @@ -268,7 +269,7 @@ jobs: - name: A concurrent run scores identically to a serial one, and a sweep reproduces its committed result run: node tools/comparison/dist/determinism-check.js - - name: R-D regression gate (tier 0) + - name: R-D regression gate (default tier, code 1) run: node tools/comparison/dist/rd-gate.js - uses: actions/setup-go@v5 diff --git a/.mise.toml b/.mise.toml index 6332904..7f5af32 100644 --- a/.mise.toml +++ b/.mise.toml @@ -632,7 +632,7 @@ run = [ # ─── Quality gate ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── -# Tier-0 R-D regression gate: encode a fixed handful of content-pinned corpus +# Default-tier (code 1, 32 B) R-D regression gate: encode a fixed handful of content-pinned corpus # photos, score mean ΔE00, and compare it against the checked-in baseline # tools/comparison/baselines/rd-gate.json. Deliberately small — a few images, no # codec baselines — so CI can run it on every push; `compare:rd` and the sweeps diff --git a/tools/comparison/src/holdout-images.ts b/tools/comparison/src/holdout-images.ts index 1890416..8e1cb6d 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/src/holdout-images.ts +++ b/tools/comparison/src/holdout-images.ts @@ -72,7 +72,9 @@ export async function ensureHoldoutImages(): Promise { filePath, // HTTPS first: r0k.us is the canonical home of the suite but is one // hobby server, and this was the only plain-HTTP fetch in the corpus. - // The Wikimedia mirror is the fallback; the digest makes it safe. + // The plain-HTTP URL is the only fallback, and the pinned digest is what + // makes it safe; there is no second host, so r0k.us being down fails + // the holdout split loudly rather than silently shrinking it. urls: [ `https://r0k.us/graphics/kodak/kodak/kodim${num}.png`, `http://r0k.us/graphics/kodak/kodak/kodim${num}.png`, diff --git a/tools/comparison/src/rd-gate.ts b/tools/comparison/src/rd-gate.ts index 6563381..d8b57b0 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/src/rd-gate.ts +++ b/tools/comparison/src/rd-gate.ts @@ -3,10 +3,11 @@ * * `ci-comparison.yml` runs the cross-format report, which proves the harness * still works — it does not prove the format still performs. A change that - * quietly cost 5% of tier-0 quality would render a perfectly healthy report and - * pass. This gate closes that: it encodes a fixed handful of corpus images at - * tier 0, scores mean ΔE00, and fails if the result has drifted past a - * tolerance from a checked-in baseline. + * quietly cost 5% of default-tier quality would render a perfectly healthy + * report and pass. This gate closes that: it encodes a fixed handful of corpus + * images at the 32-byte default (tier code 1; the old numbering EXPERIMENTS.md + * uses called it "tier 0"), scores mean ΔE00, and fails if the result has + * drifted past a tolerance from a checked-in baseline. * * Deliberately small — a few content-pinned photos, no codec baselines, no * ladder — so it costs a CI job seconds and can run on every pull request. @@ -84,7 +85,7 @@ const baselinePath = path.resolve( values.baseline ?? path.join(toolRoot, "baselines/rd-gate.json"), ); -/** Encode + decode + score every gated image at tier 0. */ +/** Encode + decode + score every gated image at {@link TIER}. */ async function measure(): Promise { const paths = await ensureNaturalImages(GATE_IMAGES); const out: Baseline["images"] = []; @@ -138,7 +139,7 @@ async function main(): Promise { if (values.update === true) { const baseline: Baseline = { note: - "Baseline for the tier-0 R-D regression gate (src/rd-gate.ts). " + + "Baseline for the default-tier (code 1, 32 B) R-D regression gate (src/rd-gate.ts). " + "Regenerate deliberately with `mise run rd:gate:update` after an intended " + "encoder change, and say so in the commit message.", tier: TIER, diff --git a/tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json b/tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json index 837d6a5..2c76b84 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json +++ b/tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "name": "holdout-candidates", - "description": "Pre-registered validation of the tune-split winners on the never-tuned holdout split (Kodak24 + 4 held-out curated photos). Candidate A is the reallocation alone (luma 4 b x 38, chroma 3 b x 8); the stacked rows add the two encoder-only levers and the anisotropic selection weight. The 21 B rows test whether a sub-tier-0 budget is viable at all - ThumbHash's own size. Every arm pins all four selection/encoder knobs explicitly: the incumbent is the PRE-adoption shipped format, and since §10 adopted L28@4 C15@3 + aniso + fit2 as the defaults, an arm that omitted them would measure the adopted recipe against itself. 'stack' here is the three-knob aniso+fit2+nearest form, without sel_hv; §7.12's STACK adds sel_hv=0.15.", + "description": "Pre-registered validation of the tune-split winners on the never-tuned holdout split (Kodak24 + 8 held-out curated photos). Candidate A is the reallocation alone (luma 4 b x 38, chroma 3 b x 8); the stacked rows add the two encoder-only levers and the anisotropic selection weight. The 21 B rows test whether a sub-tier-0 budget is viable at all - ThumbHash's own size. Every arm pins all four selection/encoder knobs explicitly: the incumbent is the PRE-adoption shipped format, and since §10 adopted L28@4 C15@3 + aniso + fit2 as the defaults, an arm that omitted them would measure the adopted recipe against itself. 'stack' here is the three-knob aniso+fit2+nearest form, without sel_hv; §7.12's STACK adds sel_hv=0.15.", "photoOnly": true, "variants": [ { diff --git a/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json b/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json index 71d4649..0888ac2 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json +++ b/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ "corpus": "alpha", "backdrops": "white-black-grey", "alphaFidelity": true, - "description": "SS11.12 - the single holdout validation of the alpha-mode changes. Run once, after every tune decision was settled. The incumbent is the alpha layout as shipped at the start of SS11, so the delta is what stabilizing v0.7 moves alpha mode by. The tier-0 candidate is A28@3 L22@4 C3@3 and the compact-tier candidate A16@3 L12@4 C1@3; both were chosen on tune by protecting the mostly-opaque subgroup rather than by taking the deltaE00-optimal corner. Every arm pins alpha_ac_count and alpha_ac_bits explicitly. They are applied on top of Tunables::DEFAULT, so an arm that omitted them inherited the ADOPTED A28@3 -- which is what the incumbent labelled `SHIPPED A5@4` was doing: it encoded to 40 bytes rather than 32 and reported the adopted allocation's own alpha MAE, so this sweep was scoring the adopted layout against itself with a different luma/chroma split. Same defect class as EXPERIMENTS.md 9.5's seven configs; this one was not among them.", + "description": "SS11.12 - the holdout validation of the alpha-mode changes, run after every tune decision was settled, and run again once the mislabelled incumbent below was fixed. Its holdout split can no longer be reproduced: cutout-wordmark-aflac was deleted from Wikimedia Commons (#83), so only the tune run can be re-measured. The incumbent is the alpha layout as shipped at the start of SS11, so the delta is what stabilizing v0.7 moves alpha mode by. The tier-0 candidate is A28@3 L22@4 C3@3 and the compact-tier candidate A16@3 L12@4 C1@3; both were chosen on tune by protecting the mostly-opaque subgroup rather than by taking the deltaE00-optimal corner. Every arm pins alpha_ac_count and alpha_ac_bits explicitly. They are applied on top of Tunables::DEFAULT, so an arm that omitted them inherited the ADOPTED A28@3 -- which is what the incumbent labelled `SHIPPED A5@4` was doing: it encoded to 40 bytes rather than 32 and reported the adopted allocation's own alpha MAE, so this sweep was scoring the adopted layout against itself with a different luma/chroma split. Same defect class as EXPERIMENTS.md 9.5's seven configs; this one was not among them.", "variants": [ { "label": "SHIPPED A5@4 L20@5 C9@4", diff --git a/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json b/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json index c992103..e7066b7 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json +++ b/tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ { "name": "v07-holdout-photo", "corpus": "photo", - "description": "SS11.12 - the single holdout validation of every tune-chosen change on the photographic split. Run once, after all tune decisions were settled; consulting holdout per-experiment would make it a second tune set. The incumbent is the constants as shipped at the start of SS11, so the deltas are what stabilizing v0.7 actually moved the format by.", + "description": "SS11.12 - the round-3 holdout validation of every tune-chosen change on the photographic split, run after all tune decisions were settled. It is not the split's first consultation: the same 32 images had already validated rounds 1 and 2 (SS4.5, SS7.12, SS10.3), and SS11.12 records that history. Consulting holdout per-experiment would make it a second tune set. The incumbent is the constants as shipped at the start of SS11, so the deltas are what stabilizing v0.7 actually moved the format by.", "variants": [ { "label": "SS10 constants (incumbent)", From e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Thu, 24 Sep 2026 22:40:40 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 2/9] =?UTF-8?q?fix(comparison):=20pin=20budget-ladder-tune?= =?UTF-8?q?d=20to=20the=20round-1=20recipe,=20and=20give=20it=20the=20base?= =?UTF-8?q?line=20=C2=A74.5=20compares=20against?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Every tuned arm set aniso, scale_fit and ac_nearest but not sel_hv, so it inherited the adopted 0.15 and measured the round-2 recipe: at 21-411 B its rows equal budget-ladder-optimized's to the digit. The arms now pin sel_hv=0, which is what the description says the recipe is. §4.5 and §7.12 compare the tuned and optimized ladders against a "pre-adoption shipped" row no committed sweep produced, and whose numbers were the retired corpus's. The config gains that row as fourteen arms: the v0.6-derived format resized to each budget exactly as budget-ladder does, with the four selection/encoder knobs pinned off. --- .../sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json | 94 +++++++++++++++---- 1 file changed, 77 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) diff --git a/tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json b/tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json index 9c7bb5c..5a2b629 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json +++ b/tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "name": "budget-ladder-tuned", - "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. Compare against budget-ladder.json, which is the same ladder with the shipped constants.", + "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. The round-1 recipe had no sel_hv, so every tuned arm pins sel_hv=0: an arm that omitted it inherited the adopted 0.15 and measured the round-2 recipe instead. The pre-adoption arms are the baseline the tuned rows are compared against (EXPERIMENTS.md SS4.5, SS7.12): the v0.6-derived format resized to each budget exactly as budget-ladder.json resizes it (26:9 at L 5 b / chroma 4 b, the upper-tier raster from 108 B), with the four selection/encoder knobs pinned off. budget-ladder.json itself resizes the layout but inherits the adopted knobs, so it is the ladder of the format that ships, not of the one round 1 compared against.", "photoOnly": true, "variants": [ { @@ -8,67 +8,127 @@ }, { "label": " 12B tuned L8@3 C3@3", - "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 14B tuned L11@3 C4@3", - "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 16B tuned L14@3 C5@3", - "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 18B tuned L17@3 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 21B tuned L19@4 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 24B tuned L22@4 C8@3", - "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 28B tuned L27@4 C10@3", - "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 32B tuned L33@4 C11@3", - "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 40B tuned L43@4 C15@3", - "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 48B tuned L54@4 C19@3", - "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 64B tuned L59@5 C20@4", - "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 80B tuned L75@5 C26@4", - "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 108B tuned L104@5 C36@4", - "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 161B tuned L158@5 C55@4", - "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 246B tuned L246@5 C85@4", - "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" }, { "label": " 411B tuned L416@5 C144@4", - "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1" + }, + { + "label": " 12B pre-adoption L5/C2", + "tune": "l1=5:5 c=2:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 16B pre-adoption L10/C3", + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=3:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 21B pre-adoption L13/C6", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 24B pre-adoption L18/C6", + "tune": "l1=18:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 28B pre-adoption L21/C8", + "tune": "l1=21:5 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 32B pre-adoption L26/C9", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 40B pre-adoption L34/C12", + "tune": "l1=34:5 c=12:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 48B pre-adoption L42/C15", + "tune": "l1=42:5 c=15:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 64B pre-adoption L58/C21", + "tune": "l1=58:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 80B pre-adoption L74/C27", + "tune": "l1=74:5 c=27:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 108B pre-adoption t2 L104/C36", + "tier": 2, + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 161B pre-adoption t2 L156/C56", + "tier": 2, + "tune": "l1=39:5 c=14:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 246B pre-adoption t2 L248/C84", + "tier": 2, + "tune": "l1=62:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" + }, + { + "label": " 411B pre-adoption t2 L416/C144", + "tier": 2, + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0" } ] } From a5a9347fdb677bb47de8fc4504700442f60e8fad Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 02:37:46 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 3/9] =?UTF-8?q?test(comparison):=20re-record=20every=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=C2=A76=20sweep=20at=20one=20commit?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Every sweep EXPERIMENTS.md §6 lists, re-run from a clean tree at e310475 with iqa-cli 1.2.1 on the pinned corpus. 35 results replace those recorded at c070e17 and 323fdf2; 17 are committed for the first time, for the sweeps §6 cites that no table bound: allocation-grid, precision-by-budget, encoder-compute, retune-32b, refine-objective, refine-grid, selection-hv, cfl-range, combined-optimizer, alpha-layout-control, alpha-encoder, alpha-balance, quant-ranges, scalefactor-bands, compact-tier-alpha, and v07-holdout-photo on both splits. Every re-run result is per-image identical to the one it replaces except budget-ladder-tuned, whose config changed in the previous commit. compact-tier-alpha, which §6 described as never run, now has a result. --- .../results/adopted-defaults-holdout.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/adopted-defaults.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/allocation-grid.json | 916 ++++++++++++++++++ tools/comparison/results/alpha-ac-count.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/alpha-balance.json | 578 +++++++++++ tools/comparison/results/alpha-ceiling.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/alpha-encoder.json | 214 ++++ tools/comparison/results/alpha-fields.json | 2 +- .../results/alpha-layout-control.json | 440 +++++++++ tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/alpha-tier1.json | 2 +- .../results/artifact-ladder-common-grid.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder.json | 2 +- .../results/budget-ladder-holdout.json | 2 +- .../budget-ladder-optimized-holdout.json | 2 +- .../results/budget-ladder-optimized.json | 2 +- .../results/budget-ladder-tuned-holdout.json | 348 +++++-- .../results/budget-ladder-tuned.json | 348 +++++-- tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/cfl-range.json | 331 +++++++ tools/comparison/results/cfl.json | 2 +- .../results/combined-optimizer.json | 422 ++++++++ .../results/compact-tier-alpha.json | 438 +++++++++ .../results/compact-tier-graphics.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/compact-tier.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/companding-family.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/deadzone.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/detail-synthesis.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/embedded-tiers.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/encoder-compute.json | 318 ++++++ .../results/final-candidates-holdout.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/graphics-encoder.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/graphics-layout.json | 2 +- .../results/holdout-candidates-holdout.json | 6 +- .../results/precision-by-budget.json | 565 +++++++++++ tools/comparison/results/prefix-shrink.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/quant-ranges.json | 240 +++++ tools/comparison/results/refine-ablation.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/refine-grid.json | 383 ++++++++ .../comparison/results/refine-objective.json | 357 +++++++ tools/comparison/results/render-raster.json | 2 +- tools/comparison/results/retune-32b.json | 422 ++++++++ .../comparison/results/scalefactor-bands.json | 253 +++++ tools/comparison/results/selection-hv.json | 357 +++++++ .../comparison/results/selection-weights.json | 2 +- .../results/synthesis-window-upper.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/synthesis-window.json | 2 +- .../results/thumbhash-headtohead-holdout.json | 2 +- .../results/thumbhash-headtohead.json | 2 +- .../comparison/results/v07-holdout-alpha.json | 6 +- .../results/v07-holdout-photo-holdout.json | 283 ++++++ .../comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo.json | 279 ++++++ 52 files changed, 7363 insertions(+), 203 deletions(-) create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/allocation-grid.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/alpha-balance.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/alpha-encoder.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout-control.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/cfl-range.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/combined-optimizer.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-alpha.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/encoder-compute.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/precision-by-budget.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/quant-ranges.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/refine-grid.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/refine-objective.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/retune-32b.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/scalefactor-bands.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/selection-hv.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo-holdout.json create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo.json diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults-holdout.json index 1d0e584..346312c 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults-holdout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults.json b/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults.json index 1282a54..e35546f 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/adopted-defaults.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/allocation-grid.json b/tools/comparison/results/allocation-grid.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5b58f04 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/allocation-grid.json @@ -0,0 +1,916 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "allocation-grid", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Luma/chroma count-vs-precision grid at a fixed AC budget of 202 bits. Because tier m multiplies every count by 4^m at constant bit width, the SAME base allocation lands at 32 B (tier 0) and 108 B (tier 1) - so one grid answers the allocation question at both anchors and shows whether the optimum moves with the budget. Every arm pins the four selection/encoder knobs to their PRE-adoption values so the comparison isolates the layout: §10 adopted aniso=1.2, sel_hv=0.15, scale_fit=2 and ac_nearest=1 as defaults, and an arm that omitted them would silently carry the adopted recipe — which had made the incumbent identical to the L28@4 C15@3 arm it was meant to be measured against.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/allocation-grid.json", + "configSha256": "91071162634bcd81413f017842784b5e60d9d92468fb0c92c5bac3cfd11bae6b", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B SHIPPED L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L24@4 C17@3", + "tune": "l1=24:4 c=17:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.157945500396549, 9.286983819133898, 26.109670310807644, 9.779545340468442, 13.248428520600719, 9.966897878667961, 14.506074757335957, 3.6953309657605815, 11.510930090585827, 12.109986889754706, 10.836358639476183, 10.237692413855202, 4.388698870664369, 11.872666001113247, 19.190235898788924, 11.142161049887525, 12.459175172819787, 10.470276321518146, 18.263939293064244, 14.405533976791986, 12.029380557204162, 4.75785028381389, 12.806006423173457, 12.773152423718543, 2.64068929210696, 13.777820014688155, 13.461068377135172, 12.895386518618059, 9.284897461642293, 11.004317912829144, 15.23087142116904], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.55547165732054, -270.95888276265623, -1231.6665253443216, -146.11481586413308, -328.24355494208504, -240.585385384502, -445.1175248916488, -63.82658587090475, -409.23240548206593, -340.7911652583113, -272.3568433030812, -165.07050505867664, -64.1719317759235, -291.12386053985, -857.317292126212, -304.1711987534203, -298.8921157599102, -122.2386171900418, -665.2479335043322, -697.8048441133183, -308.4460396791503, -65.91982448851584, -426.9816207892212, -247.25784114479598, -59.61611446718817, -417.8000702967812, -307.17619368747586, -384.3440135252273, -253.142726544477, -444.78577117662803, -677.2416461934265], + "butteraugli": [24.03307387804772, 27.534456995609577, 45.26985055928376, 28.23327704068198, 25.69706709200916, 22.21203122661399, 39.9526307924337, 13.307194077644732, 22.451734478910044, 43.85209917535226, 21.727439668382136, 27.703973184174668, 21.266156464459232, 22.40700797421066, 37.36701642049085, 29.48829606079056, 31.554326766143987, 47.81317147659097, 49.578953429427166, 25.77378127454112, 40.271545360559934, 16.461152591320964, 22.38165183588032, 26.122456370732063, 9.669685125367254, 46.23776103910163, 38.26065973272288, 40.187321382691984, 34.216173463777125, 35.70444259914962, 33.08862031245285], + "dssim": [0.3045256127727848, 0.3056342192598025, 0.4639144811411987, 0.15916312435539254, 0.3349328430674846, 0.2352763961734758, 0.21931234312457998, 0.08473799852379416, 0.40943657260037547, 0.24121265491874883, 0.3939041112951093, 0.24823818729302632, 0.151816939059982, 0.2595888720752809, 0.36630836364133934, 0.19800331615151984, 0.23012582124642322, 0.148724522765672, 0.33685891141114443, 0.3696970693152316, 0.22247017605126485, 0.1490742970480854, 0.28170901002673676, 0.23733715462372856, 0.10544720135446167, 0.28234350885109105, 0.2285843289280473, 0.31895797090907174, 0.22526637952263556, 0.3256929519946953, 0.3628668015282803] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L26@4 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=26:4 c=16:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.521120487702629, 9.334348890112727, 26.105096201098696, 9.653215195324343, 13.189076197495142, 9.896634759931944, 14.275768880352459, 3.6953309657605815, 11.308153623183333, 12.113014151941472, 10.673375001507525, 10.178752595992423, 4.387955216992343, 11.827796100026816, 19.106150224851856, 11.11388385087095, 12.289103956528756, 10.445648901120103, 18.46074439558483, 14.379292514367167, 11.987303156672997, 4.74226374045927, 12.793945064996398, 12.793712542297794, 2.641655843800502, 13.777820014688155, 13.500503993535517, 12.776814526489146, 9.245807543797072, 10.931150513603132, 15.208633079334234], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.98220146920121, -270.9659281645578, -1231.1158080726755, -136.317768893123, -319.3419140267704, -234.41963431223576, -436.39151616357117, -63.82658587090475, -374.6629301134223, -348.94984195823895, -260.82212939879355, -164.7777506233527, -64.16998996645262, -286.25925289181345, -841.1430654777491, -299.9403988443049, -285.1937919698107, -123.05667054255468, -666.5918330109197, -698.493655616644, -306.3117789201327, -65.938602864216, -425.60387228575166, -250.5393691238545, -59.567678547076866, -417.8000702967812, -302.25520374342943, -372.25203567834825, -248.95137084143607, -441.22841801474215, -677.4621250028529], + "butteraugli": [24.31544146052965, 27.75685112221001, 45.251369794560766, 27.227140104021448, 25.17690288137671, 22.023233084434718, 39.40349342239742, 13.307194077644732, 21.616703259712818, 43.16970726767016, 21.375268534132786, 29.247224703182116, 21.064471434106803, 22.205028175016846, 37.957887070410294, 29.309542503897486, 31.72581283641222, 47.23046353728234, 49.681469999734304, 25.833209872890176, 39.84538796677697, 16.446576521076636, 22.371945195894966, 25.801928404964247, 9.638632355703162, 46.23776103910163, 38.0270191466574, 41.09347471141819, 34.63904859182034, 35.98897362028969, 33.15865034402343], + "dssim": [0.3045375015033762, 0.3058641589484572, 0.46391391451504566, 0.15772579756563854, 0.33498476505044805, 0.2341130133460258, 0.2185238259014688, 0.08473799852379416, 0.40839104782070634, 0.2454937458449617, 0.39370544792180057, 0.24903001157461852, 0.15188289021984064, 0.2594691976467395, 0.3657174434029251, 0.1979160588969116, 0.2290790352488965, 0.14975244090301904, 0.3361220681856979, 0.36952776506335655, 0.22363698628642864, 0.14931723443366335, 0.2825173801750269, 0.23761453235875546, 0.10487573022138724, 0.28234350885109105, 0.2292908028715494, 0.3207158997670537, 0.2248358770696286, 0.3253961651242677, 0.3621723910549096] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28@4 C15@3", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.574584488383697, 9.198959588361774, 26.10314187867767, 9.707262002201771, 13.256490505997272, 9.878326097119645, 14.09345233409241, 3.70030285989136, 10.940341408172856, 12.152617650100034, 10.58220071351979, 10.217970520754227, 4.383874198009314, 11.868719795489072, 19.086556689221627, 10.997097025044432, 12.059361293672868, 10.411811671490309, 18.51039581773806, 14.310889995309582, 11.727059127741647, 4.70982009806234, 13.007638405276317, 12.781534420775087, 2.620126525683604, 13.760677046803174, 13.489026530725882, 12.850267530596879, 8.602856252874039, 10.224183880032692, 15.10517665523536], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.7985388480459, -261.0709748189109, -1230.640083459964, -136.36778986141027, -319.66434093288063, -233.4260981267238, -428.182503294712, -63.82082979382926, -315.9839238881463, -339.7615165510856, -258.36555087051715, -167.51215511462635, -64.16871806775657, -285.63696091810635, -836.9846709191497, -285.0719913731163, -278.96035311959633, -119.04288550564627, -661.118373318912, -696.2129862710468, -289.30493757226384, -65.89705066903119, -426.8488280873215, -248.22369511520412, -59.87613169594911, -416.78310353365373, -299.45172977056416, -371.17390161885555, -222.7498340732476, -405.4232651581327, -652.0411302010974], + "butteraugli": [23.516110570382427, 26.44987007817829, 45.24937965275986, 27.117479903187785, 24.87919703193461, 21.946188472868517, 39.1067232920922, 13.28590840801931, 20.746306832312907, 43.06007581936894, 20.901762994570166, 30.866924645027705, 20.929199068990247, 22.383762165273414, 37.44559841348565, 28.80823526757457, 31.52163330226068, 46.95744318407026, 49.735500555546615, 25.795175462070087, 38.47649018058046, 16.470970657784463, 22.330736301719543, 25.69197468987981, 10.070771249952983, 45.37476554114911, 38.170833185444415, 40.42285937734553, 31.916508299105885, 34.33438547963694, 33.19557706691639], + "dssim": [0.3044542844390209, 0.3056470450636234, 0.46389601295542376, 0.15767176896502222, 0.3347155794950565, 0.23552196399501324, 0.21895942684400577, 0.08483142367012536, 0.40647065292594126, 0.2443027939593922, 0.39380065264927705, 0.25009876049682955, 0.15189567461176967, 0.2594051485257006, 0.36559539429629695, 0.1979011718023958, 0.2286141786328269, 0.1488822908550677, 0.33535503230339536, 0.36901729063529387, 0.22661549784492435, 0.14949439041725626, 0.28577649491062473, 0.23744565506367926, 0.10380038148119336, 0.2816748614937058, 0.22942068126434245, 0.31881485683198296, 0.2228210207429106, 0.31890260993493047, 0.3616485306189587] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L30@4 C13@3", + "tune": "l1=30:4 c=13:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.7793150494923315, 9.088768576943238, 26.097608566623858, 9.706775747289656, 13.46354124047457, 9.918015396357337, 14.076357069487637, 3.642664917552328, 10.942530658400175, 12.08082508238821, 10.553120212298946, 10.40476277568877, 4.3932142775069485, 11.793334359110169, 19.00557974964479, 11.032393578620454, 12.082770943163839, 10.546481629672664, 18.583561723610703, 14.291613392585559, 11.708806595444095, 4.696325121775504, 13.168127320598293, 12.80261091809086, 2.5693293588488526, 13.558981192986952, 13.501774319156013, 12.594210454768426, 8.521866348022055, 10.1948552376421, 15.233302855073678], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.89050692324435, -251.06628871254497, -1229.464001839399, -134.90998580401194, -318.4365833926896, -226.1841761079245, -422.57438571077853, -63.788369210535166, -314.4931075114338, -338.9106197001343, -258.08010454267026, -164.00350203783972, -64.17492206598138, -284.0143540360069, -833.2103586629393, -284.8513980557473, -275.5947954996231, -113.87458300758709, -661.8381677562584, -696.6002750392704, -279.2117354356351, -65.87253575857977, -435.0190213708486, -246.12019982258238, -59.86993240438164, -395.2890127393183, -298.69483514702523, -357.2636553294034, -209.91143633420575, -403.87264469778495, -650.9089605249189], + "butteraugli": [23.16955474112218, 25.21550107484016, 45.24045583359842, 27.114441819656978, 24.885426781835196, 21.970439822976147, 38.93011463274451, 13.311461953756051, 20.65953853903316, 42.30797248691821, 20.76330713484356, 26.75749888147496, 20.81907605948083, 22.445219312694984, 37.691250826649174, 28.62373785843287, 31.516367733429888, 46.64042639142034, 49.607810347435, 25.847939073388243, 38.737390881666016, 16.441643245191674, 22.451876811400343, 25.751713496971266, 10.131791063037909, 43.736899363863444, 38.19683372705676, 39.34721858791582, 32.54374318311833, 34.33929297882674, 33.49542216942957], + "dssim": [0.30448209911367485, 0.3058617488797736, 0.46389162010018176, 0.15667073436822948, 0.3348854836757831, 0.23615002494703585, 0.21848379044239336, 0.08474985674239371, 0.40654841173653045, 0.24624479377451008, 0.39381144681491503, 0.2522452955928469, 0.15215230785283285, 0.2591413325312283, 0.3654716130217961, 0.19806505336121916, 0.22876811657219448, 0.1465567653358264, 0.33587855555484525, 0.3689249752638467, 0.2252601768138947, 0.14964121683006232, 0.28816591161209193, 0.2373925309629678, 0.10384143601060863, 0.28104607544803895, 0.22909782098511355, 0.3172897198100372, 0.22327739375525224, 0.3179043066160516, 0.3611196676655555] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L32@4 C12@3", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=12:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.770776296877056, 9.090418679912242, 26.09339606865241, 9.782180598840574, 13.56080029762314, 10.032952969508653, 14.064795727772244, 3.6309910874893916, 10.944104587800027, 12.000136082603868, 10.56303900011797, 10.40476277568877, 4.3932142775069485, 11.763072967541696, 18.984597238854487, 11.06762278338003, 12.026760276902078, 10.45681069091306, 18.63551217776032, 14.28986820477648, 11.679014600092607, 4.696325121775504, 13.145807567480787, 12.766066876058815, 2.5606772769124997, 13.300846998102017, 13.428887817674116, 12.637666450918642, 8.279953021739495, 10.17372086441586, 15.070540762276684], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.3856513697458, -252.04388463535219, -1228.5108723168428, -136.35921058548516, -316.76726057379153, -223.94129532902303, -425.05427635047204, -63.75878171483433, -315.31269547881436, -338.0454518351948, -262.88266312235913, -164.00350203783972, -64.17492206598138, -277.4461416425821, -824.7231591731345, -277.42043434466603, -267.22589560143, -110.3822922678782, -656.6784705778024, -696.0676850476539, -276.7736774264689, -65.87253575857977, -420.6847694165921, -235.65061294814234, -59.5649368586387, -376.9384966086758, -283.430116691336, -356.2214299175821, -196.46140140094042, -399.7897341096066, -627.4019580143893], + "butteraugli": [22.99938859749218, 25.22877818479606, 45.22214537048626, 26.79238021721265, 25.0246699431391, 21.894353378798172, 38.757629484669174, 13.254120648906493, 20.585716647664484, 41.71314163134394, 20.789835765382453, 26.75749888147496, 20.81907605948083, 22.684475349781206, 37.640916774701495, 28.250379147715705, 31.667848935816938, 46.03142367339075, 48.665382210459164, 25.849549574283003, 38.357825661412726, 16.441643245191674, 22.297383658169483, 25.743770906356673, 9.984634736593057, 42.637940929032794, 37.20104814764776, 39.24961578209181, 31.782177077149967, 34.32118228956016, 33.107911098725594], + "dssim": [0.3044963827016053, 0.3057877002092949, 0.46391359128216436, 0.15656959617336536, 0.334944225562111, 0.2352105083116342, 0.21903016559608846, 0.08469126500363222, 0.406634759798144, 0.24277589382955272, 0.39390272413805044, 0.2522452955928469, 0.15215230785283285, 0.2589602262591316, 0.3655057044098342, 0.1984457260983491, 0.22847643387785238, 0.14813576067509887, 0.3358415677317411, 0.36889410961694696, 0.22524105885671514, 0.14964121683006232, 0.28795799697754276, 0.23737095444174566, 0.10454731020009111, 0.2798244036980865, 0.2277438867437543, 0.31830832511535423, 0.2213030419454437, 0.3175020039322348, 0.3619158174096939] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L34@4 C11@3", + "tune": "l1=34:4 c=11:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.771153333946498, 9.107959734487144, 26.086886537395742, 10.008103691192382, 13.561122041500703, 9.846023914581934, 14.010783960631693, 3.6309910874893916, 10.944104587800027, 12.037817294151687, 10.553211477028993, 10.341796023513584, 4.4100240792518886, 11.810210527211282, 18.92060063631574, 11.024707026493052, 11.985036465871469, 10.404551855928846, 18.481805190953843, 14.291061399756687, 11.636768034178912, 4.371537167127845, 13.151197080176573, 12.742952575084407, 2.5715202845147993, 13.154848357384921, 13.37632147399402, 12.340512354969034, 8.267240487822558, 10.025857239824807, 15.052930336184957], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.06976875374227, -251.94364729758342, -1228.4607184647416, -135.4293022100063, -316.12853725842734, -206.19301611467029, -419.4255130695926, -63.75878171483433, -315.31269547881436, -336.34606368226576, -256.9482359581789, -158.85872321891287, -64.17307842957587, -276.45396245893824, -814.5269362607859, -272.8307390888011, -265.29289378808903, -105.20551229188692, -627.2411193858295, -694.7648275024003, -267.53591118584353, -64.558133923631, -419.49391408144334, -233.8357850211206, -59.57120132638886, -368.8833454629485, -284.9481710473049, -328.99714475894814, -198.85665815894538, -387.83063688999925, -626.5150366902935], + "butteraugli": [22.911696277950266, 25.235965336510887, 45.221162453035795, 26.74930547061165, 25.314659280311858, 21.76566309177302, 38.62779191230276, 13.254120648906493, 20.585716647664484, 41.66953833416621, 20.70798620972454, 25.769115654222627, 20.380270546368763, 22.624040136994438, 37.42177233918982, 28.32885150299627, 31.35121742770548, 45.86422564778233, 48.426701601491175, 25.827055217730535, 37.46928600807626, 15.841163622505158, 22.3426791047534, 25.661066150646036, 9.968062650767875, 42.65572723137875, 36.96635369780796, 36.29486936947517, 31.28810051553334, 34.61484739149778, 33.201683110030096], + "dssim": [0.3044849442391221, 0.3060115640518687, 0.4639200672393781, 0.15694000208495335, 0.3349914875472122, 0.23095604367890227, 0.21910993111533328, 0.08469126500363222, 0.406634759798144, 0.2437471155719177, 0.3938396062820403, 0.251974001289634, 0.1522172129932337, 0.2589536449749783, 0.3654746003865533, 0.19875289094876153, 0.23061625104893552, 0.14578158432902394, 0.33237747852035116, 0.3689106617607282, 0.2256146802185573, 0.14973971352499937, 0.28808146479104435, 0.23739237095608473, 0.10442856490573549, 0.2785810995913648, 0.22850437626765346, 0.31341494633248046, 0.2220258341129297, 0.31845381320387744, 0.3617679244481933] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L36@4 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=36:4 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.807344529490086, 9.01284552776223, 26.087623165838696, 10.06004509940494, 13.88095574268403, 9.855400085302481, 14.33737547226898, 3.60417836928875, 10.879712190669075, 11.674534596087092, 10.542559902137228, 10.371548223956381, 4.371356214582265, 11.963065607626064, 18.83514964005565, 10.991947718020704, 12.04434840031016, 10.42048983069813, 18.37839080181852, 14.235589689261282, 11.636779375836294, 4.3918227728300785, 13.08134970617456, 12.747514153608895, 2.5901411020366414, 12.880261971546936, 13.23271011093814, 12.325380666076235, 7.958827875097821, 10.041724786222105, 14.960188417418816], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.04704163883886, -244.53597010724184, -1229.0720146445087, -133.21623479427305, -314.9327488711813, -205.25582672736698, -419.8674075608794, -63.30966319663281, -310.14238297998475, -320.001309407558, -255.9322932260343, -158.98593892255798, -64.1314046014565, -273.1096011698903, -812.8647545415153, -267.8473566189905, -267.10900959955256, -107.65588898423974, -608.2296839062616, -694.6514309202245, -270.3924786994497, -64.55627261740003, -415.9260180220896, -229.7075163269335, -59.56787506237009, -355.12466560032533, -265.689970455947, -321.2470099415161, -188.02323738901703, -385.4196738086111, -601.6854086289039], + "butteraugli": [22.880397643846532, 25.171012042549496, 45.218228925273166, 26.405552420827377, 25.291146813724794, 21.805345866412114, 38.54449203569579, 13.260193334410337, 20.349710422686066, 36.7407742915722, 20.621713019099374, 25.437897652104613, 19.880541509014957, 22.664894529990804, 37.37152577737884, 28.384257334147424, 31.261387506157252, 46.05424775397995, 46.628380832549276, 25.771915739665143, 36.78500042315149, 15.636454697551002, 22.330027611594144, 25.53245297622907, 10.04542743147992, 40.85902727133714, 37.20999989219257, 35.70080622231403, 30.489816332708603, 34.612582495447235, 34.3411649180568], + "dssim": [0.3044962680791309, 0.30593261728853227, 0.4638992127921379, 0.1575445667797119, 0.3350004363143949, 0.23030305206388846, 0.22032823796259587, 0.0844769156921168, 0.4065042942019494, 0.2684608821585549, 0.39398645928556897, 0.25281599822894885, 0.15199748742283087, 0.25871322531462715, 0.3655325767433817, 0.1985036282005055, 0.2308493452567319, 0.1457754888916269, 0.32973065651608, 0.36863805857322074, 0.22549328085309273, 0.1497519936885987, 0.2914090342362782, 0.2372033426905707, 0.10588733921232318, 0.2775957231777141, 0.2250080873346803, 0.3189982528298557, 0.22030382303210405, 0.3186284516576202, 0.3580512996158257] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L38@4 C8@3", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.808344335627107, 8.947749615035004, 26.08106322010924, 10.231335094281835, 13.82752851807822, 9.874741287316008, 14.360734673599268, 3.5713520045664224, 10.879712190669075, 11.65380689721305, 10.50754026145414, 10.368587986733118, 4.359650337596166, 12.019660108214673, 18.769459563832047, 11.03690345842568, 12.03579378848704, 10.366611185499892, 18.61326262270247, 14.238280661955967, 11.668804338532617, 4.325370434821215, 13.088724407939553, 12.69355061010095, 2.5603280048175407, 12.900343803778929, 13.389210928244418, 12.212066553035768, 7.866845853362872, 9.922875152636156, 15.012647433493843], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.34713882549548, -241.92844905741333, -1228.7319341199445, -130.6941883184761, -314.85157291665416, -205.31750652180915, -418.648346280384, -62.85760120817923, -310.14238297998475, -321.457631687408, -255.1957463701794, -158.94199562757836, -64.13692879116002, -273.2457989905249, -801.4066039457208, -255.28860756164363, -267.02301466777607, -107.96730818243395, -613.4080047615471, -693.8085270215788, -269.15027967537526, -64.47337092023176, -416.8599784999154, -221.3854097178285, -59.562955663219185, -353.0645479034802, -262.8827202364905, -313.48688109424893, -186.09892877227952, -374.3619574549621, -594.265743496411], + "butteraugli": [22.76403454849093, 24.694115437666557, 45.216516984377904, 26.25535141391811, 25.17270495958663, 21.781486497944055, 38.45588791655329, 13.24267838815449, 20.349710422686066, 36.55083076467633, 20.338504654117987, 25.430785623913806, 19.740883661239923, 22.631962635077418, 36.8721624508533, 28.185882564643226, 31.2592269150793, 44.01813407298473, 46.66131579394514, 25.76310873261691, 36.4913224454975, 15.551843063660797, 22.311304071177215, 25.492247764764898, 10.108122932224578, 40.96549452950905, 37.10777935138072, 35.705621859749506, 30.397172929305963, 34.45771460311776, 33.85739995761114], + "dssim": [0.3044581282537667, 0.30576356680918215, 0.46381518245819603, 0.1582922878228934, 0.3351243185190007, 0.23178674436168528, 0.21982727002214086, 0.08430489230233357, 0.4065042942019494, 0.26688779221238434, 0.3939844068910338, 0.25284990648818795, 0.15201981619861132, 0.25881443550421235, 0.3647546418001103, 0.19822810115997724, 0.230846613664262, 0.14482098662320575, 0.3305498889726125, 0.36865483383628184, 0.2256543240858886, 0.14947075185288566, 0.2911432084293205, 0.23707321987991925, 0.10615464641675681, 0.27788720383652854, 0.22620588042812434, 0.3186133109213629, 0.2202867691795068, 0.31689680812078735, 0.3558127535954738] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L40@4 C7@3", + "tune": "l1=40:4 c=7:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.79605941483781, 8.86402038948104, 26.0721677829828, 10.299525803437785, 13.723159069460985, 9.865441350506808, 14.269697118138788, 3.751808683711556, 10.865500934221842, 10.893942968656354, 10.48145105210826, 10.30565727623233, 4.291813815340271, 12.105762214672142, 18.760719505819285, 11.492883590312966, 12.06462969120036, 10.331414789661867, 18.579104706022047, 14.239612673543135, 11.673323996563882, 4.3069837155766315, 13.396652667300437, 12.629103260989146, 2.5740082651343776, 12.900343803778929, 13.420104300041, 12.445574618965718, 7.801250575219779, 9.897471453927203, 15.12042050418512], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.7636885141984, -230.11266104864995, -1228.3460132199866, -128.4350332705078, -312.38623927178435, -207.4230357977205, -415.79368860447426, -62.91599741198411, -304.7731330487732, -279.60724175605657, -252.63769308364192, -157.62790775428482, -64.12267424874256, -268.5280666754209, -794.5242146719569, -255.41149167179856, -272.6945266342508, -112.49898394216021, -610.5050447127745, -693.6903160439168, -269.3004539328276, -64.49401306876274, -417.67414340806886, -220.50662848205502, -59.57069873915805, -353.0645479034802, -254.523872834023, -309.82132073479943, -182.47769794612884, -371.7761690898582, -592.1029754290357], + "butteraugli": [22.69871684087244, 24.486603096630418, 45.21833365239462, 25.811717632985907, 25.268533600061854, 21.653939822948814, 38.59088576992662, 13.277308904482746, 20.08698462281454, 31.40284885117148, 20.274763283055247, 25.33039099790251, 19.502558750633607, 22.41412549600227, 36.71805107243954, 27.83595815673299, 30.74264501137286, 43.37234001236663, 46.872158544413686, 25.7603819427807, 36.577019848430446, 15.465489076914713, 22.27605172710386, 25.525143523625058, 10.108135579098017, 40.96549452950905, 36.402470154696324, 35.07744750896985, 30.336000234334552, 34.333938490405295, 33.981224183886184], + "dssim": [0.3044216540006235, 0.30544225404396586, 0.46385195377853095, 0.15848571679095547, 0.3351216947992133, 0.23217967070352946, 0.22066448805641825, 0.08438572720123982, 0.4064070775978943, 0.2640210837998763, 0.39395922365877406, 0.2525456632206635, 0.15207078093912285, 0.2590414342517665, 0.3649200371247816, 0.1985785112440937, 0.23149224929822482, 0.1474319732308927, 0.3295904083182981, 0.3686982683606359, 0.22571898060728485, 0.14942586622588827, 0.292961693574592, 0.23709327292810056, 0.10621815975093768, 0.27788720383652854, 0.23200739726683967, 0.3173214708918801, 0.2205453018116621, 0.3165354792601135, 0.3556704307437084] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28@4 C11@4", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=11:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.7864564277761, 9.198959588361774, 26.10314187867767, 9.943910833272776, 13.384461310049623, 9.99890021079396, 13.973662454996026, 3.5304366407151417, 10.940341408172856, 12.0407599717773, 10.58220071351979, 10.536931862919403, 4.339545463315579, 11.785314121311798, 19.114576544651694, 11.02091051715574, 12.06111072344174, 10.557059021802566, 18.652887537984043, 14.207461091499132, 11.777763093307605, 4.632905246173997, 13.283490979367508, 12.570849239177594, 2.4388678728827573, 13.760677046803174, 13.293283095692981, 12.6017577515489, 8.602856252874039, 10.224183880032692, 14.840078410556766], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.93135296027643, -261.0709748189109, -1230.640083459964, -136.91684489414214, -323.1526631517357, -235.5281016473736, -428.65430695075236, -63.80728137215516, -315.9839238881463, -340.580565946941, -258.36555087051715, -169.79668602774905, -64.16940004664241, -286.56226673491665, -845.3390609409137, -284.5012995086034, -278.6975386827039, -121.30336215290765, -662.5742148017434, -695.4661579823393, -289.3880359246999, -65.84322702951542, -442.5175691875952, -249.84900805390248, -59.747158345886874, -416.78310353365373, -298.9645271045973, -369.88285550738465, -222.7498340732476, -405.4232651581327, -653.1554896301542], + "butteraugli": [23.526151692967755, 26.44987007817829, 45.24937965275986, 27.161822631152386, 24.94029733560484, 21.930317739156536, 39.119464204211205, 13.242621770387844, 20.746306832312907, 43.15477992598548, 20.901762994570166, 31.38392246276331, 21.044697290119064, 22.498028437053446, 37.37466833005066, 28.794854846710532, 31.50743659521787, 47.44509946390187, 49.488556358078576, 25.823054111013263, 38.47487536418495, 16.44827978872259, 22.44026596455737, 25.614531767168852, 10.094807552930886, 45.37476554114911, 37.903120441376785, 40.38672479818413, 31.916508299105885, 34.33438547963694, 33.060845645873], + "dssim": [0.30446948560791975, 0.3056470450636234, 0.46389601295542376, 0.1579560230205182, 0.33482707613841534, 0.23908734795694264, 0.21906958650997704, 0.084739598657461, 0.40647065292594126, 0.24902000000749663, 0.39380065264927705, 0.25122638979783984, 0.1519876854981777, 0.25920032401525595, 0.36605560346620114, 0.19789452102476934, 0.22861848356197895, 0.14820991571491754, 0.334518128444771, 0.3685992093902578, 0.22655290268991807, 0.1497253483838002, 0.2932537742320588, 0.23737814137383012, 0.10393063431850647, 0.2816748614937058, 0.23033207879583878, 0.3125449173158228, 0.2228210207429106, 0.31890260993493047, 0.3613632867916882] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L30@4 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=30:4 c=10:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.821245382633234, 9.088768576943238, 26.097608566623858, 9.927730872171422, 13.517312627360667, 9.961009432753077, 14.056292894494717, 3.5681264462305693, 10.942530658400175, 12.038202075563406, 10.553120212298946, 10.394128433279326, 4.3314563232532945, 11.873988439653514, 19.092782792340397, 11.074124656283935, 12.105572542533096, 10.356326511094991, 18.689294718046835, 14.212241602872005, 11.72082037367989, 4.64062925659999, 13.190340341880974, 12.535785852605807, 2.495494989504638, 13.558981192986952, 13.254002835560446, 12.432457013312947, 8.521866348022055, 10.1948552376421, 14.979888314640194], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.7890157047995, -251.06628871254497, -1229.464001839399, -134.7866935552773, -321.34431321324985, -226.52390252892218, -423.4825168908088, -63.812465060360665, -314.4931075114338, -341.6775891135521, -258.08010454267026, -164.4212146374585, -64.17124311514527, -286.15704452091677, -842.2749586781221, -284.65925988919884, -276.9365828813705, -114.4690563379499, -662.0212268712901, -694.7539389821306, -279.6200791572832, -65.86006976740265, -435.0391853267173, -247.01033831060658, -59.852825643788236, -395.2890127393183, -298.6776159453638, -356.9696794897168, -209.91143633420575, -403.87264469778495, -646.7690067305348], + "butteraugli": [23.14897635980638, 25.21550107484016, 45.24045583359842, 27.172654731467702, 24.895555774085437, 21.931508199426187, 38.98498904957311, 13.262876160125208, 20.65953853903316, 42.525042470036325, 20.76330713484356, 26.854610672967578, 20.88630931926619, 22.55254794482963, 37.591029450050215, 28.630275939059857, 31.511677950282273, 46.814079071966, 49.501381642555295, 25.815402349183554, 38.770209960315206, 16.459484982256292, 22.42363420511042, 25.689209646863194, 10.202698305335625, 43.736899363863444, 38.085038419204665, 39.445984349493784, 32.54374318311833, 34.33929297882674, 33.36543862180461], + "dssim": [0.30451591356938734, 0.3058617488797736, 0.46389162010018176, 0.15748120092338586, 0.3348924954738462, 0.23667384763067129, 0.21876177615444675, 0.08472480570869984, 0.40654841173653045, 0.25106139253478565, 0.39381144681491503, 0.2511141055271421, 0.15214458027275163, 0.25895472624580385, 0.36602170470995943, 0.1980358683093899, 0.22881925397771186, 0.14679368959103956, 0.3344654288825165, 0.36858919388826317, 0.2253295164524891, 0.14972995387495497, 0.2939077370951422, 0.23733959244049924, 0.10422633614324123, 0.28104607544803895, 0.22929837614521548, 0.31275796523217836, 0.22327739375525224, 0.3179043066160516, 0.35958531282961403] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L32@4 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.8178573566199905, 9.090418679912242, 26.09339606865241, 10.014211387228, 13.70710317742712, 9.999412005596223, 14.415784655667096, 3.554507813607567, 10.944104587800027, 12.074232408303834, 10.56303900011797, 10.414841723585848, 4.3314563232532945, 11.8479826266316, 19.020996989598505, 11.103474992569804, 12.076630622716454, 10.24984922445043, 18.573961467045248, 14.218925658606745, 11.670522150164835, 4.6366335056899395, 13.155966027430205, 12.539732498727089, 2.492443704590422, 13.300846998102017, 13.186820272825365, 12.43604758557493, 8.279953021739495, 10.17372086441586, 14.783891992182694], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.04182388063674, -252.04388463535219, -1228.5108723168428, -135.88519533460786, -317.29582585760124, -224.77714171441914, -424.0855279526604, -63.784750112941424, -315.31269547881436, -341.6371270074965, -262.88266312235913, -164.2876763027886, -64.17124311514527, -281.11514983865743, -834.2375872172785, -277.7741640621386, -268.2049767227991, -111.49226056787526, -653.8566645511766, -694.4033747347954, -277.0600495448085, -65.8483159323336, -420.94015497005864, -236.77417913396266, -59.54496554268525, -376.9384966086758, -282.8274013256228, -356.0053852201752, -196.46140140094042, -399.7897341096066, -625.9233051617864], + "butteraugli": [22.98768393950807, 25.22877818479606, 45.22214537048626, 26.91314680806285, 25.034688959763383, 21.875273035965858, 38.96171816524403, 13.26063844072985, 20.585716647664484, 41.87507696219385, 20.789835765382453, 26.82700620160803, 20.88630931926619, 22.82077127611882, 37.602075180224126, 28.224996125327795, 31.694324126810887, 46.16570350953828, 48.591967533312335, 25.778316054576425, 38.37090027550504, 16.45804227852391, 22.283796906723055, 25.6415931516316, 10.049949935825998, 42.637940929032794, 37.119346182935885, 39.364579095027345, 31.782177077149967, 34.32118228956016, 32.96281434936351], + "dssim": [0.30447506122580026, 0.3057877002092949, 0.46391359128216436, 0.15848635259433214, 0.3350084453092902, 0.236198621867646, 0.21965645076078505, 0.08466124806588882, 0.406634759798144, 0.24654846028435246, 0.39390272413805044, 0.2510856354800475, 0.15214458027275163, 0.25884360413410346, 0.3658571229169131, 0.19849427718467022, 0.22854250554927114, 0.14817514921435865, 0.33434734178811365, 0.36854531291700704, 0.22519191229651336, 0.1498080044782541, 0.2937414748110403, 0.23732419127696397, 0.10541664923075039, 0.2798244036980865, 0.2278063162515308, 0.31691883243743524, 0.2213030419454437, 0.3175020039322348, 0.3587468967418147] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L34@4 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=34:4 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.8224549796079135, 9.107959734487144, 26.086886537395742, 10.15707324455627, 13.657509345215658, 9.840394790424485, 14.380832168833608, 3.559073710597079, 10.944104587800027, 12.044263102192765, 10.553211477028993, 10.345217701391565, 4.340606418383182, 11.942311467066276, 18.9030348722756, 11.200529931898107, 12.05300011333653, 10.166387884488064, 18.630308398137245, 14.224021110576851, 11.6739826506925, 4.316601297592183, 13.17493889491052, 12.52283071123473, 2.492443704590422, 13.154848357384921, 13.274581532540642, 12.132320475870264, 8.267240487822558, 10.025857239824807, 14.8762167515378], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.1681936600288, -251.94364729758342, -1228.4607184647416, -135.3976847998271, -318.1038607555462, -207.5463864810623, -418.2045918645881, -63.7906686806227, -315.31269547881436, -340.92909496326405, -256.9482359581789, -159.05581849322192, -64.17231753008011, -279.97501530488, -817.1731776901923, -273.5823599520221, -266.5111588442577, -105.82186993372332, -631.1911424940888, -694.2927136717324, -267.81901162545, -64.55763783265226, -419.6487035325755, -234.5471581229114, -59.54496554268525, -368.8833454629485, -283.783119514785, -327.91470131521817, -198.85665815894538, -387.83063688999925, -625.7228873373953], + "butteraugli": [22.912623959483863, 25.235965336510887, 45.221162453035795, 26.866212518005455, 25.319351971056665, 21.756243595049693, 38.83636815837831, 13.269869230664263, 20.585716647664484, 41.81799028237565, 20.70798620972454, 25.757064267148355, 20.424134303628165, 22.746545043521817, 37.489884775647035, 28.37846633297319, 31.331793350915632, 45.89376055499394, 48.45689806678996, 25.769066969656024, 37.50294784340499, 15.80596792999741, 22.343185393005484, 25.55931617847709, 10.049949935825998, 42.65572723137875, 36.92742180250308, 36.42496874764336, 31.28810051553334, 34.61484739149778, 33.16503991849856], + "dssim": [0.30451705200422885, 0.3060115640518687, 0.4639200672393781, 0.1592221014562873, 0.3350267725302536, 0.23193839561401058, 0.2197565904949002, 0.08467557364652117, 0.406634759798144, 0.24600190261316318, 0.3938396062820403, 0.25072154866591456, 0.1522126815691795, 0.2589953764959483, 0.3655292416130369, 0.19883169404682172, 0.23060675664667868, 0.1454336962253317, 0.3318275438956868, 0.36855704664771105, 0.22565145751621246, 0.14987867920275133, 0.29374375186472834, 0.23727644006476828, 0.10541664923075039, 0.2785810995913648, 0.22826576832043605, 0.31650715266765916, 0.2220258341129297, 0.31845381320387744, 0.35761428569709075] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L36@4 C7@4", + "tune": "l1=36:4 c=7:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.8224549796079135, 9.01284552776223, 26.087623165838696, 10.193976948752109, 13.61267838971668, 9.829016393841389, 14.399194604211802, 3.6884832818293645, 10.879712190669075, 11.622574825009325, 10.542559902137228, 10.341669785616528, 4.3172872389496675, 11.91301478599369, 18.908095091736104, 11.605576737415253, 12.096796960471272, 10.196435849571692, 18.467195140044993, 14.226439182748443, 11.666277459831438, 4.334759063071817, 13.424186689302633, 12.420954040579268, 2.496306216310438, 12.880261971546936, 13.209645408184716, 12.272900769622815, 7.958827875097821, 10.041724786222105, 14.865816680690925], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.1681936600288, -244.53597010724184, -1229.0720146445087, -132.60901933078515, -317.0193346378949, -206.6154210991656, -420.29833036816603, -63.33034347289356, -310.14238297998475, -321.76726764598124, -255.9322932260343, -159.01544032667732, -64.13289338195443, -272.915664446381, -816.0756099120504, -269.9561368374707, -267.75872094661673, -108.30037531204607, -612.3112058939803, -694.7384649732122, -270.3262853830081, -64.55165869610485, -417.0103316598078, -229.65166372368827, -59.522982724269525, -355.12466560032533, -263.685423930977, -322.8662304916009, -188.02323738901703, -385.4196738086111, -604.3667553762326], + "butteraugli": [22.912623959483863, 25.171012042549496, 45.218228925273166, 26.405211121219946, 25.29382037819993, 21.809289659539974, 38.518924682673024, 13.191577187268843, 20.349710422686066, 36.80076966912401, 20.621713019099374, 25.400599875259477, 19.942754894498922, 22.60052517177883, 37.411294821672094, 28.370702475396456, 31.303289549254753, 46.31040919701112, 46.63927545119794, 25.778712186007752, 36.809166508309815, 15.597067645638793, 22.25254234519758, 25.43081624982224, 10.049839042932986, 40.85902727133714, 37.14087011386798, 35.88630404516635, 30.489816332708603, 34.612582495447235, 34.156761709922336], + "dssim": [0.30451705200422885, 0.30593261728853227, 0.4638992127921379, 0.15871487677816115, 0.3350280465691846, 0.229997374897362, 0.2202745465727715, 0.08451033913224687, 0.4065042942019494, 0.2678293746533059, 0.39398645928556897, 0.25193718335690396, 0.15202413117503566, 0.2588064095219327, 0.36580078557277074, 0.1986767076706406, 0.23089774534736923, 0.14549488759654156, 0.3280277077272088, 0.36862475212707246, 0.22558521186542585, 0.149886304526423, 0.29440939850238756, 0.2369379378719219, 0.10544055251308732, 0.2775957231777141, 0.22733647256302286, 0.31495706449226024, 0.22030382303210405, 0.3186284516576202, 0.3549153611409036] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L38@3 C14@3", + "tune": "l1=38:3 c=14:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.9018284249283814, 9.155742149974925, 26.079957703385208, 9.96275534410921, 13.744540126203427, 10.174081580759854, 14.343587475506018, 4.023639016507125, 11.22709305237949, 11.673205704420374, 10.76121777387461, 10.779181976651527, 4.452046155928911, 11.953056256761078, 18.801427149613485, 11.489650757468246, 12.81392651743552, 10.501128430792248, 18.709548440062964, 14.302644135570214, 12.120253333056699, 4.912248467277587, 13.354815685901317, 12.9048230132033, 2.781845419151256, 13.383633980420234, 13.687986363673712, 12.048527173707916, 9.31978300903976, 10.519151809133588, 14.935745425580128], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.84116041780248, -252.72423504891026, -1229.5340928708101, -132.93638335958806, -360.06904495896123, -225.76653631386165, -438.61894770358106, -63.51138489359951, -309.82206884181954, -322.176535765249, -247.65448358484082, -164.86179280122968, -64.21792405448235, -272.4519812289443, -810.3165740739097, -259.47571747905755, -302.1926537655513, -128.6018884963684, -617.552597015151, -696.4486017197806, -278.1181969220065, -65.67423726656259, -434.25872864158623, -227.69551912398742, -60.49431644301251, -371.80648671218756, -295.35538430454153, -331.8858066426312, -222.10777133054592, -407.4288603467162, -592.0615497137385], + "butteraugli": [23.976862481802126, 25.762983136903088, 45.224315850668326, 27.31135658188469, 26.755642282251078, 23.443238085204445, 39.6261660508489, 14.05200804361192, 22.03382712810856, 35.069262484191654, 22.232763839727472, 31.52317427435646, 19.903669680062553, 25.719204036520903, 38.30570610750033, 29.853923221957825, 36.43207812103589, 44.254421340987385, 51.36789245356135, 25.950258091975197, 39.28338162666045, 16.54091799101239, 22.230951327524565, 25.69091992555218, 9.524675912213638, 39.96201329904082, 42.17079198284449, 33.65220811303861, 44.328389575871874, 35.09654472874427, 33.575453195445725], + "dssim": [0.30444659544548125, 0.30541780987266587, 0.46383297615645397, 0.15864227338950965, 0.3364984466227754, 0.2360138308297472, 0.2211582931285882, 0.0851850193554351, 0.4067173197859395, 0.2748633959344545, 0.39436628877496305, 0.26345154839460294, 0.15211142298229524, 0.2604196227661736, 0.3649485054373347, 0.2041515949817489, 0.23801060894217602, 0.16311432463305503, 0.3293577990633202, 0.3689156309895947, 0.23296856634597257, 0.15134073656622044, 0.2882853009292453, 0.23749234559090066, 0.1097537861199373, 0.27830175361564935, 0.23581982260425205, 0.303624655734824, 0.21962710050188528, 0.32150256815515743, 0.35962248770145444] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L40@3 C13@3", + "tune": "l1=40:3 c=13:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.895531379938972, 9.102705197117876, 26.073975125334798, 9.880449321989921, 13.823284302910446, 10.074140532350437, 14.262864342955368, 4.00474649187604, 11.221796434635605, 10.947597161400138, 10.750346534473172, 11.017245293421238, 4.508415650537092, 11.916755029950389, 18.775495920067122, 11.493389765827011, 12.81392651743552, 10.795906526832596, 18.774047844057705, 14.285287128985823, 12.197879601070102, 4.924115784005549, 13.354815685901317, 12.967393063201941, 2.7388958940523955, 13.383633980420234, 13.577728202521392, 12.039884752558713, 9.329469687672592, 10.4974502897779, 15.025937893162876], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.9610073178631, -244.15352735216845, -1229.7277023105958, -127.50551752622903, -354.3390622388696, -225.1958223286868, -434.55801714505253, -63.513079264595575, -302.6691704793773, -312.73659349212596, -247.0165713472269, -166.81637606953825, -64.21403959392887, -271.9068380051143, -802.3800846147205, -259.67154795082905, -302.1926537655513, -135.22021597142464, -616.634981185431, -695.7449080456474, -277.80667419838466, -65.68099607343609, -434.25872864158623, -226.35741694559533, -60.39693128697604, -371.80648671218756, -277.88176765328524, -327.42387825778144, -216.61677580564583, -404.01865148758645, -590.1589176109848], + "butteraugli": [23.963599219899663, 25.59207665166416, 45.25506370648218, 27.176281085467874, 27.042002375682568, 23.237025014395126, 39.94409750948924, 14.095774094366952, 22.09331772103599, 30.589363702266713, 22.00808049856221, 31.37181529558735, 19.745155551134673, 25.713203931471316, 38.40924477846533, 29.840729600618157, 36.43207812103589, 43.14682333844218, 51.28080088801897, 25.98364715273533, 39.272759027512194, 16.518865603362247, 22.230951327524565, 25.699003659503717, 9.544842609156989, 39.96201329904082, 44.424809861033, 32.795423508307074, 48.1906273883853, 34.847944393983205, 33.39363915979772], + "dssim": [0.3044414903570819, 0.3052881926751715, 0.4638685213876501, 0.15701256842921035, 0.33661404485498714, 0.23895786801031865, 0.22229437931268098, 0.08513085167994544, 0.40655030665910075, 0.2835007416305505, 0.39452295265977533, 0.26430404686347586, 0.15229595008202929, 0.2602347258851071, 0.36491261433107214, 0.20412184934482264, 0.23801060894217602, 0.1648126133806746, 0.32983082077138215, 0.3688507876638887, 0.232899756426242, 0.1514696772800404, 0.2882853009292453, 0.23746054805462014, 0.11014550246505683, 0.27830175361564935, 0.23535900469607496, 0.30262301414421533, 0.21988961532281354, 0.32119269345098, 0.36042656888787344] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L42@3 C12@3", + "tune": "l1=42:3 c=12:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.8995198952755015, 8.878754807050655, 26.05731178195781, 9.996932015880477, 13.91109578878447, 10.044518607571222, 14.278191752420753, 4.00474649187604, 11.100051537549382, 10.801169612535647, 10.656973685108964, 11.124368552853355, 4.508415650537092, 11.867707595614766, 18.83717113031868, 11.157998731782637, 12.684851388406734, 10.882670703467822, 18.832750209232124, 14.28617553221168, 11.915107626351926, 4.963090772142552, 13.354815685901317, 12.967393063201941, 2.722458377317151, 13.426038593492526, 13.640012781510746, 12.073733053369505, 9.329469687672592, 10.436904587446934, 15.025937893162876], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.7910914397333, -230.47452567711184, -1227.5613862704308, -135.21702213231137, -355.98568438754234, -216.14465379740687, -437.29618212489004, -63.513079264595575, -286.60015919922523, -301.9146849123347, -232.86525836024975, -165.01541368426928, -64.21403959392887, -259.2662459837386, -796.9530699998086, -224.8087197741657, -286.05710188131775, -130.45809905202947, -619.7129913242484, -695.1284164021911, -258.54802877726354, -65.6270288954629, -434.25872864158623, -226.35741694559533, -60.42245830336958, -364.8145023137496, -277.70636222649387, -327.7072391588885, -216.61677580564583, -399.05716421955094, -590.1589176109848], + "butteraugli": [23.963932268543022, 25.70264133460097, 45.2133303046854, 26.703759547297164, 27.078896191444, 23.0036861060663, 39.660923441929675, 14.095774094366952, 21.651239903127777, 30.692330770509002, 21.719728965230164, 32.297771796948446, 19.745155551134673, 24.680294283251595, 37.90431949444952, 28.578565857216972, 35.99502785299422, 42.26088347337949, 49.888679452350566, 25.968987318855344, 38.49348905455795, 16.349309925010477, 22.230951327524565, 25.699003659503717, 9.56835037779014, 39.157993328885965, 44.45691283035648, 32.38713874750968, 48.1906273883853, 35.01019915899671, 33.39363915979772], + "dssim": [0.3044463998373901, 0.30488722123133627, 0.4637288170966004, 0.16014967742103997, 0.336563703221466, 0.23809071734581416, 0.22244524879201305, 0.08513085167994544, 0.40660422930599704, 0.2865192470248442, 0.39462827238990633, 0.2669433133517941, 0.15229595008202929, 0.2597893864854607, 0.36497984205014944, 0.2084647777694466, 0.23611797971846332, 0.16649044055444312, 0.33467879577926485, 0.36896072788919776, 0.23056413600890585, 0.15179711032270227, 0.2882853009292453, 0.23746054805462014, 0.11059764176470938, 0.2779126758389666, 0.23550080195685347, 0.30270838363536523, 0.21988961532281354, 0.32176561771179113, 0.36042656888787344] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L44@3 C11@3", + "tune": "l1=44:3 c=11:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.90209782125825, 8.864540690110397, 26.057883593429533, 10.164501425706437, 13.911657689386262, 10.035395196080767, 14.231267813417444, 4.00474649187604, 11.165150605645906, 10.815406223363794, 10.626231353688118, 11.124368552853355, 4.502381740015099, 11.93510038609464, 18.862136497172287, 11.162971667278445, 12.831402213759832, 10.919554958961884, 18.868749219211043, 14.28687142529725, 11.919150392385268, 4.9829623773921154, 13.354815685901317, 12.92230391591231, 2.7193046915811023, 13.37534446168414, 13.370761936692734, 12.013005201892481, 9.15651710545073, 10.436904587446934, 14.938316297904596], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.8021313873924, -231.32744023923357, -1228.2986372433115, -134.88719695619068, -355.37466342173195, -218.5593098963899, -430.7093824827041, -63.513079264595575, -282.51602663600414, -301.8855369081359, -230.09572483953048, -165.01541368426928, -64.21335290520284, -260.49070305612423, -783.7984840702427, -224.45214536685165, -301.9623228325452, -131.17478566579962, -619.8931082927918, -695.2701740543141, -258.5041799237184, -65.49091926490013, -434.25872864158623, -226.3208390738655, -60.396375352803375, -350.63254702723054, -259.776630830124, -326.6185249673024, -197.9023950682108, -399.05716421955094, -577.1216234258018], + "butteraugli": [23.96683710461804, 25.682154381872845, 45.21595447305308, 26.695997356250746, 26.979780784996507, 23.237755927332454, 39.371434534934146, 14.095774094366952, 21.029585303918697, 30.21518740645918, 21.631104582162365, 32.297771796948446, 19.735337587711808, 24.67598740903848, 38.40236761490065, 28.567100017371796, 35.53906681969611, 42.264099372300564, 49.88384474251603, 25.975897808956802, 38.453744801154265, 16.303356292141974, 22.230951327524565, 25.517923496239263, 9.562767447054144, 39.647741534526745, 43.3568334004668, 32.23472933627735, 42.6435693877366, 35.01019915899671, 32.61063215410829], + "dssim": [0.304447640994275, 0.3050473264963969, 0.46373350826805215, 0.16102694442557103, 0.336447739602619, 0.23904813423996357, 0.22259971230790881, 0.08513085167994544, 0.40719739321715365, 0.28872210484206884, 0.39483624199891754, 0.2669433133517941, 0.15226087108873676, 0.25984933345469663, 0.364742004331023, 0.20842352326511882, 0.2418638281622265, 0.16681526384567058, 0.3344641817341424, 0.36896418501472894, 0.23058669610127058, 0.152512621508545, 0.2882853009292453, 0.23747724431160516, 0.11058479470047494, 0.27840982419747384, 0.2389356816187076, 0.3029696885167704, 0.2189307736907874, 0.32176561771179113, 0.36128446797902014] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L46@3 C10@3", + "tune": "l1=46:3 c=10:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.92430716131448, 8.85097038623062, 26.050609819913696, 9.975129732912961, 14.066325973318511, 10.083244595966603, 14.27309527304839, 4.045120056155157, 11.165150605645906, 10.625079749122627, 10.626231353688118, 11.122772746603536, 4.502537702788134, 12.061961616488892, 18.77611859917227, 11.177203960569388, 12.876618099501124, 10.8370101880637, 18.89710491307125, 14.279530612850207, 11.942460343245383, 4.9829623773921154, 13.288101788036908, 12.882632904254937, 2.773464160434911, 13.213647227233983, 13.435715884080441, 12.019425739577938, 9.15651710545073, 10.392740377406072, 14.990016363287866], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.06803467581418, -227.64430121503722, -1227.2471636039963, -124.23486828700109, -355.7695772660977, -220.7757356985624, -428.38080476954826, -63.51939250166524, -282.51602663600414, -290.4819894679758, -230.09572483953048, -164.83711598946633, -64.21334106043378, -263.069482679339, -783.0186837905278, -224.8049068653483, -303.9438740875334, -127.6973058036418, -619.83279123178, -694.6116507343963, -258.861967950209, -65.49091926490013, -433.2154284162523, -223.65755137846946, -60.44768343624719, -334.7418408042376, -260.5452089712577, -316.03654306190845, -197.9023950682108, -384.8271265703846, -568.3831274642381], + "butteraugli": [23.988787973532453, 25.76200144416539, 45.197025070295204, 25.86683290872419, 26.905408464425758, 22.84270170339779, 39.63086897335287, 14.075459415394363, 21.029585303918697, 28.49814131969688, 21.631104582162365, 32.277834110834846, 19.726910879907578, 24.51804177310908, 38.84473693614894, 28.595072123760264, 35.58256966596298, 41.717065952257464, 49.93584313860604, 25.93832842565241, 38.502408771203555, 16.303356292141974, 22.235837988905335, 25.662074475274224, 9.678268727763205, 39.74800025784311, 43.26025467935228, 31.433211738506106, 42.6435693877366, 34.60105778719352, 32.425746416179216], + "dssim": [0.3044330724597897, 0.30496566600947295, 0.46364916351692836, 0.1643535287103648, 0.33643846838440494, 0.23977448825942638, 0.22266728868481372, 0.08518968560576184, 0.40719739321715365, 0.27973570414624604, 0.39483624199891754, 0.2669318979913534, 0.1522897954588598, 0.2597539996272179, 0.3649017001145044, 0.208461704059887, 0.24196355463668628, 0.16714455645501075, 0.3345208175598603, 0.36893103244632564, 0.23053018174571865, 0.152512621508545, 0.2905360054991172, 0.23754527371016154, 0.10964300244410063, 0.27773199068105425, 0.23856039587461764, 0.30316860306918947, 0.2189307736907874, 0.32267763644411873, 0.35797035518225684] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L48@3 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=48:3 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.92112213083366, 8.85097038623062, 26.04930230899148, 10.067814394189229, 14.226138581766683, 10.157732428121689, 14.490128881374035, 4.045120056155157, 11.172580518904603, 10.665541319284122, 10.61916979404616, 11.13035866199873, 4.502537702788134, 12.126224730663289, 18.840390699591016, 11.182910305424869, 12.948626733498948, 10.814011427274092, 18.83900696379193, 14.246497531279148, 11.86874831801239, 4.953292256458794, 13.288101788036908, 12.947563346323182, 2.7634222553564705, 13.076879820263956, 13.563074200976189, 11.793881278287135, 9.15651710545073, 10.392740377406072, 15.000802077416434], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.6545430085427, -227.64430121503722, -1227.5909847004996, -124.79461536333301, -351.32604987287186, -221.8011207168969, -433.9757830030826, -63.51939250166524, -282.3757718426431, -290.25656848078154, -230.59178847648616, -165.01183073349273, -64.21334106043378, -264.34723828126045, -785.798656715309, -224.8620791587839, -307.58732973939846, -127.92030032454053, -594.7325926464658, -673.7789938002963, -262.1377382019114, -65.45729290101505, -433.2154284162523, -223.52176108628703, -60.404891022548725, -322.73062306744794, -260.87249049938185, -300.9623362934335, -197.9023950682108, -384.8271265703846, -565.6249228637998], + "butteraugli": [23.558857401580287, 25.76200144416539, 45.19544212082828, 25.80064696617921, 26.41480881677059, 22.53841804352274, 40.08347387390699, 14.075459415394363, 21.156650888066967, 28.87318641146149, 21.519714987459697, 32.29179397851655, 19.726910879907578, 24.665703679296296, 38.315442152579784, 28.590890683712516, 35.50489301685024, 40.77196520884149, 49.32673618435033, 25.74778130221112, 38.990411289551595, 16.26551361467807, 22.235837988905335, 25.617635869623978, 9.684783821029079, 38.5350376639058, 41.40056797587345, 30.051634864673463, 42.6435693877366, 34.60105778719352, 32.244151808936415], + "dssim": [0.30439210180150367, 0.30496566600947295, 0.4636547540222139, 0.1647503192225787, 0.336113141695051, 0.24211497540009347, 0.22514351525954096, 0.08518968560576184, 0.40716032773805305, 0.2785546527451658, 0.39498466983308594, 0.26688084141810375, 0.1522897954588598, 0.2597040857468027, 0.3650532253731342, 0.20846078306253496, 0.2441434624137821, 0.16982582889853498, 0.33241149041332263, 0.3693102422517054, 0.23116437600860312, 0.15255491046266406, 0.2905360054991172, 0.2375487452973714, 0.10987171479478075, 0.2768903549351638, 0.23919088125731458, 0.3002191816188087, 0.2189307736907874, 0.32267763644411873, 0.3585951360742794] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L40@3 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=40:3 c=10:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.9392411918537285, 9.102705197117876, 26.073975125334798, 10.025936513895099, 13.890982582384424, 10.125849667356123, 14.258750619071238, 3.9009852918233614, 11.221796434635605, 10.959021242064985, 10.750346534473172, 11.00038497400308, 4.457924787031262, 11.985673862959109, 18.82439045317937, 11.52247850288247, 12.822340913008707, 10.683991031989331, 18.83389338077251, 14.214065685297546, 12.200969196638846, 4.8851565854849035, 13.345133532776579, 12.698956975123851, 2.6596628361064814, 13.383633980420234, 13.343221841552596, 11.796477279006345, 9.329469687672592, 10.4974502897779, 14.717172010600395], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.9498345057566, -244.15352735216845, -1229.7277023105958, -127.05380780489952, -356.80122039600667, -227.41946388659983, -433.8790372529662, -63.51995038543876, -302.6691704793773, -317.2768972498613, -247.0165713472269, -167.36166305659077, -64.21270603501114, -273.8036099002923, -812.1130488275237, -259.91201642616556, -304.4915487034765, -136.3355302660592, -621.1041151722644, -695.7457738662449, -278.59099333249384, -65.66677066826833, -432.9431798050157, -226.8928765566418, -60.35340471247713, -371.80648671218756, -277.0226908791759, -324.5055493556256, -216.61677580564583, -404.01865148758645, -586.7478323499665], + "butteraugli": [23.98645144361431, 25.59207665166416, 45.25506370648218, 27.164424573521938, 27.003037860918525, 23.267876665355175, 39.927682014449466, 14.006752600186166, 22.09331772103599, 30.710266409117498, 22.00808049856221, 31.422893358511327, 19.764040889567866, 25.45848190358571, 38.3124459920272, 29.84307821960728, 36.85827060448121, 43.25990398024138, 51.49090547111884, 25.963507144510377, 39.26528033840554, 16.536571218501994, 22.213858271614583, 25.62358259757096, 9.634701137653748, 39.96201329904082, 43.803374398408785, 32.93456960236068, 48.1906273883853, 34.847944393983205, 33.2308271952625], + "dssim": [0.3044483958253358, 0.3052881926751715, 0.4638685213876501, 0.1587574007448686, 0.3365880343095571, 0.2380286076358385, 0.22243916873330577, 0.08512630425513418, 0.40655030665910075, 0.28650882081738993, 0.39452295265977533, 0.2636205653809919, 0.15225436409566773, 0.26017082116286816, 0.3653841287722457, 0.20412535851756458, 0.23805345529098615, 0.16516446827584425, 0.3298999250877276, 0.3685618476565682, 0.233014772671925, 0.15194586804477134, 0.2923469336129675, 0.2374391654199126, 0.10850763913544004, 0.27830175361564935, 0.2361902962926366, 0.30091209261739915, 0.21988961532281354, 0.32119269345098, 0.3565360943315965] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L44@3 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=44:3 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.940215782772931, 8.864540690110397, 26.057883593429533, 10.240824927651902, 14.002107851929361, 10.08772009228672, 14.599566690848333, 3.9030023575520283, 11.165150605645906, 10.83183970264635, 10.626231353688118, 11.114966461153404, 4.457924787031262, 12.055287717184704, 18.83606267910646, 11.314179519086533, 12.892219751120669, 10.771197819963383, 18.997935738882493, 14.227659506558396, 11.958817350848454, 4.946050345175333, 13.358563289803067, 12.66859765848091, 2.671298747898835, 13.37534446168414, 13.293199304410416, 11.828621472796735, 9.15651710545073, 10.436904587446934, 14.731787989315489], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.0738525450882, -231.32744023923357, -1228.2986372433115, -134.93522422232817, -357.0269499962223, -220.77448978131963, -430.9927048898985, -63.502329998665175, -282.51602663600414, -306.6978681305702, -230.09572483953048, -165.59046082118624, -64.21270603501114, -263.66555539374053, -787.1415777394735, -225.0506436320178, -304.068622430095, -131.73518510710184, -624.3787373420334, -693.1985709157991, -259.1553847413235, -65.47975688471556, -432.6805147035336, -226.87208434135198, -60.35318331394066, -350.63254702723054, -258.55327746087374, -324.33283628600094, -197.9023950682108, -399.05716421955094, -578.4512320914808], + "butteraugli": [24.005393703589505, 25.682154381872845, 45.21595447305308, 26.827310813192597, 26.886706307441198, 23.241321300643857, 39.50655020359115, 14.004213856724439, 21.029585303918697, 30.395383450875467, 21.631104582162365, 32.38288283528021, 19.764040889567866, 24.633260851636525, 38.481831357446026, 28.684281078245178, 35.672954804778705, 42.441940470774846, 50.06479623838902, 25.882316449554306, 38.51758274235919, 16.306753573138838, 22.21574666990078, 25.44351153195439, 9.663479722620126, 39.647741534526745, 42.68718939416147, 32.42591255884772, 42.6435693877366, 35.01019915899671, 32.528600645731764], + "dssim": [0.3044458991301082, 0.3050473264963969, 0.46373350826805215, 0.16183508153904097, 0.33665515929710466, 0.23868881124447777, 0.22334966114879978, 0.08510510106414088, 0.40719739321715365, 0.28935698155948597, 0.39483624199891754, 0.2664654357519781, 0.15225436409566773, 0.25969120912613974, 0.36482355249669957, 0.20854052529779127, 0.2418628215692365, 0.16689030773095093, 0.3334152401384942, 0.3688188244603321, 0.23050002628419414, 0.15306964893355074, 0.292419833187643, 0.23745055536994736, 0.10892757463861957, 0.27840982419747384, 0.2382902557880412, 0.30670375685194695, 0.2189307736907874, 0.32176561771179113, 0.3557579184406685] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L46@3 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=46:3 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.940215782772931, 8.85097038623062, 26.050609819913696, 10.072375398251152, 14.002107851929361, 10.092913209618558, 14.554438525884889, 3.9030023575520283, 11.165150605645906, 10.654477828897948, 10.626231353688118, 11.114966461153404, 4.457924787031262, 12.055287717184704, 18.83627605572092, 11.314179519086533, 12.892219751120669, 10.701645166684736, 18.997935738882493, 14.227659506558396, 11.958817350848454, 4.946050345175333, 13.358563289803067, 12.638051967330231, 2.671298747898835, 13.213647227233983, 13.293199304410416, 11.775342871747927, 9.15651710545073, 10.392740377406072, 14.706207111446298], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.0738525450882, -227.64430121503722, -1227.2471636039963, -124.3655345320721, -357.0269499962223, -221.1119078208722, -428.8324209904831, -63.502329998665175, -282.51602663600414, -291.7284833906438, -230.09572483953048, -165.59046082118624, -64.21270603501114, -263.66555539374053, -785.9083767737117, -225.0506436320178, -304.068622430095, -128.24493903118767, -624.3787373420334, -693.1985709157991, -259.1553847413235, -65.47975688471556, -432.6805147035336, -224.49118038404555, -60.35318331394066, -334.7418408042376, -258.55327746087374, -314.0701313610539, -197.9023950682108, -384.8271265703846, -571.2810399840055], + "butteraugli": [24.005393703589505, 25.76200144416539, 45.197025070295204, 25.95644937835218, 26.886706307441198, 22.8547368365909, 39.746500683660834, 14.004213856724439, 21.029585303918697, 28.514431317442515, 21.631104582162365, 32.38288283528021, 19.764040889567866, 24.633260851636525, 38.85730205481898, 28.684281078245178, 35.672954804778705, 41.85623768718495, 50.06479623838902, 25.882316449554306, 38.51758274235919, 16.306753573138838, 22.21574666990078, 25.557494592055743, 9.663479722620126, 39.74800025784311, 42.68718939416147, 31.600032570282824, 42.6435693877366, 34.60105778719352, 32.325105502513374], + "dssim": [0.3044458991301082, 0.30496566600947295, 0.46364916351692836, 0.16443021336869856, 0.33665515929710466, 0.2402065675095451, 0.22341392185976727, 0.08510510106414088, 0.40719739321715365, 0.2780596495238392, 0.39483624199891754, 0.2664654357519781, 0.15225436409566773, 0.25969120912613974, 0.36483867517866764, 0.20854052529779127, 0.2418628215692365, 0.16646929484131, 0.3334152401384942, 0.3688188244603321, 0.23050002628419414, 0.15306964893355074, 0.292419833187643, 0.23744639740431778, 0.10892757463861957, 0.27773199068105425, 0.2382902557880412, 0.30672507195474674, 0.2189307736907874, 0.32267763644411873, 0.3553172602570972] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L29@5 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=29:5 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.802913010669278, 8.959273554775573, 26.105952665261068, 10.080329530094977, 13.875165036294243, 10.143082001357909, 14.39463983063989, 3.6636031236713897, 10.95697675149691, 12.234557266078015, 10.502170868393998, 10.391554204013966, 4.3061823194980295, 11.993690107831158, 19.154151928927263, 11.083094928905249, 12.151972741213896, 10.846179000981234, 18.715706804871772, 14.236483561928914, 11.709806410121482, 4.619618929343782, 13.088631124641605, 12.81355111258153, 2.488566188420719, 13.688978742031763, 13.56550076016977, 12.508227046271601, 8.405428837241232, 10.201028972472843, 15.15599450010436], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.25101234234717, -244.2666030132363, -1231.2589042069656, -135.07170396316243, -322.41262512030596, -235.7280162528662, -425.3481872722855, -63.810780193351206, -319.70876561507396, -337.0962189767403, -253.15361229884155, -168.62197529289654, -64.13829789241677, -284.83424286143025, -846.7726914878632, -278.61658137908523, -278.0339151673386, -122.0712474375984, -648.0743838550222, -693.8676572543521, -284.8347918872145, -65.83867259372488, -435.74259253550645, -244.90253932867296, -58.78514808649484, -400.4953175955017, -303.7408889839139, -359.09291421322746, -217.89224308637347, -401.4233645022162, -649.5714107754253], + "butteraugli": [22.78726503525067, 25.058288186021297, 45.19215282656785, 26.763998076336446, 24.957116257419006, 21.873928353732655, 39.12343132872416, 13.208721012068006, 20.26014104436018, 43.69983808014005, 20.75718005744817, 26.749920864363137, 21.512853577809462, 22.142722326641774, 37.32521763088129, 28.396349036022684, 31.41503104851472, 47.88009539325313, 49.293627424265914, 25.766294640225123, 38.670602885710885, 16.266597346295583, 22.192502147008053, 25.58528834041972, 9.76426287188573, 42.511843260557896, 37.54763797612849, 37.815236923346184, 32.54582646207306, 35.0254769941129, 33.57989653789889], + "dssim": [0.30445323964789195, 0.3048274598655826, 0.46395153832070424, 0.15638104044252638, 0.33474853069335053, 0.2318498647035674, 0.2192199736003005, 0.08469211157707562, 0.40678508161794147, 0.24685688982377824, 0.3937483746354804, 0.2493025172252874, 0.15175153673288988, 0.2585019434145772, 0.3663959125344812, 0.19768985931683897, 0.22918834830951562, 0.14671057543330895, 0.33318828890953656, 0.3686393146567124, 0.2237657674332984, 0.1493350848936994, 0.29215619293945383, 0.23741457947680972, 0.10024388552909064, 0.28103125471328283, 0.22968347828516444, 0.3122397734915979, 0.22051348425792394, 0.3177537172591385, 0.35822665955451294] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L8@5+20@4 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=10:4 l2=20:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.814236277964387, 9.205239242619655, 26.100658365510913, 9.94398993830734, 13.50681940194977, 10.0093642423577, 14.038765722240028, 3.544073912178869, 10.954834882556158, 12.165610901393803, 10.577986037491693, 10.529141382517647, 4.317416945375626, 11.838585066390245, 19.11512193640293, 11.079934009823386, 12.121201800864307, 10.450174121778504, 18.66809172640438, 14.213597900557664, 11.815986420272331, 4.671960207683162, 13.200205385574558, 12.519927149231938, 2.4413036250550957, 13.791175773093336, 13.257741307298508, 12.543836316707415, 8.560660456644143, 10.189647030841536, 14.904168700264748], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.24270159415045, -259.023576457323, -1230.1225921333858, -136.89313417054674, -323.3292799012954, -237.14899357621584, -427.4415228241054, -63.841477013516794, -316.0412958941679, -343.0780559287916, -258.7211046773441, -170.4553367472122, -64.16620413487755, -286.7320322892098, -846.2107362858721, -284.34503843823876, -282.445773758315, -120.11779366798609, -655.9421905847646, -695.3791263294601, -290.1614206163499, -65.91352219331239, -442.25135343803674, -248.70933873408205, -59.72998441441834, -415.7361679640776, -299.14473409339786, -369.44907943286347, -223.95249141836143, -404.7034809325161, -652.7454875731125], + "butteraugli": [23.120086524642193, 26.762472341836343, 45.19918113484592, 27.128343563842993, 25.04316705072631, 21.991128976188367, 39.137731921482555, 13.200965886270543, 20.70971840596056, 43.719353102256946, 20.82514704535474, 30.765904403363304, 21.08299117652656, 22.289534925914058, 37.246898287208126, 28.74355025687302, 31.403642820635913, 48.49561231437077, 49.242587945333206, 25.819149914021704, 38.29966502844212, 16.390167831009368, 22.465844285421536, 25.57465785909534, 10.280939161220088, 44.728340074713365, 38.086040324856896, 39.55934590342505, 31.234375127348585, 34.557473916676216, 33.510948396431345], + "dssim": [0.3044430636754576, 0.30524660204419196, 0.46388267541146033, 0.15784568623618295, 0.33461055552157326, 0.23815921917071242, 0.21909741145316208, 0.08475738651557957, 0.40644673467821113, 0.2519152798254616, 0.39380802948972865, 0.2512626885047041, 0.15196837413929876, 0.25847341740695773, 0.3662358175075662, 0.1978684962685588, 0.22867517260694797, 0.14806128794276807, 0.3334350998840412, 0.3685911517781223, 0.2269467924209027, 0.14954246886395794, 0.29381282740210535, 0.23712527145738777, 0.10071926337820197, 0.28194388820552585, 0.23066602055997798, 0.30615854623205274, 0.22292994303787517, 0.3181099696434263, 0.3589587208708429] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L8@5+24@4 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=8:4 l2=24:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.827731089511145, 9.0694814848684, 26.097558643283893, 10.149608525201074, 13.612831612929748, 10.074826545908058, 14.41551737108693, 3.530308126883125, 10.957723530351803, 12.060894555509797, 10.559746393759815, 10.398349137023546, 4.308802989777366, 11.874749093643638, 19.092863495317165, 11.246492165997513, 12.104783803423183, 10.245494476628753, 18.77262824016544, 14.218562721843286, 11.72891493979967, 4.669963056943292, 13.1630211314474, 12.474240998126808, 2.4512817810927667, 13.316577027724536, 13.28062818768799, 12.335022993694524, 8.240333012669726, 10.12252991688283, 14.769848808942989], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.9403985361934, -249.68383755433427, -1229.539504472205, -135.96743645047357, -318.37060021731133, -226.48931950789347, -423.79488124231625, -63.78133731678264, -314.4589667984278, -341.6052019481151, -263.56622368715557, -165.12381858216156, -64.17494650697563, -281.3538666117818, -836.1735915210518, -278.38082009472174, -270.45057303632257, -110.51674960518537, -656.5546080402488, -694.6622071528432, -278.31479017273836, -65.91991950974386, -420.75088527858975, -234.94785804761392, -59.49526840627587, -377.4370297367194, -282.7058913688463, -356.7018985999232, -197.7252075036841, -398.992419267831, -626.852817836196], + "butteraugli": [22.617468137010928, 25.312335347482527, 45.187726025818215, 26.91006043348082, 25.084546263321034, 21.942948792482024, 38.970406222533065, 13.156260638435691, 20.46503171903849, 42.26371542389563, 20.73075654429468, 26.73214605733558, 20.93278732639843, 22.509191731610272, 37.41717106164507, 28.237068368894636, 31.559211529579958, 47.041710439807105, 48.47541512024221, 25.78927871045816, 38.21933258421993, 16.3813098407902, 22.253282684900583, 25.533781294949776, 10.19854113745078, 41.94494928192419, 37.22226361095704, 38.552562738514155, 31.658030918882037, 34.623608483948544, 33.151162490303356], + "dssim": [0.30438565969715536, 0.30520482401826765, 0.4639153798127301, 0.1591188658584481, 0.33483518840408066, 0.23627564960419384, 0.21956847975770383, 0.08466547204180147, 0.4065788589570337, 0.24444202484753091, 0.39385906738089355, 0.2511705236172833, 0.15216462259898816, 0.25818864376993156, 0.3660041819924083, 0.1985116747499232, 0.2284871625519767, 0.14716038287239347, 0.33354001574480785, 0.36856107536059646, 0.22565215404916678, 0.14970656913948438, 0.29369536520433204, 0.2371132314845294, 0.10252963142998478, 0.28019112286143144, 0.22773756765862446, 0.31056314864416956, 0.22178637975163906, 0.31703538707563383, 0.3567725352591147] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L8@5+28@4 C6@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=6:4 l2=28:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.831138349579966, 9.016554245654161, 26.087537516124385, 10.789507528085865, 13.659798517355, 9.856636617373487, 14.366290503716458, 3.9210687504756896, 10.894783196637073, 11.593734197738293, 10.53758427481222, 10.598221544337486, 4.504279051970417, 12.119883202391094, 19.077406595879093, 11.630812398770779, 12.134851662200296, 10.108484078484866, 18.5793380273749, 14.226631825801318, 11.902682334670814, 4.348402672840782, 13.413132956495684, 12.388473420661322, 2.6380925227751186, 12.902216912694213, 13.347111540641519, 12.160647235227328, 7.944448928294993, 9.99183321525607, 15.090121008675194], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.3847074904891, -241.69300350976562, -1229.3642189872926, -133.5063009299353, -316.3802960951027, -208.4744773011975, -420.026667111155, -63.44132768019898, -308.8523223584372, -319.3577245432474, -257.10143328767845, -160.2892588325563, -64.13317691222315, -272.76818326352696, -819.1059896781926, -269.47186190651706, -269.8669274913033, -109.02859109327241, -608.7442100088269, -694.0051295953559, -271.87403909116455, -64.55694264895797, -418.1988351983291, -228.3659685077925, -59.548040061722304, -354.9141595833623, -262.78227653311205, -321.27196168838884, -189.37049661954188, -383.41959657721753, -601.8270072381915], + "butteraugli": [22.501468171716862, 25.15273961933721, 45.17658817031931, 26.512167893279713, 25.334616390114252, 21.8711141911362, 38.54603654102715, 13.17503608432925, 20.154667849678244, 36.65937864734273, 20.509909958299257, 25.565115087623784, 19.844470087620675, 22.3509257405684, 37.31537067109973, 28.317513468868327, 31.18366616648932, 47.654702414636574, 46.546904491296324, 25.773102576433462, 36.683994948940445, 15.534155281472204, 22.211196105663177, 25.352757890114702, 10.226975237727993, 40.38055599759804, 37.179560932854535, 34.91897030255765, 29.563264712307983, 34.79191986823363, 34.520664150467475], + "dssim": [0.30444249518464916, 0.305333001327167, 0.46389875194059094, 0.15844008014002126, 0.3348243483151614, 0.230087054519512, 0.22025772462088833, 0.08454299363186396, 0.40651442904273866, 0.26860765732345215, 0.3939808945099796, 0.25569002912744576, 0.1520242832576077, 0.25835010648413315, 0.36607052078463054, 0.19860829187871415, 0.23083310633416448, 0.14423900674893836, 0.3274808980337043, 0.3686057018634382, 0.2264764122455532, 0.14985571620443228, 0.2941194597808007, 0.23687337369909395, 0.10270688411066536, 0.2779272228062808, 0.2297882664962584, 0.3106277250629774, 0.2212043945133798, 0.3181119944495784, 0.35505495538235154] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B SHIPPED (t1)", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.838204011948919, 7.453951149238095, 25.936442060878555, 7.6509909885936285, 11.826480822363104, 8.12615141748936, 12.081026105094894, 2.876928662854907, 9.877878054669864, 9.084124864884718, 9.9428933859377, 7.800284544757563, 3.55008584103457, 10.164507096743312, 16.75912696597293, 9.334573449232558, 10.260464448685456, 7.503126311220218, 14.984942826010485, 14.24235308587455, 9.261937419473188, 3.607147773257744, 10.812648536988199, 11.214742215887687, 2.278538801479341, 10.689375872053363, 10.391225442610422, 9.583769903817277, 6.167856564760884, 8.525121531859435, 12.528219451682357], + "ssimulacra2": [-114.09152762573112, -144.6581883165179, -1215.853628863129, -86.45848241742246, -232.1155675337531, -123.98744140954642, -245.4778366968643, -60.88755805837462, -183.54187937974552, -144.71293216318713, -171.20073235547846, -82.76924182681216, -63.62120960584241, -182.09873742103252, -555.4673853095177, -140.7158176494339, -152.87534039064298, -70.37197591203525, -274.0288630521511, -621.6478024588064, -151.04871061408974, -64.18925457786446, -298.34736083412383, -129.76403310745158, -53.02203899776018, -159.75106245074477, -139.24583182192234, -145.7357717115873, -110.21030752874384, -214.97416650141406, -396.9572256123925], + "butteraugli": [17.212233125132112, 21.777836094535086, 45.00087733367321, 22.913069538635458, 22.60197521456124, 19.66320184042147, 32.4983550887056, 12.55515388889638, 17.264707299462508, 25.878456363605817, 19.22626778469052, 20.52262147093425, 18.899334448861286, 19.364181011888377, 32.08095771313904, 24.865001951411937, 26.334524006959526, 30.9062317422942, 36.58769495802835, 25.295523910193385, 30.638005555683993, 13.798805700196093, 20.89336627306123, 22.32670184517559, 7.399951393039408, 27.94365383666377, 31.954692255311986, 24.401367443436992, 25.69085869362674, 30.005755253608253, 29.16616555102716], + "dssim": [0.30392646784169886, 0.3009004994732122, 0.46305079332625637, 0.1508728832040807, 0.33643911740234544, 0.20675386593754824, 0.22050020299104783, 0.08371212563484476, 0.4038962432872495, 0.2173198290657487, 0.3929722395642649, 0.23363345555153492, 0.15232646047586046, 0.2549091462900187, 0.35892920265385186, 0.20194855792956007, 0.22840818804389257, 0.13201894248116303, 0.31290827270790134, 0.3707170868114261, 0.22220322956264016, 0.14801545797743004, 0.27288168945024494, 0.23635601146216745, 0.08962116812744497, 0.2632653317575516, 0.21313475551929134, 0.2818344321946008, 0.2095149347129342, 0.3059050918822134, 0.35063486754681955] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L24@4 C17@3", + "tune": "l1=24:4 c=17:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [6.9548377240723775, 7.662006998578488, 25.945173913632768, 7.886969226217643, 12.294142470867577, 8.15350848945416, 12.383778470128211, 3.4557047946134705, 10.04393120000606, 9.204108307039265, 10.027789730757108, 8.62621479248611, 3.7473667847651546, 10.544784763434487, 16.40847902683481, 9.408910498903174, 10.81540677385098, 8.271934472864485, 14.763962460863333, 14.382156406397138, 9.439944394946345, 4.031220082947398, 11.115704602601191, 11.175262174144127, 2.5705919193711293, 10.969765419718307, 11.162543817306465, 9.90533984606987, 6.628458329813503, 8.765061977301652, 13.167757660111834], + "ssimulacra2": [-117.19112870135856, -152.96060607089464, -1217.8130944313295, -87.22549706055815, -246.46148285787706, -130.860551368448, -269.13112620055756, -61.95161180542269, -203.74860972202293, -146.01424958924707, -179.18137001529595, -95.5909850148065, -63.961666292478895, -192.14051193416185, -541.8687133117159, -165.85888329737844, -192.82856595936823, -74.52702222520958, -285.75249182377655, -632.0997469338806, -163.1118802780024, -64.22919727598455, -301.8123326749105, -130.96598262135842, -57.902502235288694, -165.13100907468862, -159.12930288336895, -154.32529639291795, -123.65100865739237, -244.7780188090793, -407.94888053558543], + "butteraugli": [17.431277664156955, 22.03135453626871, 45.06620990575643, 23.147061970548037, 23.40156253116699, 20.038226387494547, 33.798494461327174, 12.905706789926567, 17.911994092623605, 25.994737911584526, 19.608970564820506, 22.83026984934557, 20.926062602650493, 20.245205935745947, 32.49683080637609, 25.854547744181033, 28.000077497833093, 29.98847552247807, 36.782213147893316, 25.380375477651942, 30.544672908159736, 14.248506514492362, 21.08866297353705, 22.004529619729794, 9.498957657485612, 29.252221071105378, 32.85980926201868, 25.14336069934917, 28.044766337200333, 31.33451170231727, 29.459252340969204], + "dssim": [0.3041456696465935, 0.3013977588511657, 0.46294025086821605, 0.15025015657724133, 0.33664025232732064, 0.21199481244921753, 0.22120718274938106, 0.08456779648069307, 0.4041493783237295, 0.22022135334816068, 0.3930995026834728, 0.24526256185896073, 0.15307247917428696, 0.2560712915636054, 0.3590050516385071, 0.20285199413751692, 0.23041015378731766, 0.14040624609595004, 0.31450118349280165, 0.3721687549271421, 0.2243741681367502, 0.14933593255433292, 0.27146779836260093, 0.23912863511876475, 0.10024794588418279, 0.26572192274699236, 0.21994953751473462, 0.2927909947219749, 0.21139953146353274, 0.30940916944491514, 0.35790201326870574] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L26@4 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=26:4 c=16:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.956142893260254, 7.588585297691736, 25.934061688610402, 7.923861544569754, 12.2722358228135, 8.123798692718026, 12.25452347170352, 3.4600306600497994, 10.001401111047196, 9.198517205196634, 10.01946397604418, 8.635742447797611, 3.7938464693404805, 10.576567120021162, 16.469865339463954, 9.125648520171387, 10.610498960467584, 8.256878368754029, 14.790852274431675, 14.37772436672595, 9.389862797149492, 4.031684657751755, 11.105336339679962, 11.164872303792475, 2.5674792643702187, 10.95141600391904, 11.08026647881669, 9.891457432884579, 6.5012822249698115, 8.673230958457227, 13.182593173406561], + "ssimulacra2": [-116.20415290504982, -146.73538152366777, -1215.6580430239692, -87.68088500847168, -242.7348238728141, -127.82009990737834, -249.21274256110166, -61.92243558017225, -196.4813582568297, -145.25885787512166, -175.53306775637105, -90.88724545949273, -63.94347720732415, -189.59914206113746, -531.6066934416441, -143.6719731141275, -173.6145226684809, -72.7630805854418, -275.4984211698232, -623.736382772969, -157.38702549933743, -64.22933792948169, -297.6301675051531, -127.74262389715628, -57.94748437990006, -163.04390356368776, -156.57013857075117, -152.06602013986586, -115.84251084623003, -226.80458962444044, -397.55981075327225], + "butteraugli": [17.400094368724908, 21.8891081900447, 45.04679341374949, 23.09793120018612, 22.872632580725732, 19.869282911025106, 33.068598330884434, 12.873431700765744, 17.69313063301792, 25.90423322072661, 19.647793111647402, 22.62961127351899, 21.06121462221806, 20.394195302859774, 32.10416116014843, 25.279133495865214, 26.486533623368064, 29.99056602613706, 36.27491029947131, 25.318741462644013, 30.429426955684892, 14.212841824624997, 21.003184059553018, 21.990644145180237, 9.530838659273398, 29.318405345761303, 32.805460484562104, 24.936062357567348, 27.594895842571983, 31.290627541647513, 29.70178517457334], + "dssim": [0.30413064701533343, 0.3014091703298002, 0.46281235003365473, 0.15112513631196084, 0.336774030624475, 0.21249560699092185, 0.22185106925790793, 0.0845262338110751, 0.40410167258685376, 0.22152585704203465, 0.3930036842659635, 0.24557078838089746, 0.15304073868999596, 0.25620966115648025, 0.3586668620189065, 0.2046770505832065, 0.23319290033036894, 0.13967258977426478, 0.31504788713517673, 0.3714424069799136, 0.22509058921616637, 0.14968017438463227, 0.2698477924548289, 0.23921114023891138, 0.10024083404874101, 0.265180746839338, 0.2198923149379674, 0.2908763451131696, 0.21072715288278104, 0.3065589363095206, 0.35717958264776295] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L28@4 C15@3", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.991856072743919, 7.481006486068306, 25.900417208700258, 7.864669045846976, 12.232657351052076, 8.00573958438616, 12.186495152228039, 3.479120328420012, 9.94665872699769, 9.185848763302795, 9.976311946620678, 8.622943220491626, 3.7934939177901215, 10.53854138051349, 16.41287764005326, 9.229067330725396, 10.464105805024502, 8.122328397198617, 14.740477003179162, 14.351910013618193, 9.283669890838732, 4.051522868154004, 11.094091392021218, 11.4021265975882, 2.5347109133643477, 10.715650016670166, 11.033256053611014, 9.74124709938941, 6.402752124416206, 8.492257876069713, 13.008868011222237], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.977936128214, -139.94339949027983, -1211.6236334109071, -83.07049340504295, -228.93053279549497, -112.78192564113198, -230.04823698320865, -61.793112811946514, -187.8718591288374, -142.60914823443176, -170.03003712339472, -90.18345145723418, -63.93764047156, -189.6951054493344, -508.66261924684545, -143.89099001735215, -164.26959243861177, -72.43618906656377, -263.6197152076393, -620.168871439826, -148.94755441767643, -64.22938696088895, -296.20722083210626, -119.6219342962982, -56.58153580772574, -145.30742746044706, -154.51165954310824, -132.46477853529797, -109.48451249830046, -205.77137825831807, -371.16029453997214], + "butteraugli": [16.481513613544845, 21.675262705463734, 45.02314823340483, 22.515671967831565, 22.55604594681688, 19.690029446053902, 32.10320560067659, 12.95818179706324, 17.71875976857901, 26.052645269285165, 19.514099174838567, 22.147136800797863, 20.17992163843675, 20.261559507996765, 31.79670406751298, 25.099792458276642, 26.583076730150854, 28.163160891119883, 36.52537076469483, 25.32945913908148, 30.19929733226002, 14.153358137722728, 20.791732319232036, 22.266017367835087, 8.757159724639886, 27.988106333523366, 32.563526253100356, 24.79786237191011, 27.794566157967832, 30.62786374406092, 28.390573091886697], + "dssim": [0.30419085349279695, 0.30109736029430423, 0.4625891155803296, 0.1515062121242377, 0.33681841642819166, 0.2117100700508458, 0.2225574369446484, 0.08465860650906382, 0.4040385391107583, 0.22191182090619538, 0.39266715891008963, 0.24892539682566533, 0.15330242149181322, 0.25627770947362616, 0.35887939855355727, 0.2062313729172996, 0.2340777791278439, 0.14062280924103554, 0.3139282965863682, 0.3717950784335735, 0.22497975415999183, 0.14967906575022732, 0.26876869542821813, 0.23904305901756234, 0.09611662769589097, 0.2635387361376126, 0.21966915984839336, 0.28801836322814356, 0.21025210085622376, 0.3028671046756315, 0.35417818583404015] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L30@4 C13@3", + "tune": "l1=30:4 c=13:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.050901078990522, 7.48201525565057, 25.85298843579867, 7.9028253540306554, 12.261659713456643, 8.004953389886074, 11.996953468401607, 3.4095600141267814, 9.934514056245447, 9.227436441466034, 9.940744833550268, 8.636241767655454, 3.7735778798835113, 10.650122511251865, 16.474365797675375, 9.37772761727992, 10.490588453225994, 8.188977262635204, 14.828707195658321, 14.348949777921192, 9.284131473211305, 4.059465230048826, 11.263039720708754, 11.495752572698903, 2.527620214060049, 10.68251555237073, 10.944694516773728, 9.718235048708793, 6.345807755561372, 8.397799779988095, 12.836243812634434], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.04076549474917, -141.00180529543132, -1205.9967989368138, -80.5587331086939, -227.39638644300476, -106.87696697981693, -211.70001879420533, -61.67845310336557, -184.68463645241837, -139.9817376843873, -165.94974423035768, -90.63701298692877, -63.83231885193345, -190.89660804112907, -503.2661167306517, -145.6859778866573, -171.13232671651446, -73.34544770967963, -260.74411391829955, -617.5855218521476, -147.71874369315907, -64.22943355360178, -299.03635718755106, -109.42649640449929, -56.577675518493436, -142.95996762507303, -138.6046770825428, -121.44527137312309, -104.22987650098034, -194.42209829127825, -332.73112078403125], + "butteraugli": [16.407507330957547, 21.46617339939561, 44.979738494468144, 22.485982845179674, 22.67321924208855, 19.703797943855097, 31.55839342683808, 12.794122558361039, 17.66394853372018, 26.29104609862237, 19.521249090410368, 22.09469442441369, 20.153061979320746, 20.251060759351457, 31.711186232100275, 25.096114543753256, 26.252724072412317, 27.82787706716206, 36.152325200164405, 25.330373551486847, 29.71983825636705, 14.035380769198452, 20.661045056291247, 22.55862681799176, 8.775764604223644, 27.72455550158627, 32.18237181692164, 24.51401647842414, 27.519629004108594, 29.81929418748292, 27.918133647404755], + "dssim": [0.30419865656089007, 0.30103189646017314, 0.4623051108426877, 0.151805509076606, 0.3368221895801473, 0.20849379534741208, 0.22278266565488664, 0.08463191088540617, 0.4040342574516836, 0.22093644901986798, 0.3923877900305639, 0.24932190531788545, 0.15340982090523553, 0.2563210010871695, 0.3584246698384106, 0.2061884391784729, 0.23546208145103792, 0.1439175595417359, 0.3126696618839304, 0.372490830430647, 0.225829394084967, 0.14988608571444023, 0.27275149786114394, 0.23871998865980332, 0.0959330984018501, 0.26336000954994154, 0.21815785078516442, 0.2883231084307777, 0.20966610568672506, 0.3024765210698942, 0.35225213925844057] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L32@4 C12@3", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=12:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [7.031292328209524, 7.456359815119465, 25.817800831937724, 7.885975173882425, 12.197041424738904, 8.00317414236479, 12.074313707207365, 3.4129100985288865, 9.917373872093636, 9.159904715647047, 9.872053338227763, 8.631300912820375, 3.8073662021118286, 10.664024080930329, 16.54112271979725, 9.290021424655258, 10.47611350871227, 8.186446339006588, 14.8794106652298, 14.349304436391078, 9.216904862394387, 4.003890981006599, 11.21265390201004, 11.494273694957213, 2.521318819717269, 10.657529149821176, 10.899847886824091, 9.748289056750753, 6.315270789832925, 8.3393139272524, 12.757877961862055], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.44666337590826, -138.54017474921176, -1203.2168975370464, -78.6473575047552, -220.88780700380624, -105.00611957519783, -209.71989128522478, -61.70204060816164, -182.15597237595023, -140.42935416242418, -156.55121824593272, -91.21393653917141, -63.90337268947468, -187.41751292492768, -483.0439986076983, -139.27614033265803, -172.27783031210856, -72.22688315854168, -255.2957955446052, -616.766897537076, -139.3342612579984, -64.22846414058625, -290.62069118640187, -106.27976502482383, -56.585114777460575, -139.98446948616152, -135.40660338941865, -113.75665539327088, -104.11214575889088, -184.82665061669172, -323.76769919861204], + "butteraugli": [16.356366923687627, 21.553140790090556, 44.966314994871055, 22.361735831664173, 22.652858221924845, 19.741539289099368, 31.473672310654553, 12.791501154787317, 17.663133729703905, 25.789648365692823, 19.32605234676951, 22.496538323802202, 20.241854990502276, 20.31110018625034, 31.6944803279812, 24.81771266999286, 26.36378161775724, 27.894445069052, 36.33881985735666, 25.29546012926916, 29.455827279726577, 14.033825454026754, 20.516684543215714, 22.498073103351135, 8.774132726607858, 27.44325875671159, 31.92759566732805, 24.23334783830904, 28.191303833952514, 29.016090052131812, 27.608074844055334], + "dssim": [0.3041119967148683, 0.30089572353392013, 0.46213442511302755, 0.15133303862794972, 0.33659803069211114, 0.2084251320185433, 0.22380661373762928, 0.08458849434934307, 0.40403350610541733, 0.22338736248573682, 0.3923013477398899, 0.25001659285042677, 0.15376068351749933, 0.2565859910660393, 0.35827194327687883, 0.20660377592867413, 0.23629426742915904, 0.14338086047813592, 0.3123983950857423, 0.37264336825442956, 0.22558347553419122, 0.1496162811469796, 0.2719713410724164, 0.2388798342077489, 0.09603686903941888, 0.26385752276518215, 0.21796494718092646, 0.28577792383208467, 0.2099303630082841, 0.3013737485936018, 0.3517318069004667] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L34@4 C11@3", + "tune": "l1=34:4 c=11:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.986582490535203, 7.379067513239163, 25.801667218436066, 7.869430165155298, 12.288395701913082, 8.007385771210602, 12.052188554000848, 3.4059437666667054, 9.903360224523748, 9.073162001385072, 9.874155331586325, 8.631300912820375, 3.8078117464969248, 10.710753540881266, 16.503961680360295, 9.258900256009321, 10.328572483412584, 8.17523477267403, 14.88038744788181, 14.329392355689729, 9.188456776704298, 4.00642750705298, 11.232793833589529, 11.646302652577695, 2.5207516259663487, 10.621269862030665, 10.889546030226168, 9.739463384654837, 6.280134475095547, 8.32304414938683, 12.78594086610384], + "ssimulacra2": [-112.17283232004749, -133.48286750358056, -1202.0897635465371, -76.73176607888718, -220.4713115989075, -104.3105480607166, -205.28112134781134, -61.64324188167231, -175.60139112757656, -126.3813067137119, -155.9121029637041, -91.21393653917141, -63.86729522723013, -194.63408597937268, -471.34195480337337, -136.41190453370524, -160.43386838870975, -71.45255999588358, -250.609362434765, -616.2631036570707, -135.89594564214946, -64.22908410798314, -294.09237635080797, -104.68821543242683, -56.56562139275283, -135.95657298573184, -134.7333358368635, -111.15987684399246, -100.62294042727856, -183.70811606589797, -321.5948329000468], + "butteraugli": [15.397157478659736, 21.288563184202104, 44.95999222235707, 22.169895028374242, 22.628332567713745, 19.720172495736715, 31.341806318002913, 12.913049232461296, 17.631463557016108, 25.705874286343448, 19.341118866037736, 22.496538323802202, 20.44586155246463, 20.743593721813145, 31.645546150867037, 24.743520602272923, 25.61219765967286, 27.141359312340487, 35.13497918923023, 25.30430686766726, 28.906397445092384, 14.000789287928496, 20.42125851289153, 22.657471276350496, 8.783021210895226, 26.99417369089956, 32.13292776949532, 24.1261595736736, 27.339248561600723, 28.92881486448734, 27.59863373860782], + "dssim": [0.30441100865582504, 0.30112978497435183, 0.4622186245349689, 0.1518004759276687, 0.33676772098198005, 0.20874237768651066, 0.22552920645915214, 0.0845100282570867, 0.4040918847503378, 0.21880736169270948, 0.392341344061946, 0.25001659285042677, 0.1539501558479815, 0.25699060124863515, 0.3574162901542225, 0.20687281045504063, 0.23585741112387137, 0.14553172911793433, 0.3129555161804495, 0.37230915093928796, 0.22533725992007442, 0.14984134650855657, 0.2717568871969954, 0.23848754002274314, 0.09586123881251546, 0.26331392184425517, 0.21610520502451352, 0.28610080409770977, 0.2095900765748065, 0.302369010845151, 0.35131573270820704] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L36@4 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=36:4 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [6.981817777027642, 7.2971637390759545, 25.781763320322494, 7.910984525540144, 12.295189497553126, 8.163158650996968, 12.020251046986836, 3.407134549867999, 9.86710447688309, 9.124171326480882, 9.825656243774015, 8.631300912820375, 3.808104298114456, 10.760512207674187, 16.56880804993253, 9.487766026093206, 10.32473290135076, 8.020881539572995, 15.01249230910034, 14.314717457667909, 9.2625941053103, 3.9843798872135694, 11.264204026276284, 11.800738521397507, 2.512399135119891, 10.546593864306818, 10.903240270096624, 9.736638796700671, 6.270912866908934, 8.3399601377447, 12.8032223563925], + "ssimulacra2": [-111.83587633749738, -126.49974478248157, -1200.6427000762087, -76.33987311191709, -213.86213458595319, -102.21306757884847, -193.15429785551663, -61.643492160435244, -172.0187162030262, -125.26523496675611, -151.49605501966604, -91.21393653917141, -63.90522964750119, -191.18406652199315, -448.8188483552526, -139.0809573257542, -164.7545635944868, -71.4028131027392, -240.50433836180127, -603.3120572585302, -136.39988355363067, -64.22900759467157, -295.33387223484567, -102.67615964538186, -56.612098585875145, -132.37047108347923, -134.16046678107435, -106.15002548169056, -98.80960598043899, -183.83401192695663, -301.6122315097062], + "butteraugli": [15.40008546050566, 21.056149024766334, 44.944999040647836, 22.098617674714603, 22.403490496084686, 19.587719803995157, 31.49000805133352, 12.872310036957515, 17.634775021607798, 25.09551053581846, 19.345494981483736, 22.496538323802202, 20.62246986688547, 20.777156109423398, 31.3268819216471, 24.909960321429704, 25.423928425730708, 27.219852289378224, 34.60864134339996, 25.30520212769061, 28.86020074628564, 13.947074966148874, 20.317311717468616, 22.55672890474152, 8.798111113581795, 26.78401823287545, 31.776626794285832, 24.15525269238199, 27.266637847234403, 28.393489573488523, 27.285535079366543], + "dssim": [0.3044348563998567, 0.30039211034857705, 0.46211531754203344, 0.15282481138152848, 0.33719236834873667, 0.2117155827833923, 0.22619256079069944, 0.08449215030119994, 0.40366258908052377, 0.2251541845046205, 0.3925297725996608, 0.25001659285042677, 0.15403904651690414, 0.2571269055466231, 0.35664315424579796, 0.20651596418644508, 0.23686922124268095, 0.14716908153847247, 0.3132226903332248, 0.3723442107447831, 0.2270252134549553, 0.14998701077410342, 0.2733882056070789, 0.2370088838044731, 0.0955028887356783, 0.26331185118446876, 0.21538295676155256, 0.2854713532429669, 0.20958559071142524, 0.3029001996967583, 0.34968814994631314] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L38@4 C8@3", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.996425060496346, 7.298200252774316, 25.76329743154734, 8.047612391144856, 12.159081360295822, 8.23915695299471, 11.916231483181775, 3.4085698055566183, 9.875983147080397, 9.054046491849183, 9.824724994439002, 8.70739218705149, 3.958703036211039, 11.052679174613582, 16.599869874703465, 9.477853497262661, 10.301233492142147, 8.110295528698208, 15.087781771102511, 14.293559686007278, 9.164581688975371, 3.985195047934463, 11.493696383812315, 11.78819114144052, 2.535109229418538, 10.505314890911576, 10.932691478903692, 9.70554850879702, 6.271361098490049, 8.273721106856822, 12.900781988243288], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.68543860625732, -125.7146549588866, -1198.417928712568, -75.83196447771886, -204.77717483145466, -98.99654575652082, -184.52430840128318, -61.6659241517043, -169.7820337926147, -128.86461781933744, -151.2037906512777, -91.34977027263429, -63.896202223260275, -185.91717356131954, -450.26829302474573, -138.22988145275673, -162.23626233140158, -73.06780409654806, -244.84088828771598, -600.1981409676946, -127.14610110916826, -64.22638565611697, -291.44141594410377, -103.46666572318512, -56.582941435637224, -132.0401668652494, -134.40632152141148, -104.45625385487844, -98.50427520867561, -176.91944650897364, -289.87844634220147], + "butteraugli": [15.357488513564666, 20.794753616740437, 44.92718718046581, 21.929204432519388, 22.23627775745287, 19.57180628978052, 31.091598287011294, 12.949908242287991, 17.69670915230667, 25.18507705483887, 19.28194707918075, 22.50936206920179, 20.70598099129376, 20.57543326712241, 31.32645083039377, 24.831952237266986, 25.53700090362085, 27.444719590855602, 33.61110347225739, 25.301770738463063, 28.670475784960047, 13.953035290347527, 20.46329665624557, 22.379538702152, 8.806408559194267, 27.112014496579516, 31.42006268370255, 24.038660265754412, 26.988994452871626, 27.51349085619135, 27.313368337228116], + "dssim": [0.3044539554861512, 0.30043686115313917, 0.4620540631205221, 0.1531804527680854, 0.3368474436676956, 0.20926834872911765, 0.22642928863223538, 0.08447356324143768, 0.4041113756222053, 0.22470761691995228, 0.3925000437025395, 0.24983830341064756, 0.15402921742746378, 0.25751511545824946, 0.3568057392834807, 0.20806304074278426, 0.23747441172806721, 0.14951910817977715, 0.3155632880619572, 0.371741514831503, 0.22780804006411454, 0.14983900784350562, 0.27404682272372627, 0.23694563576407746, 0.09548172402621341, 0.2636553133452614, 0.21589205708473586, 0.28658999622113357, 0.20974182725246943, 0.30123311134568465, 0.3478203289885242] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L40@4 C7@3", + "tune": "l1=40:4 c=7:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.9343403568885575, 7.2314554176125725, 25.73715756457434, 8.0309661737264, 12.191945782462582, 8.330848655155112, 11.76396762783307, 3.391925105509202, 9.859995265181748, 9.01069923931878, 9.806246675945593, 8.674882961338591, 3.9326114147332487, 11.122069425805, 16.504978778539687, 9.451674379796847, 10.31190997925116, 8.207478345456815, 14.897023171032247, 14.29238466996741, 9.055953941759597, 3.9735139029337736, 12.178230268102846, 11.853643050988707, 2.5333210884928787, 10.458521440936574, 10.997890532453797, 9.706420684722607, 6.232921169583234, 8.217984404470368, 13.037225788413856], + "ssimulacra2": [-109.7106139123508, -122.44029377402569, -1195.346771273182, -74.52142983251747, -203.95703406060085, -97.63558288440564, -177.74922667360795, -61.013585370321266, -165.22082758110514, -122.79371222118411, -150.63973676363403, -89.20609769299051, -63.69257221431218, -187.44651911532162, -424.7169088672806, -137.9637136609844, -162.46840316333675, -74.54256846844473, -213.15967157053586, -600.6596787611184, -120.17903034263975, -64.22666120484911, -292.17736348789435, -104.88370968999715, -56.5754464560556, -130.3721020636851, -131.24927932523647, -103.27438941996292, -97.99207153857009, -172.71187300498298, -288.2997592570979], + "butteraugli": [15.142277118069986, 20.644881923769564, 44.9089235435739, 21.899006798528095, 22.167506484103374, 19.38683235254852, 30.749754314376418, 12.817339188342745, 17.635319977785155, 25.133408906063906, 19.23079279656106, 22.71727914976816, 20.110457661721796, 20.757571888791688, 30.767589024577457, 24.821070120347873, 25.772306204266926, 27.442178135110467, 33.394982128708875, 25.310451046109886, 27.505862472809753, 13.969529824176982, 19.825284116531154, 22.274068454463606, 8.826582472130863, 27.045366551319603, 31.500851540356248, 23.956614498939715, 27.011142190797006, 27.485770340242734, 26.986589634287515], + "dssim": [0.30411867828614214, 0.30038163205575796, 0.4619940857870949, 0.15350994561864706, 0.3364600244951834, 0.21211960307274508, 0.22709364783002695, 0.08436881786145206, 0.40392635196705134, 0.22416179091012634, 0.39244982822143015, 0.2479479555113318, 0.15446427781716077, 0.257939108337778, 0.3561886165535971, 0.20903526459168892, 0.23790840169573224, 0.1495204998717854, 0.3138252484015369, 0.37175528658915236, 0.22884590388812515, 0.14976106701270986, 0.2785030914989961, 0.23710327095737282, 0.0957314333528479, 0.26357424595702295, 0.21550072330940911, 0.2874816777692206, 0.2101308833865248, 0.3013215294766295, 0.3474265072386891] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L28@4 C11@4", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=11:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.839790875282072, 7.481006486068306, 25.900417208700258, 7.640396655663476, 11.872486702413042, 7.900976936646517, 12.046890543562688, 3.044531638990326, 9.94665872699769, 9.031513759734485, 9.976311946620678, 8.413416320401348, 3.7028092059252584, 10.279699136021032, 16.486575882641233, 9.355021176371798, 10.438178854734485, 7.573597332169382, 14.83750943983483, 14.254266940481806, 9.27233485073653, 3.9574894667872704, 10.948551763331553, 11.01964536143807, 2.3538897776872454, 10.715650016670166, 10.649313863300117, 9.57657355445771, 6.402752124416206, 8.492257876069713, 12.36472348585983], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.68002993581592, -139.94339949027983, -1211.6236334109071, -83.46792377629299, -225.32452396265046, -113.53315252028946, -227.3893913678802, -61.614676261462165, -187.8718591288374, -144.20224148341535, -170.03003712339472, -89.81761051427395, -63.93602828125583, -190.97692517844968, -525.1343971441945, -145.75934616150914, -165.97828753098833, -72.80205833108556, -272.0359712814901, -619.6863426705775, -149.04475350935758, -64.22940033720704, -310.0287060219673, -121.18459982223641, -56.428311548448335, -145.30742746044706, -155.6454978607182, -130.83867275193572, -109.48451249830046, -205.77137825831807, -367.218819989348], + "butteraugli": [16.51983428433932, 21.675262705463734, 45.02314823340483, 22.497914051834105, 22.55945105079452, 19.68604569517815, 32.0589979062883, 12.888306025549028, 17.71875976857901, 26.125664403561796, 19.514099174838567, 22.276123022024958, 20.034946002450308, 20.234904386561563, 31.85294457795818, 25.079957938257973, 26.579719431881827, 28.33233229194055, 36.536726342559966, 25.33011288962148, 30.21841169858749, 14.180380769120026, 20.91927677606247, 22.209308826639333, 8.819913544233605, 27.988106333523366, 32.62581668413446, 24.80403356027752, 27.794566157967832, 30.62786374406092, 28.076852634878502], + "dssim": [0.3041644129177372, 0.30109736029430423, 0.4625891155803296, 0.15152963977948192, 0.33642146694146735, 0.21142746005302943, 0.22262529929239389, 0.08432228118928492, 0.4040385391107583, 0.21963172650117402, 0.39266715891008963, 0.24652570933155976, 0.15336796260027147, 0.25635106996785706, 0.3581924846041282, 0.20619825995075086, 0.23399524047921472, 0.14032993714602776, 0.3138359570687067, 0.37145052745223234, 0.2249783686704896, 0.14965213126084526, 0.27316624745731166, 0.23711258054272905, 0.09525451400827611, 0.2635387361376126, 0.21901946459243854, 0.2875286986224611, 0.21025210085622376, 0.3028671046756315, 0.3529444325643465] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L30@4 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=30:4 c=10:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.835669754985368, 7.48201525565057, 25.85298843579867, 7.623093365125532, 11.871647119535686, 7.973498670742172, 11.87303377607757, 3.033370518635586, 9.934514056245447, 9.029752192041272, 9.940744833550268, 8.426468941234763, 3.6903404146501897, 10.349276004555138, 16.527572258121214, 9.541719711966442, 10.413353951750842, 7.606731196827305, 14.867647951637851, 14.248134820700109, 9.284485760352725, 3.9713829514454724, 10.953744309252398, 11.07585459561339, 2.356640434116026, 10.68251555237073, 10.462369221232635, 9.421306099512321, 6.345807755561372, 8.397799779988095, 12.210003259997174], + "ssimulacra2": [-112.75237032910962, -141.00180529543132, -1205.9967989368138, -81.03386887379881, -225.33438574079247, -107.81190442906748, -209.8570048945714, -61.56655730613667, -184.68463645241837, -141.87106855626018, -165.94974423035768, -90.30341015704357, -63.831278816591976, -191.55730250546037, -520.0440629186634, -148.20549120268407, -170.81663370987894, -73.11594096162969, -262.38782249202245, -616.8772374653894, -147.77687951089501, -64.2295802722827, -303.0063201930164, -109.7517108398535, -56.43848517196102, -142.95996762507303, -138.65077627646914, -119.044214416898, -104.22987650098034, -194.42209829127825, -328.3280535450632], + "butteraugli": [16.445543355595422, 21.46617339939561, 44.979738494468144, 22.485047395411087, 22.692154786965357, 19.71572594096953, 31.55569660023676, 12.762388145797635, 17.66394853372018, 26.371499765988705, 19.521249090410368, 22.218622941368352, 20.020559775958116, 20.355551975659285, 31.691488691323574, 25.12089069593277, 26.249049114688663, 27.829324872090567, 36.21392207372943, 25.34827531217594, 29.75128053367165, 14.021765245952446, 20.806968127787094, 22.40311484811149, 8.821282957673466, 27.72455550158627, 32.17123438638952, 24.39595635454499, 27.519629004108594, 29.81929418748292, 27.57944150589732], + "dssim": [0.3041547639824731, 0.30103189646017314, 0.4623051108426877, 0.15200940909637, 0.336577639314515, 0.20764292302865744, 0.22276344730937564, 0.08447057675655673, 0.4040342574516836, 0.22082511025962404, 0.3923877900305639, 0.24674921285794238, 0.15346140961893567, 0.2564725759464046, 0.3585380121297266, 0.2062303519139328, 0.23548270187780956, 0.14365452795099154, 0.311499262394179, 0.37139094488790025, 0.2258001069840932, 0.1499011670611738, 0.27316178422534354, 0.2370548419912717, 0.09513332862842055, 0.26336000954994154, 0.21569289927821944, 0.2865605763193412, 0.20966610568672506, 0.3024765210698942, 0.35151479977601974] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L32@4 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.82989856424285, 7.456359815119465, 25.817800831937724, 7.6278750948411025, 11.855474353778417, 7.962377654190808, 11.889429337240067, 3.068066934614897, 9.917373872093636, 9.138122437815694, 9.872053338227763, 8.43021403381573, 3.6953454678522073, 10.386193562430476, 16.47467510325034, 9.525118289881291, 10.39573083169537, 7.541989484885673, 15.004007173890612, 14.244446295773216, 9.206995876395439, 3.9088014324525084, 10.93124962136713, 11.268810955658251, 2.3596214532978945, 10.657529149821176, 10.453528625442452, 9.39269816195458, 6.315270789832925, 8.3393139272524, 12.264225749763755], + "ssimulacra2": [-112.98404104735226, -138.54017474921176, -1203.2168975370464, -79.19078172245383, -219.0488587539702, -105.93950735175247, -207.82896817721803, -61.59563207326673, -182.15597237595023, -143.52097301812304, -156.55121824593272, -90.74183118669865, -63.87928652572873, -188.0608642765098, -495.0125854401415, -142.32322739361197, -172.67941646611564, -72.11046936989302, -259.95655001778607, -615.3288635059903, -139.48536599466075, -64.22873915779488, -292.575202079039, -110.0123838338427, -56.42866770402205, -139.98446948616152, -135.80441676461746, -111.26192978833657, -104.11214575889088, -184.82665061669172, -321.4881654092935], + "butteraugli": [16.356159553273358, 21.553140790090556, 44.966314994871055, 22.350509119591262, 22.694245274708077, 19.742083578376594, 31.466323760558428, 12.720489987385562, 17.663133729703905, 25.93187885355212, 19.32605234676951, 22.640903596856518, 20.138394740489282, 20.354134884480192, 31.67354482047287, 24.856876536134717, 26.35826108229844, 27.94177510787033, 36.38839698573182, 25.305549976288393, 29.475311599190267, 14.055833740860516, 20.50913699978012, 22.495251343326586, 8.833721442849708, 27.44325875671159, 31.94701907181559, 24.05154464352064, 28.191303833952514, 29.016090052131812, 27.36769939642373], + "dssim": [0.3040463170203338, 0.30089572353392013, 0.46213442511302755, 0.15195767733504306, 0.3364119945310627, 0.2085104210195155, 0.22357456507506618, 0.08442045157207262, 0.40403350610541733, 0.2242272278678073, 0.3923013477398899, 0.24734399494403414, 0.15365059251184454, 0.25675766755494045, 0.3579211336807905, 0.20663651288122992, 0.23618838790303587, 0.14398632851591547, 0.3119226594287333, 0.3712943607876621, 0.22555361118473077, 0.14955444029994425, 0.27336699999793357, 0.23639376973031334, 0.09509569162367731, 0.26385752276518215, 0.21465497550911117, 0.2843307397309155, 0.2099303630082841, 0.3013737485936018, 0.35054851710861235] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L34@4 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=34:4 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.778490324381808, 7.379067513239163, 25.801667218436066, 7.736053117905771, 11.884352652181791, 8.084943761176758, 11.86360520662666, 3.0890553017013183, 9.903360224523748, 8.975762992656465, 9.874155331586325, 8.51040715384, 3.873438214951555, 10.758576572685646, 16.449664408017615, 9.519408412193705, 10.2501890863772, 7.577384805371068, 15.060907136833118, 14.229205396739507, 9.208805299490985, 3.9158704762498595, 11.284587794514842, 11.29636071300732, 2.3898980457695864, 10.621269862030665, 10.433135033303511, 9.330288143060798, 6.280134475095547, 8.32304414938683, 12.377851922023856], + "ssimulacra2": [-111.52380745438248, -133.48286750358056, -1202.0897635465371, -77.3080074256072, -218.75224758252062, -106.06493551308478, -203.39982380199973, -61.56465437318971, -175.60139112757656, -132.816180323705, -155.9121029637041, -90.88143370001444, -63.86587609279374, -195.19066375518594, -485.1469571264057, -139.81586733462794, -160.82995628246556, -71.78233485096487, -254.29425908548177, -616.35151966722, -136.28356174218465, -64.2290815686367, -299.65833324489313, -107.71765441468133, -56.488936905917285, -135.95657298573184, -134.43097603993905, -108.9394269822925, -100.62294042727856, -183.70811606589797, -319.2549464079765], + "butteraugli": [15.395267331276202, 21.288563184202104, 44.95999222235707, 22.18102356135289, 22.642784484169056, 19.726362252398108, 31.35148765652041, 12.848999673381016, 17.631463557016108, 25.85358382025376, 19.341118866037736, 22.68073168170128, 20.41848099936604, 20.808094605074505, 31.557283523591014, 24.776202144148346, 25.642775437040484, 27.2578307114927, 35.07953078226607, 25.3226443260324, 28.916621189617445, 14.017618685720976, 20.602801677176178, 22.446276424571725, 8.847903467347544, 26.99417369089956, 32.040665772451426, 23.94242893161289, 27.339248561600723, 28.92881486448734, 27.31143085775969], + "dssim": [0.3043539175297172, 0.30112978497435183, 0.4622186245349689, 0.15241937462623195, 0.33661060892060096, 0.20813026528890782, 0.22536575290341643, 0.08438038253652463, 0.4040918847503378, 0.22181800937755258, 0.392341344061946, 0.24727463999592625, 0.15389955436307973, 0.2572525051955685, 0.3572990779252818, 0.20698587512587735, 0.23569134781621476, 0.14716549980512394, 0.31199717809659777, 0.37101516108651356, 0.22539618458141497, 0.14977541303728187, 0.27448290005449494, 0.2361339787770828, 0.09485490986578693, 0.26331392184425517, 0.21356674913252083, 0.2839143320050739, 0.2095900765748065, 0.302369010845151, 0.350952354582675] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L36@4 C7@4", + "tune": "l1=36:4 c=7:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.778600976443629, 7.2971637390759545, 25.781763320322494, 7.813210348919053, 11.948241615102246, 8.191051087432427, 11.743347978184586, 3.0830215756100166, 9.86710447688309, 9.026084207845553, 9.825656243774015, 8.50997961604931, 3.8754108462105417, 10.843657534984864, 16.372310066834366, 9.53142352852054, 10.285833558547942, 7.6254607868871345, 14.96538142238082, 14.211486721749532, 9.220796884197119, 3.898412732571864, 12.142792019640309, 11.35351854685111, 2.3958608178410143, 10.546593864306818, 10.561766124142215, 9.332544913301827, 6.270912866908934, 8.3399601377447, 12.472903531907875], + "ssimulacra2": [-111.43004294787772, -126.49974478248157, -1200.6427000762087, -76.55418033176048, -213.17017487133865, -105.15544608729277, -192.15884165882267, -61.54789758999161, -172.0187162030262, -130.7118409348376, -151.49605501966604, -90.92551814503597, -63.922218263502685, -192.0107478342124, -451.32755075054945, -139.35325743359127, -164.41656044382802, -71.63167194478817, -241.70667844958825, -603.2348205256965, -136.2825709598547, -64.22877231727568, -318.4990178916871, -104.81771592924594, -56.49175086561553, -132.37047108347923, -134.51749821161226, -104.3669390166047, -98.80960598043899, -183.83401192695663, -297.52510058557095], + "butteraugli": [15.415802829475007, 21.056149024766334, 44.944999040647836, 22.11162076425804, 22.453142599021888, 19.58161404292906, 31.48454553767175, 12.857333414118164, 17.634775021607798, 25.19584137891407, 19.345494981483736, 22.683839898442855, 20.521655922029122, 20.82104503512177, 31.31009473741055, 24.899160923440846, 25.445501635890064, 27.21369286431539, 34.61409809279008, 25.325857716921035, 28.841937836954873, 13.942170716554552, 20.528713722184055, 22.309463664977603, 8.84414693875958, 26.78401823287545, 31.687860203497774, 23.963725459817812, 27.266637847234403, 28.393489573488523, 27.005632221907472], + "dssim": [0.30440078436445817, 0.30039211034857705, 0.46211531754203344, 0.1530678668140184, 0.33707220513110503, 0.21291596550229408, 0.2259883985988645, 0.08441734370109694, 0.40366258908052377, 0.2244516748490597, 0.3925297725996608, 0.24720634544902287, 0.15402828246320138, 0.2573333005961683, 0.35653619945608084, 0.20657818268363703, 0.23680040210100356, 0.14718728519948754, 0.3123978440756001, 0.3708759173899797, 0.22688038262752436, 0.1497034481425552, 0.28057168561981827, 0.23576993875861973, 0.094921774672804, 0.26331185118446876, 0.2142743784122012, 0.2850553218407538, 0.20958559071142524, 0.3029001996967583, 0.348817633999998] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L38@3 C14@3", + "tune": "l1=38:3 c=14:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.1760605374345605, 8.427709159406474, 25.785446868117027, 8.576617981684327, 12.897636335041298, 8.874985070702095, 12.57328896753866, 3.9910210640881925, 10.861980192301745, 9.406315576913693, 10.60559040428319, 10.170565519222153, 4.12894724250091, 11.182445940091633, 16.68254829611819, 10.158651515907756, 12.322186730962477, 9.275668379713116, 15.89741160702824, 14.383557213232942, 10.906436857108334, 4.825330323355909, 11.596801134353555, 11.926614750612325, 2.6995288342425656, 11.60172670121174, 12.533341544063608, 9.787095608539861, 8.736171274089077, 9.556139890625182, 13.286674972494577], + "ssimulacra2": [-122.194105141737, -197.00672147072333, -1200.8502331348263, -91.46964591958732, -298.1131949504859, -147.3635743334948, -222.1152860979493, -63.39759913631781, -214.55093901005762, -162.07391472504844, -190.49954998634303, -137.8608531924472, -64.22911718415432, -244.60664102214025, -444.6276532512461, -190.73940320021774, -271.775438901572, -126.533184876174, -304.194037113374, -601.8399738250346, -204.8014285363888, -64.45992852969806, -358.23039182629896, -121.84970932048873, -59.72651307879113, -181.10385226065176, -226.78504126543055, -130.83583157977318, -198.3208442607234, -246.45547428843366, -339.87045600066034], + "butteraugli": [16.591766540912918, 23.022606642828304, 44.968582988364574, 24.076068712543602, 28.62602434498598, 25.930617087252795, 33.669450005505276, 14.136920123497058, 20.40355537019845, 25.21812465327154, 21.179269748517555, 29.925684556814726, 18.776430895425946, 23.67363334246973, 32.98161833103928, 28.74914680439544, 33.5821148559028, 30.224849367634192, 40.63292660422625, 25.511209047389602, 33.74302121809709, 16.657796072175223, 21.981040743597436, 22.729054119271208, 9.543288142778918, 41.92473603380454, 38.87402150960845, 24.809112817331748, 61.319833117724905, 30.164254266433165, 29.67370927156831], + "dssim": [0.30428389173343173, 0.30762520622599143, 0.46222138511281713, 0.16146684664921823, 0.3399208227501429, 0.2460543933665768, 0.2349489808977669, 0.08553368877454409, 0.4063530274945119, 0.2589820733530165, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27081289657236773, 0.15537819110730422, 0.25909933613892, 0.3588495610964849, 0.21212259619046664, 0.25651266409915296, 0.17935742677437128, 0.3265112570005386, 0.3734000253493779, 0.24922119131144438, 0.15318537742077115, 0.2772310283100282, 0.24312743567312806, 0.10217077242955708, 0.2732363355452264, 0.24035986926158337, 0.28307042094665535, 0.22765892998504128, 0.32701235235122805, 0.35265160601744394] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L40@3 C13@3", + "tune": "l1=40:3 c=13:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.193606023803729, 8.493908407403149, 25.7654600759022, 8.544592320107814, 12.894061820263417, 8.907784011393456, 12.513288126160466, 3.947400358975013, 10.861980192301745, 9.38440179549964, 10.60559040428319, 10.170565519222153, 4.082501123372035, 11.235664083998683, 16.636030147752006, 10.170898976154854, 12.358756892661852, 9.35069173200168, 15.772583950718309, 14.385980136225454, 10.905488105714685, 4.825330323355909, 11.852745525601328, 12.121433592252174, 2.692909315565836, 11.60172670121174, 12.609864710990845, 9.937476802349247, 8.736171274089077, 9.53519699962388, 13.285920986348607], + "ssimulacra2": [-121.04895835482776, -197.63866188302313, -1198.7099856015086, -90.32123605103828, -297.59688785498304, -143.1058658912034, -213.76875904256696, -63.30885108849063, -214.55093901005762, -157.28020862331857, -190.49954998634303, -137.8608531924472, -64.22806549335246, -245.90610590986887, -426.43305379421486, -190.75654497278856, -273.689788844855, -129.02268396812661, -283.9965344172807, -600.6350589763388, -198.6965929596263, -64.45992852969806, -355.5133300851646, -124.85875838687366, -59.73960868995843, -181.10385226065176, -227.49198494455896, -128.88780661701574, -198.3208442607234, -247.58683559519142, -339.9972857707468], + "butteraugli": [16.344326024346355, 22.813661206953594, 44.968309472581836, 24.052693591626607, 28.6131244096707, 26.10149995489772, 33.46021080794594, 14.111204223163824, 20.40355537019845, 25.18730878823415, 21.179269748517555, 29.925684556814726, 18.76066089421052, 23.663971907241272, 32.917165507723716, 28.747992115239963, 33.531290945073316, 30.250154104984578, 39.32536539088671, 25.52252363521636, 33.70511912996874, 16.657796072175223, 22.004274615108216, 22.7772844885059, 9.551258534661594, 41.92473603380454, 38.86185672233888, 25.134244953934417, 61.319833117724905, 30.483287678027825, 29.597993472467394], + "dssim": [0.3040933997946035, 0.307850636818792, 0.4622455413095273, 0.16225828557135968, 0.3399067965981687, 0.24842005297741782, 0.23504464123395535, 0.08576363881252796, 0.4063530274945119, 0.2620196973636627, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27081289657236773, 0.15565097087753382, 0.2591310776382726, 0.35837250841431967, 0.2121160799763388, 0.25651460630521505, 0.1796169530143324, 0.3248696885537953, 0.3733901536446933, 0.25469095438859746, 0.15318537742077115, 0.28245072001939076, 0.24371443163648066, 0.10189975558903508, 0.2732363355452264, 0.24054163719293054, 0.28204180845103577, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3285343478436422, 0.35206020945989747] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L42@3 C12@3", + "tune": "l1=42:3 c=12:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.185639965900172, 8.493908407403149, 25.683777493642662, 8.574611807328198, 12.927786575574144, 8.915169221019001, 12.534083077560856, 3.9389600265665714, 10.853025397570468, 9.405113638193388, 10.60559040428319, 10.161590958195651, 4.103671170672886, 11.264453876882698, 16.72386426088992, 10.261462749630846, 12.361419303476387, 9.366991714046458, 15.887205950739785, 14.37450018596188, 10.920518557586224, 4.825330323355909, 11.869306724122538, 12.133757844437525, 2.681033690660618, 11.608408641673053, 12.61131078019617, 10.019061484599176, 8.736171274089077, 9.46101070889653, 13.304197553905675], + "ssimulacra2": [-121.13556799337519, -197.63866188302313, -1187.3172638111027, -89.34904182776569, -299.51323933799705, -141.5020159317142, -208.96027380718039, -63.30862611332523, -212.430047087684, -158.1007204991481, -190.49954998634303, -137.96303396346505, -64.22836913149564, -246.9434448914708, -418.35782727661797, -203.0020784497919, -273.7001071234838, -140.43292390537727, -283.8523573325728, -596.7187989286749, -198.8233477791366, -64.45992852969806, -358.8635401074299, -124.85350478279227, -59.66893294844854, -180.443886560397, -227.64174378216302, -135.47601739371206, -198.3208442607234, -230.80727480165882, -344.1415250879018], + "butteraugli": [16.36640211682756, 22.813661206953594, 44.87668103458293, 23.80218378969582, 28.237477276843965, 27.606003091119472, 33.6420081047913, 14.103957425906176, 20.622104606355038, 25.15611478054541, 21.179269748517555, 29.923797025887353, 18.729510364276535, 23.602757497670893, 32.283500454648355, 27.833424173632157, 33.539815086745996, 30.565992127343605, 38.621139634811364, 25.55120170943337, 33.70746556348198, 16.657796072175223, 22.182864126840954, 22.79002444519152, 9.520700128681804, 37.51247958593316, 38.852866604262665, 24.63351567215801, 61.319833117724905, 30.483641569777745, 29.744960625324243], + "dssim": [0.30410025625728365, 0.307850636818792, 0.462034755335745, 0.1630822961254535, 0.3399882646617104, 0.24966952370910178, 0.2356776709035302, 0.08572505109711281, 0.40576075604782774, 0.262589970180667, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27083551850377496, 0.15572056488383135, 0.25923270298669754, 0.3579169102271491, 0.2165774790589603, 0.256477568464729, 0.183594257644492, 0.3249553310708072, 0.3734063688972943, 0.2546864424364813, 0.15318537742077115, 0.2820165321090251, 0.24363017183403574, 0.10229120678040471, 0.2743284455853573, 0.2402753669636965, 0.28141854194307503, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3248940100539226, 0.3523969478586152] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L44@3 C11@3", + "tune": "l1=44:3 c=11:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.188494744120506, 8.456962181079847, 25.65315582887491, 8.623196931501315, 13.032439545430544, 8.939049907810888, 12.542370994172508, 3.9389600265665714, 10.845396930949184, 9.411522252216626, 10.60559040428319, 10.161590958195651, 4.1280630095176125, 11.298622533324119, 16.739870622673465, 10.28304267176457, 12.373825517079846, 9.4641965362726, 15.935450077277356, 14.34559397659649, 10.921073541491662, 4.831006349594759, 11.876261681893205, 12.284701971605438, 2.6768662139565067, 11.608408641673053, 12.695149537253696, 9.990849245874296, 8.736171274089077, 9.46101070889653, 13.302269532313149], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.27844998939929, -188.09626820328822, -1182.4032535904435, -89.31125898794934, -299.93053847687173, -135.5287026544235, -209.00813149385112, -63.30862611332523, -210.2180678511295, -154.94342545992419, -190.49954998634303, -137.96303396346505, -64.22931473668385, -248.06053581137212, -410.766298743985, -203.19052497166632, -274.129935065797, -140.84789283532268, -287.1807249224208, -578.8820420886957, -198.76237087428518, -64.48077196116716, -359.4406304549526, -126.28272148853583, -59.690882133975975, -180.443886560397, -228.3997123895179, -125.8404077686908, -198.3208442607234, -230.80727480165882, -333.08167101403615], + "butteraugli": [16.249919068705584, 23.21671674073369, 44.845270098261345, 23.80174812385174, 28.127461352251675, 27.44005218463468, 33.64359635216095, 14.103957425906176, 20.592127539093966, 24.85019172503554, 21.179269748517555, 29.923797025887353, 18.778429886545233, 23.665547179565937, 32.685153326379904, 27.832895785288525, 33.54891953357539, 30.61952079149933, 38.08331442822009, 25.573584937594458, 33.69942400935914, 16.667106338512394, 22.286060595196506, 22.917940887144187, 9.520326282455684, 37.51247958593316, 38.84857339636909, 24.82160833336161, 61.319833117724905, 30.483641569777745, 29.372817077491533], + "dssim": [0.3041950891498495, 0.30760842817980805, 0.4618968615114837, 0.1635714532079398, 0.3400141930453196, 0.25018112454933905, 0.23573350224186312, 0.08572505109711281, 0.4057385371135515, 0.26535492447837816, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27083551850377496, 0.1562425604265006, 0.2592916276110263, 0.3580257808723599, 0.21651332668291096, 0.2564645865632852, 0.18380478777189585, 0.3257961314987935, 0.3736808921067263, 0.2546611844003597, 0.1529356971482198, 0.28134749757350497, 0.24366842822140627, 0.1020312734314584, 0.2743284455853573, 0.24051943350053334, 0.28035388113332493, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3248940100539226, 0.35155341512048677] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L46@3 C10@3", + "tune": "l1=46:3 c=10:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.188494744120506, 8.456962181079847, 25.581354209168424, 8.597878719555544, 13.018101250482877, 9.096913798797418, 12.537718829829272, 3.9389600265665714, 10.845396930949184, 9.392908761488744, 10.60559040428319, 10.161590958195651, 4.1280630095176125, 11.367627126603828, 16.762400530645106, 10.512288652851367, 12.3483721245807, 9.426310931745093, 16.000667140300624, 14.339441593768486, 10.974645604164072, 4.825581130427145, 11.887690405470702, 12.294931722723407, 2.6707010520087264, 11.608408641673053, 12.702895991623224, 9.990849245874296, 8.736171274089077, 9.46101070889653, 13.263991496813812], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.27844998939929, -188.09626820328822, -1173.858939011273, -91.50712894981098, -301.0729054661591, -136.0742442831834, -208.63238442962023, -63.30862611332523, -210.2180678511295, -154.99050107685773, -190.49954998634303, -137.96303396346505, -64.22931473668385, -248.04973040015489, -400.3222527301291, -207.32324607243834, -274.77291843453537, -143.16647845772405, -280.9337340846132, -573.3701637773718, -199.58568262979315, -64.48885215464503, -360.36895826817226, -122.53785544525994, -59.72769548626093, -180.443886560397, -227.9127435132836, -125.8404077686908, -198.3208442607234, -230.80727480165882, -325.79768986195455], + "butteraugli": [16.249919068705584, 23.21671674073369, 44.81462663793973, 23.503505912928617, 28.154184901297565, 27.276485613975865, 33.75574048009979, 14.103957425906176, 20.592127539093966, 24.850911049608996, 21.179269748517555, 29.923797025887353, 18.778429886545233, 23.646416528873477, 32.14946084703778, 27.814343827126596, 33.56207491498688, 30.96066279826896, 37.174225355948984, 25.50412957921968, 33.70832565657538, 16.69588161534791, 22.237685028596697, 22.7019144674319, 9.560270628282266, 37.51247958593316, 38.848841405810425, 24.82160833336161, 61.319833117724905, 30.483641569777745, 29.1561519469232], + "dssim": [0.3041950891498495, 0.30760842817980805, 0.46171148037803933, 0.166165360335702, 0.3399183466119613, 0.2496230968140004, 0.23621385046824245, 0.08572505109711281, 0.4057385371135515, 0.2650912043971301, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27083551850377496, 0.1562425604265006, 0.2595745051962953, 0.3578154994995434, 0.21675518476609185, 0.2564445138262721, 0.1854118708608256, 0.3278262527281661, 0.37370271690457396, 0.25474850377382074, 0.15288846726681027, 0.2828781636385772, 0.2438343892048908, 0.10181076851582566, 0.2743284455853573, 0.24040109879857796, 0.28035388113332493, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3248940100539226, 0.3516717404933087] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L48@3 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=48:3 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106, 106], + "ciede2000": [7.184854699667215, 8.473010313449176, 25.54675867518037, 8.673673240858571, 13.045041233647526, 9.1029238094586, 12.572210598678213, 3.9259904580984215, 10.845396930949184, 9.438928860713245, 10.60559040428319, 10.161590958195651, 4.119137727637526, 11.368570470348706, 16.826807762557948, 10.5684254286405, 12.33161627205272, 9.426200667324716, 16.112287490923666, 14.327731335641248, 10.983072330209161, 4.825581130427145, 11.887690405470702, 12.478560039282065, 2.6848298481125794, 11.541661985121639, 12.742295710595936, 10.009847440141387, 8.713896096404234, 9.436483484601588, 13.384814640821306], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.43393668977174, -187.27513292769476, -1169.109656642337, -91.87026716293639, -301.23961396997714, -136.6217155412109, -206.42775398873044, -63.31479331769131, -210.2180678511295, -143.72946235294393, -190.49954998634303, -137.96303396346505, -64.22924962064195, -248.66210475264165, -396.26385024080895, -208.00133483718116, -275.611160412665, -149.33086686489165, -282.7866099956245, -565.3560397752109, -199.525352123792, -64.48885215464503, -360.36895826817226, -125.06034444780823, -59.713882091801736, -174.0858390467697, -228.30176747472473, -121.38794038889941, -187.25500768004974, -225.4256171345702, -319.5010259171328], + "butteraugli": [16.252885718096497, 23.274539679786102, 44.807894584344126, 23.521067736546343, 28.123808189434886, 27.352699881019927, 33.051077839398395, 14.02193055303699, 20.592127539093966, 24.709115333773656, 21.179269748517555, 29.923797025887353, 18.479955444417183, 23.706709572711087, 32.1076333956588, 27.801502692189786, 33.55897672497343, 31.810287222796777, 36.391160663210734, 25.471745189880256, 33.71813964400469, 16.69588161534791, 22.237685028596697, 23.026888637809805, 9.551836455648782, 37.58094641233644, 38.773155764971165, 24.80964776486195, 67.19612004540186, 30.688746334655438, 29.24620044344863], + "dssim": [0.3041848687713202, 0.3074298766066358, 0.46161527888257153, 0.16625334324750057, 0.33992632065553074, 0.2504415865006575, 0.23721403198673585, 0.08566550363682185, 0.4057385371135515, 0.2670563481467888, 0.3946683427031332, 0.27083551850377496, 0.1559707141357613, 0.2596167272659119, 0.35768283660962596, 0.21682575032142165, 0.2565701837586537, 0.18994467900011996, 0.3295872835562007, 0.3735210002182088, 0.2548154537628231, 0.15288846726681027, 0.2828781636385772, 0.24307089035242951, 0.10141610898373488, 0.2759918121925734, 0.2402100844951452, 0.28312763071358693, 0.22979255491887585, 0.3238608288107937, 0.35030717909063314] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L40@3 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=40:3 c=10:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.977666904029081, 8.493908407403149, 25.7654600759022, 8.322395160018244, 12.522797269241936, 8.945764970359642, 12.386099967329207, 3.575374219172715, 10.861980192301745, 9.246783617727315, 10.60559040428319, 10.005739232397692, 3.967745681557117, 10.999500735602824, 16.68233961825604, 10.410942271009485, 12.279896502469752, 8.940379731805207, 15.879302122094822, 14.293752167450544, 10.91134846299523, 4.765063722533833, 11.582357639772855, 11.770182634127625, 2.5144281013108913, 11.60172670121174, 12.305097869507277, 9.603874242517186, 8.736171274089077, 9.53519699962388, 12.6783779376797], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.4947344554347, -197.63866188302313, -1198.7099856015086, -90.8065183724072, -295.12005565083285, -144.16818747104702, -212.1801107863663, -63.236006780775256, -214.55093901005762, -158.50918495844672, -190.49954998634303, -137.3801198367303, -64.22783558196329, -246.8776711183648, -441.99249017132513, -193.85339122222945, -273.36161140233, -127.93255892636128, -288.48966123832497, -599.12510826641, -199.02905448501048, -64.47264304876961, -359.96687470803954, -124.68522427473616, -59.604435438512695, -181.10385226065176, -226.3495915249067, -127.41984018819366, -198.3208442607234, -247.58683559519142, -336.84339900833834], + "butteraugli": [16.351923147251913, 22.813661206953594, 44.968309472581836, 24.092787204531145, 28.659915211877955, 25.888304479387386, 33.45244587914477, 14.003177958748376, 20.40355537019845, 25.14429639720396, 21.179269748517555, 30.163804325475354, 18.669746338641172, 23.660782335358487, 32.913927692124496, 28.738597683900252, 33.58844141494324, 30.293083050659636, 39.45725918359201, 25.51251062756063, 33.67336730176062, 16.621569343738127, 21.937653147251012, 22.463732472411476, 9.589898144428295, 41.92473603380454, 38.65149753983588, 24.946596320973725, 61.319833117724905, 30.483287678027825, 29.121931215345043], + "dssim": [0.30408976580249447, 0.307850636818792, 0.4622455413095273, 0.16272058979832194, 0.33958169793370263, 0.24697070698560225, 0.23545493014696028, 0.08555148258146189, 0.4063530274945119, 0.26146402709540784, 0.3946683427031332, 0.2688029507812201, 0.1557077241136376, 0.25943784292783767, 0.35822169432836615, 0.21235272811750744, 0.25633191874835914, 0.17996270699401556, 0.32345760346870844, 0.372994291518003, 0.25466431379826404, 0.15318285468823678, 0.2806695149104823, 0.24223178980131976, 0.10083176604835192, 0.2732363355452264, 0.24084562421291383, 0.28053874583062965, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3285343478436422, 0.3513094859462277] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L44@3 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=44:3 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105, 105], + "ciede2000": [6.973971389963075, 8.456962181079847, 25.65315582887491, 8.4942542145816, 12.598650194711892, 9.057636647599145, 12.355681856678673, 3.633816350046422, 10.845396930949184, 9.326339749870339, 10.60559040428319, 10.043489666900397, 4.161638632070253, 11.360221574314032, 16.683339733989683, 10.579756371617265, 12.274770085960231, 9.063535324780009, 16.050843359231862, 14.247778776530653, 10.961086027081805, 4.776910573426107, 11.920165758448757, 12.044667726215863, 2.5632505366252296, 11.608408641673053, 12.372598672230922, 9.621983649436958, 8.736171274089077, 9.46101070889653, 12.940242198944915], + "ssimulacra2": [-119.98827479719426, -188.09626820328822, -1182.4032535904435, -90.31518248120295, -298.90761372420354, -138.32371015440611, -207.50829085754964, -63.28262778481144, -210.2180678511295, -162.8003389602294, -190.49954998634303, -137.62378594145676, -64.22933859181083, -248.2371647160776, -423.30468443674283, -207.86172321537936, -274.6639811238641, -141.93277798626636, -294.47873065540045, -578.2044358813534, -199.08510628390195, -64.4721623369087, -366.17883814783625, -129.41221130878432, -59.70931163675775, -180.443886560397, -226.67921066981341, -123.72875318795082, -198.3208442607234, -230.80727480165882, -332.8174911233728], + "butteraugli": [16.253709996269684, 23.21671674073369, 44.845270098261345, 23.844754552210514, 28.60602821038546, 27.372463390968633, 33.64675171647013, 14.029834781944691, 20.592127539093966, 24.791268118393628, 21.179269748517555, 30.16263257830744, 18.69508163392428, 23.86926287807418, 32.45608342438508, 27.796735532781096, 33.588594200313196, 30.749126822311684, 38.10142619672801, 25.574594606371292, 33.66962996711899, 16.622234528971173, 22.203094108005036, 22.524094554275475, 9.602007605520694, 37.51247958593316, 38.634736463985455, 24.736729455489144, 61.319833117724905, 30.483641569777745, 29.07460229621201], + "dssim": [0.3042226320770465, 0.30760842817980805, 0.4618968615114837, 0.16439319624748344, 0.3395960632142245, 0.24947003127471173, 0.23571762682783598, 0.08555672653872098, 0.4057385371135515, 0.2666323208721052, 0.3946683427031332, 0.2687770257868187, 0.15624981681069938, 0.2592885196001079, 0.3579777848795398, 0.21678419039333208, 0.2565455141164211, 0.18428749593894245, 0.32491556665686594, 0.37226569152206224, 0.2547859538907389, 0.15304711334059323, 0.28123606387978295, 0.24143963079734881, 0.1004134550267724, 0.2743284455853573, 0.2401209828461366, 0.2793969034489353, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3248940100539226, 0.3509047041951161] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L46@3 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=46:3 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.973971389963075, 8.456962181079847, 25.581354209168424, 8.527083340314848, 12.598650194711892, 9.057636647599145, 12.283651386899306, 3.633816350046422, 10.845396930949184, 9.326339749870339, 10.60559040428319, 10.043489666900397, 4.161638632070253, 11.360221574314032, 16.62631752489106, 10.579756371617265, 12.274770085960231, 9.078926706869593, 16.099565981369338, 14.241011061957922, 10.961086027081805, 4.776910573426107, 11.920165758448757, 12.012427653829192, 2.5632505366252296, 11.608408641673053, 12.372598672230922, 9.621983649436958, 8.736171274089077, 9.46101070889653, 12.89979634046353], + "ssimulacra2": [-119.98827479719426, -188.09626820328822, -1173.858939011273, -91.84854161368452, -298.90761372420354, -138.32371015440611, -206.91937592144524, -63.28262778481144, -210.2180678511295, -162.8003389602294, -190.49954998634303, -137.62378594145676, -64.22933859181083, -248.2371647160776, -404.6571350399688, -207.86172321537936, -274.6639811238641, -144.34470500859643, -287.88780391049875, -571.8360761902891, -199.08510628390195, -64.4721623369087, -366.17883814783625, -125.33397785995814, -59.70931163675775, -180.443886560397, -226.67921066981341, -123.72875318795082, -198.3208442607234, -230.80727480165882, -325.0901272704124], + "butteraugli": [16.253709996269684, 23.21671674073369, 44.81462663793973, 23.543738311853037, 28.60602821038546, 27.372463390968633, 33.737509038432286, 14.029834781944691, 20.592127539093966, 24.791268118393628, 21.179269748517555, 30.16263257830744, 18.69508163392428, 23.86926287807418, 32.0313834098799, 27.796735532781096, 33.588594200313196, 31.1174579322619, 37.22860657845805, 25.483848832941742, 33.66962996711899, 16.622234528971173, 22.203094108005036, 22.213216339721082, 9.602007605520694, 37.51247958593316, 38.634736463985455, 24.736729455489144, 61.319833117724905, 30.483641569777745, 28.922690536256095], + "dssim": [0.3042226320770465, 0.30760842817980805, 0.46171148037803933, 0.16677953537379325, 0.3395960632142245, 0.24947003127471173, 0.23609902269419508, 0.08555672653872098, 0.4057385371135515, 0.2666323208721052, 0.3946683427031332, 0.2687770257868187, 0.15624981681069938, 0.2592885196001079, 0.3579416907044879, 0.21678419039333208, 0.2565455141164211, 0.1855880226436561, 0.32760744619077764, 0.3722506960662326, 0.2547859538907389, 0.15304711334059323, 0.28123606387978295, 0.24146364862174652, 0.1004134550267724, 0.2743284455853573, 0.2401209828461366, 0.2793969034489353, 0.22765892998504128, 0.3248940100539226, 0.35060027780116587] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.838204011948919, 7.453951149238095, 25.936442060878555, 7.6509909885936285, 11.826480822363104, 8.12615141748936, 12.081026105094894, 2.876928662854907, 9.877878054669864, 9.084124864884718, 9.9428933859377, 7.800284544757563, 3.55008584103457, 10.164507096743312, 16.75912696597293, 9.334573449232558, 10.260464448685456, 7.503126311220218, 14.984942826010485, 14.24235308587455, 9.261937419473188, 3.607147773257744, 10.812648536988199, 11.214742215887687, 2.278538801479341, 10.689375872053363, 10.391225442610422, 9.583769903817277, 6.167856564760884, 8.525121531859435, 12.528219451682357], + "ssimulacra2": [-114.09152762573112, -144.6581883165179, -1215.853628863129, -86.45848241742246, -232.1155675337531, -123.98744140954642, -245.4778366968643, -60.88755805837462, -183.54187937974552, -144.71293216318713, -171.20073235547846, -82.76924182681216, -63.62120960584241, -182.09873742103252, -555.4673853095177, -140.7158176494339, -152.87534039064298, -70.37197591203525, -274.0288630521511, -621.6478024588064, -151.04871061408974, -64.18925457786446, -298.34736083412383, -129.76403310745158, -53.02203899776018, -159.75106245074477, -139.24583182192234, -145.7357717115873, -110.21030752874384, -214.97416650141406, -396.9572256123925], + "butteraugli": [17.212233125132112, 21.777836094535086, 45.00087733367321, 22.913069538635458, 22.60197521456124, 19.66320184042147, 32.4983550887056, 12.55515388889638, 17.264707299462508, 25.878456363605817, 19.22626778469052, 20.52262147093425, 18.899334448861286, 19.364181011888377, 32.08095771313904, 24.865001951411937, 26.334524006959526, 30.9062317422942, 36.58769495802835, 25.295523910193385, 30.638005555683993, 13.798805700196093, 20.89336627306123, 22.32670184517559, 7.399951393039408, 27.94365383666377, 31.954692255311986, 24.401367443436992, 25.69085869362674, 30.005755253608253, 29.16616555102716], + "dssim": [0.30392646784169886, 0.3009004994732122, 0.46305079332625637, 0.1508728832040807, 0.33643911740234544, 0.20675386593754824, 0.22050020299104783, 0.08371212563484476, 0.4038962432872495, 0.2173198290657487, 0.3929722395642649, 0.23363345555153492, 0.15232646047586046, 0.2549091462900187, 0.35892920265385186, 0.20194855792956007, 0.22840818804389257, 0.13201894248116303, 0.31290827270790134, 0.3707170868114261, 0.22220322956264016, 0.14801545797743004, 0.27288168945024494, 0.23635601146216745, 0.08962116812744497, 0.2632653317575516, 0.21313475551929134, 0.2818344321946008, 0.2095149347129342, 0.3059050918822134, 0.35063486754681955] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L29@5 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=29:5 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [7.026819715886269, 7.358097928163211, 25.86366061537169, 7.8889137750262766, 12.242270816394736, 8.142690279743281, 12.050176652837257, 3.234796811726702, 9.824813199457067, 9.23031486696136, 9.863489741758771, 7.986854719057577, 3.6480754567651754, 10.523404103730508, 16.825941039789974, 9.355961416377616, 10.139730396752688, 7.91411971476824, 15.074543211279043, 14.323976068911529, 9.181385665760933, 3.677347811617705, 11.156758806677368, 11.786270710892714, 2.3884042650510007, 10.406392188000886, 10.764083948470843, 9.673392884401391, 6.042497307023491, 8.225855564973832, 12.993005023954685], + "ssimulacra2": [-112.05946987991604, -135.7535557015334, -1207.162146015357, -79.7006526332602, -222.588034918451, -107.25808219073531, -211.61027558591735, -60.49399540826798, -174.41291357244899, -138.6971950189755, -162.0374535303892, -82.2925418705052, -63.54802167906945, -181.30549945549456, -520.1649672373261, -137.35969853790584, -142.97697265041188, -69.34739164918116, -259.06796554344936, -617.95919794122, -139.35778421334462, -64.17903823909637, -294.4267468911366, -116.20689321119713, -51.05325160061946, -139.64530436327536, -128.17078236677202, -117.85044800639324, -101.27047799545065, -183.76022105116397, -366.2956988728538], + "butteraugli": [16.33206686704125, 21.316746899704874, 44.94259833311013, 22.444552188787625, 22.17657481664971, 19.540166170295656, 31.568552195667223, 12.469156614033432, 17.256947458240532, 25.981766833527065, 19.215121946464105, 20.042577206753766, 18.532262039864445, 19.30307554937705, 31.769307675294815, 24.741167286298275, 26.087051806110036, 28.440307604994143, 36.169833706718656, 25.313988609277164, 30.467895615287844, 13.691225117707676, 20.830648007952803, 22.768934745042788, 6.885625442662558, 26.891209171912042, 31.4734666687078, 24.074699828977156, 25.79758663007281, 28.52641173155817, 27.832434330588484], + "dssim": [0.30404587802345495, 0.30055426820139697, 0.46259901687343935, 0.1509451345925122, 0.3364322078280666, 0.20324882010697354, 0.22058359252199228, 0.08387604699169732, 0.4039339777601776, 0.21916438952170575, 0.3924926241533019, 0.2401966969437867, 0.15238345377921486, 0.2552218125292446, 0.358263064353629, 0.20272212106702886, 0.22849485145257115, 0.13503551868568486, 0.3103387847813328, 0.3715239558566399, 0.22103356648381572, 0.1482193500460362, 0.2731498100620363, 0.23764109892544644, 0.0860156426447149, 0.2616813827709821, 0.2114981737167106, 0.2786906600819773, 0.2082593934644923, 0.30033262970557384, 0.35055979960275574] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L8@5+20@4 C10@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=10:4 l2=20:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.819445492453322, 7.404096506928245, 25.901335435950802, 7.607826378863828, 11.782249385557025, 8.027897664156498, 12.017515060055045, 2.9682784546164043, 9.89474136287958, 8.930282030607573, 9.93761403180691, 8.038570510394939, 3.6194710913847, 10.204227082697429, 16.614511890820282, 9.46586526070769, 10.424178379680873, 7.472249248036216, 14.817668862151518, 14.245467349973119, 9.145103212968017, 3.854072979141716, 10.901490660483118, 11.031818415602785, 2.2850946318233816, 10.5976298079795, 10.592647536608215, 9.349840459375047, 6.277649102264456, 8.44894030814333, 12.249702768051398], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.10519247425657, -138.83903805467105, -1211.9988289828657, -83.25329698365283, -222.59272547708946, -114.99200777077488, -228.10629331624045, -61.601460411371875, -186.2908691256731, -143.53198951089547, -168.07158834910172, -87.83674651558403, -63.8756242157248, -187.92955538236833, -535.6478892226165, -146.1682499246369, -165.97868543253026, -72.29012533396772, -264.2322115042094, -617.7190418340356, -147.631544251565, -64.22911549811093, -307.6247512934236, -120.10993025001119, -55.05138507719437, -145.19546184551646, -151.67206933831434, -129.522703215516, -110.59916708875153, -203.52151805671417, -367.80243461105647], + "butteraugli": [16.32270909634592, 21.483922305861075, 44.989996425610855, 22.433676851233376, 22.490936066401122, 19.641946911569793, 31.944768894513356, 12.810237822528032, 17.54146044048871, 25.770619831327746, 19.327625296365046, 20.870815315322975, 19.271361817600948, 20.1785962382505, 31.8503575120293, 25.157792137720804, 26.61392417702079, 28.885669945595144, 36.47609380642877, 25.3298793604822, 30.322869220117088, 14.042629523991389, 20.68950755198451, 22.131617715743513, 8.420374136218593, 27.62459551655931, 32.29189845743721, 24.34643057802177, 26.89222237033955, 30.970879643139728, 28.17168644843476], + "dssim": [0.3041051615598179, 0.3006616264451172, 0.46280061117769805, 0.15133732073674327, 0.33658801484872225, 0.20769146183330006, 0.22242387548093584, 0.08429383455142458, 0.4040914063203327, 0.21584819139124894, 0.3926756039436128, 0.24172523999405704, 0.153200236584504, 0.2557519356477247, 0.3587914981764555, 0.20570790219293378, 0.23370209134561176, 0.13508385278480145, 0.3115415805515699, 0.3712835318092421, 0.22336681476802528, 0.1494588153954335, 0.27254510144916855, 0.23738547257021936, 0.08753497731616305, 0.2635010643299073, 0.21883880476232798, 0.27955398437623646, 0.2105158164428993, 0.3020833621540193, 0.3504834055600047] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L8@5+24@4 C8@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=8:4 l2=24:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.812580392643096, 7.371066836243167, 25.81536944679115, 7.721782211103998, 11.776555937288142, 8.088327598852924, 11.839394233768902, 3.020063857813932, 9.857164642776892, 9.011455027885281, 9.832465340676412, 8.163942085254662, 3.7988234778048504, 10.595250512754843, 16.529449745695242, 9.491142506207092, 10.386988844765327, 7.520276969411258, 14.977839077724196, 14.222420200914918, 9.05076830496362, 3.8251937603871835, 11.200101560838215, 11.205190790333285, 2.32493757320174, 10.53294462759573, 10.377539083520004, 9.14489323614079, 6.195991767545404, 8.315306434133875, 12.284982015383818], + "ssimulacra2": [-111.87431154087272, -137.42533843970105, -1203.001862862046, -78.82264797843177, -215.6035901836936, -107.45480580284405, -207.92276025036102, -61.54860270923467, -180.75870777437137, -145.91415610244854, -154.6824465564657, -89.14949889641258, -63.857192874515675, -184.91484209679174, -499.1207346478027, -141.18449635323276, -172.64469007139377, -71.95042425083233, -255.3974338118461, -615.0787172323397, -136.8291981870313, -64.22702343163127, -293.6577218379659, -109.40425651102402, -55.06001421213895, -139.62559007682952, -132.689827368815, -109.72316348759762, -104.9694481363936, -183.0635009758492, -321.4062005368222], + "butteraugli": [16.163965668984584, 21.387585090778582, 44.932086749903114, 22.27095469969954, 22.64622944659081, 19.654129201982673, 31.461205590665212, 12.719968750858898, 17.490925331774687, 25.621880539934242, 19.184132678927813, 20.739857980823654, 19.277367776053428, 20.203512882775982, 31.549355666725305, 24.878168628747165, 26.432069473087648, 28.11332988834003, 36.26639506929745, 25.33220652977218, 29.703857719677064, 13.931757642803348, 20.88828574107266, 22.38877331106147, 8.410504491914933, 27.07493120788726, 31.644905773886943, 23.666230297814263, 27.303091189386652, 29.308826489598506, 27.101629479548347], + "dssim": [0.3039403836139233, 0.3006221289486871, 0.46229888437769506, 0.15159142945644072, 0.3364875270715548, 0.20487682077749075, 0.22326791089726833, 0.0843854265031505, 0.40397219999280465, 0.2208956115827902, 0.3923058444323853, 0.24267823796326277, 0.1535911088368544, 0.2561860456297086, 0.3580655086379756, 0.20622790693333998, 0.2359604154971791, 0.1389420181039187, 0.30895215862872727, 0.37094663888600543, 0.22381448169969542, 0.14933998579754654, 0.27260375274951465, 0.23623498633528056, 0.08713163725009743, 0.2636404491640466, 0.2147833761465739, 0.27673943063882667, 0.2100107266736252, 0.30015406424996227, 0.34845117094964406] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B L8@5+28@4 C6@4", + "tune": "l1=8:5 c=6:4 l2=28:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107, 107], + "ciede2000": [6.757119280928233, 7.2403102171448745, 25.779137761579264, 7.741593275540295, 12.086877845179144, 8.252308576367026, 11.678436165373698, 3.0565785320420185, 9.813009060372314, 8.978537126648916, 9.786357420567349, 8.152303743838873, 3.820985407120126, 10.77566628489055, 16.432800033458992, 9.452929144429087, 10.326197117104327, 7.4440948578643775, 15.042085374603394, 14.21274137533211, 9.162039931729694, 3.7959026300595093, 12.124471353671225, 11.254842613100795, 2.3424062635687593, 10.410333093340899, 10.746303133500689, 9.10618512230316, 6.162108881055976, 8.302624071113604, 12.406840677559114], + "ssimulacra2": [-110.82548518241748, -125.73086005468201, -1200.5689585642313, -76.04520346678322, -212.9811506492175, -106.61957709480842, -192.4548583967101, -61.4738237361226, -170.8737803453733, -130.009421451658, -149.47246473988668, -89.10678531996282, -63.85407279000984, -189.59104618380638, -453.77411711791456, -138.09808632913925, -164.49005848447837, -71.02687458843093, -236.88520360006436, -602.22969867936, -134.10082072935302, -64.22748802015477, -317.3284716167703, -103.56837987678284, -55.121139389280785, -131.8138634243636, -132.7401864008271, -102.93982894434666, -99.50345360140733, -181.82803032182358, -298.17941172979977], + "butteraugli": [15.31072522527838, 20.929800646456783, 44.91492838219224, 21.975709649248145, 22.462502251845024, 19.517873650186214, 31.49481042497392, 12.748781287050713, 17.449405088560365, 24.869195313466076, 19.22194077156838, 20.72869702761675, 19.701913388264472, 20.690287581121837, 31.29216658450153, 24.92125373686278, 25.485937291327094, 26.95437835781162, 34.5765214128895, 25.31573624233988, 29.02825633083187, 13.817472097809192, 20.439154138527815, 22.21133887367733, 8.444583129822105, 26.64640692792645, 31.417857699743646, 23.518933616434595, 26.20169854737556, 28.664470438496508, 26.7665717707951], + "dssim": [0.30433668630401123, 0.30015618154256607, 0.46221229574596717, 0.15302122271640828, 0.3372627410494651, 0.20794067392420162, 0.22576917311690559, 0.08426935811322672, 0.40355934574953173, 0.22129442911420788, 0.3925327553486533, 0.24260667682108966, 0.1538848303824873, 0.2569883602691365, 0.3566234342243554, 0.20607807862480615, 0.2366715438668096, 0.14084508454125505, 0.31086132457308935, 0.3707466724409969, 0.2253891758033723, 0.1496938799918472, 0.2793461869678996, 0.23550199262352467, 0.08715601323533262, 0.26303437774370375, 0.21412317938099618, 0.2768202391999339, 0.20988718647022214, 0.3014021851279294, 0.3451712294798934] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ac-count.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ac-count.json index 3ffe734..7f3cfdf 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ac-count.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ac-count.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-balance.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-balance.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..03c8016 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-balance.json @@ -0,0 +1,578 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "alpha-balance", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "SS11.3 - the balanced alpha-mode allocation. The AC-count ladder showed the alpha channel is badly starved and that its coefficients are better bought from chroma than from luma, but its best arms drove luma or chroma to near-zero. This grid varies the alpha count and the chroma count together with luma filling the remainder, so the chosen point is a balance rather than a corner. Luma is held at 4 bits, matching the opaque tier-0 choice.", + "corpus": "alpha", + "backdrops": "white-black-grey", + "alphaFidelity": true, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": 32, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/alpha-balance.json", + "configSha256": "30a9a70f0482199239d58223d54a180ff58e37158c5b7f2dfbac54edc9b88fce", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-greek", + "sha256": "28b9e4888cdcbfa13cafbb1b56d0ee1f515756b99b8f7ecc00a544ecaa85dc7c" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-soviet", + "sha256": "89e2d3f669b448c56e47a9c29de65121c60a3d9e9910c95499f0233817074d94" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", + "sha256": "559304d1f8226cfafa4de7685601a3d5dd0673e93365b7b8dc9093a2112849a9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-broccoli", + "sha256": "e7f19280e60b7f164bd53e68134040fa97c3efb539ff44edf2d985ccb3a48f8f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-cheeseburger", + "sha256": "cff8d8ac543defb51454a96a1513dafb43457a569f487030380128b76cfa760a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-dod-seal", + "sha256": "8a67df69e07c9e342bd9d7ac677e6a962ac0a39507881b531bdf88e9baabbaa9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-emblem-kscz", + "sha256": "c8095953b20fd2e8b0a2db22902f3353c5c7196ac35302e00dee221842afad43" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-game-sprite-ship", + "sha256": "0e731563527cb737e4f0ff4cff0fbb723fa3dced9d48ec8f72f0ad63945519ca" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-greek-vase-figure", + "sha256": "ff3e45df88805a10348a8fd92d1212a9410ebe6cce22d52e02ab1188d05a89f8" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-green-dragon", + "sha256": "4d02f29aec4e6de647874836130026e8c413b820b122af3bbddb56a61d097ea6" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lamp-glow", + "sha256": "857ef6d2b9fd450be843429cca5f49353705c52000647791bb7530de81de840f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lineart-hoe", + "sha256": "fd3ad52a4a82f4c685d05981ce3e54ddc35403e23945a3be62fb7b2986e6f142" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-navy-crest", + "sha256": "61eab4c1618ddbc8de9cbf78135492bee775be50d15a6eebd7335bf3be370643" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", + "sha256": "75951d906cb08acc1a643554dde538d739d3f814a5f5231a7971a96550ada98a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-planet-lava", + "sha256": "74b6ae59cbfef2fa11e59d29d51ed326b3c26a10ac40604eec9ccd94883ea9cc" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-road-sign", + "sha256": "56297cb398e82ca506d2057a4402218a1113f7acb38ac92e2c1b3f5e6d460122" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["cutout-3d-star-greek", "cutout-3d-star-soviet", "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", "cutout-broccoli", "cutout-cheeseburger", "cutout-dod-seal", "cutout-emblem-kscz", "cutout-game-sprite-ship", "cutout-greek-vase-figure", "cutout-green-dragon", "cutout-lamp-glow", "cutout-lineart-hoe", "cutout-navy-crest", "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", "cutout-planet-lava", "cutout-road-sign"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "SHIPPED A5@4 L20@5 C9@4", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.51000789352154, 15.056892858460012, 7.5187010350087915, 14.394059764813425, 13.812336295445412, 20.782560258871694, 15.376532712566098, 11.407584653412059, 18.383817734476086, 15.079439020827897, 7.3056877204025765, 13.549681649598037, 27.822625681354847, 16.587655776859197, 13.7881888823225, 25.644279372887507], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.2776354565116, -224.00958121815452, -262.78109066711227, -317.65535006695495, -351.17846670317886, -785.9032933934126, -122.98000492710997, -128.28298441878937, -492.57995819615707, -218.59139364952964, -107.50015228362474, -248.85671035992632, -1058.5760225901865, -522.6689125580233, -287.6270415338086, -918.1895866950059], + "butteraugli": [49.00036642613143, 61.01134616913839, 29.703534202914103, 52.36375556899478, 45.90746854217857, 41.420957258126954, 89.85016343627838, 72.42014700331181, 51.674190638887886, 58.724000066391646, 42.11196589236203, 61.53141748341417, 83.0370995525546, 57.226388588873505, 57.477819718162095, 64.65165413760758], + "dssim": [0.22395011117746577, 0.2120820098314625, 0.21099713626534156, 0.29473993180948616, 0.2547215545729708, 0.28278339143285897, 0.18024956505578352, 0.20501764219111, 0.3104213001175085, 0.25064572089543086, 0.1454268412258631, 0.2559023129287772, 0.3047675021148124, 0.26226839903275545, 0.23635937279214922, 0.30451829728634966], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L31@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=31:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.370835250948636, 14.994249892779491, 7.514425234458528, 11.738064670186233, 13.208896795450194, 20.521856174480416, 14.951687792235779, 8.174485453029353, 13.857768165979019, 10.248870674601086, 6.890093954547488, 12.256902476138569, 26.593600771308104, 14.259011699887877, 13.2404023111393, 24.505948372438013], + "ssimulacra2": [-249.08874691601014, -220.33605829310173, -262.7867894817071, -252.58069096243514, -272.6462620292791, -766.9809116497177, -121.53773790849732, -112.11280537165062, -319.6906381686964, -158.7096475359159, -112.44067103045586, -245.2460304818314, -1006.0291901695695, -455.13134275731755, -276.1644370994438, -881.9606301063528], + "butteraugli": [48.94141783264064, 63.136222798919476, 29.67067131515786, 36.872277665002905, 45.636314605091165, 43.090107831701125, 92.48190449779402, 41.61619456201097, 32.20278607345226, 40.97411669703984, 39.42476797176575, 54.635182558077254, 69.03905083188646, 37.98535133516594, 54.866626962967295, 59.08490899901554], + "dssim": [0.2230412253163673, 0.21278505634391007, 0.21003664300337924, 0.28002410670295064, 0.2469423440396276, 0.28321716706230715, 0.17847363868558938, 0.1880323919443627, 0.2878051577879141, 0.21660176871508632, 0.13510429435084306, 0.2408227989037183, 0.3028375316948843, 0.26462608455815606, 0.24693828186891284, 0.298326922100498], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L28@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=28:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.380289777576932, 14.993442845974073, 7.522140900664934, 11.65173239587128, 13.366529461780635, 20.46511378901805, 14.988602142621088, 8.117896462399317, 13.804296411519642, 10.250154892958243, 6.887668339896521, 12.261765959680053, 26.48499450834325, 14.297783860930473, 13.207744871427657, 24.522936579599673], + "ssimulacra2": [-249.02965208576492, -221.3455396957952, -262.6250754416961, -252.08477612741112, -326.6189638292636, -764.9366959336156, -121.61390636040615, -112.44169352262747, -326.6822058711344, -160.05925685994376, -112.43377720744967, -246.1248668318523, -1000.7897234026681, -451.4991274050764, -278.28938760179216, -883.3959647593687], + "butteraugli": [48.80520636416461, 63.12576919813196, 29.633366427493893, 36.91901082839795, 46.34702628398409, 42.93454782188203, 92.5405161292458, 41.50768114258377, 32.47510506164418, 41.251490069823895, 39.52051458973517, 54.946560555315244, 67.9506047539346, 38.348540391045866, 55.489909853385335, 59.16789491423577], + "dssim": [0.22301810526133795, 0.2128957538106382, 0.2100967833677152, 0.28008794471598314, 0.24847034163236517, 0.2830905239418499, 0.1786118001938534, 0.18811961050933526, 0.2868549825422347, 0.2168578051252503, 0.13510850600543928, 0.24082274376091797, 0.30270477371416116, 0.26256690795404, 0.23678359065164165, 0.2983089873495364], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L25@4 C7@3", + "tune": "la1=25:4 ca=7:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.425254248558948, 14.99374103473324, 7.522140900664934, 11.632106151363635, 13.38168192493945, 20.489043417987997, 14.980031697086664, 8.104850691474239, 13.873490022819624, 10.345231452685441, 6.892281765252502, 12.28900388734072, 27.296492885127964, 14.372311850890526, 13.152656586512899, 24.592227051822878], + "ssimulacra2": [-252.91870360627823, -222.85583511029154, -262.6250754416961, -255.66223478325824, -322.90576204391795, -771.1337364023807, -121.71697986169313, -112.7697810251268, -337.58447530687494, -167.1726800695631, -113.06411580665032, -246.73404955458372, -1031.4688523212305, -461.6309737582562, -280.1932309351403, -886.9720540546401], + "butteraugli": [48.90134734403074, 63.07962387029235, 29.633366427493893, 37.385864182150456, 47.23627053412895, 43.18668516758609, 92.37297356540346, 41.522910890569555, 32.89007360774553, 41.04779684249389, 39.9001149082635, 55.545024859251974, 76.37746826890604, 38.722600986211376, 55.56841781575124, 59.6804821870137], + "dssim": [0.2231644978766553, 0.21266858806807032, 0.2100967833677152, 0.27997836777434776, 0.2481228070216718, 0.2831002834856751, 0.17842822378267598, 0.18811218556644838, 0.2874713885869766, 0.21752196654766698, 0.13564190143531446, 0.24089154358657594, 0.30383901975468824, 0.26242581041696283, 0.2315790614773328, 0.29833304752068085], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L22@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=22:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.426380185950963, 14.98671337061265, 7.52250538503754, 11.724028704892392, 13.13593745299251, 20.541408101232538, 14.97415493529534, 8.078500024486909, 13.94864513372877, 10.338133721584663, 6.867692886102051, 12.296993112113498, 27.579329120890893, 14.333217499458009, 13.184808084592843, 24.61941785076212], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.13753685726442, -222.78802173986136, -262.61336500090704, -258.912380817436, -324.57576743062174, -775.1001423893127, -122.58726758777789, -115.09012051229409, -348.6109151605972, -173.41876337925825, -112.5494458535026, -246.4413077484046, -1039.962691230661, -463.24816709667374, -286.5997063362809, -887.6378686196158], + "butteraugli": [48.88553197949247, 63.16607549164655, 29.641874310814444, 38.62280417436325, 46.824155371658605, 43.21430509082805, 92.28066368899623, 41.56322599754335, 33.27701560800533, 40.818202010838796, 39.93259563309447, 55.42495826475989, 82.0899856475974, 38.78677683118932, 56.318865741811585, 59.74931420284262], + "dssim": [0.2231459906295794, 0.21279233235093084, 0.21009729644958677, 0.2802784996183459, 0.24790188351199097, 0.2831129291413581, 0.17833024605127604, 0.18965539176294702, 0.2879919986063808, 0.21774038335487292, 0.13665148461893012, 0.24084789114707847, 0.30509774054765637, 0.2624665087248557, 0.2313947878890832, 0.2983127594551986], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L26@4 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=26:4 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.422928151250625, 14.986879692422677, 7.518778475637771, 11.67892671062379, 13.427974204903117, 20.493610087069282, 14.986889606480254, 8.12346507972512, 13.81152960458803, 10.359708146041408, 6.903987996091349, 12.266688808249858, 27.305362686280073, 14.383166760935923, 13.199995415905585, 24.556640627273577], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.00133799622998, -221.1575742243292, -262.68013354366747, -255.70402134735096, -327.44722858611203, -771.0899831766914, -121.69338191036076, -112.81014319536833, -332.3346325219585, -167.51811942543281, -112.91503268702108, -246.54981549538925, -1032.7425977149535, -462.38105676083825, -279.30023618202006, -887.048090108647], + "butteraugli": [49.06336735132822, 62.96696621569907, 29.66336174186971, 37.366327350102246, 46.73191295746741, 43.1863150722551, 92.50051628148559, 41.545217055598584, 32.70030230456167, 40.9977235275727, 39.64135710365281, 55.176104513894956, 76.32865536007775, 38.702462084798235, 55.5044213325312, 59.678122815035216], + "dssim": [0.22313443436891148, 0.21262009471817214, 0.21004113061351534, 0.28008371874975185, 0.24825848357196723, 0.283117733566779, 0.17857297316037143, 0.18828835518484147, 0.2870280487001962, 0.21736271778666705, 0.135070011547169, 0.24085549292602662, 0.303821637458147, 0.2624344239939131, 0.2327673334544805, 0.29832109727934075], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L18@4 C9@4", + "tune": "la1=18:4 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.434022427071246, 14.971894752532641, 7.519636891186889, 11.879050649381634, 13.33119071760999, 20.59402396334914, 14.926676054358225, 8.070840978731233, 14.023444035504758, 10.408843665711663, 6.8714685065836, 12.346283160789369, 27.580528120741178, 14.850271804842079, 13.195667506100227, 24.5708781042086], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.59167431699964, -224.11334852478828, -262.6742732131095, -267.9869931190504, -357.0666586570144, -780.8876332536428, -123.02021915581895, -115.72508468602372, -366.2623758148843, -175.98679206521015, -112.7476856402635, -247.36641962301942, -1042.0999550001895, -475.0734387137573, -289.24856073036887, -893.3508941462428], + "butteraugli": [48.89564293615763, 62.46947093576487, 29.660703218888568, 38.22082055592556, 48.49323067287753, 43.51891087454771, 92.53658398472281, 41.29959842452271, 33.62925949300872, 41.04274393869171, 40.186630369774825, 56.43839564861062, 82.30049928920558, 39.82304738123634, 56.72062971890157, 59.99781265648998], + "dssim": [0.2231556027300662, 0.2117884139894862, 0.2100580237722264, 0.28058366422634967, 0.249596450557382, 0.28293961283395236, 0.17763016749412067, 0.18996504591713484, 0.289221236156648, 0.21828927516782567, 0.1372536563699133, 0.24088684644839473, 0.3051137415792946, 0.26261437594534714, 0.23122645094129715, 0.29842544208472366], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L27@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=27:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.15266421446332, 12.897496387762478, 7.296607903491529, 10.910024801381986, 13.21818251614126, 19.492431022851687, 12.782165708114306, 7.121988171571773, 13.617495353069353, 9.824530940053718, 6.85532271469958, 11.460555449799308, 26.785236670170217, 14.272093830896788, 12.576649410525143, 24.413588975935536], + "ssimulacra2": [-245.25361772857465, -205.57929271419064, -258.4538049309446, -221.15677540428294, -318.71098496991885, -743.1583342601867, -109.92540875560816, -96.84008934909942, -316.60552327973795, -158.08366597203502, -114.01251912830936, -218.13789459863378, -1011.6263157562513, -447.7762538253782, -271.3221835893835, -872.4941326772533], + "butteraugli": [50.09382025205815, 53.18908298350616, 27.898973940602563, 33.66453308362822, 43.3159937451407, 38.99980701343853, 91.32294403371485, 35.43504846403483, 32.831709137070916, 38.69969423330924, 39.68071511993617, 52.93223456075237, 75.1784291353211, 38.000552934485775, 51.939173597357275, 54.828230285442025], + "dssim": [0.2211903387895023, 0.20577450139009515, 0.21000768907620718, 0.27633284866331015, 0.24975902089690027, 0.2761348635475663, 0.17322301517452035, 0.17357748909732443, 0.28175087313017566, 0.21598600814841232, 0.13260539662387724, 0.242649311336837, 0.3000704841129003, 0.2625194627327625, 0.2392007381423018, 0.29594172139216324], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L24@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=24:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.166011225144326, 12.878583815213977, 7.298342408633758, 10.818527330054328, 12.983698447185157, 19.460613958630177, 12.795807222597906, 7.064004193552225, 13.628673311901538, 9.851635734092286, 6.847131393714505, 11.493969303710472, 26.72464689496856, 14.233645717435168, 12.552330297073361, 24.422610069243365], + "ssimulacra2": [-245.74371289599824, -207.25773852274833, -258.45189388699805, -222.0572028429156, -314.1202011769937, -744.2431099235029, -109.92032265644723, -97.59788049091549, -332.09808606796787, -160.78555503268055, -114.097899191482, -218.3317222957064, -1008.2622691470882, -458.8425505923961, -272.63406776701294, -872.956310894172], + "butteraugli": [49.919428634367044, 53.26128404786463, 27.85871300915527, 34.09702621311019, 44.08375802915064, 38.91715158054625, 91.38548483019757, 35.16698918962774, 32.927573147312394, 38.975108349943824, 39.95286326474061, 53.47451867723975, 74.6334208448393, 38.2994152631251, 52.19571463368806, 55.54287412214524], + "dssim": [0.22123118187735444, 0.20543332752775548, 0.2101111320464125, 0.2762654626289314, 0.2494668301536164, 0.2760638228359487, 0.17306840214480956, 0.17384808273674487, 0.28224273159001645, 0.21614942279788887, 0.13380774337330828, 0.2426194531191157, 0.3001012019923744, 0.2625016020718902, 0.23010920540926091, 0.2959582973570689], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L21@4 C7@3", + "tune": "la1=21:4 ca=7:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.163696752695595, 12.860987416226797, 7.298446255995217, 10.895237228684366, 13.190560314612112, 19.568334715173048, 12.75101613065093, 7.089593763120223, 13.706100801159698, 9.884844167854835, 6.839425118955984, 11.493518616256141, 26.99828190501401, 14.232790924390336, 12.548688265002554, 24.456600520091268], + "ssimulacra2": [-245.93361742144202, -208.46608660222122, -258.3708623590385, -224.14666729789528, -342.81747425704975, -751.9315430392284, -111.17837112947409, -99.61696358169957, -340.3474834413734, -166.55865450822543, -113.90641552655093, -218.2065890056759, -1020.3144759126313, -459.9843744657364, -280.42683851726883, -878.3109577185347], + "butteraugli": [49.99348101970727, 53.12462137609049, 27.868532062660375, 34.67049016657408, 44.441442752265424, 39.05943110033004, 91.27284315986999, 35.4972906071115, 33.10167365167645, 38.34896092550187, 40.02052110600643, 53.76655189078144, 80.96116681813616, 38.36949120635063, 52.867872208972244, 55.92462215093321], + "dssim": [0.22128120507624535, 0.2063982174039982, 0.21011600625235757, 0.2767351501095949, 0.2505575626322277, 0.27592982595696, 0.17267951722329325, 0.1751530113573976, 0.28396825437727174, 0.2165628280145803, 0.1339506255502975, 0.24262161855079903, 0.3011234209815238, 0.2624489332888342, 0.2260268094366508, 0.2961044000293089], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L18@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=18:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.173859140097612, 12.86909408598946, 7.298446255995217, 11.03554291116496, 12.980268832389712, 19.567657171046605, 12.757539677671943, 7.036986848224632, 13.745809678171497, 9.899914627729828, 6.821218744572317, 11.553248568942251, 26.998607721089034, 14.701544828222742, 12.500855216074234, 24.470482470159784], + "ssimulacra2": [-245.92199601597227, -208.8532415131041, -258.3708623590385, -234.21368161253005, -348.35951178680716, -751.9716354347796, -111.1568303904749, -99.16282644579142, -353.8997264538356, -169.1966277395252, -113.7945978314582, -219.45560282395027, -1020.6572510075652, -471.42489031848345, -283.3831313727364, -879.8928817525762], + "butteraugli": [49.99406275803235, 53.340023484415745, 27.868532062660375, 34.688352077960104, 45.25833425022787, 39.07293662594547, 91.264625780195, 35.34963350401367, 33.42403123053332, 38.87227017024792, 40.169128074308595, 55.00970948981268, 81.16465238029232, 39.40938019016958, 52.88240382724016, 55.88736249671485], + "dssim": [0.22130396424595652, 0.20616827000239338, 0.21011600625235757, 0.2771862270126535, 0.2509599968385972, 0.2759249474566123, 0.1726085712786225, 0.1754877924850721, 0.2840539885167898, 0.2169390602598654, 0.13465240690820715, 0.2428153763120998, 0.30114333291458956, 0.2625617150510416, 0.22268819350097768, 0.2960893751787206], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L22@4 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=22:4 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.171615749713963, 12.865536402672836, 7.294515125133306, 10.907792529868232, 13.036850410795997, 19.528317596035322, 12.78582629117676, 7.099105674487195, 13.645539336492838, 9.913638319690348, 6.857148721835121, 11.494803739999094, 26.99913052616709, 14.236385928903951, 12.602392397744772, 24.421922864073668], + "ssimulacra2": [-245.8567946683188, -207.02599643040344, -258.47376576326997, -225.1619797434006, -316.7175447015293, -747.5707213537216, -110.51499711226101, -98.70609910572193, -335.2522286543491, -166.8092203115057, -114.10339646324098, -218.32726560415549, -1022.0352819579444, -459.7855809501173, -280.4124054955052, -873.2800325566964], + "butteraugli": [49.96036642687358, 53.505919713235095, 27.89452199549373, 34.52283395090789, 43.7814693558043, 38.77707263727174, 91.34706380064317, 35.46903880097454, 33.09044396458133, 38.50920282285623, 39.99806231224569, 53.71744996271868, 81.00017731874101, 38.352760210852786, 52.51580063413308, 55.544363155404234], + "dssim": [0.22128040811046343, 0.20563211372321413, 0.21009959736288933, 0.2767221611898778, 0.24911587987575076, 0.2760448195592083, 0.17308681966042386, 0.17435260840877698, 0.2821174567620925, 0.21649373546636563, 0.13396122880568884, 0.24260406962202438, 0.30113045170507674, 0.2624645060306125, 0.2300322933922633, 0.2959664070479141], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L14@4 C9@4", + "tune": "la1=14:4 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.203820543364301, 12.882343915708452, 7.293826789689384, 11.135885300417462, 13.05713008411747, 19.593487274290435, 12.751152866337206, 7.047541877602275, 13.825239511960705, 10.029279503391253, 6.834745642337978, 11.648189010123163, 27.646132442861845, 14.699550362756876, 12.569458122586695, 24.803738489262784], + "ssimulacra2": [-247.5659057787747, -209.62461339394864, -258.4652725064089, -239.59307626947728, -356.9430842742501, -765.1752058725951, -111.16034349407819, -99.9170844882812, -361.22552926781015, -172.07467040145028, -114.0223849220434, -223.87245991440855, -1053.6292238412532, -478.04249652483617, -288.68307055452095, -920.1857595308014], + "butteraugli": [49.802341894025936, 53.77141489541779, 27.8980616376531, 35.555324948648575, 45.65560964416641, 39.05216343723787, 91.29545818794018, 35.95145681124496, 33.096463610520175, 39.185765805520596, 40.23490925222268, 56.21571462763246, 85.63949690269159, 39.51119491223176, 52.930191574352285, 57.83596483103977], + "dssim": [0.22135465681747277, 0.20553394196069993, 0.21010059009873006, 0.2773627284117626, 0.25142726653323716, 0.27596583038236017, 0.172748086060016, 0.176623389158179, 0.28382630679916665, 0.21793951606882858, 0.1341938191445076, 0.24282572321808418, 0.30313701673859056, 0.2626099085659214, 0.22146658450807696, 0.29600580238159385], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L23@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=23:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.205190710243768, 12.071145506325825, 7.280262069754535, 10.486820783268149, 13.200994636857367, 19.497676125897765, 12.206609431259304, 7.101380604681954, 13.617505280370265, 9.216809386967602, 6.809140969686612, 11.41282872353167, 27.035314195547453, 14.22856897305041, 12.62966006465416, 24.288512475144582], + "ssimulacra2": [-247.28255343336298, -200.81522980707882, -257.0629190467157, -211.90080011603413, -314.1154117410096, -744.4896450781279, -106.18333288823537, -95.85919329693972, -326.5962078445645, -146.97647929124864, -114.86060751242718, -215.9436428650013, -1014.7095880034591, -456.20247895561516, -277.08773484281187, -864.1162335933319], + "butteraugli": [49.522594745709945, 47.34854785125358, 27.88487323682071, 32.67551683951236, 44.21689641834545, 38.99556821231767, 82.44091933439148, 33.31375601620339, 32.35091598344774, 37.50366872924756, 38.884935561622335, 52.30324525107435, 79.96096278463956, 38.40189891111871, 52.01014265681072, 53.40424899834221], + "dssim": [0.21921937005926914, 0.20308218143105183, 0.2075884488058788, 0.2724879745658731, 0.24965803626280314, 0.2761574128163519, 0.16581378622377066, 0.1739135866885071, 0.2815354869312871, 0.21209928876875517, 0.1363613750318346, 0.24276443645515786, 0.30003116403563107, 0.2625314504229302, 0.23946907124474945, 0.2960717469602629], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L20@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=20:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.201382600333881, 12.03932215865583, 7.282189180281901, 10.475678256004642, 13.213909039321491, 19.569367159854234, 12.210084537086878, 7.085589373868282, 13.594360725490864, 9.251565510423502, 6.81136274328593, 11.417798597682435, 26.982831354262554, 14.606624819883072, 12.645335937921203, 24.28709420626517], + "ssimulacra2": [-247.23129185622543, -201.8006424507229, -257.02790414907616, -215.11444345938335, -345.69995782508187, -752.1940950609163, -107.50656349645759, -97.1483983796554, -334.6689234801392, -153.45389575034622, -114.88680019664393, -216.29802289010516, -1017.3662802840299, -469.5561054130624, -282.2032569524758, -869.273607168342], + "butteraugli": [49.580064777639336, 47.20184219386306, 27.83764413969349, 33.74177562893323, 44.71937386221714, 39.08321306878799, 82.5844111557999, 33.469846588029014, 32.59783262263651, 37.36602361401376, 39.04762398371344, 52.607004916495306, 80.52002491990208, 40.00649307235665, 52.87303461524986, 53.92179745131465], + "dssim": [0.21923955744350043, 0.2033112295932371, 0.20764546423813102, 0.27306682208974026, 0.25076714565029423, 0.2759444221930413, 0.16561533906729137, 0.17482211731528616, 0.283654315661517, 0.2125478753514315, 0.136443257496259, 0.24272828769845986, 0.3001286758646264, 0.2627972862458545, 0.230421070908739, 0.29619362959608725], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L17@4 C7@3", + "tune": "la1=17:4 ca=7:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.209363861455126, 12.054845040723803, 7.281061138559867, 10.609083533474857, 13.222378217142223, 19.5856931945515, 12.217351717949265, 7.079454842418085, 13.65999701620607, 9.326005052903758, 6.815951039819143, 11.460012447339272, 27.024827459682935, 14.621877341742048, 12.584975532996419, 24.31563230868363], + "ssimulacra2": [-247.6516226958071, -202.88895295001703, -257.07029419350897, -223.57833941949056, -348.9249532818653, -755.683907953749, -107.53803646365584, -96.64242199459908, -349.1696421334564, -157.68323035253144, -115.37249365380755, -216.69590233944828, -1014.4572304252388, -469.7580939479678, -285.4975394403719, -871.3894310112167], + "butteraugli": [49.57952054764048, 47.307809751050854, 27.83640484752928, 32.82344520357904, 45.20920180679983, 38.94891711103935, 82.57457670641837, 33.84027300099836, 33.074485667382156, 37.007334183285685, 39.63774774897038, 53.580787049909084, 80.5668254939659, 39.99992618868242, 52.83671781944853, 53.58861041033614], + "dssim": [0.21924995114509857, 0.20393724738359956, 0.20763424692051635, 0.27346589714354624, 0.2509597774664781, 0.2759610311436859, 0.1656334701704404, 0.17540960556536636, 0.2838185567727822, 0.21325259337998678, 0.13630519977787, 0.24275883343662488, 0.3000823999020849, 0.2626615861922819, 0.22265733841226512, 0.29620359870511886], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L14@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=14:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.246049340428263, 12.070721479277458, 7.281061138559867, 10.700555671052493, 13.079081834749479, 19.59367437537461, 12.20636178964867, 7.048154042709105, 13.754266185163317, 9.346666709334716, 6.803749189345631, 11.558382238881235, 27.57402860527229, 14.582793113401463, 12.56834104224526, 24.696207580336807], + "ssimulacra2": [-249.31898092504582, -203.7617152307489, -257.07029419350897, -229.1580297487469, -356.98431424592536, -764.9083272408028, -107.5780244194355, -97.69308549104174, -356.01460136908946, -159.18976010298675, -115.29158401482842, -221.6620978173643, -1048.2511701463395, -476.87892463215684, -288.5598260960166, -911.3629776880571], + "butteraugli": [49.43943780898406, 47.47715935618069, 27.83640484752928, 33.68337733554247, 45.61637860240132, 39.021286730860226, 82.51507255268535, 33.991437956796744, 32.69172342159934, 37.44205383031936, 39.68362711036073, 54.57748438404111, 85.01520590601648, 40.3878960086897, 52.94197298106323, 57.24899155093451], + "dssim": [0.21933059066097008, 0.20379201933210878, 0.20763424692051635, 0.27354438078084375, 0.25141319194798123, 0.27595431148073746, 0.16562289100732366, 0.1764756383082924, 0.2833267954759752, 0.2137549511000341, 0.1364743511668087, 0.24283853193170143, 0.3020329847843076, 0.2627143572640403, 0.22136631635908488, 0.29616552718551], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L18@4 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=18:4 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.21220078355335, 12.035982502562597, 7.279740564908049, 10.626618245664455, 13.24843358585772, 19.582464892489714, 12.201236873409448, 7.097902119145729, 13.638757340643716, 9.307958991315342, 6.828755989403397, 11.458633480165053, 27.00500965315118, 14.651669990860944, 12.616048121008133, 24.281237970410896], + "ssimulacra2": [-247.74713654714955, -202.56115976998595, -257.0737654289016, -223.77185794212983, -348.3469718590075, -752.4043306850408, -107.58380020406736, -97.24685537891288, -348.6005669741924, -156.0697712624553, -115.44571290847215, -216.89693999272944, -1017.9584592516421, -469.7332479147755, -283.26952601126806, -871.4564045591491], + "butteraugli": [49.57952826328216, 47.38179894752161, 27.858636384707268, 32.849345390752696, 45.221478387473105, 39.1080125870865, 82.68724643142458, 33.4985804535553, 33.08438351037553, 36.94259252578741, 39.591429970046896, 53.49118722957942, 80.80563559658566, 40.00931381349123, 52.968353623143884, 53.9655101813394], + "dssim": [0.21926865067684886, 0.2033307771812196, 0.2076739221585994, 0.2734456357780816, 0.25103152452609573, 0.27595715315033703, 0.16560323383246112, 0.17487133930333285, 0.2833798181953247, 0.21305305585610854, 0.13632991999190816, 0.24272920714912938, 0.300199586939379, 0.26267669918507996, 0.22657645834029658, 0.2962130815336382], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@4 L10@4 C9@4", + "tune": "la1=10:4 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.259303982159869, 12.072837332156444, 7.279801034797607, 11.055847880145308, 13.192022255523915, 19.80918187997507, 12.065313808729492, 7.047802619299564, 13.76536412728178, 9.62024038052641, 6.829481110781589, 11.619582619343824, 27.557976495310328, 15.535701519594305, 12.52846789949949, 24.666911355910088], + "ssimulacra2": [-249.58147585517509, -207.43423311363213, -257.0292969659942, -242.5708699124849, -367.9498092807659, -771.994930452303, -108.36374274923371, -98.17228136442633, -359.10540542173567, -171.4582614717741, -115.84777681844442, -222.95440863181247, -1051.4949892764416, -503.45204996304693, -291.74728380060077, -910.7457777384593], + "butteraugli": [49.6704698396253, 46.62103188120677, 27.865118341965026, 34.844583940474784, 45.43041625192254, 39.403655396223826, 82.485659501284, 34.140665713492325, 32.77547349804805, 36.63574692511862, 40.011104672079746, 53.93758726910721, 86.73873372563817, 41.045724240612294, 53.3579986371897, 56.8954348825352], + "dssim": [0.2193421442246292, 0.20180366537530683, 0.2076462556750364, 0.2745301589603199, 0.252315277408572, 0.27635934036626025, 0.16527755420074022, 0.17663009677190242, 0.2840786155791549, 0.21495268336427312, 0.13657454134653904, 0.24290077427349951, 0.30206373235695594, 0.263253555251496, 0.2125452960823533, 0.296056872710727], + "alphaMae": [0.2302398952538762, 0.1934489324674542, 0.19467182600799326, 0.1502880824769667, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.19430107820536002, 0.1559546058006536, 0.19846257341379947, 0.19988551957042358, 0.16425293928625437, 0.24391805727973007, 0.11497498464336106, 0.20320934779513466, 0.18426121730430453, 0.08561955375347041] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L19@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=19:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.659771646619085, 11.941185985941312, 7.227515658153976, 10.213416312885476, 13.223314464277939, 19.62449518958192, 11.488831235501685, 6.990476432345678, 13.690440711690826, 8.567285984170733, 6.791656101905178, 11.424025989109685, 27.08272539571162, 14.717350639273086, 11.99076935379479, 24.20989033839444], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.50864507870736, -202.8312863481539, -254.9163934214629, -202.92683694627237, -338.6564971810592, -757.657822375712, -101.09092965454438, -94.52125194426746, -344.2356872423666, -138.76295922994373, -113.44127855161321, -217.58581424508395, -1022.673879818854, -470.00579358098565, -263.93053033212163, -871.8779016718366], + "butteraugli": [46.462368434159266, 45.97161647152325, 26.96534666948692, 32.50658420473272, 44.64372243809518, 38.32840433198961, 69.60001139367212, 32.84333592221322, 33.205015432353456, 30.821549196530928, 38.94608699977459, 51.794925107141665, 80.8134600781734, 39.83506067411462, 51.07739087511533, 54.13369312934707], + "dssim": [0.21340468138651522, 0.20317704768342107, 0.2062127355415052, 0.26675293315625814, 0.24839752527842, 0.27618853430259244, 0.16277833877844558, 0.1738693799694951, 0.28199162044919374, 0.20815434358641108, 0.13658318113272425, 0.24488043699126838, 0.29959432250706236, 0.26274395611700535, 0.22496908029382987, 0.29615946042353913], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L16@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=16:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.660245702998473, 11.936599285225105, 7.23423675398076, 10.201857295016232, 12.999838957158572, 19.601782543883207, 11.523609691975613, 6.9493216630847945, 13.656283351712261, 8.579073793319933, 6.796621322111449, 11.494896452165655, 27.676554003238824, 14.60007662048973, 11.977037870155511, 24.208553520637285], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.71144156578987, -203.15740679292978, -254.93158358711108, -209.0431103473555, -338.18952261300313, -761.6773081330795, -101.0615141255148, -93.8500415022457, -352.28018840904434, -141.2352693098289, -113.83208849737457, -220.6824554406896, -1054.6102577709078, -474.8638655618974, -268.7376475331201, -871.9311410824112], + "butteraugli": [46.48569745571866, 45.971256644057036, 26.930170130264383, 33.14658681546946, 44.655931716724034, 38.1140978633035, 69.77712351728773, 33.2960470781315, 33.433703565811015, 30.617510751136987, 39.55475202643993, 53.279409304274985, 84.49894544717377, 40.10092874819887, 51.37028643337191, 53.7017552237238], + "dssim": [0.21337967787942494, 0.20274606416095567, 0.20620841503302367, 0.26710169915306664, 0.24830741193269334, 0.2761257100550933, 0.16286859108370894, 0.17439338653399936, 0.2832188314909097, 0.20837490198829597, 0.1366488483233319, 0.2447915828954932, 0.3015338432199789, 0.26265813796657156, 0.2185913027726678, 0.29613034426638235], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L13@4 C7@3", + "tune": "la1=13:4 ca=7:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.691379844010589, 11.931465082630988, 7.235490179748498, 10.466472471991212, 13.090330900925485, 19.592955101096205, 11.436532243008935, 6.970747482961649, 13.747139928077969, 8.677390051354857, 6.792837043692977, 11.54573504696635, 27.651983831157253, 14.880549999678957, 11.882746635065507, 24.59322215947559], + "ssimulacra2": [-241.74570712424398, -206.94296768115228, -254.86732213906558, -216.3570798481513, -344.33027083665576, -768.7420777833776, -101.20819406059722, -95.86731109529622, -354.640661713537, -143.6604311349723, -113.6404501542256, -222.5761391948905, -1049.2966676504416, -480.02382771752445, -271.7776576518524, -909.9087268192701], + "butteraugli": [46.41773601423912, 45.90547045029897, 26.943825448728678, 33.76868352406649, 45.24893914419011, 38.089703391752096, 69.55547347842496, 33.202173513914865, 32.84022584998234, 31.102244134516543, 39.64413767777154, 53.0909052298671, 84.77244492217487, 41.31241970331036, 50.27968586203744, 57.12648896316753], + "dssim": [0.21349765758293207, 0.20414557170398884, 0.2062493284791096, 0.26759625470438647, 0.24862051645604719, 0.2760690431822372, 0.1626485665646625, 0.1751232787772, 0.2825978382687971, 0.20910773663092339, 0.13647697331251693, 0.2449000508635184, 0.30155065616713467, 0.26336387151644375, 0.21203465762855014, 0.2960117010862812], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L10@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=10:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.697107431619045, 11.959663667681793, 7.235490179748498, 10.573821312725395, 12.995559951475352, 19.818399299744755, 11.40472103988734, 6.935203642474417, 13.767310992019594, 8.872165977504858, 6.8012069310702294, 11.605427893900725, 27.612323211503895, 15.508411899303338, 11.849098656657198, 24.61496350700889], + "ssimulacra2": [-241.48252868720974, -207.8163699046037, -254.86732213906558, -224.84166255572265, -354.29555741494715, -777.090612463719, -101.70505349224986, -95.40150859557603, -359.2254759330808, -154.00392028278975, -114.31762903406991, -223.93485040432753, -1050.1081047011694, -503.99745643354163, -273.58743633828254, -909.4273163279489], + "butteraugli": [46.606794122899096, 45.28844696821724, 26.943825448728678, 34.140041650594185, 44.741694312406615, 38.62673900655553, 69.48305615938733, 33.29360589770419, 32.96445990988121, 31.52402394645415, 39.953800887977344, 52.80686356144303, 86.52225028187127, 40.86750183813644, 51.196054935361836, 57.02340661380359], + "dssim": [0.21347818777241048, 0.2036423879284325, 0.2062493284791096, 0.268155648786101, 0.24970910528147985, 0.27652401378089747, 0.1625342264545591, 0.17548385419835136, 0.28343415990619686, 0.210339590887571, 0.13665500634180197, 0.244901389737223, 0.30155342065352736, 0.263274995536555, 0.20860682881182377, 0.29600684176159714], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L14@4 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=14:4 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.691239709746798, 11.945583428315624, 7.231311297614305, 10.247797924424523, 13.11945908779645, 19.6283158832808, 11.514892313479047, 6.990056917821224, 13.724851756564439, 8.663741641177007, 6.80799065887156, 11.543503925945663, 27.640853892108705, 14.618380753540393, 11.974243594422026, 24.544684008044342], + "ssimulacra2": [-241.5302288603274, -204.21536943212467, -254.95525242564852, -210.90139431163868, -345.1204280978629, -770.6037577728995, -101.06431100450304, -95.23058292051654, -355.0426633388535, -143.07704343602788, -114.03539388914629, -222.49331465430842, -1051.3754446146315, -476.141101690411, -269.55288352293593, -911.9124924835754], + "butteraugli": [46.3583465241609, 46.20368502508828, 26.945541125759362, 33.08373919398534, 45.03010997282555, 38.16176360063264, 69.72375701488872, 33.21725437700914, 32.931318393668995, 31.253275147918018, 39.607969652566986, 53.12340277249057, 84.5925062317819, 40.21473675015351, 51.22431712778795, 57.27124328971403], + "dssim": [0.21348219356829765, 0.2027349034259184, 0.20622166731928124, 0.26715897228204827, 0.2487411009380006, 0.2761325333898297, 0.1629452061910812, 0.1750650642068249, 0.2825811779987431, 0.20897172224340022, 0.13643235735186526, 0.2449057136576862, 0.3015639922956201, 0.26281454123317854, 0.2146156968854127, 0.2960859070076691], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@4 L6@4 C9@4", + "tune": "la1=6:4 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.715691254412675, 11.99672790221092, 7.234287315790887, 10.751023801327598, 13.013126596143591, 19.817413950427966, 11.39140651984657, 6.953227428460253, 13.866618604888394, 9.210504548624703, 6.844540249198023, 11.721790687294591, 27.753188292530577, 16.1712219501421, 11.89695006242406, 25.05255023200822], + "ssimulacra2": [-242.22270529629532, -209.37438625265645, -254.89917633946695, -233.4037266577268, -339.5759341914524, -777.2270564060926, -101.68500048855451, -97.05332910460089, -367.3315026905116, -163.76530766123335, -115.66510143710813, -225.50535045099414, -1053.3845963918918, -520.2003541187879, -275.23168130138464, -954.414645476544], + "butteraugli": [46.61164829759085, 45.45754844929644, 26.952606206561715, 34.61022285318968, 42.832859277352604, 38.62451673225194, 69.46599635619945, 33.48156809631889, 32.826828117765025, 31.762424232647646, 40.78442746217547, 53.09494577096206, 84.60300026050682, 41.062288088009524, 51.54004878954648, 63.7906289815055], + "dssim": [0.21349907496616663, 0.2036013082221837, 0.20621860270555237, 0.2689194231387823, 0.24941431092538494, 0.2765315300643572, 0.1625271324878913, 0.1758287177222625, 0.284852417188745, 0.2114445507100502, 0.1373927720084294, 0.24535826804163263, 0.30191699549650614, 0.2642369651079459, 0.21467527010709142, 0.2959994486343137], + "alphaMae": [0.21400467757525546, 0.18806955159112826, 0.1930470854586204, 0.134285266064257, 0.17985135540653213, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18178538289034876, 0.15135558505809732, 0.19719679956298558, 0.17062760377687972, 0.1621790767238772, 0.2434734855116289, 0.10881885399941614, 0.2033614217211781, 0.16476703718596813, 0.08263931817195905] + } + }, + { + "label": "A28@4 L15@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=15:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=28 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.404293135415388, 11.303002823023823, 7.127596387379158, 10.295901216743424, 12.47817205620904, 19.652946333939266, 11.467006597772938, 6.490264722134621, 13.754585692439472, 8.522578921328195, 6.3201250719792865, 11.441394006398454, 27.75918564510758, 13.685911493728183, 11.610362500053796, 24.30615425798366], + "ssimulacra2": [-236.2517989337448, -189.76892397981297, -247.51230770556677, -210.16918154171034, -318.85855405148874, -770.9643767962328, -100.17926154630784, -80.29621192447362, -354.1881945630866, -139.29391336827624, -111.49792701035425, -223.0874879552507, -1058.1144898641605, -399.777717934945, -255.23546724669518, -881.4639003750316], + "butteraugli": [44.207308661571574, 42.42266187196129, 25.750610681797724, 33.675059016605054, 42.288246432699275, 38.21189191964416, 69.94507964443572, 30.70869321335591, 32.44637448332952, 30.519290530856953, 38.65836721664308, 49.97195613619747, 84.8038953297606, 35.799997714112784, 43.135867183112396, 56.61407899617527], + "dssim": [0.21005351773002343, 0.20171557688409458, 0.20742363795702498, 0.26665045605017507, 0.2438170124666629, 0.2761959431423196, 0.16242541036803268, 0.17019873355274828, 0.28256844922322905, 0.20720062286569607, 0.1262098151944154, 0.24248242622792446, 0.3012920198260605, 0.2614656947415906, 0.22375447677099816, 0.2960418875648164], + "alphaMae": [0.2050206570304178, 0.1699989076060752, 0.19046674201775304, 0.13206622445665014, 0.1526162508625151, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18211829621705242, 0.13071557847676107, 0.19449295343137254, 0.16616224336426683, 0.1429010763206311, 0.23913531321619558, 0.10648966239721695, 0.15631019394272233, 0.15650497137331496, 0.08070791715469373] + } + }, + { + "label": "A28@4 L12@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=12:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=28 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.418748083288323, 11.271172633650949, 7.134166356565696, 10.548779380745975, 12.404020991798305, 19.75847223679933, 11.403515352867212, 6.473263105076903, 13.689375128832694, 8.600190547561528, 6.323449773149765, 11.507952093264786, 27.66586379290578, 13.845342678748144, 11.545454367882359, 24.491836449673727], + "ssimulacra2": [-237.53967300991485, -192.70863922788294, -247.53801030182152, -224.29363391254537, -327.2084202784499, -769.6749641224575, -100.34665503038417, -80.98762575918921, -354.9529405768385, -141.2373616045708, -111.54564065516702, -224.4881006421173, -1050.575993605133, -407.2091086975243, -259.9299562372185, -908.2328524296572], + "butteraugli": [44.28265806558687, 42.00047549356707, 25.71195552342537, 34.19012902444953, 42.24199726631726, 38.53691179835288, 70.03170030881427, 30.82223115386687, 32.389232168755086, 30.927237834660804, 38.84401065014355, 50.09181112743621, 84.54047522871394, 37.1053076607667, 43.66686482122128, 57.23780593040349], + "dssim": [0.21013579975398042, 0.20131002829160372, 0.2074942855700812, 0.26774118590944035, 0.24443172394146329, 0.2764227761855305, 0.16224563544925127, 0.17032589306114873, 0.2828189434115859, 0.20784000332771893, 0.12615559122730488, 0.24266060790865632, 0.30134444491039014, 0.2623535308542609, 0.21552273329894048, 0.29575954870648774], + "alphaMae": [0.2050206570304178, 0.1699989076060752, 0.19046674201775304, 0.13206622445665014, 0.1526162508625151, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18211829621705242, 0.13071557847676107, 0.19449295343137254, 0.16616224336426683, 0.1429010763206311, 0.23913531321619558, 0.10648966239721695, 0.15631019394272233, 0.15650497137331496, 0.08070791715469373] + } + }, + { + "label": "A28@4 L9@4 C7@3", + "tune": "la1=9:4 ca=7:3 alpha_ac_count=28 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.434134679106377, 11.30029462537432, 7.134166356565696, 10.63108713921484, 12.460973526229765, 19.823276357409213, 11.393078093279017, 6.471452997204367, 13.731814497499101, 8.826230678242851, 6.344720075893558, 11.518935152541365, 27.676902369784372, 14.518339860182394, 11.471334259921813, 24.992288042493303], + "ssimulacra2": [-237.2823591942862, -193.8376631154314, -247.53801030182152, -228.0311562134818, -330.0063992665505, -776.9774394064202, -100.9091257618594, -81.16290353950643, -357.91030801040625, -151.48691428015698, -112.24904268788036, -225.0555807442707, -1049.4685216748376, -432.9870386394602, -262.62928930048656, -951.610882890369], + "butteraugli": [44.360330261832445, 41.69126738247103, 25.71195552342537, 34.46966592213806, 43.35719134688666, 38.63061174894091, 69.88381473205953, 30.799363716153664, 32.43838636133629, 31.059954281315612, 39.411319099185185, 50.322257972509455, 86.5094148473389, 36.80586109361703, 43.078768454336775, 64.75450273139377], + "dssim": [0.21009435275042945, 0.20163575484429366, 0.2074942855700812, 0.26802575260726574, 0.2446521559270699, 0.2765283269623492, 0.16218048646363753, 0.17053405346252273, 0.28347273799519673, 0.20902916083261067, 0.1267418772026336, 0.2427055533594337, 0.3013393411079726, 0.26227388284491443, 0.20874479518108838, 0.29585088774264356], + "alphaMae": [0.2050206570304178, 0.1699989076060752, 0.19046674201775304, 0.13206622445665014, 0.1526162508625151, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18211829621705242, 0.13071557847676107, 0.19449295343137254, 0.16616224336426683, 0.1429010763206311, 0.23913531321619558, 0.10648966239721695, 0.15631019394272233, 0.15650497137331496, 0.08070791715469373] + } + }, + { + "label": "A28@4 L6@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=6:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=28 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.43262871666492, 11.333484110865806, 7.134166356565696, 10.698575273214326, 12.287401015701247, 19.817490361639504, 11.391353031277722, 6.461662287956485, 13.81546514651866, 9.110043274314021, 6.379263569114909, 11.639935482841288, 27.802427575185202, 15.175794713378837, 11.475126664854024, 25.01761214120533], + "ssimulacra2": [-237.6597335302764, -195.4160150940219, -247.53801030182152, -232.0573371062045, -316.92296494970606, -777.1904204557732, -100.9146381677718, -82.00736663527984, -366.54723680659134, -160.7656027390835, -113.75867402764254, -226.64813724358385, -1052.634526248313, -453.77314736309694, -264.24296947533696, -949.5643517168118], + "butteraugli": [44.37017985972012, 41.74390996209821, 25.71195552342537, 34.71555182571433, 40.220475595762885, 38.61266060355356, 69.87113801429298, 31.273907625347153, 32.25593010888009, 31.36999430079751, 40.45024586797064, 50.79883906753667, 84.60511008010484, 37.43958070249332, 43.51675435354366, 64.33298684449856], + "dssim": [0.21012079388221128, 0.20325934364993556, 0.2074942855700812, 0.26842636342400183, 0.24480487579952093, 0.27652173844444644, 0.1622013736139626, 0.17158817720172423, 0.2847518650818064, 0.21009186776381905, 0.1273170296587159, 0.24300074371376992, 0.30172861349201757, 0.2633913100161494, 0.21463906093337082, 0.2957143819826764], + "alphaMae": [0.2050206570304178, 0.1699989076060752, 0.19046674201775304, 0.13206622445665014, 0.1526162508625151, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18211829621705242, 0.13071557847676107, 0.19449295343137254, 0.16616224336426683, 0.1429010763206311, 0.23913531321619558, 0.10648966239721695, 0.15631019394272233, 0.15650497137331496, 0.08070791715469373] + } + }, + { + "label": "A28@4 L10@4 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=10:4 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=28 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.421838166260526, 11.291715097602811, 7.131464872385199, 10.561943546312765, 12.450031250015705, 19.835765329654564, 11.385268314740147, 6.492729227554226, 13.708511516021707, 8.851841897418105, 6.3574318624674335, 11.520283003383435, 27.664457559384488, 14.539008596645623, 11.540531567292257, 24.489283379780776], + "ssimulacra2": [-237.55289208065736, -193.52367529567505, -247.56868458716568, -223.76983183658965, -327.81719421145567, -777.2068137831171, -100.92993563012197, -80.89544968991974, -357.6641988833255, -151.74850752866317, -112.52735157921695, -224.8334307555274, -1051.189404487409, -433.3801052604337, -262.46734198453197, -908.3138490658988], + "butteraugli": [44.33276608582446, 41.817369242358176, 25.764604712085305, 34.353148514964964, 42.49541104951138, 38.63368751792217, 69.97331826513617, 30.72494873799258, 32.467947706463434, 31.099273703012283, 39.29920152155342, 50.222498043304704, 86.2360490939153, 36.78711368393649, 43.21989268167993, 57.111138506148016], + "dssim": [0.21008369775945668, 0.19915411345444725, 0.2075102960062695, 0.26773395996404736, 0.24462466361066126, 0.27655322791660963, 0.1621421540930043, 0.17065703747035757, 0.28355518268937235, 0.20903429357423683, 0.12654538418620226, 0.24270531854614594, 0.301360039433602, 0.26228863485696324, 0.21077008598294636, 0.2957510297618667], + "alphaMae": [0.2050206570304178, 0.1699989076060752, 0.19046674201775304, 0.13206622445665014, 0.1526162508625151, 0.1410984385192433, 0.18211829621705242, 0.13071557847676107, 0.19449295343137254, 0.16616224336426683, 0.1429010763206311, 0.23913531321619558, 0.10648966239721695, 0.15631019394272233, 0.15650497137331496, 0.08070791715469373] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@3 L22@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=22:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.425026802028091, 11.977059152490256, 7.287889125632117, 10.64592008277645, 13.0113415218298, 19.504956556662016, 11.593671169358792, 6.918413099347087, 13.445133601138354, 9.095842922611466, 6.857137876848949, 11.259341716462856, 27.032021196759, 14.1683322784969, 11.897735787805763, 24.350983215158465], + "ssimulacra2": [-229.6092603157317, -200.63660952135547, -255.3090630288486, -214.3591739958324, -312.8491382981097, -749.8238137551322, -103.43997314168503, -90.81262456813329, -324.17705053901676, -159.7743006051833, -114.17934540837636, -212.61193630812076, -1017.977790088742, -456.32155201899815, -263.34346685827734, -879.9955164933854], + "butteraugli": [50.063196126307865, 46.742017573095474, 27.20583985676619, 32.37025212987769, 45.585789039986004, 38.094758782021074, 79.20283149305038, 35.604233099730294, 32.8471321162295, 35.694545119746515, 38.839610260407184, 50.48405904507842, 80.41546053111378, 39.18636516331916, 47.93471151824789, 54.58775416457121], + "dssim": [0.2106476123558451, 0.20410623613180479, 0.2046048566418782, 0.27859069044289336, 0.24546763145462216, 0.27621094845121685, 0.16374932300775277, 0.17542361432344442, 0.27917661035510766, 0.21059653283302615, 0.1382572027267096, 0.24441396747198108, 0.3001590644412156, 0.2620662808086364, 0.22045344020048505, 0.2974263708459585], + "alphaMae": [0.2029239622785734, 0.18898990916807296, 0.19421350923533828, 0.1553793298192771, 0.18557104339169686, 0.14464706901596253, 0.1822548925435953, 0.14954804375453884, 0.19038607999213836, 0.18839458055805017, 0.1647236818892081, 0.2338571839720737, 0.11372647849462365, 0.20502228510698886, 0.16452727972292433, 0.09805766920982995] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@3 L16@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=16:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.438933528387336, 11.975258099737813, 7.28700324243021, 10.814680360968152, 12.975409304688592, 19.603622186622584, 11.53515974323699, 6.899277796692073, 13.542562013047338, 9.091133094364565, 6.84692270765177, 11.364516411215343, 27.634186031924077, 14.63715894622325, 11.831132059581114, 24.432525535811184], + "ssimulacra2": [-230.28656799382307, -202.2680331095919, -255.2307536651742, -228.129395557903, -342.7882867397304, -759.9096242548736, -104.35404017265995, -91.01352954811686, -348.95756429612385, -163.6260658333155, -114.50993985069961, -216.29660174118354, -1054.6873972321184, -476.211421186652, -270.3086069985409, -889.5036021399841], + "butteraugli": [50.10532435918532, 46.49593475957291, 27.18386073108236, 32.86596866431213, 47.40591810601651, 38.24948848885754, 79.06260818888596, 36.20562103952575, 33.82648254037222, 35.982634450130156, 39.500538786281695, 52.63222587601703, 84.76892893406678, 41.10516209694205, 48.03343584777198, 54.887701328109415], + "dssim": [0.21069257937906558, 0.20558942680203005, 0.20460796717551158, 0.27907136175952796, 0.2470032699084532, 0.27615940823490154, 0.16357964930301397, 0.17728784686946195, 0.2809998951997881, 0.21118670130426995, 0.13851522033293207, 0.24437246205376342, 0.3020455812174998, 0.2622378892131864, 0.21298981354105742, 0.2976621241206811], + "alphaMae": [0.2029239622785734, 0.18898990916807296, 0.19421350923533828, 0.1553793298192771, 0.18557104339169686, 0.14464706901596253, 0.1822548925435953, 0.14954804375453884, 0.19038607999213836, 0.18839458055805017, 0.1647236818892081, 0.2338571839720737, 0.11372647849462365, 0.20502228510698886, 0.16452727972292433, 0.09805766920982995] + } + }, + { + "label": "A32@3 L16@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=16:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=32 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.277594528546622, 11.354238124258487, 7.171029490298818, 10.871015639927856, 12.464884475507317, 19.58599387956389, 10.999509196005205, 6.227733576118555, 13.54928369377973, 9.057376115395954, 6.440788548467135, 11.205878000285034, 27.71076463499428, 13.527379644233866, 11.445170294307891, 24.273560701316715], + "ssimulacra2": [-234.0314486988708, -190.2962389674848, -246.62626866536547, -223.51337112647295, -312.11038955908475, -757.734084316989, -97.1302389125503, -76.11174104148652, -354.6050240153349, -159.38374793255267, -113.81941311095387, -216.82036608234867, -1054.8900496774813, -390.73431846369334, -259.3633179858213, -883.1997985581652], + "butteraugli": [46.84852135877145, 44.69585612179342, 25.59571009969407, 32.550852454538, 42.913511564328566, 37.619637989762765, 61.470487398604114, 31.865583419630813, 34.9668735251651, 37.177819952789356, 38.45454890289064, 49.1109554111811, 84.61325084559013, 36.18423851309532, 41.01667299709278, 54.56219803192047], + "dssim": [0.20728193019032484, 0.20397439886086122, 0.20473865477138756, 0.28179369469412235, 0.2434110080950885, 0.27612979885009115, 0.16398924369608983, 0.1702969187247616, 0.2825521938888309, 0.2123617472187028, 0.13163508017464418, 0.23709317739030747, 0.301843719728059, 0.26184968890457144, 0.2164624807027442, 0.2987899514413609], + "alphaMae": [0.197126555287608, 0.17194128131529252, 0.1910165392874492, 0.15548975313016775, 0.16030516862170088, 0.14123885427458654, 0.164764237534153, 0.12203519312817719, 0.18401902255595634, 0.1832972390610188, 0.14547962661928523, 0.22540055558208133, 0.10815713110616455, 0.15727380552843542, 0.15151190664253983, 0.09858431480999479] + } + }, + { + "label": "A32@3 L10@4 C9@3", + "tune": "la1=10:4 ca=9:3 alpha_ac_count=32 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [12.322412001675538, 11.412447427956058, 7.173575691537703, 11.205255686483502, 12.475406735819083, 19.763499045597985, 10.908767212159669, 6.221544143704441, 13.693050887857003, 9.329354854119778, 6.449526374421292, 11.309839498183257, 27.65369020406315, 14.425753315115342, 11.349235431625466, 24.7120629373989], + "ssimulacra2": [-236.33459898535338, -195.32327573494504, -246.80516614267802, -237.65058458888726, -329.748514646507, -773.5702797713561, -97.63655828861026, -77.1550743959022, -362.05588230696236, -173.11286072509367, -114.55206572423418, -219.7201674650437, -1051.0685311644152, -426.20819242313337, -266.74521824991774, -923.9233120016685], + "butteraugli": [46.97617105704498, 44.405794102966524, 25.578976916072463, 34.63968084032336, 42.89923458258943, 38.17575527498437, 61.40493143851301, 31.9226260328377, 34.874083101140116, 38.443684630463885, 39.0437016825156, 48.87773102572685, 86.63134079014584, 37.58099651023097, 41.16553389558782, 57.53704813494435], + "dssim": [0.2073485793341975, 0.2033260204695241, 0.20477324263593044, 0.2829912684629919, 0.24474661567760023, 0.2764571741115719, 0.16364776360366196, 0.17166077537902824, 0.2826417160961039, 0.21430123952978572, 0.13164982725589405, 0.23713733399394785, 0.3018549131007278, 0.26285972615740855, 0.20643483003092503, 0.2988341374967677], + "alphaMae": [0.197126555287608, 0.17194128131529252, 0.1910165392874492, 0.15548975313016775, 0.16030516862170088, 0.14123885427458654, 0.164764237534153, 0.12203519312817719, 0.18401902255595634, 0.1832972390610188, 0.14547962661928523, 0.22540055558208133, 0.10815713110616455, 0.15727380552843542, 0.15151190664253983, 0.09858431480999479] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ceiling.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ceiling.json index 3ed9bfe..c7d3c66 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ceiling.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-ceiling.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-encoder.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-encoder.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5317ef8 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-encoder.json @@ -0,0 +1,214 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "alpha-encoder", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "§11.2 — bringing the alpha channel's quantizer up to the same generation as L/a/b. `alpha_ac_fit=1` routes alpha through `quantize_ac_channel`, so `scale_fit` (search the scale code by reconstruction SSE) and `ac_nearest` (pick the code nearest in reconstruction, not in the companded domain) apply to it. Both were adopted for the colour channels and were worth −0.43% and −0.05% there; alpha has never had either. The arms separate the two effects and check that neither depends on the layout. Every arm pins `alpha_ac_count` and `alpha_ac_bits` explicitly. A config that overrides only part of a layout inherits the rest from Tunables::DEFAULT, so when the default alpha allocation changed in §11.3 these arms silently stopped being 32 bytes — the same class of drift the corpus pins exist to prevent, in the knob space rather than the corpus.", + "corpus": "alpha", + "backdrops": "white-black-grey", + "alphaFidelity": true, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": 32, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/alpha-encoder.json", + "configSha256": "b774c211c61c1e0891689f26585769c7a5e6e5b459e09a123c5355ec44b7e327", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-greek", + "sha256": "28b9e4888cdcbfa13cafbb1b56d0ee1f515756b99b8f7ecc00a544ecaa85dc7c" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-soviet", + "sha256": "89e2d3f669b448c56e47a9c29de65121c60a3d9e9910c95499f0233817074d94" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", + "sha256": "559304d1f8226cfafa4de7685601a3d5dd0673e93365b7b8dc9093a2112849a9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-broccoli", + "sha256": "e7f19280e60b7f164bd53e68134040fa97c3efb539ff44edf2d985ccb3a48f8f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-cheeseburger", + "sha256": "cff8d8ac543defb51454a96a1513dafb43457a569f487030380128b76cfa760a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-dod-seal", + "sha256": "8a67df69e07c9e342bd9d7ac677e6a962ac0a39507881b531bdf88e9baabbaa9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-emblem-kscz", + "sha256": "c8095953b20fd2e8b0a2db22902f3353c5c7196ac35302e00dee221842afad43" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-game-sprite-ship", + "sha256": "0e731563527cb737e4f0ff4cff0fbb723fa3dced9d48ec8f72f0ad63945519ca" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-greek-vase-figure", + "sha256": "ff3e45df88805a10348a8fd92d1212a9410ebe6cce22d52e02ab1188d05a89f8" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-green-dragon", + "sha256": "4d02f29aec4e6de647874836130026e8c413b820b122af3bbddb56a61d097ea6" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lamp-glow", + "sha256": "857ef6d2b9fd450be843429cca5f49353705c52000647791bb7530de81de840f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lineart-hoe", + "sha256": "fd3ad52a4a82f4c685d05981ce3e54ddc35403e23945a3be62fb7b2986e6f142" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-navy-crest", + "sha256": "61eab4c1618ddbc8de9cbf78135492bee775be50d15a6eebd7335bf3be370643" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", + "sha256": "75951d906cb08acc1a643554dde538d739d3f814a5f5231a7971a96550ada98a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-planet-lava", + "sha256": "74b6ae59cbfef2fa11e59d29d51ed326b3c26a10ac40604eec9ccd94883ea9cc" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-road-sign", + "sha256": "56297cb398e82ca506d2057a4402218a1113f7acb38ac92e2c1b3f5e6d460122" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["cutout-3d-star-greek", "cutout-3d-star-soviet", "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", "cutout-broccoli", "cutout-cheeseburger", "cutout-dod-seal", "cutout-emblem-kscz", "cutout-game-sprite-ship", "cutout-greek-vase-figure", "cutout-green-dragon", "cutout-lamp-glow", "cutout-lineart-hoe", "cutout-navy-crest", "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", "cutout-planet-lava", "cutout-road-sign"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "DEFAULT (legacy alpha path)", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.51000789352154, 15.056892858460012, 7.5187010350087915, 14.394059764813425, 13.812336295445412, 20.782560258871694, 15.376532712566098, 11.407584653412059, 18.383817734476086, 15.079439020827897, 7.3056877204025765, 13.549681649598037, 27.822625681354847, 16.587655776859197, 13.7881888823225, 25.644279372887507], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.2776354565116, -224.00958121815452, -262.78109066711227, -317.65535006695495, -351.17846670317886, -785.9032933934126, -122.98000492710997, -128.28298441878937, -492.57995819615707, -218.59139364952964, -107.50015228362474, -248.85671035992632, -1058.5760225901865, -522.6689125580233, -287.6270415338086, -918.1895866950059], + "butteraugli": [49.00036642613143, 61.01134616913839, 29.703534202914103, 52.36375556899478, 45.90746854217857, 41.420957258126954, 89.85016343627838, 72.42014700331181, 51.674190638887886, 58.724000066391646, 42.11196589236203, 61.53141748341417, 83.0370995525546, 57.226388588873505, 57.477819718162095, 64.65165413760758], + "dssim": [0.22395011117746577, 0.2120820098314625, 0.21099713626534156, 0.29473993180948616, 0.2547215545729708, 0.28278339143285897, 0.18024956505578352, 0.20501764219111, 0.3104213001175085, 0.25064572089543086, 0.1454268412258631, 0.2559023129287772, 0.3047675021148124, 0.26226839903275545, 0.23635937279214922, 0.30451829728634966], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "alpha_ac_fit=1", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4 alpha_ac_fit=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.361629230220132, 15.056892858460012, 7.506688304208121, 14.5674319832108, 13.812336295445412, 20.634291910340114, 15.694881011551383, 11.385044771068594, 18.302108740535132, 14.693861929679846, 7.30894371640073, 13.52149638861391, 27.957397324190193, 16.602033172982107, 13.43244332861302, 25.644279372887507], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.91307318398148, -224.00958121815452, -262.3125601323729, -318.7521569279742, -351.17846670317886, -782.1183552505672, -121.6894670366241, -128.62389360024667, -491.82477854637636, -219.47016506227655, -106.1305197873108, -248.83129469256542, -1064.0442551032236, -523.0938385352832, -285.8820541974587, -918.1895866950059], + "butteraugli": [49.74156444175848, 61.01134616913839, 28.796811113438082, 51.166515299857565, 45.90746854217857, 40.57227435379818, 89.83452444823321, 71.06507301803819, 51.664046132686025, 61.456477566021555, 42.15496694785629, 61.59083270099831, 83.20800667430431, 56.782867478302286, 56.589965226484594, 64.65165413760758], + "dssim": [0.22109941878591358, 0.2120820098314625, 0.20053727892366802, 0.2968989985389505, 0.2547215545729708, 0.2827361786266066, 0.1819425286254707, 0.20571678560867257, 0.31041192297867554, 0.2475530044176882, 0.14727552044003908, 0.2559604498663808, 0.3049143059328088, 0.2623114136572573, 0.23283253487724886, 0.30451829728634966], + "alphaMae": [0.2655029287243066, 0.26262549973883, 0.2001815809375552, 0.29131029633238836, 0.2251093192959002, 0.21704688938931738, 0.2694730517719383, 0.2926029468500363, 0.35790867496762857, 0.39377184755899813, 0.18094435597182318, 0.3402815576988371, 0.19734881312947017, 0.2868660567183305, 0.21859317854339, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "alpha_ac_fit, scale_fit=1", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4 alpha_ac_fit=1 scale_fit=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.326909580681203, 15.104207348560934, 7.524940462124988, 14.398165598459299, 13.822668317999367, 20.88238342815725, 15.862797134012226, 11.408602695247064, 18.405901058240648, 14.938204684787559, 7.327705965684551, 13.553328429679643, 28.10562231893934, 16.634865802056765, 13.770680396838928, 25.639717624876624], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.0989860737071, -224.46289459644854, -263.25872425829226, -317.18625705433055, -350.94227492850786, -786.8144221044805, -119.69785687540673, -128.27055641512504, -494.0998796337229, -219.40910389780927, -107.69212566402477, -248.40696893326114, -1068.1494907352624, -523.7072676192157, -286.74860747792627, -918.1157297073819], + "butteraugli": [49.61354039869472, 60.93090402848517, 29.738578227538415, 52.318664723114544, 45.86466427575326, 41.48009793827737, 90.85074913034224, 72.46275913281191, 52.031113944285515, 61.40678042976618, 42.23466795998349, 61.62157359699967, 83.78706296356394, 57.240714173588735, 57.25273785567388, 64.65609005124497], + "dssim": [0.21987025985691755, 0.21574230754783805, 0.21049030021151136, 0.2947096120601302, 0.25467568684693803, 0.2828719349666953, 0.1835399963215771, 0.20500915037716486, 0.3103232417636325, 0.24975457456154238, 0.1433332068182692, 0.25592711571066845, 0.3050429907922436, 0.26231505126985477, 0.23814492222465633, 0.30451696667258527], + "alphaMae": [0.26328191267704265, 0.26262549973883, 0.20139968783121356, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.2765524706937078, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40429726478695804, 0.18039024695675188, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19878401267454873, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "alpha_ac_fit, no nearest", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4 alpha_ac_fit=1 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.361674185463727, 15.056892858460012, 7.507350978922415, 14.567608595212455, 13.83285688802543, 20.63946976894903, 15.696377680683797, 11.385044771068594, 18.302108740535132, 14.693861929679846, 7.30894371640073, 13.52149638861391, 27.957397324190193, 16.581943915014374, 13.43244332861302, 25.644279372887507], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.02482328903056, -224.00958121815452, -262.4244216548329, -317.9285483745427, -352.14016903126185, -782.3540211208078, -121.66732929417049, -128.62389360024667, -491.82477854637636, -219.47016506227655, -106.1305197873108, -248.83129469256542, -1064.0442551032236, -522.8133642414037, -285.8820541974587, -918.1895866950059], + "butteraugli": [49.73970476316299, 61.01134616913839, 28.798738873935733, 51.13779400865581, 46.19261166175637, 40.58040433555279, 89.83351758494148, 71.06507301803819, 51.664046132686025, 61.456477566021555, 42.15496694785629, 61.59083270099831, 83.20800667430431, 57.20068317927715, 56.589965226484594, 64.65165413760758], + "dssim": [0.22109169911610638, 0.2120820098314625, 0.20052181390154047, 0.29685318140459194, 0.2546144223208709, 0.2827415951610872, 0.181932231196118, 0.20571678560867257, 0.31041192297867554, 0.2475530044176882, 0.14727552044003908, 0.2559604498663808, 0.3049143059328088, 0.2622895997184897, 0.23283253487724886, 0.30451829728634966], + "alphaMae": [0.2655029287243066, 0.26262549973883, 0.2001815809375552, 0.29131029633238836, 0.22499696772037261, 0.21704688938931738, 0.2694730517719383, 0.2926029468500363, 0.35790867496762857, 0.39377184755899813, 0.18094435597182318, 0.3402815576988371, 0.19734881312947017, 0.2868660567183305, 0.21859317854339, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "alpha_ac_fit, no fit no near", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4 alpha_ac_fit=1 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.503955442823667, 15.126490493523221, 7.520820768780498, 14.30973370718588, 13.787978074432774, 20.89562758661056, 15.384203480468477, 11.365920957394067, 18.422893891798186, 15.13130463430465, 7.342382927065639, 13.611117758552053, 27.84358813591989, 16.507318545014964, 13.795342728941819, 25.693307480255925], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.1057685790502, -223.46149375517666, -263.08710116439016, -314.2960212966245, -346.2424280823963, -787.8049770056869, -123.11121011585618, -127.74637368887291, -493.97882427637086, -219.94532972281817, -107.6012520625025, -249.44378926626996, -1056.8456098504082, -523.0206344147292, -286.5836900619736, -917.7403726391489], + "butteraugli": [48.98331078606686, 61.19562610644153, 29.727885783398122, 53.12043436071591, 46.38911317205498, 41.42651864291961, 89.91606021368081, 72.3329889998857, 51.852780015599194, 58.99734702905446, 42.0530897835118, 62.121954842273766, 82.79764482968149, 58.12900270132318, 57.31976648049427, 64.68642040313043], + "dssim": [0.22394729023953178, 0.21546899496865937, 0.2109265598074849, 0.29449587176345315, 0.2543680484395811, 0.28282842096875543, 0.17966668361822755, 0.20472164449334632, 0.31030802711303784, 0.25075273446001606, 0.14348335503668455, 0.2560284534999053, 0.30462446075573113, 0.26214682723512667, 0.23958349698041514, 0.30452008439050904], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "legacy, no fit no near", + "tune": "la1=20:5 ca=9:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.503955442823667, 15.126490493523221, 7.520820768780498, 14.30973370718588, 13.787978074432774, 20.89562758661056, 15.384203480468477, 11.365920957394067, 18.422893891798186, 15.13130463430465, 7.342382927065639, 13.611117758552053, 27.84358813591989, 16.507318545014964, 13.795342728941819, 25.693307480255925], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.1057685790502, -223.46149375517666, -263.08710116439016, -314.2960212966245, -346.2424280823963, -787.8049770056869, -123.11121011585618, -127.74637368887291, -493.97882427637086, -219.94532972281817, -107.6012520625025, -249.44378926626996, -1056.8456098504082, -523.0206344147292, -286.5836900619736, -917.7403726391489], + "butteraugli": [48.98331078606686, 61.19562610644153, 29.727885783398122, 53.12043436071591, 46.38911317205498, 41.42651864291961, 89.91606021368081, 72.3329889998857, 51.852780015599194, 58.99734702905446, 42.0530897835118, 62.121954842273766, 82.79764482968149, 58.12900270132318, 57.31976648049427, 64.68642040313043], + "dssim": [0.22394729023953178, 0.21546899496865937, 0.2109265598074849, 0.29449587176345315, 0.2543680484395811, 0.28282842096875543, 0.17966668361822755, 0.20472164449334632, 0.31030802711303784, 0.25075273446001606, 0.14348335503668455, 0.2560284534999053, 0.30462446075573113, 0.26214682723512667, 0.23958349698041514, 0.30452008439050904], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "alpha_ac_fit @ L22@4 C14@3", + "tune": "alpha_ac_fit=1 la1=22:4 ca=14:3 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.332666995453456, 14.899719014018958, 7.489746904659907, 14.46297969755912, 13.562526430179767, 20.292863748552907, 15.915902493567707, 11.276200254892473, 18.211642828245996, 14.63042384205968, 7.3027972373406795, 13.483783644961187, 27.943900433871704, 15.96952751602173, 13.19323610662704, 25.138841302322714], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.57114450704208, -221.0230625732364, -262.27170489201166, -314.1252305225987, -324.44980383328675, -773.392242512649, -121.77231778237613, -127.16574373044877, -481.7556492225769, -218.91777045292258, -106.14800962641357, -248.5204188674545, -1058.7183723550145, -504.4166081004889, -280.41205988177757, -902.6386430322979], + "butteraugli": [49.78604679219472, 60.858504242613286, 28.720021936028047, 51.4403403151388, 44.83173811504762, 40.23100003434768, 89.73180821417496, 71.236676200884, 51.572445632760804, 61.89022636582917, 42.15949314882838, 61.07739717034062, 83.49882563578699, 53.76445263670575, 56.196934943427955, 64.89659141987615], + "dssim": [0.22107507121167433, 0.21417637293254463, 0.20066558108798946, 0.2967302788886925, 0.2526871975960052, 0.28265205559581014, 0.18147832983814682, 0.2040262967222807, 0.3098682015468217, 0.24767808517681136, 0.14747692467833468, 0.25591802491996335, 0.30485195658330166, 0.2616051641836185, 0.22497412628014465, 0.30431705031705936], + "alphaMae": [0.2655029287243066, 0.26262549973883, 0.2001815809375552, 0.29131029633238836, 0.2251093192959002, 0.21704688938931738, 0.2694730517719383, 0.2926029468500363, 0.35790867496762857, 0.39377184755899813, 0.18094435597182318, 0.3402815576988371, 0.19734881312947017, 0.2868660567183305, 0.21859317854339, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "legacy @ L22@4 C14@3", + "tune": "la1=22:4 ca=14:3 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.484262091544418, 14.899719014018958, 7.503210170011266, 14.28760467556757, 13.562526430179767, 20.434994481553712, 15.60384682351829, 11.299819713720765, 18.292328243574485, 15.027035568186923, 7.296218067368368, 13.51076321361573, 27.81379815187484, 15.962897857311589, 13.53962684169199, 25.138841302322714], + "ssimulacra2": [-252.960001376235, -221.0230625732364, -262.7114568897689, -313.08606492753086, -324.44980383328675, -777.6024509171971, -123.13570377181888, -127.03917544228932, -482.2497242034004, -217.90134889308402, -107.29431949604118, -248.0551909770627, -1053.4151859431058, -504.21637152724225, -282.44726603806004, -902.6386430322979], + "butteraugli": [49.0433556268222, 60.858504242613286, 29.631088439592386, 52.57972439189274, 44.83173811504762, 41.05502035111578, 89.87682169027569, 72.55574440016574, 51.92467523864192, 59.28064279166902, 42.09775056522731, 60.997105243526256, 83.30484618716493, 54.254103015888525, 57.074639798477925, 64.89659141987615], + "dssim": [0.22392767150494927, 0.21417637293254463, 0.21108685024180707, 0.29462143598686374, 0.2526871975960052, 0.2826974956688224, 0.17984127081772314, 0.20366653697246714, 0.30981378031352486, 0.2506902344801318, 0.14553463579964668, 0.2558564219722195, 0.30469745850960356, 0.2615789662066375, 0.2290988212421955, 0.30431705031705936], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-fields.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-fields.json index f00dd53..f380856 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-fields.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-fields.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout-control.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout-control.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6adc124 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout-control.json @@ -0,0 +1,440 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "alpha-layout-control", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "SS11.1 control - the same alpha-corpus images, flattened to opaque and encoded in the format's opaque mode. The alpha corpus is cut-outs, insignia and line art, and the graphics corpus independently prefers more luma than photographs do; without this control, 'alpha mode wants a different layout' and 'this content wants a different layout' are the same measurement. If the opaque optimum on these images sits near the photographic optimum, the alpha-mode shift belongs to alpha mode; if it moves the same way, it belongs to the content.", + "corpus": "alpha", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": true, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/alpha-layout-control.json", + "configSha256": "9252811f673367bbb5eb9d60e0344578e31d34166076ef955c648c52a3bc75a6", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-greek", + "sha256": "28b9e4888cdcbfa13cafbb1b56d0ee1f515756b99b8f7ecc00a544ecaa85dc7c" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-soviet", + "sha256": "89e2d3f669b448c56e47a9c29de65121c60a3d9e9910c95499f0233817074d94" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", + "sha256": "559304d1f8226cfafa4de7685601a3d5dd0673e93365b7b8dc9093a2112849a9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-broccoli", + "sha256": "e7f19280e60b7f164bd53e68134040fa97c3efb539ff44edf2d985ccb3a48f8f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-cheeseburger", + "sha256": "cff8d8ac543defb51454a96a1513dafb43457a569f487030380128b76cfa760a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-dod-seal", + "sha256": "8a67df69e07c9e342bd9d7ac677e6a962ac0a39507881b531bdf88e9baabbaa9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-emblem-kscz", + "sha256": "c8095953b20fd2e8b0a2db22902f3353c5c7196ac35302e00dee221842afad43" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-game-sprite-ship", + "sha256": "0e731563527cb737e4f0ff4cff0fbb723fa3dced9d48ec8f72f0ad63945519ca" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-greek-vase-figure", + "sha256": "ff3e45df88805a10348a8fd92d1212a9410ebe6cce22d52e02ab1188d05a89f8" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-green-dragon", + "sha256": "4d02f29aec4e6de647874836130026e8c413b820b122af3bbddb56a61d097ea6" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lamp-glow", + "sha256": "857ef6d2b9fd450be843429cca5f49353705c52000647791bb7530de81de840f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lineart-hoe", + "sha256": "fd3ad52a4a82f4c685d05981ce3e54ddc35403e23945a3be62fb7b2986e6f142" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-navy-crest", + "sha256": "61eab4c1618ddbc8de9cbf78135492bee775be50d15a6eebd7335bf3be370643" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", + "sha256": "75951d906cb08acc1a643554dde538d739d3f814a5f5231a7971a96550ada98a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-planet-lava", + "sha256": "74b6ae59cbfef2fa11e59d29d51ed326b3c26a10ac40604eec9ccd94883ea9cc" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-road-sign", + "sha256": "56297cb398e82ca506d2057a4402218a1113f7acb38ac92e2c1b3f5e6d460122" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["cutout-3d-star-greek", "cutout-3d-star-soviet", "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", "cutout-broccoli", "cutout-cheeseburger", "cutout-dod-seal", "cutout-emblem-kscz", "cutout-game-sprite-ship", "cutout-greek-vase-figure", "cutout-green-dragon", "cutout-lamp-glow", "cutout-lineart-hoe", "cutout-navy-crest", "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", "cutout-planet-lava", "cutout-road-sign"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "v0.6 shape L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.392817911851782, 16.72492791520949, 9.397466376426662, 13.39157341817883, 12.316435577223439, 20.949559394936486, 15.701538100469879, 11.072967787837753, 16.569016725004857, 11.726841267807222, 10.572619033248085, 10.01184969359816, 28.424422921827343, 13.06048656446615, 14.506329567365592, 24.059361139825732], + "ssimulacra2": [-270.4940738381447, -283.4147504776143, -275.0098696716925, -307.7620442740301, -179.6514605163337, -702.4761270140629, -112.9909616310697, -153.9002599436262, -328.1339393434836, -199.35286217266798, -151.23994495262343, -176.5825045516085, -983.8871290566751, -427.58411164016604, -275.59716464566634, -823.5908296814926], + "butteraugli": [56.31505826787866, 63.12123533732851, 38.94517631906039, 42.94468386305092, 44.44269824320613, 48.8510330200223, 78.70690296294784, 61.755974664593076, 45.608051447831514, 51.976024527845105, 47.02525410511138, 43.47941017369732, 83.44617932850434, 34.21662509145208, 54.21498021765969, 47.17686372079361], + "dssim": [0.14826633114652799, 0.191849470637032, 0.12068999985734452, 0.25117884608077, 0.2036701197160935, 0.25638331422246174, 0.12614183813522079, 0.16886486899416614, 0.2786428391643557, 0.17930866789898953, 0.10801005619719195, 0.17899144117968602, 0.28902721664013076, 0.25149536384229276, 0.24385091171226397, 0.27751793164946137] + } + }, + { + "label": "DEFAULT L28@4 C15@3", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.85703427627244, 14.77255336745978, 9.082795678020585, 12.842680355599247, 12.05664299950183, 20.96037689204998, 14.440047409999282, 10.510437856468972, 16.659466805438804, 11.042576504121236, 10.503770878454485, 10.038379639085543, 27.547336995051964, 12.602107028485795, 14.38232942791702, 23.47538115133551], + "ssimulacra2": [-259.7921856230412, -278.4748122912074, -271.72624889657124, -298.36035365723995, -179.38571715135566, -690.3944173693753, -113.07792732305472, -125.59232930478305, -323.34561364652006, -158.7588660241908, -152.62115026902086, -178.0192895592645, -940.2172547881294, -430.97090046829476, -277.36469465399375, -814.1367634249057], + "butteraugli": [59.10007581823957, 63.00499183478693, 39.01786663711907, 43.45192564967565, 44.81704891533855, 46.52488698024709, 81.92271236977292, 58.56340266924283, 45.181336489634454, 54.21460948725072, 46.029781151434825, 43.3347368315568, 74.65761814584086, 32.137626040043905, 53.248434898012356, 46.5596741648628], + "dssim": [0.14696913382468263, 0.18396079632545703, 0.12143731994034429, 0.25143671720475436, 0.2042504520298642, 0.25628690621871364, 0.12493616634346116, 0.16592698219512653, 0.2787902139468479, 0.1777176788218791, 0.1103416667264061, 0.17889055225075995, 0.2891127182825719, 0.25344437950844567, 0.24916249670995216, 0.27771485919758954] + } + }, + { + "label": "L46@4 C2@3", + "tune": "l1=46:4 c=2:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.042414167057366, 17.72635869162667, 9.391207339232412, 15.1318832419332, 14.094886805300074, 21.465643130504727, 17.050442654099406, 9.485646025198475, 15.138354193169675, 10.634482114262035, 10.268907569723245, 9.80550633813082, 26.44062365896946, 12.301421039589348, 13.704784324334739, 24.675837219084205], + "ssimulacra2": [-229.95760804231196, -239.46073902714193, -262.17183720847714, -267.6265763271636, -109.44906941557855, -689.893536799035, -80.86889553748449, -91.01984515251073, -237.3072435737617, -113.57579470919461, -137.83495959499362, -168.3303454785792, -870.2289641148242, -378.0098838623861, -234.53671918852757, -793.1800087044132], + "butteraugli": [51.007533535127884, 56.03659789250671, 35.383549432142964, 33.42562104858579, 36.55079189971747, 43.027444999411294, 85.29662944673673, 40.6707862730519, 39.761424458457036, 40.45591309743519, 44.45693708355486, 39.94609127383722, 70.83287821265391, 30.756448335236968, 42.946923339537115, 46.06239949988342], + "dssim": [0.14907798687231383, 0.1936093098947156, 0.12222552794494868, 0.2509046920746355, 0.19949055217121803, 0.25751414399232453, 0.1304446563520491, 0.16245290076841706, 0.2744678141089245, 0.17834552240465845, 0.11399691588038402, 0.1801642451015077, 0.2916464944578866, 0.2555731824568501, 0.21447276677333948, 0.27749111837139906] + } + }, + { + "label": "L26@4 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=26:4 c=16:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.994474799750602, 14.887682807337814, 9.165801746114054, 12.803440179349778, 12.02123497896636, 21.051806452558637, 14.371381348715413, 11.325112414401397, 16.72591336504461, 11.51798850483698, 10.60108262543291, 10.041372029260552, 28.705808020029508, 13.161188485313023, 14.407071137109723, 23.459047666920863], + "ssimulacra2": [-265.0468435300721, -286.1940928410633, -275.0142905495504, -298.8789433151036, -180.02852762690475, -700.5285834837047, -114.30480564336219, -154.41827061218896, -329.0988179799483, -195.18549818954818, -149.854954332641, -177.01437571539321, -984.8346869183151, -427.87861820811906, -280.15492673550807, -812.0449697449282], + "butteraugli": [58.86947206389592, 62.979590469391844, 39.62463285604487, 43.3607970380886, 45.76047901788238, 48.18052876034591, 82.9538734494514, 52.57836803296072, 45.21670280004064, 54.14100531189263, 47.07971876873674, 43.676187101239826, 83.01992943761303, 34.24025262238992, 53.12245242146605, 46.77216794021928], + "dssim": [0.14712589400184228, 0.18402038763740192, 0.12105604846594137, 0.2511319365625787, 0.2039331862347254, 0.2562332675993382, 0.12474827553362328, 0.16815065848420296, 0.2778088228802943, 0.17922110261100777, 0.10840039775386473, 0.17878334244280142, 0.2892374810744035, 0.25118804640949277, 0.24854016740524837, 0.27746176049037197] + } + }, + { + "label": "L4@4 C31@3", + "tune": "l1=4:4 c=31:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [16.90490830957668, 18.846393274600942, 9.664397975518591, 17.159869325628133, 17.629177701067356, 22.694511640032985, 16.591685430710292, 21.111421205815308, 24.529216661091734, 21.89782349033668, 12.05578359274935, 10.428631480743672, 30.774179037863714, 15.80794595770276, 24.189301550191765, 24.93131565185038], + "ssimulacra2": [-269.3738134365546, -313.5783724581522, -285.8203628519708, -377.90861157435785, -312.02804755506287, -748.1848551243947, -116.10736997892496, -219.45227933250692, -564.1224134883039, -290.44869160132896, -136.3798735562422, -180.28054992596424, -1029.99138046294, -488.61005326762995, -411.17548832746655, -885.2476787705145], + "butteraugli": [74.01133064325408, 87.36248571483084, 43.224185708157165, 81.39735149607371, 87.37111053926124, 75.91235685606796, 82.31711153245018, 141.39819725122038, 102.4213861464453, 113.64767688898769, 59.747587432692036, 51.53748954868494, 98.32021826757064, 60.87518646756049, 147.62670787245665, 56.35273675400009], + "dssim": [0.14555087597665856, 0.18269824654190842, 0.11989836185808395, 0.25267385882717, 0.21477833984645384, 0.2581773492470989, 0.12831809075243333, 0.18279082655698226, 0.28569312459944085, 0.1933399195844982, 0.10190753319935114, 0.17761845621248107, 0.29144493533308446, 0.25162803114390886, 0.26966918603259504, 0.27705321367872593] + } + }, + { + "label": "L36@5 C2@4", + "tune": "l1=36:5 c=2:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.424594612714255, 18.34038107007814, 9.501693007100092, 15.493862375090227, 14.524253251169068, 22.003509362774988, 17.420032845505272, 9.331399252710622, 16.23151730948042, 11.204609769298784, 10.422169894501723, 9.859860361949865, 26.675823812456716, 12.284859089603128, 14.562220330667591, 24.67841064734029], + "ssimulacra2": [-260.1861110830071, -263.3431211423866, -269.3311110415231, -287.55909201258186, -133.31024603096586, -696.4893436010627, -90.31985873008068, -87.16083424209455, -298.63146136834666, -127.02658590580711, -147.44548302251104, -169.2014236186924, -889.6532560307946, -382.1770392977874, -241.18639846532017, -799.3586014089612], + "butteraugli": [50.1024471292336, 58.236766072833156, 37.005197962246534, 35.091157570594696, 38.71569382025671, 45.7072030416806, 88.48675145315342, 45.836203573640255, 44.698240104477755, 41.61419035156795, 45.223114311969596, 41.88210757778825, 70.16835763551666, 31.063724162573617, 50.900405266576, 46.792957805054506], + "dssim": [0.1489306814383617, 0.19231228930358207, 0.12142182260777273, 0.24970137002287168, 0.2015345531317972, 0.25787103669960576, 0.12902232740965425, 0.15824637968258298, 0.27318206510761833, 0.17718427670842057, 0.11134922401249336, 0.17986343624006107, 0.28894149615614917, 0.25444537664588773, 0.221592249232326, 0.27743705248769557] + } + }, + { + "label": "L21@5 C12@4", + "tune": "l1=21:5 c=12:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [15.212591570470012, 17.82863247003851, 9.465624577028848, 13.300783031325304, 13.252245852521186, 21.08996859113254, 16.188529214442855, 11.416231756954426, 16.779596286365532, 11.79839977611719, 10.887521160857549, 9.968737847840966, 29.24648912531599, 13.00852907012585, 15.851214910957943, 23.531095596194135], + "ssimulacra2": [-287.9125110010518, -315.571300232962, -283.19819257078956, -316.9315657330267, -190.83819496648186, -717.5177031446436, -124.63692525141545, -163.73805172185894, -344.8833603958682, -203.44503231196114, -156.6137836219039, -176.65034133966208, -1011.0147132533189, -430.11785836962315, -318.08164584648273, -823.1980868237422], + "butteraugli": [66.72047505758552, 64.82711603077199, 41.900566477108185, 49.05745506288923, 50.562805079371294, 49.36972458681506, 86.72102962394102, 57.28145980184505, 46.584848639615394, 54.59870931333137, 49.05076904020742, 44.24729089634004, 91.08535248135784, 34.22747418596284, 76.1448083305641, 47.644776524759756], + "dssim": [0.14557843506866242, 0.18670879624703535, 0.12029653850600469, 0.25225178211575183, 0.2050203984557606, 0.25569828875781275, 0.12567192414037315, 0.16637191907420107, 0.2768937342870702, 0.17874762702917063, 0.10687232350218773, 0.17882572536694608, 0.28970769481511727, 0.25176888820299925, 0.2549305598172509, 0.27778290663726246] + } + }, + { + "label": "L5@5 C22@4", + "tune": "l1=5:5 c=22:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [15.587231413117788, 19.060334715336314, 9.576779591073905, 16.887044457080286, 15.157309177383084, 22.800856110571264, 16.881014115370906, 19.681118943688727, 24.527112804249004, 21.625901658023125, 11.776466905400074, 10.465637076342515, 30.583645785153863, 15.735391795044292, 18.02870874316248, 24.8185986226128], + "ssimulacra2": [-266.94922790251843, -311.00738916963337, -288.76777618421056, -372.9783743174844, -243.59084280668526, -763.7743685267782, -121.3280056595076, -210.2360918920848, -565.9626618678626, -297.80463153610293, -146.48263268764364, -181.34481471121308, -1014.9865908424956, -488.54322627815975, -328.8765359595871, -875.0727104935858], + "butteraugli": [64.05699796715204, 87.06358778159439, 43.958608119582685, 76.6200461042563, 60.60795487779264, 54.62907716686726, 86.469405747015, 142.6595731334994, 102.36378206183862, 113.64402026487066, 55.193483564517614, 50.10722665389121, 98.56703938972494, 59.38477701543713, 89.14313354871162, 52.80161104766582], + "dssim": [0.1438941259369298, 0.1838286104559848, 0.11974988832772288, 0.2524399781966006, 0.213986851229858, 0.25736250265018046, 0.12739655045662907, 0.17791749229810067, 0.2853198068997518, 0.19270691772978832, 0.10320448038135654, 0.17761685843521335, 0.2918433313721094, 0.2515718574545319, 0.26282289857157803, 0.27675472993549033] + } + }, + { + "label": "L61@3 C2@3", + "tune": "l1=61:3 c=2:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.610208084268441, 17.89449020283819, 9.413637880124716, 15.391864543999901, 14.530435562978347, 21.140837876995718, 16.44469127924822, 9.675631326852145, 15.702232348865687, 11.505321841615519, 9.998903628603003, 9.754933715932257, 24.75427570261005, 12.288326576565858, 13.698906369958243, 24.547320411471077], + "ssimulacra2": [-195.2322627764088, -250.10685958706108, -261.8900534338812, -223.51428156646983, -120.38781958054031, -662.4564525961239, -76.40485932897181, -95.95149516701949, -234.4014112343898, -144.19972421124453, -126.41392798048577, -159.99154556294638, -733.2474530150946, -368.0513284572488, -274.26537617826403, -791.9874205601678], + "butteraugli": [43.10081993855069, 53.960822384511935, 35.39745876549785, 40.97861720378972, 52.558445920456904, 43.8951321118465, 85.60687777811013, 57.481283624871764, 42.96221642060737, 55.70055433830263, 43.88392736877697, 39.645768661686816, 58.621649767764154, 31.159695432417113, 47.3325638044381, 45.01656721133833], + "dssim": [0.1513686775993972, 0.1971467941394211, 0.12292458380022803, 0.25215478927102475, 0.20346516108757612, 0.2569531547869367, 0.13249552385378943, 0.168267531096217, 0.2750912334642358, 0.18194945802548257, 0.11478229420279923, 0.18094190288078577, 0.293615714680592, 0.25732278889904736, 0.2161421980041915, 0.2804811247754456] + } + }, + { + "label": "L35@3 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=35:3 c=16:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.657319366342694, 15.430217029885323, 9.13933346250566, 13.043854984151745, 12.51773045101274, 20.948072783220606, 13.41892143221577, 10.092625558431822, 16.55595218123287, 11.643856186890192, 10.48268197480046, 9.911946319649164, 26.72451845033972, 12.31589690554294, 14.024091472380688, 23.425583133028063], + "ssimulacra2": [-259.53302984197313, -298.1435482796892, -269.1323821749415, -301.61353219927315, -157.76882362560139, -693.6321211639822, -103.31753845664937, -105.63496180261635, -309.11613812844394, -150.2746068838565, -153.7950724217316, -171.13206217131267, -891.3862384981892, -396.60017558102567, -265.77597113637097, -790.2606455810547], + "butteraugli": [57.79974589587464, 59.44046095126951, 39.92525646136733, 45.36074864015498, 41.9415320874802, 47.27335304316538, 72.35036364919812, 78.95705961143038, 43.74608919336007, 54.84435202421111, 46.22192343041738, 43.13916127872839, 70.34730476079376, 31.76256365762825, 54.80462874668269, 46.22401548192147], + "dssim": [0.1479833943542081, 0.1837208073319505, 0.12080555022619249, 0.2504589795402391, 0.20495619810907245, 0.25654530205797577, 0.1258994147462193, 0.16657619094132464, 0.2758110642012189, 0.18017130553092597, 0.11039533718885819, 0.17978758000332729, 0.29021476238663824, 0.2543567552864462, 0.2320939544007103, 0.2776921396526002] + } + }, + { + "label": "L5@3 C31@3", + "tune": "l1=5:3 c=31:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [15.807020970240751, 18.989823749777482, 9.670759007953457, 17.341797989827807, 15.006460802928709, 22.1241984620703, 16.552089245879213, 19.880476846403468, 24.69013493839047, 21.916572207154214, 11.782359307136595, 10.49734593008119, 30.58979416587773, 15.687571633948927, 17.826318266519294, 24.774524021194832], + "ssimulacra2": [-259.52295389374007, -310.7513149409619, -286.8623373286762, -361.34186050312746, -247.04235096852477, -757.8236653696853, -116.13239786272783, -208.65539984211387, -564.160014208203, -293.0899573107874, -147.5481705676066, -181.61600068078263, -1016.8817825783804, -486.5816369854035, -333.78942257903253, -876.7484920992696], + "butteraugli": [61.995112637127704, 89.48401123933668, 42.63100962854825, 82.05164167418842, 75.830298721179, 53.45774835643493, 82.11204080562794, 152.56640490401466, 101.25695905328719, 112.0801086979186, 55.585216050397634, 50.25901270803058, 99.2459311025699, 63.86027914605885, 84.69958274106631, 52.22132415230687], + "dssim": [0.1445256313696925, 0.1829136541635185, 0.12011723326414864, 0.2524290770853952, 0.21341633866355442, 0.25666204375384727, 0.12827194741890963, 0.17945659976898076, 0.28605705270758597, 0.1928153808137994, 0.10323983666718745, 0.17766949098042, 0.2919476746333841, 0.2517624348604006, 0.26485071346131217, 0.27678641778498303] + } + }, + { + "label": "L63@3 C2@2", + "tune": "l1=63:3 c=2:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [13.634855607986703, 17.877503311030747, 9.397729251243735, 15.424327092084699, 14.362785740938609, 20.997513582649194, 16.267151941959852, 9.831893351496564, 15.434285358107381, 11.570939112825739, 10.13947552610809, 9.777519862639208, 24.72393196471549, 12.294561783436546, 13.697466895485912, 24.564441458517106], + "ssimulacra2": [-194.91493632116908, -250.46694009961988, -261.3582160402674, -238.60164463106287, -106.60939205382377, -644.8886645709786, -73.45825646581102, -95.88240499195769, -220.74886048365306, -143.98922309345357, -126.14421172475977, -162.12035239203084, -731.5734675824807, -356.26246308600514, -274.6803665169282, -791.7280970157467], + "butteraugli": [42.77153040316849, 53.94349424527775, 35.24035713543793, 40.49028187209277, 47.8645433210746, 42.40432786653016, 85.95649329698288, 57.25504359255456, 40.331352919722015, 55.67194899747502, 43.929962323017605, 39.59804135920775, 61.55338128771939, 31.07486289932636, 47.1921060170687, 45.04439432055054], + "dssim": [0.15137125157719078, 0.1971851223044478, 0.12298002720395074, 0.2528200333621018, 0.20189666542039858, 0.25668486067250884, 0.13186564964086994, 0.16810551190458728, 0.27512116662357544, 0.18204991597876263, 0.11504583484461589, 0.1812152781361056, 0.2950879714631558, 0.25677280194471586, 0.21613397659591066, 0.2804882101925251] + } + }, + { + "label": "L37@3 C21@2", + "tune": "l1=37:3 c=21:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.483724306027291, 15.915733158031841, 9.146403866453213, 13.961560875268992, 13.130631184105273, 20.919342887534242, 15.02435965487961, 10.173074034939491, 16.67936318589617, 11.76476880439975, 10.481181402901361, 9.923731756587824, 26.647200130542274, 12.373048186258524, 13.914277591055306, 23.57856510547131], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.31110303552703, -288.0643664310551, -270.85658371412296, -301.09729958333196, -150.43395522093562, -694.6287622922114, -100.70332047495285, -101.85987087430166, -309.4060568363625, -153.85174494109737, -147.21436302738906, -169.83685382799075, -896.5280256997216, -396.586886815591, -276.11820347228786, -776.3358438280408], + "butteraugli": [55.35440916137438, 60.21958050412464, 38.947963318735496, 44.58729024368697, 40.818555062251015, 46.34456958904692, 73.69149856159807, 67.52954501243096, 43.56579578097976, 52.804301138718984, 45.77807802657926, 43.127366241351616, 70.78461739984324, 31.761555395641775, 57.99601626555921, 46.140462949702474], + "dssim": [0.14759652734345347, 0.1832994661852141, 0.12093874800685694, 0.2506836518540866, 0.20376339499432272, 0.2562563609273171, 0.1277873827660847, 0.16586443606440543, 0.2767946094139455, 0.18186006516347547, 0.11150117337786486, 0.17987469084734953, 0.2900077805591126, 0.25441060646149904, 0.23722968039331604, 0.27822058341687617] + } + }, + { + "label": "L15@3 C39@2", + "tune": "l1=15:3 c=39:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [15.505513106459833, 17.931583289299958, 9.274772175930364, 15.39527664898234, 15.136790568053344, 20.72229790004151, 17.325260720653482, 12.046513664360239, 18.457313284894408, 14.323899383322459, 11.267777956014722, 10.157458013824646, 29.831731840524593, 14.211643403189212, 16.346154576562782, 23.65946564727975], + "ssimulacra2": [-279.78837709902444, -330.6232388803402, -287.96297740326713, -357.1440188231426, -245.6381506544273, -720.2046432698833, -126.78656087790176, -174.09622213576074, -395.73824673091457, -258.23392401801135, -156.38889604894905, -180.20702599293662, -994.233047581683, -459.6658223110069, -342.0722598601766, -769.0627667986009], + "butteraugli": [71.16201349220762, 78.63180799812146, 41.222780089896695, 72.58596492430509, 55.03988556505734, 50.53484281167397, 83.31710251641196, 84.42657030107053, 49.63376593073257, 75.15507691403674, 50.61228966616407, 46.52890892142327, 92.77001428461058, 38.01244279829286, 67.54361633940589, 47.03976350949325], + "dssim": [0.14487210936745504, 0.18013032986443617, 0.12017491302231736, 0.25217446884027084, 0.2133734211113541, 0.2550928213164696, 0.13177908872408595, 0.16877636876331886, 0.28019598333275464, 0.1824116565487341, 0.10661290418376163, 0.17856653941831596, 0.29130612570813064, 0.2508491322216334, 0.25363268251309967, 0.27735835832388933] + } + }, + { + "label": "L47@4 C2@2", + "tune": "l1=47:4 c=2:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.067745246886082, 17.53223927725817, 9.361604448241074, 15.12020190150312, 14.038445522865526, 21.467710498302903, 17.04545260247264, 9.648353384675037, 15.169218506310633, 10.669999486996781, 10.326337580838098, 9.771755239925339, 26.21915657021879, 12.367528777346383, 13.734948197616653, 24.67892599977849], + "ssimulacra2": [-226.7516629599428, -236.84767260829017, -262.12674547705, -266.26594320721085, -109.63465530041191, -690.8863561212444, -80.95193793856475, -90.94993933876844, -237.14289659678434, -111.95406611922948, -135.4705329457098, -166.60581799533293, -865.288188782406, -378.0204526111632, -235.11304912193953, -791.0211216606889], + "butteraugli": [52.22150466310276, 53.28447861541946, 35.331869798932274, 33.87102623022725, 36.678607817207, 43.312789729639114, 85.34020824421766, 40.6669833652117, 39.82401302572759, 38.39610043566367, 44.26066207744814, 39.86173390164465, 67.93184175397137, 30.74791578749934, 42.86124672374953, 45.97234782396648], + "dssim": [0.14910931860511106, 0.1940911907148402, 0.12226211466905407, 0.25059805395512647, 0.19950381703696335, 0.2575302836056149, 0.1304630937990669, 0.16235929167771096, 0.2741405903858254, 0.17831092330638976, 0.11442402139720304, 0.18045231059078543, 0.29169021896532155, 0.25555010138217693, 0.21511921238937787, 0.2775520634919132] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4 C21@2", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=21:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.902266755596647, 15.367086201852214, 9.177592963551566, 13.699004452123235, 12.769449762881761, 21.018737072889117, 15.943579126114022, 10.908390898050994, 16.70953839407337, 11.442068909413418, 10.649105025998377, 10.038379639085543, 27.45963900971012, 12.594026522297813, 14.420167917984056, 23.678689118715738], + "ssimulacra2": [-263.8100699719542, -275.8745174916072, -271.7981221174439, -297.8445482452214, -179.15007343845502, -690.9668162791901, -113.63442105099293, -126.07114695297071, -325.5380119266978, -160.5063012398732, -153.5764324204894, -178.0192895592645, -945.0728148756232, -431.55372106817697, -278.1183803256267, -798.5006321228524], + "butteraugli": [57.713180792009005, 64.52877266454306, 39.10724539030151, 43.12108450583005, 44.848701096092555, 46.89267796036014, 80.18337982072309, 58.498868078761724, 45.11055765355426, 54.34264632106931, 46.23849380409928, 43.3347368315568, 75.24126745143305, 32.12160998255913, 53.067231007003095, 46.53288227842406], + "dssim": [0.14709663769236464, 0.18389084633048863, 0.12151210259016088, 0.2516254810355607, 0.20344548696664977, 0.25611890981367424, 0.12685178608784037, 0.16618812827777135, 0.2805877548319623, 0.17787477480195152, 0.11051177699181985, 0.17889055225075995, 0.28891988148990844, 0.2536042466844427, 0.24890451419171766, 0.27794589379806733] + } + }, + { + "label": "L11@4 C39@2", + "tune": "l1=11:4 c=39:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [16.735394795424824, 18.90629956436985, 9.59982645269679, 15.956243305292567, 14.68240463078203, 22.445571285465096, 17.64405259276481, 14.129583270504876, 18.38813975357747, 14.997498335930267, 11.379484696042429, 10.22424513292781, 30.546285242143956, 14.226557073151014, 17.04003131595964, 23.991495614469972], + "ssimulacra2": [-274.3251194215469, -313.1886258662087, -289.4334375937219, -383.58348706639117, -245.06002659273202, -761.7290684201791, -128.40449169363367, -209.6983370707821, -404.7838819678941, -270.4088002336493, -152.5190600041711, -181.1764972817483, -998.2100339382291, -475.32809682468337, -336.32667739540466, -808.840404592724], + "butteraugli": [65.93754978531261, 88.73362039126543, 43.97579120522331, 64.30668455211499, 54.77852806748532, 53.713352856230564, 90.46081891251352, 81.79817691666925, 49.872619842822765, 80.09763374189116, 50.855762360321386, 48.76060864684158, 94.5983666097012, 36.55422812843312, 84.5267203459136, 49.334801454339924], + "dssim": [0.1436161497361928, 0.18187693936087396, 0.11970686739944053, 0.25262165749759624, 0.21113412460217446, 0.25742559882904537, 0.1343641386769147, 0.17272166639399067, 0.2801357323173369, 0.18477884488147933, 0.1053304952394461, 0.1781922052092898, 0.2925779189321782, 0.2507004232258464, 0.2628014863576462, 0.2773551166021836] + } + }, + { + "label": "L37@5 C2@3", + "tune": "l1=37:5 c=2:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.411275645079286, 18.323064293237604, 9.503471793576916, 15.482483478811027, 14.49054216352354, 22.00244882215223, 17.406663049132497, 9.354241977421934, 16.207842887259947, 11.088808998103064, 10.367491038989487, 9.85228417952551, 26.698611954352703, 12.289742046692574, 14.519138250820868, 24.682673519360204], + "ssimulacra2": [-260.28582765483054, -263.6645751276682, -269.44347366341134, -287.14522220598667, -133.8167961509784, -696.3775650036528, -90.00303883382728, -86.96405217646077, -296.7625086975983, -127.49811516062698, -143.1082355713421, -170.18260827712714, -888.5704057798306, -382.5467636218405, -234.03946353673314, -798.9570165836371], + "butteraugli": [49.98741185047155, 56.38597194167111, 37.09575988066459, 35.084296923574506, 38.68465451796348, 45.722667813283465, 88.74161173793296, 45.427177822494656, 44.46686135776889, 41.8517035270499, 44.78286538557878, 41.72589157506818, 70.20708314103712, 31.067411475846793, 49.02038607880721, 46.78714055360748], + "dssim": [0.148920540669435, 0.19221342204216313, 0.12142059616284412, 0.24969929539040203, 0.20153541493179666, 0.2578795980083898, 0.12894910365758833, 0.15830045156580647, 0.2730299115252419, 0.17790549879691137, 0.11192680033221841, 0.17989432780877906, 0.28892969450227035, 0.2544126945542112, 0.22154538666582085, 0.2774591634274717] + } + }, + { + "label": "L20@5 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=20:5 c=16:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.594650334529003, 16.285024898777255, 9.304078290745634, 13.07619144958125, 12.940506595457997, 21.347472616983488, 14.753116971064903, 11.489223631064737, 16.82632032280708, 12.436835903237553, 10.982097186546753, 9.968737847840966, 29.520763922249813, 13.609573133393347, 15.826916677320414, 23.543749150717993], + "ssimulacra2": [-273.76122911788855, -317.3996128540782, -283.3150678756561, -310.5963483902857, -195.06812489251638, -710.7861380951358, -125.22203819658742, -161.69236457869465, -346.7083102335596, -219.56076522721452, -157.03562705212096, -176.65034133966208, -1010.0881841788826, -440.9442573435181, -319.4476222205865, -819.4688644573407], + "butteraugli": [71.6373269139387, 67.80497333748256, 41.5821339998193, 49.08735994229888, 50.449126620152754, 49.6600987189665, 89.75393900373065, 58.08808481438101, 47.15008041815951, 60.964190323529884, 48.99473047202586, 44.24729089634004, 91.13894938356545, 37.00156064477493, 75.87232340710929, 47.571032467773165], + "dssim": [0.1445622698366144, 0.1815285289342619, 0.12023976941887854, 0.25233766981111094, 0.20911886142188624, 0.2553998076034788, 0.12363463961712551, 0.16555833905043055, 0.27556476019574605, 0.1796551154781238, 0.10682793283060832, 0.17882572536694608, 0.2896481444806399, 0.2511858672968157, 0.24328055673831378, 0.2777323840685775] + } + }, + { + "label": "L4@5 C30@3", + "tune": "l1=4:5 c=30:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [16.886394491105282, 18.98169152110052, 9.648979384579397, 17.159592941787526, 17.670448185467112, 22.691211799442296, 16.802810265748114, 21.185308190319542, 24.583082698632573, 21.870355521301345, 12.045988823835236, 10.428961227819007, 30.77524534004751, 15.747469207723558, 24.14902821379839, 24.936039393000943], + "ssimulacra2": [-269.41878670901497, -311.4953241109194, -286.0413372487505, -376.55068275846975, -314.8630611465432, -748.2705545225837, -123.02875289382942, -219.23512283423838, -562.6440085821919, -290.96388449774406, -136.31157264035716, -180.20271918382582, -1030.278902666293, -489.04243268429855, -411.8616279383856, -885.4966557086698], + "butteraugli": [74.34551060761392, 86.90437858103785, 43.189142316108075, 82.56741673625116, 86.42638405905569, 75.66691467814586, 85.73023036371069, 137.81909580312475, 101.81229475064963, 114.3688588048095, 59.69544440253899, 51.56593407394246, 98.24481504945352, 59.840962840242184, 147.7538152853948, 56.420358940083595], + "dssim": [0.14554014773761415, 0.18269548939370317, 0.11988264801317983, 0.2526668633225587, 0.21489663833633277, 0.25818412092716037, 0.12743099532010937, 0.18228803096462226, 0.28574610413115464, 0.19335355820157818, 0.101885044809299, 0.1776283320226098, 0.2914314807229844, 0.2516187971215721, 0.26911572156886454, 0.2770439811206984] + } + }, + { + "label": "L45@4 C2@4", + "tune": "l1=45:4 c=2:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.178929004972199, 17.710819194791632, 9.394524170438059, 15.171109830393002, 14.110857716912532, 21.460715062395487, 17.051057976652206, 9.441856605374731, 15.190145957089765, 10.810100271469494, 10.301407241479822, 9.7987519876122, 26.42200311902403, 12.281592613813686, 13.711444402085482, 24.691872022071372], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.09731450915547, -240.43073416167977, -261.8732266114825, -270.0444217175439, -109.43695107364653, -690.4422515034531, -80.8971345601168, -91.80205341205411, -240.6958008761228, -112.45076296925822, -139.2224667729563, -168.44178583417812, -870.2838400598256, -378.94429161027574, -234.82668345327596, -800.1965335721928], + "butteraugli": [51.21677639725905, 55.018084222281175, 35.72188296841314, 34.1883778364821, 36.58621072543199, 43.04129968689224, 85.28794408789575, 41.95113139346939, 40.02150918696943, 39.936282635087046, 44.398532774508965, 40.71284518340362, 70.87225803749406, 30.73333430017424, 42.93229514095882, 46.23119174390089], + "dssim": [0.14896388273193956, 0.19351116352006842, 0.12218038574991641, 0.25096989832639016, 0.199496576873939, 0.2575381365986671, 0.13043952444770102, 0.16248897896954212, 0.27422823003128916, 0.1779130846794068, 0.11390255194901194, 0.17995946704205357, 0.2916229338871037, 0.25561015018949795, 0.21453279403157272, 0.2774414936668944] + } + }, + { + "label": "L26@4 C12@4", + "tune": "l1=26:4 c=12:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.652127287236224, 16.613380575158434, 9.364839275916236, 13.04987163934143, 12.427655695946099, 20.786629403457162, 15.735945176231223, 11.25935531711048, 16.67683848303462, 11.605445211005009, 10.484879023073756, 10.041372029260552, 28.427656197265552, 13.097642508202455, 14.370501447260592, 23.447690815020742], + "ssimulacra2": [-269.5379405456539, -280.98135221360303, -275.5287891923538, -305.12631245982936, -179.80387822532919, -707.1321714940382, -113.29015636255292, -155.2858368819534, -328.10068427597736, -195.02983960006344, -149.8829410424998, -177.01437571539321, -986.0548138614083, -427.5695128119877, -281.720624866198, -814.1231160496903], + "butteraugli": [57.089030712191914, 63.844698558873425, 39.251316535998704, 43.01117434301258, 46.147485730986126, 49.327446703240504, 79.73806804787678, 52.62609915531127, 45.402956098060976, 54.14640344950223, 47.08608298314823, 43.676187101239826, 83.08975677116565, 34.2407631268455, 53.082965105899426, 46.92484210554783], + "dssim": [0.14709370343648948, 0.191181271540596, 0.12101407676418546, 0.251052271267873, 0.20287912429943677, 0.25663387056157705, 0.12621359736370596, 0.16858737767132453, 0.27912403889505777, 0.1791981001133574, 0.10844310760223536, 0.17878334244280142, 0.289351536879083, 0.2511694685384587, 0.24798915822316842, 0.2775265106325818] + } + }, + { + "label": "L4@4 C23@4", + "tune": "l1=4:4 c=23:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [16.970795129431213, 18.944328079110345, 9.5726487051136, 16.85345416444798, 17.787628075207532, 22.84362895500654, 16.83066462600394, 21.030064503038336, 24.477327736207886, 21.860898402705722, 12.073856461433365, 10.428631480743672, 30.759843653914363, 15.802445253456709, 24.11120768854582, 24.957215474085597], + "ssimulacra2": [-275.8464486095776, -313.8541821778363, -288.49427323194953, -377.1925043944668, -315.9590057625487, -750.6494279864196, -119.38286766686139, -220.80371030891706, -567.2779898297068, -290.3032970320794, -137.25635940540423, -180.28054992596424, -1029.2032288428968, -487.57066379309754, -411.1863461621062, -881.9110627605545], + "butteraugli": [76.61034083359358, 86.86076315668542, 43.75089940131025, 81.3819921529525, 86.52176299887607, 75.26530073960468, 85.83771885900025, 141.91069429459745, 103.0468284441801, 113.5026054402826, 59.5519968972038, 51.53748954868494, 97.92094272994046, 60.844487637478494, 146.97457977199394, 56.227697529704415], + "dssim": [0.1445352115971414, 0.18351503122404683, 0.11977814345484022, 0.25264034812583314, 0.2149367162979124, 0.2583865905644782, 0.12777968288118124, 0.18274434704294157, 0.2852529317590977, 0.1932622637308571, 0.10193117373461225, 0.17761845621248107, 0.29135795222362915, 0.2515710949750133, 0.26820600652156223, 0.27696356647920395] + } + }, + { + "label": "L38@5 C2@2", + "tune": "l1=38:5 c=2:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.403728860250876, 18.247520610661102, 9.484910250768237, 15.399541117359465, 14.362765560285629, 21.99923547305687, 17.40043973915314, 9.474486558419967, 15.701604357303156, 11.129910370073558, 10.448486374377081, 9.839621418575792, 26.662132344972765, 12.370636575637214, 14.518065506056065, 24.697214127800457], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.1077631910253, -260.2508598201591, -268.9164337020985, -282.1054052809774, -130.61344344253428, -696.2481888108528, -89.8872881122578, -86.9009305215279, -278.56112894815516, -126.62262993753046, -141.71217121981135, -169.46410856309404, -883.7019526516244, -381.8589824720951, -232.89925859478495, -799.0492379372329], + "butteraugli": [50.0985736321586, 57.6847256300245, 37.14032114560055, 34.53075462956236, 38.85684657007651, 45.56761931208683, 88.82460722411827, 43.38913828718402, 44.96503011104924, 39.362860759793584, 44.72064628701276, 41.82489008678269, 70.21236690030622, 31.022291181297316, 48.72461130796868, 46.943197261509425], + "dssim": [0.14884093658106617, 0.19240287125003752, 0.12143326937264326, 0.24987645262453445, 0.20196935208517064, 0.2579138990034948, 0.12896050861200248, 0.15899429063795084, 0.27077692673868003, 0.1780212304138613, 0.11298185597715465, 0.17985318729372518, 0.28906759623643685, 0.25442461172689246, 0.22146760159047502, 0.27749867981587395] + } + }, + { + "label": "L24@5 C20@2", + "tune": "l1=24:5 c=20:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.931197402516641, 16.308973028206164, 9.268282395215891, 13.78040560589832, 13.303709562325386, 21.007543756985935, 15.942960883559932, 11.575115932749167, 16.87719299455172, 11.96564929140915, 11.073038798966222, 9.971894646675624, 28.53674133368012, 13.14534513457198, 15.047492115924928, 23.706026011064065], + "ssimulacra2": [-274.55607440311974, -311.6863253865047, -281.55158285815475, -300.1281323835426, -180.39244895510444, -699.6972415717651, -114.81161134102649, -156.03016058965727, -345.88850487317484, -204.67444718586597, -154.61396667980216, -174.40189413187272, -989.0842645336459, -429.12875222725256, -278.4556337980112, -799.6726214670887], + "butteraugli": [62.71876174552201, 65.89617717064844, 39.78036879016269, 43.184156670747775, 49.21870599493855, 49.472639453249705, 79.01595450175544, 62.62265017035738, 46.00426959440146, 53.248047813796376, 48.96185984688174, 43.968057806130446, 83.55007833268455, 34.218692804839264, 70.11350538845173, 46.8475007025446], + "dssim": [0.1479141530016328, 0.18191306654784806, 0.1206105322835575, 0.25171370260267467, 0.20421054645909026, 0.25596441073631804, 0.12682861173962312, 0.16750277494367738, 0.2783659824376715, 0.17995357595929556, 0.10719943114230462, 0.17878790491492702, 0.2888613123781818, 0.2515999207060554, 0.2417000999550573, 0.27778949521434093] + } + }, + { + "label": "L9@5 C39@2", + "tune": "l1=9:5 c=39:2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [16.748510531781708, 18.990826077019626, 9.594596170245897, 16.42199637564525, 15.521693365904005, 22.447238073747275, 17.71758817858666, 15.314252775741867, 18.433622128155264, 15.313513938547938, 11.697369023461707, 10.253875686658656, 30.557886891787433, 14.228776664785439, 18.2364890211564, 24.32177298778575], + "ssimulacra2": [-274.4765671090761, -309.76753911982485, -289.4919680138961, -382.07853190723205, -259.97169400079207, -757.0809680307171, -127.49578005646723, -206.94526289028835, -404.99720632510906, -282.88681795807383, -147.43069931809148, -180.03033032680037, -999.5260825862917, -482.8106951501935, -331.1489637286504, -845.0848820961613], + "butteraugli": [66.28591535918396, 90.30274301479004, 43.91648157255943, 70.67306050059045, 61.28099808009253, 54.24608432815887, 87.0881066002983, 88.6537181768375, 47.69736686034196, 81.09886897744582, 54.275783939725386, 50.276692404164606, 95.09027857615956, 38.40318617855346, 89.73881905753474, 54.49897163986916], + "dssim": [0.14356244656190037, 0.18087028102620234, 0.11970720792330541, 0.25265706188605674, 0.2145260731995699, 0.2570811050604149, 0.13419799188929965, 0.17195763843721384, 0.281162780649708, 0.18584200878252438, 0.10411079564260167, 0.17788149653154522, 0.2924507740645226, 0.2509160896764845, 0.2645413751299973, 0.2774807287946254] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout.json index c417245..47bea54 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-layout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-tier1.json b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-tier1.json index eb469b2..8792f9b 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/alpha-tier1.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/alpha-tier1.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder-common-grid.json b/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder-common-grid.json index 007f6b8..d252b98 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder-common-grid.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder-common-grid.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder.json b/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder.json index 9d01439..6825987 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/artifact-ladder.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-holdout.json index 9203fc3..57a9780 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-holdout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized-holdout.json index b79145e..8f54a88 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized-holdout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized.json index 779d6ea..4aa881d 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-optimized.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned-holdout.json index a973894..26d0ea6 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned-holdout.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "name": "budget-ladder-tuned", "split": "holdout", "settings": { - "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. Compare against budget-ladder.json, which is the same ladder with the shipped constants.", + "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. The round-1 recipe had no sel_hv, so every tuned arm pins sel_hv=0: an arm that omitted it inherited the adopted 0.15 and measured the round-2 recipe instead. The pre-adoption arms are the baseline the tuned rows are compared against (EXPERIMENTS.md SS4.5, SS7.12): the v0.6-derived format resized to each budget exactly as budget-ladder.json resizes it (26:9 at L 5 b / chroma 4 b, the upper-tier raster from 108 B), with the four selection/encoder knobs pinned off. budget-ladder.json itself resizes the layout but inherits the adopted knobs, so it is the ladder of the format that ships, not of the one round 1 compared against.", "corpus": "photo", "backdrops": "white", "alphaFidelity": false, @@ -19,12 +19,12 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json", - "configSha256": "d5ba1ba97adce6d3d66fe3d1791abd2828955d84190991f553eecc1c98efb54f", + "configSha256": "aeefd38b4323a69c313656827cde38b50f0006f1971a1f1fdab90583aca7f711", "binaries": { "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" }, @@ -177,210 +177,392 @@ }, { "label": " 12B tuned L8@3 C3@3", - "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], - "ciede2000": [14.996302697048467, 5.510918081762876, 14.999099275122413, 13.984766859916014, 16.003109065854026, 9.700671854754013, 12.745044042824036, 18.679878595839938, 10.769776641987143, 10.0513299541841, 13.251535692378102, 11.069419050662372, 13.976967473497767, 15.445061510025779, 21.114369443116548, 8.999984971063705, 10.901154096964612, 13.841119914525144, 11.01724313892715, 11.382030532188713, 11.491487761100055, 12.977644191292375, 18.50649307775213, 13.308738957108599, 13.284234245283255, 11.350985926267251, 17.591512407636134, 9.19245959107509, 16.207777880240474, 14.568766970978533, 17.716394418013582, 14.29429629057359], - "ssimulacra2": [-462.5748183107298, -84.84975420407812, -293.4726386511863, -243.31609746361175, -816.5388938351792, -122.76982975315403, -430.86739067437816, -802.5915245239682, -202.02058092546076, -216.5258075426239, -317.3260089968776, -104.89298979528502, -560.2760496770481, -554.1359978760815, -448.86769063923464, -124.67055986727186, -399.4847395776884, -472.7879195312521, -247.4882851522533, -172.32789113120526, -271.61931726276714, -291.1054096023782, -353.3963819391696, -477.9382889944869, -288.9244796296745, -103.96475395707924, -633.6996718025858, -124.72652956254447, -615.5492797269012, -445.4440502277346, -848.2689015701853, -470.3450926357648], - "butteraugli": [24.25180933187545, 29.703609547394677, 35.762922079147934, 26.85793000711747, 29.78042067499918, 34.88327153601066, 26.759658099366792, 38.482670080255645, 33.69185680556776, 27.746477642177524, 28.74471445992707, 39.749190201324595, 31.924533873025243, 37.69637234459055, 53.35713455125032, 31.79704043910252, 30.02816658664413, 30.717512077016995, 27.226599594103394, 41.85743858246485, 34.070715587310055, 27.161438345484896, 41.70759416980214, 39.17574507408475, 40.37351282016241, 41.1856635945302, 37.99294983738537, 20.62012769885869, 31.449490950671855, 42.55191024778791, 44.151336683533, 34.357771061562076], - "dssim": [0.3792734893666355, 0.18743620853597365, 0.18500304980748988, 0.23451001609396455, 0.3978569129445208, 0.2793783498193866, 0.25692174332113027, 0.39671415119097936, 0.1845979452153273, 0.2085100490156499, 0.28609695861930495, 0.17631454227979942, 0.39797830263272804, 0.3420394386853176, 0.2342091484565168, 0.22245560023813893, 0.26580123094934094, 0.3218758312320762, 0.2527726902201958, 0.1756241966948086, 0.24209140190939987, 0.2672078082769528, 0.1908596405194285, 0.3148613967745989, 0.1998624901447233, 0.10476978253958635, 0.35478679486817477, 0.24227049444788523, 0.34927565720936316, 0.26506154131254767, 0.32714964630387466, 0.32209335039917175] + "ciede2000": [14.996302697048467, 5.510918081762876, 14.999099275122413, 14.177988993071162, 16.003109065854026, 9.700671854754013, 12.745044042824036, 18.679878595839938, 10.900298121917805, 10.089583199977755, 13.251535692378102, 11.069419050662372, 13.976967473497767, 15.445061510025779, 21.114369443116548, 8.999984971063705, 10.800294455792502, 13.836142084122178, 11.054680128924296, 11.382030532188713, 11.491487761100055, 12.977644191292375, 18.50649307775213, 13.308738957108599, 13.284234245283255, 11.273692044490703, 17.591512407636134, 9.19245959107509, 16.23060430693367, 14.476083282393699, 17.716394418013582, 14.053686783684906], + "ssimulacra2": [-462.5748183107298, -84.84975420407812, -293.4726386511863, -255.8301260731153, -816.5388938351792, -122.76982975315403, -430.86739067437816, -802.5915245239682, -221.75762419681735, -220.62475124482808, -317.3260089968776, -104.89298979528502, -560.2760496770481, -554.1359978760815, -448.86769063923464, -124.67055986727186, -423.65261351113315, -475.512674072368, -247.0103888683122, -172.32789113120526, -271.61931726276714, -291.1054096023782, -353.3963819391696, -477.9382889944869, -288.9244796296745, -102.93347279172633, -633.6996718025858, -124.72652956254447, -611.4245153661444, -451.4338088628117, -848.2689015701853, -478.0325049728226], + "butteraugli": [24.25180933187545, 29.703609547394677, 35.762922079147934, 25.673958039705692, 29.78042067499918, 34.88327153601066, 26.759658099366792, 38.482670080255645, 37.80872930666311, 29.02955056419532, 28.74471445992707, 39.749190201324595, 31.924533873025243, 37.69637234459055, 53.35713455125032, 31.79704043910252, 26.646549182260628, 30.76227203066129, 26.923878110929603, 41.85743858246485, 34.070715587310055, 27.161438345484896, 41.70759416980214, 39.17574507408475, 40.37351282016241, 37.055501230489654, 37.99294983738537, 20.62012769885869, 31.918521074383573, 42.968783356689904, 44.151336683533, 32.52139626778017], + "dssim": [0.3792734893666355, 0.18743620853597365, 0.18500304980748988, 0.2363235845413969, 0.3978569129445208, 0.2793783498193866, 0.25692174332113027, 0.39671415119097936, 0.18513270670043486, 0.20870379555895313, 0.28609695861930495, 0.17631454227979942, 0.39797830263272804, 0.3420394386853176, 0.2342091484565168, 0.22245560023813893, 0.27394112936005766, 0.32134233508255994, 0.2531415826637171, 0.1756241966948086, 0.24209140190939987, 0.2672078082769528, 0.1908596405194285, 0.3148613967745989, 0.1998624901447233, 0.10491354471651965, 0.35478679486817477, 0.24227049444788523, 0.3479815071067083, 0.2653372747139361, 0.32714964630387466, 0.32358372314376715] } }, { "label": " 14B tuned L11@3 C4@3", - "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14], - "ciede2000": [14.955825755097015, 5.424460496986863, 14.772152495191294, 13.66368753617014, 15.935414440599255, 9.580136481230262, 12.793094386208976, 18.206850457164553, 10.811075540933139, 9.927630255988877, 12.53445287352114, 10.799555777594867, 13.032847699135605, 15.338548970003272, 18.797671065752645, 8.63739908614917, 10.272798563218677, 13.614825336313057, 10.37070409708072, 10.828582152937278, 11.36573297956857, 12.761674785498666, 18.304906136705767, 13.005674008673557, 12.681936269553633, 11.158011615185032, 16.872954984006558, 8.241787084850401, 16.208929361601577, 13.904252530494327, 17.411774676699146, 12.771722818121567], - "ssimulacra2": [-459.204560282364, -83.66827064019901, -284.0769189986794, -232.95427180408763, -805.2977745169575, -126.19811340259338, -430.7323129646377, -749.95691963536, -206.68562867879882, -215.4298639437273, -289.5560485455203, -103.67121418167727, -508.65616570214615, -544.3584657395185, -416.2042086420738, -114.8294541917345, -384.07481966079564, -465.2693172610924, -221.76785305792828, -165.7639704007666, -269.02620973025853, -276.6785652955889, -338.53591354310356, -475.31218491169386, -273.78446317416706, -102.60485954847383, -609.9743100770253, -103.35829561938792, -614.8862326849212, -443.7437261202622, -838.1835475380833, -441.9624726987864], - "butteraugli": [23.583920247114026, 29.858586204013776, 35.628014448647626, 26.011925687236005, 29.73136217636731, 32.189919456658934, 26.41577487976741, 37.779710402527996, 31.91371525306747, 28.49477615731887, 25.465030826418836, 37.74923684756274, 26.40301739557204, 35.15892179705889, 54.643585168328855, 29.029774494193873, 25.692729695314313, 30.557793655464057, 28.032579404804622, 42.05636993189828, 33.77723326950902, 27.070166943839013, 39.54742151390482, 40.9473529814085, 40.510555594430215, 37.28171918424326, 38.54234911427404, 19.77821723749347, 31.97946013069212, 45.94776290063064, 42.79776668329055, 30.6835719245075], - "dssim": [0.3790990099314552, 0.1870809753940345, 0.18036348701685845, 0.2341785890219828, 0.39747982411349275, 0.28043908172311904, 0.2570257165408324, 0.39479676805300284, 0.1848262789568133, 0.20870546644218968, 0.2818454845181231, 0.1757079314622157, 0.39597196540043006, 0.34154933741287985, 0.2262282418706833, 0.2216435051961146, 0.2677541338897036, 0.3216358905053146, 0.25206312284682963, 0.17505128933157904, 0.24199643293421874, 0.2669945422032999, 0.1919533161775619, 0.31477439316921807, 0.19717545197736003, 0.10495860946440244, 0.3506699910339844, 0.2410924680491497, 0.3495688250261243, 0.265345746996289, 0.32413111717004284, 0.32092772701363226] + "ciede2000": [14.955825755097015, 5.424460496986863, 14.772152495191294, 13.539912087816308, 15.935414440599255, 9.580136481230262, 12.793094386208976, 18.206850457164553, 10.752777795230786, 9.899090206469376, 12.53445287352114, 10.799555777594867, 13.032847699135605, 15.338548970003272, 18.797671065752645, 8.63739908614917, 10.299091946538967, 13.636637949924033, 10.630250607155498, 10.828582152937278, 11.36573297956857, 12.761674785498666, 18.304906136705767, 13.005674008673557, 12.681936269553633, 11.158011615185032, 16.927869143810387, 8.241787084850401, 16.208929361601577, 14.55691831104162, 17.411774676699146, 12.544753306030564], + "ssimulacra2": [-459.204560282364, -83.66827064019901, -284.0769189986794, -220.23258826515615, -805.2977745169575, -126.19811340259338, -430.7323129646377, -749.95691963536, -200.94647114472707, -211.93266619402192, -289.5560485455203, -103.67121418167727, -508.65616570214615, -544.3584657395185, -416.2042086420738, -114.8294541917345, -391.92348936252426, -464.46655501941245, -231.93213539672797, -165.7639704007666, -269.02620973025853, -276.6785652955889, -338.53591354310356, -475.31218491169386, -273.78446317416706, -102.60485954847383, -613.1989368227601, -103.35829561938792, -614.8862326849212, -444.62523214467444, -838.1835475380833, -429.31841875965574], + "butteraugli": [23.583920247114026, 29.858586204013776, 35.628014448647626, 24.95802769889111, 29.73136217636731, 32.189919456658934, 26.41577487976741, 37.779710402527996, 31.7331342324706, 27.770640147580973, 25.465030826418836, 37.74923684756274, 26.40301739557204, 35.15892179705889, 54.643585168328855, 29.029774494193873, 25.648418078110698, 30.631399984787095, 25.793198641728065, 42.05636993189828, 33.77723326950902, 27.070166943839013, 39.54742151390482, 40.9473529814085, 40.510555594430215, 37.28171918424326, 39.86710503561297, 19.77821723749347, 31.97946013069212, 44.46068232497938, 42.79776668329055, 31.81087049087006], + "dssim": [0.3790990099314552, 0.1870809753940345, 0.18036348701685845, 0.2339925862004299, 0.39747982411349275, 0.28043908172311904, 0.2570257165408324, 0.39479676805300284, 0.18442299908789517, 0.20844281806917248, 0.2818454845181231, 0.1757079314622157, 0.39597196540043006, 0.34154933741287985, 0.2262282418706833, 0.2216435051961146, 0.268742108546417, 0.3215197595717042, 0.2525112821772292, 0.17505128933157904, 0.24199643293421874, 0.2669945422032999, 0.1919533161775619, 0.31477439316921807, 0.19717545197736003, 0.10495860946440244, 0.3503046580837339, 0.2410924680491497, 0.3495688250261243, 0.2645481931394421, 0.32413111717004284, 0.3206354247365134] } }, { "label": " 16B tuned L14@3 C5@3", - "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], - "ciede2000": [14.942735710012336, 5.482101383812277, 14.565821179839315, 12.680686087749017, 15.967824522829178, 9.585956769590226, 12.484485074762707, 18.00383776310555, 10.503437350261136, 9.838237456904748, 11.563659286847603, 10.233173527568175, 12.487995344666745, 15.173699122652955, 17.742424906340105, 8.068676514526302, 10.165292818795079, 13.552517003659146, 10.501123348694204, 10.52337734514259, 10.804997539952168, 12.595656568807742, 17.760672459854288, 12.765879916435674, 12.562343340242665, 11.0594286932487, 16.627606346080043, 8.216514169275738, 16.084047244760146, 13.35151442018951, 16.970020738958617, 12.461090577568449], - "ssimulacra2": [-459.56286590022455, -83.25346435829692, -267.06280496843726, -191.90109990991527, -804.756380374576, -126.34003081164079, -396.3358192595902, -735.031860515005, -198.5589061463645, -210.31771174283284, -289.60406346614195, -96.36253285209025, -496.3202696260947, -540.4888541776849, -385.4302675305215, -114.04853306330608, -379.3697238069352, -456.7804632925887, -225.5071919917131, -163.45677298086866, -261.53416736734727, -278.7446693222029, -315.22533162354586, -471.04548873473436, -270.00903617230193, -99.69152130850853, -597.5332075041943, -103.09260960938553, -614.9924934594453, -431.2564263370142, -823.7896853285206, -422.39012246842424], - "butteraugli": [23.609384741910873, 29.015014455602643, 34.81561081711917, 24.703864530064564, 29.58831514362687, 32.16760926708742, 26.167546041285657, 35.46541203374561, 30.21643975273393, 28.927369578458208, 25.128308233606486, 38.66846920117204, 25.1853356051451, 35.31948995291929, 48.172351926849295, 29.174505247980537, 25.25770001616006, 31.130388668266324, 25.798880779773935, 42.04142732512526, 30.80575784616272, 26.660928788910827, 35.77881277921444, 38.93955918205231, 38.87944920427189, 37.307723889232, 39.09471099435728, 19.712620836061202, 32.00257378518397, 45.85136280110682, 41.071255065898335, 31.15564757482082], - "dssim": [0.3790711089865995, 0.18830946141696092, 0.17792011261468987, 0.22981600938339114, 0.39740658394062933, 0.2805238675970485, 0.2567124103781453, 0.3938861563288923, 0.18387625875428149, 0.20862656675836572, 0.2798417271692305, 0.1747532101427987, 0.3948436183385601, 0.3398325545408656, 0.22313266504276436, 0.22139097868090657, 0.26758361165932054, 0.32108475011729765, 0.2522239208339726, 0.17490997842651063, 0.24185361183586274, 0.2666911131185138, 0.18861976423231963, 0.31475645639615657, 0.19690318047079886, 0.1040450884184363, 0.3496048497540346, 0.24112143466237113, 0.34922825098537236, 0.2637977525409817, 0.31629769836284793, 0.32019738146680243] + "ciede2000": [14.943710564219996, 5.491295609016706, 14.40970625047096, 12.617448334889156, 15.950474495189267, 9.573445649218286, 12.487250221160462, 18.045632384246872, 10.592077575207925, 9.844759261791031, 12.447463614153946, 10.009878225681721, 12.68816490464049, 15.324224383315856, 17.658135802474153, 8.41527159409516, 10.165292818795079, 13.572521454412353, 10.501123348694204, 10.828582152937278, 11.370333631900756, 12.744335228929986, 17.980026268528587, 12.81089648941009, 12.643878017592373, 10.567448051786283, 16.973123199428652, 8.216514169275738, 15.40934277613667, 13.406462141080317, 17.046046267957674, 12.509915767169886], + "ssimulacra2": [-460.4887361559829, -83.089474961203, -265.6048258806767, -189.22860253056865, -806.175456766809, -126.22258192240082, -397.25854266399676, -735.6493944349846, -201.10959120855142, -204.58317661206672, -290.07353462282094, -96.05228290964055, -498.2583320587818, -540.3565818028667, -384.6551454852714, -114.35489410624103, -379.3697238069352, -455.8399270170934, -225.5071919917131, -165.7639704007666, -264.9469709417172, -279.12922377167513, -315.11391920219404, -471.3741079885334, -269.41219819629464, -107.22138532368899, -605.6341115600333, -103.09260960938553, -593.782637169445, -428.5450366681397, -825.2747650823336, -428.6427237727419], + "butteraugli": [23.602915475531887, 29.12200595321785, 34.836105756427095, 24.83394462266877, 29.652511892968732, 32.2313301915324, 26.14572704096119, 35.46351715316823, 30.978881760416858, 27.104257859779295, 25.237562029281918, 38.67322183968485, 25.098796952246474, 35.33936181530293, 48.25753080655438, 28.949793340127666, 25.25770001616006, 30.947129368556205, 25.798880779773935, 42.05636993189828, 31.054091369601537, 26.69794806178484, 35.87712803694662, 39.0671072632924, 38.83937021012262, 36.69428268623982, 37.85600073436576, 19.712620836061202, 31.326109019840434, 43.11106181341383, 40.855122520386196, 30.96685389901116], + "dssim": [0.3791102106861797, 0.1878989306637105, 0.1813267754881358, 0.2292704456800651, 0.39752214872915753, 0.2804596814309789, 0.25679391482619485, 0.393873835984272, 0.18410650016244584, 0.20823873257033126, 0.28122258328174066, 0.17471041313177005, 0.39500854095886706, 0.3414977358835064, 0.2236879277866895, 0.2215199947385909, 0.26758361165932054, 0.32131761697032946, 0.2522239208339726, 0.17505128933157904, 0.2420451863622295, 0.2668599169428725, 0.18885169227196857, 0.31466592282678196, 0.19681049704790293, 0.1036907798762357, 0.35155580448775237, 0.24112143466237113, 0.3473272673316833, 0.26415905844334453, 0.3210305752181156, 0.3206473318314146] } }, { "label": " 18B tuned L17@3 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18], - "ciede2000": [14.893979989884226, 5.4849374340465, 14.678961498740984, 12.466264829388699, 15.947597109192653, 9.350512369619285, 12.452781209500209, 17.779536491397987, 10.27997984879555, 9.39004434113981, 11.627533867442335, 9.987695883361278, 12.213316934356326, 15.00415710648248, 17.275187502334713, 7.661935471562918, 10.140326914568892, 13.174528378251704, 10.457091053574173, 10.367708347118988, 10.699328861602684, 12.377349059408745, 17.687790356785847, 12.691908071383255, 11.601834941609143, 10.347151640016149, 16.501432444621404, 8.216514169275738, 15.182247021241418, 12.912185128085326, 16.915515483011514, 12.334214286599698], - "ssimulacra2": [-455.84865068001045, -82.7856890276754, -257.9654229518924, -187.47302720153442, -788.216604323636, -127.47556236035007, -392.2252523278262, -714.0453721065654, -187.80998002845917, -196.6566641451074, -289.60129619291905, -96.489438279112, -477.66433679237, -530.7116201493068, -370.4610353577121, -99.10284793132806, -375.74887184468844, -445.0140584689034, -224.36553914180638, -155.61095820097333, -259.3222274082621, -259.1925778292848, -302.9199635166884, -467.0755770004447, -235.88471704988018, -99.2681495947154, -591.9412315707696, -103.09260960938553, -574.3023284426702, -389.00836703963944, -821.5444098258569, -408.09555735536435], - "butteraugli": [23.70278469693436, 29.034794479587465, 30.003628573968143, 24.591587414138825, 28.897176748374417, 33.98522712160655, 26.06510381904449, 35.26026375198163, 30.246938337017934, 27.578745950586057, 25.03040248309114, 36.563319861454715, 23.49453314534451, 32.63052042396202, 48.143063109334356, 24.781399661816966, 25.207587153262306, 29.994456527077386, 25.622018841340978, 41.17266338516735, 31.093431765928553, 26.271654708188844, 37.92928332768624, 40.582336994557004, 34.88698354153893, 35.666520462512814, 37.366369903558294, 19.712620836061202, 31.831255728469557, 38.385155942416155, 40.85082665726469, 29.370845625719898], - "dssim": [0.3788831141839446, 0.1882767031232752, 0.1784295789820028, 0.22978998680222978, 0.3969827193960382, 0.28131140215107475, 0.25661898612339695, 0.39312260453957665, 0.18381838196247657, 0.20761377158445748, 0.27989464276352194, 0.17450440720263533, 0.3948626134108207, 0.3404973734293595, 0.21935464333375826, 0.22157616975972672, 0.26677018494514115, 0.32081369603351473, 0.2520114769339793, 0.17404406114051624, 0.2417605166287609, 0.2652857243261558, 0.18666968586588634, 0.31433692923613343, 0.1919385409871715, 0.10284919247499841, 0.3485198408939377, 0.24112143466237113, 0.3463543683704764, 0.26373913515768, 0.3174702496988261, 0.3207093911910702] + "ciede2000": [14.884228990439762, 5.502466127865206, 14.51247661838698, 12.479834610169984, 15.911325411103014, 9.686672957563252, 12.46016172608769, 17.88610388698754, 10.219038604373084, 9.40206147923589, 11.627533867442335, 9.993777822045848, 12.234037405920612, 14.990447480628685, 17.261591516202216, 7.661935471562918, 10.140326914568892, 13.167435932213387, 10.457091053574173, 10.367708347118988, 10.799930970858895, 12.62404404692881, 17.647640844716996, 12.627345342945187, 11.527773557241963, 10.26137113685221, 16.501432444621404, 8.216514169275738, 15.332231873675807, 12.912185128085326, 16.877820760802887, 12.309016225367827], + "ssimulacra2": [-452.903711566232, -83.09152783671223, -254.56605779319722, -187.58117688010304, -782.963597864373, -133.1903109591479, -387.66116333709135, -725.8177128131684, -182.7509085097472, -199.16928325978, -289.60129619291905, -96.60303209085168, -485.5377113620697, -532.8017410704059, -351.18290412645024, -99.10284793132806, -375.74887184468844, -443.9988739288618, -224.36553914180638, -155.61095820097333, -261.15997283795355, -282.84064907496224, -295.6203526831697, -459.2816029975902, -232.71209816488306, -100.66424457379188, -591.9412315707696, -103.09260960938553, -592.6417979199273, -389.00836703963944, -824.2014856611161, -405.929094785248], + "butteraugli": [23.50611624696842, 28.764761421022712, 30.646572375773058, 24.464522860505053, 28.67930724506262, 31.310326180968797, 25.761717471257516, 35.387238679203335, 29.992719674487812, 27.904022518199877, 25.03040248309114, 36.787074325803246, 23.541556868432107, 32.94664122172242, 52.849286821717165, 24.781399661816966, 25.207587153262306, 29.515465678658305, 25.622018841340978, 41.17266338516735, 30.76427946551655, 26.55455366728826, 37.28002554853496, 38.46588859688654, 35.276408196865574, 35.48631524334029, 37.366369903558294, 19.712620836061202, 31.06411356455159, 38.385155942416155, 40.889137465356214, 29.090986596689163], + "dssim": [0.3788468076619766, 0.18832552116142676, 0.17835588192185198, 0.22981036207669953, 0.3967861706536017, 0.2818809075171298, 0.256978389670641, 0.3932586786703329, 0.18376296267791176, 0.2077867203974207, 0.27989464276352194, 0.17475604757938568, 0.39498841894004977, 0.3414659664856844, 0.21916416979686187, 0.22157616975972672, 0.26677018494514115, 0.32087644296234297, 0.2520114769339793, 0.17404406114051624, 0.24186072939402087, 0.2663681868161396, 0.18660143908880888, 0.31398693705687375, 0.1919490750003482, 0.10274823392354132, 0.3485198408939377, 0.24112143466237113, 0.3478029061259529, 0.26373913515768, 0.3182316341143153, 0.3203005093073047] } }, { "label": " 21B tuned L19@4 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], - "ciede2000": [14.88641183319647, 5.492329359267073, 14.459583263499745, 12.376452999870342, 15.903774644555453, 9.028568460388938, 12.093307767151032, 17.623098925928474, 9.912177096070804, 9.178667542391684, 11.190142141712407, 9.797142307098857, 11.868115374992014, 14.87958630545021, 16.64238671669925, 7.579836557936629, 9.868180098064363, 13.114545306715312, 10.073033860565285, 9.637232100653154, 10.633979354371515, 12.183143524001137, 17.60920943714403, 12.362307855723591, 10.264275526192577, 9.861017945862567, 15.933221296897415, 8.16879304169055, 15.004618116581481, 12.724240837032154, 16.627419976140825, 11.707513384350147], - "ssimulacra2": [-456.32313660626517, -82.91458679836586, -258.5512967067599, -185.90917300739744, -787.5051968451794, -120.83792215452729, -381.89657624403713, -710.9695805657, -180.395204361251, -178.8359862596767, -270.4674091338894, -100.24326588604666, -453.83240354511895, -525.2039960427442, -349.7628395525928, -94.18229844493709, -371.79147509935706, -434.65025129251626, -218.59733095999513, -153.20468536555083, -255.90224104029943, -249.23835347375655, -302.03887227731735, -453.76209611876584, -199.7594057567175, -93.31064423954047, -576.1489353369561, -106.37555351052106, -561.482801504011, -382.63938856432816, -814.1970922882082, -372.27195395984927], - "butteraugli": [23.612265609792903, 28.303145649712473, 29.770849940757113, 24.48918545648304, 28.187344777213088, 27.25525461713521, 25.31351333629244, 33.19045641893886, 29.23163764091082, 25.808353477272586, 25.378070115375404, 35.69276719359942, 22.37085424346066, 30.87211066696089, 44.13351242993906, 21.149089561635147, 24.587412817507765, 29.45385741230864, 26.169950955106362, 36.91484070188264, 30.52007670305207, 26.4630003123267, 35.83714990273384, 37.212912936904665, 34.16798020020831, 30.767093683249442, 39.09995894524385, 18.797242580575183, 30.618637066658295, 36.5825554608009, 40.603290410858754, 29.70100168398908], - "dssim": [0.3787893106933343, 0.18889567629642323, 0.17672289266540236, 0.2297159649076977, 0.39723848009227464, 0.2795544107727187, 0.2554921816497703, 0.393038366197829, 0.18335632664946538, 0.20665342664936065, 0.27851564506517124, 0.17481733617547707, 0.3940107212239116, 0.340026382473538, 0.2156545554783384, 0.22118156127754618, 0.25869529262297375, 0.32067152005891775, 0.25169995078997964, 0.17338811616210986, 0.24176530579197636, 0.2645793782178838, 0.18571878020843796, 0.3135169689323317, 0.18807988184960067, 0.10169296550427703, 0.34507052687906525, 0.24106644967704033, 0.34557117208272375, 0.2623051492653671, 0.317361447416767, 0.31790516941550073] + "ciede2000": [14.869939596605846, 5.504221471083933, 14.139095753071297, 12.377522980550816, 15.91127611557015, 9.235483047127277, 12.117034980687558, 17.80138812282029, 9.923977713026217, 9.248909133276719, 11.22883134251491, 9.917271277461133, 12.151800055619862, 14.914831882151459, 16.644844318398956, 7.579836557936629, 9.86584981275857, 13.157633023798567, 10.070834587515952, 9.74290126487797, 10.677184566486677, 12.427773157666202, 17.239743824215324, 12.283228695738758, 11.10014906995294, 9.889092251080873, 16.03570908882899, 8.16879304169055, 15.115869850933377, 12.724240837032154, 16.570683829341824, 11.857855436815052], + "ssimulacra2": [-451.68556668717144, -83.05803139173327, -251.7841802438778, -187.44680169302052, -783.136729316176, -124.850488876042, -375.0160828442392, -727.3697465725621, -178.8248305175204, -189.57129544835652, -272.9095659929561, -98.06955755056964, -476.86985714827085, -530.7250187454543, -323.21498056145913, -94.18229844493709, -370.7421805970103, -437.0106741819377, -217.0779733783021, -154.6395857292039, -258.0248008192859, -273.83695890362645, -270.6375804367844, -440.42582752422175, -212.1739411700347, -94.02988747743859, -576.3560868074335, -106.37555351052106, -575.5801335049226, -382.63938856432816, -807.699532396457, -393.84158930751767], + "butteraugli": [22.97675878504529, 27.97382630729094, 29.068535592402792, 24.33829466437851, 28.025743115151005, 29.903579679687017, 24.677119878715242, 34.12142245368503, 29.00822125013634, 25.671320819834705, 25.226845640780116, 36.59988452014529, 22.686347285451518, 31.784303242894566, 48.40009706809869, 21.149089561635147, 24.52700045387249, 29.172735491134123, 26.021758800574162, 36.38879507650982, 30.44298347038439, 26.18057056686133, 33.392443487059815, 32.783014725095875, 35.128501623838396, 31.21751031212393, 39.68352942381825, 18.797242580575183, 30.467127893922747, 36.5825554608009, 39.83476092763604, 28.873085143968495], + "dssim": [0.37864331796856854, 0.18871035298702127, 0.17849856908765988, 0.2295813595656938, 0.39706359213151454, 0.2794844229093587, 0.25578551386541926, 0.3935191637967103, 0.18359622553958782, 0.20732816265845383, 0.27887180838492764, 0.1752027870214397, 0.39467217463943705, 0.3420960155515792, 0.21615829430776073, 0.22118156127754618, 0.25855507292687807, 0.3202055767298986, 0.2516184651297353, 0.17365831340267768, 0.24183245292350047, 0.2659110322925976, 0.18321765372173887, 0.3129489452779344, 0.18962496663421374, 0.10206331402081076, 0.34539628005399126, 0.24106644967704033, 0.34620957142933084, 0.2623051492653671, 0.3179549121851145, 0.3188304342409759] } }, { "label": " 24B tuned L22@4 C8@3", - "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], - "ciede2000": [14.46427644743338, 5.414177159424497, 13.23654956818522, 12.049110065178269, 15.56679685978206, 8.836781255225006, 11.904750941159337, 17.3136748878725, 9.720536335598581, 9.095194093750395, 11.185894530582635, 9.596384916369463, 11.717542242472748, 14.628320505712608, 16.024141543198436, 7.490610463200615, 9.684520825721085, 12.692695464004473, 10.0350633663592, 9.655819061906945, 10.465576322819112, 12.044950244512076, 16.865331667665433, 12.095532844899488, 10.15693406005486, 9.396604941769768, 15.944498275947632, 7.927368966295757, 14.98228524308214, 12.336306186756774, 16.285518423538033, 11.411688657834485], - "ssimulacra2": [-367.88185130646247, -82.0313835396384, -240.05043737782046, -184.7731160873043, -778.4680229982571, -119.79783414171953, -351.08729908377745, -703.7160276204188, -168.3206246094344, -175.427227258382, -264.77018062683817, -98.90714000239953, -443.48548355114895, -525.2353420848715, -316.9962673178444, -92.75048592831897, -370.26061599944524, -428.1957853697088, -207.74413609203356, -156.28503348304918, -242.1043855100969, -245.10810990516484, -261.3122403182609, -424.32620778525813, -198.21300917432785, -90.7250463601531, -563.7148315433276, -95.9200793759409, -558.3114598408615, -380.18016104024207, -803.3321568201596, -366.60599614081144], - "butteraugli": [20.919368880097835, 27.620467453984435, 28.08289809876669, 24.39038339932023, 27.78154208360064, 27.601538067503345, 24.03487137382484, 33.27926852402102, 29.602196670540668, 25.635567491106297, 25.238925090490316, 32.56951579149122, 22.082686044764724, 30.45618637390024, 41.52392041966815, 21.629330359575874, 24.671930711022252, 28.542247789641664, 25.63491677761061, 36.182792986828225, 30.121342101813713, 25.523128292601513, 32.666155183296745, 30.738530784603665, 33.270952282333646, 31.27340957013169, 38.42547623157901, 18.76591858764975, 30.82873996174277, 35.761154661667916, 39.41264974141784, 29.81945837465376], - "dssim": [0.376931789217812, 0.18781531515415034, 0.18075804493991637, 0.22900217023964897, 0.39700715947422527, 0.2797391396871417, 0.25587290555329767, 0.3925677559824842, 0.18308852615625854, 0.20649158443849097, 0.27818742870958457, 0.17537773253063166, 0.3938018801933872, 0.34065906129228807, 0.21685710484816528, 0.22071933351529288, 0.25972887543268985, 0.3191864265106671, 0.25138652305688935, 0.17406861809622737, 0.2416869296190844, 0.26473092066476744, 0.1822209882052644, 0.31269210091032207, 0.18814006123962107, 0.10244401326322422, 0.3446633807305687, 0.2406709241814553, 0.34548511787535674, 0.26208624047742, 0.3162810679495721, 0.3174690037184713] + "ciede2000": [14.802359663788907, 5.4077458889255166, 13.166913965078786, 12.06062341037247, 15.573407816762886, 8.825306974346255, 12.034627866556207, 17.334993245078692, 9.741405501116507, 9.220424351572605, 11.253554640739619, 9.73821207639729, 11.700527052238236, 14.638696197705972, 15.95023930783941, 7.579173461342533, 9.628698573643227, 12.688781275434236, 9.99515138471148, 9.655819061906945, 10.556621438885552, 12.063400439112485, 16.877319936924508, 12.232871118091738, 10.15693406005486, 9.239590132082911, 15.944498275947632, 7.927368966295757, 15.009663971385882, 12.671029250913696, 16.273848815341697, 11.502680517465052], + "ssimulacra2": [-446.23565321639444, -82.34386739076456, -234.99027567861214, -187.81721080116472, -777.3512605688024, -120.73308724306747, -368.0754978794976, -703.4977973698244, -169.88308770116623, -190.77935748546105, -271.3816811252626, -99.85740096537654, -444.3712859021646, -525.3876759411269, -310.0715103651482, -94.11378335021351, -337.6223983325702, -432.1317151480614, -205.60185741137923, -156.28503348304918, -255.12410239741854, -247.31400165582545, -267.717460065455, -440.6850931850804, -198.21300917432785, -89.53288017484383, -563.7148315433276, -95.9200793759409, -562.1732013430404, -381.07391090800627, -801.2135691666934, -383.4669013157778], + "butteraugli": [23.35766859277335, 27.945960489936578, 28.371001284117074, 24.097328183138586, 27.705056034108633, 27.321541693095785, 24.58000218115689, 33.22923450955707, 29.327063430928934, 25.086852335649308, 25.301522756268678, 35.59263912167455, 22.07590526829873, 30.472766105809146, 44.277523800948664, 21.16687001853339, 24.363280751523373, 28.63719992619228, 25.474871554292644, 36.182792986828225, 30.52852287725675, 26.2997021084976, 33.02930663161986, 33.49542720432356, 33.270952282333646, 29.355137843723316, 38.42547623157901, 18.76591858764975, 30.671482624972924, 35.77828669149027, 39.486979579577955, 28.43070277685384], + "dssim": [0.3785507276514835, 0.18768931779495657, 0.18147404365035352, 0.22917071467782762, 0.39703752819519716, 0.27944678371663445, 0.25528256731106824, 0.39264240715477944, 0.18316559959683126, 0.20711536477499698, 0.2786716992847418, 0.1748469565557753, 0.39384142997567384, 0.34059205684792093, 0.2154633715008072, 0.22115776948904553, 0.25449251895356606, 0.3188977405658453, 0.251321811470815, 0.17406861809622737, 0.2416976139440033, 0.2646764457384103, 0.18237097978929567, 0.3131471516119524, 0.18814006123962107, 0.10144717520748264, 0.3446633807305687, 0.2406709241814553, 0.3453767098789461, 0.2619429960198515, 0.31529122349860617, 0.3182093597615494] } }, { "label": " 28B tuned L27@4 C10@3", - "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28], - "ciede2000": [14.227180483726896, 5.30865713233673, 13.435942889911882, 11.658717704184118, 15.62408543350134, 8.63529258909704, 11.799006839067701, 17.067552064611224, 9.093568024357026, 8.918631623348798, 10.861221744582316, 9.376086958809367, 11.633232729060271, 14.237285843748468, 15.760593542826895, 6.979982055520398, 9.277914863829016, 12.569144497533351, 9.748500408501705, 9.216144934167898, 10.144438442604338, 11.589287499195327, 14.960587234105587, 11.888950033538551, 9.804098401505206, 8.61775636264226, 15.779655961112399, 7.463374755831797, 14.603264300016896, 12.201132279852343, 16.144362597896084, 11.033616822566623], - "ssimulacra2": [-359.3620503267803, -80.91515950281902, -219.67106649177862, -174.34254116566382, -758.9072084952876, -112.24040855461709, -343.8896897150568, -679.0298103319669, -140.33952289325083, -165.9641346004724, -256.8010313009977, -92.99094246213912, -441.6797396666866, -464.69621850749286, -263.6958296549884, -88.20387019333941, -321.1402691747032, -410.58619339823593, -188.2964012970172, -153.47919341956316, -235.51294157646913, -228.06399623308812, -224.928481852223, -411.5493653356387, -186.97487715530366, -80.27783706494711, -559.9249356915453, -93.88010886862594, -546.6962176677725, -379.8232521451353, -791.4013234240194, -340.68637878089487], - "butteraugli": [20.64327084378537, 27.67517764255723, 28.01710801659333, 23.20373606658326, 27.420650443518014, 28.752679533611126, 23.495512631030582, 32.76109505003037, 28.394247710654895, 25.528185234015552, 24.80586842584599, 30.392554513734765, 22.08773413352067, 27.738276789336425, 42.677402312275014, 20.386433881926994, 23.277130985014253, 29.027692556682965, 24.837555158699175, 36.14908063171391, 28.48183563306864, 25.095535907082205, 32.27584724713401, 28.436258862609748, 32.68971277781993, 25.415349193507907, 38.14065910028668, 18.329994981044916, 29.66427859979542, 35.364500821022524, 39.52365512701518, 28.646075299356557], - "dssim": [0.3765882008949222, 0.18767185682840531, 0.18074667295571817, 0.2281847502222118, 0.39666936427638816, 0.27992992674358197, 0.25565122473717683, 0.3921756516749013, 0.18182368382963104, 0.2058129526049361, 0.27766617268428884, 0.17495752683957483, 0.39391092316590165, 0.3388452184051547, 0.2135841613895385, 0.22039136812465587, 0.2532857827099424, 0.31867814368680625, 0.25069401962830196, 0.17402868476519817, 0.24156057061189035, 0.26414678514935797, 0.18085362142188893, 0.3113852691162047, 0.18614290990326937, 0.09954840815647259, 0.34455707038153394, 0.24069297986937283, 0.3445328957823651, 0.2618970161800128, 0.31437127545220067, 0.3168405022295301] + "ciede2000": [14.397925464789164, 5.3447897186013975, 13.424346803582782, 11.705219684177264, 15.653305471919122, 8.770904014878036, 11.828632975565482, 17.24808406222174, 9.363171646632466, 8.751387387455903, 11.149346608929946, 9.4403153258095, 11.6281390052948, 14.396823103274205, 15.136735823326639, 7.315274921378125, 9.385973752879092, 12.549229914618858, 9.92674551415981, 9.5774253295943, 10.40883437292286, 11.90949472294069, 14.818862541786029, 11.871700144015211, 9.79225401732661, 8.445560087611616, 15.757222520935485, 7.463374755831797, 14.522578226724006, 12.252541616230596, 16.09867985326152, 11.107702575475791], + "ssimulacra2": [-359.2014367582032, -80.6378187129657, -218.15197702463325, -179.25932925175158, -766.0367841188483, -119.32534809598701, -345.11549535954816, -699.1892118381476, -157.69236451151568, -162.10529660081482, -266.9750726094781, -95.63640617476923, -442.4337932182102, -496.66726554109664, -260.5099237864031, -88.8777816209315, -332.4956816376263, -417.99189259185437, -205.6782661473867, -155.96675739002262, -237.680978380312, -236.0856467458015, -226.52739713090307, -416.60511278247895, -190.6288485556654, -79.00145189276878, -560.4175242692224, -93.88010886862594, -538.4702210326814, -384.4262969342055, -786.1378489200031, -350.7300975601416], + "butteraugli": [20.671428874211607, 27.44669744374221, 27.726459599642997, 23.700854371256643, 27.40924128472605, 27.792348676060584, 23.46141977043379, 32.704905885029895, 27.583652239919118, 24.625824582769848, 24.955775908465085, 31.72235041361003, 22.162758330824914, 28.77821655730827, 42.50086190446863, 20.327857664476564, 23.775765084309697, 26.038642239272235, 24.784002949650187, 36.134364151903355, 28.303044100943826, 25.147217712891262, 31.899993480767467, 27.906509452486333, 32.491502684120285, 25.02961100549652, 37.96662125349824, 18.329994981044916, 29.785918165786597, 35.778229245696664, 39.669619109983394, 29.148048125080653], + "dssim": [0.3767541500678427, 0.1877411972576875, 0.1818800096341297, 0.22879419851309263, 0.39683781931855394, 0.2797504617923823, 0.25576233760375566, 0.3927153286111717, 0.18218971995531735, 0.20575158728561532, 0.2781240879042036, 0.1752869579939748, 0.39368633154643556, 0.3398004957365441, 0.21313084400024573, 0.22060018018274852, 0.2545593148172792, 0.3199802232889929, 0.25109818673951867, 0.17415457906645354, 0.24172527979906122, 0.2647404053749698, 0.1812753018476188, 0.31166357926459654, 0.1871166493585486, 0.09892890292391437, 0.3445757938364121, 0.24069297986937283, 0.34388582294288284, 0.2621275916300395, 0.31560066981242696, 0.3172554543172271] } }, { "label": " 32B tuned L33@4 C11@3", - "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], - "ciede2000": [14.16147395972273, 5.352581699705247, 13.297308534348591, 11.475961704114495, 15.559708481498763, 8.439848337811798, 11.699151064388607, 16.841252093046503, 9.154096763556852, 8.657805092379382, 10.849754525256293, 8.906079208427846, 11.487556471283344, 14.111680043650288, 14.850083929078671, 6.841310275038617, 9.219094768153424, 12.285853745158079, 9.625450348238006, 9.054548867370166, 10.054032152751203, 11.554654649964968, 14.782191258497237, 11.788802869623789, 9.418723791410391, 8.36887743007622, 15.742225985751125, 7.470255998029128, 14.535810454286088, 12.034339138794726, 15.767813696382115, 10.915561991859688], - "ssimulacra2": [-354.00063015310116, -81.10564291206569, -201.14225077713866, -162.98814730891206, -734.3439847527885, -108.41046301035834, -332.26271997516403, -646.5509225742799, -139.42934970691257, -153.8525972380988, -250.527650826117, -87.36032264249593, -427.4891391562319, -451.0050138695234, -249.054544862733, -85.25330508806732, -312.26027477614264, -379.63418764624225, -189.17303709157022, -145.561908194961, -225.54014156293846, -227.26002308333642, -223.50273361805313, -411.94001917018295, -175.41560853743272, -77.65513093583229, -558.3109769425453, -94.18818758225007, -540.8091415832267, -356.61638150474295, -751.6024992321506, -321.42713856718865], - "butteraugli": [20.397807293735426, 26.97903080840413, 25.809791517298805, 23.17311571278114, 26.74603855434779, 26.56671377891391, 23.570599532623362, 32.68471505750316, 27.603654482536268, 24.83099753600111, 24.196384328722203, 26.86622778440471, 22.23951998048112, 26.626164174746105, 39.28347387071926, 19.31610720041428, 22.39209389234013, 26.518314225097413, 24.223922126545176, 36.19611915940893, 27.63525213900802, 24.237772037700932, 32.136287558232624, 24.11154526869284, 32.563923102362004, 24.213691152512933, 38.00897590498706, 18.248901453993017, 29.599238625725878, 35.998992796666975, 40.71697983033286, 28.24105710508041], - "dssim": [0.3764347832631102, 0.18794539265373306, 0.17998362833453546, 0.2276632664359406, 0.39659246787229807, 0.2790985880694401, 0.255474702839674, 0.39139984199897104, 0.18197180978134692, 0.20524702462414685, 0.27765315474812635, 0.17409772167048176, 0.39356391017747394, 0.33875965239440103, 0.2134700393458322, 0.22019478132974907, 0.25372364965854133, 0.318359291618005, 0.251063117352078, 0.17438279973775117, 0.24140988099949762, 0.2644534609325565, 0.18002798810443205, 0.3119021505548658, 0.18307803080971569, 0.09880630057752787, 0.34438763468136013, 0.24076843349163796, 0.344711014498823, 0.2606708281317619, 0.31492739375232026, 0.3159616579564948] + "ciede2000": [14.045503700200829, 5.305407021352431, 13.325456072823524, 11.516103243081886, 15.562869552597949, 8.574074574782836, 11.745892270744003, 16.866758418892562, 9.096153160516538, 8.621370347184254, 10.898766910503866, 9.078040578409752, 11.487482715006976, 14.116195646126382, 14.820741506342173, 6.989496231022538, 9.175046310852975, 12.314220224182623, 9.736483346569374, 9.188130669505917, 10.099171699998703, 11.474087762726132, 14.708699173084211, 11.617894241746797, 9.425158763518168, 8.110867735607592, 15.617824566306323, 7.463374755831797, 14.535810454286088, 12.13610887228497, 15.810699197347759, 10.922414642337744], + "ssimulacra2": [-336.70775374184046, -80.47716281320132, -208.68073199364176, -165.953585523075, -742.2081702704531, -111.59522858026969, -334.6718923401197, -660.2821820982409, -139.51533229365543, -153.47376373324954, -256.62998037578427, -88.69825854050299, -426.7480778435164, -452.0508519868405, -246.77100577602494, -87.82118535525206, -312.1061695771072, -385.1586231954363, -181.76227985392046, -151.74410619463197, -232.27148832502104, -213.43124286894238, -212.71578664904087, -391.9962645645254, -180.12806635254293, -74.90755301303577, -530.2470255210726, -93.88010886862594, -540.8091415832267, -375.53747713361196, -765.053712442271, -329.63836536706486], + "butteraugli": [19.528520068266786, 27.274134746698774, 27.050505667855976, 23.16538739651902, 27.08062439979994, 28.714946332163027, 23.37784711138997, 32.164509344585596, 27.806856194280794, 24.96155559651093, 24.366033181242045, 28.519091867875844, 22.20093938687914, 26.674510188295486, 39.17765566384915, 19.74231106886789, 22.86506984341398, 26.293078741847438, 24.11887131634981, 35.84703563004157, 27.89091792626704, 23.36414702698231, 32.388712255341375, 26.419454906555277, 31.361296266987086, 24.207315109765037, 38.237847899983215, 18.329994981044916, 29.599238625725878, 35.626374176104044, 39.55933009726457, 28.43934397542277], + "dssim": [0.37601976402583653, 0.18745471184860057, 0.17967543813591424, 0.22812739886655126, 0.3965382502198213, 0.27986782534986643, 0.2554626844908685, 0.3914061063700435, 0.18186369196729174, 0.20513010617576644, 0.27771083069661484, 0.17448484475513465, 0.39356350698190606, 0.3395530897685438, 0.2128511202161653, 0.2204774132700409, 0.2535361340108869, 0.3207316971065529, 0.25106043475756556, 0.17427567202320882, 0.24149101464888606, 0.2639490880507106, 0.17987864127313397, 0.3108472605868047, 0.18490324429283106, 0.09808252018196084, 0.34347865607978323, 0.24069297986937283, 0.344711014498823, 0.26203521900288707, 0.3145979946463163, 0.31641610775445017] } }, { "label": " 40B tuned L43@4 C15@3", - "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40], - "ciede2000": [13.854413743954662, 5.40202541681782, 12.100590210244205, 10.130793000247683, 15.32936964759242, 8.45863359729502, 11.679881315631725, 16.588086446111543, 8.975232869145028, 8.363631829536372, 10.49171994649012, 8.270977052378159, 11.25541640702305, 13.650798959093537, 14.038263230620329, 6.703560967025708, 9.001293904242328, 12.058888578792455, 9.175428662322627, 8.556542601228532, 10.05846759819722, 10.904146387339184, 13.830893636662305, 11.26465018309084, 9.19285857038989, 7.51646648463168, 15.193164206495398, 7.447113237125148, 14.275803992090133, 11.408588210716587, 15.45697308743065, 10.571221537667158], - "ssimulacra2": [-319.55787778445097, -79.02766116460435, -188.9847956928337, -146.44805102751275, -722.5649744243033, -114.16439766146965, -309.2214372281132, -612.3593093112169, -127.90583649374864, -144.87545112447773, -239.95547859074793, -76.29226556574312, -362.8756695308595, -393.2447310516414, -237.55345340885043, -78.23436329050901, -291.8909018143748, -359.69644167655576, -164.33509069720782, -121.40970600462, -224.4860912609343, -178.23754115690554, -194.28158892327764, -363.52077206889044, -170.29927524401228, -69.58610758909919, -516.1938821133059, -92.17710714454014, -529.4903025151125, -316.9288409116134, -712.3393317581113, -295.3227819797349], - "butteraugli": [19.43892942734048, 24.62814593933558, 24.619353336591, 22.471046098715917, 26.634062175844843, 24.67426383587681, 22.896802052701492, 31.471884422773645, 25.07517362072515, 24.92494066069251, 24.058734366775585, 25.21169281599623, 22.08311911392398, 25.0834992426464, 39.32493769322662, 18.942863935187223, 21.86191670382378, 25.023023583257906, 23.335226513987788, 34.87864781894354, 27.00783623409718, 22.082699302071774, 30.121488520620016, 23.176090946818874, 30.42539944428835, 23.25301868097031, 37.48971533104791, 18.028023266075504, 28.778595505575108, 33.96625585559659, 39.36683120021457, 27.146583135777533], - "dssim": [0.37539006280358683, 0.18821893740103685, 0.17468593456888892, 0.22536645810121253, 0.39659830696925946, 0.27951683443904873, 0.25518522770278806, 0.39035251433249046, 0.18149540438784356, 0.20481629323409428, 0.2771917618844171, 0.17282108320338047, 0.39283069919544855, 0.3359867189406147, 0.212369947246762, 0.2201400284055629, 0.25634018685800264, 0.31779003185168775, 0.2511771473490837, 0.1750519205079885, 0.2414658071928375, 0.2629381626914502, 0.1785030219537893, 0.30979033158668234, 0.18296930712077392, 0.09692940207966289, 0.3440546373236053, 0.24077952683105724, 0.34406429929666205, 0.258597270134719, 0.31224983352232816, 0.31470686455426644] + "ciede2000": [13.888957222100995, 5.385089200722486, 12.007802510914425, 10.14438801204064, 15.344216504065463, 8.467853704270015, 11.710440774052685, 16.43432656160848, 8.971039697841398, 8.347794509963173, 10.607125599964299, 8.364144131963421, 11.281498350419692, 13.867489703888955, 14.136765716016033, 6.824647752580253, 9.001293904242328, 12.078618930364549, 9.177315518115815, 8.737130905582102, 10.097723732448703, 11.062458255881817, 13.718082539230982, 11.494118615803615, 9.057788767674504, 7.454070533722286, 15.251787258301368, 7.447113237125148, 14.262173213739016, 11.441426387018554, 15.461491933127785, 10.578599211868104], + "ssimulacra2": [-316.1997743815922, -78.88260820647488, -177.92612516001964, -149.2352075076986, -729.1956470055786, -108.53229544277923, -312.1728894376174, -575.8431687534103, -127.24441190844348, -143.37850796929263, -248.74244998722702, -78.6199456510565, -372.7780351411388, -429.12419252676716, -250.08898142947373, -83.71878580581364, -291.8909018143748, -359.43553383022027, -163.22871424003813, -122.06791818615915, -226.59518310811848, -201.1826296218867, -188.82344551316567, -383.26752780623815, -153.849245661135, -68.38190695041831, -519.9793798095299, -92.17710714454014, -526.8709122296166, -318.6260664299386, -721.7334093102975, -296.7906025976819], + "butteraugli": [19.16156831451215, 24.845328002697247, 25.404867217156852, 22.44206089615976, 26.547514975990612, 26.581984140411407, 23.351221762323107, 30.503139757525204, 25.15466434122253, 24.81573105542996, 24.049961058081266, 26.38990064040645, 22.668203214858675, 26.206833943083097, 38.06968583333976, 18.317481049286904, 21.86191670382378, 25.174119320326326, 23.222657157802725, 33.95316459919405, 27.244249560622006, 22.502452917972636, 28.58477930433303, 24.01970227794223, 29.36820826090431, 22.900461595099276, 37.91840302570157, 18.028023266075504, 28.697092212913827, 33.37698484319264, 39.183383097643315, 27.299700072721624], + "dssim": [0.3753107944883555, 0.1885630219811783, 0.1726521033255855, 0.22537170163443326, 0.3964393136367602, 0.27912108747144915, 0.2551810221131955, 0.3898462465869559, 0.18151425486755324, 0.20479756960227552, 0.2775329815754881, 0.17308505364523025, 0.39280015252111483, 0.3376841167758397, 0.21419228028992116, 0.2202740805159477, 0.25634018685800264, 0.3176536207892916, 0.25107836852275267, 0.17562672165770538, 0.24148431911343243, 0.2637875243912696, 0.1776392334988693, 0.3104498714945897, 0.18222746322332162, 0.0966337608926997, 0.3417218522038623, 0.24077952683105724, 0.3439915684027425, 0.2594066171385804, 0.3138813086792832, 0.3147226085722886] } }, { "label": " 48B tuned L54@4 C19@3", - "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], - "ciede2000": [13.72127728411293, 5.348363761116234, 12.038451493664793, 9.354615081058224, 15.10352892345723, 8.227996128131217, 11.428202448968854, 16.190380399682223, 9.003408626010959, 8.182730596086763, 10.196498600673179, 7.620805190147229, 11.126095741816517, 12.944772012428032, 13.776805627220531, 6.698858841018157, 8.600148126843216, 11.627222280009423, 8.962515138568534, 8.575444690822435, 9.920291152869497, 10.203483513482924, 13.284330876323578, 10.971161676108903, 8.673155335044143, 7.153398670991825, 14.943981016119489, 7.481891784169092, 14.021266851917192, 11.057824926940695, 14.875000807266883, 10.270934257065042], - "ssimulacra2": [-300.2654262234693, -75.83683870607962, -169.29619658926634, -123.80584395704903, -688.1261350756286, -103.18322511894192, -289.63040128415525, -552.929522903444, -122.61121905329469, -130.99101897227118, -188.75781647767872, -70.39003508812249, -353.01782300866125, -359.5660088380686, -248.1245095034771, -76.32410057331919, -245.8192088422486, -294.95917405523215, -139.66277048314427, -111.3726347198787, -217.72927894444115, -153.50954994135674, -173.79179886068596, -341.7456846435491, -138.48299016652803, -67.19210219104099, -489.80182084510704, -95.08519500134102, -510.4840872487622, -287.0359658970952, -625.7828560453227, -282.81656505755785], - "butteraugli": [19.117716139816213, 23.021260852631254, 24.728602189342393, 21.664912734247455, 26.119059168698897, 22.713266924662005, 22.546632866999175, 29.63830231281943, 24.843848277694452, 24.880072369368232, 23.86703355354217, 25.05983114943126, 21.941795671617147, 23.52949505804949, 36.328451939435666, 18.26709512826395, 21.279401534487796, 22.978408545706312, 23.864529513186614, 32.36983230137417, 26.584079518623327, 21.429983665966407, 28.332273948145893, 22.575562444474787, 27.417959569187545, 22.491501540222014, 36.85896167364037, 17.878406107936552, 28.290097966288993, 33.076799143068946, 37.9545384446551, 26.024263584912187], - "dssim": [0.37471921574430833, 0.18923869390663867, 0.17251275617016915, 0.22269001760832258, 0.3960336569576608, 0.28031906562621267, 0.25444983365980545, 0.3896078147588938, 0.18218326639651167, 0.20429635882082597, 0.27583055404443313, 0.17160385154124913, 0.39259153613031345, 0.334626590391226, 0.21406538264563552, 0.22031698544147038, 0.25130613003445723, 0.3169981543899565, 0.25000760758525176, 0.17559587583005737, 0.24128877938889232, 0.26273664272291697, 0.17544783999494645, 0.3093717145714384, 0.18156564132920155, 0.09614958329763751, 0.3401911169550359, 0.24119758972591215, 0.34355442594670915, 0.25884845226034037, 0.30866289580600603, 0.3140523251691013] + "ciede2000": [13.684679371617108, 5.384396113365129, 11.821452118586173, 9.505945467412952, 15.103366870217824, 8.331698364814889, 11.196744739474319, 16.018013857775863, 8.8218461626091, 8.197132982709181, 10.49694241608114, 7.504122433483887, 11.177470380539484, 13.302004643368837, 13.67506290908164, 6.743909026289337, 8.609576694683021, 11.686889310653655, 8.996222713349173, 8.639604670760045, 10.02988020606896, 10.424980073337302, 13.57570490820993, 11.082647976425333, 8.652398119713638, 7.287269545975169, 14.963753673908874, 7.481891784169092, 14.059682721484476, 11.12332751870817, 14.971999193292298, 10.355767502715207], + "ssimulacra2": [-299.53397952706484, -77.57448736090447, -141.16387823965667, -126.25144841097008, -687.4519239751907, -108.18841131384102, -265.91303624002484, -539.511980930966, -119.74987166375968, -138.3169541370624, -236.15138333375103, -69.34648571684929, -356.0269935031866, -363.9419023360674, -223.33423125922855, -78.11906923355292, -250.2543608107644, -310.1296844892187, -139.72751608422487, -110.83501581146149, -222.61288541326513, -154.60592918326756, -169.33304760733745, -346.44948687049794, -136.32906527647071, -66.70823429030503, -484.73650549257707, -95.08519500134102, -518.0195838406845, -292.6974219399173, -636.3306618879767, -279.3052155070677], + "butteraugli": [18.711597562815825, 22.604516928056665, 23.941016913659407, 21.694151424469165, 25.76674689831685, 23.666246649233226, 22.85533308596955, 29.223703853799208, 25.345771435456346, 24.364878068561257, 24.09792043884276, 25.204083787322975, 22.037124376479024, 23.612616078449065, 37.65981923356375, 17.99514920965427, 21.522531512413803, 23.099236483801167, 23.607942929936495, 32.440445605394295, 26.236367153044682, 21.558229154375045, 28.00340107324426, 22.975984125691184, 27.655773500565505, 22.21171205214669, 36.72859830610123, 17.878406107936552, 28.559635833021176, 33.055487189866106, 36.74285415481761, 26.545135290744543], + "dssim": [0.37440346276078984, 0.18985710294048636, 0.1729730921620291, 0.22280642237254483, 0.39624351233123634, 0.27873408214349527, 0.25370582107988804, 0.3892823686478611, 0.18136010595181284, 0.20463387799408878, 0.27682623763995395, 0.17150193702023508, 0.3924557976709259, 0.33577198853390045, 0.21288391931333395, 0.2203852478519958, 0.2508075529972037, 0.31671903527925716, 0.2503262777733103, 0.17538947619041534, 0.241608370788365, 0.2628116760154052, 0.1746983844758898, 0.308887681583074, 0.1811594790190612, 0.0958228040308225, 0.34021582751607293, 0.24119758972591215, 0.34327438309148584, 0.2593901722963071, 0.3110446711406242, 0.31406123780890616] } }, { "label": " 64B tuned L59@5 C20@4", - "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64], - "ciede2000": [13.625042409124704, 5.218803227100761, 11.411692409385822, 8.998973407403154, 15.060647936516599, 7.918384603991124, 11.000897434914997, 15.889100683905617, 8.708234348290716, 8.106323995912971, 9.629124506408118, 7.201787027000697, 10.875941274066241, 12.693450447102059, 12.706450639316692, 6.404115657668562, 8.32122191710821, 11.39127880414053, 8.737898505997903, 7.695801261715362, 9.650853618155057, 10.018465415043273, 12.950889864768646, 10.831913219614316, 8.362687000781142, 6.759519508142481, 14.55774055291802, 7.1778737912056245, 13.706608613278476, 10.943127325498027, 14.624879483786183, 9.959248018789502], - "ssimulacra2": [-291.7002763700758, -74.92299100310191, -139.74672309826224, -111.40047315297272, -667.8660300006832, -92.92539273983823, -250.9040488963816, -525.75682269613, -114.9354495372825, -128.2593084550818, -173.99388384034683, -68.70417844402212, -324.59370293828067, -340.65892248764885, -212.76552542742297, -73.17852337054399, -239.67213544300165, -284.1427177085725, -131.32273768036896, -95.38480386158182, -215.74559285498765, -158.64920247522707, -165.44331757142947, -326.6967845479459, -131.6407605458517, -67.16977637253763, -441.9737162144179, -89.01517475339142, -494.9801948423428, -281.5144952355845, -597.8988241726604, -265.83495102813583], - "butteraugli": [18.881969546439393, 21.82750655740398, 22.951165335002752, 21.167369337264144, 25.93036206302158, 21.704899291642068, 22.6278527121019, 29.283427391870124, 23.95363416417258, 24.044331705163433, 23.84027179237295, 25.209846602615347, 21.06238482048539, 23.381181262830054, 35.54615551030197, 18.241877400136573, 20.847236393167154, 23.002139686009187, 24.33766451617261, 32.44827647759618, 25.61898393439797, 21.221393271807305, 27.719691252216823, 22.152923221251076, 26.98492856918789, 21.550002915033378, 32.93115638909102, 17.766597065525392, 28.201865814400474, 32.419095976732386, 37.37946524687337, 25.036428127660784], - "dssim": [0.3745464971305563, 0.19006807941688592, 0.17130634756849988, 0.22135090261658757, 0.3958681978174521, 0.27999728852419836, 0.25356158048610555, 0.38916328104715037, 0.18171182308631856, 0.20430947506375968, 0.27436656902776413, 0.17127103165131252, 0.3918029841440874, 0.33446435996496626, 0.21196896558861672, 0.2198397814563548, 0.24846374663358062, 0.3164279898394794, 0.2498926612437114, 0.1716276849718419, 0.24177589452720222, 0.2624831886849145, 0.17491068590990494, 0.30845799646125005, 0.17906504889680824, 0.09551619442231135, 0.34060890430925594, 0.24079487470767225, 0.342610584592887, 0.2584149517740586, 0.3084147031447134, 0.3132816022994507] + "ciede2000": [13.599904497760425, 5.258705931291049, 11.412565550826852, 9.223519978800567, 15.140815868191604, 8.08655697852045, 10.919166216743518, 15.842222062735685, 8.74965177863948, 8.134960014153432, 9.913052008802984, 7.179647597297315, 10.956027377077032, 12.86782756184747, 12.687900615281963, 6.445495703858316, 8.291537801865196, 11.398599311968443, 8.482478111393018, 7.814364955718067, 9.639920290770513, 10.09940784147748, 12.974779029822892, 10.773928872529247, 8.327467999529185, 6.840419074408833, 14.833568694587328, 7.364188442463706, 13.716078835623774, 10.977534011930778, 14.701800327746692, 10.042549550198208], + "ssimulacra2": [-291.4050836237174, -75.50434162265105, -136.35722258140868, -117.45949646396235, -684.4777382663864, -103.08516525594808, -254.85988622568982, -521.8724898196525, -117.39385527461485, -135.53016596229583, -228.21907163724399, -68.65442891727122, -346.90939753523423, -360.4337981223486, -203.99856718727006, -73.44118974879774, -243.7313470456598, -299.8115162480393, -120.28012697185332, -99.78307899695776, -209.26443282729883, -151.9074663853383, -165.93788409859252, -326.3106006871299, -134.0473453974299, -66.4974411644086, -473.91528199463653, -92.11298640772426, -495.95977644252696, -288.420031155629, -621.9414213215218, -268.23825624813094], + "butteraugli": [18.62935137281318, 21.801256389207623, 23.008277393628237, 21.386833384953842, 25.928757122169134, 23.167060991445393, 22.831792428190266, 28.451615349615537, 24.170959563893188, 23.637271923064237, 23.794146320533525, 24.990979124333975, 21.447064236644465, 23.621798592358747, 35.454321292161985, 18.279867525719947, 21.03710737316748, 22.991385480791262, 24.608201427319795, 33.42632894644163, 25.74907224584979, 21.08591348048847, 27.56050309303374, 22.442286301160667, 27.06973622316814, 21.102875830618316, 34.398886761670184, 17.82890427685495, 28.30332845819665, 32.7760314559508, 36.98996853117786, 24.860007720023702], + "dssim": [0.37421456534424646, 0.19013907848139283, 0.17197150771850755, 0.22208320607132814, 0.39620236689386773, 0.27852823497365553, 0.25328933740586845, 0.3892784271737732, 0.18150893518015926, 0.20471253026674469, 0.2757892334369362, 0.17142406187145637, 0.3920177320373354, 0.33530276976602313, 0.21180450634914272, 0.22000511451714333, 0.2481974857210567, 0.3167875201193876, 0.24946520568600505, 0.17200881089467268, 0.24150163259404173, 0.2623745010399098, 0.17537516466004793, 0.30825977605759036, 0.17911526573947573, 0.09503017891508803, 0.3416008925531737, 0.24107041795551365, 0.34240652593557164, 0.2585834214133146, 0.3097229711084749, 0.3134062260106151] } }, { "label": " 80B tuned L75@5 C26@4", - "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], - "ciede2000": [13.03075526435064, 5.066303354796437, 10.509265045741175, 8.760442650074891, 14.821489139329556, 7.652499712267735, 10.642266200659497, 15.412543992297666, 8.41515423565574, 8.020327133710033, 9.474761146083697, 7.095793695181871, 10.579610384157206, 11.99789759560772, 11.753685062729065, 6.284618602439849, 8.04323766191599, 11.206405022819679, 8.203683617758985, 7.462847653295473, 9.536701459699637, 9.542372221221154, 12.632261986598502, 10.549721799130666, 7.853025830914631, 6.209931266896789, 14.31972068380527, 7.170861460141359, 13.50484250178018, 10.389938643469954, 13.859254443282914, 9.673420132207884], - "ssimulacra2": [-264.0910438384355, -71.66882684706417, -116.58806862223304, -100.61907565606103, -638.9772682883734, -88.21417618588447, -223.99238954691486, -431.60311891653976, -102.95894125264297, -127.05577803230278, -156.3058929520733, -69.19493330110666, -282.72619585819706, -286.82329276422627, -163.71395361879547, -71.20901482189305, -216.80802500684177, -263.0718079176204, -109.11030713932479, -91.30584097385767, -187.12792357488064, -129.87539630378672, -157.7095550464544, -297.3316313659209, -115.11123346027486, -65.13695729848763, -412.6398050198401, -88.13119030716626, -462.6261797166908, -237.61977087696448, -476.2031492885636, -246.5759868413599], - "butteraugli": [18.58041069861402, 19.739198604203168, 22.025258809480068, 20.65660756929587, 26.147175840315267, 22.21945156125746, 22.297159314196147, 27.29420529396044, 22.720360901005332, 23.55768017560354, 23.601801036546124, 24.917984497556393, 20.662712575766008, 22.56587886736757, 32.23343676194876, 17.38635525404721, 20.409804179128567, 22.792609855420675, 23.93733934610042, 32.38926126349107, 25.113550259650903, 20.30109868046873, 26.57110527430541, 21.434604311411306, 24.652201096507962, 20.04514337371696, 32.91215757317937, 17.669562231177547, 27.92334845544239, 29.147872923248272, 34.35415656726604, 24.346035257698748], - "dssim": [0.3736391934797576, 0.18807330078874668, 0.17134130307119222, 0.22053108932037296, 0.39562057510042364, 0.28006561835958976, 0.25275684117127406, 0.3887398542776226, 0.18185126624865883, 0.2042598080731829, 0.27333828329882803, 0.17080069088354494, 0.3911177768358458, 0.3328238787668284, 0.210064319118675, 0.21962940684519944, 0.24850508451680287, 0.31519863760182376, 0.2493437219352716, 0.17208779060332474, 0.2423156308158964, 0.26188013589250136, 0.17258516516807915, 0.30748979007755606, 0.1786012506263432, 0.09499410733057356, 0.3401663616310543, 0.24088743350777458, 0.34220659612727844, 0.25792544887383206, 0.3050248436462424, 0.31287386556121655] + "ciede2000": [12.969664849959324, 5.060482284124898, 10.536005394947136, 8.797321583595435, 14.837581240351625, 7.760584240636556, 10.708922793195054, 15.65235033140404, 8.593811308957953, 7.932036671497808, 9.665333676750624, 7.053271774971061, 10.71961383975539, 12.148465114447232, 11.548301323576782, 6.197241982226634, 7.948645784653364, 11.176123550837305, 8.336820267196234, 7.5838078108353235, 9.62990145889369, 9.732336906713586, 12.444549333758674, 10.626212241131855, 7.989015512887065, 6.2024953864702335, 14.354261349375577, 7.163866557032134, 13.503802460712352, 10.439434263912938, 14.225707636193787, 9.70059676120419], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.82778595070556, -71.40278626333495, -123.66138027709394, -103.87940878428918, -632.6750256210415, -91.5599615919981, -231.4065407330172, -486.63294373530505, -108.79816637103741, -126.44949708540793, -160.34790641431601, -67.85120735176588, -306.7967695586048, -310.98429868628943, -158.41656578817026, -71.12012559966189, -208.40351787304456, -256.6140606705545, -114.73134420709755, -93.82026171859195, -209.12478797659838, -140.74878740251006, -144.91872357484596, -303.8730374668811, -123.62632794893801, -65.11746748221353, -417.7805381299206, -88.4372156112448, -472.0786354176872, -248.14349374278203, -557.8302279477948, -246.21653776471447], + "butteraugli": [18.019017154681823, 19.785301576123057, 22.605632644653927, 20.753106205949525, 25.74934829756351, 21.75584102593268, 23.321657079731917, 28.132178177250875, 22.91360032454025, 23.568324538513647, 22.297953848460736, 25.095273882969607, 20.714834291613446, 22.76163795441178, 33.30337030882376, 17.742912062692216, 20.157433882542048, 22.298950494357726, 23.94370311143565, 31.641887053017275, 25.083275479009558, 20.670246258627206, 25.97674820859255, 22.050894015755947, 25.85878728733928, 20.15383670759042, 32.59591829934356, 17.701136241240324, 28.110449456991294, 29.096452608849443, 36.379883264463636, 24.564896833637235], + "dssim": [0.3732390180879114, 0.1887535991881622, 0.17129810955983027, 0.22083869745805124, 0.39526415363894796, 0.27944342981870174, 0.25242785252569466, 0.38937660108283023, 0.1820387783786251, 0.204256976346249, 0.2749389866368188, 0.17121805231275494, 0.3914946228982131, 0.3341894428933364, 0.20892412673444277, 0.219522658814938, 0.24798796480848134, 0.3154530615637354, 0.24975416558316405, 0.17240412672990196, 0.2421213943272324, 0.26219658419627323, 0.17114578879889591, 0.30809533530672184, 0.17808751826926295, 0.09499862035806128, 0.33995749552074195, 0.240799520097787, 0.3419413454105882, 0.2585541996532855, 0.30529007890007165, 0.3130419378785213] } }, { "label": " 108B tuned L104@5 C36@4", - "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], - "ciede2000": [12.56169283589061, 4.896956551138738, 9.754898561962179, 8.60567688700356, 14.613338390474668, 7.4048402887436495, 10.243183301254165, 15.014191185193255, 8.130792207555817, 7.609815818385281, 9.154927269412884, 6.480713818567538, 10.189020785528992, 11.373503249896206, 10.894074434380762, 5.977981998604255, 7.6051352246764266, 10.434680752814115, 7.983737615249682, 7.188047322590821, 9.12852512494061, 8.94041506310745, 11.22298056702736, 10.155981859513204, 7.2639587877936895, 5.727508583877438, 13.831515154156278, 7.134496748983547, 12.940954873513796, 9.762204655853187, 12.90854548561798, 9.343025951806245], - "ssimulacra2": [-200.144373260618, -67.09519679827133, -87.90362220981476, -91.29756728297355, -570.6259075965136, -85.14192954775007, -189.80823972334366, -382.58409488461314, -90.22941573114369, -101.6071828223036, -130.15713193995919, -65.7507203762103, -227.78174188313494, -215.5170777931463, -134.08859423852445, -68.48711433623723, -171.94196304627678, -196.35342413251226, -98.31924318285704, -78.2781765985533, -146.9845549350188, -102.93607820479096, -109.44280912860347, -230.46527096740158, -93.36606859542434, -64.48065650848778, -359.9761192644545, -88.50407593335248, -397.44129943749437, -187.91895859036197, -328.4618057483564, -218.4858449406949], - "butteraugli": [17.44613666155443, 17.95464168976254, 20.901469973092002, 19.964221478286422, 24.625673192332446, 20.531061634446257, 21.96161236407151, 26.607509106091314, 21.216983059040828, 21.166072354415594, 21.69109651666044, 23.15972209515682, 19.85183384467822, 20.275520686542762, 30.065698700758684, 16.715976787223422, 19.507049264961996, 21.31586857923371, 22.750760695746635, 30.154386328383538, 25.12135920445728, 19.076403421559576, 23.006781411355572, 20.82349860465736, 22.298734797945844, 19.058040512137907, 30.690842288176913, 17.612255390631486, 27.181273273246717, 27.677397024249398, 34.7409365949322, 23.042135049326998], - "dssim": [0.3710572460822996, 0.18979258951249856, 0.1694694532732015, 0.21952295136937772, 0.39506706518614587, 0.27936602129122134, 0.25215203736288416, 0.3882398028773807, 0.18208081330077225, 0.20400926060058383, 0.2726452089741519, 0.169391695263103, 0.3896353926665629, 0.3338213546919526, 0.20829584413226493, 0.21944087290951492, 0.24613678987821042, 0.3131446901011319, 0.24899093799883237, 0.17152174398818593, 0.24077957481068402, 0.25979001604377683, 0.1704172742565439, 0.30698343258396277, 0.17440768190829709, 0.0946558038181109, 0.3394604532067391, 0.24113189176065913, 0.3402439750094658, 0.2578312921737441, 0.29452445495970947, 0.3125350913378121] + "ciede2000": [12.602617993570934, 4.892413811857404, 9.448208405194977, 8.481991408953991, 14.621838061971381, 7.575953029226314, 10.275385006853584, 15.038047007239738, 8.163989446884413, 7.512965514664281, 9.209402770857205, 6.512825929194706, 10.350040655184646, 11.545598354152313, 10.825168826750847, 5.983740683635579, 7.635401674169871, 10.390887628515245, 8.015114922778215, 7.210170006770087, 9.20495949158845, 9.018144641257626, 10.960888946514187, 10.148384171072916, 7.315637871818339, 5.82487598290054, 13.949652825232484, 7.149359225264411, 12.937310041644375, 9.778194784238522, 13.136288114440116, 9.321872772701116], + "ssimulacra2": [-202.25031151313487, -67.14151973418612, -88.32428045407994, -88.23410451610403, -580.6418314750272, -86.37694024115174, -198.42068609486137, -376.1527476940225, -92.79397937259361, -100.82074452670352, -127.79116146718292, -66.51585708644717, -257.69330783629914, -239.08451518317645, -134.36552607575763, -68.37099384028699, -178.4951562573632, -197.23657477052376, -98.69980950052636, -78.15095314091988, -155.07620073165853, -105.57115064025845, -106.740453624378, -244.40605787482247, -95.46812004840265, -64.44070919125227, -370.23892621722814, -87.68492848988276, -409.4452230421772, -184.8192791718505, -368.6025545514895, -213.07280692100124], + "butteraugli": [17.263703334208802, 18.145815575249284, 20.520034295797743, 19.49997157524416, 25.12913358150816, 21.81644215046116, 22.088938970811437, 26.75706564649011, 21.424343835790808, 21.274495813294035, 21.585949015172975, 23.37471747059425, 20.116319691577612, 20.835479642058342, 30.734290737852405, 16.58249701677987, 19.53241121052571, 20.95214081237321, 23.431216995272603, 30.092102775983392, 25.000197715563413, 19.341732235183404, 23.33438946741563, 20.73114930868816, 22.521222060474628, 19.420185668847058, 31.48308321179412, 17.655807544236023, 27.258278042251106, 27.256087577595427, 34.28984278578472, 23.035268254996055], + "dssim": [0.37159757277420513, 0.19003560681079318, 0.1703063096935421, 0.21836606056844943, 0.39476029765395404, 0.2804071014022784, 0.252065697823432, 0.38786318040709017, 0.18188397112004467, 0.20333885924595985, 0.2721178184192883, 0.17024206554373905, 0.39032201385218895, 0.33257699027800647, 0.2079103437561184, 0.2194411239531338, 0.24637985636163445, 0.31356065291960533, 0.24903733807365125, 0.17191483687424713, 0.241090308854931, 0.2600839669222609, 0.16933344689462, 0.306597900192066, 0.17470750496162096, 0.09451050503020958, 0.3387308545658917, 0.24087235503247256, 0.34015769548260166, 0.2577616144331999, 0.29817179981721, 0.312584036103285] } }, { "label": " 161B tuned L158@5 C55@4", - "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161], - "ciede2000": [11.992503367766341, 4.664399326887257, 8.497427290178715, 7.862241578052511, 14.239153046684088, 7.093962548557729, 9.734971708318126, 14.414219067085925, 7.679623862753866, 7.143336090920814, 8.712561411368116, 5.796654341867698, 9.922421013889846, 10.618813093622279, 9.940548091582816, 5.605192023539093, 7.183203763643736, 9.769841638639432, 7.577041508029446, 6.761630204522964, 8.662996242919542, 8.500109102644169, 9.679658943186439, 9.540482788649856, 6.413093846835158, 5.193856955432265, 13.113803238671737, 7.020486144689493, 12.495974924352659, 8.852187012560204, 12.081083772380913, 8.796990622429911], - "ssimulacra2": [-154.17645937274528, -64.62270850236891, -70.52956604126405, -76.37802112789959, -485.134569015545, -75.25316806565672, -145.29543432905353, -297.02267304840177, -73.64437246210309, -77.55842225947023, -95.63479638339768, -64.23039844824015, -179.59928450735617, -139.45069239770248, -95.563474293555, -65.01844450404235, -131.75811173621327, -134.36720188504285, -77.39895833440389, -68.76357978732608, -100.92168368491195, -82.25124735972852, -77.14316458275394, -156.4355873153193, -67.91743657014709, -64.22915721231135, -262.9688556241894, -80.86532024288928, -341.05782735381797, -124.3025521983298, -257.38881778064416, -152.3906690928879], - "butteraugli": [16.549115218761806, 16.211351449652877, 18.567343443892867, 18.457112908697507, 24.029123298332195, 19.678144634605783, 20.411456611329857, 25.14876079398854, 19.638029501630765, 19.226657472629878, 19.679396161296467, 21.113791049490455, 18.684417431993825, 19.529664003123184, 27.494820944763195, 14.94326777960177, 18.492751210810937, 19.738542359331703, 20.93075571012354, 27.99412905176919, 22.770338299062356, 18.359239087832663, 20.988483427246546, 19.030268949158394, 20.931979780315256, 17.831325722861052, 27.492003200310176, 17.061004315630257, 26.557274758096003, 25.130346874857043, 33.136314983772, 21.649007658571975], - "dssim": [0.36998635383656264, 0.18842850797871047, 0.17074857383235303, 0.21739898583783446, 0.3938188938330458, 0.2785037437216461, 0.2512857521350058, 0.38553394957607423, 0.18058783538970424, 0.20286961893991284, 0.2696647454089607, 0.16773705315433468, 0.3890812131588113, 0.32865382403088883, 0.20461723615075972, 0.2183512843819415, 0.2427970221123938, 0.31113062869426666, 0.24735506814060526, 0.17117602512915092, 0.24001935090819826, 0.2579344619672458, 0.16564906507475258, 0.30600754568202704, 0.16474163977739814, 0.09396902858474832, 0.34061049191949666, 0.24138222322761116, 0.3387747284912337, 0.2551921295399655, 0.29016624270537117, 0.3100972592309309] + "ciede2000": [11.816955937920659, 4.653346271419391, 8.48815083308815, 7.809837450175998, 14.243354875750875, 7.138110706686755, 9.685467254854014, 14.357377964250892, 7.762074572650067, 7.26900892979804, 8.730449655278985, 5.770534659548447, 9.996336730375978, 10.713975960901577, 9.809144744816386, 5.716075854263053, 7.169516513966313, 9.805916528126255, 7.585863046920468, 6.8394487795459815, 8.749215753723293, 8.55064887394697, 9.683773245350249, 9.532152440902083, 6.494725254664281, 5.14133537455662, 13.10731792709953, 7.068050974776266, 12.6007803076389, 8.751116747233592, 12.122363602068837, 8.854384307122457], + "ssimulacra2": [-147.03420740174053, -64.62168811011213, -71.85392556678772, -75.85273628167101, -482.15512886456906, -74.48932793181814, -142.58056268716706, -286.3261038251238, -75.20325634309015, -81.78792582792647, -93.12373317628214, -64.23171855914887, -192.7084822716967, -137.65075767066412, -94.92451355189536, -65.79367027696233, -127.08595194821001, -133.39009600656067, -79.65507932091529, -70.36092041775674, -115.40133223023886, -82.79918689599538, -77.62887521202583, -161.83195392667938, -70.13959284094955, -64.22911171685627, -263.746985710281, -85.00693046204876, -351.79367893650067, -116.89662021342161, -261.89891450417645, -160.18778244482598], + "butteraugli": [16.37529820642737, 16.494141850018664, 19.282585682204285, 18.388327187113052, 23.980383339942247, 20.13361826460504, 20.585379672214433, 24.99935980587789, 19.761933611115637, 19.500025664816608, 19.328221311085315, 21.235871051907047, 19.226757936201412, 19.40962008503836, 27.362286883135955, 15.265108251687721, 18.371792469194236, 19.659802301379376, 20.677273020960172, 28.311262600759008, 23.716053757682698, 18.483659814801314, 20.810896783028628, 19.23939566384303, 21.153672701411715, 17.874943173541862, 27.901485200848487, 17.209978355955972, 26.610640555739057, 25.3408993852487, 33.832206847054444, 21.645786920417276], + "dssim": [0.3697920873224715, 0.1886690123910018, 0.17106481961739256, 0.21655139143145585, 0.3935640797948216, 0.2785056333856969, 0.2507604721299401, 0.38488286994090987, 0.180769093292117, 0.202824302422685, 0.2695569649329772, 0.16800827387192002, 0.3889224552217849, 0.32933385697970163, 0.20380635308327938, 0.21864144429127935, 0.243086516826163, 0.31064903236367236, 0.24765246561912785, 0.17214143153884737, 0.24037352677158907, 0.2582505578084586, 0.16555930908567945, 0.30547598124538233, 0.16633646548381148, 0.09338207227586887, 0.3386073384528866, 0.24180915366111283, 0.3388390730426024, 0.2544198838230175, 0.29002717268242173, 0.31092396145084855] } }, { "label": " 246B tuned L246@5 C85@4", - "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246], - "ciede2000": [11.17099103238331, 4.43830728265266, 7.686111112264607, 7.345023720130559, 13.789819748878077, 6.8992995518443925, 9.083412916374396, 13.708225230469141, 6.919539389360965, 6.79488656263136, 8.187824297136872, 5.574750512138272, 9.585435252215003, 9.922388295969366, 9.289589520191866, 5.3817322073353555, 6.70645881561942, 9.214625089542436, 7.215789613414206, 6.558540693166417, 8.134171687384672, 7.948486068972712, 8.807952262077125, 9.102449663807503, 5.92988686322495, 4.825476588505256, 12.340609012165958, 6.938405313947906, 11.863998500607524, 8.225547705316552, 10.47185099802825, 8.33794746093372], - "ssimulacra2": [-102.9076637936846, -64.23314513218878, -66.16373768063215, -66.0975632844004, -349.5573960552121, -71.6668379128127, -97.30994821211485, -222.32513316735538, -66.94016273561869, -68.25000980001704, -74.64898446005901, -64.09908568121281, -129.23860531650627, -87.8608666484956, -77.38643375640663, -64.2971226831088, -96.558801049865, -94.25275086718673, -69.38697099077501, -67.39283469703909, -76.74697809322763, -70.02545942804278, -65.88207959405295, -113.3696457710522, -64.86351900841598, -64.15537787914224, -170.50093272650201, -74.47791363811092, -244.44834169790306, -96.7390677139013, -104.10575449763678, -112.21639696994967], - "butteraugli": [15.650724023315027, 15.036548812688599, 17.752334904499538, 17.640781223861314, 21.97189595680099, 17.962431858952826, 18.69477180461067, 23.838539152295496, 18.507088714154094, 18.274307954765995, 17.3696710486723, 20.403910580678254, 17.84766856263084, 18.113350801016477, 24.68810077307838, 14.058557712207266, 17.375496009467454, 18.758835314820022, 19.037378056119703, 26.837611885596278, 20.27566735781865, 17.014095230871675, 18.86545250260441, 18.231101960331497, 19.17316801391179, 16.94428093423552, 26.333577930623914, 16.932086025038537, 25.81728814873456, 23.56507790545864, 27.862012454654934, 21.07420631150803], - "dssim": [0.368063356390388, 0.18746227371193985, 0.1695658504502131, 0.21374149397795184, 0.39137199756622465, 0.2800418477157788, 0.2496829661028257, 0.3844591361718759, 0.17948010597595182, 0.20166698888398793, 0.27005699373293934, 0.16681569630613008, 0.38783347876354024, 0.3235535970054042, 0.20273786937131094, 0.21850368632711398, 0.24064800282784565, 0.3085570826270675, 0.24596872340513837, 0.17203025763638718, 0.23677117800539738, 0.2569499768103308, 0.16004517394032414, 0.3053470514472323, 0.1615297853365671, 0.09330585863980251, 0.3383703253196011, 0.24124729586972038, 0.33643672400404023, 0.2525072306054309, 0.2729522313966689, 0.30998195241650195] + "ciede2000": [11.089983138200141, 4.435628181000091, 7.708431297700173, 7.289179084013025, 13.76188731040484, 6.927796172939125, 9.069140231235822, 13.6667717854823, 6.947858375598064, 6.778679636828392, 8.163012595655076, 5.597653492151073, 9.601197242037491, 9.965055566146072, 9.245019076792229, 5.396185408691732, 6.715753001239831, 9.196442367032702, 7.182019918721258, 6.5449406004922, 8.278401065438349, 7.946752663353176, 8.624989146392677, 9.115812156093446, 5.9242309174212675, 4.763654455944896, 12.385062917636903, 6.983855033347059, 11.957271355902854, 7.986504490007509, 10.62825987013998, 8.304899724293492], + "ssimulacra2": [-99.5049870312208, -64.2325442207958, -65.88882910991245, -66.13118167830365, -336.7774941677735, -72.21271894269253, -97.5460388709173, -213.25898152238221, -67.02425625964338, -69.12983533387523, -73.7666468295113, -64.0812578188677, -133.98253167979163, -91.74695118096321, -76.4885152712603, -64.34195587231017, -98.74691069374683, -94.40423697876412, -69.12273864406447, -66.61104591414559, -80.24857969209731, -70.34181412944287, -64.8266667619302, -110.09727823941591, -65.00340196517243, -64.11545038779553, -178.8527762986102, -77.23324437915647, -257.79684491304357, -82.98288067107137, -119.80066591321415, -109.26467028981983], + "butteraugli": [15.372438605213647, 15.332912854635579, 17.808274338867005, 17.68568337890036, 21.78532681326442, 17.92763892328067, 18.845239364415608, 23.735220163831457, 18.537122012480697, 18.41182982389734, 17.529962038311123, 20.495278346961545, 17.85009339654165, 18.13351747663709, 24.50467514647974, 14.155747004870511, 17.578521141289805, 18.75553236801963, 18.779290131510695, 26.27715506542098, 20.867963300917623, 16.825060093371775, 18.515465170720095, 18.705910393685894, 19.232883031750408, 16.897400791650444, 26.04391167784171, 16.982871864063444, 25.923665160781827, 21.973118718148058, 28.764520088571626, 20.639039628630595], + "dssim": [0.367391873410598, 0.18741420213439902, 0.17005005465669737, 0.21378536427247502, 0.39081893252397126, 0.2793709396556654, 0.24917154364035682, 0.3839447071571637, 0.1799002919291116, 0.20175322285082348, 0.26979879001756624, 0.16666741237548544, 0.38771173159354116, 0.3246757382554484, 0.20172832707183724, 0.21805157782739548, 0.2412624092297983, 0.3086549000905524, 0.24601834819363938, 0.17176381587255612, 0.23868390478822127, 0.25682900598234426, 0.15906587458996196, 0.3048540367958249, 0.16124187974017107, 0.09323747098285012, 0.3395140524719604, 0.24183874393876853, 0.3365356570951944, 0.25110581976413615, 0.2738017616910825, 0.31004551208183906] } }, { "label": " 411B tuned L416@5 C144@4", - "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], - "ciede2000": [10.456547451615481, 4.174507139175746, 6.935200915906484, 6.656648041843496, 13.160274333972106, 6.823698990078768, 8.420227180734521, 12.936642784382526, 6.406605754855321, 6.227753431130351, 7.697491894770776, 5.287500251422335, 9.215874022970851, 9.223793626826087, 8.436817573832187, 5.143671940614986, 6.282188683422258, 8.64014793599323, 6.828884638909524, 6.343486237118586, 7.667147667602727, 7.323570209132807, 7.6060152797570595, 8.43130045076697, 5.3616964707499255, 4.5081008195635945, 11.58444345434087, 6.898952083764976, 11.347102816437015, 7.233113474639276, 9.075840184575258, 7.749991839895993], - "ssimulacra2": [-79.09943701531358, -64.12641237166386, -64.23840427882095, -64.23014697013909, -213.50472630297492, -70.22111609841517, -72.85407922750846, -134.17793546654212, -64.2767007197699, -64.29838092232745, -67.45170929729355, -63.68222328740828, -90.60653800979952, -73.05199442717492, -67.0155069942495, -64.25110777823386, -77.50257608812589, -73.69942004638713, -64.50799728553164, -66.34803114275368, -65.87553249593054, -65.58265687384622, -64.22532150423768, -71.7237167188766, -64.22097753365398, -63.47485191606026, -109.9285289944317, -72.56358949536417, -164.090470163656, -66.31597722997557, -67.28690493730846, -79.6858785273015], - "butteraugli": [14.914029091975195, 13.84939120183022, 16.54739359615999, 16.411331397384288, 20.807716288339048, 17.706494556767833, 17.51006643897328, 22.55326510967548, 17.231064495707603, 16.860481703366887, 15.943029614038764, 17.5148000832456, 16.708494435231508, 17.577299127547096, 21.864860879988964, 13.797610300584225, 16.396321868904398, 17.977093128686892, 17.486227198878, 24.28324974749474, 18.680710877755594, 14.689453675217692, 16.83129957261046, 17.203191799578367, 16.74738403034011, 16.260727831544923, 24.211763022583472, 16.47105700552714, 25.159495110479224, 20.630277527747506, 24.43725470836115, 19.066831747700466], - "dssim": [0.36665134678436595, 0.1867478545732862, 0.16631630247380502, 0.2090276305569841, 0.38715892400921165, 0.2790175852707, 0.2476176725591122, 0.380729546246582, 0.1784556617833551, 0.19835547889346178, 0.26774132287310104, 0.1661615803485117, 0.3847613874916295, 0.32105809058606494, 0.20071270784358552, 0.21778013451055606, 0.2384533989406888, 0.3050337791656388, 0.24268223947147766, 0.17324483590027911, 0.2338698125140835, 0.25631951133043673, 0.15486185872488206, 0.3019401093014359, 0.1542983057004137, 0.09223135808093508, 0.3350974442868404, 0.2420847014555672, 0.3329998636308996, 0.24233209849401965, 0.2521591574524995, 0.3041011684153563] + "ciede2000": [10.388117392320593, 4.156407858428101, 6.935226413936516, 6.638656843310813, 13.160946443441336, 6.830319245453032, 8.422263655557403, 12.912746039703233, 6.433524053803738, 6.22049281006557, 7.74091626640621, 5.211188542670839, 9.255958328184839, 9.257515406509583, 8.366904298021636, 5.19097070942695, 6.289443504258958, 8.65255059978951, 6.845079798982916, 6.379400773226219, 7.694337056868465, 7.345495589749001, 7.5344401130464895, 8.438455192526305, 5.347954694218693, 4.507956377876799, 11.577720442172764, 6.9153071722086805, 11.357428272596458, 7.208533514403987, 9.102794980527806, 7.727547865136503], + "ssimulacra2": [-79.0157376661152, -64.02689951577776, -64.23544943222109, -64.229684884791, -208.63707841673295, -70.26664186430509, -72.77609989039189, -131.16282914427418, -64.27794596784142, -64.31113394921212, -67.66979727842346, -63.647016938594334, -93.99954002842202, -73.19577535001869, -66.93808050371584, -64.26103098160351, -77.87883907315276, -73.6438854430925, -64.54951945167747, -66.34199929964069, -65.80985880939164, -65.57688584235308, -64.21066597561514, -72.45909925871581, -64.21910769930992, -63.44932087051279, -105.7840378491099, -73.49191134901753, -162.1388167244429, -65.96457690318931, -67.48435055253682, -79.40184289824583], + "butteraugli": [14.956546455288859, 13.962467311085012, 16.57955882796914, 16.51204718662522, 20.81793505684237, 17.701561451802508, 17.487145726954637, 22.610013587371387, 17.2952021562094, 16.97091370039556, 16.045787843514756, 17.556436870277196, 16.74084138691804, 17.55398703293796, 21.63790631999409, 13.801488331523565, 16.449605351858832, 18.0332534346327, 17.46764269086006, 24.203802703049103, 18.820403126867227, 14.592776604128252, 16.61762153103629, 17.25910739944104, 16.77756944123021, 16.337847886597096, 24.062766870541882, 16.52685354950494, 25.22286661253169, 20.56569877573245, 24.587895777943416, 19.01675031699264], + "dssim": [0.36686825120064015, 0.18694997135546465, 0.16676871027806195, 0.20894078827223417, 0.3870753789479029, 0.27906465266282654, 0.2475275317413258, 0.37992479747326374, 0.17829268307519214, 0.19853917493501466, 0.26763640832849467, 0.16593737099475853, 0.38501645827438646, 0.3207905207769519, 0.20037085510332725, 0.217825051500055, 0.2385590532890372, 0.3048955041450162, 0.24276719358176024, 0.17381016976512537, 0.23361807529900275, 0.2562792407299087, 0.15358842284858115, 0.30202874101182287, 0.15438516826315823, 0.0919217960189902, 0.3348374627106829, 0.24206236923674845, 0.3331322450484161, 0.2421760468952902, 0.2529487437237763, 0.30438923979950294] + } + }, + { + "label": " 12B pre-adoption L5/C2", + "tune": "l1=5:5 c=2:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [15.212620789899919, 5.698417311499421, 15.338380313653639, 14.605831994631975, 16.095497180428364, 9.980764780442392, 13.694133134281328, 18.677685758073522, 10.883034833673353, 11.27040375022522, 14.939193123757802, 12.06034865488856, 14.230349339650083, 16.638414703497663, 22.52374847393008, 9.907170445057988, 11.596871382631898, 14.378565831532816, 11.147131600808372, 11.597487451761358, 12.537592287194707, 14.21105626552387, 18.880595433499348, 14.347667652754405, 15.59623868289097, 13.136187415272994, 18.820276926538376, 9.127995368715867, 18.76978414173806, 15.29196537682031, 18.616244105723194, 15.42604564819023], + "ssimulacra2": [-473.26076613449663, -85.44854914679175, -286.3332460119974, -269.4037357995748, -824.791338914347, -125.04198704105761, -440.6498009652777, -802.6459954508907, -222.6007827788357, -247.98726466623464, -358.2128251141822, -116.13141105444711, -577.0042440268339, -588.2059809546774, -463.18027132567477, -146.10728179656152, -439.6572516802456, -488.8989633219297, -246.10331994187527, -184.68862206501956, -311.1384957973589, -318.6675504628101, -362.16810549500906, -523.0803377946295, -344.0027438008715, -118.40011777563305, -700.3122083203556, -131.3828976199814, -601.5658860744568, -488.7450491347207, -901.8201114202902, -542.5755400784699], + "butteraugli": [23.140330972573235, 30.07364704443277, 37.39309291959069, 27.168485745501176, 29.38446422663551, 35.39692220367089, 26.934714756529573, 38.81294566088987, 38.08796721476471, 33.15952881094927, 30.521172083067086, 42.709000316915, 38.29512518958525, 39.11683717399309, 57.4413971557766, 33.11830806616516, 27.955277619978236, 32.5931760443475, 27.646276435741147, 43.03047363572255, 37.14250235635342, 29.01169739360647, 41.8425077972829, 45.45702647744639, 52.00646343855315, 52.050192861341024, 39.55372777811456, 21.68166127863529, 35.46858016387194, 47.86394282778733, 54.78080615468368, 43.66152601755342], + "dssim": [0.3791766243862786, 0.18875763916330568, 0.18165457429438575, 0.2388344970143252, 0.3981191836441361, 0.27972355865313125, 0.25827518457656795, 0.39688111639838414, 0.18494624385661762, 0.21031344729308682, 0.29605052890047945, 0.17770847303349802, 0.40009290713258683, 0.34633640165912316, 0.2325062240902081, 0.22492747222001547, 0.27288103114490403, 0.32227153715322143, 0.2535805138889611, 0.17584212895286638, 0.24415778778239422, 0.2700311247563265, 0.19236810510611657, 0.3181516665857692, 0.20493456721158204, 0.11084171289855677, 0.35655826012819025, 0.24121061612577427, 0.3468923816216629, 0.2690489270070454, 0.327423760478203, 0.3253724978435766] + } + }, + { + "label": " 16B pre-adoption L10/C3", + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=3:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [15.001144690406923, 5.595937007449213, 14.93223522000005, 13.54979120424313, 16.024043763931857, 9.390022173418386, 12.755460282577246, 18.505624371488388, 10.721460112624495, 10.547911604178783, 13.224073894191976, 10.7471554031756, 13.63881227513867, 15.718585978663288, 20.542515661166902, 8.926178236304336, 10.605934548193655, 14.029576133196182, 10.65341704330554, 11.147270323613554, 11.34058249910944, 13.061925127108958, 18.22816689550216, 13.010231761624578, 12.663015446587641, 11.215592769597576, 17.26990135430992, 9.086968304165966, 17.96336805028002, 14.193225670938546, 17.641102981031167, 13.108093056605558], + "ssimulacra2": [-461.1209442230902, -83.79283525515882, -287.45860034698177, -239.2783624669487, -817.5453356194964, -121.91566880015958, -428.33559272481875, -795.9441560478388, -213.8859638310269, -216.1084682808193, -315.0953712042605, -104.5332761445593, -554.5925445146519, -550.245417137575, -412.1483198006821, -123.71280720714043, -416.9261954887627, -474.80055391415056, -234.24916395107653, -165.61013701829285, -265.2379081145774, -287.00249464297775, -339.9656721653657, -470.8120987441363, -283.94758400916976, -107.37682987721726, -625.761755417966, -124.32943149713114, -584.230979168254, -435.7696325830657, -839.8669201758468, -474.1427781051375], + "butteraugli": [23.601687376220763, 29.426140722369666, 34.056274633061534, 24.283639198710304, 28.90246841750762, 34.02283663064875, 26.546460139244704, 38.250592695905716, 35.34567795768272, 27.745207801611837, 28.103026640301806, 39.23882914039459, 29.050055776351787, 37.05213615308227, 51.01134008715351, 30.381563503843257, 25.092280928558797, 30.916598699532226, 26.104395380603936, 41.265420843676, 31.726214217542733, 27.000928069903534, 39.99972857236532, 42.93725752590813, 38.34090262085838, 34.57978108527089, 38.710236832675854, 19.829528593807044, 31.831141395307828, 40.76188428122089, 43.48227471250076, 33.61208396215242], + "dssim": [0.3791339818879624, 0.18730248828472323, 0.18191198919353946, 0.23309679032177577, 0.39779758499767504, 0.27843450116142343, 0.2568628043790523, 0.3962089963952056, 0.18456641989661576, 0.20883625437980552, 0.28473772530749164, 0.1755270772303174, 0.3971684846162712, 0.3421351525637848, 0.22660206265846633, 0.22220271324813684, 0.26758765775570503, 0.3227615527151355, 0.2534234574129425, 0.17502879953572664, 0.24186228797315207, 0.26645446034225084, 0.19026230778744668, 0.3138850650814555, 0.196918106550863, 0.10516480336648243, 0.35273782093453343, 0.2419167499716206, 0.3450077199321174, 0.26491228268240385, 0.32506945809752774, 0.3222844748922852] + } + }, + { + "label": " 21B pre-adoption L13/C6", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [15.010370368009328, 5.673815641318235, 13.779147634335809, 12.701312286390637, 15.958736851151953, 9.305439692236646, 12.429303903345495, 18.047743356102067, 10.058011584238065, 9.99185527693874, 13.04321150566051, 10.364931044885378, 13.624744837895086, 15.140721706677347, 18.329742059932187, 8.616869438497654, 10.082859447015187, 13.238402739045274, 10.597449235646836, 10.78900382984535, 11.397424216346765, 12.559963433338504, 18.15955732063641, 12.71300523391807, 12.386001722049539, 10.084640119267283, 16.448742960738617, 8.150437495491376, 15.06806956167474, 13.87252408086536, 17.20904292441107, 12.392527185408095], + "ssimulacra2": [-459.4345787226133, -84.24633677846049, -280.1038624045813, -223.6549900981908, -815.7622615969333, -120.91104801282401, -414.95698458591835, -755.6512165654963, -190.57438576773018, -204.86889583053983, -311.5152982361156, -99.61354374135522, -555.1711467439045, -546.8165240836685, -417.37797212716373, -117.2413862108391, -389.21381179320565, -463.06062149961974, -233.00929867000013, -165.03542659292287, -265.55957965922966, -278.8526306497248, -329.12180995426377, -458.771979621062, -273.76273881816985, -104.08846630786257, -603.8871664502852, -103.98846397451683, -579.6617205523839, -427.25872161943437, -838.3022554797735, -439.4815602637831], + "butteraugli": [23.507919366753796, 28.68759448556584, 33.566868491826135, 24.605403396678796, 28.623029016699736, 33.75012360630408, 25.568724811734757, 37.17896611125778, 29.777614063910278, 27.525174840932333, 27.71944726234599, 37.74434705896993, 28.96462255960439, 36.10861976854063, 49.43898646717174, 28.13281003922832, 25.258912558185045, 29.96020464780774, 25.512874026049086, 39.785671079139114, 30.679851356557407, 27.171156778863235, 38.85868905329881, 43.997688666150246, 37.45456103978125, 34.20538606607738, 40.75643605210701, 19.211155708745054, 31.486396106109776, 39.60962881366688, 42.78799815346377, 31.938990330015628], + "dssim": [0.3790615287636109, 0.1878233606639208, 0.18301043661410638, 0.23117909368843187, 0.3977451191121308, 0.27832947941099406, 0.25643355555972913, 0.3940748972085645, 0.18328031728218025, 0.20823936739750337, 0.28474574437320443, 0.175130682230006, 0.3972190948813364, 0.3400035360975464, 0.2235037749593471, 0.22198478532615767, 0.2601442958395268, 0.3212625486446372, 0.252350001586614, 0.17543769740845488, 0.24200183986415258, 0.2660629659706286, 0.18946609446616264, 0.31335884182294327, 0.1964869174665677, 0.10353739883978558, 0.34671601311125, 0.24088064748114063, 0.34668440240849596, 0.26405408631612115, 0.3186295602105058, 0.3199704683042618] + } + }, + { + "label": " 24B pre-adoption L18/C6", + "tune": "l1=18:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [14.957914311458325, 5.606705350661274, 13.372880559473732, 12.235614704986382, 15.811234233011843, 9.187765285018537, 12.08709197829264, 17.85944645197357, 9.744599944651963, 9.737912606276613, 12.010910884867068, 9.894135930600362, 12.376862408449842, 15.123304895465214, 16.803729078034298, 8.336513961198621, 9.730849549768998, 13.125885975762522, 10.13908836225266, 10.159754708141161, 11.23016011885826, 12.496193369531184, 17.643073430386153, 12.460821349156646, 11.46458599853449, 9.23490085537548, 16.092357224331376, 8.146915936319111, 14.622612595140595, 13.11156532100788, 16.759223003023937, 11.870685358188817], + "ssimulacra2": [-459.0153599282021, -81.95085837038653, -257.7949780054394, -184.29109296628235, -797.3266761354162, -124.21147743081289, -386.4524845272593, -725.3535144084266, -183.27641391867627, -188.74586352870045, -274.7208871769954, -96.05302898206801, -477.3284591424647, -532.8767493046995, -338.0683550954189, -110.9109177912647, -367.23230433094693, -447.49348724601145, -205.12542750642518, -156.62848003280305, -258.37025980268953, -269.1350410593575, -304.77904005012584, -457.1647397529473, -242.77228817667606, -90.08960361021553, -593.8687406294952, -103.67834454974474, -555.8557033873132, -413.5476532636819, -816.2816189503998, -418.7677433043468], + "butteraugli": [23.27488822819061, 28.54547764988675, 30.871929369034792, 24.122421084297844, 28.409395769139934, 30.65841544730573, 24.884359879279742, 33.44677077653497, 28.463920940135335, 25.84822312461905, 25.568708462453838, 36.9783291304565, 23.565456615742907, 33.481323518109804, 46.18126282273246, 25.808040224100626, 23.656459480803615, 30.00303714627459, 25.1460252597501, 37.546435928744884, 28.888210344800985, 26.491097877302494, 34.44523020523399, 38.80602178421509, 35.69293215527373, 30.86072578024851, 38.14639846122791, 19.11499972408063, 30.290115004053376, 38.927612947985146, 40.2898844021895, 30.55434114289001], + "dssim": [0.37899659351297527, 0.18940906319580691, 0.18221468562177107, 0.22844798850315662, 0.39733479979199704, 0.27883347143125226, 0.25587947632412367, 0.3936108010744052, 0.18255736585922272, 0.2075007563202967, 0.28007341754128, 0.17464535730098946, 0.3943198486116435, 0.3415749998158466, 0.21459398043609873, 0.22176480995026654, 0.25815620394434113, 0.32046387807321486, 0.25159835626000737, 0.17407658389093522, 0.24190677961425516, 0.26586059071619705, 0.18670264055792107, 0.31353383342496244, 0.19275356693758627, 0.10031304047463957, 0.34542506316460053, 0.2409276136175615, 0.34461511208514195, 0.26306199163286026, 0.31873204563281843, 0.31942461521680865] + } + }, + { + "label": " 28B pre-adoption L21/C8", + "tune": "l1=21:5 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28], + "ciede2000": [14.994041770712792, 5.592760791623113, 13.064209327880537, 11.974614201729205, 15.811939550217579, 8.967270539973114, 12.11370811497653, 17.628244480195807, 9.78590963347603, 9.044039240350488, 10.924566724467516, 9.697601172283699, 12.047090597652105, 14.71964770469682, 15.952411731674973, 7.810046020136364, 9.65852832236104, 12.535209637340982, 10.034402918872456, 9.650628112097737, 10.38766079902778, 12.274841452303834, 16.776164546119162, 12.319494690916452, 11.194428597494912, 8.944138091016125, 15.85625162165727, 8.179067923245345, 14.505334462555156, 13.022047817609048, 16.192531873158867, 11.537016851965117], + "ssimulacra2": [-453.401429755716, -80.89984448978382, -245.7010248822496, -182.85902573555126, -795.5518029224919, -122.22764474877832, -383.55038718860186, -721.1403548591107, -180.60506011824248, -174.12927728225947, -275.70020460598954, -91.53476497752257, -468.72707081807744, -527.146257019313, -287.186072864065, -109.48177787899326, -357.8761817617527, -434.18829301816925, -203.81885948616514, -154.6195781690611, -250.7878262831793, -264.5329030338953, -275.43026514335287, -457.3635297784974, -239.18610453719447, -86.92357166365144, -575.5718146238133, -104.39566612596929, -554.2800728180018, -416.32018249887255, -801.7464482758671, -399.42829918396023], + "butteraugli": [23.134794601236965, 27.812414176671272, 29.25971300744151, 23.243758845642432, 28.159796818870245, 30.513857608957824, 24.885535506228806, 33.127719542107236, 28.187106752233813, 25.538382381032125, 25.218601315743012, 36.143296077013325, 23.45674327867886, 33.4968140746519, 43.301975706509175, 26.066644828656496, 23.263703798160723, 29.018857638604675, 25.106027060065845, 37.01670847524007, 28.209171768694407, 25.891983691613774, 32.12913661481792, 36.040672174226366, 35.53429012532829, 27.211902574492658, 38.37259884427828, 19.00287613910669, 29.985061740131055, 38.44473230766673, 39.975417934285936, 30.420981625092185], + "dssim": [0.37883008762440246, 0.18935017449024483, 0.18147130341811857, 0.22839936284974577, 0.39736110014920406, 0.2786636765992767, 0.2557243728143489, 0.39363753073819785, 0.18244065146624305, 0.20676669672222997, 0.27925062100175546, 0.173890620449268, 0.39386668701662764, 0.3392321687043508, 0.2117255941837669, 0.22188149927588374, 0.2570644862148498, 0.32004266815469273, 0.2513452756082567, 0.17379260144947573, 0.24174183388867848, 0.2658126558764077, 0.18406786646572437, 0.3134689975324203, 0.19231767412546436, 0.10022220627273787, 0.3447280559219055, 0.24104646308039812, 0.3444094822899164, 0.26360701014349075, 0.31455680700892064, 0.31836203823683173] + } + }, + { + "label": " 32B pre-adoption L26/C9", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.97060246716555, 5.609469516729318, 12.845351278355698, 11.682481073556591, 15.745117167785608, 8.742407855764363, 11.97132164007678, 17.27551065526376, 9.43395890710866, 8.939234694585961, 10.897257932728738, 9.662170508524643, 11.644909361930752, 14.550240013926281, 15.387252963074092, 7.503363259756005, 9.383929197410334, 12.439497729352466, 9.754066348852321, 9.334311111356197, 10.38392778897854, 12.017992130005902, 16.448881564148092, 12.148304075645395, 10.028909288814273, 8.643039921322279, 15.533682075917923, 8.147975140352761, 14.345438131145166, 12.766554960950563, 16.08310237946088, 11.206410866218635], + "ssimulacra2": [-445.2503973592145, -81.00475283512361, -222.7074422332762, -179.0403753809689, -772.1655635655139, -117.4121498666315, -365.0882893399145, -689.2897622445489, -158.42247340524546, -172.61457323229462, -270.96886789162875, -92.72704390964154, -445.47905711053727, -517.1634122814157, -275.1290028640853, -93.37105607708, -322.08664052150016, -419.11700637374895, -191.81279551680058, -150.78156207724237, -251.05375256788693, -243.6165797456917, -253.15735142625965, -439.0486092102716, -193.65971060282357, -82.85560394093437, -561.4251604374282, -103.03650116989971, -537.8258476450569, -383.5804218068266, -789.5518525122292, -367.8061917262152], + "butteraugli": [23.61260833635229, 27.770840742887525, 27.09176586358167, 23.024015998077754, 27.119737299131543, 26.895237795296605, 24.212074337262496, 33.07402768667264, 27.624259784617845, 24.65749284345379, 24.840971421227163, 34.229036876315426, 22.01522939081892, 30.399384550109676, 43.6775010370909, 21.557583147501017, 22.924766056934583, 27.841503148417086, 24.942789014202265, 35.55609548763177, 28.297573022978543, 26.065967590355797, 31.199406751247206, 31.696028043719846, 33.57683837732417, 25.338823248068085, 37.72866870125821, 18.839249918662045, 29.381327139174676, 35.08043154422975, 39.20212393116367, 27.792302601786687], + "dssim": [0.378477384278724, 0.18912610254475004, 0.18038687461769554, 0.22838446221673742, 0.3967225075873569, 0.2794864770392025, 0.25525356618602546, 0.3923933614286697, 0.1819614709651039, 0.2066035689792331, 0.27910867632033176, 0.1741247316904868, 0.3937120452311927, 0.33980684959437535, 0.21031535008453067, 0.22108900974018314, 0.25163550228030174, 0.3196287953186937, 0.2510112449320999, 0.17340917906268705, 0.2418067625523172, 0.26444665974283843, 0.1813982358247611, 0.3127918727026111, 0.18701818294257772, 0.09954758231965283, 0.3456191754251916, 0.24102083893927545, 0.3439373914583846, 0.26303579806191135, 0.31547634759247245, 0.3176837816320681] + } + }, + { + "label": " 40B pre-adoption L34/C12", + "tune": "l1=34:5 c=12:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40], + "ciede2000": [14.861230296022082, 5.6091866258610725, 12.310638576662445, 10.664686393652303, 15.678327452211263, 8.673047168280153, 11.624218713999811, 17.163596925588877, 9.060368199452673, 8.535503210423906, 10.78661318289507, 9.241247411122648, 11.535904767757795, 14.030702166818802, 14.147083429432941, 7.07979785790617, 9.036507842655784, 12.179269901285009, 9.72638587435319, 9.131011434648155, 10.31326387535322, 11.438616160516789, 14.518980015256986, 11.93459920497244, 9.486417378942301, 7.788937005965849, 15.354680362755117, 7.444988083369963, 14.297026285463586, 11.708430062011066, 15.738187123938664, 10.711797605358079], + "ssimulacra2": [-426.78961138431737, -79.85985635379461, -202.52113529385377, -165.47914470590194, -760.002741820083, -116.01425872212249, -348.2582273933877, -679.1360365328587, -147.2143141881226, -149.64382245662077, -263.4893438250777, -90.78353899872644, -441.2727793746807, -481.9213454958144, -254.0315757973483, -85.31107374169858, -294.64941295553706, -390.84484934710866, -191.8193896423673, -143.07254531852914, -248.63850652448798, -223.71688388531516, -212.63694141896292, -417.9896148583423, -173.16350790387338, -72.93467266083451, -556.6317777879432, -93.52239954293768, -533.3076838166091, -352.4135177375533, -755.2043937620069, -313.2790653985373], + "butteraugli": [24.058982420740758, 25.76361402359574, 24.89932144906437, 22.61358498884842, 27.170119628121085, 26.79892397982735, 23.571336197240615, 32.037614192786656, 25.755542515799863, 24.519451851168522, 24.535647008954005, 32.74168463868133, 21.997005420454574, 28.022536947466886, 42.718249286032886, 18.771994857337834, 22.241257394738074, 26.66489000123791, 24.414310327014814, 35.29277745082715, 27.53880786744897, 25.445223282761077, 30.10839811120682, 27.695161529681695, 31.263394593713482, 23.512794278064632, 37.108750540764014, 18.361097801315594, 29.35638991254177, 33.59407803716443, 38.93637398189631, 26.603907055308667], + "dssim": [0.37790293671837927, 0.1896690571174709, 0.1808139385620542, 0.22586026013365962, 0.39629804267440605, 0.2794529475638119, 0.25459857908598493, 0.3923271322141109, 0.18178806509863882, 0.20507710300838838, 0.2788262401309909, 0.17355963021215998, 0.39366296300236786, 0.3388693191684694, 0.21206084430510092, 0.22040380424487854, 0.2498992392062856, 0.3192650763434691, 0.25130249391067894, 0.17362575038503136, 0.24192685810527176, 0.26437504719229743, 0.17874021003340118, 0.31159935207200806, 0.18458688863250589, 0.0979553649311094, 0.3478679558846086, 0.2407679008099215, 0.34369098770571715, 0.26086279520480127, 0.31352022527192447, 0.31581489847882493] + } + }, + { + "label": " 48B pre-adoption L42/C15", + "tune": "l1=42:5 c=15:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [13.942618484293355, 5.6301234645837654, 11.946681436592094, 10.014750258502074, 15.628584531447267, 8.44390095607352, 11.4956975625673, 16.757559230919824, 8.911795231021204, 8.365945212574196, 10.352681404275089, 8.654549677618427, 11.318433556379274, 13.539836562748487, 13.51070872374235, 6.588726309992626, 8.83754581025171, 11.900726762637767, 9.422911244383577, 8.450277661154397, 9.770001856904878, 10.782811500091285, 13.719564817071262, 11.49652363125865, 9.045434359831493, 7.4179157836838225, 15.160203306910326, 7.460384427140581, 14.088951071288458, 11.572019197175607, 15.565201438646222, 10.361396223023254], + "ssimulacra2": [-317.54426951910864, -79.03963753616449, -191.78347291275878, -144.23211179881463, -734.2221195974014, -107.60848882275332, -303.48441738492613, -635.7715097747536, -129.78824082232236, -142.69121911302904, -237.17676107986892, -82.23173088012709, -412.5333821744606, -399.36730221423716, -240.42661244914433, -78.695791367325, -284.1611477334467, -363.0603099740723, -164.90557370148332, -125.23936403158163, -225.79889850652876, -193.2720933820957, -189.14636894115495, -362.74956433225873, -160.31988377456378, -69.76765225165875, -541.3515757116186, -94.34944042862662, -518.6976175795849, -349.1802023267808, -739.3053063495041, -290.0842925734085], + "butteraugli": [19.75475546695577, 24.35814498999041, 24.230062043683933, 22.188674728568113, 26.800204813873933, 27.974495574898867, 22.27793867630785, 31.518753118355523, 25.395498358664657, 24.896839187108345, 23.516985946964372, 27.697825339420945, 21.4855725766112, 25.108023875992075, 37.31318480301588, 18.854036963502892, 22.41714673284022, 25.170938634612565, 24.083349869935518, 34.9583881338586, 26.76551003948491, 23.07384507534725, 29.92063241527983, 23.31955765927229, 29.44000953381743, 22.784041417871347, 36.60830730137658, 18.289857039770222, 29.197469448671757, 33.4355087651457, 39.16316572610278, 25.874306209135778], + "dssim": [0.37506381339632994, 0.19061613213722844, 0.17451335920475336, 0.2243951695138025, 0.3959728225342758, 0.28010122933807013, 0.25427588140944335, 0.39100440737887315, 0.18140774206742444, 0.2046905718301278, 0.2773319697881319, 0.17288262499461865, 0.39333185766999873, 0.33678437479839296, 0.2134679801075246, 0.22015079084839312, 0.2498975910791224, 0.31858190957862464, 0.2509413265608341, 0.17277230259334347, 0.24163779584661943, 0.2633597577113096, 0.1773742073965831, 0.30987687142535303, 0.18206693626442005, 0.09665468834887042, 0.34545195991678823, 0.24089883061916023, 0.3425260983826916, 0.2605908610419839, 0.3117764911170302, 0.3148694717883016] + } + }, + { + "label": " 64B pre-adoption L58/C21", + "tune": "l1=58:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64], + "ciede2000": [13.643100476909831, 5.569194783857839, 11.044354711102988, 9.673584419202859, 15.511214385625983, 8.244043407940955, 11.115993760526463, 16.378205003439245, 8.955611343684295, 8.210602729018404, 10.300117787794422, 7.66259055423316, 10.974722113716998, 12.955515922008457, 12.217152882288222, 6.430755215005505, 8.335624317282806, 11.530797645726059, 8.541883557726552, 8.087896424140782, 9.729342580934516, 10.444306168523376, 12.405692852980751, 11.19923024447719, 8.559347410244035, 6.8068549708990105, 14.7021305854611, 7.384983250403675, 13.563597461823674, 11.053782992266639, 14.923472568258287, 10.03259853703383], + "ssimulacra2": [-281.15201560403307, -73.20323952470287, -172.21895216721168, -124.74918670064139, -697.9465592601048, -105.33535383179867, -293.3323604738387, -587.5309659534278, -114.09430241351015, -138.37075381024133, -232.88200164852776, -73.8088890162827, -350.27910082251776, -377.6780942698983, -193.81344612782442, -74.40064986936616, -224.59460662294873, -334.4315854762817, -132.02243364957437, -107.94215350042145, -213.35679946412398, -159.91760330248337, -155.83883748017453, -332.90315125690773, -134.7681165504939, -66.46379949098204, -472.65006593785995, -91.44860343506409, -476.8421723178416, -292.0380566356118, -644.7605941822694, -259.8674166167999], + "butteraugli": [18.91257633305417, 20.845520278049506, 23.360415350702965, 22.161005806310886, 26.57469194750733, 25.805278136192314, 22.304671067178642, 30.490060251270652, 23.582243015907252, 24.14297117654317, 22.997018683397517, 25.5645236720047, 21.294422109878806, 24.5126012597334, 33.40730263607464, 18.97353751884108, 20.563595392659717, 24.847865551133026, 23.718546969839963, 33.95003195022763, 25.761929237878352, 21.131002008400966, 27.0434540394884, 22.65189155286248, 29.219577374041638, 21.77893003182631, 36.023249216203716, 17.99191517714813, 28.257408468740223, 33.16394288621897, 36.84019885898522, 25.045273528230723], + "dssim": [0.37392920437890953, 0.19269433111788198, 0.17460089952258273, 0.22287422373307247, 0.39589998086296746, 0.27938479814355666, 0.2538347286618714, 0.38993930985411646, 0.18127226037315558, 0.20477669354266959, 0.2775443118374963, 0.17205205578839244, 0.392109011675694, 0.33555250173105405, 0.21295908170650968, 0.22001617524125877, 0.2462928107317257, 0.3174227512483955, 0.24975755248295034, 0.1727833023964352, 0.24175330492274627, 0.2625001215380396, 0.17533928584832736, 0.3094224340435593, 0.17921073817836142, 0.09559900118187731, 0.3425683790464673, 0.2407992678590491, 0.34238405417077644, 0.2589555296334277, 0.30651058653344143, 0.3137649983273332] + } + }, + { + "label": " 80B pre-adoption L74/C27", + "tune": "l1=74:5 c=27:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [13.355819756408147, 5.49714346814437, 10.136966944063799, 9.291467265524753, 14.868253402642662, 8.054585735866944, 10.711908075275339, 15.740863356390813, 8.836215679461489, 7.871943277670464, 9.813478347004317, 7.3027097078407746, 10.769982787835437, 12.17167417142493, 11.76246336521999, 6.286119083816273, 8.137171985179352, 11.044381818871997, 8.339354470351445, 7.614039988638426, 9.494300364216459, 9.852433812173372, 11.93085140270688, 10.960168504887516, 8.061697379805002, 6.28892133914616, 14.525197268324215, 7.368167747769391, 13.2181087795817, 10.338962800647773, 14.241371943796029, 9.692127451899745], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.10798278570917, -70.21756873992817, -124.76231697634606, -105.69485310932072, -641.7169067193014, -102.81063095355321, -251.684657314451, -503.64929399084895, -111.65980850744029, -119.66106757559882, -204.10609829075236, -66.68139933805904, -306.2342169785662, -330.7602374710104, -164.26753155013478, -70.75170779894464, -211.58204522088954, -274.69806270100884, -117.5286218686941, -90.52092156533803, -201.1429653665627, -145.5064991817231, -136.56632332858328, -306.2089466960455, -112.08016337872095, -65.15703160370154, -446.07048005788886, -91.1999360749503, -447.0071757073887, -235.59093783040652, -552.1239204423739, -240.57381615628515], + "butteraugli": [18.222375143464916, 19.838899448694075, 22.101540252361, 21.38039835043251, 25.257878141878027, 22.70760047362155, 22.487116519854357, 28.507525413320536, 23.271215051263965, 22.867511782268764, 23.252508616106905, 25.516127026701003, 20.50607105039436, 23.085335134962097, 31.609545715220516, 17.852838061401396, 20.19670207857516, 22.622896809976666, 24.24276861574202, 31.664760906022423, 25.572751298393783, 20.646204875031408, 25.6129464911065, 21.85961910251166, 26.225596531535746, 21.35507577702997, 34.843710252025744, 17.915154486658324, 27.94129159152347, 31.620356091038605, 36.64410965481037, 23.8297373606117], + "dssim": [0.3731731214575279, 0.1949933202197534, 0.17337284882918497, 0.22112963642633526, 0.3956176063430362, 0.2788954707859943, 0.2529087566094177, 0.388903366448938, 0.18156000796823563, 0.20418842875595117, 0.2756405118025339, 0.17094589110354486, 0.3915494454419353, 0.33347648988514694, 0.21098004063185433, 0.2196930202376784, 0.24802662318996177, 0.31686947025735623, 0.24966305787935222, 0.17256974840078398, 0.2414662563036391, 0.26240466097983306, 0.172110202889242, 0.3081772352934463, 0.17642008627741596, 0.09496379002611932, 0.34281739262588584, 0.24082524644189507, 0.34186590958490404, 0.25637125958195794, 0.3057442766887968, 0.31300016166969746] + } + }, + { + "label": " 108B pre-adoption t2 L104/C36", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [12.728818828385105, 5.339397562125044, 9.098271130896627, 8.718407337838606, 14.690061915079795, 7.736224427149106, 10.535199313599197, 15.381284113797166, 8.517415621713148, 7.579183754529323, 9.426291904949274, 7.031109423762472, 10.366873013199365, 11.793993731177009, 10.851578954680072, 6.068391676737865, 7.665449962929099, 10.570760365212584, 7.9845236457709445, 7.460262902099692, 9.413634075428055, 9.354352472942887, 11.323619440741187, 10.609981232955398, 7.559351258651133, 5.781133398578064, 13.789285035762267, 7.207489336960133, 12.876720172003019, 9.957265624802991, 13.494829318139242, 9.355620311832855], + "ssimulacra2": [-222.48648824312704, -67.86003894255757, -84.00980282081935, -88.43842570243967, -586.3331657839826, -90.86048806259089, -207.15435326355737, -433.5269060326008, -92.89971919587515, -98.36652275801313, -137.10335626897577, -66.44095871380497, -241.52468342087138, -261.0437657604237, -125.0070158485762, -68.55360792788073, -163.60398134908797, -216.45633905897182, -92.79112391574921, -85.63161306171384, -191.18339099002804, -117.648399214504, -99.98049750533553, -242.54112476624186, -91.64296390461286, -64.37817810861819, -345.14608853576885, -88.09659277031858, -390.55969527450134, -207.59054810409094, -438.00039906164113, -208.50239554355068], + "butteraugli": [17.790084855897863, 18.858566022660156, 19.872092420959728, 19.95096124535411, 24.92204496259993, 21.666822604162046, 21.67315368314784, 26.780540544970005, 20.97394358580506, 22.066342640983322, 20.690117037928815, 25.010327952416304, 19.640591136793617, 21.46371429482544, 30.071305316378584, 16.87456128081433, 19.511404427838997, 21.70927009298209, 23.39294398923647, 30.84047519838656, 25.36053125185639, 20.108929398354103, 22.262741685154726, 21.013294948807996, 23.41239887551431, 19.329529849208814, 31.517092835393594, 17.650421088544913, 27.100211573434606, 27.169162121411546, 34.655238228865876, 22.758598506529847], + "dssim": [0.37251407724441343, 0.19691395462617645, 0.17528400238539804, 0.219496608695935, 0.39457708194722274, 0.2797683505161439, 0.25186361760577036, 0.38826897551119166, 0.18179132605879628, 0.20271604926842013, 0.27467343173440306, 0.17071359254136986, 0.39046080453552773, 0.3328478089210235, 0.20856051378519685, 0.21951258915899735, 0.24652085519562544, 0.3143377111640756, 0.24849763589159007, 0.1731197513199057, 0.242080838568075, 0.2612180331032846, 0.16874865393395738, 0.30698225286883407, 0.17398344824162953, 0.09439799077344563, 0.3392805800036186, 0.2408084213027617, 0.34054855189591043, 0.25852240977616636, 0.30345691146610987, 0.31231592410474973] + } + }, + { + "label": " 161B pre-adoption t2 L156/C56", + "tune": "l1=39:5 c=14:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161], + "ciede2000": [11.929886376144877, 5.160507144134413, 8.406472095816646, 8.095745475835326, 14.25279739613861, 7.3915230217696966, 9.793249045845162, 14.610311136404084, 7.879080550380472, 7.3311022935537995, 8.937722661176, 6.498163545280644, 10.069545654700129, 10.899256018524843, 9.898874806989586, 5.812661568192618, 7.300259206670861, 9.976635773850719, 7.564271585579755, 6.931941092166166, 8.885513425592691, 8.67710544952755, 9.639728132306352, 10.19312755762675, 6.8867182869751575, 5.28195683803232, 13.426529505914944, 7.224514460260154, 12.243485897661659, 9.103203231120558, 12.210345698482417, 8.848705049576612], + "ssimulacra2": [-149.60314454528697, -64.99804588031196, -71.28859089513892, -74.9666345459627, -438.1377143741005, -83.78345207318068, -158.23118728365097, -313.3749141939392, -76.23086840820233, -81.60338377206696, -99.61814598654837, -65.1449283509925, -194.4060743553428, -165.29868416015472, -89.42191601290202, -66.06607273506864, -129.67710820658635, -145.46458500725333, -76.50879919743602, -74.08061606365948, -129.75389181309905, -84.52386502406466, -77.118508779521, -174.2263932575451, -75.27448399017447, -64.229203548552, -301.5042530677956, -88.5016283146106, -302.67671923134526, -143.72383458736036, -245.23742499209686, -164.8089468718793], + "butteraugli": [16.768010890360074, 16.995986766825055, 18.344996818541826, 18.722589726520827, 23.575358259902185, 20.96733386754194, 20.625132291556138, 25.24211645427216, 19.32592630394444, 19.961899774133204, 19.584951247636706, 22.626889892609398, 19.04424828830628, 19.459011002802505, 26.422970505058533, 15.32604161717182, 18.49818155184997, 20.200814705686696, 20.719760431438132, 28.99137566325116, 24.673193875137258, 18.259969370658677, 20.697374454663446, 20.076589134310368, 20.40826628028191, 18.254972452800015, 28.894072877777727, 17.650684126954854, 26.328984606249936, 24.95013292292606, 32.37376765452289, 22.005072594814223], + "dssim": [0.37070048284593304, 0.19838152555640476, 0.17571441293280382, 0.21766621193910934, 0.392987752563958, 0.28085687780097657, 0.24967034072740296, 0.38703629754210944, 0.18090116652464455, 0.20296132606457246, 0.27124264280525334, 0.16887828473259026, 0.3892269181782233, 0.33055491734267484, 0.20526374315347962, 0.21897400465180672, 0.24514152660535116, 0.3114000303562954, 0.24717048171549744, 0.17295643375582354, 0.24082429281035966, 0.25931945725318784, 0.16723483042568782, 0.30687752735487794, 0.16934286104881952, 0.09319547112851517, 0.3429134354037051, 0.24144250204134132, 0.3370022914429783, 0.2571568505871056, 0.2924530446012452, 0.31122872129772716] + } + }, + { + "label": " 246B pre-adoption t2 L248/C84", + "tune": "l1=62:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246], + "ciede2000": [11.435571050573525, 4.967830100259589, 7.678126537406509, 7.4918610586840035, 13.753731892718514, 7.09723534845185, 9.225738647437423, 13.828779827372179, 7.222380193901777, 6.93145607382811, 8.586343046067826, 5.970102206034147, 9.712955543436545, 10.145190770658662, 9.148808166858174, 5.525849398615421, 6.895396723251898, 9.53662820338432, 7.147256933954795, 6.634259821957372, 8.415179129314577, 8.281523065798416, 8.349894267625134, 9.72761859623153, 6.187489629946793, 4.937910737325719, 12.579621814537589, 7.130965416643446, 11.753775444018402, 8.619380126316505, 11.007800833906513, 8.306192085063772], + "ssimulacra2": [-111.77632266386416, -64.2294561475399, -65.45671176682762, -64.79861246520579, -292.8329411629751, -73.85248660669743, -110.72761651285848, -217.80669248413005, -66.43416725432272, -68.99239349722137, -80.50381852588313, -64.17293428920442, -137.2275094630549, -97.34571341791349, -72.17016213023567, -64.51719145778475, -92.63795795642005, -101.99679889916271, -67.84527981161003, -70.52776784144288, -88.51295410593565, -69.45331461355732, -64.5813821649995, -110.10458065737026, -64.52943957492352, -64.17668918552334, -201.23714230069754, -83.61669419415219, -228.1395698168705, -104.31556229838111, -127.80978623356731, -115.4592623200837], + "butteraugli": [15.824650540019945, 15.332009499525219, 17.5516026441598, 18.380444428360235, 21.835658571953243, 19.425539404726514, 18.853294162597006, 23.848860944111582, 18.15256178960612, 18.0858921046018, 17.48139501022841, 19.56945192326052, 17.903732566342125, 18.02118448279816, 23.256611092061437, 14.628902237971824, 17.4544656563285, 18.777568660651443, 18.812451981357064, 25.95166183928893, 21.59131154035183, 15.575046318104517, 18.259386751259616, 18.562190651708523, 18.601985852171186, 16.940632330252512, 26.20829344308471, 16.92225805031381, 26.09995110020688, 24.41540307250541, 28.602827524015282, 20.746150457456448], + "dssim": [0.3705314708055605, 0.19735003778390242, 0.1740863205995971, 0.21393237443312513, 0.3905304999796322, 0.27845461539250527, 0.24969231857347235, 0.38420646175386836, 0.1799797901445102, 0.20282194801863773, 0.27060173827536904, 0.1665162867780175, 0.3879124528481644, 0.3262808556922666, 0.20108427995415895, 0.21809747348774594, 0.2423856970117071, 0.30940618544834875, 0.2446573994120203, 0.1761045157589694, 0.24070560025675308, 0.25866026201399517, 0.15971110828053187, 0.30471290062709555, 0.15941344283105635, 0.09387986921872171, 0.34141564552962467, 0.2419542479360307, 0.3348780498200076, 0.2541973514804675, 0.2791855979188168, 0.3103935966405562] + } + }, + { + "label": " 411B pre-adoption t2 L416/C144", + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [10.462556301722126, 4.839678893713183, 6.913382931867457, 7.006145564159891, 12.983833384273886, 6.8647098773339446, 8.511253924232971, 12.947994299000747, 6.746314007618181, 6.411501071434005, 8.035246257322223, 5.630240345536223, 9.356856758290997, 9.320370973489146, 8.530508169200967, 5.334942160023227, 6.498406966798077, 8.932090088154467, 6.851638363535816, 6.385031451068646, 7.885318941157225, 7.5397006394197925, 7.732886187068018, 9.259773621579892, 5.574898851712416, 4.690786478992273, 11.750927583504668, 7.0687741122171035, 11.2566788866809, 7.6725370725431405, 9.303466106949891, 7.755945359214599], + "ssimulacra2": [-74.8683470734795, -63.785381774543566, -64.23030629530854, -64.22949289470435, -167.3382318786326, -70.06315477191109, -70.99801151246248, -124.64229797218195, -64.36592306784138, -64.44645625938091, -68.87752036106798, -63.586059194336144, -93.94854031073754, -71.50740679184986, -66.71631428156329, -64.26575614933287, -75.72992663354933, -76.72797129924791, -64.80032482174357, -68.6635911764103, -69.30514766179596, -64.99786806677491, -64.22785198183925, -73.5481120923921, -64.21029488077647, -63.9520398895863, -108.2943733143776, -76.49219132047537, -147.58325200611185, -69.27083588144939, -67.03486879624069, -81.99882739969973], + "butteraugli": [14.688513721245963, 14.074459027447423, 15.990497356296189, 17.19080752277839, 20.402484093479277, 17.219230020662465, 16.917746290225022, 22.97684834724804, 16.993399699213807, 16.769234979601695, 16.554332447297877, 17.78267850420951, 16.600834932107286, 17.12158174198115, 20.971207166243435, 13.50777819081216, 16.65803059233748, 17.976024843483003, 17.016934573407223, 24.068167472274457, 18.834906621666704, 14.02743912594858, 16.80337026640993, 16.732311001092693, 16.577950380569334, 16.119422903569486, 24.22280239627175, 16.23788164269223, 24.294271959167414, 21.259702218558303, 24.91444235511388, 19.122294236464622], + "dssim": [0.36826186652942894, 0.19594775662542552, 0.1731890484253773, 0.209882430208306, 0.3857516696179067, 0.2799751544514655, 0.24707659411831884, 0.3807523306218202, 0.17940143969549804, 0.19958314105125885, 0.2680907690246005, 0.1665482858379133, 0.38538386590350193, 0.32027369921097193, 0.20300257905864078, 0.21855913936784083, 0.24115324619658934, 0.30649159431508033, 0.2438490008155793, 0.1779768238649202, 0.23770470034934393, 0.2564856856619626, 0.156967677376265, 0.3015434904900889, 0.15308629622260933, 0.09399358318039797, 0.34062773731761464, 0.24269923574125674, 0.3339123555883754, 0.25041168318632834, 0.25861673097349547, 0.30623493270072977] } } ] diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned.json index 342c706..0e66ccc 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder-tuned.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "name": "budget-ladder-tuned", "split": "tune", "settings": { - "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. Compare against budget-ladder.json, which is the same ladder with the shipped constants.", + "description": "The byte ladder re-run with this round's findings applied: luma precision chosen per budget (3 b below 20 B, 4 b to 56 B, 5 b above), chroma one bit below luma, plus the two encoder-only levers and aniso=1.2 selection weighting. The round-1 recipe had no sel_hv, so every tuned arm pins sel_hv=0: an arm that omitted it inherited the adopted 0.15 and measured the round-2 recipe instead. The pre-adoption arms are the baseline the tuned rows are compared against (EXPERIMENTS.md SS4.5, SS7.12): the v0.6-derived format resized to each budget exactly as budget-ladder.json resizes it (26:9 at L 5 b / chroma 4 b, the upper-tier raster from 108 B), with the four selection/encoder knobs pinned off. budget-ladder.json itself resizes the layout but inherits the adopted knobs, so it is the ladder of the format that ships, not of the one round 1 compared against.", "corpus": "photo", "backdrops": "white", "alphaFidelity": false, @@ -19,12 +19,12 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json", - "configSha256": "d5ba1ba97adce6d3d66fe3d1791abd2828955d84190991f553eecc1c98efb54f", + "configSha256": "aeefd38b4323a69c313656827cde38b50f0006f1971a1f1fdab90583aca7f711", "binaries": { "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" }, @@ -173,210 +173,392 @@ }, { "label": " 12B tuned L8@3 C3@3", - "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=8:3 c=3:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], - "ciede2000": [7.855442570133254, 10.406890560114858, 26.187877929624516, 13.221855011385866, 14.849615774506782, 13.769863049578067, 16.53773764041222, 4.79223920696544, 12.682854853421087, 13.20327333690142, 11.543067245165318, 17.41493753613755, 4.669089678854646, 13.443580036445404, 20.6435953179569, 12.311338671607283, 14.47262639006141, 13.361482806337193, 21.219390715481865, 14.280008846796177, 15.323763055906966, 5.915416686791398, 14.037451687047854, 13.89441744619101, 2.881647202512127, 15.530437649245538, 17.596532318521543, 16.346270654050933, 11.436937325151048, 13.085035316591641, 18.649988276807026], - "ssimulacra2": [-142.00987959195558, -300.8159958334703, -1232.5452672345914, -284.39945966105495, -364.44602274653334, -415.5466612045358, -509.6081280587599, -64.20354699847172, -462.5446133947514, -373.47657289269296, -327.2315813715578, -433.0203766818771, -64.23192432012104, -360.4140414258231, -950.3968418744366, -330.2130335688225, -348.45230204541326, -141.82648840448732, -836.9238546621457, -708.3226117292894, -406.4945130175282, -67.90177905779512, -467.8297757589577, -288.89917099804677, -62.68397738729897, -514.2628036061158, -473.69141988250715, -524.841949059648, -351.28421159111264, -539.2196493268137, -787.9516606015695], - "butteraugli": [26.54866972776456, 28.72066202525745, 45.153022346272884, 41.52557973946346, 31.342932030466937, 33.827370580096364, 41.66304960437237, 14.255005118210505, 26.213673768973223, 53.665847137776744, 31.04232692062942, 54.73544960057253, 27.03115180893526, 25.489266118198742, 42.122803055701034, 32.272437214853916, 38.76423387317388, 55.41512265088972, 57.934705242317385, 26.07757834115431, 51.16752172211749, 20.000288942908828, 24.995169446494582, 30.31460387807906, 12.690498152600219, 54.332749492732006, 66.45671821926815, 51.72567755669843, 55.52465851111299, 45.48831526713843, 35.745281297522716], - "dssim": [0.30458445133076073, 0.30812737232436815, 0.4642074927862651, 0.18076955194479777, 0.33566057342157163, 0.2732623189496185, 0.22212516244120023, 0.0852762906132774, 0.40996475493589474, 0.25301629107439494, 0.39481828272760944, 0.27210970555056835, 0.1516281383090357, 0.2625044566282829, 0.37027088664798863, 0.19786098729977053, 0.2339053914654769, 0.16173009405786137, 0.35399085912936534, 0.3685275929837317, 0.22943738186559975, 0.15078057899286373, 0.29429370010778044, 0.23866100840454946, 0.14663797414159624, 0.2835631506376951, 0.25185262180983947, 0.35879445666813825, 0.23192945993776787, 0.34856444163315276, 0.36313714875603886] + "ciede2000": [7.877056489812408, 10.385966689120869, 26.187877929624516, 13.221855011385866, 15.012775604453516, 13.769863049578067, 16.74859782749518, 4.79223920696544, 12.682854853421087, 13.20327333690142, 11.543067245165318, 17.41493753613755, 4.669089678854646, 13.443580036445404, 20.6435953179569, 12.690957120131594, 14.667731507172753, 13.361482806337193, 21.219390715481865, 14.280008846796177, 15.323763055906966, 5.915416686791398, 14.06929779920359, 13.89441744619101, 2.881647202512127, 15.371047368577516, 17.596532318521543, 15.411148114318182, 11.436937325151048, 13.096494605484374, 18.649988276807026], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.1479139799928, -309.77138292102387, -1232.5452672345914, -284.39945966105495, -362.45201142143844, -415.5466612045358, -523.928282012196, -64.20354699847172, -462.5446133947514, -373.47657289269296, -327.2315813715578, -433.0203766818771, -64.23192432012104, -360.4140414258231, -950.3968418744366, -339.91135609916995, -360.51444714965453, -141.82648840448732, -836.9238546621457, -708.3226117292894, -406.4945130175282, -67.90177905779512, -470.44367517319915, -288.89917099804677, -62.68397738729897, -509.3394832024612, -473.69141988250715, -474.967146235419, -351.28421159111264, -538.3413380515466, -787.9516606015695], + "butteraugli": [26.561378959898935, 30.42200034211683, 45.153022346272884, 41.52557973946346, 31.155464617497113, 33.827370580096364, 42.2411766186191, 14.255005118210505, 26.213673768973223, 53.665847137776744, 31.04232692062942, 54.73544960057253, 27.03115180893526, 25.489266118198742, 42.122803055701034, 33.90451221997298, 38.537108123600014, 55.41512265088972, 57.934705242317385, 26.07757834115431, 51.16752172211749, 20.000288942908828, 24.957739806132707, 30.31460387807906, 12.690498152600219, 50.31819452088822, 66.45671821926815, 48.58658329605501, 55.52465851111299, 46.81549805612693, 35.745281297522716], + "dssim": [0.3045639385268991, 0.30778657071069526, 0.4642074927862651, 0.18076955194479777, 0.3358936078859349, 0.2732623189496185, 0.22316361579869265, 0.0852762906132774, 0.40996475493589474, 0.25301629107439494, 0.39481828272760944, 0.27210970555056835, 0.1516281383090357, 0.2625044566282829, 0.37027088664798863, 0.19902909820366793, 0.23508570377693622, 0.16173009405786137, 0.35399085912936534, 0.3685275929837317, 0.22943738186559975, 0.15078057899286373, 0.2937153586532151, 0.23866100840454946, 0.14663797414159624, 0.2839975292464587, 0.25185262180983947, 0.34325400930362326, 0.23192945993776787, 0.34891128985480613, 0.36313714875603886] } }, { "label": " 14B tuned L11@3 C4@3", - "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=11:3 c=4:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14], - "ciede2000": [7.864980880153705, 9.913530597273308, 26.183290018115038, 12.892659019694621, 14.80574197718321, 12.605581773787954, 16.41684720037023, 4.484158043497485, 12.367272012135736, 12.776246228201567, 11.543067245165318, 15.262240557027537, 4.562410880337014, 13.116794477248675, 20.079135360176828, 12.089026304508435, 14.19769100536793, 12.420305129634897, 20.875329510551495, 14.263808225500284, 14.295652615377405, 5.9011368549380245, 13.826183266452333, 13.750869690629703, 2.875889246949084, 14.987262532698802, 17.00471478337706, 15.130054051611674, 10.960947163442102, 13.085035316591641, 18.239381487073352], - "ssimulacra2": [-142.17350959763863, -282.3976110936138, -1232.6715304813833, -280.6802628264591, -363.9999503663393, -376.5710503750595, -502.8060467130671, -64.1735923350686, -447.84342130968525, -340.1857873404233, -327.2315813715578, -322.1042265993864, -64.22940410665501, -344.799463197862, -913.7542106659686, -324.76385394041233, -355.1366941253617, -139.0024149042949, -823.6909924629957, -706.4327352596678, -378.33577393078417, -68.5288972116571, -467.7579928088669, -285.60152569231536, -62.368967673921645, -511.62319965965423, -439.8281754143429, -472.61475145568795, -340.4806328230975, -539.2196493268137, -773.0898051184989], - "butteraugli": [27.06833509578058, 26.976803166307917, 45.144225811513955, 39.90346291827655, 31.257198312950326, 29.946837588206876, 41.532019546085394, 14.241103061215256, 25.620989928310454, 50.84362701613666, 31.04232692062942, 53.70382733029254, 25.684948872803687, 24.86400115170852, 40.673241474123834, 32.50105394468856, 41.54893162411626, 55.8574080126912, 55.30753172991862, 26.015065575962527, 44.29593998204076, 18.87129276323824, 25.11733066288762, 28.47768784263558, 11.819869718812349, 50.73210024228185, 53.54458088178264, 47.675271791726054, 46.56080300485352, 45.48831526713843, 35.35773422729395], - "dssim": [0.30462801823689367, 0.30666246299852673, 0.4642512904845849, 0.1762838067025912, 0.33568495532311093, 0.27949940462265943, 0.22158000083607493, 0.0853399677831137, 0.4099328829891881, 0.2438408720461953, 0.39481828272760944, 0.2723335609900116, 0.15159127483150442, 0.26242767901616826, 0.36895195321707974, 0.19795467864618094, 0.23470242585314965, 0.16408914213042558, 0.34567054750345705, 0.368516608645376, 0.2257424670130898, 0.15208265515894176, 0.291019416191284, 0.2386621933979462, 0.11310948762723472, 0.28344604687883357, 0.2443578263927077, 0.3374582150410911, 0.22988972698875937, 0.34856444163315276, 0.36503827006110723] + "ciede2000": [7.864980880153705, 9.913530597273308, 26.183290018115038, 12.892659019694621, 14.80574197718321, 12.605581773787954, 16.41684720037023, 4.484158043497485, 12.367272012135736, 12.875359678666653, 11.427525185462962, 15.262240557027537, 4.562410880337014, 13.162467941351187, 20.04521963965369, 12.24963840491267, 14.401705310786525, 12.420305129634897, 20.875329510551495, 14.263808225500284, 14.295652615377405, 5.9011368549380245, 13.826183266452333, 13.750869690629703, 2.875889246949084, 15.053600541169347, 17.00471478337706, 14.795636780432359, 10.960947163442102, 12.910922746049096, 18.239381487073352], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.17350959763863, -282.3976110936138, -1232.6715304813833, -280.6802628264591, -363.9999503663393, -376.5710503750595, -502.8060467130671, -64.1735923350686, -447.84342130968525, -349.2052502785131, -322.53429133974987, -322.1042265993864, -64.22940410665501, -351.62422819342396, -913.1146596435942, -321.411878722268, -355.66063240476944, -139.0024149042949, -823.6909924629957, -706.4327352596678, -378.33577393078417, -68.5288972116571, -467.7579928088669, -285.60152569231536, -62.368967673921645, -502.3265295572611, -439.8281754143429, -460.76552360082655, -340.4806328230975, -515.3154325943975, -773.0898051184989], + "butteraugli": [27.06833509578058, 26.976803166307917, 45.144225811513955, 39.90346291827655, 31.257198312950326, 29.946837588206876, 41.532019546085394, 14.241103061215256, 25.620989928310454, 51.63797962476946, 29.69265542663968, 53.70382733029254, 25.684948872803687, 24.466979187641034, 40.63235003741881, 31.507313594291777, 42.83350369857326, 55.8574080126912, 55.30753172991862, 26.015065575962527, 44.29593998204076, 18.87129276323824, 25.11733066288762, 28.47768784263558, 11.819869718812349, 49.85885312323075, 53.54458088178264, 49.96068731701744, 46.56080300485352, 44.94853140544942, 35.35773422729395], + "dssim": [0.30462801823689367, 0.30666246299852673, 0.4642512904845849, 0.1762838067025912, 0.33568495532311093, 0.27949940462265943, 0.22158000083607493, 0.0853399677831137, 0.4099328829891881, 0.25293524386483013, 0.3947503578240345, 0.2723335609900116, 0.15159127483150442, 0.26263833442513307, 0.36890028504462, 0.19774656050111866, 0.2348186422161111, 0.16408914213042558, 0.34567054750345705, 0.368516608645376, 0.2257424670130898, 0.15208265515894176, 0.291019416191284, 0.2386621933979462, 0.11310948762723472, 0.2836474469255458, 0.2443578263927077, 0.3368787475731042, 0.22988972698875937, 0.34440719340319914, 0.36503827006110723] } }, { "label": " 16B tuned L14@3 C5@3", - "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], - "ciede2000": [7.8564806414365576, 9.731204435890897, 26.172957471848946, 12.945809771133225, 14.65532157055519, 10.84490396282935, 16.31936537293946, 4.271418691095217, 11.647254480590298, 12.941409696845172, 11.418981133623204, 13.051785754938868, 4.385829127004196, 12.970200815549378, 19.875533162621366, 12.079084101393565, 13.650949184498941, 12.379012590684626, 20.625841356636187, 14.245900975884657, 13.611052930577044, 5.681858338152057, 13.706714569146602, 13.69738946863597, 2.71838495466195, 14.900822484891261, 14.961129735773516, 14.00439984414611, 10.960947163442102, 12.109866652622284, 17.78114806722602], - "ssimulacra2": [-142.08628593725294, -277.2711519752284, -1231.1050289269301, -289.5508243356293, -350.9162186024528, -285.76651871563655, -495.8757056707617, -64.13272915114624, -418.40219953562996, -359.35271246752785, -315.5383419351027, -270.04135565699266, -64.22930320317391, -335.3356763945129, -910.5874018796696, -320.8716109309342, -339.591898548916, -130.54716518735182, -809.8055384303088, -701.7411638802395, -370.71206418940056, -68.33505526565034, -461.10853458496035, -289.51847460658706, -61.91846371357542, -498.7179497041343, -364.3286072435617, -430.6289262350548, -340.4806328230975, -514.774650946082, -755.2104473492582], - "butteraugli": [27.226859935856577, 26.642366302279527, 45.13491033833109, 40.47927036261296, 29.32368967194688, 24.54127962345461, 42.72209725095353, 13.72370257194703, 24.691891925651287, 49.01070612774256, 28.26196941002046, 45.78359253921891, 25.81534166722615, 24.1106931965984, 39.876023920786444, 29.984861914119517, 35.90934983837556, 52.31437910019207, 55.136629074249754, 25.958281055304468, 42.534288298372736, 18.44868362194944, 23.537314345005115, 28.320641020671292, 11.195204384186662, 48.853452774188106, 48.02034640651012, 46.106869162371616, 46.56080300485352, 39.338436071839965, 34.79722849524503], - "dssim": [0.3046438775430249, 0.3062268004147105, 0.4642797895392072, 0.1751741102763647, 0.3351561534394313, 0.25400425607631893, 0.22173008638066233, 0.0853748783978156, 0.40974110150545645, 0.2444940901376293, 0.39449890154844003, 0.2543620154647248, 0.15149808751834798, 0.262075498434603, 0.3688751815915896, 0.19951683763179023, 0.2344223013151152, 0.16389723247487176, 0.34485694873996064, 0.36860004148488623, 0.22500401386771646, 0.15033295992179396, 0.2926375120013608, 0.23938470471340434, 0.1146287421804087, 0.2830807060064455, 0.24442446411637847, 0.3158228761752666, 0.22988972698875937, 0.33022119771583713, 0.36214676002639623] + "ciede2000": [7.8564806414365576, 9.718012558558843, 26.172957471848946, 12.945809771133225, 14.214461967872786, 10.864663859681778, 15.46976081555715, 4.47422327610516, 11.647254480590298, 12.826056858866423, 11.359969867489683, 13.459532467460228, 4.567051927477587, 13.017704854326999, 19.685735559651796, 12.413282771507882, 13.650949184498941, 12.207168548042107, 20.343462363969874, 14.250451999879608, 13.840427856677735, 5.681858338152057, 13.706714569146602, 13.69738946863597, 2.833430663478639, 14.699883559615973, 15.170200932365045, 14.00439984414611, 10.960947163442102, 11.916833148679364, 16.56551391219298], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.08628593725294, -273.9169070616791, -1231.1050289269301, -289.5508243356293, -353.2203619376046, -284.4344816299447, -483.23630429524553, -64.14300782174945, -418.40219953562996, -336.1583775015101, -312.7038392754421, -270.7500084251057, -64.22937916419, -343.6818619464537, -892.6308838435483, -321.0048763590611, -339.591898548916, -132.44359272536576, -806.7795346641963, -702.6446851880165, -371.21782066280934, -68.33505526565034, -461.10853458496035, -289.51847460658706, -61.893324816788095, -487.7629410255439, -363.89342680412324, -430.6289262350548, -340.4806328230975, -500.7877065047405, -739.0052311627063], + "butteraugli": [27.226859935856577, 27.488563978033586, 45.13491033833109, 40.47927036261296, 29.248835651055305, 24.544890042086106, 42.41098172410452, 13.838371953003326, 24.691891925651287, 50.24676702368938, 27.463155839810202, 45.96503640525222, 25.679889780370733, 24.770566875000156, 38.73698123682594, 31.198602648056738, 35.90934983837556, 52.68335811156413, 55.10911114186854, 25.962863653077928, 42.445224475368484, 18.44868362194944, 23.537314345005115, 28.320641020671292, 11.191370382209678, 48.40280376370225, 48.06381072496953, 46.106869162371616, 46.56080300485352, 38.60742454966222, 34.74995514387276], + "dssim": [0.3046438775430249, 0.3061595723460213, 0.4642797895392072, 0.1751741102763647, 0.3349194268185086, 0.2517522948516985, 0.22049142303196112, 0.08537701483317006, 0.40974110150545645, 0.2407314093348863, 0.3944687999132665, 0.2583319816453582, 0.15156981226103788, 0.2625715767956315, 0.3681859181504613, 0.19920817691881965, 0.2344223013151152, 0.16663000679629497, 0.3425860733406363, 0.36858898829745934, 0.22502270291194765, 0.15033295992179396, 0.2926375120013608, 0.23938470471340434, 0.11482882908666264, 0.2825937688672794, 0.24430072569910766, 0.3158228761752666, 0.22988972698875937, 0.3325359777458351, 0.36014815651954346] } }, { "label": " 18B tuned L17@3 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=17:3 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18], - "ciede2000": [7.826340989856093, 9.775064368250321, 26.171104745163053, 12.11725155613653, 14.079681776198276, 10.771800486630761, 15.526103213139379, 4.17100681231453, 11.603136201533891, 12.744428398027708, 11.359969867489683, 12.024060775790861, 4.34762158040738, 12.893575914587933, 19.610638930527713, 11.660760200101457, 13.507241058113632, 12.108484603471364, 19.483277883970988, 14.242697630437204, 13.329782649405512, 5.073383258280495, 13.706714569146602, 13.427863506107691, 2.5722050344119283, 14.699883559615973, 14.927934615264906, 13.984383321400852, 10.943740890124882, 11.814690822531462, 16.03476593920742], - "ssimulacra2": [-142.89250943817567, -281.06531624834025, -1232.5907277406222, -236.61120689276527, -332.2133342422153, -276.55159852407456, -472.73152536308555, -63.99242659023548, -409.78347048964457, -347.4541605707718, -312.7038392754421, -207.87045744193892, -64.18858626602588, -334.59075546684505, -891.2131451661975, -306.32733952121055, -334.5189412882546, -130.59152689385257, -732.2784289051178, -700.368469616361, -353.4946083092007, -66.34797564875342, -461.10853458496035, -274.48084473395824, -61.273823567214265, -487.7629410255439, -369.99442064881964, -426.59310050579154, -334.0269458945028, -499.05603109278377, -733.5709884828966], - "butteraugli": [25.898086328114953, 27.547045474558633, 45.14429393209863, 36.61501657194699, 27.008498270211145, 24.340635492131895, 41.79009319787042, 13.637141601918323, 24.218130160237212, 48.406425709498386, 27.463155839810202, 34.59647802907497, 22.720243472738037, 24.115321193271566, 38.311153856486605, 30.354084602163667, 35.57933687238968, 51.55326626453834, 51.52494536722467, 25.8881314699124, 42.08898968606409, 18.7855563227851, 23.537314345005115, 28.2409477626706, 11.65641646493718, 48.40280376370225, 48.70471131782829, 45.612548300361055, 47.45013339309438, 38.229461544735095, 34.50870250697967], - "dssim": [0.304511620140559, 0.3065490245023774, 0.46461991043663553, 0.16871355512805863, 0.33445735277499955, 0.2509078198253196, 0.22060024595564326, 0.08493774920183128, 0.4091962258452067, 0.2446667633785234, 0.3944687999132665, 0.2543105321817337, 0.15196257197719448, 0.26174344363837165, 0.3680221154078601, 0.2001598985215825, 0.23354414908054177, 0.16084112739360967, 0.3412726576178592, 0.36860700155778836, 0.22434794140390152, 0.15137125681535374, 0.2926375120013608, 0.23846807522527058, 0.1091823384462029, 0.2825937688672794, 0.24598237953366603, 0.3189707105585984, 0.22928403305185657, 0.3319788547811726, 0.3570555753392185] + "ciede2000": [7.82746236178496, 9.7071114867808, 26.168648661042504, 12.090220440422781, 14.244017015338471, 10.811645091388728, 15.135699063218203, 4.17100681231453, 11.647254480590298, 12.744428398027708, 11.359969867489683, 11.900460776174969, 4.303506664521249, 12.893575914587933, 19.610638930527713, 11.834192240540524, 13.324968176897503, 12.096490400034526, 19.483277883970988, 14.242697630437204, 13.027065392375285, 5.215466411314619, 13.710944211964936, 13.496878740502762, 2.5722050344119283, 14.656382898659452, 14.927934615264906, 13.970675052332945, 10.943740890124882, 11.76991550058893, 16.028543371359202], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.91630472352844, -277.3694379456921, -1232.8512410037672, -226.56054825090655, -353.50255031999325, -282.307190919507, -481.42273225928125, -63.99242659023548, -418.40219953562996, -347.4541605707718, -312.7038392754421, -204.59766768176036, -64.1859186838559, -334.59075546684505, -891.2131451661975, -316.24385057006924, -329.65185006925566, -135.2037824062176, -732.2784289051178, -700.368469616361, -335.6330678697053, -66.60958065351747, -461.1763566708713, -288.123387571413, -61.273823567214265, -471.2676096910583, -369.99442064881964, -423.3883460500009, -334.0269458945028, -498.5224590286307, -703.1907715939832], + "butteraugli": [26.225212953189914, 26.648397016232877, 45.14497341307842, 36.631244912826055, 28.474250676656258, 24.535128823309492, 42.41979919267579, 13.637141601918323, 24.691891925651287, 48.406425709498386, 27.463155839810202, 34.714902500399056, 22.985412932802415, 24.115321193271566, 38.311153856486605, 31.07479561883964, 37.51748716671034, 50.95670474859381, 51.52494536722467, 25.8881314699124, 41.064340417795314, 18.737184807587997, 23.560245997396873, 27.631693626185626, 11.65641646493718, 47.33614957518242, 48.70471131782829, 45.312152488032105, 47.45013339309438, 37.55485259072021, 33.76700054601568], + "dssim": [0.30441052900358323, 0.3066347153961263, 0.464468521204253, 0.16959054590230677, 0.3349623696641395, 0.2508718251042429, 0.22154459793300552, 0.08493774920183128, 0.40974110150545645, 0.2446667633785234, 0.3944687999132665, 0.2533816439197467, 0.15170169427762364, 0.26174344363837165, 0.3680221154078601, 0.20026561090569395, 0.2324627125468317, 0.1596995308720039, 0.3412726576178592, 0.36860700155778836, 0.22383307556755166, 0.15184108717459277, 0.2916493557908443, 0.23916704366372382, 0.1091823384462029, 0.28322791082683163, 0.24598237953366603, 0.3192413043812802, 0.22928403305185657, 0.32918335355272277, 0.36034947679368684] } }, { "label": " 21B tuned L19@4 C6@3", - "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], - "ciede2000": [7.776014504486732, 9.396455198920494, 26.166661623361254, 11.221954341669583, 13.95935092652041, 10.51263390369127, 14.916407602047487, 3.8956262618359196, 11.414922133693548, 12.651849994951462, 11.280522373086745, 10.92419901754221, 4.210537019106085, 12.723082330046312, 19.515021380252122, 11.411808282920534, 12.980793774753181, 11.721124632468488, 19.16887296175175, 14.210460951578916, 12.905414935773846, 4.781214648718981, 13.621276853624158, 13.086598506480753, 2.386244763017709, 14.32773465991485, 13.901584414941468, 13.747882789270575, 10.268129218833149, 11.60918139311934, 15.849270243373518], - "ssimulacra2": [-143.98065393566714, -273.3346190723461, -1232.7515999669945, -210.38248116946244, -326.4389073148647, -271.0954016250367, -465.43475675081675, -63.873318003379154, -396.1797420625749, -342.17118679804344, -311.0611128148512, -179.91249752799627, -64.13935327766467, -321.2804659488522, -884.5640563159362, -297.4355312798491, -317.83841509974167, -131.20218775242935, -689.4555510513823, -695.7235661408508, -339.2772453636585, -66.21941947854003, -454.03664154043634, -261.7436777424757, -59.916976573444, -461.87966240365927, -314.08946465501907, -424.2393490453853, -295.2635289812059, -489.14845117356526, -720.2610790596225], - "butteraugli": [25.013198327113415, 27.42705783248822, 45.14939604859702, 31.109843559658184, 25.84659700121607, 23.93882741334745, 41.120903626711645, 13.322643772203955, 22.87931819695711, 46.90301206420071, 25.455376447542125, 28.593152971641327, 22.70702450928349, 23.205988947378007, 37.76986444203275, 29.39043402487221, 31.71020238092608, 52.121130912660725, 49.89983413872886, 25.73022245984102, 40.944595458000514, 16.724683937220053, 22.640075632788996, 26.78062444165941, 10.101199780935383, 48.69999843165882, 40.4459369265887, 44.646248671903855, 39.260928455347134, 37.745064559234386, 35.077604609532], - "dssim": [0.3044273498619994, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46448791381267424, 0.16698112678195137, 0.3344582249611492, 0.24863070490083183, 0.2211568959477111, 0.08464748674739392, 0.4087523843747863, 0.25426033824986705, 0.3944772259450307, 0.2513307099814748, 0.15150094593172286, 0.2600049455792901, 0.3678216571540833, 0.1975533551256759, 0.23266201524735813, 0.1523964025012195, 0.33662283088673084, 0.36860540886260296, 0.2245223369436235, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2922778060441086, 0.23787318026562737, 0.10280053230244252, 0.2833021212837312, 0.23307999008545838, 0.31270891298436443, 0.22694115016689026, 0.3321907993520228, 0.35709603108854004] + "ciede2000": [7.789203926443911, 9.376219973370707, 26.16164851669451, 11.175262874528539, 13.984256405031347, 10.597875852769373, 15.018700389460333, 3.9285003217414944, 11.57272935354342, 12.635140922572347, 11.25212234714879, 11.524791204922442, 4.194245617027632, 12.773949133791932, 19.491924633025302, 11.511843317742876, 12.799758720032992, 11.62507753778494, 19.072848610309144, 14.215653122481639, 12.567124411535096, 4.971064524335094, 13.620514676029623, 13.300414018322794, 2.4061417090283928, 14.408893703019054, 14.24704779005055, 13.743639538603167, 10.408831272943143, 11.508231798376514, 15.724827018033912], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.13806055162658, -272.52176036326694, -1232.541057416469, -194.65198958756963, -332.7298479582114, -276.67185570401733, -471.98589975155664, -63.95924954614492, -419.6214842783925, -341.3950716570646, -310.63013530603644, -210.33094557588555, -64.12745735692337, -326.11118077774967, -881.1349343154604, -303.0918167134951, -310.3797058091266, -122.30297770196884, -696.3219560194909, -697.8282729046771, -319.2256373016601, -66.41805511847565, -454.30588369144596, -274.15525539348783, -60.087454567184125, -459.30936629318023, -349.1193549619702, -419.61672055423435, -310.6529647841795, -486.4652078932313, -693.7184331893975], + "butteraugli": [25.265118414680728, 27.075529087745892, 45.13881433594008, 28.515601528165703, 26.430741959618175, 23.8664183577161, 41.291262625958474, 13.366440568682293, 23.82925880112697, 46.93345245376191, 24.31377998593008, 33.42421389899377, 23.400178083018265, 22.892322810144332, 37.86193032623244, 29.772294964635844, 31.49174094547031, 51.71985232809646, 49.84285004762578, 25.78102074070017, 40.01080422024264, 17.068264931619677, 22.639164557794402, 27.008112092106263, 10.443218128927917, 46.25314121540092, 42.49238500848565, 43.80356982547258, 45.74788569873803, 36.47308201426056, 33.640020835191436], + "dssim": [0.3045505248234468, 0.3059238629872011, 0.4644168301288938, 0.16513047374424544, 0.3345750844570947, 0.24967787983088813, 0.22149873845903262, 0.08464095696461832, 0.40958702291364807, 0.2552917269788719, 0.3946388677661789, 0.2517211679370185, 0.15136448696000704, 0.2605421188495951, 0.3676450106681487, 0.19778974097170005, 0.23102416269420867, 0.14812663301054646, 0.33670272119923206, 0.36860308356255733, 0.22378502053516153, 0.14934387808610072, 0.2922854387497662, 0.23841586842046797, 0.10575491014617167, 0.282821095649212, 0.23504402554645393, 0.31297897342011194, 0.22857305398828365, 0.32880203640490646, 0.358138943012968] } }, { "label": " 24B tuned L22@4 C8@3", - "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], - "ciede2000": [7.706926976735602, 9.247477998357889, 26.164040665907326, 11.02535228502462, 13.900364840796598, 10.42579110651495, 14.752515296390976, 3.7044235596163197, 11.350869197419811, 12.47584193646498, 11.106545561283184, 10.889532166979192, 4.09557860445858, 12.241533216552911, 19.125845220249037, 11.15239196822961, 12.700906052156677, 11.003878591351729, 18.898692031522664, 14.208774156142638, 12.387350361602309, 4.47924088153234, 13.483360181419831, 13.001971511601154, 2.36883665197626, 14.164318852356041, 13.490507580548876, 13.331933576063303, 10.02677932527379, 11.440566581050144, 15.573239040884916], - "ssimulacra2": [-140.05353513477496, -262.3742017850659, -1233.2280226047314, -193.1638587762463, -325.6413355706509, -267.1679403452686, -460.1224928616899, -63.42308090803684, -386.1762172690296, -353.7895478713042, -294.55635522887655, -179.94095508376807, -64.05877292804081, -306.3258970596803, -854.6341049141689, -285.9005047830956, -306.86577804851083, -129.58894611063192, -664.5312813216794, -696.4443977707411, -313.6280659412106, -64.71912907969966, -445.0155826919121, -257.42587841221456, -59.50236238330177, -439.04365028694065, -298.0123471679145, -417.04813562006893, -284.30268829173133, -480.6104553675859, -688.2937857421417], - "butteraugli": [23.402570794628033, 26.46271346006495, 45.13875168663677, 28.5247271846095, 25.96546286307996, 23.8451405838828, 41.181483749264636, 13.337060248675373, 22.274003605637123, 45.63035151708116, 23.989316034307247, 28.440053150094155, 22.992984185178027, 22.615285127974644, 38.40131499050958, 29.165650488164733, 31.498606576986305, 51.17373089281667, 48.14613467087721, 25.741475141615908, 39.10734855849536, 16.07193030226853, 22.610891046922017, 27.066918718487983, 9.746930203033157, 46.8218679948842, 40.08282272739754, 41.72359068942638, 41.214907372964774, 36.548554296380956, 33.45081210827675], - "dssim": [0.3043372840264016, 0.3057870836292863, 0.46449789054253465, 0.16517266273384923, 0.33465938693523556, 0.24433280640084176, 0.2210604654177436, 0.08452321870842172, 0.4083480070199826, 0.2552142702770247, 0.39437312957117027, 0.2523429248948357, 0.1511108884028643, 0.25958280668789613, 0.3665386466748883, 0.1976845233732376, 0.23059688926157446, 0.14717986826948576, 0.33138983526458465, 0.36856415609059423, 0.22379184142967828, 0.14986151046504226, 0.2925809342324056, 0.23790163581792861, 0.10280307953118989, 0.28262315476030886, 0.2266913677550072, 0.30990373602790844, 0.22489390465824272, 0.32730382223558396, 0.356849977034025] + "ciede2000": [7.73978146186197, 9.399947469752764, 26.155975213985677, 11.011653382702768, 13.865943012751984, 10.454017072239449, 14.822735951500492, 3.752003689576659, 11.379514006047842, 12.47584193646498, 11.106545561283184, 11.126542832245827, 4.204690209902003, 12.241533216552911, 19.125845220249037, 11.343560823044992, 12.586196674838856, 10.905524558020087, 19.092433497193085, 14.208774156142638, 12.424093671881458, 4.781214648718981, 13.56842975131682, 13.038670933483905, 2.36883665197626, 14.321879971383218, 13.633145716430937, 13.208451589850696, 10.209981534732314, 11.36724475480023, 15.548065435070919], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.147536940864, -273.75364158483825, -1231.8046307008217, -192.8127708706017, -322.7608800179317, -266.67127832773986, -466.8574890890101, -63.85830275143411, -389.88072730087333, -353.7895478713042, -294.55635522887655, -191.94683253833085, -64.13888396286717, -306.3258970596803, -854.6341049141689, -293.9360171345263, -297.5802903861613, -126.83535345238255, -687.9837932589743, -696.4443977707411, -313.75254999674183, -66.21941947854003, -453.0360456655841, -257.67034939123675, -59.50236238330177, -456.41183923870165, -306.33899730939174, -406.28536901335747, -290.2765093472073, -473.74232439093544, -686.3192987019354], + "butteraugli": [24.053496583901822, 27.152933619075636, 45.119304235461904, 28.387104443749507, 26.075785253644796, 23.668995183786887, 41.175129299762574, 13.383134332782616, 22.8911717548941, 45.63035151708116, 23.989316034307247, 31.897657623611384, 22.56523814683847, 22.615285127974644, 38.40131499050958, 29.234044528037956, 31.527608282544946, 50.367304638518995, 49.83956848153152, 25.741475141615908, 39.61396781314959, 16.724683937220053, 22.422896390702252, 27.37037027121794, 9.746930203033157, 47.06673891853768, 39.40930753499014, 42.539796698483265, 39.33238129244103, 36.63714559966315, 33.53862374304071], + "dssim": [0.3043810208312937, 0.30588296489429856, 0.46443465576181, 0.1654088386298887, 0.3347724066485839, 0.24578470282828235, 0.22176242104265326, 0.08461791358601967, 0.408709580334766, 0.2552142702770247, 0.39437312957117027, 0.25115620586306264, 0.15145599594482556, 0.25958280668789613, 0.3665386466748883, 0.19765907776452524, 0.23022431390970483, 0.14691386765189618, 0.3354827416332443, 0.36856415609059423, 0.22402841744445595, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2937733739539168, 0.23813535974329753, 0.10280307953118989, 0.28346777508467236, 0.22705935210518807, 0.3059293045376843, 0.22661782867729102, 0.32702719064758157, 0.3566178598809696] } }, { "label": " 28B tuned L27@4 C10@3", - "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=27:4 c=10:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28], - "ciede2000": [7.683050517699742, 9.1043568480155, 26.154191363127467, 10.837064067062887, 13.664626392252961, 10.322440514835193, 14.519220987455022, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.234819322431298, 10.558241956361742, 10.493539142074205, 4.073916763855903, 11.842791956798893, 18.95459592239392, 10.760450044456093, 12.297875033071639, 10.148637264015287, 18.817579964510546, 14.17211272406256, 12.31296170720419, 4.454831041103851, 13.455170375766548, 12.984669263861491, 2.344196835907279, 13.930451656028506, 13.211542707812706, 12.90365882083673, 8.882669476629305, 11.211519576499281, 14.938846542927685], - "ssimulacra2": [-138.8202774019155, -254.574499193301, -1231.3162263241818, -182.63854253420573, -319.68864913306334, -260.91207417027425, -448.1802491190317, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -347.1976743011612, -260.27891631302174, -177.18639541513505, -64.05751540900434, -293.3735107386246, -832.2241290597709, -243.35803748116456, -280.6529971093404, -119.6245747450896, -666.2785320994121, -695.3839527521243, -315.9223198673335, -64.71223004829287, -431.425418943208, -258.67840070399546, -59.57982322204049, -418.56238340518826, -278.9581478025631, -395.7863131819747, -236.34886745042616, -460.5981700778332, -654.8115400628483], - "butteraugli": [23.272178809694555, 26.28853813178587, 45.11641931059964, 28.500279086097475, 26.137188611390027, 23.271404129364623, 40.741610574785426, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.351710930437626, 21.400860758942127, 33.7384773209566, 21.833583810428213, 22.84662300390954, 37.10093378595142, 27.093804262698928, 31.86440535143687, 46.673685619279276, 48.188451865321234, 25.77023650297575, 38.55757018738345, 15.739855624828266, 22.33713389259999, 27.589744426474315, 9.775440960600472, 45.34973512894925, 38.49126425063994, 42.27782469644645, 33.56886587970192, 36.83032657265844, 35.11170850011457], - "dssim": [0.3043052639319488, 0.30509332472921147, 0.46447365985633, 0.1654527505238419, 0.3347164594689849, 0.24652486954493813, 0.22016760436586197, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2576782227441682, 0.39372784396620136, 0.2504809670208169, 0.1509485308741137, 0.25902612452968554, 0.36568376596830066, 0.20101492795213766, 0.22895857448207896, 0.149111476119979, 0.33096654818330107, 0.36853413416653413, 0.224646456873912, 0.14989006571273755, 0.29190895631399705, 0.23823572720418112, 0.10302400767956016, 0.2816622319687503, 0.22628663036818636, 0.30339583249276836, 0.22068262707206865, 0.32933721124312243, 0.3595497522612897] + "ciede2000": [7.694731334792819, 9.222406717150244, 26.143735333697766, 10.8707643516295, 13.73119399007861, 10.104934045893868, 14.394152070579795, 3.567767492633594, 11.084550918846091, 11.825602010678724, 10.564166223641045, 10.69713402162714, 4.1122326643530425, 11.746000115789078, 18.942445825243613, 11.114695205549948, 12.162521527343143, 10.628343311079353, 18.62767044741767, 14.17410488344075, 12.172674952779328, 4.454831041103851, 13.440291854209281, 12.853980042831859, 2.3438662332410503, 13.488634835866982, 13.054868983864273, 12.598485849689391, 8.465540272078814, 10.44862406911159, 15.000102780413668], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.28451337661238, -257.7347392339958, -1230.4504566352757, -188.03010656695056, -318.83968170322026, -240.18079236083292, -441.6766783612777, -63.274176353547546, -335.1398009610109, -324.55399699180396, -259.96754417150805, -188.1745808783147, -64.06562034742683, -287.391283645714, -832.8384848215626, -278.9975403150164, -283.00584962069456, -127.27799993882297, -654.2939026736786, -696.1405664989727, -307.229899123516, -64.71223004829287, -429.60511678031435, -255.75024644451162, -59.560891779956194, -396.0875148100917, -276.48431061993347, -377.424706901609, -213.27123521516648, -422.2815260166201, -654.8944997012145], + "butteraugli": [23.26266786356585, 26.368668328196538, 45.09670319288534, 27.996275539295937, 26.099727752882824, 22.185409062086606, 40.349175615952674, 13.251492356788047, 20.515243124701012, 39.70030991725491, 21.759712840589547, 32.12476144093147, 22.07471918425361, 23.424330111448388, 37.55407409786372, 29.506909151536508, 31.825905544830466, 49.07099372318703, 47.89224018324012, 25.760182751970746, 38.71942349747156, 15.739855624828266, 22.377574623849256, 27.14876207963623, 9.749120664123582, 44.705825681440324, 38.060501158502085, 37.71261548591702, 31.494453543021166, 34.060011478436664, 35.031520736523646], + "dssim": [0.30440101950692633, 0.30583468814687575, 0.4643546805875636, 0.16580311968556177, 0.3348660601407611, 0.2415447771140828, 0.2196915224875951, 0.08461042226407195, 0.4071043564619281, 0.26863740573163764, 0.393673916968096, 0.25047650264965193, 0.1512525965280831, 0.2587840869980961, 0.3658081913056981, 0.19802159519227008, 0.22900217164790404, 0.15017103053249126, 0.3294495319791907, 0.3685588822844975, 0.2241105045018385, 0.14989006571273755, 0.2915403078818076, 0.23788009332052057, 0.10304362737833067, 0.28057835651996876, 0.22615366412050775, 0.3090472129780625, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3188526349828099, 0.35891145246363143] } }, { "label": " 32B tuned L33@4 C11@3", - "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=33:4 c=11:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], - "ciede2000": [7.351818806328752, 8.919252861946896, 26.139019894409348, 10.39316956439873, 13.565124854111863, 9.948471391735234, 14.387469291796982, 3.5089266815982523, 10.902665843553287, 11.537382824487766, 10.489331658841937, 10.332638419950012, 4.073916763855903, 11.671383483548219, 18.84672408258482, 10.647120423501919, 12.00056998663115, 9.887175248639302, 18.346931580126338, 14.174943816876173, 11.849350569194295, 4.295897206880726, 13.396578360084268, 12.699235858871157, 2.3144102804149087, 13.258604679006966, 13.020264008629482, 12.498717377238473, 8.04625125647341, 10.288912642322908, 14.84615658458368], - "ssimulacra2": [-140.07059122875177, -248.62301462759234, -1230.3120036089902, -162.8193139259447, -318.65661686037583, -214.96427150089, -433.32652156871313, -62.92512873111403, -322.67944994733847, -314.29501670088723, -247.75399617527228, -176.7824531255153, -64.05751540900434, -274.69812435091967, -817.533560584211, -239.99322088047006, -267.0707823365165, -107.74463862183893, -606.4169352819217, -693.641452262961, -290.2415607736518, -64.49777214798763, -423.75829745371834, -244.12093807933798, -60.104289353493954, -365.7147018694063, -272.10536382436794, -367.90882818770916, -192.26366838929403, -400.338319903904, -640.5684861870668], - "butteraugli": [21.91680240052054, 27.175465886996136, 45.081196473104605, 27.252874584123262, 25.840510611217223, 21.913948958399658, 39.15860736393512, 13.170379183685094, 19.822190060233304, 37.833848174793, 21.214667468429102, 30.359934677818615, 21.833583810428213, 22.79995439932044, 37.63643472694278, 26.79028697817198, 31.336447732809763, 46.039790441634246, 45.873672948358625, 25.747052707662714, 37.66108454020553, 15.669795874109274, 22.36499070276575, 26.497638270397022, 10.41065697881911, 41.35047299112867, 37.23909881413514, 36.4171810107131, 38.12093912889395, 34.78118031864449, 33.94952798956256], - "dssim": [0.3044365715529709, 0.30502076970785075, 0.4643500120408935, 0.16004360811578583, 0.33492681539962277, 0.23195245028114475, 0.21976096206902213, 0.08436146050105636, 0.40681367479578456, 0.26579404094677517, 0.3937854355367071, 0.24831383512560673, 0.1509485308741137, 0.25887292323076194, 0.3656277747576059, 0.2014446021345297, 0.2281997174533294, 0.1447629697965021, 0.32880689736700064, 0.3685074723845426, 0.22355029543038651, 0.1495140015330501, 0.292326590560538, 0.2379046391968372, 0.09890594552805299, 0.27865911409211785, 0.22749719552875675, 0.30483160033544254, 0.21769032143079625, 0.31878575751093463, 0.35841861216313486] + "ciede2000": [7.679475777396719, 8.933162109232388, 26.129616937537925, 10.374265074961494, 13.597358104172029, 10.073348665043154, 14.423375840206736, 3.519425254125617, 11.011330063761063, 11.560635899982037, 10.423589559104107, 10.408928334665532, 4.0752347392431885, 11.567696291729156, 18.83338327506491, 10.674781059518658, 11.986071287510851, 10.036019995814337, 18.513766584448888, 14.171695737819926, 11.960630987825855, 4.340499379981559, 13.396578360084268, 12.699235858871157, 2.344196835907279, 13.297170312685893, 13.028223372722792, 12.235359216906017, 8.06615662227945, 10.290806634870973, 14.829919936828123], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.10071191724165, -252.16006979447013, -1229.865556477439, -166.43776655932504, -317.56132069991816, -235.43463077024057, -438.4190339616938, -62.92503613451845, -324.1321102653581, -315.6269990748225, -245.08485544638546, -182.61218403707056, -64.02810935711256, -273.1008842301643, -815.9090137522343, -230.60038849915082, -267.81061044072493, -114.7048779138814, -636.7511945499282, -693.9725724475828, -302.0198040281098, -64.51336839153711, -423.75829745371834, -244.12093807933798, -59.57982322204049, -373.94360149049925, -273.0022600965463, -360.7525088515505, -196.39915829590655, -401.55660606191196, -636.071330960363], + "butteraugli": [22.906327250428465, 27.275481108864415, 45.09566532180511, 27.511737448105688, 25.890447032919724, 21.79807137288874, 39.503276729517985, 13.161462954849581, 20.09902409512838, 37.78812286108226, 21.0589809492386, 33.18256609122779, 21.559242658278336, 22.852151082695, 37.20438694273225, 26.68328746097008, 31.57908699041576, 45.62051038116163, 47.25265818903535, 25.754241398766194, 37.952319822929105, 15.79543320094213, 22.36499070276575, 26.497638270397022, 9.775440960600472, 42.672018988933054, 37.102737843151836, 37.12137945623041, 32.44169266667817, 34.785690615559396, 33.438664844853044], + "dssim": [0.3043310585300488, 0.3049908557560831, 0.4643906576897276, 0.16094200763813804, 0.33470449169235306, 0.242552994098236, 0.21978587084216145, 0.0844718104585449, 0.40685082680561063, 0.26527539275073686, 0.39387946634239385, 0.24781100956680596, 0.15102636184267798, 0.258221238638072, 0.36555189078349337, 0.20176841649557337, 0.22799031294562278, 0.14785988674345713, 0.3298339593971582, 0.36855677093628303, 0.2242612528800641, 0.14952370073521587, 0.292326590560538, 0.2379046391968372, 0.10302400767956016, 0.2796459505501685, 0.22716640821839068, 0.30503187127628373, 0.21782833873960034, 0.3186134404662644, 0.3582170517246137] } }, { "label": " 40B tuned L43@4 C15@3", - "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=43:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40], - "ciede2000": [7.02366892209227, 8.755019001565396, 26.116010568803148, 9.91759824299302, 13.063171096678936, 9.462769093848099, 13.796998427714444, 3.539130467920009, 10.636895660889838, 11.250162606186917, 10.236808349330827, 9.732379341195927, 4.065872613103076, 11.475768204646661, 18.626908928937095, 10.434701567321143, 11.582916295518586, 9.423317561001657, 17.73800998301473, 14.141143792363392, 10.889744748662876, 4.119782519195745, 12.893709203686115, 12.606584636450606, 2.278664319782355, 12.971624493588463, 12.765729642479524, 11.721685326216663, 7.849298314837731, 9.992764224600611, 14.646754349068335], - "ssimulacra2": [-134.74825247696958, -235.83707722529118, -1228.5885199535298, -132.49392065345995, -304.7015065591697, -199.6539438717425, -419.35195686704924, -62.78690668738835, -288.61968959844876, -292.13226011293415, -240.29066695559243, -130.92651018770982, -64.058072764548, -248.52124216135417, -791.9325394889012, -221.18526567733284, -238.5958088190796, -101.03076910394668, -541.2400924974526, -664.0713584629412, -226.73248021741443, -64.27363473403409, -404.5627089698235, -231.02372195526425, -59.257193369600685, -323.9662007778197, -253.7568989688868, -319.2529873106008, -188.0781471639882, -367.47293557465946, -597.2658093769844], - "butteraugli": [19.88697100680896, 25.188034685620295, 45.06801507769885, 25.713510436415273, 25.185038438095802, 21.138274120358236, 38.14590142209616, 13.156958576803476, 19.08505997385003, 36.06737656551993, 20.179263705782684, 25.697238515033575, 19.91296014758136, 21.935663285280626, 36.19487510969694, 26.450484346910116, 30.802014945233044, 41.16934878427023, 44.83183727513773, 25.567670444438733, 33.40837379967019, 15.097778299483613, 22.038979218337065, 25.363998105770282, 10.062628369524068, 37.98970782358182, 36.652964315098046, 34.517391036013514, 35.51268135918127, 34.89230196835316, 33.996501096695575], - "dssim": [0.3042068202747792, 0.30437116873485737, 0.4642790254140603, 0.15907450154299713, 0.3343448118789556, 0.22923908189568054, 0.22068321946992436, 0.08435125264907173, 0.406892210574412, 0.26386429771631514, 0.39397571798714515, 0.24710511647432798, 0.15148223281287648, 0.25732325893413943, 0.36471655882015575, 0.20113256264816276, 0.22734079196530665, 0.14742915176205496, 0.3261419339487889, 0.36883730154865624, 0.22200920785971873, 0.14896638926994893, 0.28597211716965054, 0.2374247639959181, 0.10186872799633556, 0.277016643726292, 0.22271024804981326, 0.29813484890320285, 0.2170681587730532, 0.31772974258287545, 0.35615386389471304] + "ciede2000": [6.950866566191196, 8.743219992009271, 26.124320961464704, 9.892145589532339, 13.000062294922449, 9.475756200610366, 13.718236614963553, 3.5089266815982523, 10.69282647046242, 10.570299806169777, 10.231055220269416, 10.055841616359125, 4.056606437484256, 11.413715835667617, 18.470086812871703, 10.476900604049003, 11.624766870297456, 9.346541564985221, 17.601470293667948, 14.152217625560418, 11.537120990206105, 4.182220658133543, 12.637850971306078, 12.337789409082623, 2.2926711654980396, 12.876537880944065, 12.689643188199918, 11.683460628484509, 7.866772579211574, 9.836167791572878, 14.465360398820554], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.00393317578346, -231.28350671637094, -1229.944752518285, -129.67862670417006, -299.1458006903183, -202.85066645924752, -411.2103613243859, -62.92512873111403, -280.1239722738532, -245.94535897075616, -241.47595248493423, -155.25655616319585, -64.018631317987, -256.0184638789116, -787.5296916603043, -226.66446657818682, -234.84335019999236, -99.7133063534014, -527.7850279490976, -676.5661690901264, -272.8421079947387, -64.38389957123704, -387.9530211932122, -224.84430034327454, -60.0915375537254, -309.5062368029084, -247.27964668926717, -317.53657203142666, -182.2657303851089, -355.1610794719452, -570.5495488664828], + "butteraugli": [21.873785412144645, 24.364708896984542, 45.07791195543181, 26.118498629949443, 25.151478199158806, 21.514185432274804, 38.261142876621335, 13.170379183685094, 19.476469064536378, 31.052627173725497, 20.166525062543172, 27.33875649170098, 20.491551313090675, 21.85697362927598, 36.534765998867364, 26.704655975681646, 30.793131564611134, 40.24570398155478, 42.89305916576101, 25.639423469298652, 36.42293896954813, 15.228134432360783, 22.464347608625022, 25.304645423405884, 10.386340717306211, 39.004452103496625, 37.109585553712044, 34.71208875756142, 31.898757830215846, 34.14413181917853, 35.12515691976907], + "dssim": [0.30442551207778246, 0.3048434153134584, 0.4644322086215287, 0.15847913829221288, 0.3346925007521937, 0.23025161524411725, 0.22115574361759377, 0.08436146050105636, 0.4061530479141755, 0.25630157767817763, 0.39402020438582924, 0.24881808531489574, 0.15115137726924616, 0.2580785312593534, 0.3645782597820407, 0.20124051804051563, 0.22707137082918688, 0.14536675069350552, 0.3275388921624808, 0.3685981329876835, 0.22379619909597498, 0.14945426508476195, 0.2815288703215253, 0.2373813382781676, 0.09968213494463196, 0.2766494385030621, 0.22198373101102203, 0.2935936374925683, 0.2167185812518751, 0.3172020039061684, 0.3535545206791497] } }, { "label": " 48B tuned L54@4 C19@3", - "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], - "ciede2000": [6.818032935949239, 8.358606147567384, 26.09439998585236, 9.252344236318944, 12.71850322778114, 9.039279411158049, 13.641343907827304, 3.3279507673101025, 10.53068648885552, 10.423270946718711, 10.092579783251958, 9.25452480768935, 3.7782726665185646, 11.29311219917941, 18.046691847155387, 10.165746976645746, 11.279791687336747, 9.067523917185492, 16.908831154283874, 14.105790646704689, 10.540727666199901, 3.9101424850740876, 12.664981954727791, 12.466872336582826, 2.2282162640159244, 12.432023272485702, 12.407690391948517, 11.322016719297363, 7.673843944167074, 9.436872586950521, 14.37957289983098], - "ssimulacra2": [-123.21373770556954, -197.52984444443877, -1227.592121263497, -115.72431984536334, -289.7507741200252, -171.6354971325364, -400.0682042671778, -62.32604930075547, -267.367900464678, -234.47775927723234, -216.79800661895132, -117.08892008475291, -64.00619024508043, -247.91326655162862, -728.7530237636292, -204.97273773408654, -219.30756182425876, -91.77507779456357, -460.2283809471544, -662.7816742753507, -205.77523325059786, -64.22910384943222, -383.4939700567314, -204.9438595488857, -58.86218617273096, -268.7912903571486, -234.3343228061624, -285.0323127618245, -174.9067713163904, -321.38739176693696, -556.7273854357393], - "butteraugli": [18.50823500631984, 24.100147910659306, 45.04572377189633, 24.89790643196261, 24.999043809973802, 21.12149369709726, 37.99843820288106, 13.178820125528672, 19.38619434910572, 30.492468765343173, 19.775795346845744, 24.457997012805254, 19.27495628877072, 22.383403310046706, 34.340211784844854, 26.094693995037193, 30.744660494496575, 37.836592355074764, 40.87199601792356, 25.46222855641531, 32.19252097324517, 14.98909129274783, 22.214177308096577, 25.18353978428131, 9.826566564987752, 36.66811697174885, 36.3520326666741, 31.676589181913112, 30.8378753273592, 33.535691585801224, 33.24786006731994], - "dssim": [0.3041365349315721, 0.30332528955616345, 0.4641983005198711, 0.15725174762046096, 0.33453011627866813, 0.2242449790299334, 0.2212349924391423, 0.08423604150478431, 0.40650563051182437, 0.25927723273583536, 0.39405591070272855, 0.24184841755991388, 0.1513746766015791, 0.25694724009749514, 0.3625473548179925, 0.20126305944062722, 0.2279387393902667, 0.14624749333110004, 0.32353269336680424, 0.36890638303780005, 0.22147761374483993, 0.14886328292157525, 0.2808809364408099, 0.23764297715447918, 0.09753631339055824, 0.2745319349731016, 0.22015177610680392, 0.2957932064134212, 0.21572475392211032, 0.31760079140689, 0.3533100705545469] + "ciede2000": [6.931850877880345, 8.58387616598588, 26.102939199092795, 9.168705263455509, 12.760541637085408, 9.099602916359583, 13.51235050981503, 3.4232017739704776, 10.537019267538396, 10.513513122451197, 10.11551344120855, 9.32613524059582, 3.7915979928055075, 11.362068373249514, 17.947662617196038, 10.252414243993293, 11.365625119768616, 9.172176768079165, 17.061190033139454, 14.108470344137869, 10.596445284432127, 4.078658835033235, 12.672255127232688, 12.499964229964764, 2.227725946365046, 12.403251566173875, 12.573113494522143, 11.266163555151365, 7.722745159778865, 9.435323198460544, 14.242147616834226], + "ssimulacra2": [-131.60569469782718, -217.8885243005953, -1228.3023944280858, -109.73490403356794, -290.3101163702365, -172.8796799113486, -394.3546837544991, -62.76948226879193, -267.5229394566179, -236.2213082058796, -221.41011893107623, -120.82651085884007, -64.02882106083086, -248.5258921262335, -720.0144025855534, -217.51872583540018, -225.1897928938821, -91.37439781571334, -452.47695061893216, -663.3533722318235, -209.97751429509879, -64.24662238201103, -371.20793452598326, -210.63706580816415, -58.26916909930159, -264.69408730085684, -250.45657472651067, -271.6716196850188, -177.80613534364898, -325.96922592259597, -554.2478053981891], + "butteraugli": [19.06578643792137, 23.74129184239979, 45.048120234029454, 24.763628872829713, 24.882669178466596, 21.063821988933018, 38.01071985331063, 13.16502707513026, 19.23082410141611, 30.38199408509223, 20.129486128678874, 25.062149788453066, 19.374961014688783, 22.22806336929847, 34.5737196023508, 26.314094294524505, 30.778862190393923, 37.41721763293067, 41.37011980984372, 25.48763503205349, 32.40720352262545, 15.023580897741724, 21.815679426362674, 24.495873681332615, 9.752356348398608, 37.05707254423066, 35.18034436053537, 31.634058518736385, 30.91142942021811, 33.618414386959444, 33.53681687521772], + "dssim": [0.30423845409657213, 0.30379981795226063, 0.4642661428578949, 0.15627640334794107, 0.3345860708622783, 0.22357547635063635, 0.2209855708377621, 0.08431446202671528, 0.40629530953109555, 0.25855685610367984, 0.394063742891516, 0.24214715103109236, 0.15142326465336042, 0.2567370490098645, 0.362132507058183, 0.2007699751079977, 0.2282265508085724, 0.14643375405936904, 0.3226707420648254, 0.3689649850534811, 0.22199940629305642, 0.14911641380442325, 0.2825515149122688, 0.23844332618877045, 0.0995244381142888, 0.2750567464730461, 0.22300881596212324, 0.2937641909548504, 0.21628393240272614, 0.31701981002140855, 0.35317051455115755] } }, { "label": " 64B tuned L59@5 C20@4", - "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=59:5 c=20:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64], - "ciede2000": [6.677905099458365, 8.190477411967068, 26.061102127428097, 8.83782996071835, 12.378767040549178, 8.963583944427214, 13.34060693102503, 2.9388776151236615, 10.313541685464914, 10.296925816833584, 9.936980651550085, 8.418192533541639, 3.647851558541962, 11.010913380716119, 17.80315174262847, 10.071792863303545, 10.977166120486984, 8.420369292474204, 16.519198390476866, 14.092790798221303, 10.087211444967613, 3.722286762924975, 12.584552069632727, 11.89375311023166, 2.1169281311133163, 12.244851533477641, 11.633121840475305, 11.254600950074092, 7.32650746789802, 9.315673757940404, 13.678735210500452], - "ssimulacra2": [-119.39496952748027, -189.2059287996678, -1226.0578966702233, -107.56660024641107, -282.9730548075094, -168.9739666259004, -391.97504092600724, -61.689439299173046, -254.1918190436238, -227.0644632576848, -189.14826023306983, -101.03749218107299, -63.85829278266294, -227.2910212274781, -699.1796850622892, -194.67729939974174, -217.63236905216684, -80.36879398202507, -439.6392959982518, -640.4591368185479, -190.48930387415055, -64.22762208121443, -374.7500762795116, -196.2173068594737, -56.31756228477559, -262.53130758123064, -216.53863804596745, -272.6483439365272, -171.84326634949406, -310.6335339575471, -542.8881794663056], - "butteraugli": [18.10650565700036, 23.58609382465805, 45.044351246626434, 24.72665137650623, 23.479237162577817, 20.622625662293142, 37.96353635035969, 12.86984280120415, 18.552348514813385, 29.901848982711517, 19.48351386030684, 23.66888789388, 19.216851213940753, 20.697709296325673, 34.270536354553954, 26.13322389726237, 30.06377861961847, 38.7118435049324, 41.30710773147512, 25.3493780187148, 32.988146418150926, 14.312472234065297, 21.84944564371213, 24.521065947238892, 8.444819009425753, 36.3557360730648, 34.50097141593103, 31.760521529719927, 28.738440443651765, 33.67018961464561, 33.015339248381395], - "dssim": [0.30397226628663954, 0.3025832502455139, 0.46397927975562503, 0.15580934104116473, 0.3349942694917132, 0.22114903694192234, 0.22204412393861667, 0.08379520780147742, 0.40527555994288705, 0.26295698164190084, 0.3941554052479488, 0.23547855329485717, 0.15131547705557807, 0.2557126557856315, 0.3618228025439594, 0.20181042832823426, 0.22694793979770972, 0.13551817568387658, 0.32140897995746476, 0.36888234522251184, 0.21955996963367158, 0.14798714804344631, 0.28073169780092866, 0.23734887555471684, 0.08814213133968068, 0.27392029901851456, 0.21862298382719003, 0.29919928087341574, 0.21650879007809787, 0.3142878327510913, 0.3549429935560107] + "ciede2000": [6.698063439587923, 7.995854179445659, 26.07312784526343, 8.819893798434336, 12.425715112225781, 9.018812459952285, 13.319659913228845, 2.9943214450458098, 10.394364793646279, 10.298267350304268, 9.97881680222216, 8.536563465637306, 3.6719324528633304, 11.084889315293289, 17.75327599025463, 10.087847150706715, 11.011704698206453, 8.445428202831899, 16.554932016559754, 14.100961251943673, 10.27087079589441, 3.816879512879879, 12.594141372409515, 11.974789858643398, 2.108244978555179, 12.10328937810708, 11.610985660692572, 11.174267982432587, 7.373407255098813, 9.286349197836527, 13.620810915623695], + "ssimulacra2": [-122.58139348522843, -177.20534142188848, -1227.1598530728684, -108.0247551567764, -283.69357540381435, -169.38186222044288, -389.6124200816368, -62.28414429144573, -255.82348581799943, -225.6128008159564, -208.00976218503308, -107.36526618822538, -63.88571662173106, -227.11221335584173, -684.3545231528775, -196.98232210284095, -220.6210137484382, -82.96302523587414, -444.4452956600928, -661.028527766668, -201.1713925300075, -64.23042842650551, -362.7330322210216, -196.99643166163776, -55.49196872380713, -250.65714432370783, -201.42598413080964, -261.77551675066195, -173.5671326977274, -305.3997539658312, -538.029359323795], + "butteraugli": [17.971202201106987, 23.308295322898573, 45.05004902886778, 24.549292768176006, 23.86978550398948, 20.78489880568517, 37.63511235704047, 12.874072501837324, 18.48778236442777, 29.7403574532336, 19.5427299335573, 24.313025740460745, 19.187914621693526, 20.7267560491143, 34.19729918637202, 26.115614039298663, 30.25208815301133, 39.31647323550098, 41.0247718224684, 25.439504786628053, 33.396801985841904, 14.299113975810362, 21.342143953182415, 24.199873862594746, 8.261639949536852, 35.97473207097283, 33.237356389058846, 30.738582826043444, 28.863875120641136, 33.06667543983692, 31.692315386001052], + "dssim": [0.30413276066997463, 0.30178501028244376, 0.4639979006582081, 0.15472157313573048, 0.3351734378593372, 0.2202659156006465, 0.2215474681948031, 0.08393059913746964, 0.4061309346340363, 0.26260341998489045, 0.39422737851152845, 0.23600921182264728, 0.1512440585010733, 0.25621898060878234, 0.3618575687530583, 0.20205737216194503, 0.22716158258380764, 0.1389289258292754, 0.3241536542327813, 0.36888884326837446, 0.22095933498113596, 0.1483626432186007, 0.2827139607825101, 0.2378248171351564, 0.09275669928598895, 0.2735470320627217, 0.22015526972350474, 0.2960888413842905, 0.21715687850970422, 0.3145276994876628, 0.3563796747602983] } }, { "label": " 80B tuned L75@5 C26@4", - "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], - "ciede2000": [6.601855210786153, 7.683539468228845, 26.02451605014496, 8.43594497294905, 12.192986580439728, 8.67016965298202, 13.10184244548517, 2.8495535458947314, 10.007989148129024, 9.823949620752773, 9.83543367000351, 8.110692244234524, 3.4461332097081403, 10.473387224748615, 17.28594204896728, 9.599163798628332, 10.657852117826847, 8.048582493597621, 16.070388877311117, 14.067799168958468, 9.66243133995253, 3.6432638463961786, 12.175679341053227, 11.671720338411445, 2.018580428125535, 11.816580245081939, 11.008556730815634, 10.529041541182334, 6.8078109045875275, 9.050022044764804, 13.085576935268257], - "ssimulacra2": [-114.69436605309204, -156.0408805713568, -1222.751207897329, -97.74347469682544, -265.6051849488812, -144.0289634608918, -363.4126450842399, -60.964214846007906, -204.27646728085915, -204.01399095690402, -178.9026598452208, -90.26005161509673, -63.55177731111547, -195.77758576783486, -617.1012632528408, -157.28502251219663, -204.25419817610464, -76.82671495163947, -368.39602880885826, -632.431600201171, -169.20853365831374, -64.21447727902293, -338.707585156561, -171.95124234445746, -52.87787443582209, -225.21665785195978, -175.61609029728777, -228.0600445857214, -138.17122115224447, -284.17150749281745, -466.9091935477346], - "butteraugli": [17.000142613974607, 22.327369458296356, 45.011443505231846, 23.83127599531714, 22.885804994292965, 20.20490265447052, 36.93558696478303, 12.725149080556301, 17.6434633348884, 28.772071206012622, 19.20014764857808, 22.0449821874244, 18.345319044457273, 19.996698951144335, 33.49617546822243, 25.147780576479864, 29.814998717333328, 33.457616120886, 39.540064945813555, 25.345389470548813, 33.674409697045085, 14.041593340025083, 21.179582722869824, 23.389347444583176, 7.0877075541649885, 33.41918626156981, 32.35395884297577, 29.274133444961866, 26.986855801821587, 33.12822335792884, 29.38081699731485], - "dssim": [0.3040481360533447, 0.30108350043907517, 0.46377211662324774, 0.15511277846872268, 0.33533004153090007, 0.21522212014141268, 0.22349979697621802, 0.08377933183715963, 0.4044392930150487, 0.24535945592150638, 0.3936470253295984, 0.2352171691750924, 0.1514104508927971, 0.25534410683897735, 0.3600640949081326, 0.20208155827880486, 0.22639102238949532, 0.1389844262314734, 0.3165780481691314, 0.3691845147212225, 0.2188158599110983, 0.14796560649143076, 0.28216069539538136, 0.2377030796756185, 0.08516947262245828, 0.272390642138144, 0.2167323367625868, 0.2896802543872582, 0.21305791275795816, 0.3116628053076498, 0.35466744757691526] + "ciede2000": [6.630194026887956, 7.721365597308991, 26.033620676724208, 8.327409991779678, 12.073183675474388, 8.686847106020485, 13.118811691719218, 2.889254189276905, 10.092783624522202, 9.81311301131523, 9.844126990674326, 8.166985591334075, 3.4959150809572934, 10.647999196471075, 17.366887206616326, 9.577997300674951, 10.63833053603207, 8.191136273542064, 16.019934919713457, 14.07287899897178, 9.780662437703999, 3.6763682150913084, 11.745422359126518, 11.544429393420883, 2.0627883081994667, 11.844752805483964, 10.936720261267705, 10.511041376143057, 6.70597638103999, 9.038639974102361, 13.076693915950987], + "ssimulacra2": [-116.76162564932244, -156.90647628862945, -1223.4513323499227, -95.51879927954954, -262.78713580305464, -147.44196023658546, -356.1055302675343, -61.247110329765405, -218.19020969089377, -202.19934525691184, -181.560080990816, -92.62807775597969, -63.792330808936725, -194.8893134475186, -629.3954435177902, -158.74581588276317, -204.45897336533346, -77.76257198517368, -368.31888299053, -634.3199593357306, -179.54281422558955, -64.22315353520008, -330.60797445877546, -157.34658534523885, -54.29199467196506, -231.7741016426213, -172.6528112532966, -228.84097808761294, -135.52468683614114, -279.8452356333438, -476.91131811686046], + "butteraugli": [17.91366643730558, 22.309296773608917, 45.012562875011675, 23.958228377879532, 23.49862303354602, 20.509006093890275, 36.76654940306079, 12.831800225807319, 17.634153094318677, 28.73614968603391, 19.2442049251696, 22.41319960392742, 18.815215715561134, 20.105646583338963, 33.89004960181224, 25.014799335948766, 29.624508463838836, 35.03113293021128, 39.54230927111902, 25.356753370681147, 33.07006054411602, 14.057729931355189, 21.333595035828836, 22.818239493333866, 7.573135402477959, 33.87037860805222, 32.27580231469321, 28.907017603253905, 26.897769097386746, 33.393889454378105, 29.63580143726702], + "dssim": [0.30405843226493856, 0.3010332911621296, 0.46390362509075855, 0.1544296291510226, 0.33622290001127714, 0.21280996773615274, 0.22387587031342443, 0.08378942974790543, 0.4047946852090604, 0.24371050053158222, 0.3936693509619495, 0.23441562310083097, 0.15148510787558672, 0.2550066129807508, 0.3602100672426277, 0.2024005676383584, 0.2262699294829809, 0.13628425995847598, 0.3164879677880327, 0.3690238470705026, 0.21957451330768102, 0.1480119364481281, 0.2780976208703765, 0.23766916527447463, 0.08856229130416732, 0.2721027777240025, 0.21531795392080977, 0.28976703252537417, 0.21213376556647084, 0.3110113458325645, 0.3553509635015404] } }, { "label": " 108B tuned L104@5 C36@4", - "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], - "ciede2000": [6.4654540589466905, 7.39763923700012, 25.940291510403757, 7.716283732976999, 11.609619901844694, 8.196398791510578, 12.118782590805012, 2.778953263338479, 9.837593260423034, 9.174211360923348, 9.725003284071278, 7.941436339230749, 3.3070301302036103, 10.002426185465122, 16.512762296078005, 9.028232177981236, 10.176323308012975, 7.315569215420465, 14.986877701854043, 14.053995988503251, 9.163548787477168, 3.5411450722272404, 11.339507683117693, 11.06778436830679, 1.9832400051872558, 10.953914746771106, 10.353075082730092, 9.548248149930897, 6.403735497271883, 8.526190209686066, 12.457946541394305], - "ssimulacra2": [-105.26957297794198, -140.7583405129946, -1213.6206059495898, -82.43477640776644, -212.74623064026815, -120.19990576825597, -255.76409651094696, -59.705866779253256, -187.97079972228016, -156.39546410756373, -163.65686032141502, -85.34827919607753, -62.27938750810364, -176.22198900269314, -489.0635192211498, -137.17286445380574, -157.98758980853614, -67.81015768026688, -271.2294935149711, -618.9285850703799, -144.44474207829109, -64.07910802764712, -284.9503009388397, -121.67408572675004, -50.67697007953649, -167.3809729184277, -141.02387859716882, -144.96389099109683, -116.36776256661847, -212.9718971574905, -390.67081448835523], - "butteraugli": [15.565281796320813, 22.107164839367982, 44.927473640926564, 22.699530059617597, 22.203552268036002, 19.61848519795643, 33.13938532635597, 12.726812684512742, 17.335960028593433, 25.088819542312493, 19.14857625732691, 20.898333135630637, 17.54633727993074, 19.471437150926217, 31.55179487222598, 24.574871163944085, 27.63442080996317, 27.883267117772064, 36.49537428332849, 25.24394170490646, 30.36789583312776, 13.872759984865882, 20.326296141671346, 22.025867318692743, 6.74957621246747, 29.666701680662474, 31.693258764275345, 24.69849669347128, 25.755667581219438, 31.218366823762803, 27.72649739302095], - "dssim": [0.30401504523755885, 0.30066258337152596, 0.4635411567671853, 0.1527811438356384, 0.33426391594669064, 0.21070025202768683, 0.22070360865507171, 0.08354120371228407, 0.40403523031575533, 0.22923514225172276, 0.39297812598932047, 0.23383134198462158, 0.15146771062235626, 0.2548187801349552, 0.35915316058002916, 0.20324306082951266, 0.22804765817214578, 0.1337685472237422, 0.31286416677328854, 0.36942048621500956, 0.2191666786336584, 0.14784685564308414, 0.27688006943474053, 0.23663453693838649, 0.08497238778013477, 0.2652795235717681, 0.21024253474880156, 0.28235471586483873, 0.21080478493291843, 0.3036510603208852, 0.35163679639653933] + "ciede2000": [6.501028494936473, 7.330762238530262, 25.946440347021742, 7.769055416791733, 11.690131961084823, 8.262218448034407, 12.008455283834166, 2.7995280178096573, 9.875330160381857, 9.19254962203175, 9.711132405160951, 8.004139786520263, 3.423588967985655, 10.000319021723316, 16.63508261952022, 9.10311893405415, 10.230156141473357, 7.3786832395690825, 15.108279973813245, 14.056475723825992, 9.171568813968596, 3.575878864578659, 11.160670362694272, 10.815042368043763, 1.9659043846716635, 10.801515871821875, 10.358368996115948, 9.32120663046571, 6.321754953035656, 8.465498647033392, 12.410965179905931], + "ssimulacra2": [-110.15814472039119, -131.2934470717052, -1215.0628777632314, -84.51688578980946, -215.31417876577552, -124.21150527444283, -246.1058211483964, -60.53084773823025, -189.16470923618812, -160.68740634389002, -160.60231452263366, -87.39689547171224, -63.32228629660801, -178.40205272776825, -513.7682379050025, -142.21936456680154, -157.78709128606874, -68.18954276041961, -294.9695920698631, -619.9950279049882, -137.6268552135511, -64.14293855914087, -299.30609674114237, -112.07361707949158, -50.049783859409445, -159.18575988012697, -148.3743240470597, -128.98654882354413, -116.4496388778353, -210.45805822352332, -381.26516230131335], + "butteraugli": [15.74015844765458, 22.135166286474796, 44.91962483101114, 22.767950427464488, 22.43127932910254, 19.69513927228857, 32.80614488245377, 12.728093606585036, 17.31861790237944, 25.172795627201342, 19.147738342660887, 20.939839175695642, 17.966071529680033, 19.540567101845042, 31.899612824268825, 24.65980417042719, 26.812682371146483, 27.59503638734793, 37.582843278759924, 25.238811971440555, 30.37949804187872, 13.79116695798667, 20.46276277597182, 21.8146732237833, 6.494962633486445, 27.637695273075256, 31.57044304758107, 24.023787318469328, 25.494602610139694, 30.39446873572864, 27.794519514467492], + "dssim": [0.3043200591278771, 0.2999671218815825, 0.463643490033493, 0.15282365817168692, 0.3348686112614281, 0.2122066671443132, 0.22093424785343746, 0.08359491930430196, 0.4040513851060085, 0.22849024125494677, 0.392803930581983, 0.23519973711550057, 0.151726840333459, 0.2546301506105131, 0.35917377735352596, 0.20307535111753466, 0.22740938784261733, 0.1334222146675857, 0.31213828298870705, 0.36940349865842126, 0.21971660664831644, 0.14805655852805222, 0.27542829317178763, 0.23637683148298866, 0.08483931246297116, 0.2640399594180064, 0.21125616820215776, 0.2812752419171839, 0.21120146313663624, 0.30295629242367794, 0.35118487742332305] } }, { "label": " 161B tuned L158@5 C55@4", - "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=158:5 c=55:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161], - "ciede2000": [6.295859087013338, 6.988257827641516, 24.614736611712324, 7.106212950382608, 11.168232035579157, 7.46958735831553, 11.223073697211369, 2.6880624797056853, 9.621536269422808, 8.430933138156147, 9.416585352243365, 7.5604957434960935, 3.150261317841058, 9.714230843289366, 15.527573103352962, 8.24048388308642, 9.607451875193057, 6.65587505065334, 13.750686818645539, 13.955969774364275, 8.593588266884346, 3.4840805039670086, 10.190490027828115, 9.663324538811839, 1.9561616392108974, 10.041912379287563, 9.63114190437801, 8.551624564495643, 5.714810156563483, 7.862818454984976, 11.696797867856153], - "ssimulacra2": [-103.03189563528232, -107.3656618573821, -991.593847025051, -73.03093056424802, -176.8413262497299, -92.64759128194112, -172.56516254763375, -57.198871487316666, -147.49354825371384, -102.77156930580648, -136.3442042876701, -74.97969244217146, -60.81527744238781, -144.0231511966255, -365.4292112237118, -99.00547087603456, -111.11585849307238, -64.63671718360365, -207.81213467564294, -558.320854373422, -110.54084845767727, -63.903348179072964, -216.6297747942658, -78.06524958747451, -49.188204310055994, -114.18714963380009, -111.69775674966289, -98.33929750489642, -80.44987384954513, -153.97977369085913, -283.58942055192495], - "butteraugli": [14.82411188027124, 20.54740982062999, 43.82020130648294, 22.150072077536365, 22.097646835052128, 19.280777282374782, 30.466470302320413, 12.61305961946754, 16.79120026226591, 23.629830722991855, 18.32302157251183, 19.75373007147434, 16.61003656898033, 19.0905924609694, 30.907026996440504, 23.779100969699524, 24.997751880436876, 25.434926860462763, 34.02744374901412, 25.03762384186355, 28.315004180299127, 13.516838973189872, 18.599678245895852, 20.213875351649534, 6.6180867603765305, 25.90972544904967, 30.48235687297144, 22.573818728404643, 24.591596953589, 28.32173385505831, 25.93721453320519], - "dssim": [0.3039103323871536, 0.29916025079290365, 0.45900098267588063, 0.15006067313771093, 0.3348023887358522, 0.2000224500066034, 0.2203125030018025, 0.08323842868040598, 0.4028251984793559, 0.2124920615208129, 0.39156976330185517, 0.23097977821680243, 0.15157190374775037, 0.2548542001664985, 0.35554628155394774, 0.1996965182675947, 0.2264203434667415, 0.1288529910569638, 0.3082728957615811, 0.36899665688764194, 0.22040638124130058, 0.1481184838954654, 0.26856547836114575, 0.2344652878283801, 0.08347700740267999, 0.2599571035901961, 0.20664513781000643, 0.27385051168164876, 0.20461022213703978, 0.2971769378385536, 0.3459622902839017] + "ciede2000": [6.286883190761376, 7.060034202407603, 25.74453918752333, 7.021540261231407, 11.160438098203981, 7.445964084067665, 11.241796908574274, 2.7039219836494963, 9.653068942541786, 8.394485740456759, 9.431287343714574, 7.647361510294354, 3.1822856288086587, 9.660436400852431, 15.535976887602233, 8.430466002517491, 9.61071559409336, 6.827087496767602, 13.83778662656172, 13.974198073285095, 8.55424429345603, 3.5078707100460593, 10.149761975087463, 9.733903648017574, 1.95635424037414, 9.906780917119706, 9.636403956508968, 8.463863666723373, 5.737435718639889, 7.7923866675852045, 11.576132290085999], + "ssimulacra2": [-98.89389555948671, -108.36415939730853, -1189.064384234778, -72.8840202807734, -180.92055119471706, -91.59624816607177, -172.14414984326163, -57.98691506627014, -148.2373576473448, -101.39669980519727, -133.4213668783998, -75.62737058465433, -61.139605157216806, -145.13026365684965, -364.53168434350675, -110.19217798079353, -116.24784764912405, -64.94220462650159, -206.91994218279996, -574.1834173105098, -109.09761846204452, -63.91174339278561, -226.7164072284762, -83.66651315005919, -49.39019452635992, -109.47835630019128, -114.06835374786658, -98.7964970403292, -82.53101382075525, -144.31089165552385, -270.76699353337835], + "butteraugli": [15.040434224602707, 20.7275101527363, 44.777495364075236, 22.184210961729928, 21.92175448456612, 19.274344434915616, 30.515788464713733, 12.527667948914681, 16.823363009662557, 23.717144591009184, 18.490151920525303, 19.754320823113165, 16.745718876342533, 19.033178016075688, 30.660493906445108, 24.269075997441007, 24.831407666932023, 25.905172416771432, 34.195960078568596, 25.16856797604038, 28.643678242651536, 13.353400028186007, 18.767931057730717, 20.416248719190122, 6.819995395900157, 26.553738811441292, 30.287746744794276, 22.648742851670743, 24.501888988139825, 27.36006891722217, 25.753127263112333], + "dssim": [0.3039002837460031, 0.299371649622612, 0.4628740552206229, 0.14995159893538507, 0.3346958697595228, 0.1983688383045174, 0.22056034572698902, 0.08333266262525663, 0.40327823910331084, 0.21048183445740415, 0.39174529615416215, 0.23194583373021477, 0.1517518301539973, 0.25451099539307465, 0.35523398780562543, 0.20161523929418002, 0.22683477609352037, 0.12749275551742273, 0.3073559546039085, 0.3691408200209174, 0.2213153430422507, 0.1482079267267295, 0.2701431831929072, 0.23722837484373932, 0.0843967163731898, 0.2600410857661154, 0.20743479466181353, 0.27374133865641903, 0.20497533650728983, 0.2952066968977475, 0.3450485591702369] } }, { "label": " 246B tuned L246@5 C85@4", - "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=246:5 c=85:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246], - "ciede2000": [6.122872229195075, 6.542092381520512, 21.184945770293066, 6.615120208008907, 10.76141394845696, 6.994220589354927, 10.386632187486011, 2.595839815403437, 9.418088713944533, 7.680583402708115, 9.235887062024066, 7.392284632792014, 3.0738555267006578, 9.162917319812125, 14.446565968527345, 7.680431926475576, 9.03367313414045, 6.074872364803763, 12.613626683210258, 13.783020578392119, 7.763657861073561, 3.4304562801696488, 9.68022855063825, 8.91173965079564, 1.9125893273459469, 9.574719590912471, 8.817639683190619, 7.911481307380795, 5.126476873792906, 7.30762078621194, 10.74063293744296], - "ssimulacra2": [-89.33610261626927, -80.00323149744233, -510.7162225645925, -67.19646877407706, -139.94261116145128, -74.5361652568962, -123.72013176573304, -52.78540161878996, -113.00307351562816, -73.70406760742395, -110.7341052204224, -69.33129317598093, -58.63772097765076, -108.24306320332391, -235.4617445729749, -77.39565295409523, -91.09641740803772, -64.2734218754199, -132.71416740838103, -484.99593021291093, -80.3378620159416, -63.24571781246186, -165.15406537001525, -68.83046588532264, -47.49134447512458, -94.47751306427588, -80.22310120540891, -77.37062638303087, -67.2965934601873, -107.5515922948257, -172.8476428387304], - "butteraugli": [14.520704389567484, 19.40478300578126, 38.70262730513277, 20.91193284978579, 20.935108668827574, 18.683951025424715, 28.991478735215605, 12.371418203876518, 16.093823305471233, 21.550563516146855, 17.65552895809855, 18.721011400470033, 15.4716170405609, 18.373071264144322, 27.76994680566318, 22.63315782728119, 23.692288717934925, 23.94465300310722, 29.91152189722459, 24.789120151750875, 26.09817141933674, 12.967331644372052, 17.85209579978894, 18.69209201188103, 6.151399981138678, 26.463415246988948, 27.807762869746057, 21.326743509404242, 22.845728203901103, 23.6844886743053, 24.96171950861363], - "dssim": [0.3036888862814965, 0.29635491896817834, 0.44475268300659365, 0.15076528602858136, 0.3345907108822902, 0.19241234281741643, 0.2210518477416113, 0.08289830265929538, 0.4011042863274658, 0.2038963379516302, 0.3909582692128201, 0.231468412435605, 0.1517895979806217, 0.2517546180635132, 0.3511409387166763, 0.19843075935818555, 0.2252939714287096, 0.12742034616070486, 0.30384703571205873, 0.36904485044248336, 0.2200435364897408, 0.14907345923610937, 0.264314909706829, 0.23285305920029759, 0.08166500069930654, 0.25932020681035484, 0.20260178212585944, 0.2662903557455303, 0.19861689999681464, 0.2870772709741377, 0.33856045104737253] + "ciede2000": [6.20081453577109, 6.552534019228385, 21.585121920609666, 6.610841012944458, 10.766594927097247, 7.040846240198627, 10.417873572672233, 2.622476167313583, 9.430335891594417, 7.6440160094313905, 9.235317687618531, 7.3951561927247464, 3.096452125873257, 9.169954988852906, 14.53215294589054, 7.815490699732687, 9.01863587926055, 6.13805126139673, 12.610959603208688, 13.807464107292946, 7.710871670233432, 3.4484506652145317, 9.804829808861149, 8.875045408032511, 1.916438554897658, 9.519890184015642, 8.831847121117404, 7.677944326422211, 5.294595956066336, 7.266743062109973, 10.773701836139072], + "ssimulacra2": [-93.0636486551565, -80.20590414782998, -563.6053994994124, -67.39890812714845, -138.40328382636685, -75.50924469731231, -125.0825667338735, -53.59947517793677, -114.58286576703173, -71.93761616957903, -107.98553922510888, -69.30457946083803, -59.03731534613121, -105.50862429577711, -246.4838273202824, -80.99343739408965, -90.59328872311602, -64.34051456818938, -131.1855412049225, -499.57920353836016, -77.26460494615912, -63.40057241453201, -168.806585893438, -68.54099029105058, -47.936271574623646, -91.80095660727662, -80.34396529385322, -73.37283920432239, -69.66346737393965, -104.8708309051546, -171.0406881177094], + "butteraugli": [14.483445586424859, 19.527533885352018, 39.636397117186526, 21.04638209216238, 20.965757200105738, 18.654683031299495, 28.713146391505074, 12.314774970633431, 16.35439411660168, 21.66683085571633, 17.58728107583087, 18.936007353022603, 15.597350276611769, 18.408637024933057, 28.45512000581749, 23.19284899107697, 23.64890517643786, 23.91356745243853, 29.938160377536665, 24.887195115877358, 25.590381654424842, 12.838119701636833, 17.923739838915306, 18.899601495474645, 6.1908225748225325, 25.04908385256537, 28.05354022500803, 20.944504262137666, 23.106534928908573, 23.34858990147293, 24.82499703964361], + "dssim": [0.3039906791944681, 0.2964258631208926, 0.44616791622317253, 0.15007683416582607, 0.33480119727614177, 0.19502207988127512, 0.22149627364486246, 0.08298093493631148, 0.4009969274053417, 0.20361446744225936, 0.39062069473629435, 0.2322945705131621, 0.15158328623536893, 0.25211253649886034, 0.3526003234951687, 0.19810500704812123, 0.22526451560471927, 0.12796653001952302, 0.3019378137381409, 0.36887894726539816, 0.21935393844077633, 0.1496487426566993, 0.26537751140658006, 0.2325387534548708, 0.08261224479090323, 0.25901515239383965, 0.20176959521259674, 0.26262958012264404, 0.20208467841759886, 0.28641340141293525, 0.3388487619529058] } }, { "label": " 411B tuned L416@5 C144@4", - "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tune": "l1=416:5 c=144:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", "tier": 1, "version": null, "perImage": { "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], - "ciede2000": [6.006148286245828, 6.088297049602137, 19.055372338506515, 6.115837132118654, 10.39951584913524, 6.438402080146803, 9.01981564721075, 2.586013819926192, 9.233753238297933, 7.064873858201373, 9.078380598428641, 7.128166540239659, 2.985091170131297, 8.673635375810884, 13.132777212880045, 6.946358054351304, 8.516461245978984, 5.523984062740297, 11.265219850714669, 13.682504932649136, 7.084831656580275, 3.398812697128524, 9.263000027192385, 8.582456348356677, 1.890747386565494, 9.057214747891555, 8.219892239785084, 6.946693385349827, 4.796349350649743, 6.532606026255019, 10.198754994384464], - "ssimulacra2": [-80.47120708726999, -68.65821133324647, -252.03598529042097, -64.29298476394933, -110.09813349775743, -65.16298877542573, -71.0012456477948, -50.62643998104156, -89.42329676640665, -65.24261918022202, -90.39993607633409, -65.67084044493956, -56.645716376613365, -80.33222429257921, -123.32387392035517, -65.24618482342274, -78.86582608664816, -64.22136302110476, -77.3007494520958, -457.37511470170364, -66.75591713244364, -62.6733362176609, -121.04237392015972, -65.29081970440134, -47.29442863935046, -78.75452079841585, -67.2168985866162, -64.57908986849534, -64.58258500786744, -70.76417249973787, -114.76616596558546], - "butteraugli": [14.271420040964367, 18.324228117990554, 34.31198721652563, 19.338518720118525, 20.34617961173789, 17.735499780767306, 26.28937540754551, 12.342396485904027, 15.434958654445099, 20.505430387205724, 16.839947711025065, 17.66850136906689, 14.762170787426781, 17.787356289339574, 24.61659468438206, 21.40499722819627, 22.720723399041443, 23.80177144018698, 26.716789953202664, 24.627260875952228, 22.912273025494965, 12.521869288866545, 17.031933337804567, 18.034171346970503, 5.9518707481881705, 22.72674400773848, 26.19212710031447, 18.9115381482691, 20.98057628999474, 21.450031769955242, 24.040853327741175], - "dssim": [0.303381857674641, 0.29375883000190406, 0.4302475149230351, 0.14862905721955383, 0.3332133610898479, 0.18336038341244326, 0.21416521230175672, 0.0828712082162828, 0.3997578868538874, 0.1894560127321348, 0.38916324747086417, 0.22870380210761204, 0.15205183697690677, 0.24983244108993535, 0.34428111105562775, 0.1991791283163547, 0.22687155559090405, 0.12434813381303461, 0.291172067215414, 0.3689510173592948, 0.21666488684354962, 0.14981444591602128, 0.2623706305656014, 0.23049453883836485, 0.08174843598465609, 0.25586407199450834, 0.19926096292258905, 0.254059831865179, 0.19495099468109783, 0.2707252258311251, 0.33350874509102546] + "ciede2000": [6.0041926884494154, 6.104573641561043, 19.232525432450416, 6.0996678278120635, 10.411079104879041, 6.459366324099528, 9.086936416434675, 2.591457469625907, 9.241113463802478, 7.057080501529014, 9.071957219621344, 7.148373915529628, 3.0165654914113817, 8.651678908482303, 13.187369809473621, 6.9994144645223395, 8.52213954405267, 5.549940343844163, 11.278254123185922, 13.683030522233759, 7.05875762533052, 3.403973820029997, 9.26064599196369, 8.548336040332972, 1.8968957843059688, 9.039470477914398, 8.24671857854669, 6.904035018034791, 4.812282053572001, 6.531781334662195, 10.177634812038463], + "ssimulacra2": [-80.17359418704868, -68.96693340038965, -270.98057058315334, -64.28141417616231, -112.89389335050643, -65.19728440443711, -72.2033000867196, -50.64152093140484, -89.67654563954898, -65.28183957603028, -90.43116028512816, -65.75728780076619, -56.94892327306786, -78.96370156354573, -125.74158759366145, -65.42664551770861, -77.30834779784814, -64.22033336322454, -78.35096498906762, -459.7724957021537, -66.47632893650933, -62.463620834333284, -116.36520676650576, -65.2161408642452, -47.33383621347198, -78.60249897652125, -67.44974789231463, -64.54368581930154, -64.67883545310866, -70.62376084901788, -113.92830646749789], + "butteraugli": [14.224300678636588, 18.390630122638765, 34.35027491767571, 19.291120040969815, 20.40952188155641, 17.7872050013161, 26.396951534151217, 12.34534967549385, 15.438815847487994, 20.678207534791774, 16.847388296872065, 17.732616395139832, 14.58801450507932, 17.768199004493432, 24.827899900092984, 21.643652661992224, 22.586917000132487, 23.70511984151891, 26.804739609596634, 24.62238368603741, 22.845085264538785, 12.36632062079717, 16.888305578940003, 18.010221309226527, 5.972865947839085, 22.821144117607158, 26.100748875311776, 19.158641936545305, 21.042668982196872, 21.34172759065805, 23.88300841930455], + "dssim": [0.30333031011102074, 0.2938571567812852, 0.43200749163778274, 0.14840747567532236, 0.3339775055436983, 0.18444340692682948, 0.21520679765671497, 0.08286120169330974, 0.3998952356215541, 0.1891765097312404, 0.38927800785717853, 0.22922239104443132, 0.15225818730066543, 0.24962890663611897, 0.3448321200501393, 0.20005508254858018, 0.2267798390885155, 0.12432018402845363, 0.29106018100610176, 0.3688002280248973, 0.21622224888795977, 0.1499668196804132, 0.261936088017493, 0.2305881299523802, 0.0818150374280242, 0.25601624876308604, 0.1989450821360475, 0.25310911369792044, 0.19539922316682373, 0.27105960788389194, 0.33352607551097735] + } + }, + { + "label": " 12B pre-adoption L5/C2", + "tune": "l1=5:5 c=2:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.978352490951777, 11.659777980932894, 26.160927592140425, 13.221706584620929, 15.596838257222474, 14.326557420334627, 17.59281809368566, 5.003011377634827, 13.213490381540343, 13.284421920837097, 12.16734611337497, 17.288575922139003, 4.86128404071045, 13.658251128855804, 20.93712601830201, 13.729481165682987, 14.837788879957456, 12.028123211222317, 21.7153834407772, 14.320157927189276, 17.18898094139305, 6.5896121891633825, 14.23716570870733, 14.41755715112072, 3.571801392589262, 15.876070480061005, 20.33781533857254, 16.44671260417198, 14.349185663782565, 15.457700477334587, 19.3517175408383], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.63691059459353, -324.5193872354475, -1232.2793716636327, -275.42177406131174, -368.30631193015824, -426.578410671887, -531.0211081722662, -64.2280444945209, -488.9440856080305, -375.4440442497725, -344.7882492441349, -459.56261050446403, -64.2350395359, -375.52519889208736, -966.2691410111511, -351.3413686331054, -385.6785816879585, -133.16872151620703, -828.1903324966008, -711.1208977551332, -400.36597041177276, -69.89204477220392, -469.306782049164, -309.8413902573953, -63.920225317474404, -524.7823096187362, -499.7425761078972, -531.1082489666761, -381.54809286639255, -573.6709741504937, -804.3914684517948], + "butteraugli": [28.418980727554953, 35.40475734804664, 45.24936433401316, 41.482212989793226, 31.84037639104261, 42.59401126543674, 43.64927132455248, 14.220073329709969, 28.87244141259525, 56.99487252081399, 30.0733405804615, 56.663241097818265, 26.969497397488738, 29.103874081406108, 41.67173897333509, 40.97722797512781, 41.4322733037283, 59.78167431131217, 57.65915399791598, 26.11867670015488, 55.79874368779185, 20.721448770602894, 24.774420710465307, 30.93341279618889, 13.966137043624274, 69.94129927834042, 70.74063417156836, 54.30558571860562, 75.77118639126341, 60.781654382053894, 36.39826989245824], + "dssim": [0.3047206242851237, 0.3098086891307693, 0.46370246759488715, 0.1793989260062423, 0.33535340620982734, 0.271844359465915, 0.2224413266221153, 0.08569063825849144, 0.4101204725631506, 0.2492167716128481, 0.39525532070279334, 0.2706700508940042, 0.15186376062750412, 0.26333457526817794, 0.37159460288328594, 0.19982637928788738, 0.236526194877758, 0.15480938826574703, 0.35053396511234514, 0.3686193172003802, 0.23630278133611854, 0.15355070925141862, 0.29690544012653186, 0.2401158124314568, 0.15175856458808862, 0.2856154957464683, 0.25171914962049113, 0.36668671625073623, 0.23675475173430516, 0.34949294292648014, 0.3663505545258876] + } + }, + { + "label": " 16B pre-adoption L10/C3", + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=3:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.920672462115209, 10.452488904522735, 26.135964459389218, 12.969463143654373, 15.340195076767936, 11.876629148266748, 16.94099409713504, 4.289346534659488, 12.086944642843207, 13.22578434482965, 11.502568628565472, 15.042629334874587, 4.696843016936187, 13.162719920459994, 20.452170588494123, 12.588889104948642, 13.868214416381221, 11.570230560571842, 21.031650482814406, 14.285229015769444, 14.71329896634195, 5.681558487742778, 14.170460245136072, 13.454158871334638, 2.959198576858492, 15.128463907282521, 17.75049608895324, 13.940408613392668, 10.963757662935713, 12.315158456295759, 18.539390785863816], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.6316692286789, -300.5011393637137, -1230.4989311345005, -290.0279527347863, -367.598062784141, -336.2338745014681, -516.2092334277587, -64.18711638731253, -444.1607184246176, -382.374586987946, -315.7294903420428, -374.9107054154125, -64.23221683995638, -356.008658727227, -947.1315079742301, -332.7223357100891, -343.2579771458554, -125.95506446644251, -815.7535195939055, -705.6428907057244, -392.02541528280517, -67.62268689963949, -469.61896596926033, -276.90126631923215, -62.46979889953701, -506.1069012822263, -477.0720522057136, -445.45204927389307, -344.5210488633416, -517.6599909980202, -780.5170893024406], + "butteraugli": [27.596843337280514, 30.429194287134617, 45.242846543903234, 37.76006332009707, 29.50926177883244, 26.2932634524001, 43.82507692246111, 13.558672547537219, 22.84713085271221, 52.90826894354137, 27.182297021865775, 45.70644034911988, 26.730549955752537, 24.740865429218246, 40.99150839471729, 31.492834307197313, 33.443354824351765, 54.976436696817416, 55.50305126907648, 25.9537190565663, 46.63077955480323, 19.849259547942278, 24.009773157080307, 28.46539432502887, 12.563442097662323, 49.633227036858365, 64.63153195691619, 43.902984572940476, 51.41528965928122, 40.566351347009665, 35.623879244314054], + "dssim": [0.3045533874073555, 0.3074047466425669, 0.463796676522469, 0.1756666852860363, 0.3354063474261321, 0.26141960032535316, 0.22222759403825704, 0.08506958157845884, 0.41006572925224877, 0.26668976232651864, 0.3943808890599167, 0.25855404831115414, 0.15175836052101138, 0.2625000754052722, 0.3704550594289787, 0.19748776330044887, 0.24056128640872115, 0.15338107664499406, 0.345784090558489, 0.36856485037531506, 0.22543671188030096, 0.15107544761318675, 0.2967999184572998, 0.2379635242934552, 0.14323819021696155, 0.28417143282582746, 0.24305497011923088, 0.3202854203325217, 0.23203196868268672, 0.3358889406425578, 0.36807531468397525] + } + }, + { + "label": " 21B pre-adoption L13/C6", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.898548020995201, 9.676118423937845, 26.135445509393843, 11.718609542730094, 14.234094471730877, 11.655187395986866, 15.65947719231447, 4.261196374388893, 11.730666691527015, 12.654581481253432, 11.445229116029624, 14.76495393121619, 4.6188985939539755, 12.936449028384004, 19.815237755941787, 12.637438301378495, 13.512258075203562, 10.888840678902518, 19.744326266649484, 14.27854100631581, 14.181896085186226, 5.255036309077364, 13.75268897226279, 13.078267278300428, 2.944840689566194, 14.984169611061283, 16.754409904256637, 13.88293595499416, 10.372979020507321, 12.019332139948624, 16.269326516058413], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.03979931800603, -271.92958478951033, -1231.3071028885745, -233.1577499107147, -368.36208436275444, -330.2703871825091, -486.3123989847178, -64.17629183902068, -423.9405391968735, -346.9686488747198, -315.53245757462724, -382.2909142961937, -64.22960396967628, -344.39809227445255, -901.7783898020552, -331.6556196465076, -327.7089751273666, -124.36787523430155, -757.5043356081856, -701.6239289533404, -372.3523476495265, -67.17652532710528, -467.0644047364017, -277.02511999065223, -62.31374406473478, -501.6099395110882, -460.44000652462853, -440.31994883521963, -319.3484389994837, -508.2522217203617, -750.1130339337706], + "butteraugli": [26.74363422910824, 26.90151162422623, 45.249860601500984, 32.64353433761966, 29.146052879867494, 26.81950262959032, 41.971207670225404, 13.509537386023837, 23.47630886361927, 50.94035147525244, 26.70035778042106, 43.73703091831673, 25.332219594072644, 23.49614672169069, 39.406894386322556, 30.61390516072879, 32.064597161171854, 54.62358765970066, 52.77495012608002, 25.916239256112192, 47.5998560859857, 19.02457187481052, 24.035827925919936, 28.278906775514987, 12.199451723423257, 51.32310023411181, 69.22299769518894, 43.821127829537595, 48.16952332216738, 39.55822246575629, 34.967217548210435], + "dssim": [0.30459632102745926, 0.30607422069996526, 0.4638550253263906, 0.17049915569470442, 0.3358573883356122, 0.25494236243091806, 0.22061580979516388, 0.08501138348313048, 0.4097490591693022, 0.24424776419718908, 0.3943991325597557, 0.2605006762069356, 0.15177700296797808, 0.2617480501620931, 0.3685640439993073, 0.1975942077987145, 0.23498351785384491, 0.15038858497067026, 0.33490738576380497, 0.3685090560637123, 0.22435740929621345, 0.14939991177157697, 0.2959973904329626, 0.23801057100664214, 0.14307328047028706, 0.2842285445674956, 0.24523354359798355, 0.3191050772831113, 0.22918206720038042, 0.3328103802053529, 0.3613550089673684] + } + }, + { + "label": " 24B pre-adoption L18/C6", + "tune": "l1=18:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.8614012911962625, 9.395808714869922, 26.123731225666436, 11.700699603388498, 13.965115956647095, 10.556751010924314, 15.329612477920675, 4.170670073928778, 11.522099139028441, 12.322221528494017, 10.979601020449039, 12.2142444124952, 4.646135974171983, 12.528673980168415, 19.736992397178632, 12.084024231360768, 12.995204132138811, 10.489762578678672, 19.67951037042153, 14.263511572480018, 13.313304106910929, 4.876590947522939, 13.599338312462757, 13.05001570150352, 2.766099567291871, 14.522129996374765, 14.00257077569624, 13.140141512966306, 9.881603857880515, 11.504285291288491, 15.770344547756315], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.18607856330433, -270.12319563771473, -1229.9645039211673, -229.8525228535454, -349.0224679559805, -272.93407103934203, -470.51282396242004, -64.0801962193116, -410.5758551909802, -331.0771985465648, -277.0475095815445, -231.15258803941356, -64.22922278110337, -316.0053255721618, -897.564873842713, -302.9609995434665, -312.5292632271553, -116.6325781530688, -747.1516154320354, -697.678190493845, -361.3326781658486, -66.70987504252753, -451.4272419965421, -275.0933452826976, -60.85012114342149, -481.4358114900217, -320.0454764091095, -408.55603603791985, -290.5756447687719, -474.11773068309947, -717.5080928699424], + "butteraugli": [25.07055217784954, 26.710451329088215, 45.23685966164614, 32.56580034161224, 26.614136899925995, 23.812125866967033, 42.01280356718207, 13.251998451482459, 22.879326533002267, 49.35949289498182, 24.53628763092287, 41.561896101261674, 24.577451694193673, 23.343654228172543, 39.23117609811435, 29.431306604975877, 32.648952575995786, 51.895912785213284, 51.152558038247, 25.828538019242078, 43.550885349089356, 16.581227784152713, 22.724330941430527, 26.609085008126176, 9.708909835027795, 47.11652614586203, 40.19663318665104, 44.47848011583891, 39.97655338600945, 37.01034425788384, 34.60225357176558], + "dssim": [0.3044518207695278, 0.30577728356784595, 0.46386483770155884, 0.1702786562421777, 0.33510093489259685, 0.243926272624594, 0.2199533226187242, 0.08500849871648869, 0.40963296693080004, 0.24032506545256288, 0.3935334532354746, 0.2565977959086908, 0.15160425477873662, 0.2608941283698598, 0.36844096803856574, 0.19776876097412321, 0.23326004377033077, 0.1441980411745063, 0.3345609549476295, 0.36859429231414187, 0.22478990501492496, 0.14907217154197577, 0.2946071216174583, 0.23819261731100022, 0.11168301913673506, 0.28444726635933193, 0.23502408425046095, 0.30915725984365483, 0.22529552117145618, 0.32989504130749614, 0.3585900046802035] + } + }, + { + "label": " 28B pre-adoption L21/C8", + "tune": "l1=21:5 c=8:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28], + "ciede2000": [7.836036484776895, 9.33742621760595, 26.115488216032446, 10.829708697257958, 13.735407112161253, 10.225407531196685, 14.98617832474263, 3.6874670175128683, 11.52802482720233, 12.395119424993249, 10.867481008214028, 11.711299073083923, 4.464802074126065, 12.124932704500019, 19.371727507512, 11.683932227891216, 12.768979287562482, 10.601316888462819, 19.5256548007746, 14.247650161845046, 12.827046546636389, 4.905918466748625, 13.190930908877839, 12.817409234281477, 2.5841872352289466, 14.101942925286174, 13.604668910619987, 12.663113210335148, 9.16956179460638, 11.15413791747923, 15.252353903361866], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.31865701647195, -270.1655489240902, -1229.9303011460365, -202.31265191206552, -333.7994572598597, -246.90584836065852, -460.5538139470864, -64.04751620983308, -408.9085865777307, -343.6948689509188, -272.1856823734968, -230.38886012892806, -64.22927713639595, -300.92162322087404, -877.0474215623016, -302.0889853763223, -309.41390624605845, -117.80830866785305, -735.584306958159, -697.0386517466285, -345.1510000546651, -66.84283510142268, -441.47042129843317, -259.70472931062403, -60.666201754242536, -446.2899531894916, -313.6884343156397, -388.99701849738386, -253.871594704465, -444.06430823371386, -712.9059291891737], + "butteraugli": [24.34778115977079, 27.98340583276186, 45.224700161968116, 30.766969149649174, 25.615361380897326, 22.44478834886138, 40.429003456207845, 13.255251728946519, 22.96397894116348, 46.588191251915795, 22.592172205391687, 39.65892871104239, 24.632034862239063, 22.62485714366615, 37.92879690610589, 29.66394172142451, 32.39444258877378, 50.055442899583916, 50.84871973709423, 25.835512876954798, 42.164359376823306, 16.539039210125143, 22.506158654018538, 26.509811627923913, 9.623869427768883, 46.29962346495879, 38.690846635403844, 40.187394845115676, 38.36653480087023, 39.01038412372976, 34.07547835468157], + "dssim": [0.3044221476929967, 0.3056896084901597, 0.46378564398762384, 0.16709699348478585, 0.33480814218012667, 0.23820087817771524, 0.21998959618630987, 0.08492401722620507, 0.4096860044826045, 0.25021324454632177, 0.3937815276930771, 0.2494614752440451, 0.15163969427334023, 0.25949253026519614, 0.36741371210851914, 0.197974605832627, 0.2321099257470453, 0.1431819473387022, 0.33343962538813554, 0.3685602386880751, 0.22312200099169832, 0.149043325280739, 0.29422950836080963, 0.23774331025357498, 0.11026364639855996, 0.2840733821639543, 0.23178026350856012, 0.3136529232093169, 0.22348461953124826, 0.33104492952667774, 0.3585003364333289] + } + }, + { + "label": " 32B pre-adoption L26/C9", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": " 40B pre-adoption L34/C12", + "tune": "l1=34:5 c=12:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40], + "ciede2000": [7.780173368111454, 8.99218800724775, 26.091395564557942, 9.627199923307408, 13.240938108326652, 9.755150944306733, 13.827034456788168, 3.417762325387506, 10.943834802835577, 11.839292509702565, 10.483981048659233, 10.02973254350202, 4.25296983165051, 11.527146144098198, 18.711714266893914, 11.004467120763799, 11.819299340858134, 9.932196424153108, 18.3229862693581, 14.208280875603776, 11.512268895490639, 4.2704894805327, 13.164330161298297, 12.395461931509155, 2.3459803002639354, 13.188775551476212, 12.93448131311509, 11.886649616753132, 8.072810962168658, 9.963102797693098, 14.47651121980778], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.49609818750446, -245.94769196646212, -1229.2092924872923, -134.5667568853284, -314.47624158251904, -208.30177099815927, -418.6509564406929, -63.733099120163814, -317.12167635664025, -331.34818489873504, -248.21991035006135, -153.89686646116155, -64.13497085024869, -270.1357441993337, -806.7590064014154, -266.22255472057583, -256.81957783426645, -105.31174867688165, -617.2460203196079, -694.5710381205514, -264.07083935622916, -64.5175924024121, -416.147406613112, -230.9470673466285, -58.31552695480579, -369.3428328393086, -284.83138902396377, -328.22940460780217, -201.71528306366065, -386.15291971376166, -622.1878207126383], + "butteraugli": [22.44769759374204, 24.997236962957714, 45.168339179410644, 26.302981335318066, 25.230835738683698, 21.637359324982473, 38.38470946554411, 13.0300870514112, 20.021648207843214, 42.31661387687064, 20.741176538833283, 25.753136836269377, 20.906123290847944, 22.27508622698723, 37.39579360824271, 27.884345230516345, 31.43708973835574, 46.701084139634794, 48.281851859405094, 25.80140085880073, 37.528687126324, 15.46313663538154, 21.885457886509, 25.39394394039917, 9.362945952886804, 41.40248437704497, 36.58297730637043, 34.04762074543344, 31.085153874755665, 34.79203576897492, 33.238837065664576], + "dssim": [0.30441574436955887, 0.3049485622111291, 0.46394120533906913, 0.15503856900014013, 0.33483528607614954, 0.2255567746938143, 0.2189656562484134, 0.08451225412889601, 0.4068362778997231, 0.23443670783768572, 0.3937802995523421, 0.247263985301505, 0.15183733913460556, 0.2579219732735608, 0.3652964271198431, 0.1982645518771609, 0.22919696762205755, 0.13966523252851637, 0.32994354485146193, 0.3686003668554054, 0.2230112743261647, 0.14978028674441873, 0.2937009661851716, 0.23734903876557517, 0.09864107313661785, 0.27874787304077875, 0.22977735897089563, 0.3045097796089229, 0.21887872798446167, 0.3167366338900852, 0.35958627491612216] + } + }, + { + "label": " 48B pre-adoption L42/C15", + "tune": "l1=42:5 c=15:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.559844797336946, 8.565191003238866, 26.065591574332178, 9.371149966401898, 12.831724180839934, 9.316093894107421, 13.705552539705401, 3.2545153795521684, 10.660465703848718, 10.484644157216927, 10.319057201027816, 9.473096021545649, 4.119262172113977, 11.315154388048404, 18.495757078825168, 10.528293718625248, 11.554923335562384, 9.281643151570126, 17.84416735475403, 14.232623862393758, 11.10855632075422, 4.126033426017692, 12.868649183306706, 12.135782253523558, 2.429753487550678, 12.909176465889091, 12.330635424156908, 11.598776733215423, 7.608962965991704, 9.771205837024505, 13.93257559707766], + "ssimulacra2": [-135.40315942836602, -222.75482511221242, -1227.359848964331, -128.94769298408121, -303.4578141620556, -195.24356766869573, -419.08755778111083, -62.747214740221466, -286.31055629120306, -261.39894426020624, -230.41934343845696, -145.9658738821276, -64.05865061206566, -245.93836410723645, -774.1896005644425, -214.44577017721696, -244.2272487189677, -101.33631599620344, -589.2980890394334, -692.3707804367608, -247.03671069265386, -64.36000031414886, -397.16500785763196, -215.24122538389133, -57.928297479220134, -343.9992715858446, -245.21289830682463, -308.969209125499, -183.5754126970893, -363.0627480843914, -578.1194189677007], + "butteraugli": [22.268103605828355, 24.309823504275972, 45.14523450804759, 25.384085651065835, 24.90681931781872, 21.414438313010447, 38.152453377677524, 12.973701894600879, 19.277250398159662, 30.518964220230956, 20.128454152869185, 24.856726432083224, 19.894997800937983, 21.485853898848546, 36.193875072269115, 26.320883899717135, 30.616960232969763, 43.97907198673897, 46.0822402140858, 25.741533139451718, 35.9302898935716, 15.110283285579927, 21.659299616279885, 25.2595767146661, 9.26887584481531, 39.34168334457119, 36.17742098471654, 32.670575982837995, 29.177508072682176, 35.03381268196961, 33.63753405523485], + "dssim": [0.3043913782966007, 0.3041775163847097, 0.46384050548853745, 0.15574802014020112, 0.3348580934750878, 0.22209977650980756, 0.2201818102365634, 0.0841083314508333, 0.40636202719225206, 0.2631501884125165, 0.394039012237068, 0.24644476588803177, 0.1515157243086782, 0.257049360570626, 0.3640664726741827, 0.2001821128043222, 0.22784344290869601, 0.14198661091971426, 0.32618312685182904, 0.36872873051567284, 0.2222705270975615, 0.148835669677716, 0.287056164000412, 0.23700147654786835, 0.09898162961109969, 0.2774261576252923, 0.2233278421980633, 0.3027704112968168, 0.21757184350888598, 0.3156974507033692, 0.35720221153989984] + } + }, + { + "label": " 64B pre-adoption L58/C21", + "tune": "l1=58:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64], + "ciede2000": [6.968321717089029, 8.336683721835998, 26.034741499357963, 8.445389838715977, 12.442428780167184, 8.815923440669883, 13.268847818869661, 3.13830432336292, 10.294211177376594, 9.611390003478906, 10.161774290816075, 9.214702061238519, 4.084217225433951, 11.066543513411874, 17.607444584200714, 10.006822398072352, 11.320590575681853, 8.40853339303459, 16.830163144735902, 14.231819730498437, 10.36680867965899, 3.9343042810494335, 12.405715838367614, 11.83024592559387, 2.356394482060344, 12.210839928107122, 11.82213532284355, 10.771369125284185, 7.03977222190496, 9.25765878865879, 13.57640829380411], + "ssimulacra2": [-135.73760998104717, -211.54995305313275, -1225.46403485901, -106.99788244918577, -278.5883133134847, -163.27902731681007, -366.17865575366943, -62.447980406561726, -234.59938292295317, -206.65871417383636, -219.36763703169117, -130.69885615053227, -63.92086384259869, -226.58956158684714, -677.805111886617, -191.76083569860066, -229.35161925988263, -83.42193438467183, -459.4672131147091, -672.7039851072393, -209.03602964424675, -64.25513236096839, -369.9921126384172, -198.09591936555842, -56.72359873518059, -270.6500035565657, -204.8197688893286, -251.1724013587674, -149.83505039017558, -306.1262252563928, -539.6915605904483], + "butteraugli": [20.62245141722867, 23.80356669162659, 45.10521480302268, 24.17869849948035, 24.053778893653874, 20.55257205868249, 37.36430724092506, 12.869994536965459, 18.304495534513677, 26.843286880783012, 19.57378767149063, 24.444598012082537, 19.07891243127918, 20.622555559258867, 33.67885311875478, 26.012876003393533, 30.968598225471748, 41.518992048525284, 40.784122597141376, 25.61557834025784, 33.840350120198615, 14.426867224396537, 21.630621986924115, 24.09140294514621, 8.786395151806401, 36.068740587150835, 34.620398070433765, 29.133291342609976, 27.602024522598082, 34.10499374546916, 31.559875444312272], + "dssim": [0.3043425466383769, 0.30366631545530776, 0.4636822905027457, 0.15430124010903473, 0.3349886766338819, 0.21807006905779502, 0.22351081727815014, 0.08397298728368935, 0.406039526526292, 0.241584268823285, 0.39424953419897163, 0.244186414138108, 0.15185229457994476, 0.2565206356212353, 0.36180631056056667, 0.19983362509579056, 0.22735728248406412, 0.13855221199019901, 0.32314393001633246, 0.3690145829919151, 0.22171830465352244, 0.1486344042990732, 0.27991888678925025, 0.23663483395867163, 0.09303482146905112, 0.2743201725094493, 0.22032578912663897, 0.2889491588353207, 0.21409783216389144, 0.31357233261581874, 0.35752700459129516] + } + }, + { + "label": " 80B pre-adoption L74/C27", + "tune": "l1=74:5 c=27:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [6.945152759006825, 8.152599110644534, 25.993191398975725, 8.116502006271412, 12.037108687198987, 8.646771232153524, 12.42172757392247, 2.9310349406795386, 10.216376579250667, 9.243846881489235, 10.089363548409276, 8.152433860596515, 3.780048553738523, 10.771635004288491, 17.188622531516817, 9.896951064191557, 10.823342743258202, 8.074846381762502, 15.886633815823258, 14.245895706869417, 9.720084854048798, 3.766175491032765, 12.120760432775858, 11.608412178127079, 2.3437397625067953, 11.507010192805913, 11.156092890159936, 10.299560907941345, 6.759564447126893, 9.079038863801385, 13.286767856685294], + "ssimulacra2": [-131.05770125711467, -192.52052322677156, -1222.310369507766, -94.69229302640804, -258.7205454117641, -151.6351904176746, -287.00963418179214, -62.23542642186604, -219.22663027032138, -173.98073736478398, -209.81010039403452, -95.30039023812239, -63.87449548315698, -212.5317630322653, -627.5387076914949, -181.95668074672483, -187.54250354866548, -76.07839531739376, -354.27650405253524, -641.9498642010144, -178.12484152910474, -64.22912486527949, -345.3827697175621, -160.18639691040323, -54.71189490249634, -211.18778174976921, -176.18035396506684, -201.98968333877866, -138.0406222023201, -288.5799248678231, -499.3346796307834], + "butteraugli": [18.25416639358274, 22.962198479061296, 45.05838237251168, 23.38975361040686, 23.65603207254712, 20.0095875712867, 34.00988185283559, 12.87608800558187, 17.996957017065853, 26.289063715794544, 19.440757259053452, 21.59774044055553, 18.58271941047489, 20.13918453891637, 33.50817829207816, 25.603108942697208, 28.791089867713584, 35.972488794763784, 38.82357512071608, 25.386256325002236, 31.220105273595752, 14.24341451369798, 21.464458751694128, 22.857687741949423, 8.088663288818674, 33.33761153417041, 33.07337815590021, 28.12809480391117, 27.213660498283243, 33.07433057983539, 29.63091492103492], + "dssim": [0.3042193454009895, 0.30294506789490294, 0.4633543056004092, 0.1531333377754724, 0.3352295756298215, 0.2156691336942202, 0.22009163894380257, 0.08388057159003415, 0.40577830259548775, 0.22456381169010425, 0.3940768684886653, 0.23561054379796015, 0.1517696365776961, 0.25559007872738904, 0.36030993805677725, 0.20069570948401833, 0.227025696304051, 0.1370825283557257, 0.3168012457373497, 0.36994337884064066, 0.22267578381372183, 0.14819173490612148, 0.2795941802106099, 0.23643508181866246, 0.09313612127526877, 0.2688902886209794, 0.21680741546357113, 0.28431234168290587, 0.21324617848543836, 0.31240284106273486, 0.35550725904953895] + } + }, + { + "label": " 108B pre-adoption t2 L104/C36", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.838204011948919, 7.453951149238095, 25.936442060878555, 7.6509909885936285, 11.826480822363104, 8.12615141748936, 12.081026105094894, 2.876928662854907, 9.877878054669864, 9.084124864884718, 9.9428933859377, 7.800284544757563, 3.55008584103457, 10.164507096743312, 16.75912696597293, 9.334573449232558, 10.260464448685456, 7.503126311220218, 14.984942826010485, 14.24235308587455, 9.261937419473188, 3.607147773257744, 10.812648536988199, 11.214742215887687, 2.278538801479341, 10.689375872053363, 10.391225442610422, 9.583769903817277, 6.167856564760884, 8.525121531859435, 12.528219451682357], + "ssimulacra2": [-114.09152762573112, -144.6581883165179, -1215.853628863129, -86.45848241742246, -232.1155675337531, -123.98744140954642, -245.4778366968643, -60.88755805837462, -183.54187937974552, -144.71293216318713, -171.20073235547846, -82.76924182681216, -63.62120960584241, -182.09873742103252, -555.4673853095177, -140.7158176494339, -152.87534039064298, -70.37197591203525, -274.0288630521511, -621.6478024588064, -151.04871061408974, -64.18925457786446, -298.34736083412383, -129.76403310745158, -53.02203899776018, -159.75106245074477, -139.24583182192234, -145.7357717115873, -110.21030752874384, -214.97416650141406, -396.9572256123925], + "butteraugli": [17.212233125132112, 21.777836094535086, 45.00087733367321, 22.913069538635458, 22.60197521456124, 19.66320184042147, 32.4983550887056, 12.55515388889638, 17.264707299462508, 25.878456363605817, 19.22626778469052, 20.52262147093425, 18.899334448861286, 19.364181011888377, 32.08095771313904, 24.865001951411937, 26.334524006959526, 30.9062317422942, 36.58769495802835, 25.295523910193385, 30.638005555683993, 13.798805700196093, 20.89336627306123, 22.32670184517559, 7.399951393039408, 27.94365383666377, 31.954692255311986, 24.401367443436992, 25.69085869362674, 30.005755253608253, 29.16616555102716], + "dssim": [0.30392646784169886, 0.3009004994732122, 0.46305079332625637, 0.1508728832040807, 0.33643911740234544, 0.20675386593754824, 0.22050020299104783, 0.08371212563484476, 0.4038962432872495, 0.2173198290657487, 0.3929722395642649, 0.23363345555153492, 0.15232646047586046, 0.2549091462900187, 0.35892920265385186, 0.20194855792956007, 0.22840818804389257, 0.13201894248116303, 0.31290827270790134, 0.3707170868114261, 0.22220322956264016, 0.14801545797743004, 0.27288168945024494, 0.23635601146216745, 0.08962116812744497, 0.2632653317575516, 0.21313475551929134, 0.2818344321946008, 0.2095149347129342, 0.3059050918822134, 0.35063486754681955] + } + }, + { + "label": " 161B pre-adoption t2 L156/C56", + "tune": "l1=39:5 c=14:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161, 161], + "ciede2000": [6.632127234499392, 7.096945634266849, 25.764737260299658, 7.096895254281481, 11.227296369993807, 7.436025196373566, 11.322207248348413, 2.765912901161958, 9.70699674975655, 8.382506723765578, 9.692336004749789, 7.644331370307396, 3.442324899875606, 9.750743521001217, 15.773575535582282, 8.761982423351647, 9.611624723566411, 6.655984602192135, 13.81595990114171, 14.210552765473258, 8.55385516388812, 3.5103421410046125, 10.290896583079675, 10.185083769123096, 2.2182965437268956, 10.077502960302304, 9.535550095017348, 8.582623597567013, 5.74534748971152, 7.911097612608622, 11.6386422028039], + "ssimulacra2": [-104.21207352465501, -119.39546728408246, -1199.7176151212493, -72.11135041338409, -172.80383778448584, -89.16279003103782, -179.32542405099787, -58.38634507346879, -152.6699466717278, -107.29437502673821, -137.88051429467833, -76.93887311879905, -62.63322323112584, -156.04531773007676, -408.68755814872463, -116.95661144204843, -114.88487584342582, -65.41294412020386, -189.17657319616842, -598.2011382680421, -112.70597036952825, -63.92778120768958, -250.30440314809874, -89.64208998241696, -49.48801881840245, -120.73428606236678, -106.92388363059837, -97.7714904553952, -86.51843417306605, -155.8040153078667, -268.6845663657345], + "butteraugli": [15.037289591770742, 20.4125234455969, 44.89046648306521, 21.566429408385712, 21.470777181069405, 19.14321052440276, 30.735740692733014, 12.271463116528858, 17.021493424513114, 24.670942921601675, 18.695753493956385, 19.59174695127827, 17.87917955543981, 19.19704095901243, 31.24597630240629, 24.3803080376307, 25.03473192614855, 26.575242601502215, 33.06150653744232, 25.223315241019886, 27.691780678709033, 13.41600292101748, 19.58083619048498, 21.32537959463161, 6.712857465841284, 26.684632620464455, 30.93014005735539, 23.08399406817503, 24.306441845738984, 25.54782877274253, 26.1642564034222], + "dssim": [0.30392056956692015, 0.2999444259673305, 0.46240517514459717, 0.14996882082451285, 0.33514838205980246, 0.19706160697517433, 0.22339175984797816, 0.08352601273085986, 0.403900089132056, 0.2034769956034706, 0.39243570800430644, 0.2330795260738759, 0.15273953851564964, 0.2538090980062925, 0.3557985634408045, 0.20354009129459139, 0.22648961318626587, 0.12893144624644526, 0.3043677255874482, 0.3707354763690409, 0.22329074697360357, 0.1481529386754361, 0.26900966384019687, 0.2363421211086723, 0.08454940493433716, 0.2613339490186608, 0.2060434843482894, 0.2715467464350466, 0.20535817328117167, 0.296312768373341, 0.3455131026458662] + } + }, + { + "label": " 246B pre-adoption t2 L248/C84", + "tune": "l1=62:5 c=21:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246, 246], + "ciede2000": [6.474648900909252, 6.58507703353899, 23.859805511838132, 6.611708526621019, 10.834723486806519, 6.997840957849503, 10.029701145089717, 2.72808535959433, 9.468194217511785, 7.885199145137375, 9.49096352253831, 7.386645115604871, 3.3026187938721074, 9.335859132285195, 14.498411313524707, 8.142818498005504, 9.169575771455545, 6.051486651310024, 12.60045568271308, 14.102432428263597, 8.019365474751668, 3.510753000894745, 9.861375644264646, 9.12965612299959, 2.214599908872938, 9.410269075248276, 8.920870823198651, 7.693664584074089, 5.337457203247101, 7.134375593742267, 10.8641321539329], + "ssimulacra2": [-97.51444074179801, -88.24362319561888, -859.1876044955349, -67.82528228782454, -142.2867801972529, -73.58437441792077, -95.70909897413031, -56.543322286847086, -114.92132330776218, -77.0902083729352, -110.01478173746676, -71.84353788240128, -61.37353400723009, -114.10716255038915, -247.15521245360867, -88.38221628393856, -95.78646123020928, -64.38152234561375, -114.89472844771399, -511.45325990344475, -86.99235070029209, -63.797716008265866, -181.0570001045117, -71.24217511744061, -48.89045624924779, -89.0474664996504, -83.76745289380642, -74.27091020149788, -70.60592744476662, -93.67379997297127, -181.36400136649974], + "butteraugli": [14.45131941556829, 18.987234267057655, 43.27878603566055, 20.480581319173144, 21.08526845089258, 18.265456358605547, 28.710555732505153, 11.988907554019349, 16.800788603057086, 24.37125043130614, 17.841080501461093, 19.026211779707065, 16.848267176513577, 18.44250658049239, 28.570509224354794, 23.637970882626657, 23.84344037862773, 25.882639807286306, 30.097971979443553, 24.982480270642743, 25.40278816312266, 12.85550953708316, 18.140750178777825, 19.119777054127965, 6.488378383533862, 25.847966192481778, 27.19321098333855, 21.619137855318055, 23.307027189449638, 22.94610738832087, 24.866323080962882], + "dssim": [0.3037304940036655, 0.2972586257145452, 0.45421790353865865, 0.15053511536231995, 0.3351902208503955, 0.19054747709923303, 0.22066010485612209, 0.08341902471757418, 0.40156398712984337, 0.19712501093622858, 0.3911860226841865, 0.23368506963226043, 0.153303692317023, 0.25296857074149237, 0.3514962799988972, 0.2032105036912369, 0.2277669225066689, 0.12478841091054377, 0.29520441022824995, 0.37083227589706413, 0.22638440904421825, 0.14878959390113367, 0.2646355393074906, 0.23458258980402036, 0.08384856685970576, 0.2580638090671997, 0.20483244634082126, 0.2594119559803264, 0.2020086515670627, 0.2819019073821478, 0.33869062941348327] + } + }, + { + "label": " 411B pre-adoption t2 L416/C144", + "tune": "l1=104:5 c=36:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [6.335195886124831, 6.12071800616486, 16.9768553033866, 6.004772827796782, 10.461417145996242, 6.3981928599879305, 9.091987525085438, 2.6363078395795494, 9.22111453414921, 7.175623718190869, 9.301145327383638, 7.137988711819762, 3.2064048757950725, 8.779693666315813, 13.134974910038073, 7.41628101486911, 8.589441558640864, 5.703808481865203, 11.090608005027823, 14.03112501541093, 7.2974947078074175, 3.5157335058474084, 9.400167139408145, 8.69656243162903, 2.2141469469718995, 8.914656187178492, 8.219593788673137, 6.774330261895586, 4.742074029700919, 6.528432825938707, 10.043254499229155], + "ssimulacra2": [-82.28093828834633, -69.21897758456049, -128.12701689265333, -64.2428277646066, -116.92277704066154, -64.68322641787668, -68.29889580751535, -51.26677531700528, -84.8568024407914, -65.00414623572755, -89.30389699282978, -66.54917730794409, -59.37339183006759, -84.07525419205763, -121.15834651039546, -68.5688959590776, -78.00600472880922, -64.57435274316029, -73.54529592133827, -463.20913512251263, -70.31079434872271, -63.49900107240558, -122.37643090782058, -65.36170085067593, -48.40674365207565, -75.46371673474025, -66.21268053042994, -64.46976683628253, -64.37932252928584, -70.72211366383951, -109.63976459875798], + "butteraugli": [13.644533573441572, 17.849899530237277, 29.686699039060795, 18.814887753874824, 20.554930909080614, 17.48858020833671, 25.497868112306985, 11.86916912626434, 15.537639467563318, 20.139554423993776, 16.658309949101724, 17.860425631246798, 15.659318805397703, 18.16462556305493, 24.28844426907291, 22.41350071156961, 22.383823680593093, 24.452004656571884, 25.753666198000342, 24.764724413303906, 22.29186850503898, 12.399870936419836, 17.151788414277174, 18.361015254991123, 6.048883962595826, 22.633719843519497, 24.475425330531635, 18.19155108719609, 20.488995253921022, 21.20446685313025, 23.741785527385925], + "dssim": [0.3034186735260527, 0.2940723083345199, 0.41693369812273395, 0.1484141384164222, 0.33557011655452773, 0.18243517148962934, 0.2153561261070649, 0.0830558733938147, 0.39896316378503766, 0.19317142759928463, 0.3893483648231057, 0.23489449545993096, 0.15333311276182565, 0.25048318059551955, 0.3436492297573587, 0.20613507772127032, 0.22931438499710194, 0.13161207531518349, 0.2826478015605818, 0.3721818175940339, 0.2262916568849932, 0.15072871698374818, 0.260727064698562, 0.2314849052195161, 0.08197653224904827, 0.255523875769874, 0.1981980633410116, 0.24198664099005673, 0.19512607699538392, 0.27033176155442495, 0.33025726441949554] } } ] diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder.json b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder.json index 3cd3059..702fd68 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/budget-ladder.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/cfl-range.json b/tools/comparison/results/cfl-range.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fca97bf --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/cfl-range.json @@ -0,0 +1,331 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "cfl-range", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Audit of the CfL result: a least-squares predictor whose gains are FREE cannot make the residual larger, so 'free CfL is worse than no CfL' means the signalled gain is too coarse for the alpha the data actually wants. This sweeps cfl_range (the span alpha is quantized over) against cfl_bits, all in free mode (the gains are added on top rather than paid for), so the ceiling of the idea is measured before it is rejected.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/cfl-range.json", + "configSha256": "864210a0438d2ab3346877bbd65198657ecb3b007ae366463b0d52df43198959", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B shipped (no cfl)", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl6 range0.50", + "tune": "cfl_bits=6 cfl_range=0.5", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.051076873810927, 8.996802373274656, 26.14419087905463, 10.449955034564836, 13.178058678043334, 9.947538198313703, 14.276539836353308, 3.617380596758192, 11.059960105639565, 12.082901468357358, 10.473773797787436, 10.278463046179105, 4.111857125613419, 11.8839384764716, 18.80431668951572, 10.77208443675207, 12.188216759886338, 9.901204200074472, 18.191077657260717, 14.151010287405697, 12.075811277240705, 4.4517411590120455, 13.09342648685182, 12.858156681680281, 2.303105310364665, 13.533332266463093, 12.716510328846176, 12.376930739185353, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.73701615476464], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.71617290196542, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7549492511746, -183.01567380066388, -316.4327403180625, -239.5942676517348, -449.2495127412782, -63.301873787773246, -332.7903685019995, -341.23279376372176, -252.48615816639438, -185.64183765557465, -64.05442285462144, -280.66851997090964, -826.8275607295116, -247.23922598460672, -280.5192486763354, -120.06717751260948, -644.1443991474821, -694.8980606838159, -307.18632222899396, -64.71821818240977, -414.83762424746, -257.6174755581219, -59.58346515307787, -396.23129470847454, -274.4953972044476, -374.16115187802416, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -646.7945336103237], + "butteraugli": [23.173882467335243, 27.02560129647775, 45.102084784187404, 28.295866797882336, 25.957929922960982, 22.099317192142667, 40.29812473064828, 13.151663799410278, 20.277412323402388, 44.14328774774973, 21.596479178557683, 32.34030238176029, 21.863691264489763, 22.170013063874773, 36.89620343908076, 27.129070786790482, 31.753901116815765, 46.46204134102485, 48.10444913119329, 25.76932837389424, 38.73649432414736, 15.726154041411908, 22.25618392525975, 27.161903187509903, 9.758017470341505, 45.234560527842824, 37.933561025105355, 37.53124290824172, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.20294827493526], + "dssim": [0.3042761963137395, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436856434564355, 0.1617154853272298, 0.3344209988032494, 0.24045298889530814, 0.21991794754693533, 0.08453880671316688, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24849227083024522, 0.3936550632444543, 0.2456532528396816, 0.15099171296300895, 0.2585088099089131, 0.3654215247413998, 0.2012620407742427, 0.2290992606099327, 0.14504482892506237, 0.3282250922939517, 0.3684417076377642, 0.22413507129933652, 0.14899187963958466, 0.29009374447318115, 0.238735288193469, 0.10308234310933467, 0.2812584544440796, 0.2253788083255177, 0.3047225543902461, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35956687477899374] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl6 range0.25", + "tune": "cfl_bits=6 cfl_range=0.25", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.051076873810927, 8.996802373274656, 26.147635832346328, 10.45627319650422, 13.152272030388948, 9.947538198313703, 14.162653856476807, 3.6333755777408903, 11.059960105639565, 12.067206916797048, 10.473773797787436, 10.262090122949246, 4.1146082320174004, 11.904902293908753, 18.798865879724115, 10.77208443675207, 12.194095242326412, 9.910224163443061, 18.196358128175042, 14.151010287405697, 12.0602839005724, 4.482228929271497, 13.133591387658653, 12.853151247206574, 2.294816561126641, 13.533332266463093, 12.716510328846176, 12.321566864926412, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.722009980642689], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.71617290196542, -252.4414132060964, -1230.8342663745357, -182.6833104085232, -316.94583168784027, -239.5942676517348, -449.46688564567705, -63.30132501864898, -332.7903685019995, -340.74407116765485, -252.48615816639438, -185.1325058723529, -64.04885806505771, -280.64991011280677, -826.7395146131117, -247.23922598460672, -280.641454011018, -120.02610686227058, -645.3379500402582, -694.8980606838159, -307.42149166321224, -64.69476322252171, -415.2963782757429, -257.96795411911097, -59.57352451938303, -396.23129470847454, -274.4953972044476, -374.9711127367847, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -647.0999938185474], + "butteraugli": [23.173882467335243, 27.02560129647775, 45.10619484681439, 28.287027891672285, 25.925275451103573, 22.099317192142667, 40.344538634413944, 13.155578011330043, 20.277412323402388, 44.12101137867018, 21.596479178557683, 32.339992531963425, 21.82520665182032, 22.18821562150771, 36.89995950215879, 27.129070786790482, 31.74546762931259, 46.471208117649205, 48.123696870389075, 25.76932837389424, 38.72084367251323, 15.684551918653014, 22.24434062600504, 27.164886177581838, 9.696328463519484, 45.234560527842824, 37.933561025105355, 37.489126507385784, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.17539420223426], + "dssim": [0.3042761963137395, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438784594872956, 0.16169791748980655, 0.3344171932606214, 0.24045298889530814, 0.21990542387068718, 0.08452495262930343, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24755505112145437, 0.3936550632444543, 0.24543117224567035, 0.15096426976187427, 0.2584805367068238, 0.36545986280585396, 0.2012620407742427, 0.2289907380946528, 0.14498822954715324, 0.3283181190733342, 0.3684417076377642, 0.22395893182884058, 0.1489460344819249, 0.28266481517174535, 0.23865725493403406, 0.10311040318318065, 0.2812584544440796, 0.2253788083255177, 0.3071467282550969, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35935887605369343] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl6 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=6 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.053314023780188, 8.996802373274656, 26.148573180524977, 10.460094814732388, 13.27982248335816, 9.937126718763666, 14.105532456401077, 3.6015734766029173, 11.059960105639565, 12.074788762238496, 10.467773156923698, 10.276580076303468, 4.138270307741676, 11.892014390153951, 18.803573712831763, 10.76179324887162, 12.186196009449404, 9.91901380016707, 18.193073332528524, 14.158161700724948, 12.091525243009373, 4.444711873865772, 13.092339273377808, 12.950069513863516, 2.2951709155492024, 13.533332266463093, 12.722457606379328, 12.375008527731604, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.666629226753505], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.77270833347637, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7195685552888, -182.81959577886573, -317.223620623376, -239.5992278509276, -449.14999202085164, -63.30270170731691, -332.7903685019995, -340.812281127528, -252.4694008011059, -185.17689269180687, -64.04956032230061, -281.04799500239244, -827.01080144934, -247.19926452389666, -280.45480300719976, -120.23734823872479, -644.7954977065078, -695.4841922640816, -307.70052730313154, -64.71208626202986, -414.6966699679549, -257.6238330470069, -59.56695701370248, -396.23129470847454, -273.7635164211748, -374.7768947049656, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -647.1203844267263], + "butteraugli": [23.175317698465506, 27.02560129647775, 45.10627521118712, 28.292155401911714, 26.030759091420435, 22.1051300020286, 40.32795629035181, 13.135622211247103, 20.277412323402388, 44.176869258692506, 21.62893262215573, 32.351692595883186, 21.81434871347982, 22.188481622640097, 36.91150618405461, 27.121750835932072, 31.736840201521918, 46.47902634214816, 48.148598613265584, 25.751714754281608, 38.73259185653071, 15.720546217230828, 22.29203743183591, 27.24425964241486, 9.718625946407528, 45.234560527842824, 37.933170628256796, 37.53010446186878, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.077208603920724], + "dssim": [0.3042968352009484, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438957276391934, 0.16138262285045096, 0.33447389399768557, 0.24048324784079073, 0.21990489411748926, 0.08455619907014994, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24786604628405157, 0.39362355086876727, 0.24545928034068826, 0.15099942919215037, 0.2584720348823307, 0.36545727994037974, 0.2012390770433895, 0.22904243827557708, 0.14511415813990114, 0.32836344780044924, 0.36839472390183114, 0.223937048200112, 0.1490448032402913, 0.2876102123399945, 0.23872494148247386, 0.10318370571613283, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22532136612207715, 0.3042595798601816, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.36183286744484566] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl6 range0.05", + "tune": "cfl_bits=6 cfl_range=0.05", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.0525049302881895, 8.996802373274656, 26.1475312429365, 10.613154657204769, 13.348423280683201, 9.937126718763666, 14.248653815141909, 3.6875067681995044, 11.059960105639565, 12.064736475169452, 10.47143545592275, 10.270215891642916, 4.1808163325424585, 11.878159974049552, 18.77114490006816, 10.766809897415389, 12.18574739762925, 9.964121156843786, 18.204979290812553, 14.157103606229057, 12.096145744108872, 4.462701826881914, 13.085850450940457, 13.078329898970546, 2.2951709155492024, 13.533332266463093, 12.70111317109919, 12.335989464028168, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.728401507072197], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.75184562911735, -252.4414132060964, -1230.6897469066232, -182.51645187578913, -316.1882042930103, -239.5992278509276, -449.2788901072489, -63.319756566111096, -332.7903685019995, -341.49589128791916, -252.4060039056008, -185.33285702356307, -64.05547412717922, -281.1143164031739, -829.2993985346207, -247.2063841763461, -280.8413445525507, -120.09074877872965, -645.0216668491727, -695.2998815694702, -307.6455817284122, -64.69686099385854, -415.8290890119807, -256.8411373268866, -59.56695701370248, -396.23129470847454, -274.2000075813774, -374.72590052618375, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.2973577348429], + "butteraugli": [23.172742697323752, 27.02560129647775, 45.10571712298766, 28.307476075101395, 25.921279029567604, 22.1051300020286, 40.35626591280782, 13.137652546380169, 20.277412323402388, 44.19583485591749, 21.618029117616956, 32.35096161849379, 21.76946740643707, 22.18950875582138, 36.85508433412678, 27.118300708317904, 31.74610524483994, 46.50818835466102, 48.04149292096498, 25.778285885450387, 38.74227997394345, 15.73537936277635, 22.28065014491143, 27.15615698565342, 9.718625946407528, 45.234560527842824, 37.8905351857638, 37.624138009323715, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.09424941785798], + "dssim": [0.30429090326330066, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438537210344155, 0.16263388860425626, 0.3343565223465541, 0.24048324784079073, 0.2199559077857982, 0.08447005820435755, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24872451813325197, 0.39362711017428476, 0.2456536200771406, 0.15099941169502484, 0.25850163913278557, 0.365525324021854, 0.20124919674058667, 0.2290455686033825, 0.1449374659466791, 0.3290193812072072, 0.3684486379331984, 0.22394521560321728, 0.14940644562922406, 0.28651111949338615, 0.23842940785029326, 0.10318370571613283, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22532406729592275, 0.3071067051122055, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.36002099435819634] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl8 range0.25", + "tune": "cfl_bits=8 cfl_range=0.25", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.053311669705475, 8.996802373274656, 26.147686233008645, 10.46198152557831, 13.145260495441228, 9.93611961200422, 14.128059996477743, 3.6286585095149637, 11.059960105639565, 12.06226663823837, 10.468727670160535, 10.271869322165932, 4.111153637237284, 11.900698007048996, 18.799843541004833, 10.761759983541696, 12.190878245307866, 9.910333325630889, 18.20995708242251, 14.151276240275898, 12.097824517007023, 4.446149358020069, 13.120233493402433, 12.85096378711387, 2.295692893600143, 13.533332266463093, 12.715517526044893, 12.329226980105654, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.724494311655997], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.7168089965914, -252.4414132060964, -1230.6865077033683, -182.71840613534295, -316.91980948174097, -239.61752154558928, -449.2132482040481, -63.30317611655073, -332.7903685019995, -340.9055022907454, -252.369411337967, -185.30325603604814, -64.05232759426531, -280.4514286301065, -826.7585138170525, -247.29323265273734, -280.6669639941211, -120.01905861415099, -644.8747799864409, -694.4866113759456, -307.7106518264174, -64.7163150717517, -414.94208088070536, -258.0791808453299, -59.57696967773609, -396.23129470847454, -273.98919584164685, -374.59852404755907, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -646.8379937993404], + "butteraugli": [23.17284251035287, 27.02560129647775, 45.105712613588, 28.291041186366712, 25.926000898917835, 22.101870220851527, 40.336262070457785, 13.152347838672648, 20.277412323402388, 44.1418454305591, 21.61533309609399, 32.34731199091832, 21.853431726336996, 22.17723685483932, 36.90765811291385, 27.12018555399942, 31.746583858299896, 46.478242360828084, 48.074848593470165, 25.76288566965603, 38.74258221730775, 15.722194831622303, 22.245709235921055, 27.165849945420167, 9.717352981506851, 45.234560527842824, 37.93052036764134, 37.51462231686227, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.19045896685139], + "dssim": [0.3042789170722583, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438602034653, 0.1614840081759803, 0.3344156533954913, 0.24040902966427524, 0.21989579168423895, 0.08453013323280062, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2476779121312081, 0.3936302003871355, 0.24543697760785266, 0.15096422983831442, 0.25846108010473645, 0.3654515825459195, 0.20123298563855951, 0.22900021929514947, 0.14509875928681337, 0.3286978692993535, 0.36843572628958, 0.22392949235109033, 0.14909203486737393, 0.2880969342277959, 0.2386587774964815, 0.1031851294328498, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22532189456448282, 0.3078843419347068, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35939389046065556] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl8 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=8 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34, 34], + "ciede2000": [7.052224713093557, 8.996802373274656, 26.14777157540596, 10.459509138988835, 13.278113609196629, 9.937672240933162, 14.104211844669441, 3.6016908720416048, 11.059960105639565, 12.07313778663088, 10.469313962574594, 10.26945395632347, 4.137777155267921, 11.892507365461682, 18.80120806163379, 10.760952819359122, 12.186863509649461, 9.910333325630889, 18.19467791529429, 14.158161700724948, 12.094221183372587, 4.444560043433693, 13.092339273377808, 12.950069513863516, 2.2970530431218674, 13.533332266463093, 12.715491323145232, 12.38620492144626, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.666629226753505], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.70587849922322, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7216209160379, -182.87268655392847, -317.18388410368755, -239.58496114076985, -449.34506228659654, -63.303556315078026, -332.7903685019995, -340.8446323377367, -252.36196656697416, -185.30272694118094, -64.05028804254044, -281.0574531200655, -827.0694688048993, -247.0218523589648, -280.6580492783914, -120.01905861415099, -644.5725183498032, -695.4841922640816, -307.77664757222567, -64.71784568209404, -414.6966699679549, -257.6238330470069, -59.567716095873266, -396.23129470847454, -274.2384016329337, -375.2591480667183, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -647.1203844267263], + "butteraugli": [23.172304426414048, 27.02560129647775, 45.10618942684251, 28.29429075636557, 26.03027464188105, 22.10508434121337, 40.329443084751325, 13.135968514479458, 20.277412323402388, 44.180284244464225, 21.617351184908575, 32.34787910347711, 21.797921204765586, 22.18881105608803, 36.90849890001822, 27.119424457580664, 31.7453194976174, 46.478242360828084, 48.145791942953814, 25.751714754281608, 38.74270366619338, 15.721055723366879, 22.29203743183591, 27.24425964241486, 9.71863827837584, 45.234560527842824, 37.92202101385168, 37.57149005673139, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.077208603920724], + "dssim": [0.3042950979309553, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438746601152886, 0.1613756933108707, 0.3344712303678863, 0.24045197383607586, 0.21990850805085993, 0.08455201053315903, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2478794628203429, 0.39362686800861174, 0.24562994984990866, 0.15098888289718726, 0.25848855178549346, 0.3654631441495103, 0.20124481506904712, 0.2290196524547899, 0.14509875928681337, 0.3284689428467382, 0.36839472390183114, 0.22393880154776746, 0.1490837722591099, 0.2876102123399945, 0.23872494148247386, 0.103175769061854, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22537703188807046, 0.3048530318071798, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.36183286744484566] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl10 range0.25", + "tune": "cfl_bits=10 cfl_range=0.25", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35], + "ciede2000": [7.052362709796937, 8.996802373274656, 26.147686233008645, 10.460423130102797, 13.143179123713102, 9.937523450563825, 14.12595287907952, 3.628795040183582, 11.059960105639565, 12.063027141364444, 10.46856899904369, 10.271676860220731, 4.11207288933559, 11.896245746436625, 18.80152145000194, 10.760999029631531, 12.187500689849102, 9.91121076985977, 18.214776555970136, 14.151383519463103, 12.094894331231819, 4.445935554582836, 13.120239121996779, 12.850209046870079, 2.296083074028754, 13.533332266463093, 12.715468574955956, 12.330746985269176, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.724590286361442], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.75478183042594, -252.4414132060964, -1230.6865077033683, -182.85519534573734, -316.7093993814274, -239.560823008561, -449.0604582184818, -63.305175090304715, -332.7903685019995, -340.81847507237853, -252.38845877228817, -185.31998332404015, -64.05243871112623, -280.68348763796075, -827.0011471700202, -247.107718989942, -280.749616771849, -120.03416447048039, -645.2788584659613, -694.4308032082674, -307.6858867696624, -64.71412870174453, -414.9764894625764, -258.0713782690143, -59.57520166113571, -396.23129470847454, -274.0571648301147, -374.4575855157091, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -646.8509989412297], + "butteraugli": [23.171313184182974, 27.02560129647775, 45.105712613588, 28.293192357713437, 25.92134275514523, 22.103343675273823, 40.33143762721448, 13.152193450906166, 20.277412323402388, 44.14115206667159, 21.61732771789816, 32.34756742317723, 21.85344112892297, 22.175689986773012, 36.90958238633204, 27.12056195224252, 31.747173140896212, 46.480741546478235, 48.09883497366389, 25.764459736737205, 38.74228704759929, 15.720624705824013, 22.24585213029231, 27.16549628839047, 9.718727022999545, 45.234560527842824, 37.92944610636973, 37.51280276155008, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.19156931379468], + "dssim": [0.3042880504933084, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438602034653, 0.16140714223154667, 0.33441903383049854, 0.24045186927124756, 0.2198961240715192, 0.0845358938330742, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24762243886300972, 0.393627360548182, 0.245590102704495, 0.15096265913280754, 0.25845857781418524, 0.36546261707546607, 0.20124129056186796, 0.22902793814094102, 0.1450921942659658, 0.3286568031952093, 0.36844263415970235, 0.22393114153202048, 0.1490818071151529, 0.2880997833452552, 0.23865912406037287, 0.10317108445804496, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22532962789479916, 0.307853744153895, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35932579452764524] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl10 range1.0", + "tune": "cfl_bits=10 cfl_range=1.0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35, 35], + "ciede2000": [7.052807437008589, 8.996802373274656, 26.147686233008645, 10.459887444473534, 13.14286519416283, 9.936168506007915, 14.15945726165735, 3.6291931810377522, 11.059960105639565, 12.061042072753212, 10.469092796495074, 10.274361112858656, 4.111110693725232, 11.896245746436625, 18.798751726531787, 10.762604851126271, 12.186040672534206, 9.916703244626252, 18.21235933047872, 14.151453595904648, 12.099098400028332, 4.448021276241749, 13.087755601865647, 12.985100921073789, 2.295673504998629, 13.533332266463093, 12.716671700205469, 12.320066210522533, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.723432266827393], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.72709026780996, -252.4414132060964, -1230.6865077033683, -182.8490727435859, -316.93202145879593, -239.59293252182243, -449.3696259825207, -63.3008711117418, -332.7903685019995, -340.67753433367153, -252.35388848641952, -185.33562377236643, -64.05270140028045, -280.68348763796075, -827.0398630590134, -247.35646061990593, -280.67952916734987, -120.16067967015371, -644.664225971276, -694.4415513723279, -307.7087845141416, -64.71332374549229, -414.4288125684459, -257.976779548574, -59.576871983904766, -396.23129470847454, -274.07475243816464, -374.66782704720936, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -646.6214860968666], + "butteraugli": [23.17224998021798, 27.02560129647775, 45.105712613588, 28.29455426766695, 25.927965432973636, 22.102849797307957, 40.343277492711415, 13.155219289883021, 20.277412323402388, 44.14091901118909, 21.616711113558846, 32.34778113899997, 21.853429912972175, 22.175689986773012, 36.910610592856436, 27.123319263223618, 31.74602013018725, 46.48281114994764, 48.076422538518194, 25.764469023366292, 38.742225717215426, 15.720558413734073, 22.2535825350575, 27.212081089464203, 9.717349339398842, 45.234560527842824, 37.92944451028949, 37.472167279208676, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.19083746435632], + "dssim": [0.3042931156616523, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46438602034653, 0.16137584976255992, 0.3344159164872531, 0.24046360031739628, 0.21989186390581156, 0.0845338750189577, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24764821076364324, 0.3936282334132143, 0.24541321729542748, 0.15096236714168532, 0.25845857781418524, 0.36545164647071315, 0.2012487621644236, 0.22902237357029304, 0.14509095356803386, 0.3286320627124335, 0.36844088553123056, 0.22392480480521998, 0.14908511233919564, 0.2903287830759157, 0.2386468229977557, 0.10318858599583347, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22532423460779222, 0.30705307355827893, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35932064238683614] + } + }, + { + "label": "free cfl4 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=4 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33, 33], + "ciede2000": [7.056154851984304, 8.996802373274656, 26.14594894735827, 10.456620339760203, 13.291788972358988, 9.937427811467355, 14.104378521006689, 3.6034094592305386, 11.059960105639565, 12.071754451797565, 10.471315430060939, 10.283992646989498, 4.1398931283545055, 11.891431376155358, 18.797588761781554, 10.789321543904014, 12.248667479616467, 9.923080324440086, 18.19982941570244, 14.158161700724948, 12.086626407625907, 4.449751386842544, 13.092339273377808, 12.950069513863516, 2.3269743405764993, 13.533332266463093, 12.748924145190585, 12.372853202881991, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.666629226753505], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.72332243786533, -252.4414132060964, -1231.0061105717677, -182.72203776375125, -316.60904788961517, -239.58710408018788, -449.4472935828027, -63.30865506943013, -332.7903685019995, -340.6504695184509, -252.4216448981843, -185.6187064273957, -64.0509820744036, -280.89927588761697, -827.0019353687719, -247.7905610584594, -280.7781099879006, -119.9412619392564, -645.449084020011, -695.4841922640816, -307.63164042157393, -64.72336645127461, -414.6966699679549, -257.6238330470069, -59.53408024278207, -396.23129470847454, -273.7956017149172, -373.99124947365465, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -647.1203844267263], + "butteraugli": [23.15942458442828, 27.02560129647775, 45.10592607023259, 28.290778933844773, 26.03355533870373, 22.117275902925332, 40.32948822104882, 13.136468241908725, 20.277412323402388, 44.163259127699256, 21.61964297394781, 32.34288515668519, 21.796067353271354, 22.191726857268392, 36.90202878411187, 27.09731213584188, 31.735645348229724, 46.477441972431826, 48.16745096793071, 25.751714754281608, 38.745624366166105, 15.726960358842062, 22.29203743183591, 27.24425964241486, 9.705524060483254, 45.234560527842824, 37.92361855400526, 37.5642724686966, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.077208603920724], + "dssim": [0.30430711880246564, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46437669953203875, 0.16156316539247512, 0.33448649866101754, 0.24088975880523517, 0.219915833534978, 0.08457511091076847, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2478263993098136, 0.39363053723716196, 0.24524801197407525, 0.15098601441822201, 0.2584944313038894, 0.36546310976856156, 0.20124186921615062, 0.22905580410055476, 0.14511088718380954, 0.32854076883392225, 0.36839472390183114, 0.2241498406404695, 0.14901137505761203, 0.2876102123399945, 0.23872494148247386, 0.10311454393084613, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22521352825306012, 0.3048504567248892, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.36183286744484566] + } + }, + { + "label": "t1 free cfl8 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=8 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110, 110], + "ciede2000": [6.456080737538399, 7.406141729320733, 25.936758763280242, 7.720697424745235, 11.65686194199351, 8.194886628787007, 12.166103576804206, 2.8167820513726936, 9.835861112034245, 9.153078089269146, 9.713236355024671, 7.945755622594137, 3.320334919085692, 9.975594421468786, 16.569207330815363, 9.03233971137157, 10.169637243218833, 7.249467311650745, 14.977048194120606, 14.054756117033932, 9.157437984081161, 3.543062115492081, 11.358977271151819, 11.077800035812105, 1.97585718271819, 10.940516518120177, 10.300623281631122, 9.551095870740614, 6.396827632988628, 8.522547218634148, 12.42435721648576], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.28834916976598, -141.26378717982817, -1213.15497181196, -82.4953725039131, -213.7247431038029, -119.51541803743072, -256.36384374673526, -59.62818463711778, -187.8632323369846, -157.2095042897805, -163.67402375708411, -85.55743956990096, -62.43810704570123, -176.09898665488726, -486.7100377444307, -139.56912367046468, -158.10465781044525, -68.25097277462291, -268.94011877951135, -618.7241793988709, -144.68022576197365, -64.08408703461862, -283.2765921122908, -121.6710771720098, -50.38698345061536, -167.39644324794557, -141.11609127518605, -144.35918351271357, -116.90550353876279, -211.80337272533825, -389.30102764673086], + "butteraugli": [15.347666317675879, 22.140207956557504, 44.92455738582772, 22.697967100995623, 22.287528283511815, 19.613641412900893, 33.12610374443932, 12.651253001308561, 17.36478545530412, 25.036556475868355, 19.189835101137202, 20.93284108620351, 17.568907631081945, 19.4929549736213, 31.54416271863524, 24.659152849882158, 27.657637886357634, 27.808310280394114, 36.44271856368975, 25.246429749969106, 30.345126017100586, 13.864971102633346, 20.250903729492872, 22.070445815983685, 6.70698709306632, 29.632176029877247, 31.752953810771032, 24.70881890249231, 25.720408431806362, 31.26231665184316, 27.728452679086235], + "dssim": [0.30392199346912174, 0.30068419460793383, 0.4634879507732514, 0.15295467989227013, 0.3343815702344366, 0.21011422068637592, 0.22092582299501068, 0.08353952584322916, 0.40395537662844366, 0.2297670036573607, 0.3929996590366615, 0.2340418549307708, 0.1516607920166808, 0.2551714941302129, 0.3590060574230367, 0.20441419568270608, 0.22822734042290665, 0.1349419419448783, 0.3118635576970704, 0.3695292021841211, 0.21933626184385874, 0.14788340757446794, 0.2738980102527915, 0.23746185682422954, 0.0838448481684706, 0.2655606695810029, 0.2106974905390926, 0.28117957964078466, 0.21109877166596108, 0.30299290095002684, 0.34979022874361465] + } + }, + { + "label": "t2 free cfl8 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=8 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 3, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413, 413], + "ciede2000": [5.985842584856997, 6.118094915242893, 17.683936617246882, 6.113943002245874, 10.425926085848884, 6.3841877171849895, 9.056820598512251, 2.5274425335228243, 9.193573764961503, 6.841466162371212, 9.06574728138561, 7.05013738003253, 3.0405314319265426, 8.602635233113235, 12.985832043333163, 7.0288299153403, 8.608613524460798, 5.369825254654629, 11.013210312576078, 13.660237175228781, 7.086015192136361, 3.4326270715323193, 9.147904835506356, 8.477290286781818, 1.8840657486126504, 8.97498913058221, 8.062450370998672, 6.767553474010786, 4.726244192215543, 6.535950770306044, 10.02239560680584], + "ssimulacra2": [-80.25301259378745, -69.07578593101985, -186.61966274246038, -64.3226899790144, -109.07575109830952, -64.8054047625956, -70.65581567113898, -47.68163256998238, -84.94844419339543, -64.37150059685817, -88.02029322403999, -65.48235359541758, -58.17275334645177, -80.86339214909688, -105.97966267057129, -65.19992851656554, -81.38568264909767, -64.22619344490556, -71.54958060063672, -448.53115800145656, -67.0699551776718, -62.920940405037356, -115.7953521034128, -64.63692586757205, -47.56650228427134, -76.25658587008118, -66.22168855705385, -64.49455036244285, -64.36882735428037, -71.20643020747266, -102.46099819375732], + "butteraugli": [13.246822478664091, 18.015873342202692, 31.520864158269728, 19.258460330120922, 21.268170061081936, 17.328598221349804, 25.978629214087743, 11.857212857642502, 15.140861033166772, 18.13295365661011, 16.50190605815236, 17.555935329998487, 14.756002225104263, 17.67916572736435, 24.62299129652959, 21.550455953964526, 22.480908968178984, 23.072655147089193, 25.40144501021709, 24.706603161370325, 22.81601489943373, 12.380748625851915, 16.974351015571457, 17.214466842652723, 5.838558642005484, 22.284472728239322, 24.29788189639802, 18.727099882527543, 20.060817720318557, 21.445633178419456, 23.377822831971883], + "dssim": [0.30325369121411216, 0.29329052007191236, 0.4215329417243233, 0.15095251715281227, 0.3333681762144841, 0.18501352967842716, 0.21695837863250117, 0.08199064049881111, 0.3989874076078871, 0.19124558011736564, 0.38911637055941384, 0.23123621201321037, 0.15315340925577314, 0.2507666901662773, 0.3409390133024066, 0.2080350732645702, 0.2304819919595057, 0.12573108935554056, 0.28438738096935945, 0.36940100009481985, 0.21938078847071496, 0.15059732898713357, 0.26140645477570634, 0.2304513375566561, 0.07986555167498088, 0.2551515299445808, 0.1989769966423512, 0.24481168197306896, 0.1934826820324846, 0.271294479382594, 0.3275685265250351] + } + }, + { + "label": "t3 free cfl8 range0.10", + "tune": "cfl_bits=8 cfl_range=0.1", + "tier": 4, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625, 1625], + "ciede2000": [5.889906474348042, 5.280655520916247, 10.932158352770912, 5.500216560486616, 9.663926497421254, 5.352925024078216, 6.961875613694981, 2.469672546121093, 8.604362681517221, 5.542932925793348, 8.556672681088719, 6.917247429605638, 2.969215830611524, 7.5976332507526685, 10.11062417258925, 6.293294531781501, 8.02590670750919, 4.867576181340515, 8.367908171626407, 10.996614596400471, 6.1373876688519315, 3.457774727442004, 8.233782467553192, 7.791109473396548, 1.8755921982024002, 8.140911071061497, 6.931778122857504, 5.399746378738851, 4.3559308093709115, 5.627758986277434, 8.031712975202964], + "ssimulacra2": [-73.391492031387, -64.22911460462143, -64.19055300835313, -61.38968582257718, -76.1528689472608, -63.16921001312707, -62.366350279713686, -44.845527563959905, -64.2422420328354, -61.07169348739086, -64.38945618468128, -64.46790035110394, -52.431957580089716, -64.34869070467175, -63.462195119877805, -64.214556177844, -70.2386871138167, -64.24374933018501, -61.90128019349169, -90.45835864849775, -64.22806930937921, -62.59365941292225, -68.4172454434933, -61.99135784952898, -47.132178327442176, -64.33874331681136, -64.22913577874067, -56.18311907882941, -64.1366343292249, -64.21090968918855, -63.40293737064076], + "butteraugli": [12.49140075993256, 14.554697115173333, 22.576110922037813, 13.585362342933621, 16.765946584949532, 14.169871979964904, 18.455116198758358, 11.062195133749887, 13.124197338470681, 13.236119527704275, 14.05292080784398, 17.504766393983598, 9.935114226625652, 14.403752009960465, 16.429455346982923, 17.810948501802542, 19.15312337383878, 17.052066427848555, 17.06737457984134, 20.470190312842227, 17.813828226682155, 11.370086349178555, 13.91943158601885, 11.826675866185923, 5.802528528649071, 19.66004251286996, 19.233431444028213, 12.606498530951635, 19.956073620314022, 17.51018774299513, 16.224440331655327], + "dssim": [0.30206176986384425, 0.2799544756646061, 0.33135557418464756, 0.1499584988554556, 0.3330941819335269, 0.18274598101106304, 0.20078759094212156, 0.08185677030174437, 0.38361387513709777, 0.1770755869383172, 0.37905359867690785, 0.24779902505139612, 0.15540204951628384, 0.24826689169920502, 0.30210002857063534, 0.22045496336820708, 0.24733989506098403, 0.13735369315124418, 0.24843857161092292, 0.33835035601298846, 0.22350577406017552, 0.15663938221431634, 0.2609905630116638, 0.22020555508703837, 0.07978930689215041, 0.25418444054796174, 0.19639267337264066, 0.21565475953715335, 0.1874968456330957, 0.24782975006450414, 0.26630056885277065] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/cfl.json b/tools/comparison/results/cfl.json index 397497a..59ebea3 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/cfl.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/cfl.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/combined-optimizer.json b/tools/comparison/results/combined-optimizer.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..241884c --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/combined-optimizer.json @@ -0,0 +1,422 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "combined-optimizer", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Everything this round found that pays, stacked and cross-checked. STACK = aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1; REFINE = refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1. Rejected here and not stacked: prefix narrowing (costs more than it buys, and the aspect 'gain' is a metric artifact), b_scale_from_a (+3.9%), and the pixel-SSE refinement objective (+0.3%).", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/combined-optimizer.json", + "configSha256": "3fed6c704808428ad52b0cd14db1805e30f82161eb922d49a0ed4808b65ea466", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B shipped", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28C15 stack", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L30C13 stack", + "tune": "l1=30:4 c=13:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.044418379860401, 8.91325867318813, 26.137538975154683, 10.59818349537967, 13.536035609611034, 9.903112373166527, 14.475297277557658, 3.519425254125617, 11.059089280878368, 11.602791105279174, 10.477745679189459, 10.435962578989535, 4.0849644006360775, 11.583593101086981, 18.794483224198082, 10.759948921585023, 11.983783115617465, 9.820849278156489, 18.522985481078077, 14.162125660062344, 12.068026517932749, 4.312644173086212, 13.189085030198315, 12.957161791045971, 2.327111741541153, 13.497280649960453, 12.933609361689745, 12.278311940752847, 8.413496110888214, 10.36876458236321, 14.861877623333797], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.23257957242103, -250.08734744386368, -1230.277972648811, -179.34907735757798, -320.18772687185725, -240.04119252668067, -444.37023154326437, -62.92503613451845, -332.17008415361306, -320.60542350874294, -248.91215967533697, -184.6099205453085, -64.0577731055296, -274.07390715261334, -816.4209460468595, -241.2179133430849, -267.85585031703823, -113.93901352492631, -644.935788321734, -694.5139013649272, -304.8951115490232, -64.50253246180284, -410.41894009233056, -258.1145722691232, -59.59017899544719, -388.5827947304234, -272.3392442758019, -371.52939138970976, -216.40104422282332, -415.47180470883484, -639.4051197112028], + "butteraugli": [22.55776334650632, 27.605642722543745, 45.08736356491496, 27.92621942763705, 25.694331262551373, 22.113008089165458, 39.68780149618683, 13.161462954849581, 20.344284047627166, 39.01978804496377, 21.37364050583885, 32.56131909881923, 21.832991381497806, 22.93251394664304, 37.49157099717664, 26.934546480666068, 31.592899882813715, 46.25827844581401, 46.92223048362697, 25.75908694059453, 38.12667687551734, 15.82968330057688, 22.28568436396301, 27.36938543927681, 9.776577700195283, 44.23347318102006, 37.63968400510654, 37.25059859774088, 31.591245548947132, 34.49286428235004, 33.43386250230307], + "dssim": [0.3042532292210396, 0.3047783226068803, 0.4643663855775727, 0.16415904365114536, 0.33470036797296954, 0.23983660316658134, 0.21973831315673303, 0.0844718104585449, 0.40701826719533535, 0.26893426869323067, 0.3936681416734501, 0.248070806565383, 0.15103355769702181, 0.2584911883835366, 0.3655333770886106, 0.2015125311761941, 0.2280159775797556, 0.14658906012059708, 0.32930264857170777, 0.36848956554286283, 0.22426764816583034, 0.1496914311676003, 0.2866193729420329, 0.23828422444270098, 0.10302215628306105, 0.28039183196435946, 0.22573044226401406, 0.3047634460559544, 0.21953729730671678, 0.3192254990588137, 0.3571459165930204] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L32C12 stack", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=12:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.351818806328752, 8.93490370519654, 26.140795915557504, 10.434101484098916, 13.559112773193526, 9.809049675669408, 14.398937799815393, 3.519425254125617, 10.902665843553287, 11.568460458964028, 10.48491935980954, 10.435962578989535, 4.0849644006360775, 11.588660624323792, 18.820654647578348, 10.651111950746571, 12.00056998663115, 9.950066317258702, 18.34740609588651, 14.172896550757441, 11.957132867690671, 4.312644173086212, 13.427874361672432, 12.740117971962697, 2.3144102804149087, 13.224472775329858, 12.972251863280302, 12.297890622786918, 8.11954339968586, 10.357764665709134, 14.82761097032018], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.07059122875177, -247.87802104774278, -1230.7720814906659, -162.68635088999974, -321.18570147992637, -224.69001781300966, -435.59418692834595, -62.92503613451845, -322.67944994733847, -316.743491605479, -248.97210306030246, -184.6099205453085, -64.0577731055296, -274.33460871353793, -817.6746247833337, -240.16431463048696, -267.0707823365165, -110.25253350678582, -605.2635359714791, -694.4676090601256, -302.56294449298105, -64.50253246180284, -426.8201921612268, -246.48311800730585, -60.104289353493954, -363.68648184122577, -271.6500519984429, -365.8815478016808, -200.68695937757502, -411.13941916388603, -639.0675367963654], + "butteraugli": [21.91680240052054, 27.329807028058024, 45.088350185478, 27.471838994278453, 25.847235479429457, 21.784324506096805, 39.3486616696885, 13.161462954849581, 19.822190060233304, 37.9890631500001, 21.18489864228438, 32.56131909881923, 21.832991381497806, 22.756329206003887, 37.49913065160893, 26.793937982001065, 31.336447732809763, 46.24853020732879, 45.89015444073334, 25.746200954578864, 37.702601547190625, 15.82968330057688, 22.426465224385083, 26.469033150247203, 10.41065697881911, 41.63529175061468, 37.27100280910678, 36.82475239752868, 32.265157403236806, 34.60222552995109, 34.023231081077206], + "dssim": [0.3044365715529709, 0.30488383790844154, 0.4643598589251745, 0.16123451997370508, 0.3347990373325561, 0.23429922562552385, 0.2200124896242282, 0.0844718104585449, 0.40681367479578456, 0.26684857838095444, 0.39375606775011196, 0.248070806565383, 0.15103355769702181, 0.25876945485043334, 0.36551255356549006, 0.20148081085470676, 0.2281997174533294, 0.14546511458678973, 0.32863656115777373, 0.3685098859885149, 0.2244151118103661, 0.1496914311676003, 0.29151322645816946, 0.2379850159161399, 0.09890594552805299, 0.27845443580722573, 0.22678245961520638, 0.30534408664386137, 0.2183784304796581, 0.3199902938858573, 0.35762786443378825] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L36C9 stack", + "tune": "l1=36:4 c=9:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.698587197541532, 8.879859836233335, 26.12494778898899, 10.152818462871364, 13.638407435455905, 10.004824795799893, 14.18728175041083, 3.6054718990411727, 10.833728545115246, 11.574680942384887, 10.384629403550313, 10.143692018869155, 4.075275833051137, 11.496584853162917, 18.926231676556217, 10.616606995104565, 11.999702547757193, 9.933878615425298, 18.431488118095388, 14.174012745012945, 11.811735996000774, 4.216338150657684, 13.396578360084268, 12.75817341990971, 2.3483084767764, 13.253485880738747, 13.166104056685619, 12.522312955453998, 8.004918149319407, 10.086654041544449, 15.070101507978178], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.43107569611908, -251.02255211115187, -1229.3889024959933, -131.5229359818377, -320.454345741037, -216.34149971631336, -427.00515919106397, -62.96597055893267, -310.84927951731856, -314.3267390411738, -244.31995821634507, -162.73798115803976, -63.98710110452345, -259.8783015335135, -824.7716015536554, -230.27392096432175, -266.9931655327557, -113.85167020264802, -604.9579336042327, -693.1911529498212, -285.1918383085763, -64.40200816249504, -423.75829745371834, -241.7032449896392, -60.042954971995755, -366.40833117829834, -271.238888113339, -365.90302432532474, -189.34499217529634, -381.22777573641906, -634.6559094792423], + "butteraugli": [22.0481140814094, 26.525607775454443, 45.07832899257185, 26.414228476104217, 25.815607450389916, 21.567693678405586, 38.37297001306146, 13.188321785052546, 19.634540500129606, 37.10717112673392, 20.603587628633235, 27.872606423897977, 20.768483280903894, 21.9995445997309, 37.02685624520034, 26.692088638635145, 31.340015474317173, 45.534414983768706, 45.94775521095485, 25.767888324890894, 37.77836965530688, 15.281937780376813, 22.36499070276575, 26.030303516771244, 10.399158571316372, 40.65605748411139, 37.570704763769136, 34.45069519691912, 39.55380513709613, 34.901820888151995, 33.69716806140969], + "dssim": [0.3043854153914587, 0.3047804151439578, 0.46437566097405397, 0.15915549417461367, 0.3348733643543135, 0.23273031703775876, 0.22019378353084196, 0.08440320072254731, 0.4064786123576308, 0.2648733890814837, 0.39389853637242206, 0.24762448312974333, 0.1513225318710456, 0.2575840461350102, 0.36570129486820413, 0.20178558833021798, 0.22814576409116932, 0.1472671746282539, 0.33278749441386113, 0.3685450122083006, 0.2229203923522366, 0.1496480447385285, 0.292326590560538, 0.23810255948741055, 0.09921749720982415, 0.2783171143395389, 0.2262825367793611, 0.30325308095151393, 0.21746547723381804, 0.31894071700246673, 0.3587781093678073] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L38C8 stack", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.700153115888159, 8.912595931750543, 26.12637937856586, 10.201045387696633, 13.73080779981809, 9.968457688979807, 14.147024931727477, 3.6054718990411727, 10.790437498800674, 11.445522045260418, 10.320533293396391, 10.36815346429736, 4.121941848536388, 11.60476367593855, 18.893210236426658, 10.555731957523411, 11.851489883496516, 10.211080956862661, 18.465267028309025, 14.179502347211773, 11.690812896485468, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.778973288317692, 2.351383154351986, 13.11953641581423, 13.16577096162637, 12.62432066438981, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.075649359888144], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.83776361247902, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6227877492252, -132.61464326345487, -319.369285887243, -215.15693170653594, -423.1331821366882, -62.96597055893267, -300.518292282055, -294.32721126125216, -244.86742937580027, -166.0519134467831, -63.981169388638875, -261.4704960734822, -820.8659974859756, -227.11353530376425, -244.80300052097436, -110.90917751779642, -593.9956716068152, -677.1551497509682, -274.4196752938118, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -241.12082463180616, -60.04107288806151, -349.11667130136925, -267.04295258809344, -367.32381405845905, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.9535321700258], + "butteraugli": [21.149976468695613, 25.989735467241832, 45.07985143311412, 26.387225690812887, 25.432174540381208, 21.49033616985284, 38.37897826746991, 13.188321785052546, 19.36460318984157, 36.659238743943654, 20.31371468600456, 27.796673243854325, 20.80758971269439, 21.89071352544754, 36.942437783618395, 26.74170665415075, 30.61739277370246, 45.12078185495064, 45.555821198951776, 25.647687239483286, 36.573357394503226, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 26.012735683731535, 10.42219463510112, 40.49235609902217, 37.62590765415828, 34.551997895041204, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.43343099123112], + "dssim": [0.3042885741415553, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643909211403664, 0.15946634301327278, 0.3347675736865815, 0.23594307907022755, 0.22066619605328225, 0.08440320072254731, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26165594754308796, 0.3939415860957996, 0.2500487961173269, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577282676551266, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20136652214569378, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1469262129751927, 0.33151934625458845, 0.36874801102994126, 0.22388648658521398, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23797656468577033, 0.0994303234645646, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565696878096558, 0.3056313746384203, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35492799100061434] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28C11@4 stack", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=11:4 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.284202950815209, 8.996802373274656, 26.142600953890934, 10.602700724238622, 13.601911280515433, 10.1918090070399, 14.49082344185494, 3.4027409180119386, 11.059960105639565, 12.100810577663973, 10.49475074132589, 10.342405417276723, 4.091322461068746, 11.768437299032144, 18.974381171628128, 10.77340174612915, 12.28965633105375, 10.08256624719258, 18.486216022987943, 14.17016206618184, 12.067774489234148, 4.410016675309736, 13.526918759222191, 12.7678633618728, 2.295451464524333, 13.533332266463093, 12.866408265745473, 12.347255962202452, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.457697425368092], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.23356413693034, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7330217345047, -182.5158104400258, -318.7525206246722, -241.67640739130957, -449.8156019917327, -63.31880962983854, -332.7903685019995, -344.18315566097976, -252.21112313058887, -184.99502725557386, -64.06203951803639, -283.30691404429024, -831.2562618927359, -246.83941908928932, -280.8356446134378, -121.07435194593833, -655.1067150634108, -695.0203796700769, -307.3110191473458, -64.70423074135326, -430.16752713681456, -259.2379825757732, -59.51983626267503, -396.23129470847454, -275.154968852191, -372.9842871007083, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -651.2436204696194], + "butteraugli": [23.18821370866444, 27.02560129647775, 45.10177504924415, 28.304535728685902, 26.099865225421876, 22.1348296674098, 40.50881883743755, 13.139493466660527, 20.277412323402388, 44.14196256729889, 21.603912660997782, 32.47781196639838, 21.770826922878797, 22.33720431147997, 37.07661423150996, 27.09280334430676, 31.817710628610055, 46.4411830690479, 48.01394103320499, 25.74936288347547, 38.74760527698373, 15.727255014234473, 22.31721815603996, 27.31445831775513, 9.680349229818194, 45.234560527842824, 37.95880822026527, 37.526338116442, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.01030740529447], + "dssim": [0.30429960548238577, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643631297557227, 0.16303381199687367, 0.3346566134347104, 0.2411793296327231, 0.22020770130704248, 0.08450886633801052, 0.40697665305280767, 0.25213255393549705, 0.39362880874506734, 0.24594570601160304, 0.15096758640606733, 0.258734065791959, 0.3655268378394728, 0.20127138374242104, 0.22903334584572366, 0.14686351628319888, 0.3290476445618594, 0.3685164583226237, 0.2239731508133504, 0.14992397189667744, 0.29383166341889444, 0.23819671887589705, 0.10320408269681658, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22739989074020933, 0.31050484677034607, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.359933202352269] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L26@5C9 stack", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28C15 stack hv0.3", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.3 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.292487038811993, 9.002153945224254, 26.152214872540352, 10.564375501085674, 13.31558759901147, 9.746283821867994, 14.238019863814527, 3.3861462652292293, 10.903735570622274, 11.956472702601188, 11.043413743331136, 9.996635065082883, 3.8176315172023036, 11.968746867493692, 18.701605123384486, 10.80811741173374, 12.197979300295481, 10.014985336859503, 18.391518353909692, 14.14585082172779, 12.03647402579225, 4.290735582245184, 13.135658557950947, 13.024967026835073, 2.2774318425730598, 13.999118862503442, 13.016175824932633, 12.694530786563897, 8.685260945167798, 11.235741543571685, 15.027566607273323], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.64286540902987, -249.97728273326635, -1232.2203742460235, -179.31604377074666, -322.13725517875304, -226.8836127498701, -445.44682698657755, -62.92952954636078, -324.682548854959, -343.9333966154285, -284.30782979631374, -174.21294701248286, -64.0235245272585, -289.02139895969674, -821.1420867014032, -247.4900078961963, -273.6415672911408, -112.56206850781814, -609.4398274391367, -694.4224698999983, -307.5668049262538, -64.50024108784095, -438.63827161633117, -259.61686700266534, -60.07401104195259, -409.5737101456013, -288.53380392151934, -393.4746910431841, -234.44172287970662, -460.8655874416029, -662.5803915616301], + "butteraugli": [22.638082345232466, 26.4998407409734, 45.119588869639095, 28.16501460057978, 25.658589209031884, 22.317181171590338, 40.00724863265925, 13.189059396246671, 19.971725249838652, 44.98215511071496, 23.222427628709408, 29.30836657835198, 21.6770050986417, 21.702442747042145, 38.022000397249236, 27.08457563622478, 31.345949815298326, 47.38632078173729, 46.83508295904676, 25.728399117878485, 38.272727086763076, 15.818095518640902, 22.639285494535475, 27.219911942059877, 10.413356257718158, 43.9011990146115, 38.90356979301468, 42.31781095642784, 32.17262828873833, 35.86488030404336, 33.256037132602074], + "dssim": [0.3042713332327095, 0.3049436393834868, 0.46440227212785934, 0.16342170271377204, 0.33445969968032074, 0.23469298637381902, 0.21957687835355927, 0.08437551351771705, 0.4067106243515058, 0.24652033869253914, 0.3943439101585547, 0.24777939604411497, 0.15095172939908058, 0.25873913842943175, 0.3656208945909366, 0.20123385172995306, 0.22882764092002145, 0.14406696655858836, 0.3280688263013877, 0.36832486691102373, 0.22396952307731932, 0.14922448939808913, 0.2903939113395255, 0.23847104447578277, 0.09920757812967484, 0.28077233286889036, 0.22892179706211002, 0.302430180360459, 0.220534831937511, 0.3265495788011531, 0.35783874781816216] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28C15 stack aniso1.6", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.6 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.046345047740214, 9.116843133235143, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.255046647054833, 9.90850381919552, 14.2009444006856, 3.4418442303559216, 11.059960105639565, 11.710304821033601, 10.49513185513634, 10.019866691415288, 3.8171522473827135, 11.712863530551717, 18.564702329282238, 10.768917701096987, 12.259852885443369, 9.97159173318088, 18.39977556119487, 14.160495266509384, 12.081180649743773, 4.432622844075262, 12.954947783688272, 13.023357473050764, 2.3035769614931665, 13.826531774016978, 12.978665597074025, 12.64257209731079, 8.465540272078814, 11.236218710016127, 14.880792090580005], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.12644520908952, -254.9730643277028, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -315.48732321602364, -239.53924616707172, -446.74633656481103, -63.27000252140948, -332.7903685019995, -319.8184297028573, -251.3390137621264, -182.45763790431005, -64.0254179088933, -274.6168105177787, -821.9617365309482, -244.59777139509288, -280.2635003691952, -120.35829542646186, -648.1874915078271, -694.7992077608329, -307.3304852702049, -64.70038483525613, -414.7693409270188, -255.89579341174505, -59.47078286911474, -401.5094446056559, -273.8801271243618, -386.4110285946223, -213.27123521516648, -457.41083205559937, -650.3149125612425], + "butteraugli": [22.792239910702776, 26.99800372888556, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 26.35058047717337, 22.11840806282835, 40.0798550120567, 13.131618883289454, 20.277412323402388, 39.56829730856339, 22.07715951636746, 32.23191664827758, 21.613353646031964, 22.832696165134802, 37.51382990389175, 26.964096803605447, 31.580408529974658, 46.39825879207149, 47.94569883743139, 25.756871438438225, 38.72876156829949, 15.72818507821808, 22.250797006079342, 27.36751446489015, 9.708979997840828, 42.72106537875601, 37.994986748454515, 42.53022125426627, 31.494453543021166, 35.90086003984127, 35.16160441001153], + "dssim": [0.30428479278587883, 0.3054705746981312, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.3343900988664327, 0.2409117260789016, 0.2201143485377206, 0.08445754433283642, 0.40697665305280767, 0.26819757502891495, 0.393638989097161, 0.2455930370141693, 0.15092447290397243, 0.2582567522780822, 0.36535424137017347, 0.20157425813942514, 0.22920788530382968, 0.14713646186182455, 0.3292182226978082, 0.36845064225418456, 0.22409215051012593, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2877941043862601, 0.23842808730654202, 0.10268615428453076, 0.28005479068683237, 0.22425455619538726, 0.30206673416354546, 0.2190437586520111, 0.32695720176731624, 0.35793194880355905] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L28C15 stack+REFINE", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.558309571978771, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.206365471779776, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773480133975156, 12.223455143955883, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -181.9651698067978, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.6962479308229, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -255.04990916249488, -371.2741049854743, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.35534338089487, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.529038584882095, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 38.00188942207895, 41.17884694746785, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.1669974774636211, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32788568545087127, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22368653630105628, 0.3022322301786785, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "32B L32C12 stack+REFINE", + "tune": "l1=32:4 c=12:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.388074948001631, 8.93490370519654, 26.21160170808296, 10.563193943900167, 13.552791798338639, 9.88016224213812, 14.236551339016218, 3.519425254125617, 10.848652800838831, 11.479544989351394, 10.480175642330744, 10.460036899687847, 4.104899778803035, 11.678989878832626, 18.820654647578348, 10.653722545769913, 12.00056998663115, 10.109313992724394, 18.190028414991477, 13.994524313883026, 11.957132867690671, 4.165574144767939, 13.425133783574227, 12.740117971962697, 2.242093971674549, 13.343261985440282, 12.85724522615883, 12.118837442441142, 7.927054360835022, 10.357764665709134, 14.669230923249406], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.23138722954985, -247.87802104774278, -1227.4583258436123, -161.7713694654757, -321.4427001599015, -223.0440704165826, -435.37727982560557, -62.92503613451845, -322.5332874289165, -304.4108587474705, -247.65968902356144, -178.95198232460837, -64.08456474411508, -274.1298777729748, -817.6746247833337, -240.34657712441054, -267.0707823365165, -110.69461623206408, -598.6756919861875, -692.0896526916998, -302.56294449298105, -64.51241441046432, -426.0481597605302, -246.48311800730585, -60.048098181753346, -361.75406891887064, -258.4433376386414, -370.21906321660913, -195.5151742074886, -411.13941916388603, -633.9308893918217], + "butteraugli": [21.774024367839598, 27.329807028058024, 44.72150446474715, 27.686058961822027, 25.843400304807204, 21.831473370991706, 39.136529045079335, 13.161462954849581, 19.92088519867083, 36.5011877984079, 21.241750636274226, 34.79310591159663, 21.811345991768984, 22.772502478831935, 37.49913065160893, 26.807080349561534, 31.336447732809763, 45.59754188519997, 46.27014662054038, 25.922695182150534, 37.702601547190625, 15.878333441592119, 22.426712407742084, 26.469033150247203, 10.406154187069454, 41.361117129125894, 37.259013877977104, 37.25471311914788, 30.766697583597097, 34.60222552995109, 33.04781866559693], + "dssim": [0.3044601026950904, 0.30488383790844154, 0.46494504622428456, 0.16190149234372703, 0.33484810997665493, 0.23662555746820252, 0.21992954684742866, 0.0844718104585449, 0.40685215162664384, 0.27429195706827236, 0.3938201067932627, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15111958208715048, 0.2583078372160932, 0.36551255356549006, 0.20154450199186152, 0.2281997174533294, 0.1481364155119243, 0.3291216862877788, 0.3682567963238679, 0.2244151118103661, 0.14992854491003432, 0.29211222047682783, 0.2379850159161399, 0.09917062858464015, 0.27872420834738376, 0.22787649067989152, 0.3066147747178676, 0.21774431464842436, 0.3199902938858573, 0.35673486449437974] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L19C6 stack", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.776014504486732, 9.396455198920494, 26.166661623361254, 11.221954341669583, 13.95935092652041, 10.51263390369127, 14.916407602047487, 3.8956262618359196, 11.414922133693548, 12.651849994951462, 11.280522373086745, 10.92419901754221, 4.210537019106085, 12.723082330046312, 19.515021380252122, 11.411808282920534, 12.980793774753181, 11.721124632468488, 19.16887296175175, 14.210460951578916, 12.905414935773846, 4.781214648718981, 13.621276853624158, 13.086598506480753, 2.386244763017709, 14.32773465991485, 13.901584414941468, 13.747882789270575, 10.268129218833149, 11.60918139311934, 15.849270243373518], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.98065393566714, -273.3346190723461, -1232.7515999669945, -210.38248116946244, -326.4389073148647, -271.0954016250367, -465.43475675081675, -63.873318003379154, -396.1797420625749, -342.17118679804344, -311.0611128148512, -179.91249752799627, -64.13935327766467, -321.2804659488522, -884.5640563159362, -297.4355312798491, -317.83841509974167, -131.20218775242935, -689.4555510513823, -695.7235661408508, -339.2772453636585, -66.21941947854003, -454.03664154043634, -261.7436777424757, -59.916976573444, -461.87966240365927, -314.08946465501907, -424.2393490453853, -295.2635289812059, -489.14845117356526, -720.2610790596225], + "butteraugli": [25.013198327113415, 27.42705783248822, 45.14939604859702, 31.109843559658184, 25.84659700121607, 23.93882741334745, 41.120903626711645, 13.322643772203955, 22.87931819695711, 46.90301206420071, 25.455376447542125, 28.593152971641327, 22.70702450928349, 23.205988947378007, 37.76986444203275, 29.39043402487221, 31.71020238092608, 52.121130912660725, 49.89983413872886, 25.73022245984102, 40.944595458000514, 16.724683937220053, 22.640075632788996, 26.78062444165941, 10.101199780935383, 48.69999843165882, 40.4459369265887, 44.646248671903855, 39.260928455347134, 37.745064559234386, 35.077604609532], + "dssim": [0.3044273498619994, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46448791381267424, 0.16698112678195137, 0.3344582249611492, 0.24863070490083183, 0.2211568959477111, 0.08464748674739392, 0.4087523843747863, 0.25426033824986705, 0.3944772259450307, 0.2513307099814748, 0.15150094593172286, 0.2600049455792901, 0.3678216571540833, 0.1975533551256759, 0.23266201524735813, 0.1523964025012195, 0.33662283088673084, 0.36860540886260296, 0.2245223369436235, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2922778060441086, 0.23787318026562737, 0.10280053230244252, 0.2833021212837312, 0.23307999008545838, 0.31270891298436443, 0.22694115016689026, 0.3321907993520228, 0.35709603108854004] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L19C6 stack+REFINE", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.792846930155082, 9.396455198920494, 26.235226893874348, 11.25661815908648, 13.978690046496917, 10.487700305227822, 14.760773407035382, 3.8884989501614706, 11.451092745364463, 12.651253891171555, 11.280522373086745, 11.01528513365364, 4.227445691832899, 12.83921931611817, 19.515021380252122, 11.41382100152873, 12.980793774753181, 11.52075275566944, 19.177449694593832, 14.028799204626814, 12.905414935773846, 4.660977149480652, 13.621276853624158, 13.14831305470237, 2.3079957471741417, 14.438752381368197, 13.761528692486234, 13.351616987376687, 9.871439305903655, 11.60918139311934, 15.752443936583113], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.3540001913075, -273.3346190723461, -1229.089837769759, -210.70948351594473, -326.6414038811866, -269.5594071042897, -462.9366829661268, -63.87842339435221, -393.36279709451856, -343.7167657074545, -311.0611128148512, -179.32975861015996, -64.13670680964205, -321.30879449777467, -884.5640563159362, -298.5615991148328, -317.83841509974167, -128.36621081189884, -691.8744019763224, -694.7315787273545, -339.2772453636585, -66.25900067354081, -454.03664154043634, -264.500756860976, -59.932617430362654, -464.24165385170704, -318.722841981095, -426.23519485175984, -285.9512775538033, -489.14845117356526, -719.8366875243023], + "butteraugli": [24.85058786332611, 27.42705783248822, 44.769526153494866, 31.414884683279563, 25.879575401323297, 23.9395441714927, 41.240445314101926, 13.29642223104881, 22.487499959477294, 46.59274494913893, 25.455376447542125, 28.5549817187454, 22.691181283880198, 23.187153692174974, 37.76986444203275, 29.432230605368403, 31.71020238092608, 52.07281625309016, 49.996691545851924, 25.926799814845108, 40.944595458000514, 16.626443562697514, 22.640075632788996, 27.239091646282514, 10.126144632746572, 47.678045730067076, 40.54379814923127, 45.589939848696396, 41.66402457761015, 37.745064559234386, 34.686196078776135], + "dssim": [0.304444234581178, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46507083613007144, 0.16781043524160472, 0.3345233283664386, 0.2521258031300545, 0.22008890678178972, 0.08465675636494024, 0.40886444999128296, 0.25417041320494327, 0.3944772259450307, 0.25307025208361467, 0.15157977303784276, 0.259523613474376, 0.3678216571540833, 0.19758406580476823, 0.23266201524735813, 0.15255063611736114, 0.33664924146241637, 0.3683794330926864, 0.2245223369436235, 0.15013570296147555, 0.2922778060441086, 0.23818787529692687, 0.10282856854279249, 0.28281534959196797, 0.23712890898309752, 0.30836996003678385, 0.2259852015643124, 0.3321907993520228, 0.35185822967565483] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L22C8@3 stack", + "tune": "l1=22:3 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.763696691839447, 9.554230489335177, 26.173548331317406, 11.354118301517897, 14.050865794487542, 10.726228229753026, 14.981750389233445, 3.896653096139193, 11.410127683370318, 12.493150353329353, 11.217929690477442, 11.534130470763698, 4.2100954014222784, 12.372145621945904, 19.230712976995385, 11.53204816648899, 13.294413028011565, 11.461504409801016, 19.431457411028465, 14.2290160327786, 12.749445793103618, 5.048202224259061, 13.517619104490384, 13.273832611548059, 2.570733695759069, 14.406123007970894, 13.762837225290237, 13.616657674337183, 10.535777825712687, 11.663729977065707, 15.85243093290966], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.84542621919078, -269.24627005930813, -1233.1968671379427, -209.16063843158088, -337.36378459701916, -274.6070479571799, -461.9654829851588, -63.62661914412598, -381.59911472970185, -367.5183840117689, -297.78197060822936, -197.02275738960157, -64.09330453055298, -309.2053888753993, -855.615537617058, -294.461430435694, -328.5961769185234, -157.6094568218324, -704.766007404117, -698.4935775091535, -314.5666244831711, -64.93856138318512, -447.5514326605153, -271.5662434045993, -60.9771012876611, -456.38742237696897, -317.40245871255024, -418.74930708310774, -296.150345580847, -494.1930333780234, -692.7122786451458], + "butteraugli": [24.316961172307305, 26.716096996240747, 45.14448148022766, 29.54435120392098, 27.379896776215883, 24.199594046480186, 41.449555935884, 13.836008264779588, 23.558550517949744, 46.53709695886377, 24.439470044847315, 32.624264652920736, 23.285875310267652, 23.190761160002264, 39.478869370312715, 30.00912787129032, 37.43512946253213, 51.480832867587644, 48.720226543687865, 25.831986487289573, 40.52668882047677, 16.603445785491036, 22.71940828276692, 27.628493479240205, 10.336874044401142, 46.76194233820937, 44.99505261150734, 42.76378616970202, 45.58290046480638, 37.11837950920804, 33.22107778365365], + "dssim": [0.3044090711618611, 0.3064419914144787, 0.4646259465489404, 0.1681437588123152, 0.3348530154510728, 0.24700681641702632, 0.22140276031561779, 0.08473970818295934, 0.4086045197575639, 0.24691675782719208, 0.39437800802483575, 0.2544362037943736, 0.15113118239659934, 0.2621581582057695, 0.36657800237945415, 0.20066031990211047, 0.23240037323931229, 0.15628850206261075, 0.34510698267141704, 0.36860086717616414, 0.22181096023499924, 0.15233693502596507, 0.29223524674540113, 0.23885678175226904, 0.10535016658375596, 0.28309098985927295, 0.2338477217054386, 0.31504262104454794, 0.22500124674415112, 0.32696498944819397, 0.3586125188105044] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L22C8 stack+REFINE", + "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.7251316307054685, 9.247477998357889, 26.231003434174053, 11.097912828695204, 13.908048248781165, 10.429543149176181, 14.560966553784885, 3.6429690903335565, 11.387027626200526, 12.497041215106426, 11.09121129168755, 11.078434019827265, 4.133739045796729, 12.360657858289384, 19.125845220249037, 11.143344659563022, 12.700906052156677, 10.925167606126537, 18.878908615167173, 14.022694101520182, 12.387350361602309, 4.342527272024155, 13.483360181419831, 13.047325851019718, 2.279280700858154, 14.164318852356041, 13.339781870811795, 12.929914775913199, 9.524648889361929, 11.440566581050144, 15.460893277106463], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.3885605947175, -262.3742017850659, -1229.531132666126, -196.81313946487887, -325.9100827593933, -267.1803955401939, -455.570778456149, -63.42285291695734, -384.4307507602948, -354.2495863381697, -293.5077515430936, -184.55909041043031, -64.06568847444774, -306.7528397265459, -854.6341049141689, -285.5447080395379, -306.86577804851083, -127.03546727807253, -661.1001791580333, -694.3283495256816, -313.6280659412106, -64.71345277484406, -445.0155826919121, -259.96730881203297, -59.49586562656498, -439.04365028694065, -298.21047852768487, -415.8631329950864, -257.80803975644505, -480.6104553675859, -686.0655622779077], + "butteraugli": [23.259209915318852, 26.46271346006495, 44.75818254686243, 29.0738692181631, 25.965682417292726, 23.84960055855771, 41.48347503064196, 13.396456640962237, 22.05106536499487, 45.50400226940942, 23.859146054177305, 29.986804768850664, 22.62878954543868, 22.638724071100523, 38.40131499050958, 29.15797977869862, 31.498606576986305, 52.60619594444299, 48.49290377677219, 25.92081063562149, 39.10734855849536, 16.096002621842715, 22.610891046922017, 27.457379357178045, 9.8131151369583, 46.8218679948842, 41.3650788633585, 41.20997063186821, 43.585875172876115, 36.548554296380956, 33.35646401628431], + "dssim": [0.3044047199489579, 0.3057870836292863, 0.46509818516575396, 0.16692327801262513, 0.3347281505197446, 0.24985491652626451, 0.22033708187080842, 0.08449133387589258, 0.40846462654640975, 0.25561976033198774, 0.39436798340411144, 0.2559939761328477, 0.15116176666922848, 0.2591422291752601, 0.3665386466748883, 0.19768548752199733, 0.23059688926157446, 0.148189865513203, 0.33150567092564054, 0.3682840810810951, 0.22379184142967828, 0.15006341493741354, 0.2925809342324056, 0.2381466177785463, 0.10348057562760454, 0.28262315476030886, 0.23007727461122385, 0.305885503237041, 0.223067904754928, 0.32730382223558396, 0.35254021824453585] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B t1 base", + "tune": null, + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.460348627730683, 7.406141729320733, 25.93828271794926, 7.721771907969617, 11.611603234963079, 8.19222384581283, 12.128587206342123, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.179432134465637, 9.721910522905754, 7.946309156635416, 3.310746104779896, 10.00818452008688, 16.513662005282484, 9.056320549141937, 10.168976542833649, 7.326874893788768, 14.99276434239793, 14.051518862761734, 9.169833930389713, 3.5437465236315893, 11.343223535649768, 11.08853353981668, 1.9713466057781046, 10.940516518120177, 10.338508532607511, 9.552798757455742, 6.396827632988628, 8.522547218634148, 12.460331691337952], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.39038246477116, -141.26378717982817, -1213.3990210035383, -82.5124310139935, -213.57867395975074, -119.76020416431749, -255.95306934416647, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -156.6067020667124, -163.78643714164008, -85.55060841086765, -62.42178515044719, -176.03451197457963, -486.52996913469497, -139.47205802885406, -158.18575121654806, -68.16309306141989, -268.88217550110573, -618.1881335365836, -144.62207681711635, -64.08167150561934, -285.0746616004951, -122.11403504620318, -50.47071656960571, -167.39644324794557, -141.05986535569016, -144.67825707242122, -116.90550353876279, -211.80337272533825, -389.0563602153415], + "butteraugli": [15.363000088053326, 22.140207956557504, 44.92674237052605, 22.696167708264568, 22.273135801923193, 19.632497071497465, 33.15047179702949, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.041794385975574, 19.192371669075044, 20.927786916688547, 17.531124819288, 19.49442349952079, 31.521336640512022, 24.658012719014184, 27.66218275167182, 27.79236566090094, 36.44058949370932, 25.237605376728098, 30.35621426147402, 13.869843320365979, 20.281816826239517, 22.0380043904314, 6.692810449981778, 29.632176029877247, 31.74211558873468, 24.71893925917175, 25.720408431806362, 31.26231665184316, 27.724991890155156], + "dssim": [0.3039300594656206, 0.30068419460793383, 0.4634857347467497, 0.15308817799474772, 0.3343923236319388, 0.21053570220492518, 0.22062410242981606, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.22994482425786006, 0.39301903391134946, 0.23415739304865568, 0.15164999540525853, 0.2549507711927276, 0.35907464012548085, 0.20450477236964515, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13511731347751277, 0.31148824553831755, 0.3694858967196917, 0.21939815959732606, 0.14802542771952226, 0.2763480074974578, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0837189415281478, 0.2655606695810029, 0.21077065007893175, 0.28133726607274145, 0.21109877166596108, 0.30299290095002684, 0.35096109481830406] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B t1 stack", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.460348627730683, 7.406141729320733, 25.93828271794926, 7.721771907969617, 11.611603234963079, 8.19222384581283, 12.128587206342123, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.179432134465637, 9.721910522905754, 7.946309156635416, 3.310746104779896, 10.00818452008688, 16.513662005282484, 9.056320549141937, 10.168976542833649, 7.326874893788768, 14.99276434239793, 14.051518862761734, 9.169833930389713, 3.5437465236315893, 11.343223535649768, 11.08853353981668, 1.9713466057781046, 10.940516518120177, 10.338508532607511, 9.552798757455742, 6.396827632988628, 8.522547218634148, 12.460331691337952], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.39038246477116, -141.26378717982817, -1213.3990210035383, -82.5124310139935, -213.57867395975074, -119.76020416431749, -255.95306934416647, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -156.6067020667124, -163.78643714164008, -85.55060841086765, -62.42178515044719, -176.03451197457963, -486.52996913469497, -139.47205802885406, -158.18575121654806, -68.16309306141989, -268.88217550110573, -618.1881335365836, -144.62207681711635, -64.08167150561934, -285.0746616004951, -122.11403504620318, -50.47071656960571, -167.39644324794557, -141.05986535569016, -144.67825707242122, -116.90550353876279, -211.80337272533825, -389.0563602153415], + "butteraugli": [15.363000088053326, 22.140207956557504, 44.92674237052605, 22.696167708264568, 22.273135801923193, 19.632497071497465, 33.15047179702949, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.041794385975574, 19.192371669075044, 20.927786916688547, 17.531124819288, 19.49442349952079, 31.521336640512022, 24.658012719014184, 27.66218275167182, 27.79236566090094, 36.44058949370932, 25.237605376728098, 30.35621426147402, 13.869843320365979, 20.281816826239517, 22.0380043904314, 6.692810449981778, 29.632176029877247, 31.74211558873468, 24.71893925917175, 25.720408431806362, 31.26231665184316, 27.724991890155156], + "dssim": [0.3039300594656206, 0.30068419460793383, 0.4634857347467497, 0.15308817799474772, 0.3343923236319388, 0.21053570220492518, 0.22062410242981606, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.22994482425786006, 0.39301903391134946, 0.23415739304865568, 0.15164999540525853, 0.2549507711927276, 0.35907464012548085, 0.20450477236964515, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13511731347751277, 0.31148824553831755, 0.3694858967196917, 0.21939815959732606, 0.14802542771952226, 0.2763480074974578, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0837189415281478, 0.2655606695810029, 0.21077065007893175, 0.28133726607274145, 0.21109877166596108, 0.30299290095002684, 0.35096109481830406] + } + }, + { + "label": "108B t1 stack+REFINE", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.490426552561483, 7.4032697996829695, 26.009124194616195, 7.743375774427395, 11.554256282298494, 8.254259047379586, 12.008290546606965, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.068813482108, 9.720819520300774, 7.835366504693131, 3.301556052255819, 10.032664042054547, 16.515708543308182, 9.057836032474023, 10.168976542833649, 7.171197133063761, 14.771506685549486, 13.884763671832369, 9.117590471887624, 3.416535623481274, 11.439363222874363, 11.08853353981668, 1.9330477505713197, 10.960741186721064, 10.25258097653761, 9.013516051316696, 6.328530433781551, 8.51789134624504, 12.44152642151391], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.50766516819073, -140.8324469354293, -1209.7740923833335, -82.44569933375433, -213.14221613109117, -119.55614419514393, -250.70444245749394, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -154.36184566409332, -164.24029067733284, -85.5397999161741, -62.471635081182, -175.86532897013842, -487.57342852923034, -138.5258250551578, -158.18575121654806, -68.05817660177794, -260.35964613821795, -617.1038743723352, -142.72362848325076, -64.08408209817341, -286.46955781280076, -122.11403504620318, -50.18230300251054, -164.77057318669097, -140.8978104883565, -141.592787751122, -111.54729076981948, -211.6660307978093, -382.55849901548766], + "butteraugli": [15.288481761624771, 22.20364799543552, 44.580726769966255, 22.60552433285285, 22.33355197347163, 19.57480750984485, 32.96516372712967, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.443661770349905, 19.164471694415493, 20.928114254831318, 17.583508384398442, 19.484904597422943, 31.538623133130482, 24.673451150475557, 27.66218275167182, 28.178881947581402, 36.01148134138281, 25.29658105184117, 29.907365383474627, 13.86284620197871, 20.345795129627565, 22.0380043904314, 7.015281176388091, 29.69585605420387, 32.092737547466335, 25.060379770769202, 26.484526943864356, 31.284874150602878, 27.872122700344892], + "dssim": [0.3039158645525698, 0.3006571783348979, 0.46414111382940265, 0.15418418713157706, 0.334402310304592, 0.2138145195578352, 0.2208915664435947, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.23416148774929252, 0.39299055115773424, 0.23428629906193638, 0.15172534534330356, 0.2554920095322878, 0.3589809528006107, 0.204512335973894, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13780745681635193, 0.31101074440203214, 0.36927820324003136, 0.21901941000179553, 0.1479759055287952, 0.270744700953399, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0840072705010424, 0.2663679154628683, 0.21049462874402353, 0.27176575156034566, 0.20938899173311099, 0.3033286798614142, 0.3506716944150138] + } + }, + { + "label": "411B t2 stack", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 3, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [5.992568117849593, 6.118094915242893, 17.683609567003014, 6.164949519494134, 10.387323247493386, 6.418941273925112, 9.061010218358545, 2.574122718692297, 9.193573764961503, 6.848408241521188, 9.076892476950947, 7.133046472462339, 3.019723944106072, 8.706353407158554, 12.996584622500379, 7.060656042217775, 8.568213801224148, 5.333490327268093, 11.050417517495664, 13.671486987140867, 7.083254699947777, 3.450658506047531, 9.281816312136947, 8.573664254406916, 1.8836329053651748, 8.97498913058221, 8.13169915577608, 6.8835165320569, 4.726244192215543, 6.535950770306044, 10.092334543815866], + "ssimulacra2": [-80.21168281657881, -69.07578593101985, -186.60102968153205, -64.32464225281717, -109.212403903813, -64.80534338488465, -70.74609618949253, -47.82855118876961, -84.94844419339543, -64.37216398685166, -88.04234274821806, -65.48358431996886, -58.189890999520514, -80.9350610288507, -105.62334036319095, -65.20327597358954, -81.29559277251727, -64.22610552874056, -71.5157295141394, -448.33089884977494, -67.06178589447256, -62.934608710595626, -116.70165259085533, -64.64710406138298, -47.5947441633987, -76.25658587008118, -66.24281912483269, -64.49901851800462, -64.36882735428037, -71.20643020747266, -102.37798105552315], + "butteraugli": [13.24147739891796, 18.015873342202692, 31.52152789540297, 19.262350597957138, 21.21737899702937, 17.32545402489334, 25.998306273225534, 11.824349247770229, 15.140861033166772, 18.14324406839519, 16.508107060172588, 17.556291018915232, 14.76926452305672, 17.694307020978652, 24.62186702132046, 21.553037985442174, 22.47182868443792, 23.1265750983011, 25.396075782538052, 24.713759990819344, 22.812207137826945, 12.408636472662508, 16.989954766503995, 17.19739613840439, 5.8377909642816626, 22.284472728239322, 24.29372525356037, 18.745521005011355, 20.060817720318557, 21.445633178419456, 23.365508052094402], + "dssim": [0.303280176049194, 0.29329052007191236, 0.4215395212730095, 0.15072213895174835, 0.33346307458702223, 0.18469270971924728, 0.21690232276610227, 0.08210026250389113, 0.3989874076078871, 0.19179020026499266, 0.38916061127939156, 0.231373051680636, 0.15312284496676587, 0.25105291470980584, 0.3412780288809618, 0.20800646928200073, 0.23049535060025123, 0.12575519383608685, 0.28527390867126756, 0.3694867068986336, 0.21939078767321146, 0.15083818202019672, 0.26111899437910113, 0.23038660364127156, 0.07984276737898627, 0.2551515299445808, 0.19896198450305164, 0.24667043477992007, 0.1934826820324846, 0.271294479382594, 0.32819189002310367] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-alpha.json b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-alpha.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6bf1345 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-alpha.json @@ -0,0 +1,438 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "compact-tier-alpha", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "SS11.10 - the alpha-mode row of the 21-byte compact tier, re-measured after SS11.3 found the alpha channel badly starved. The first pass held the alpha AC count at the shipped 5 and was therefore measuring the wrong question. Alpha mode spends 9 extra prefix bits, so the opaque compact layouts do not fit: the same coefficient counts cost 25 bytes. Budget is 161-168 bits = 54 prefix + 9 alpha DC/scale + L*lb + 2*C*cb + A*ab.", + "corpus": "alpha", + "backdrops": "white-black-grey", + "alphaFidelity": true, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": 21, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/compact-tier-alpha.json", + "configSha256": "a847b72d9a4b0b16e960fde637b8aeb39e5deaec419aae062b40dae51b832522", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-greek", + "sha256": "28b9e4888cdcbfa13cafbb1b56d0ee1f515756b99b8f7ecc00a544ecaa85dc7c" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-3d-star-soviet", + "sha256": "89e2d3f669b448c56e47a9c29de65121c60a3d9e9910c95499f0233817074d94" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", + "sha256": "559304d1f8226cfafa4de7685601a3d5dd0673e93365b7b8dc9093a2112849a9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-broccoli", + "sha256": "e7f19280e60b7f164bd53e68134040fa97c3efb539ff44edf2d985ccb3a48f8f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-cheeseburger", + "sha256": "cff8d8ac543defb51454a96a1513dafb43457a569f487030380128b76cfa760a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-dod-seal", + "sha256": "8a67df69e07c9e342bd9d7ac677e6a962ac0a39507881b531bdf88e9baabbaa9" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-emblem-kscz", + "sha256": "c8095953b20fd2e8b0a2db22902f3353c5c7196ac35302e00dee221842afad43" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-game-sprite-ship", + "sha256": "0e731563527cb737e4f0ff4cff0fbb723fa3dced9d48ec8f72f0ad63945519ca" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-greek-vase-figure", + "sha256": "ff3e45df88805a10348a8fd92d1212a9410ebe6cce22d52e02ab1188d05a89f8" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-green-dragon", + "sha256": "4d02f29aec4e6de647874836130026e8c413b820b122af3bbddb56a61d097ea6" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lamp-glow", + "sha256": "857ef6d2b9fd450be843429cca5f49353705c52000647791bb7530de81de840f" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-lineart-hoe", + "sha256": "fd3ad52a4a82f4c685d05981ce3e54ddc35403e23945a3be62fb7b2986e6f142" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-navy-crest", + "sha256": "61eab4c1618ddbc8de9cbf78135492bee775be50d15a6eebd7335bf3be370643" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", + "sha256": "75951d906cb08acc1a643554dde538d739d3f814a5f5231a7971a96550ada98a" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-planet-lava", + "sha256": "74b6ae59cbfef2fa11e59d29d51ed326b3c26a10ac40604eec9ccd94883ea9cc" + }, + { + "name": "cutout-road-sign", + "sha256": "56297cb398e82ca506d2057a4402218a1113f7acb38ac92e2c1b3f5e6d460122" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["cutout-3d-star-greek", "cutout-3d-star-soviet", "cutout-bioart-astrocyte", "cutout-broccoli", "cutout-cheeseburger", "cutout-dod-seal", "cutout-emblem-kscz", "cutout-game-sprite-ship", "cutout-greek-vase-figure", "cutout-green-dragon", "cutout-lamp-glow", "cutout-lineart-hoe", "cutout-navy-crest", "cutout-nokia-soft-shadow", "cutout-planet-lava", "cutout-road-sign"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "shipped shape A5@4 L9@5 C5@4", + "tune": "la1=9:5 ca=5:4 alpha_ac_count=5 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.54971720183381, 15.06115533551992, 7.521147327063249, 15.101960853701698, 14.305017770910887, 20.962094253271445, 15.271553878035766, 11.50422577579703, 18.563283147240146, 15.42167103135779, 7.338149026577738, 13.723825845425816, 28.59317903061655, 17.3892658001088, 13.870225919344449, 26.414394010864843], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.1016274128448, -228.6431954056768, -262.83723604255505, -351.9844757091195, -374.456185340563, -803.0666236084049, -123.59487821578176, -131.73223610118285, -513.2494990657225, -235.99735218117397, -107.52249614951545, -253.77112677039904, -1092.719290704905, -558.6222815865935, -292.2495999902413, -996.7873728633507], + "butteraugli": [49.1345269676994, 60.29213390755663, 29.690931924286946, 53.79688998636462, 47.628875712344346, 41.8283330266728, 89.66388379151802, 72.92721856193045, 53.70959845332883, 58.91832078073666, 42.17247873319635, 63.36363941650878, 89.84092680141453, 58.24427566983258, 58.14399651148628, 72.15139446781711], + "dssim": [0.22397353915999063, 0.21328907290334334, 0.21100111511806507, 0.29617025670839925, 0.25623296807037316, 0.2831139387795868, 0.18051931304038282, 0.20723792787860287, 0.3104052925650771, 0.2521749013917285, 0.14627453914105157, 0.2560490412793786, 0.30697935829865725, 0.2632001185853836, 0.22777977997364263, 0.30477626410784564], + "alphaMae": [0.27047658191797846, 0.26262549973883, 0.20142853101263028, 0.28422882707299785, 0.2251093192959002, 0.2217056557211926, 0.26203745906661846, 0.2931721756989833, 0.3654010734600444, 0.40949503489372846, 0.18090229866046678, 0.34070648382459046, 0.19393431767868438, 0.287288145289236, 0.2282112719965916, 0.17365787472345134] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@3 L18@4 C1@3", + "tune": "la1=18:4 ca=1:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.32190849156025, 15.245219015676659, 7.507660629398362, 13.23041171831594, 14.532093096364974, 20.889730346550916, 15.088286736418299, 9.132565203038745, 18.07425460996969, 11.240140487450525, 7.23283483854514, 12.41050251793566, 27.903907658177193, 15.186024295929188, 13.981496508995868, 24.825674015323035], + "ssimulacra2": [-253.99572538444053, -225.7931895221333, -262.98865197749495, -304.77198070787955, -353.5601179401595, -787.3061011703136, -123.55616255102844, -118.8455328983971, -502.5218479711916, -191.75612712494055, -109.05611470327194, -242.2694272567629, -1061.5610254810479, -481.4830933427639, -286.4027557001454, -900.8621877428262], + "butteraugli": [49.63422745335486, 60.18948178381505, 29.730258696840988, 46.09524664502349, 46.99249890215123, 41.551009222221346, 90.73411308455066, 51.866718835780695, 55.13336634085882, 46.181449171952835, 41.70183535190257, 55.26009139343676, 83.7766937653782, 40.274282023184405, 57.94836533728297, 60.164822717315275], + "dssim": [0.21943564329357104, 0.21521902607853538, 0.2096305597167103, 0.2876287544481592, 0.25637884164662283, 0.28290633581848496, 0.17980754684413727, 0.1940024821153922, 0.31157564934034626, 0.22424633906456778, 0.1400696710537036, 0.24133854425758142, 0.3048525731127106, 0.26262225195455674, 0.25359894946020295, 0.3003680024685632], + "alphaMae": [0.26253128452085056, 0.264161553133036, 0.20130517120981276, 0.23958936850342546, 0.2284529803490311, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25902016031822567, 0.21631215391249092, 0.3506626751526082, 0.26653567875941725, 0.17732313482912446, 0.28498993347338936, 0.19393431767868438, 0.2209887760861606, 0.2282112719965916, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@3 L17@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=17:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.317779037758177, 15.254590288793631, 7.503825215540249, 13.223809044225815, 14.397502825998913, 20.89398473605247, 15.088307863138306, 9.129064918699653, 17.96730734174369, 11.285249506846915, 7.217605458205818, 12.411619268406541, 27.9015195500816, 15.18299766392424, 13.953220708550402, 24.835330223399765], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.10388302019064, -225.9640967785366, -262.8490165919246, -304.68612432511486, -354.23304665122674, -791.4769855054213, -123.54551961789116, -117.94195135407254, -501.76919822764216, -193.53621868827017, -108.94992246799636, -242.0453169072267, -1058.0685280191237, -481.64814510458353, -288.6921067765625, -901.5664169213205], + "butteraugli": [49.62517890176829, 60.15924017523796, 29.726081641277514, 46.12812325144662, 47.02271436908617, 41.46571075729897, 90.74806889353317, 52.88775205110374, 55.367169293131155, 46.34641255749121, 41.724080697997195, 55.266095932837906, 83.34371185456652, 40.271067690109625, 57.6753807558271, 59.988076100894354], + "dssim": [0.21944048926396098, 0.2151082761982963, 0.20963416550028344, 0.28761078304492543, 0.2564106592410555, 0.28291621054484617, 0.17980673199989758, 0.19465404386311444, 0.3106868236216422, 0.2245476866798269, 0.14034724045588548, 0.24131201878011088, 0.3047066982047854, 0.26263032124934593, 0.2511896991996872, 0.30036141705620256], + "alphaMae": [0.26253128452085056, 0.264161553133036, 0.20130517120981276, 0.23958936850342546, 0.2284529803490311, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25902016031822567, 0.21631215391249092, 0.3506626751526082, 0.26653567875941725, 0.17732313482912446, 0.28498993347338936, 0.19393431767868438, 0.2209887760861606, 0.2282112719965916, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@3 L15@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=15:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.337890955863086, 15.209043794372917, 7.512747245375561, 13.307479872804612, 14.365791317345659, 20.864867540053684, 15.125071332940935, 9.099286649513468, 18.033679424236407, 11.264198097048627, 7.2153765951446545, 12.45595149142716, 28.734746855950707, 15.064795341114467, 14.0031479935323, 24.839823262443073], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.3386195363531, -226.46587242501414, -262.81938420967873, -308.1525977705695, -362.65071995786707, -799.8658011922548, -123.51794859534321, -118.66885654303776, -503.5786768647901, -194.88656671481996, -108.96819037980181, -244.9864151135838, -1100.404182885566, -484.762816573689, -290.5397227891013, -910.6552127293518], + "butteraugli": [49.763686230013796, 60.29368976378267, 29.695141281151283, 46.407567122575394, 47.074182029483815, 41.52698021916229, 91.09343812419009, 53.09547739425586, 56.9813141458736, 46.423445233762294, 41.71629697094856, 55.91700704496737, 88.52560151452373, 40.22774489836047, 57.9626535883047, 63.014852788310286], + "dssim": [0.21945410702218707, 0.2133961029239606, 0.2096899454701219, 0.28766402402858815, 0.25656864689788156, 0.2828804335878284, 0.17977323843616375, 0.19502897599848326, 0.310025121979655, 0.22464604890600456, 0.1403056204363187, 0.24139406734395683, 0.3068678896374433, 0.2623727201510051, 0.25044207489480513, 0.3006094429148279], + "alphaMae": [0.26253128452085056, 0.264161553133036, 0.20130517120981276, 0.23958936850342546, 0.2284529803490311, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25902016031822567, 0.21631215391249092, 0.3506626751526082, 0.26653567875941725, 0.17732313482912446, 0.28498993347338936, 0.19393431767868438, 0.2209887760861606, 0.2282112719965916, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@3 L12@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=12:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.34616216744532, 15.124855691884358, 7.522710874916016, 13.607696758769109, 14.34031427924211, 20.873849176774222, 15.083071970300741, 9.102835279896084, 17.99636554001791, 11.380036092291817, 7.216918649705279, 12.556865654505144, 28.58807150360123, 15.258981834806747, 13.888998463570902, 25.020192681973317], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.32413789195422, -229.7047378140899, -262.7836035548114, -323.2493230375996, -373.65055219920697, -797.1009793564109, -123.80508303521214, -119.61723023457176, -504.9257315718351, -196.79746062245053, -108.98015981487458, -247.55202172843295, -1092.6239530386727, -489.1774819665092, -290.43333312547446, -936.1354453857988], + "butteraugli": [49.53733220653253, 59.21736652618919, 29.66715825298502, 48.89580800899183, 47.289934155468636, 41.78552468477155, 90.59585218536864, 53.45136083479853, 56.19977132439911, 46.477191009674165, 41.79059552513013, 56.61365830002464, 88.29449788595896, 41.05911367018469, 58.766174671465755, 61.85160813365843], + "dssim": [0.21939175505037226, 0.21643297642854553, 0.20973783464316498, 0.28870047771309243, 0.257721939122024, 0.2830228830576938, 0.17973870036317532, 0.19496346909255322, 0.310224622921723, 0.2253527905275794, 0.1407639393278499, 0.2416295565818969, 0.3068820592750115, 0.2630888749506912, 0.23247126206942678, 0.30023396482507014], + "alphaMae": [0.26253128452085056, 0.264161553133036, 0.20130517120981276, 0.23958936850342546, 0.2284529803490311, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25902016031822567, 0.21631215391249092, 0.3506626751526082, 0.26653567875941725, 0.17732313482912446, 0.28498993347338936, 0.19393431767868438, 0.2209887760861606, 0.2282112719965916, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@3 L15@4 C1@3", + "tune": "la1=15:4 ca=1:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.300609857699655, 15.17493280809542, 7.50974078377878, 12.453955479898996, 14.14649190627456, 20.685547173207137, 14.896482518831805, 8.29895914139941, 14.098531598209135, 10.93848138422114, 6.961479178873669, 12.457690332805363, 28.366292114482487, 15.116771188468421, 13.417773778952053, 25.01689613962006], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.9472789619946, -228.31778460159293, -262.58695668538644, -282.68315629174634, -368.78954581166835, -794.9947789749291, -123.69025976328514, -110.38752250036987, -366.133051300404, -194.7215899276863, -113.98162173513326, -252.52625994816557, -1087.5773380751564, -477.94134190406817, -297.29520497486095, -911.7471385412754], + "butteraugli": [49.578423521836214, 61.68364244038341, 29.72093527200735, 41.92342655098643, 52.26321949725203, 44.522848255715836, 93.63528862031855, 49.975991839442116, 35.94862124725966, 44.261798204208105, 40.45011977960621, 55.822314946829806, 86.96948306759536, 41.15488650835801, 57.87267264408239, 63.01530758863742], + "dssim": [0.2185574677330969, 0.2147019301322239, 0.20832573068289761, 0.28418257241447775, 0.2494588524894347, 0.28320238045023366, 0.17790161818974692, 0.18891436310579182, 0.2835576270075506, 0.2221641565502798, 0.13649459834676117, 0.2387277500349169, 0.30687419925396003, 0.2624861254211042, 0.24645282894133366, 0.30052265824743335], + "alphaMae": [0.261747352990492, 0.26227207263540664, 0.20130091028528527, 0.21094907202338767, 0.20509038888649303, 0.20897181432504508, 0.2549725426159193, 0.18917826910856933, 0.2068426935927673, 0.25499233289053536, 0.17021027080498008, 0.2832219417122909, 0.1804185748430886, 0.21656023080912865, 0.2075633030311734, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@3 L14@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=14:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.320802398122561, 15.180357851823715, 7.50974078377878, 12.430131237054326, 13.990432024107582, 20.685547173207137, 14.896606644436266, 8.27977185260542, 14.05865852141838, 11.039463246167777, 6.946416578185935, 12.48248197678709, 28.35296502250604, 15.113593399762564, 13.356539293643698, 25.191682603893415], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.7783781052428, -228.77837456002445, -262.58695668538644, -282.0606616857433, -369.35242471189326, -794.9947789749291, -123.74344664305822, -111.03304468048889, -364.853092300747, -195.84875247034373, -114.05783146598723, -253.60915029282592, -1083.4818861396168, -479.58341447347607, -298.00740152739746, -939.8495129815573], + "butteraugli": [49.373713576585175, 61.8080908298677, 29.72093527200735, 41.73849925744408, 51.91536687849839, 44.522848255715836, 93.62968535914337, 50.1467772485797, 35.82329945307763, 45.12402705935506, 40.43036212881829, 55.53894840816876, 87.13213972771604, 41.30242063073902, 57.84516705150019, 62.107905863846305], + "dssim": [0.21857335310357331, 0.21484575498858774, 0.20832573068289761, 0.2842430016684616, 0.24943417662491033, 0.28320238045023366, 0.17788165657222055, 0.18902405592583552, 0.283330272845798, 0.2228828103939496, 0.13648670232445978, 0.23878221851138326, 0.30687207566867475, 0.2626238628055042, 0.24415447590713937, 0.3002843109827659], + "alphaMae": [0.261747352990492, 0.26227207263540664, 0.20130091028528527, 0.21094907202338767, 0.20509038888649303, 0.20897181432504508, 0.2549725426159193, 0.18917826910856933, 0.2068426935927673, 0.25499233289053536, 0.17021027080498008, 0.2832219417122909, 0.1804185748430886, 0.21656023080912865, 0.2075633030311734, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@3 L12@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=12:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.311476870215275, 15.044706900114742, 7.526037196582877, 12.783147043283245, 14.021079449608877, 20.68074405716281, 14.844160486447668, 8.265481757757126, 14.072079230454273, 11.046295539372858, 6.945529816355058, 12.570694554871162, 28.47158223907375, 15.282495072270047, 13.317742489182693, 25.02140315863451], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.75943771416232, -231.42092496477179, -262.71737855642044, -297.79894568976255, -382.9121411294764, -790.919393893551, -124.108672299534, -111.56729728521832, -365.199072324223, -196.72716806532526, -113.957275818119, -255.95087560855404, -1082.9861078098022, -482.5141772080644, -299.23459095229765, -936.3005744005728], + "butteraugli": [49.44967252987659, 60.7429834548961, 29.688897723284402, 46.1876392090716, 51.705875999373085, 44.70956714915647, 93.39962328858337, 50.054095291651976, 35.68124194107373, 45.25110014708776, 40.489545607978876, 56.23546804638233, 87.35562469927595, 42.40969484379525, 57.42650583178054, 61.86086521221552], + "dssim": [0.2185827979959052, 0.21701279789710826, 0.20832468148182492, 0.2852845046649936, 0.25019284636710193, 0.2833036169197947, 0.1778038944068133, 0.18917379896701622, 0.2832650987602554, 0.22283971135677816, 0.1364723824720652, 0.23890540732644885, 0.3068521119178144, 0.26321695005931417, 0.23332138457600285, 0.30022407454681527], + "alphaMae": [0.261747352990492, 0.26227207263540664, 0.20130091028528527, 0.21094907202338767, 0.20509038888649303, 0.20897181432504508, 0.2549725426159193, 0.18917826910856933, 0.2068426935927673, 0.25499233289053536, 0.17021027080498008, 0.2832219417122909, 0.1804185748430886, 0.21656023080912865, 0.2075633030311734, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@3 L9@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=9:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.323615507486217, 15.044190655630379, 7.528966859366065, 12.776646326184753, 13.828481858092497, 20.671249175759545, 14.857837639996083, 8.218146336356249, 14.086683539004119, 11.258463959799146, 6.97160638716791, 12.57274288510033, 28.38702114473341, 15.851723126968045, 13.250852547254395, 25.455208164779922], + "ssimulacra2": [-256.314690561869, -231.4920392105987, -262.63153352216494, -300.5330114391885, -383.6498062247363, -798.4597269599996, -124.44696304237759, -111.51315237707684, -368.73712650339917, -208.9233095195907, -114.71953797674057, -255.65570116341272, -1080.0774386602732, -508.9169718270105, -301.22276731864486, -977.784747595551], + "butteraugli": [49.65800093305884, 60.69510516721047, 29.66012319200038, 47.33344279999353, 51.738958876512406, 44.546173244618046, 93.51176538889628, 50.04899254913985, 35.358451829373486, 47.25614612522663, 40.84135897317213, 56.506224452157504, 88.50849493196166, 42.35479290084549, 58.29784355668176, 69.16816169980956], + "dssim": [0.21859393495416776, 0.21501260309009687, 0.20843284659865047, 0.28560794101435377, 0.2500776228673507, 0.2832526189637368, 0.1781069534803994, 0.1893682030758926, 0.2841876424618363, 0.22417957307261527, 0.13653342744792396, 0.2388696455550631, 0.3068834322364838, 0.2633171036966198, 0.22301329511203657, 0.30047628170964646], + "alphaMae": [0.261747352990492, 0.26227207263540664, 0.20130091028528527, 0.21094907202338767, 0.20509038888649303, 0.20897181432504508, 0.2549725426159193, 0.18917826910856933, 0.2068426935927673, 0.25499233289053536, 0.17021027080498008, 0.2832219417122909, 0.1804185748430886, 0.21656023080912865, 0.2075633030311734, 0.11634985576088842] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@3 L12@4 C1@3", + "tune": "la1=12:4 ca=1:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.756541722513248, 12.817143273593075, 7.323402466193921, 12.14497432931698, 14.008377312858483, 19.832552140437468, 12.342059428446353, 7.321150988949942, 13.877698004730057, 10.658022147475302, 6.944799643496528, 11.625947998158383, 27.78644870705175, 15.219253174588353, 12.643225122976745, 25.059914225394923], + "ssimulacra2": [-238.79361965913733, -212.7736032492836, -258.88337761623535, -271.15447038541834, -370.8455179534292, -766.9313163310611, -116.40822609262506, -96.81991300500651, -360.26259384305655, -192.3075406217266, -114.58467969203669, -226.94713805258655, -1062.795150789544, -478.53774925485635, -288.7877903717377, -935.1621290449988], + "butteraugli": [54.0156763683864, 55.206814991868214, 28.238324633808077, 38.90392954148581, 48.68209456904278, 39.43839186645767, 94.00135458747543, 36.61142127961881, 33.9929621292527, 41.786519325645315, 40.82318139812812, 54.250483647981525, 85.63345877140529, 41.15817489586104, 52.988293269093425, 59.118491217896775], + "dssim": [0.21471884106293407, 0.21096128313312765, 0.20660783035365693, 0.2814531831050031, 0.2508238879012669, 0.2763799386996161, 0.17170949903085517, 0.1763080725761359, 0.2800433933695201, 0.22110346830426394, 0.1358835710944437, 0.2374040032183251, 0.30445261979118105, 0.263010058984081, 0.22863447848386062, 0.2980461439164134], + "alphaMae": [0.21394198524480215, 0.20970169798195917, 0.19557690157988872, 0.18534880330144107, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.20333767151840246, 0.15426555691721133, 0.19386012069922307, 0.23966000442797986, 0.16877219035107616, 0.24064341882586368, 0.12472894011823092, 0.20854493379301928, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10668481856238071] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@3 L11@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=11:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.761857176333995, 12.810402903629594, 7.323402466193921, 12.141443053262138, 13.823507862080158, 19.832552140437468, 12.341949478000714, 7.291599868430729, 13.876948412982061, 10.851152097217964, 6.932470815928386, 11.63302521938302, 27.830734746050354, 15.862786978074444, 12.55050951646414, 25.062261798597504], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.1523768019898, -212.7218172030213, -258.88337761623535, -271.04589529808476, -371.2697056388895, -766.9313163310611, -116.38184736465153, -96.87828294005476, -362.7886405208788, -204.6705009750631, -114.63892360987388, -227.01405069039416, -1064.7295541034412, -507.9097969415573, -289.3707537323769, -935.7898953155985], + "butteraugli": [54.01818108743464, 55.302009368486125, 28.238324633808077, 38.89601884617831, 48.77494099291578, 39.43839186645767, 94.00043117300773, 36.80614436420666, 33.84298513150914, 42.20712904237571, 40.75823307411038, 53.746188871290634, 87.14159316787726, 40.82815779547766, 52.89683166050158, 59.145065066280864], + "dssim": [0.21474959864036194, 0.21114142185059234, 0.20660783035365693, 0.2814403249392961, 0.2509189035555744, 0.2763799386996161, 0.17168586117431164, 0.17672331940884164, 0.28068052698945095, 0.22243418007236584, 0.13592456423213353, 0.23741802192420322, 0.3044729413773861, 0.2633489781930784, 0.22247113852726472, 0.2980536431048945], + "alphaMae": [0.21394198524480215, 0.20970169798195917, 0.19557690157988872, 0.18534880330144107, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.20333767151840246, 0.15426555691721133, 0.19386012069922307, 0.23966000442797986, 0.16877219035107616, 0.24064341882586368, 0.12472894011823092, 0.20854493379301928, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10668481856238071] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@3 L9@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=9:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.764451714731251, 12.774167558990854, 7.323961679853981, 12.21204373272492, 13.764626254331295, 19.833597268894014, 12.364053328981639, 7.248366137058302, 13.902407093397933, 10.85873407695403, 6.95721030817494, 11.625782277824287, 27.94046757663685, 15.754393860559148, 12.57830599809985, 25.356756834250024], + "ssimulacra2": [-238.94008068580766, -213.31362787794737, -258.7680413992489, -275.0602758351893, -372.28449930176015, -772.1021690279931, -116.77429030360896, -96.94262651738103, -361.76964839552517, -205.0005529527294, -115.38101314013893, -226.94543357257706, -1063.9139370352748, -504.47744730027625, -290.9572294436824, -977.146817825725], + "butteraugli": [54.1773377759508, 54.95548832120328, 28.21113332772779, 39.49567700465073, 48.88359816432109, 39.48658214210087, 93.88017256557015, 36.935788800944486, 33.88205774468518, 42.33217905591864, 41.21931864539101, 53.545336107034224, 87.48761489756913, 40.96078151124445, 52.596550181323494, 66.18534229066854], + "dssim": [0.21471735870341427, 0.20947780588927298, 0.2067415969513672, 0.28169029977103754, 0.25047429160061013, 0.27638365703489925, 0.17107652786069613, 0.1764195909350421, 0.28062469205727253, 0.22264274261202063, 0.13571796468468586, 0.23736714452229815, 0.3044536379938829, 0.2631144412415037, 0.22280312658145027, 0.2983744489067626], + "alphaMae": [0.21394198524480215, 0.20970169798195917, 0.19557690157988872, 0.18534880330144107, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.20333767151840246, 0.15426555691721133, 0.19386012069922307, 0.23966000442797986, 0.16877219035107616, 0.24064341882586368, 0.12472894011823092, 0.20854493379301928, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10668481856238071] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@3 L6@4 C5@3", + "tune": "la1=6:4 ca=5:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.767400109966275, 12.791074078032247, 7.326869831593548, 12.212753839143945, 13.56724445038797, 19.791255702021704, 12.411913371900647, 7.217761892715437, 13.925158558009821, 11.084774875026726, 6.98899042121441, 11.761028269131293, 28.05859915553194, 16.31510986048035, 12.486011384340316, 25.357695999263], + "ssimulacra2": [-238.9204414205392, -214.31609975464036, -258.70335731356164, -278.41323947344557, -351.6088980895763, -772.0042188907855, -116.69046388862341, -97.8028146923828, -369.930710299107, -213.52823606320203, -116.20486591072138, -228.81987608070713, -1065.017611670056, -523.0218474792223, -293.9554228986605, -974.8986733040659], + "butteraugli": [54.15499185215885, 55.3553034640807, 28.13865370195901, 39.091361233480676, 47.657354390772156, 39.393100938079165, 93.92795675664225, 37.07090995715726, 34.08042973973493, 41.96131166996464, 41.7643445706899, 53.38493932980597, 85.26953524995821, 41.47474867583094, 52.86817203581655, 65.71065593185203], + "dssim": [0.21470814166325317, 0.2092880416251477, 0.20674517768196377, 0.2820881707412101, 0.24997769890015772, 0.27628544554996587, 0.17106966317615666, 0.1775463185791478, 0.2818266461888764, 0.22341775071921255, 0.13680806610600252, 0.23768916453227829, 0.3050147922952106, 0.26411458847264363, 0.21260292498870811, 0.29826277191426537], + "alphaMae": [0.21394198524480215, 0.20970169798195917, 0.19557690157988872, 0.18534880330144107, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.20333767151840246, 0.15426555691721133, 0.19386012069922307, 0.23966000442797986, 0.16877219035107616, 0.24064341882586368, 0.12472894011823092, 0.20854493379301928, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10668481856238071] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@3 L9@4 C1@3", + "tune": "la1=9:4 ca=1:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.822289811241925, 12.06979092326811, 7.305180276271805, 11.851327123767922, 14.035063076031994, 19.869496822826907, 11.77839571095078, 7.284710057804247, 13.851858882856332, 10.391531168189546, 6.970929695878648, 11.486424048998012, 27.704339152018836, 15.763221767589819, 12.653299413255622, 25.46137817368451], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.4452686191793, -209.73426781621797, -257.3373561313533, -262.5777648726731, -371.4458877695287, -772.1888781986777, -110.21207129616941, -96.2349992743912, -356.9044082161877, -192.36169684331352, -117.83234090869904, -219.78966311437804, -1063.3372694929224, -504.1373819686619, -290.7819927698933, -975.4545973732374], + "butteraugli": [53.87233110704815, 49.20311237613591, 28.106865384601633, 36.4586742727279, 48.88244967971665, 39.48716890614151, 87.9218371533493, 37.71629116671918, 33.800732905381096, 38.91134938989694, 40.13910775026165, 52.258452118186945, 86.63115768074421, 42.066428872441485, 52.625929118494206, 64.60330368266469], + "dssim": [0.214349443551606, 0.2095048164167789, 0.2044673126402614, 0.28219457356214206, 0.25060893266375056, 0.27640144862587457, 0.16625558560236897, 0.1762679140668012, 0.28115290090069045, 0.22056725183425527, 0.13835437868305625, 0.24278634325877949, 0.3026528095786356, 0.2630364852292942, 0.22837071941149475, 0.2978651322569057], + "alphaMae": [0.2141593433147907, 0.19248250914095147, 0.19501463204932873, 0.17075603886132767, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.19142919655054644, 0.1516693616103849, 0.19038607999213836, 0.22187034204585143, 0.16690331780205656, 0.2350633103620236, 0.12034659629981025, 0.20502228510698886, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10062613195167447] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@3 L8@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=8:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.82300239276696, 12.072833772345504, 7.305180276271805, 11.891103645491576, 13.794962661128155, 19.869496822826907, 11.779358172186667, 7.279004514068695, 13.888640758779431, 10.408582527349976, 6.976866655200644, 11.492125859277811, 27.89160320698883, 16.38521273199863, 12.559446798471726, 25.47444856633209], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.56662418231767, -209.63509855367556, -257.3373561313533, -265.8811158285829, -350.9383744342761, -772.1888781986777, -110.26222132917285, -97.64978008005419, -360.97911676849964, -192.2589988963372, -118.65253152131118, -219.6186133960562, -1068.0337129299633, -521.8588600882423, -292.19807883621246, -974.92146892111], + "butteraugli": [53.86687773790394, 49.227116727740075, 28.106865384601633, 36.514739038364496, 49.01757439612058, 39.48716890614151, 87.92407427526742, 37.494752046914904, 34.308441828116344, 38.8464707939899, 40.540262160637376, 52.23580138648834, 85.30921193081997, 42.42027972061562, 52.718167014031934, 64.45032814378494], + "dssim": [0.2143483983995841, 0.20967415020110067, 0.2044673126402614, 0.2824584019964452, 0.250302330068403, 0.27640144862587457, 0.16623444074014632, 0.17678525211578547, 0.28205415992832833, 0.22042238138926104, 0.13911797071893758, 0.24272946356040026, 0.3030177345694281, 0.26406317406709917, 0.21941363340527595, 0.29791108179772413], + "alphaMae": [0.2141593433147907, 0.19248250914095147, 0.19501463204932873, 0.17075603886132767, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.19142919655054644, 0.1516693616103849, 0.19038607999213836, 0.22187034204585143, 0.16690331780205656, 0.2350633103620236, 0.12034659629981025, 0.20502228510698886, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10062613195167447] + } + }, + { + "label": "A20@3 L6@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=6:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=20 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.817703931792998, 12.055859420142333, 7.310379574463561, 11.921448794744366, 13.792819420428804, 19.832863600403563, 11.83065823419876, 7.2263269228785205, 13.904803332878197, 10.600174680395698, 6.9890759937400615, 11.619724682518333, 28.005141093471565, 16.296377673748108, 12.577406273200529, 25.294921900544377], + "ssimulacra2": [-239.36554415546803, -210.8532013139965, -257.36891475628045, -266.33439695960027, -351.8390069177082, -772.4935924019677, -110.28559990878716, -97.31147349758409, -365.2542034979235, -200.61588785539428, -119.23546977897605, -221.41924672546313, -1066.248425449043, -521.3381890680272, -293.0719671736438, -971.0403588668356], + "butteraugli": [53.91846733827149, 49.43506722557536, 28.06264850834143, 36.774433617611784, 47.82591850808143, 39.453801935473535, 87.8482585021763, 37.68062642153573, 33.85073149578731, 38.99238479449478, 40.79822374697423, 52.18643538416631, 85.10936764572779, 42.384490617471705, 52.81415158956679, 64.03578029807367], + "dssim": [0.21432508532643446, 0.20738673207564026, 0.2044705216750821, 0.2824621848104483, 0.2500384504215789, 0.27638552268668076, 0.16602658419048508, 0.17690187117095557, 0.28210129326702194, 0.22138504097857958, 0.13956224358279415, 0.24315209385791517, 0.303012187739461, 0.26402556985916587, 0.2155702842451661, 0.29782704747612204], + "alphaMae": [0.2141593433147907, 0.19248250914095147, 0.19501463204932873, 0.17075603886132767, 0.19203997398079467, 0.14704747695311002, 0.19142919655054644, 0.1516693616103849, 0.19038607999213836, 0.22187034204585143, 0.16690331780205656, 0.2350633103620236, 0.12034659629981025, 0.20502228510698886, 0.1778744716270297, 0.10062613195167447] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@3 L6@4 C1@3", + "tune": "la1=6:4 ca=1:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.49416564606937, 12.095303714749924, 7.282543853998462, 11.509866570700519, 13.972764234235838, 19.86837806744437, 11.308463501561981, 7.255011093081545, 13.960836020291291, 9.89623589874517, 6.973890072472398, 11.600113643370944, 27.880492168398902, 16.37547806236399, 12.118686069989266, 25.40129469285071], + "ssimulacra2": [-232.64086728042068, -208.44833674462984, -255.7010026720377, -253.57217343467815, -346.42472349920837, -775.5473038739377, -104.95300048100432, -95.22632428974805, -366.1206133032561, -187.76311596936986, -117.42816183203144, -221.06619741167393, -1064.6667357562415, -521.7015268809704, -277.3854481320133, -977.5849513951974], + "butteraugli": [50.0896455696608, 46.01162861324551, 27.273799483138216, 35.955722380288314, 46.53228235850445, 38.84107179055866, 78.98239526913663, 36.40156237230553, 33.95110318750454, 37.57108421955338, 40.844786314742635, 51.775631693073215, 84.5521806583307, 42.404348781828844, 48.29561964701163, 64.78077199824594], + "dssim": [0.21077739409960639, 0.20999146660526105, 0.20461422066134893, 0.28063681172842636, 0.2482957334154697, 0.27661157357827343, 0.16335439781902625, 0.17954911799965947, 0.2821095988524122, 0.21447978541217694, 0.138747918334628, 0.24479095109085147, 0.30252679569347385, 0.26406021045939493, 0.2131692623997451, 0.2978294694835885], + "alphaMae": [0.2029239622785734, 0.18898990916807296, 0.19421350923533828, 0.1553793298192771, 0.18557104339169686, 0.14464706901596253, 0.1822548925435953, 0.14954804375453884, 0.19038607999213836, 0.18839458055805017, 0.1647236818892081, 0.2338571839720737, 0.11372647849462365, 0.20502228510698886, 0.16452727972292433, 0.09805766920982995] + } + }, + { + "label": "A24@3 L5@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=5:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=24 alpha_ac_bits=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [12.495960860816476, 12.097147214599524, 7.282543853998462, 11.511410442165479, 13.765499812130487, 19.863527412713335, 11.30843335878928, 7.215934039357176, 13.909741763287235, 9.952881739440349, 6.973927928404035, 11.610112503403144, 27.95845164726464, 16.381018691049086, 12.056414733950392, 25.432859578886745], + "ssimulacra2": [-232.7176609395774, -208.6828884017476, -255.7010026720377, -253.69980005527734, -346.0018843447501, -774.1667948274144, -105.00845709449534, -95.0443356328011, -365.91179222988944, -188.647025641812, -117.58578767764095, -221.3718580664894, -1064.8130389885662, -521.0060851137122, -277.00639240581285, -977.0383739310629], + "butteraugli": [50.08736192527302, 46.049749172629596, 27.273799483138216, 35.941639691813855, 46.61902840577176, 38.83044810041267, 78.99041881744311, 36.38438311229629, 33.936112684109766, 37.386873163413725, 41.19566049701047, 52.1910950233185, 88.55363465777441, 42.449994706178465, 48.22304681464065, 63.4780877886788], + "dssim": [0.21077984487251347, 0.2100624270978015, 0.20461422066134893, 0.2806160690952389, 0.24828745797915883, 0.27659142845366136, 0.16338101399446595, 0.17943523229527072, 0.28211803879208147, 0.21465620441835295, 0.13944561848535247, 0.24492447214048452, 0.30287047654632304, 0.2640756919245982, 0.2124404310717022, 0.29780007799679514], + "alphaMae": [0.2029239622785734, 0.18898990916807296, 0.19421350923533828, 0.1553793298192771, 0.18557104339169686, 0.14464706901596253, 0.1822548925435953, 0.14954804375453884, 0.19038607999213836, 0.18839458055805017, 0.1647236818892081, 0.2338571839720737, 0.11372647849462365, 0.20502228510698886, 0.16452727972292433, 0.09805766920982995] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@4 L15@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=15:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.468735315166, 15.118921936889585, 7.500222479616838, 13.015616055597212, 14.361031724087674, 20.908704559911637, 15.027132505288462, 9.146296884659023, 18.066707710440756, 11.041604387258593, 7.210834083608195, 12.455309489759264, 28.606741686392922, 15.162968650143549, 13.98500840360879, 24.875283124480394], + "ssimulacra2": [-254.14530856152138, -224.8690307067324, -262.86812777749486, -299.04282292965837, -363.21746970385567, -800.6272098014852, -123.03740558117515, -123.13307853687196, -500.4707747153291, -186.1351271430119, -109.24532779817469, -244.43585899148613, -1100.3319587415176, -484.49043514279896, -290.41543942512027, -906.3026665736887], + "butteraugli": [49.074918718880745, 63.12984253531196, 29.724531449371465, 44.24852309906032, 46.36662954695961, 41.56140429032042, 90.3286602094347, 49.0900872507846, 54.59502616322982, 44.31254812336589, 41.67868561519922, 56.71091820483139, 88.20801700115108, 39.290297142671335, 57.876814154790814, 63.21860424997413], + "dssim": [0.22407167200877298, 0.2144654358495334, 0.21068242922819858, 0.2862478095007741, 0.2554454542141494, 0.28291552869906306, 0.17923154566062238, 0.19627984498553253, 0.3095651706141041, 0.22188841956681457, 0.14091380707445442, 0.24384083419904093, 0.3068813684333918, 0.26229516665390284, 0.25100990030587395, 0.2985587844179862], + "alphaMae": [0.2683835550065096, 0.2610928679232964, 0.20136152926823883, 0.22773873065792583, 0.22473518091254097, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25807655797974927, 0.21849154071350763, 0.3520173259457085, 0.25681639942872825, 0.1775706743976511, 0.2866783147918258, 0.19393431767868438, 0.22033061538930926, 0.2282112719965916, 0.1088300703301232] + } + }, + { + "label": "A8@4 L13@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=13:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=8 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.48371178488496, 14.982046828483229, 7.516326216119768, 13.231909344160568, 14.29957140510085, 20.84493878155723, 14.987610104770186, 9.123125741157807, 18.074600224147684, 11.129604006349998, 7.211012532343599, 12.474923071314388, 28.705269811059882, 15.335199028752022, 13.953844347297661, 24.91645103928741], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.22978039246354, -227.63244337951383, -262.95584941330145, -305.00255394174206, -363.1488951137338, -798.599950572309, -123.42595435945941, -124.11364087310352, -502.02020031695696, -187.3286682700115, -109.32976989670834, -245.1975011657986, -1095.3024959297775, -487.4304348774981, -292.2381815022321, -930.8730408337977], + "butteraugli": [48.96357434021513, 62.185855309106024, 29.69165358350799, 44.93135042440298, 46.94033788296144, 41.4866550615738, 90.01807256756534, 49.0257950559138, 54.18755813529939, 45.392185518905166, 41.75064612510021, 56.64738633062621, 88.55173814991291, 39.93631450804083, 57.36215192884075, 61.950718542397475], + "dssim": [0.22405493014553138, 0.21678169370929834, 0.2107108528954995, 0.28672311809496115, 0.2551418578798279, 0.28284094727617487, 0.1790453634975481, 0.1964750010297526, 0.30934713013747345, 0.2225152207374402, 0.14144537045421582, 0.2439007030519369, 0.30689303368358567, 0.26291445322106655, 0.2471582563877257, 0.2983107492639842], + "alphaMae": [0.2683835550065096, 0.2610928679232964, 0.20136152926823883, 0.22773873065792583, 0.22473518091254097, 0.2217056557211926, 0.25807655797974927, 0.21849154071350763, 0.3520173259457085, 0.25681639942872825, 0.1775706743976511, 0.2866783147918258, 0.19393431767868438, 0.22033061538930926, 0.2282112719965916, 0.1088300703301232] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L11@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=11:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.475876146904193, 15.023674430880149, 7.515186273911172, 12.46694322979288, 14.088579715180991, 20.76073364508125, 14.76756286628292, 8.333013387185726, 14.309365038803543, 10.954259425416808, 6.911948274272535, 12.520010131718559, 28.3677232023733, 15.959552558036501, 13.396007289864011, 25.058092372089117], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.5212321954186, -228.32021174759794, -262.91625788857823, -290.2288526426028, -378.2519582644884, -791.5421628079215, -123.16503846226455, -118.77103672885217, -378.16081704259483, -192.2476272241049, -113.33105872900296, -253.1550396719982, -1083.7912158532436, -511.8893196477624, -295.4353397509763, -933.0074361039864], + "butteraugli": [48.73057202071802, 61.210657270809016, 29.713180859487508, 41.0664734040868, 48.554087651556436, 43.59801388670974, 91.92207035215115, 41.81757073127101, 33.81277690656363, 41.46544529194688, 40.32462541604895, 57.47388843014998, 88.60073378032727, 40.545400034406015, 56.18593262437404, 61.389592823894056], + "dssim": [0.2231253588407823, 0.21815386385630967, 0.20997188651676058, 0.2818469182751729, 0.25137526331396565, 0.2832001638635386, 0.17755786602879364, 0.19190542769520433, 0.2895721859763906, 0.22032949218788364, 0.13727972500530886, 0.24111739225852494, 0.3069280814177482, 0.263446208078669, 0.2343126285073879, 0.2982074856091075], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A12@4 L9@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=9:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=12 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.484448978282975, 14.977473326574744, 7.516652738723977, 12.538520109639542, 14.031697909803059, 20.76489993863244, 14.782200603109827, 8.299501671808333, 14.334668035881313, 10.95009298385731, 6.9373286929727636, 12.519926794663576, 28.48720870593468, 15.848434782386306, 13.414523777561643, 25.34508544767432], + "ssimulacra2": [-255.1917116004646, -228.0598008021091, -262.8644006265832, -294.4171250191482, -380.06497493718507, -798.235707872031, -123.48067277676275, -118.95613788122269, -377.2299592606425, -192.31506149436788, -113.95349740852366, -253.64345486411014, -1083.0480736209377, -508.5759638607586, -296.1036402650603, -971.1176362444518], + "butteraugli": [48.99532887886502, 61.854179523581166, 29.672443154972314, 42.11449825156807, 48.90147364749074, 43.580592229894506, 92.34388922073397, 41.90869178095297, 33.78325682842219, 41.511722779325126, 40.62437422634144, 57.785657858239524, 88.87125998194354, 40.72219478752315, 56.489969341320865, 68.77247515894126], + "dssim": [0.2231307668254321, 0.21670371060149937, 0.2100610119761165, 0.2821124677700794, 0.2510328457580062, 0.2832038077577242, 0.17770705101081422, 0.1918471121941351, 0.2894699663642187, 0.2204141437640373, 0.13725050871146952, 0.24110485256455272, 0.3068908823375512, 0.26317937663720053, 0.23321669643658036, 0.2984681403731558], + "alphaMae": [0.2681270681688169, 0.2606533677123513, 0.20134648665209326, 0.20072626904677535, 0.2044013651098269, 0.21105799554410806, 0.25457906106858724, 0.19340535925018154, 0.2190154024463559, 0.2429744214002395, 0.16930828324260294, 0.2829446480296664, 0.17903488085680924, 0.2149084251179725, 0.2108682969037224, 0.10927969915842443] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L7@4 C2@3", + "tune": "la1=7:4 ca=2:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [13.224744438341622, 12.94554859847896, 7.29617727519106, 11.812849249833434, 13.749912492845901, 19.889895024246247, 12.528401991294963, 7.355251631107219, 14.06219229140848, 10.715949417372508, 6.923201271633091, 11.809264900292986, 27.945129586811174, 16.435070756097566, 12.71678734410195, 25.410384773298336], + "ssimulacra2": [-248.45005791923373, -213.27390902970333, -258.6881958472133, -265.4922920005901, -349.64211343942816, -772.5210564793665, -111.80927461920237, -103.08549295575915, -370.00689001335496, -196.15977947202327, -115.80182398589544, -226.11028555985413, -1065.79441846393, -523.9499682670945, -290.6176391999297, -963.1297540504296], + "butteraugli": [49.99317117690877, 52.36730983402557, 27.94278768271343, 37.40739921043565, 43.86791648743716, 39.48308854652385, 91.12953591171049, 36.41442845375226, 33.28144745528825, 39.23168563479708, 41.07831342479681, 54.97466600718059, 85.1829379412578, 40.61320114792853, 53.506073324657365, 64.51870134193983], + "dssim": [0.22136795907465326, 0.21129381319325305, 0.20998808899658017, 0.27874873997185096, 0.25200080777369527, 0.2764667716783954, 0.17290852138930016, 0.17815104321343656, 0.28526505227025517, 0.22027450784612476, 0.13491913434354622, 0.24333602194345608, 0.3037273270416108, 0.26418070685087053, 0.22192052955078215, 0.2959481802480417], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + }, + { + "label": "A16@4 L5@4 C3@3", + "tune": "la1=5:4 ca=3:3 alpha_ac_count=16 alpha_ac_bits=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [13.22534539665299, 12.928338276986892, 7.295930814102253, 11.793821608793442, 13.641253254692858, 19.854744550096317, 12.569842208955833, 7.299826498657549, 14.069995592344918, 10.776784835942726, 6.954976351872492, 11.836177289145276, 28.153680742851815, 16.34664804027261, 12.747759160125595, 25.28180120310985], + "ssimulacra2": [-248.12425889056132, -214.25688557338424, -258.594779544432, -265.1226233279236, -348.9629019069969, -771.6765103472984, -111.82429019743296, -103.0980063610769, -374.5822624053306, -198.48195664404702, -116.50816591760235, -226.78496168579932, -1066.6507740569216, -522.3240774533741, -292.6510070212421, -961.6142215941945], + "butteraugli": [50.09915548272227, 52.45156628321786, 27.910307189159244, 37.39271026043199, 44.147505144300204, 39.48163469727882, 91.07127433049936, 36.453284907775846, 33.160665766935985, 39.73814415620742, 41.479887047196655, 55.57141001981918, 89.32563405007012, 40.57888924399569, 53.76151849136513, 63.05467193697124], + "dssim": [0.22135006949874314, 0.2096239389235779, 0.21007050050466716, 0.27871866292095054, 0.2516356128092992, 0.2764443657047448, 0.17236644111250288, 0.17830169716457814, 0.28538840603461596, 0.220524081929338, 0.13527833289597768, 0.24341595216846038, 0.304174564420514, 0.26420713920466055, 0.21840019015132803, 0.29599778559404155], + "alphaMae": [0.23030269546198762, 0.21152257425767437, 0.19541712553546195, 0.16723603974722417, 0.1877866065781151, 0.14256442517075324, 0.20765535850610736, 0.15663869598765431, 0.20220172753653348, 0.22473116393503967, 0.16714847491052978, 0.2476239051491809, 0.11947830000486546, 0.20749017319583435, 0.18426121730430453, 0.09103355321664064] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-graphics.json b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-graphics.json index 1ebba07..3086787 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-graphics.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier-graphics.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier.json b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier.json index c888a3c..ac26ef5 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/compact-tier.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/companding-family.json b/tools/comparison/results/companding-family.json index ac8b41c..3a1cfb2 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/companding-family.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/companding-family.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/deadzone.json b/tools/comparison/results/deadzone.json index e651148..36cb05a 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/deadzone.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/deadzone.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/detail-synthesis.json b/tools/comparison/results/detail-synthesis.json index 4b2cbb5..5294ce2 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/detail-synthesis.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/detail-synthesis.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/embedded-tiers.json b/tools/comparison/results/embedded-tiers.json index d332366..cce915f 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/embedded-tiers.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/embedded-tiers.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/encoder-compute.json b/tools/comparison/results/encoder-compute.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4f51716 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/encoder-compute.json @@ -0,0 +1,318 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "encoder-compute", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Encoder-only levers: zero wire cost, decoder untouched, bytes unchanged. ac_nearest picks the AC code nearest in RECONSTRUCTION instead of nearest in the companded domain; scale_fit=1 normalizes by the dequantized scale the decoder actually uses (removing the shipped encoder/decoder scale mismatch); scale_fit=2 searches every scale code for minimum reconstruction SSE. Measured at the 21 B (ThumbHash-equal), 32 B (shipped tier 0) and 108 B (tier 1) budgets. Every arm pins all four selection/encoder knobs explicitly: this round measured the levers against the PRE-adoption constants, and since §10 adopted scale_fit=2 and ac_nearest=1 as defaults, an arm that omitted them would measure the levers against a control that already contained them.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/encoder-compute.json", + "configSha256": "d878ee51025fc633c054addf5a670a8b6e7675d0a45dd354276631a5de3ffdf2", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32 B shipped", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": "32 B ac_nearest", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.821623708701667, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.67205507442276, 10.078734377988464, 14.567723526930534, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.231005468055661, 10.643717173667637, 10.318544940309703, 4.242660244806155, 11.795991855682244, 19.134537989631472, 11.349386207179531, 12.316297128665378, 10.533901647435368, 18.633103740192894, 14.230940920523073, 11.962430340365062, 4.58668585319393, 13.18052886966758, 12.594941437654906, 2.421610947709588, 13.850797185982646, 13.32877318086465, 12.502520210551825, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 15.014674718636458], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.421159622267, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -322.77898232595754, -237.36829872252093, -435.56523168202773, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -344.77844515460055, -255.97300766846013, -168.4049519156107, -64.13512366838529, -285.67821862228897, -852.5992787297619, -295.81724372362726, -287.30849327133774, -123.8225364872277, -657.823865660009, -695.038483996912, -300.8847980036634, -65.8540156398235, -440.88294863227975, -249.18722209594478, -59.04362686580177, -420.48381090834494, -302.47159805873537, -374.19171438461933, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.3199406382448], + "butteraugli": [23.802747929154354, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.216367453063196, 21.964888236413675, 39.25808038990792, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.28547685810204, 21.53573344418942, 27.383584167924113, 21.85082093167057, 22.1154185639349, 37.82395795603674, 28.937416055893323, 31.624781328236537, 48.519471857733684, 49.46379242029843, 25.747435229961116, 39.93361828533785, 16.323330120739268, 22.374909037367548, 25.609360119802137, 9.762432724630946, 44.75633885626322, 37.36009412764573, 39.239254025257594, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.58266631445576], + "dssim": [0.3044561320729259, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.33495309348723434, 0.23165293660590086, 0.21913154023648246, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.24552144375836132, 0.39356559647449113, 0.24865480347274388, 0.15168356623214452, 0.2583985736602924, 0.36646363017097594, 0.197933152078975, 0.2295982496069034, 0.14655800988059003, 0.3331992481955769, 0.3686376841632717, 0.22223800946184896, 0.14944645848554794, 0.2940122301328453, 0.23756996082915194, 0.0999688038271696, 0.28259880489304323, 0.231645353039083, 0.31124570520244876, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3603897349092078] + } + }, + { + "label": "32 B scale_fit=1", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=1 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.823899515828306, 9.227271661692745, 26.12880613999717, 10.198139706275335, 13.672486504438245, 10.087913257926783, 14.511036674376811, 3.5386890019903396, 11.31029406899651, 12.182939525256975, 10.643717173667637, 10.295919052463752, 4.143004757002201, 11.772895201137443, 19.141804855209, 11.304025397761789, 12.318362839007058, 10.55303602973478, 18.57971088368143, 14.1889049721474, 12.005900892075019, 4.546204194790476, 13.184053305448325, 12.541930599474293, 2.3104916804229925, 13.850797185982646, 13.24619735547037, 12.478287945053504, 9.115905015481268, 10.934529567859181, 14.953251286809788], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.6700256348422, -264.3699831763988, -1231.3145346233512, -136.9202154994968, -324.106114473656, -238.18649646603154, -437.42645245391236, -63.840241925493075, -376.37098891639164, -350.11422876048323, -255.97300766846013, -168.24176886040595, -64.10129373001581, -285.7439574454411, -851.0489076958469, -295.43298880648433, -289.71588442313276, -124.39461483107183, -656.8661991464326, -694.2580888192072, -298.9651577361466, -65.85213046289098, -440.8425360463657, -248.0514019926565, -59.060050325336135, -420.48381090834494, -302.4373391892635, -373.9007874872292, -248.56912907753838, -435.6538244809873, -670.216445207129], + "butteraugli": [23.83363703901142, 27.85936778679969, 45.13848906394811, 26.85526423162446, 24.90760973247703, 21.999818069739973, 39.16437664248624, 13.228263741371308, 21.682223561848947, 42.91961336981089, 21.53573344418942, 26.993626116438765, 22.499011413853726, 22.14435879564802, 37.55606208856735, 28.943465007532367, 32.12814769906726, 48.538925215628545, 49.749626398700705, 25.722475101995602, 39.77861679287334, 16.320940992317343, 22.38386188731938, 25.630909326151272, 9.539769788835896, 44.75633885626322, 37.21050430997048, 38.60455348980258, 38.36644618134495, 37.78137195143962, 33.68378199562334], + "dssim": [0.30443509937481494, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46413313984655863, 0.1577183451183543, 0.3349859636578546, 0.23235123841917354, 0.21926545753089183, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40873065870931174, 0.2494180607459915, 0.39356559647449113, 0.24787718119904006, 0.15134956977012332, 0.258286989155169, 0.36633790738769567, 0.19788371457345805, 0.22910002064539498, 0.14816459583518116, 0.33312895836301226, 0.36861431474780126, 0.22149923685742468, 0.14953348052452742, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23760284584869135, 0.09883380360594773, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23290819139808489, 0.3104414597369676, 0.22312031298351964, 0.32466538924254496, 0.35969815216567946] + } + }, + { + "label": "32 B fit1+nearest", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=1 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.83931392509975, 9.227271661692745, 26.12880613999717, 10.029980708100208, 13.67982660514298, 10.085553291632461, 14.511036674376811, 3.5386890019903396, 11.31029406899651, 12.182939525256975, 10.643717173667637, 10.295919052463752, 4.143004757002201, 11.772895201137443, 19.129723683363835, 11.304025397761789, 12.318362839007058, 10.55303602973478, 18.649710274802274, 14.187513760638138, 12.006824494758593, 4.528931204619935, 13.18052886966758, 12.560819069864097, 2.3104916804229925, 13.850797185982646, 13.24619735547037, 12.484337803148131, 9.115905015481268, 10.948755634042763, 14.953251286809788], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.47223385718237, -264.3699831763988, -1231.3145346233512, -137.13090987968513, -323.38820985638574, -237.52864687515057, -437.42645245391236, -63.840241925493075, -376.37098891639164, -350.11422876048323, -255.97300766846013, -168.24176886040595, -64.10129373001581, -285.7439574454411, -850.9916432775633, -295.43298880648433, -289.71588442313276, -124.39461483107183, -662.7549063216238, -694.4439038466368, -298.62029197460197, -65.83283339224892, -440.88294863227975, -248.01536276973184, -59.060050325336135, -420.48381090834494, -302.4373391892635, -376.0541898786775, -248.56912907753838, -437.56803951386826, -670.216445207129], + "butteraugli": [23.83582085107369, 27.85936778679969, 45.13848906394811, 26.859409908988084, 24.887303125525772, 21.98665764161018, 39.16437664248624, 13.228263741371308, 21.682223561848947, 42.91961336981089, 21.53573344418942, 26.993626116438765, 22.499011413853726, 22.14435879564802, 37.554783028178, 28.943465007532367, 32.12814769906726, 48.538925215628545, 49.33125892690665, 25.72773485811634, 39.7687757811795, 16.393335651492702, 22.374909037367548, 25.6427168032252, 9.539769788835896, 44.75633885626322, 37.21050430997048, 38.19442303345958, 38.36644618134495, 37.78458073377545, 33.68378199562334], + "dssim": [0.30445120722507435, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46413313984655863, 0.15769236404488235, 0.3349715401528728, 0.23253693311252893, 0.21926545753089183, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40873065870931174, 0.2494180607459915, 0.39356559647449113, 0.24787718119904006, 0.15134956977012332, 0.258286989155169, 0.3662727140637734, 0.19788371457345805, 0.22910002064539498, 0.14816459583518116, 0.3347785004335774, 0.3686123051066601, 0.22147128604480232, 0.14933223733175655, 0.2940122301328453, 0.23763256372678399, 0.09883380360594773, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23290819139808489, 0.3106893011096582, 0.22312031298351964, 0.3250029857990322, 0.35969815216567946] + } + }, + { + "label": "32 B scale_fit=2", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.732481755095158, 9.227271661692745, 26.132265368449314, 9.964975545570006, 13.68632453125632, 10.061493522100632, 14.496156711283698, 3.546093866280474, 11.31477624486425, 12.163494725380827, 10.484545860721108, 10.383097528082137, 4.158197734079072, 11.70303223532246, 19.152793021541186, 11.363782568365917, 12.287870304976316, 10.452766365016844, 18.635679814672578, 14.1889049721474, 12.004378320050252, 4.546818370176457, 13.184053305448325, 12.498954427702786, 2.313088401063057, 13.850797185982646, 13.22846731300584, 12.428195095110516, 9.115905015481268, 10.934529567859181, 14.956857678039745], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.5876156427685, -264.3699831763988, -1231.4991208944045, -135.6667650476674, -324.42205703309105, -237.79959282382862, -437.75467426950206, -63.827906084469475, -380.3075966983766, -348.71914399286965, -255.60502777753754, -166.52945151811105, -64.09525897625983, -285.34413521159956, -849.5040881119851, -296.5010018438042, -289.2420687724772, -124.78523013606096, -665.5799977670439, -694.2580888192072, -298.68063750157233, -65.83722827317064, -440.8425360463657, -248.65071237758286, -58.96361569647502, -420.48381090834494, -301.9984289515023, -377.42797441863394, -248.56912907753838, -435.6538244809873, -673.3961065199403], + "butteraugli": [23.435944238076512, 27.85936778679969, 45.11079851641973, 26.908482764492266, 24.945950295854306, 21.989940512908586, 39.448195323978005, 13.217140823883767, 21.56733142200713, 42.78374244750978, 21.434699454100866, 27.982900131331736, 22.43497709145254, 22.158587568344235, 37.558481373095454, 29.260349357844103, 32.12416924924613, 48.52818010570504, 49.16714098658199, 25.722475101995602, 39.77201881839138, 16.32575594833383, 22.38386188731938, 25.86398694239519, 9.18016555051682, 44.75633885626322, 37.18434534543133, 38.43532732417756, 38.36644618134495, 37.78137195143962, 33.64490294541727], + "dssim": [0.3044559823481988, 0.30528943403583575, 0.4641888712796783, 0.15730413662659165, 0.3349656956325875, 0.23307673680039603, 0.21953219700845283, 0.08462325741418492, 0.40872034068034635, 0.25187006213597896, 0.3935732114960927, 0.24746568036127997, 0.1513107686053135, 0.25818254928384166, 0.36624444004397544, 0.19874108894276593, 0.22907746572349513, 0.14788290805958865, 0.3359665398321977, 0.36861431474780126, 0.22149263173721606, 0.14944213793573624, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23764930383207883, 0.09775628086962707, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23289936134655115, 0.30975590569306877, 0.22312031298351964, 0.32466538924254496, 0.35971205815187657] + } + }, + { + "label": "32 B fit2+nearest", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.732481755095158, 9.227271661692745, 26.132265368449314, 9.964975545570006, 13.682665046984484, 10.05692963809728, 14.494212677472683, 3.546093866280474, 11.31477624486425, 12.163494725380827, 10.497832214163996, 10.383097528082137, 4.158197734079072, 11.70303223532246, 19.119450589264932, 11.363128801908015, 12.287870304976316, 10.452766365016844, 18.6335048586791, 14.187513760638138, 12.004378320050252, 4.53453280896557, 13.18052886966758, 12.536637930732004, 2.313088401063057, 13.850797185982646, 13.22846731300584, 12.431950271189576, 9.115905015481268, 10.948755634042763, 14.956857678039745], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.5876156427685, -264.3699831763988, -1231.4991208944045, -135.6667650476674, -324.9088051150927, -237.38311512484933, -438.0601049418226, -63.827906084469475, -380.3075966983766, -348.71914399286965, -255.52891796709457, -166.52945151811105, -64.09525897625983, -285.34413521159956, -849.6434678189291, -299.00832443364527, -289.2420687724772, -124.78523013606096, -665.3142728607577, -694.4439038466368, -298.68063750157233, -65.86106673303718, -440.88294863227975, -248.91438226575417, -58.96361569647502, -420.48381090834494, -301.9984289515023, -375.9381598543246, -248.56912907753838, -437.56803951386826, -673.3961065199403], + "butteraugli": [23.435944238076512, 27.85936778679969, 45.11079851641973, 26.908482764492266, 25.02609077691466, 21.991336758141482, 39.462201888651094, 13.217140823883767, 21.56733142200713, 42.78374244750978, 21.447957690529957, 27.982900131331736, 22.43497709145254, 22.158587568344235, 37.563081672397495, 29.203840260008736, 32.12416924924613, 48.52818010570504, 49.15686477174511, 25.72773485811634, 39.77201881839138, 16.40723838156284, 22.374909037367548, 25.884708300308827, 9.18016555051682, 44.75633885626322, 37.18434534543133, 38.44626860137244, 38.36644618134495, 37.78458073377545, 33.64490294541727], + "dssim": [0.3044559823481988, 0.30528943403583575, 0.4641888712796783, 0.15730413662659165, 0.3349561860056227, 0.23346631942224577, 0.21932663852413126, 0.08462325741418492, 0.40872034068034635, 0.25187006213597896, 0.3935590822443611, 0.24746568036127997, 0.1513107686053135, 0.25818254928384166, 0.3662208819835619, 0.1988011831034413, 0.22907746572349513, 0.14788290805958865, 0.3357381126794837, 0.3686123051066601, 0.22149263173721606, 0.149321809965344, 0.2940122301328453, 0.23765298622316672, 0.09775628086962707, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23289936134655115, 0.3094511167445223, 0.22312031298351964, 0.3250029857990322, 0.35971205815187657] + } + }, + { + "label": "21 B shipped-quant", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.898548020995201, 9.676118423937845, 26.135445509393843, 11.718609542730094, 14.234094471730877, 11.655187395986866, 15.65947719231447, 4.261196374388893, 11.730666691527015, 12.654581481253432, 11.445229116029624, 14.76495393121619, 4.6188985939539755, 12.936449028384004, 19.815237755941787, 12.637438301378495, 13.512258075203562, 10.888840678902518, 19.744326266649484, 14.27854100631581, 14.181896085186226, 5.255036309077364, 13.75268897226279, 13.078267278300428, 2.944840689566194, 14.984169611061283, 16.754409904256637, 13.88293595499416, 10.372979020507321, 12.019332139948624, 16.269326516058413], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.03979931800603, -271.92958478951033, -1231.3071028885745, -233.1577499107147, -368.36208436275444, -330.2703871825091, -486.3123989847178, -64.17629183902068, -423.9405391968735, -346.9686488747198, -315.53245757462724, -382.2909142961937, -64.22960396967628, -344.39809227445255, -901.7783898020552, -331.6556196465076, -327.7089751273666, -124.36787523430155, -757.5043356081856, -701.6239289533404, -372.3523476495265, -67.17652532710528, -467.0644047364017, -277.02511999065223, -62.31374406473478, -501.6099395110882, -460.44000652462853, -440.31994883521963, -319.3484389994837, -508.2522217203617, -750.1130339337706], + "butteraugli": [26.74363422910824, 26.90151162422623, 45.249860601500984, 32.64353433761966, 29.146052879867494, 26.81950262959032, 41.971207670225404, 13.509537386023837, 23.47630886361927, 50.94035147525244, 26.70035778042106, 43.73703091831673, 25.332219594072644, 23.49614672169069, 39.406894386322556, 30.61390516072879, 32.064597161171854, 54.62358765970066, 52.77495012608002, 25.916239256112192, 47.5998560859857, 19.02457187481052, 24.035827925919936, 28.278906775514987, 12.199451723423257, 51.32310023411181, 69.22299769518894, 43.821127829537595, 48.16952332216738, 39.55822246575629, 34.967217548210435], + "dssim": [0.30459632102745926, 0.30607422069996526, 0.4638550253263906, 0.17049915569470442, 0.3358573883356122, 0.25494236243091806, 0.22061580979516388, 0.08501138348313048, 0.4097490591693022, 0.24424776419718908, 0.3943991325597557, 0.2605006762069356, 0.15177700296797808, 0.2617480501620931, 0.3685640439993073, 0.1975942077987145, 0.23498351785384491, 0.15038858497067026, 0.33490738576380497, 0.3685090560637123, 0.22435740929621345, 0.14939991177157697, 0.2959973904329626, 0.23801057100664214, 0.14307328047028706, 0.2842285445674956, 0.24523354359798355, 0.3191050772831113, 0.22918206720038042, 0.3328103802053529, 0.3613550089673684] + } + }, + { + "label": "21 B fit2+nearest", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.794731885304666, 9.678919268690597, 26.16106090376372, 11.759014467944237, 14.23515153219447, 11.663829551071226, 15.583055828967005, 4.290982019343043, 11.72253470058808, 12.624194648770162, 11.34514577660275, 14.941960286478974, 4.532613407613387, 12.802607459156176, 19.797292936029795, 12.506122763137906, 13.471903882570349, 10.792201372212412, 19.778471450584732, 14.22702840679351, 14.296237939877251, 5.24874778422154, 13.77010284826067, 13.128692921392133, 2.7663962766129964, 14.984169611061283, 16.72694887391114, 13.794146809817372, 10.414939843036455, 11.916138758534617, 16.28054893378419], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.5688120779549, -272.0352235458407, -1233.0245578056424, -234.48058237232254, -364.98759642242567, -330.32352370021897, -485.09070017758074, -64.17765769976404, -423.994438277888, -347.9119114020199, -315.001118698847, -381.15525957192295, -64.22938598760823, -344.0658643542037, -902.0920325764637, -331.11887863919844, -326.9678323765577, -124.15673275360945, -757.5002047162069, -700.426037449964, -368.6905132062912, -67.24062259654045, -467.69557844814153, -277.85711235773397, -62.23961329855064, -501.6099395110882, -460.28640139276627, -440.9986101734544, -324.0455440979956, -506.7969585624246, -749.5998974653855], + "butteraugli": [26.397968200324055, 27.003820561737836, 45.15783401825106, 33.14508050191308, 28.685887651468125, 26.849390641449805, 41.841189983847364, 13.522195648543514, 23.301974614024772, 50.14778294420381, 26.474907770206915, 44.354785935583685, 25.57229551704988, 23.486885212481145, 39.39023454300065, 30.844452626239217, 32.56460669253272, 54.54296362937587, 52.83163417473983, 25.887980765442407, 47.43347748605831, 18.85769843204851, 23.993380485432144, 28.426550574084896, 11.99302350057117, 51.32310023411181, 69.12739798514967, 43.73797044386922, 46.98136336423634, 38.648936370874466, 35.09046463689685], + "dssim": [0.3045168540031019, 0.3061557600191954, 0.46410742715234693, 0.17106263902137842, 0.33583348732821494, 0.2551066589009223, 0.2204616224491418, 0.08503514801228956, 0.40963968775187215, 0.24605676984620944, 0.39437031194517297, 0.26006926567677247, 0.15168143958820046, 0.2615388203566268, 0.368605662462583, 0.1980451812439668, 0.23375411626085402, 0.15038698751848933, 0.3368740144724329, 0.3684686342656588, 0.2246352249712969, 0.15035659477290242, 0.2959128680124318, 0.2381529912298203, 0.1423539154576436, 0.2842285445674956, 0.24444126510421166, 0.3178378723317663, 0.2295909277462408, 0.33233642482574666, 0.36170601776536515] + } + }, + { + "label": "108 B shipped-quant", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.838204011948919, 7.453951149238095, 25.936442060878555, 7.6509909885936285, 11.826480822363104, 8.12615141748936, 12.081026105094894, 2.876928662854907, 9.877878054669864, 9.084124864884718, 9.9428933859377, 7.800284544757563, 3.55008584103457, 10.164507096743312, 16.75912696597293, 9.334573449232558, 10.260464448685456, 7.503126311220218, 14.984942826010485, 14.24235308587455, 9.261937419473188, 3.607147773257744, 10.812648536988199, 11.214742215887687, 2.278538801479341, 10.689375872053363, 10.391225442610422, 9.583769903817277, 6.167856564760884, 8.525121531859435, 12.528219451682357], + "ssimulacra2": [-114.09152762573112, -144.6581883165179, -1215.853628863129, -86.45848241742246, -232.1155675337531, -123.98744140954642, -245.4778366968643, -60.88755805837462, -183.54187937974552, -144.71293216318713, -171.20073235547846, -82.76924182681216, -63.62120960584241, -182.09873742103252, -555.4673853095177, -140.7158176494339, -152.87534039064298, -70.37197591203525, -274.0288630521511, -621.6478024588064, -151.04871061408974, -64.18925457786446, -298.34736083412383, -129.76403310745158, -53.02203899776018, -159.75106245074477, -139.24583182192234, -145.7357717115873, -110.21030752874384, -214.97416650141406, -396.9572256123925], + "butteraugli": [17.212233125132112, 21.777836094535086, 45.00087733367321, 22.913069538635458, 22.60197521456124, 19.66320184042147, 32.4983550887056, 12.55515388889638, 17.264707299462508, 25.878456363605817, 19.22626778469052, 20.52262147093425, 18.899334448861286, 19.364181011888377, 32.08095771313904, 24.865001951411937, 26.334524006959526, 30.9062317422942, 36.58769495802835, 25.295523910193385, 30.638005555683993, 13.798805700196093, 20.89336627306123, 22.32670184517559, 7.399951393039408, 27.94365383666377, 31.954692255311986, 24.401367443436992, 25.69085869362674, 30.005755253608253, 29.16616555102716], + "dssim": [0.30392646784169886, 0.3009004994732122, 0.46305079332625637, 0.1508728832040807, 0.33643911740234544, 0.20675386593754824, 0.22050020299104783, 0.08371212563484476, 0.4038962432872495, 0.2173198290657487, 0.3929722395642649, 0.23363345555153492, 0.15232646047586046, 0.2549091462900187, 0.35892920265385186, 0.20194855792956007, 0.22840818804389257, 0.13201894248116303, 0.31290827270790134, 0.3707170868114261, 0.22220322956264016, 0.14801545797743004, 0.27288168945024494, 0.23635601146216745, 0.08962116812744497, 0.2632653317575516, 0.21313475551929134, 0.2818344321946008, 0.2095149347129342, 0.3059050918822134, 0.35063486754681955] + } + }, + { + "label": "108 B fit2+nearest", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.5682422566891185, 7.45563319380734, 25.980768143969588, 7.611440057762919, 11.755020242725136, 8.102436228670413, 11.958669257009015, 2.8616922239594813, 9.870654034139333, 9.050704386155072, 9.749289649024224, 7.86237557423631, 3.422715683981592, 10.117836326248783, 16.74709038016073, 9.313134440067959, 10.227067161993164, 7.584640386920056, 14.969112521988542, 14.057249038508111, 9.22912206809316, 3.5875998511377456, 10.808177120194852, 11.206601870973376, 2.0360786549050776, 10.698864117390352, 10.261013568563683, 9.402719254267316, 6.172210559253543, 8.517074050245593, 12.485825466256943], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.00623460234368, -144.73223579987467, -1218.3281981887965, -86.52981827245097, -234.77940044419904, -123.23898927418139, -246.8751700257198, -60.95051548600435, -189.28938330471817, -141.7479388575313, -170.76657194124698, -81.13267603393712, -63.37797310399526, -179.3251231573213, -550.7909969572815, -140.96394383073587, -156.46084980250544, -70.37005619775647, -279.7719230527625, -620.7299395932616, -150.58792672913103, -64.19447558900737, -298.5464962970445, -129.6786313536698, -53.142770187525656, -160.41523679049772, -138.80781167228247, -142.33011261231442, -111.11669110011263, -215.83196333328493, -392.51748320810003], + "butteraugli": [17.34713438267529, 21.7451161915597, 44.941208910960256, 22.995160615998596, 22.677337536827576, 19.765508143299094, 32.526377696077034, 12.583038200865351, 17.21969297312572, 25.801442881246818, 19.15617283965661, 20.680313661567116, 18.26683839901661, 19.3782634780293, 32.21090904250011, 24.95843014633097, 26.409358801268837, 31.167784964257958, 36.82624491956051, 25.23743290959297, 31.06701185214855, 13.763560130508756, 20.90173030898021, 22.61343425488214, 6.906968993689179, 28.154567215938176, 31.962515796905347, 24.328068903815602, 25.728886241836577, 30.239059076052115, 29.141037382455693], + "dssim": [0.30389250295510417, 0.3010269043803647, 0.46374195261625734, 0.1524472878186412, 0.3359590255114353, 0.20790010110426155, 0.21999261480903448, 0.08375140940591846, 0.40394944153803325, 0.21538132344862376, 0.3929649666867965, 0.2325146779982366, 0.15153885800812567, 0.2550819264618349, 0.35876449662847965, 0.20322223010482848, 0.2276426282665696, 0.13222869763936734, 0.31413697053999023, 0.3693749222410632, 0.2199720427790256, 0.14817053302824618, 0.2733223411296709, 0.2372295898294503, 0.08769291891458314, 0.26351947215546634, 0.2128452626922328, 0.28237182863889587, 0.2094485459575589, 0.3064219304531417, 0.35101335644700626] + } + }, + { + "label": "411 B shipped-quant", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 3, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [6.338681619587604, 6.126753098302861, 16.859616944401928, 6.012926694805614, 10.46628920371676, 6.398552729086175, 9.102278161203534, 2.635882252689907, 9.224919378820504, 7.175349388673923, 9.307421494615642, 7.14388880771562, 3.2061811599728647, 8.780148925730318, 13.134472995099365, 7.42391328999894, 8.593171072955428, 5.710205185052352, 11.103612552143632, 14.032999921962004, 7.299526951346216, 3.5208984664698786, 9.403806324072475, 8.698750406828122, 2.214343209073327, 8.916343876328211, 8.227219550188822, 6.775685296045623, 4.747983318869868, 6.52961419827247, 10.050124783777205], + "ssimulacra2": [-82.38736426018264, -69.3017441893411, -124.84310135499823, -64.24375258777488, -116.86580454941989, -64.68474439390087, -68.33215054981486, -51.36526092012639, -84.8748032097925, -64.99778781816684, -89.29906933318557, -66.60238214420576, -59.538488683710284, -84.23344983129269, -120.8298057990805, -68.68665673629306, -78.32208748455102, -64.66886892182018, -73.43174794393957, -462.3824354241917, -70.49207747690059, -63.508027511519316, -122.6021798458406, -65.3620387337389, -48.44323844486101, -75.60546745465734, -66.26742157498722, -64.4712461929933, -64.39090028106415, -70.67938228899641, -109.27368026744364], + "butteraugli": [13.669389664449378, 17.854098949008172, 29.63070981956747, 18.8104707491387, 20.557269036692464, 17.480135271440403, 25.51152465514362, 11.890325242803343, 15.541669704674362, 20.123742390802143, 16.65685659759446, 17.87462214184945, 15.65336765172349, 18.172784132244182, 24.28198280784036, 22.478573245248175, 22.427395098977957, 24.65292015426802, 25.724572039975147, 24.767403757551975, 22.290363271439457, 12.400562216449215, 17.161821537310185, 18.3979546470467, 6.0332956527136785, 22.640470919395593, 24.48363329232606, 18.176451078303817, 20.600596099738045, 21.212865410823014, 23.750439278116847], + "dssim": [0.303469727261952, 0.29422556630329577, 0.41636298752403433, 0.14874500851409245, 0.335647083717723, 0.18241936627793143, 0.21561440063360415, 0.08302017475943985, 0.39892734939064034, 0.19390885388554735, 0.38942032981877633, 0.2352893019233438, 0.1534301585239824, 0.25063907737386637, 0.3436318923872034, 0.20611953631311897, 0.2297062123799451, 0.1319184576274235, 0.2817747072495441, 0.3722257056135364, 0.22659414760973506, 0.15095205026848763, 0.2606372347086623, 0.23153857230660096, 0.08173353942502826, 0.2557106234138097, 0.19882215563004152, 0.24153915986248636, 0.1955219018576626, 0.2699387686227517, 0.32976443689374535] + } + }, + { + "label": "411 B fit2+nearest", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 3, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [6.056127569648928, 6.1276403554133525, 16.831879061307614, 6.028126774874794, 10.411440630433274, 6.3760052622764185, 8.875333144308561, 2.60522344856352, 9.2317466621583, 7.074979702141309, 9.0671151794603, 7.187301617678113, 3.073904610939935, 8.71156747129361, 13.107697496464658, 7.266350658592872, 8.563398391670326, 5.7060735508256, 11.055069257156012, 13.698318350215681, 7.130234344888104, 3.509180739986695, 9.385253981319325, 8.632659364360203, 1.8890203192267039, 8.908300028109084, 8.106834239111599, 6.740465706775424, 4.735654212522798, 6.50148585456049, 10.01291197446301], + "ssimulacra2": [-81.51873599415893, -69.32470991760201, -124.02143980015663, -64.23698173660412, -115.1398235627889, -64.64788446058989, -68.09031319662424, -51.23528050891014, -86.13119758253387, -64.97272247470121, -89.29608234346932, -65.87963893468583, -58.43034775451923, -83.64400630634034, -117.89850823370645, -68.46562013685144, -78.98594224708862, -64.61951018854211, -73.1473911558304, -455.87527445146645, -69.19751094121688, -63.4741423878705, -122.4420624442628, -65.03815317527398, -48.113529719671305, -75.37599029870938, -66.18896978445622, -64.38379531138673, -64.45245279736727, -70.43777561628016, -105.24282178062904], + "butteraugli": [13.725902375181144, 17.847500011540873, 29.636726191245632, 18.786715105807893, 20.477774481587886, 17.504844051417354, 25.475493374978672, 11.89670643252141, 15.539689509513963, 20.00905605212432, 16.636779744277607, 17.941680514850482, 15.246335623597039, 18.15106293501198, 24.46921610845915, 22.469713306800404, 22.445055207743536, 24.599816687364164, 25.415741696026743, 24.69488081510866, 22.24932234433916, 12.390524465281125, 17.156355157715968, 18.579923479943123, 5.938390499683734, 22.452242782424225, 24.479211342270407, 18.166509898210595, 19.963297484695328, 21.149860020951106, 23.879436192883148], + "dssim": [0.3034316331627147, 0.29433401932170444, 0.41615095039499017, 0.14959507676431066, 0.33471789479759206, 0.183013779470997, 0.21458487649138652, 0.08286555216563801, 0.3994243062903846, 0.19308328194349467, 0.3895143275722171, 0.2326897524403319, 0.1528447383382705, 0.2510447548276915, 0.34359881470733866, 0.2053539827270069, 0.22925241385082457, 0.1320823394352975, 0.286159434973838, 0.36917565745373515, 0.2219591821711634, 0.15135387640590015, 0.2608829793995999, 0.23200101912753718, 0.08017147679587572, 0.2553415243437285, 0.19767856481883833, 0.24244231307937664, 0.19470680487590336, 0.2708055710153586, 0.32970756018060443] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/final-candidates-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/final-candidates-holdout.json index e0cafeb..891b809 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/final-candidates-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/final-candidates-holdout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/graphics-encoder.json b/tools/comparison/results/graphics-encoder.json index 14e4be5..1f31a29 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/graphics-encoder.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/graphics-encoder.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/graphics-layout.json b/tools/comparison/results/graphics-layout.json index 1077c95..ac1b942 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/graphics-layout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/graphics-layout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/holdout-candidates-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/holdout-candidates-holdout.json index 426a30d..4ad1be1 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/holdout-candidates-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/holdout-candidates-holdout.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "name": "holdout-candidates", "split": "holdout", "settings": { - "description": "Pre-registered validation of the tune-split winners on the never-tuned holdout split (Kodak24 + 4 held-out curated photos). Candidate A is the reallocation alone (luma 4 b x 38, chroma 3 b x 8); the stacked rows add the two encoder-only levers and the anisotropic selection weight. The 21 B rows test whether a sub-tier-0 budget is viable at all - ThumbHash's own size. Every arm pins all four selection/encoder knobs explicitly: the incumbent is the PRE-adoption shipped format, and since §10 adopted L28@4 C15@3 + aniso + fit2 as the defaults, an arm that omitted them would measure the adopted recipe against itself. 'stack' here is the three-knob aniso+fit2+nearest form, without sel_hv; §7.12's STACK adds sel_hv=0.15.", + "description": "Pre-registered validation of the tune-split winners on the never-tuned holdout split (Kodak24 + 8 held-out curated photos). Candidate A is the reallocation alone (luma 4 b x 38, chroma 3 b x 8); the stacked rows add the two encoder-only levers and the anisotropic selection weight. The 21 B rows test whether a sub-tier-0 budget is viable at all - ThumbHash's own size. Every arm pins all four selection/encoder knobs explicitly: the incumbent is the PRE-adoption shipped format, and since §10 adopted L28@4 C15@3 + aniso + fit2 as the defaults, an arm that omitted them would measure the adopted recipe against itself. 'stack' here is the three-knob aniso+fit2+nearest form, without sel_hv; §7.12's STACK adds sel_hv=0.15.", "corpus": "photo", "backdrops": "white", "alphaFidelity": false, @@ -19,12 +19,12 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/holdout-candidates.json", - "configSha256": "e1b24af4bceda4a6fe9a2addd64f16ecba635550d262d49d1a7f43cc687c111b", + "configSha256": "a3b6f01b03c9032bfb1f77eeed2981ac7784bd1ea5323ba4144b75689faf6e94", "binaries": { "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" }, diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/precision-by-budget.json b/tools/comparison/results/precision-by-budget.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..df3c2d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/precision-by-budget.json @@ -0,0 +1,565 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "precision-by-budget", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Where does the count-vs-precision optimum sit as the budget moves? The same six precision families (luma 3/4/5/6 bits x chroma 3/4 bits), each filled to the same byte target with as many coefficients as fit, at 16/21/24/48/80 B. The shipped format holds precision constant across its whole tier range; this asks whether that is true of the R-D optimum. Every arm pins the four selection/encoder knobs to their PRE-adoption values so the comparison isolates the layout: §10 adopted aniso=1.2, sel_hv=0.15, scale_fit=2 and ac_nearest=1 as defaults, and an arm that omitted them would silently carry the adopted recipe — which had made the incumbent identical to the L28@4 C15@3 arm it was meant to be measured against.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/precision-by-budget.json", + "configSha256": "faf080c6aa68eb11903b879e12756e979cc56f6094db9b217850a02844823020", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B SHIPPED L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L14@3 C5@3", + "tune": "l1=14:3 c=5:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.965414448363419, 9.446219272790794, 26.133157636143277, 11.875005627440455, 14.921075006114842, 11.789405827385524, 15.74114064573218, 4.639308321016348, 11.80381379219136, 12.625657162717424, 11.560942784827903, 13.41913494376015, 4.7705572994835235, 13.206439115277284, 20.08080263322415, 12.683047717249343, 13.875525022303089, 11.634097190522663, 20.690883528144425, 14.273315001820109, 14.292378423183532, 5.713785348967388, 13.682086218377783, 13.664607975707032, 2.9435941280146185, 14.929651351368738, 16.502281158500587, 14.01194753249025, 11.240443724882356, 11.914496177255245, 18.098046353990775], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.0619778642545, -269.6544443362788, -1231.1153667007184, -241.8783318555271, -383.68739685096847, -330.67594743638807, -492.91538260605193, -64.19843114758706, -420.72627525691973, -342.63140636423964, -319.8585403785554, -271.9646799343493, -64.23040267435306, -344.42918114187944, -907.9488985382991, -326.02417946306525, -341.9381110245828, -143.7197695501805, -766.4062093888873, -699.7858249138983, -391.89882267601195, -68.19422128059156, -462.24603308737085, -284.16580790618065, -61.976705462784196, -494.7396415080418, -427.677149535044, -421.61354178187185, -320.4217481609518, -508.9499394175315, -767.8176865631144], + "butteraugli": [26.802627907684414, 27.945140513526002, 45.297297851921336, 33.42594509212224, 31.858229438426275, 26.43516867909442, 42.62953657388666, 14.354164161759224, 25.063415351334147, 49.145981909743206, 27.638156489718895, 46.80048967615958, 24.597869982120333, 24.85295630786993, 40.813759240237225, 31.051185747556815, 36.138513170732814, 56.60152419022345, 55.10361117684181, 25.906789579235703, 44.20882471800243, 17.479262700266684, 23.41175458139214, 28.031175980022358, 11.175394368025357, 49.63690680178539, 52.38015342636036, 46.035208219945936, 51.27312905996492, 36.983197982046455, 34.827435259646755], + "dssim": [0.30451033923732773, 0.3058888530836519, 0.46392446498481793, 0.17502332966888073, 0.3366323964202663, 0.2599170986855214, 0.22137681063881476, 0.085786386899038, 0.4101225875981113, 0.2570424508921244, 0.3946656464270553, 0.26759408346638247, 0.15182521157080825, 0.26246496843999145, 0.3687132349980724, 0.19909571510440482, 0.23656316073498984, 0.16346121979290346, 0.3383756685394408, 0.368606901093802, 0.22746634810998828, 0.1532170966970408, 0.2916544080050607, 0.2388554328975086, 0.11528991006766853, 0.28472188906026363, 0.23899263347573707, 0.31624592554112707, 0.22858279448097585, 0.331648302779628, 0.3694396218676975] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L12@4 C4@3", + "tune": "l1=12:4 c=4:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.894790249740198, 9.714675712683556, 26.137780746908334, 12.09475921926703, 14.862150345765388, 11.79441787655316, 15.677327140648634, 4.4354681994857845, 11.779398613766164, 12.829795988026312, 11.46408256381205, 14.909642941564067, 4.635563046684221, 13.224498533296066, 19.927939913643925, 12.534934052681178, 13.598344323889467, 12.281981338871432, 20.790044521752385, 14.257565717942684, 14.342288885586903, 5.545544736085064, 14.010386251486036, 13.589173480517108, 3.036459190843057, 14.986955195436794, 16.95626033827857, 14.370915092974434, 10.523509395678047, 12.1081920059906, 18.245357774791035], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.11043272010724, -277.6327692760203, -1230.7226775194076, -253.23702757673004, -367.45309408299244, -333.2259923251673, -491.7450417100056, -64.1753476011823, -429.5018129736359, -350.3515178124353, -314.12462796136737, -387.6390098269084, -64.22981713594339, -347.5528052358669, -902.3515588028265, -330.31303375253367, -327.2330836430124, -139.45369033918234, -813.7819556147058, -700.7312279173755, -375.6008917193568, -67.2993321287257, -468.9620971711546, -277.91189947428217, -62.58094907933426, -504.2709500276037, -461.21914955521424, -441.24639891689503, -329.89689410013347, -513.3136341040567, -774.2302870476032], + "butteraugli": [27.491826496583997, 27.639675703461137, 45.295728772446246, 36.13836618522891, 28.626345497155782, 26.258038429604124, 41.978712392528614, 13.632750428172235, 23.198228997220756, 50.648667982025586, 27.25927376923398, 44.18427870510482, 25.047154846932184, 23.878184363155395, 39.607258566046745, 30.94763640869175, 32.460656109176874, 53.513424322951465, 54.68680091039304, 25.860459963656435, 46.24861358019876, 19.52790632000576, 24.38531477924215, 28.438880526095108, 12.05540376489501, 50.792955043830375, 66.3565876649076, 44.62032006881136, 45.7305237373094, 38.71635772892245, 35.092833449857864], + "dssim": [0.30459911551693397, 0.30625333549185396, 0.46384273571241036, 0.17204135972155, 0.335825296853981, 0.26052806407145723, 0.22044234067233665, 0.08516382002570766, 0.4097434013416081, 0.2576683451621491, 0.39445376760281364, 0.2585873519535825, 0.15178650442517166, 0.262652891406974, 0.3684260931342195, 0.19757114605348014, 0.23412391183246195, 0.15969814445760672, 0.3455885776578975, 0.3685045611361626, 0.22415165512842955, 0.1509275728648758, 0.29527160723829804, 0.23840520563832368, 0.14395099282377988, 0.2839621197591119, 0.24705941211952603, 0.32870714475363993, 0.231289207458461, 0.3334073992585162, 0.36946503553087084] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L10@4 C4@4", + "tune": "l1=10:4 c=4:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.91018787690629, 10.280930403966854, 26.14186633991501, 12.842176719667286, 14.803458087705039, 11.82170342530232, 15.885259540924942, 4.3310108605888304, 12.10286789394251, 13.205024207166764, 11.499715335568169, 14.95616795336874, 4.697923310051483, 13.23307462223868, 20.538468427023606, 12.545134738156976, 13.788615023606356, 12.248958989679021, 20.810445924802586, 14.282180683481393, 14.420959604644604, 5.663538674649352, 14.0823607854546, 13.44098951991282, 3.0274593594677732, 15.130642821822677, 17.496882858414846, 14.092195017099531, 10.972982784091977, 12.275599953740816, 18.268095019257075], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.87812263245425, -305.61100013208574, -1231.3261537707624, -286.76182959656904, -365.24669878782896, -336.20512583909385, -509.74886685031174, -64.18067110302087, -446.9890033607877, -381.5846133124387, -316.88172258471025, -376.3999430940987, -64.23278165801932, -356.43132418895965, -946.3931737232488, -332.45177510952044, -341.0273198703896, -131.34687943044625, -820.5167604477335, -705.3088138166673, -392.9086365843501, -67.63677110016386, -469.68417769876635, -278.8873483175027, -62.680379408293135, -508.0820515065791, -476.3812125338137, -442.64923323202106, -347.3636573185279, -519.5964328210471, -777.0533921460842], + "butteraugli": [28.162961060918704, 30.725166256745826, 45.304164297193985, 38.17832160978435, 29.439980300723423, 25.9844277558408, 43.525243262899664, 13.633709629260247, 22.82264799531445, 52.8037782831715, 26.991642726549458, 45.33214052525785, 26.538003114485324, 24.85594668050148, 41.360769754138424, 31.528234617880543, 33.532256714638066, 53.579360213505275, 55.58206215161474, 25.94479553679774, 45.83043030088106, 19.95906890837907, 24.136365651661265, 28.48238867389287, 12.266620032361034, 49.66010419291103, 63.77934696618494, 45.250549099597485, 45.08296065867046, 40.23074846367092, 35.11524413416107], + "dssim": [0.30459243363945177, 0.3075221398204778, 0.46386517203432176, 0.1748339093766113, 0.3356122449660889, 0.265002516949426, 0.22244136722742053, 0.0851946202906369, 0.4100290522409871, 0.2617471268420788, 0.39450476470084617, 0.25916905048656036, 0.15181275589882381, 0.2626252328340679, 0.370267573824102, 0.19759898881436327, 0.2391176843822153, 0.15771991477751218, 0.34542024756471656, 0.3684957492680049, 0.224941536836955, 0.15088797328715597, 0.2964332792375488, 0.23803460904715784, 0.14391980480962357, 0.28403631538713703, 0.24675586400948268, 0.3256150459784819, 0.23337916274390874, 0.33578821846665174, 0.3688762756728433] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L9@5 C3@4", + "tune": "l1=9:5 c=3:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.920672462115209, 10.5109433974285, 26.135964459389218, 12.998505662278832, 15.453623724598202, 12.92940584208668, 17.57215123880524, 4.319378173121582, 12.592003793737083, 13.23531315406867, 11.483921542675867, 17.226875161719263, 4.696843016936187, 13.151779215802543, 20.526042142492653, 12.588889104948642, 14.388632600782111, 11.697423049425923, 21.13817719328072, 14.288894826227653, 14.71329896634195, 5.792709528914607, 14.170460245136072, 13.66463480565709, 3.015775101594339, 15.169179421171659, 17.79365358047903, 14.73480795667809, 10.956570494950048, 13.063285220940445, 18.55557637485827], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.6316692286789, -303.7371460306153, -1230.4989311345005, -285.14654722563625, -365.04844420764897, -380.94981028702637, -526.2164757459506, -64.1855591233994, -465.8147864146009, -381.9743727004638, -322.21297609403223, -436.9755096446646, -64.23221683995638, -357.25196710166864, -950.9248453236919, -332.7223357100891, -363.45444389875814, -125.99146070353288, -818.3764576966355, -709.4220823484238, -392.02541528280517, -67.95870934209094, -469.61896596926033, -282.46391292956196, -62.72674887621835, -510.5368894954569, -477.8586354188566, -459.7836889163533, -343.20381843129655, -537.4263632406509, -779.6799389259364], + "butteraugli": [27.596843337280514, 30.089617676991228, 45.242846543903234, 37.63743474062738, 30.39122892955736, 35.91037103183746, 43.00750533372642, 13.541788787972905, 25.953515647673537, 53.06505122344563, 28.55774359840093, 55.86327901334116, 26.730549955752537, 24.846338050353783, 41.88121460982277, 31.492834307197313, 38.65288577115087, 56.2152331547263, 55.685547975957775, 25.99034246859826, 46.63077955480323, 19.625948399387706, 24.009773157080307, 28.95508363758528, 12.865534378395177, 50.21202556799192, 65.8734245379984, 49.21596718307319, 51.963237523918565, 46.812155704836435, 35.431616356113274], + "dssim": [0.3045533874073555, 0.30750247698412925, 0.463796676522469, 0.17700853834762675, 0.3356294154297177, 0.2719873459665514, 0.2228078577443961, 0.08512070384776904, 0.4098027825123218, 0.2691898245030949, 0.3946293514403327, 0.2697538853661442, 0.15175836052101138, 0.26233098050061265, 0.37036967401681276, 0.19748776330044887, 0.23500896583043224, 0.1519049173667995, 0.3467988594861901, 0.36853086320736084, 0.22543671188030096, 0.15109715810339308, 0.2967999184572998, 0.2380860131899391, 0.14415846740042348, 0.28447812827123586, 0.24380338645182892, 0.33859512474463527, 0.23194412447700158, 0.34664074664433253, 0.36822183596007346] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L10@5 C4@3", + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=4:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.899022263141804, 10.452488904522735, 26.135964459389218, 12.906469813840458, 14.927885244322255, 11.866171021086995, 15.894115785643933, 4.378182586903726, 12.086944642843207, 13.314878183219557, 11.502568628565472, 14.953676614245355, 4.6389002757300375, 13.384608326125525, 20.491847500226108, 12.576489269210038, 13.812890505047628, 12.262211801633283, 20.78980784057604, 14.28374998711265, 14.414362157285995, 5.702248824586668, 14.009706820296561, 13.662545124699575, 2.942554126133666, 15.128463907282521, 17.555971637591696, 14.233163117589536, 10.963757662935713, 12.315158456295759, 18.165171280551963], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.41969138176643, -300.5011393637137, -1230.4989311345005, -290.0642501125259, -367.67185253516243, -335.64185368708195, -510.57291679352284, -64.18505218662389, -444.1607184246176, -380.8323385470635, -315.7294903420428, -375.20333016245246, -64.23222880465454, -356.3703709515806, -947.41296524225, -332.1822322178692, -343.08677870263296, -125.79323418536305, -814.7380012789996, -704.919026742718, -390.33640461419293, -67.66979518775872, -468.6147859377693, -277.2767853354402, -62.45229409373303, -506.1069012822263, -475.84216722045915, -447.105714375159, -344.5210488633416, -517.6599909980202, -774.1272265310819], + "butteraugli": [27.55256018932323, 30.429194287134617, 45.242846543903234, 37.932521006479554, 29.5161548107322, 26.25692804525778, 43.55035906802663, 13.57250197893223, 22.84713085271221, 52.82489470501364, 27.182297021865775, 45.85777928821512, 26.77383999842655, 24.663689865348818, 41.06349381397777, 31.542438283540978, 33.364003713673384, 54.802476427141215, 55.51022096968421, 25.954253108334147, 46.597009295804895, 19.789485825701604, 24.027419746889677, 28.500011612313273, 12.496872814861385, 49.633227036858365, 65.24837059193338, 43.80831183008812, 51.41528965928122, 40.566351347009665, 35.59132224724661], + "dssim": [0.3045415206883222, 0.3074047466425669, 0.463796676522469, 0.1747601755713581, 0.3355246319373928, 0.262832579024591, 0.22242660479366566, 0.08512059678723594, 0.41006572925224877, 0.2627056479179736, 0.3943808890599167, 0.2585907363375629, 0.1517555117046881, 0.2622869900296818, 0.37035770405516594, 0.19751574138814615, 0.2398491344699631, 0.15401224814628356, 0.3451496445294545, 0.36854406758983094, 0.2254617874870189, 0.1509558078911694, 0.29621123799385085, 0.23809226718727672, 0.14291979459728205, 0.28417143282582746, 0.24970981041534873, 0.322608546501182, 0.23203196868268672, 0.3358889406425578, 0.36660169032323753] + } + }, + { + "label": "16B L8@6 C3@4", + "tune": "l1=8:6 c=3:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.906962867877709, 10.545160940868938, 26.152262607648716, 13.105136523895558, 15.429774548137273, 13.51869585469386, 17.581895146208318, 4.378926485112295, 12.566868206475759, 13.201268375035506, 11.512633953112939, 17.286463466423452, 4.681551368609612, 13.154523582557575, 20.52566740028462, 12.916675064459419, 14.432497696481564, 12.186087343062406, 21.089126030556457, 14.286630680029562, 15.56680340549125, 5.790338804803131, 14.167787981297357, 13.665894282738705, 3.0257903029086273, 15.30126257621546, 17.850609936392843, 14.970225921098017, 10.900953648439508, 13.064397483065472, 18.86116647906629], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.5528197290992, -307.4367640008488, -1232.3641055288513, -281.0691762721195, -364.3465873633921, -408.21657887333174, -525.4774736132996, -64.19136777318457, -466.20878697738476, -381.37172868336955, -327.2331846622619, -434.90862197838885, -64.23230588087674, -358.1520674348643, -949.1547398510986, -338.1712323462745, -358.97833255929356, -134.8144286660026, -826.8386912675944, -707.9883136367476, -400.49596920901877, -67.91947208801147, -470.7090794104855, -282.78491501356194, -62.84290761934284, -508.28107809800395, -477.2165782370787, -460.37810167548696, -341.27685254899944, -539.7697126201449, -793.490829598941], + "butteraugli": [27.540518249034523, 29.888211729076772, 45.27373615755897, 39.78069776743178, 30.181529584179145, 34.74765786410416, 43.199157869268596, 13.567001159981325, 25.927260404489562, 52.8122289263647, 31.12065031285086, 56.997893931454655, 26.6914187150678, 24.792509821218754, 41.7852460221842, 34.80591782633494, 38.68485314426753, 56.25323132176201, 57.22439959776676, 25.997831547374886, 50.68302136810655, 19.558851258394693, 24.12404541023528, 28.915960137100058, 12.871182392252846, 49.40546744403034, 65.51422182536693, 50.07152752009017, 55.80709165284725, 46.669363896198774, 35.47583218982779], + "dssim": [0.3045061463187596, 0.3077334083161637, 0.4637625167496363, 0.17884343398485852, 0.33549636613085965, 0.2729471449206792, 0.2227822028330958, 0.0851261158773573, 0.4097862415725425, 0.2672453474510341, 0.39474734847128495, 0.26849434816604045, 0.1517401553961919, 0.26238580466628403, 0.37037714262142984, 0.19834708456539735, 0.23486276011082818, 0.15626154296970457, 0.3492312009397085, 0.36845553733304015, 0.22930563915173185, 0.15111891651019677, 0.29675299607356753, 0.23812959138869277, 0.14436258584131495, 0.28462938776481994, 0.24426816329423495, 0.34564975195033365, 0.23217067173858652, 0.3472753647489789, 0.3717675647959806] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L22@3 C8@3", + "tune": "l1=22:3 c=8:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.892455328762429, 9.430552746894886, 26.108126241611373, 11.026512042186425, 14.23161364727929, 10.583871161263712, 15.20031298163694, 4.212583300821052, 11.675053958514079, 12.52495354074214, 11.064767553417445, 12.517753926146783, 4.697672780873461, 12.585827640415543, 19.570758212084254, 11.84485682973296, 13.266036592722838, 11.57052202449654, 20.182756797753246, 14.264190180909091, 12.78773040331071, 5.410396797689031, 13.222296944775895, 13.204075871300839, 2.8933011159559188, 14.217595362248058, 14.282784912086983, 12.870289188944835, 10.203786447425816, 11.254713118129978, 15.642437135180755], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.44327512822358, -276.27345991251764, -1229.4648197629322, -185.22092440539132, -358.07884080895866, -258.14987222800573, -465.501805665417, -64.13655394072134, -406.4084684929512, -347.21888266513594, -272.17073116772997, -235.9203165104351, -64.23246398309263, -307.85319053023943, -885.1311667703538, -320.2539394044981, -326.75167896593507, -146.99781817726853, -757.3438934242632, -693.7360682452106, -327.7121067996852, -67.91412398129245, -447.0244613681392, -254.45883361485863, -61.414629213435006, -453.4014251461292, -326.30065294070687, -395.8780712322588, -258.51337852065825, -457.48267961878594, -681.6055222009416], + "butteraugli": [25.35599648617675, 29.288887548900913, 45.27192173606508, 29.43487690690523, 27.2941015645917, 23.59215122916305, 41.053003250070006, 14.107959622850492, 24.812339386826398, 45.412705726487786, 22.36541235853421, 43.37487594437076, 23.415643052489525, 23.607858306041425, 38.865848106329516, 30.465560646010193, 35.277980146547286, 47.593015735351344, 54.10644747763693, 25.84042124947878, 43.26863894352141, 17.12096045395469, 22.793618758819008, 26.290821735066306, 9.270839963089879, 48.799708552018075, 42.15472894565329, 39.42114735474163, 46.00816547173977, 36.92196836580265, 33.44863360000991], + "dssim": [0.3044586142621821, 0.30616251061041766, 0.46380663724915655, 0.16632584069216277, 0.335368784700229, 0.24739722049414908, 0.22094290772229835, 0.08578332492780144, 0.40997881438187417, 0.2615729851911788, 0.3940914941070493, 0.2640481000380247, 0.15195083011823102, 0.26160919979196295, 0.36785631233843696, 0.20085040372716711, 0.23541191855224058, 0.1590641668236732, 0.3408615565340831, 0.36875665622915454, 0.2269645512473391, 0.1516070065168167, 0.2906472310856172, 0.23785736771617233, 0.11578016360875404, 0.2843497317538739, 0.2365137761837129, 0.3121947455293229, 0.22324499573709466, 0.3327321762207658, 0.35918765753375315] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L19@4 C6@3", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.855430143030249, 9.431467182332849, 26.127601387743756, 11.861584685456245, 14.131127443907777, 10.606023777611865, 15.300082080282982, 4.3416880437088965, 11.559522076955277, 12.386658556136721, 10.94366207688423, 12.32557612410197, 4.693064375431719, 12.712906143391715, 19.511481547298462, 12.022608206968538, 12.98250889950063, 10.815238869191965, 19.753287471255156, 14.27151358367994, 13.286741457141956, 4.992113134105085, 13.560972766431364, 13.289168624661054, 2.7962322707760263, 14.477040324257986, 14.284070906262272, 13.530337360980932, 9.986484150320067, 11.507754933208828, 16.216053672331217], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.93542770363422, -272.92273767945403, -1230.147004550729, -224.2097279961822, -346.63873765478036, -271.19963605284914, -466.86744701641953, -64.0609106169357, -412.8450600778564, -334.2459739749702, -275.98635230487906, -227.5594752107778, -64.22966778999813, -318.3866243085893, -881.409455112315, -305.2409899253503, -316.11864317539255, -118.52194617240315, -749.1943885420557, -697.4764827503782, -356.9330054611015, -66.88124120839564, -452.65695576657254, -275.0988864758775, -60.76601711128916, -481.9659005499094, -321.1818130805956, -408.10123597063205, -290.16004684232985, -480.8068995417033, -719.767338320577], + "butteraugli": [25.490520193676335, 27.25852240774442, 45.2968711686295, 30.78782968958794, 26.39095403040368, 23.8268281714076, 41.3934649212371, 13.504139762644817, 22.838939953427623, 47.97413412771306, 23.10944892518059, 41.9722367416805, 24.088866631054305, 23.111287515964808, 38.190479720753835, 29.674456501218796, 32.3911192757588, 51.19863230388631, 51.59560934598852, 25.823556929120866, 42.62290700063205, 16.641738758297322, 22.65560732632301, 26.92663424132975, 9.41708367085686, 48.52412618395423, 39.4413252361669, 45.23180933151459, 36.27984572630638, 36.139701918566054, 33.936807271789846], + "dssim": [0.3045642477834234, 0.3059111282823136, 0.4638901069765008, 0.17006810651012122, 0.3349904630833903, 0.24978854469289985, 0.21964684474048607, 0.08514687350703104, 0.4096420162010174, 0.24866577270495327, 0.393755925097175, 0.2569555316636257, 0.15187382371906527, 0.2617625511581432, 0.36779750371610653, 0.19773419775997886, 0.23236090669846055, 0.14688931338478756, 0.3356114841911718, 0.36858317296101395, 0.2244005710938356, 0.149235038199169, 0.2943401890429027, 0.23834029203536294, 0.11812213850285164, 0.2844451746853517, 0.2354440477830711, 0.32272284575710297, 0.22639607147351493, 0.3323312815502022, 0.36078368262352395] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L16@4 C6@4", + "tune": "l1=16:4 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.886089369320656, 9.477719846998383, 26.131090899451987, 11.639218808408964, 14.185657497043957, 10.623389113526253, 15.586067030422955, 4.220711332958322, 11.64930997493298, 12.417495806891518, 11.464427559172378, 12.481789685473892, 4.674549190647808, 12.792894831911466, 19.730192958306016, 12.232196803144712, 13.44684355797718, 10.854415496245903, 19.80132119233106, 14.26332973324847, 13.726550971259723, 4.932484875393112, 13.641261302400437, 13.034792592618055, 2.800631291121672, 14.553818737388026, 14.355180453523246, 13.415268026511045, 10.215717400432233, 11.597501307976636, 16.265520999790585], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.6250159152916, -276.9852827713786, -1230.1019726816157, -228.61167017900016, -361.81156397570385, -279.3862291700706, -484.5979955170071, -64.06549105899609, -423.81300117857006, -332.6437738086578, -316.99229898382964, -235.81529072243666, -64.22948628368829, -327.5220399391565, -899.7473502735157, -312.56017078720214, -323.8390007381827, -128.52887505076023, -759.7899068292863, -698.56843476559, -375.76102967157806, -66.90618714869768, -455.5716581009318, -274.8863583710462, -61.0500658650015, -478.83064087560786, -322.8065621051892, -410.0484862430332, -295.51310708737395, -484.46094218322946, -745.8225545014476], + "butteraugli": [27.098970654822683, 26.995691488632435, 45.29872516459445, 32.67870201296592, 27.981943017588446, 24.354527969927915, 41.9946040654237, 13.459030974670151, 23.20683896466488, 50.12843719270429, 26.400849916791305, 41.37628392940212, 24.8675949826097, 23.210775790709274, 40.01339155797192, 30.200202595964356, 32.24132375304006, 53.59941773437192, 51.98860845627894, 25.84349648594565, 43.7844522180413, 16.887606844326402, 22.613917482074182, 26.79627892011206, 9.718298473601056, 49.99829213512704, 42.72460585930753, 45.43608028096579, 36.253224588110804, 37.36504181117203, 34.25067812502616], + "dssim": [0.3044509032018571, 0.30615497323133867, 0.46390583371082367, 0.17023226344811748, 0.3359873793541581, 0.25089587242888545, 0.22057585764532345, 0.08512072183931901, 0.40990308858038543, 0.24508144709027907, 0.39455306551905317, 0.25669563202226076, 0.15168878583358625, 0.2619204617850619, 0.368542302942933, 0.19796316123136776, 0.23399165004609096, 0.14761647749742357, 0.33672509634857506, 0.36853005952894585, 0.2263887655429273, 0.14906589506321272, 0.2949973344718555, 0.23813154404953207, 0.1181681848042031, 0.2842029723817091, 0.22946354881206704, 0.3200288233619256, 0.22785088195908837, 0.33003530180009677, 0.3621748387746036] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L14@5 C5@4", + "tune": "l1=14:5 c=5:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.905037176345134, 9.562716264654346, 26.134253108246824, 11.57894824046908, 14.645698576907614, 11.532476246626878, 15.514643358504799, 4.252804020900298, 11.67453249607007, 12.525522854987434, 11.445229116029624, 12.843907926424235, 4.640047839479585, 12.928533347047214, 19.979745010519373, 12.531810982379454, 13.61113475765916, 10.839660364008033, 20.208715713937558, 14.268432957894815, 13.875272368634015, 5.328906602648202, 13.732618872083334, 13.213699811803599, 2.8100381702784105, 14.851125719641754, 15.89718894554412, 13.656233559949507, 10.222744873015447, 11.74530286942832, 17.936792491008198], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.72204364880605, -268.34070752675734, -1231.3123400755894, -231.03207665792723, -371.43439476753827, -319.83986132808155, -490.35784786765623, -64.16073339560856, -424.2591439062527, -337.7154646562139, -315.53245757462724, -273.13225034826365, -64.22931215726376, -340.17946930929156, -901.9691130295769, -318.05763352448866, -328.72957377899445, -125.28230470422884, -761.0382170142196, -701.8141913028317, -371.0442206639204, -66.92495827756187, -462.81561828313966, -277.78399649382936, -61.444825914846064, -488.7516486754739, -435.13440578513973, -419.5528212070942, -309.64985582668464, -497.4037357148427, -762.3614434851999], + "butteraugli": [26.483822937718873, 27.132539039714526, 45.244588405577424, 33.450318237076154, 29.18038170125001, 25.77859767459495, 42.30069104720843, 13.535321184879692, 23.49634205958887, 50.530667690240854, 26.70035778042106, 42.562705072832976, 25.157296184520778, 23.3966374420218, 39.52764310138886, 30.823032848264717, 32.0610307528403, 55.32497691357654, 52.08215343485861, 25.85995680880882, 44.335965060980925, 17.257675527041144, 23.181526490429622, 27.604708085524777, 10.57140180386891, 48.2378060628873, 52.562495416566726, 46.320599248736166, 44.70160238545555, 38.438976592092786, 35.06246369860949], + "dssim": [0.30445385798485414, 0.3058116832843314, 0.463854257664142, 0.17060407116124843, 0.3360343369248152, 0.2563724516594944, 0.22090958526954607, 0.08505207121984998, 0.41015123858363406, 0.24567728579611786, 0.3943991325597557, 0.2594349264466439, 0.15164104858974065, 0.2619701427912592, 0.3685283337300146, 0.19767668657279852, 0.234969396267233, 0.15057182994658042, 0.3363639527587511, 0.3684853243154299, 0.22603737783469718, 0.15114019760276404, 0.2926969795002724, 0.23823509685691868, 0.1150252066007999, 0.2843590269098639, 0.23701101680401782, 0.3143762850052274, 0.22797407811093678, 0.3293743541192544, 0.3657296267111282] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L16@5 C5@3", + "tune": "l1=16:5 c=5:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.87427033448138, 9.410303315307415, 26.128198129001067, 11.671946463529656, 14.74031676941634, 10.75224199573569, 15.52146797258537, 4.2999415083162855, 11.606308532276973, 12.400336183322302, 11.445229116029624, 12.460587725583382, 4.60687850385038, 12.973547749809788, 19.85618498692992, 12.3041756916542, 13.565533459278534, 10.629702683559277, 20.22206697242728, 14.267317920278954, 13.709732963092456, 5.262229665883602, 13.612371073411357, 13.364263127219553, 2.769338190277369, 14.57982653678741, 14.378508059673374, 13.575191440833732, 10.082391869514446, 11.613686571156425, 17.8693586605548], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.3924722185482, -271.3933430856239, -1230.5659988358846, -228.2636372719884, -369.8676556354031, -281.29960453451883, -487.6416998959546, -64.08455689125663, -420.0131544145445, -329.73823720978373, -315.53245757462724, -245.23422049097337, -64.2293069406723, -327.1399922121635, -900.5898084186183, -310.17508910473657, -324.45379280552174, -123.63016525896217, -760.8943390842229, -698.2060688004354, -370.00508590472356, -66.9158137332364, -452.7988483856295, -274.9107408329311, -60.887619912362425, -479.7691742395292, -322.5992700723239, -414.81776060367235, -295.59748822581975, -482.6138596753003, -758.624741441465], + "butteraugli": [26.502106308215843, 26.5470839885781, 45.252880986669986, 32.821745885435654, 28.230862238223224, 24.36273304225189, 42.16408159112288, 13.324407482448962, 23.278729405224606, 50.6947295047099, 26.70035778042106, 40.163770698647845, 25.12445982012885, 23.16938666988305, 39.816035627391194, 30.012154986056384, 31.904565688203093, 53.524291195976666, 51.902836810895785, 25.79083808356039, 44.78424928971759, 17.000539808182427, 22.812645412926496, 26.642741157714127, 9.795544544434534, 48.59963329779146, 43.08474630202527, 44.26824044389017, 39.78084044932964, 37.94238878542583, 34.837637154982126], + "dssim": [0.30449217445396437, 0.3058355374680247, 0.46386354199108076, 0.1702888046090339, 0.3361882061267648, 0.2473430305021303, 0.22076669443560387, 0.08502503419124124, 0.4099853787494619, 0.24387519256820378, 0.3943991325597557, 0.25761472590024237, 0.1516112353980097, 0.2614958813138195, 0.3685645149801522, 0.19797837321893802, 0.23454972787679101, 0.1457091799173565, 0.33657505987360914, 0.36853481355385986, 0.22558612141731865, 0.15087156202984509, 0.2918345804803112, 0.23837475246590573, 0.1119925525113597, 0.2842946508394656, 0.23406284089498258, 0.3132317018390578, 0.22638247256224153, 0.32925372128604546, 0.3631780467526078] + } + }, + { + "label": "21B L13@6 C4@4", + "tune": "l1=13:6 c=4:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.913386418295497, 9.664030576735925, 26.136135505946815, 11.761275440130605, 14.625784957434554, 11.695621625395662, 15.580691931113796, 4.269960281378249, 11.730344955621819, 12.676934607114035, 11.421029590310264, 14.83988319368489, 4.627174656092359, 13.083933053320017, 20.026977726773666, 12.58249487110482, 13.603089854656636, 11.531747401613407, 20.22403225820896, 14.257878818691069, 14.210644534812586, 5.551712712676983, 13.986319317689041, 13.311926489574955, 2.9525902907559542, 15.011265700213459, 16.811000269165834, 13.935214656679682, 10.332063147062556, 12.00375668304879, 17.991113585608105], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.68912200605985, -271.795982866249, -1231.3692525756378, -235.47106756647497, -368.59911128487636, -331.39205007383146, -487.4353901598214, -64.17524125842462, -425.17035873894065, -347.69730257699445, -314.13517480139046, -380.2636685763507, -64.22970170738824, -347.1455586789717, -903.420932917712, -331.4900082964761, -327.53664997111116, -124.94057476396551, -763.4545046064823, -701.034208001108, -370.6642618627785, -67.26859103362327, -468.000486969838, -279.87302279185604, -62.32489633753633, -503.47516150014815, -461.83555641645876, -439.89656673149307, -322.10302509990936, -508.44041738258466, -764.825881498697], + "butteraugli": [26.80006586612021, 26.990966429750234, 45.243053954611604, 32.891076224046294, 29.198953703276334, 27.046516162655866, 41.8731480308877, 13.516864599158273, 23.15766318191793, 51.04207968467815, 26.925346198474973, 44.6036748462781, 25.248005011109772, 23.51047078040436, 39.29541500736293, 30.75603061847703, 32.402695428697655, 54.78963148186498, 52.931771212694, 25.853601103956706, 47.01034797921116, 19.18211958501627, 24.002796152190417, 28.216443051632286, 11.947660590432628, 50.79062576263187, 69.26850890804792, 43.8984982554594, 48.08415409696849, 39.30175903006696, 35.176938994161254], + "dssim": [0.304585292717685, 0.30605233094619544, 0.46383911215036505, 0.17100370834784878, 0.335867740329099, 0.2567027279844226, 0.2205308971030875, 0.08504529340578237, 0.4096910570866054, 0.24944898960270656, 0.3943727994590443, 0.2596815947107356, 0.1517861145894548, 0.2620758698779504, 0.36855255762799244, 0.1975515631561306, 0.23412820714752436, 0.15119459393774054, 0.3376893762518528, 0.36848985784001176, 0.22400724431316577, 0.15090623209474657, 0.295761900752331, 0.23828790993384635, 0.14284794426603664, 0.284243682694702, 0.24560138308902446, 0.32148076222252175, 0.22993757156443434, 0.3323584932534195, 0.366274979931878] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L27@3 C9@3", + "tune": "l1=27:3 c=9:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.901309836888594, 9.470273929722058, 26.10339255273845, 10.362656370898005, 14.215459346425577, 10.490411727452921, 14.761769563387356, 4.128216332681891, 11.242834452814723, 12.292735379857177, 10.899405554435278, 11.211880555907793, 4.505101215819644, 12.324222962333616, 19.34927870771376, 11.428968717210747, 13.044898125955283, 11.472474191503595, 19.29562368092695, 14.244971023352706, 12.414339595754212, 5.2644543696638575, 13.221249747654177, 13.22047730296157, 2.7634222553564705, 13.950457244914652, 14.210514022486306, 12.708579129031225, 9.629925534004322, 10.778824953729078, 15.55088453636429], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.15355567745414, -275.09154160504215, -1231.4845813702161, -139.1744752554775, -352.33878823502175, -249.91225139394646, -440.13627293264176, -63.97946628216209, -315.25277248022377, -356.31719991801896, -256.4987068058946, -183.06965136720265, -64.21632602999449, -292.37499896755764, -862.1712867344072, -302.23390780473596, -327.04528873794976, -156.9261955233551, -678.3816976345746, -694.5067435361703, -307.020896482291, -68.18802129973707, -446.8153668299012, -254.7095124916982, -60.404891022548725, -420.760953908602, -329.71468176949764, -384.7668748702025, -237.61238360230027, -442.6071840555361, -677.6136272874708], + "butteraugli": [24.079857504544893, 28.19861824031588, 45.26744318588487, 27.895430609756392, 26.376109314780237, 23.284522594298398, 39.98561773641351, 13.98011334951086, 22.2705848900554, 41.972366221600296, 22.562423398415003, 31.45052090034315, 20.9036668707466, 23.481834112135214, 38.39311289965371, 29.639950372867386, 35.27260629299416, 46.36226088936892, 55.086102300624816, 25.891417029285975, 42.02935966192494, 17.160895082328494, 22.77759667321483, 25.926413486708668, 9.684783821029079, 45.2172690881691, 41.12775049722661, 38.86740797227127, 48.01908669016216, 34.6246924637166, 33.79277046425579], + "dssim": [0.30444927559825086, 0.30596515589929296, 0.4639424802738899, 0.1605448354142947, 0.33553642828760344, 0.24233904132619338, 0.2203658919007423, 0.08545860016183943, 0.4065689967641239, 0.2631085762516835, 0.39395526816015863, 0.26166865795168537, 0.15220754908170725, 0.2606602819541409, 0.36698666652884915, 0.20065558351999152, 0.2346461956584931, 0.16454122659375864, 0.33882077721588544, 0.3687647894196033, 0.23005664318577224, 0.15159474744739693, 0.29022419763122065, 0.23804427266065026, 0.10987171479478075, 0.28198454558362906, 0.2416617940126034, 0.3091242184949018, 0.2208490906038033, 0.3225222120404295, 0.3601009692997582] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L22@4 C8@3", + "tune": "l1=22:4 c=8:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.826416856632817, 9.409778748295443, 26.11590942320846, 10.778709684596206, 14.000558168406522, 10.279597344941696, 14.97471361671053, 3.8755727273398652, 11.55818783443475, 12.508134673139471, 10.889105275996025, 11.893787255895663, 4.559534875677784, 12.353964457820835, 19.356970681678458, 11.425583350923988, 12.734583601043447, 11.07723303587427, 19.638917057208943, 14.256900854626112, 12.422489343142518, 4.970403554619095, 13.159164264074347, 12.95432627192799, 2.7184985233922045, 14.018753400317086, 14.003286453244508, 13.04273220514948, 9.284897461642293, 11.092870935542045, 15.583675523508004], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.3047572607806, -275.0341472849444, -1230.6685116789836, -183.12150700690984, -334.2874800234822, -242.58245627271714, -459.8235680080111, -64.03727715679796, -413.9237856658615, -347.34196806064637, -272.23536561944087, -224.64891042780346, -64.23012333089588, -305.24317477778163, -874.5024118084763, -303.87540715713294, -306.9670523747326, -127.53552421540377, -744.630194661232, -694.1357807806895, -322.72293971311944, -66.41693331168565, -444.4568223865608, -250.73811192303907, -60.47938364778204, -444.21005711479927, -313.519196034763, -388.12777233863847, -253.142726544477, -446.66953445586716, -687.4967453692115], + "butteraugli": [24.590330443832745, 27.628361581089493, 45.27868646979882, 29.210981683266468, 25.615150106210965, 22.339923967817374, 40.953608404983626, 13.43628045504019, 22.988842732668687, 45.70742438021072, 22.3800780281246, 40.40505355205705, 23.642597716984614, 22.613705906318284, 37.502975141693156, 29.452364014084804, 32.04517326321423, 48.19789841538242, 51.27601454607321, 25.729553575929884, 40.74758637464242, 16.631485552873187, 22.63688496247708, 26.15805699381882, 9.155327021109583, 48.38930125484233, 38.52774411092614, 41.41475197001512, 34.216173463777125, 37.06312122749538, 33.067722467003016], + "dssim": [0.3044624872128443, 0.30606172710764545, 0.46383799012443466, 0.164131908047988, 0.334802865210184, 0.2425250407057989, 0.2199385607879778, 0.08508093851914761, 0.4095859048047715, 0.25693825270394066, 0.3938935980808235, 0.25097904815864025, 0.15182250494933563, 0.2606376094567898, 0.3673267558088672, 0.19791053513757784, 0.23150488222341953, 0.1496381346196543, 0.33647498939137144, 0.36862983569202057, 0.22273470142699098, 0.1492561568311656, 0.29092371047890453, 0.23743632438232698, 0.11686001738657986, 0.28378398985982933, 0.23077905867200482, 0.32532733771888867, 0.22526637952263556, 0.33171896657233046, 0.3597597822246672] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L20@4 C7@4", + "tune": "l1=20:4 c=7:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.859547838718275, 9.437887136441885, 26.11939511995114, 11.034831118969409, 13.775156003286975, 10.298153259117493, 15.31526480498084, 3.952936831688404, 11.559522076955277, 12.356055113041052, 10.906153963770914, 11.82448737193234, 4.517268177869875, 12.305292320142021, 19.36748131212674, 12.011432475855887, 12.925860181062658, 10.715797572394248, 19.57918583757791, 14.256556318921453, 12.92962868510856, 4.95233179494931, 13.584791225359464, 12.833176793029319, 2.646779684419648, 14.162082195279805, 13.871273947134547, 13.01983642100712, 9.594078020745666, 11.228749014693348, 15.593976943612702], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.3352242406491, -273.6633356425491, -1230.2694969146332, -218.81591872363356, -335.250841884666, -249.87794477500194, -464.0226219138908, -64.04321353128563, -412.8450600778564, -334.99358041521646, -275.3763917071297, -225.64711490853512, -64.2295383660936, -314.23009766196634, -875.3523954068793, -305.71841495609306, -316.25424978241085, -122.46061757933455, -744.1693319053155, -698.3419581714339, -349.186742764991, -66.89861408375646, -455.16376544434524, -263.33883440993, -60.71424484204957, -460.0495111879876, -317.9594806575099, -389.8347932404016, -272.22798447423344, -455.864017012491, -718.7915778685788], + "butteraugli": [25.495118870170387, 27.39745130733716, 45.28607344869914, 30.33053143951115, 25.386292288979792, 22.615629998037146, 41.47804857175959, 13.497734065994388, 22.838939953427623, 47.883232352910916, 22.216317584503866, 40.49181178583066, 24.261617911102064, 22.84024537729323, 38.16848858016001, 29.812487471683948, 32.43030370334798, 49.52746534760169, 51.17825550312142, 25.83332796474711, 42.10204653067661, 16.652205937245565, 22.646625268895452, 26.76407916118177, 9.43141821063468, 48.31883785956987, 39.00359224321714, 42.166172995271104, 33.9688860624191, 36.27492519864578, 33.68407686159079], + "dssim": [0.3044978461700437, 0.3058824050334068, 0.46382060863992125, 0.16955957145345818, 0.3348047923240137, 0.24435712388572967, 0.21953752907721252, 0.08507662312809844, 0.4096420162010174, 0.24721725777583398, 0.39389922423595836, 0.25035276861316713, 0.15180342991178714, 0.26132889020578653, 0.3675453482370017, 0.19786371470132685, 0.23225736291821691, 0.14641552444802208, 0.3350142693969794, 0.3685505346708957, 0.22360502936537036, 0.14902032409535604, 0.29609293321070007, 0.2376873816357623, 0.11724996139903093, 0.2840320398418652, 0.23310483804335863, 0.32595481863359244, 0.22678061807624933, 0.3309849906066642, 0.3589545904793273] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L17@5 C6@4", + "tune": "l1=17:5 c=6:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.884419793449181, 9.410303315307415, 26.124895057983462, 11.707910318520693, 14.187513589724906, 10.646232176339984, 15.395476071078475, 4.1741370397769115, 11.549793983691892, 12.331580939710237, 11.004432729850892, 12.44737040860763, 4.639315650244716, 12.528673980168415, 19.776518829829467, 12.292321536840054, 13.216468790085447, 10.606560333972519, 19.676451483518704, 14.266116298467905, 13.290910418032382, 4.881437251789376, 13.609964286720297, 13.042989269134624, 2.768450007898892, 14.522129996374765, 14.07155750318744, 13.325900654158044, 10.065136736806998, 11.610518330433587, 15.889742380673868], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.4240451671663, -271.3933430856239, -1230.2746860813795, -230.63894545359398, -367.9473830115979, -278.712256196947, -478.6661691703075, -64.08358208483239, -412.5731189411608, -331.37012323675765, -276.48196901576, -245.22793862341217, -64.2293317808145, -316.0053255721618, -900.1400554669964, -307.11261174133926, -323.0322297445646, -122.39458407270138, -749.5439721645847, -698.6026683284169, -358.8469463387835, -66.77046098234507, -452.7918952330192, -275.04545924106134, -60.89487760132124, -481.4358114900217, -319.5956463999328, -413.94624523136895, -294.1269486489676, -483.9585191350003, -727.5948139587838], + "butteraugli": [26.285102306294295, 26.5470839885781, 45.234853633312866, 32.48354976443251, 28.206336222855544, 24.079157635070672, 41.89224087694564, 13.295610210603783, 23.104981740319037, 49.57056177676996, 25.08949805490691, 40.15428522020522, 25.112883403596076, 23.343654228172543, 39.82450985048369, 30.2173791602526, 32.22164232472792, 52.95877727976335, 51.135369626144914, 25.816597214623716, 43.78515192419956, 16.659771880172045, 22.79767538106727, 26.61194697334783, 9.742393923225515, 47.11652614586203, 40.836097787060766, 44.32339585080398, 40.04911515399428, 38.082192381528905, 34.44435771537477], + "dssim": [0.30448472505305146, 0.3058355374680247, 0.46389218824383277, 0.17031893170187457, 0.3361572939290428, 0.2434763528607316, 0.2200078066429237, 0.08502123918192006, 0.40999744575475017, 0.2412745766050946, 0.3934870073801642, 0.25763035730827133, 0.1516333606755092, 0.2608941283698598, 0.3686239343127474, 0.1979136444549352, 0.2352900844334747, 0.1449308101255165, 0.33482632886839525, 0.3686238232671072, 0.2245106462498298, 0.14913514823056095, 0.29454252795217584, 0.23812955690462778, 0.11189649384391248, 0.28444726635933193, 0.23384687102783125, 0.31131364273848017, 0.2263526409759068, 0.32930878385743867, 0.3585224812842648] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L19@5 C7@3", + "tune": "l1=19:5 c=7:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.842655299643352, 9.325641574015382, 26.123731225666436, 11.27017338151563, 14.052273710601156, 10.59361160542864, 15.277297279046143, 3.9946201115995215, 11.529626918963821, 12.414099023273858, 10.913810297392933, 11.834951179776146, 4.4528973634243965, 12.42161767974772, 19.396573584825074, 12.075564360939241, 12.87655459896612, 10.812756031799458, 19.566500901111294, 14.273882191648177, 13.037809555029392, 4.9286086839916825, 13.560036155157038, 13.295427264346614, 2.6670547946470666, 14.521807505639037, 14.136622130962355, 13.402661159900907, 9.881603857880515, 11.52343782064338, 15.714908646001854], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.91956333992962, -266.6165913088832, -1229.9645039211673, -226.42034591016989, -348.2148732574724, -274.1026535256908, -466.3427377714497, -64.05768485371826, -410.7294962670038, -331.0455840812118, -272.4718195132897, -230.56455662765904, -64.229205582198, -315.94357838190376, -878.4850850158188, -302.7249002355549, -315.20916926639023, -112.4904264389771, -738.845703242513, -698.3629940723706, -352.506775405069, -66.71647686660836, -451.0040383552673, -274.8430371367527, -60.63589844262759, -483.4201988673408, -320.76014126638455, -409.65016473439005, -290.5756447687719, -480.24766466751555, -715.5521503460103], + "butteraugli": [25.06876201600242, 27.266304489610103, 45.23685966164614, 31.304153319207995, 26.684136987200386, 23.818532236267327, 41.44463475033723, 13.300239219866958, 22.944511743870393, 48.486630709981966, 23.61053895795112, 41.06057041400434, 24.795138372534037, 23.47158329008309, 37.91897931583591, 29.404639908852957, 32.34376312849952, 51.11664205100059, 51.21647558670174, 25.826891510715445, 43.45584016600603, 16.531093237605337, 22.760929801311832, 26.695180220684723, 9.55379171181315, 46.90354308299905, 39.58771865778581, 44.31667616736621, 39.97655338600945, 36.91947963804879, 34.28638827220619], + "dssim": [0.30442752483279945, 0.3056506512179702, 0.46386483770155884, 0.16980012682910312, 0.3352293857906773, 0.24419865300604104, 0.21989109436701543, 0.08501804624303416, 0.40965975560205675, 0.2450572072105821, 0.3935738362534158, 0.2510899080065573, 0.15160853414657466, 0.26068539494377396, 0.36772884163932074, 0.1977817786028852, 0.23279039289305498, 0.14242604532515357, 0.33453656168793855, 0.3685988874183201, 0.2236337902541386, 0.14917150672811258, 0.29441723032845657, 0.23836875805539814, 0.11043106879350972, 0.2845785251245364, 0.23769397410222776, 0.3129364516405726, 0.22529552117145618, 0.33065712811612, 0.35848816945531137] + } + }, + { + "label": "24B L16@6 C5@4", + "tune": "l1=16:6 c=5:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.876876034800943, 9.39715866491882, 26.128640518500795, 11.599836573866538, 14.582178618132327, 10.616390421790431, 15.49870386565641, 4.140910474466515, 11.61323625180773, 12.37024966848148, 11.422963300603568, 12.474517853484462, 4.635854646872529, 12.854401266044048, 19.93829900190709, 12.289586330158194, 13.542623198241076, 10.548517102827958, 20.144915841037736, 14.257813107418038, 13.683031820529468, 5.233881042886418, 13.654360112007975, 13.12608366390809, 2.76355236602555, 14.591026646848862, 14.300848052337058, 13.322973095689186, 10.054652323744943, 11.614127836299444, 17.861987460643775], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.2934229426807, -273.1195591566171, -1230.798264497106, -229.5527221602997, -366.36587074994367, -278.80218687960854, -487.2287371014273, -64.06910961875636, -422.9046854698655, -330.60474113187587, -314.47989090278975, -240.94031925809384, -64.22925058125185, -326.91619860607835, -901.6203000437974, -310.2881956312125, -324.71983603773197, -122.84944240497055, -760.9754099145025, -698.4568778053326, -370.38124262341444, -66.85186732700188, -452.95005627423893, -275.54799646232493, -60.942150432800446, -479.8949731807188, -323.738934380082, -413.0913800156112, -297.12761303884037, -483.78000087142175, -757.8982652281512], + "butteraugli": [26.51646614575238, 26.644761558360926, 45.25501662581001, 32.82266091073847, 28.207515951252613, 24.244186007151587, 41.99489465668875, 13.291082990851729, 23.04062394562042, 50.6974106938992, 26.914149893384863, 41.44346188459658, 25.08701218180615, 23.118000974625925, 39.690775896258344, 30.201381647098145, 32.176635484176956, 53.62605079824173, 51.94217662763756, 25.785421860458786, 44.11450695321258, 17.06190367179686, 22.926024231290356, 26.58793182584277, 9.570224625160996, 48.27060016423249, 42.36775869406679, 44.39615106803313, 39.559053346342296, 37.79387411837609, 34.79489429417272], + "dssim": [0.30446386174496987, 0.30592375888881274, 0.46385027397607836, 0.1705313734139841, 0.3360800034614226, 0.24880904099907447, 0.22067197301149505, 0.08500581013540348, 0.40988482248607133, 0.24344728679332245, 0.3943900343724132, 0.25805010591693744, 0.1516523208209264, 0.26129100955062323, 0.3686279349192473, 0.19791755452949022, 0.23389578641070008, 0.1446919705917737, 0.3368701422926902, 0.36849598920209126, 0.2255098817053292, 0.15046500407436314, 0.291853159582931, 0.2382305145280415, 0.11125400812227837, 0.2841475422804173, 0.2313536993543041, 0.3125855029324488, 0.22679124560611352, 0.3292120922930438, 0.3656236122144392] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L65@3 C22@3", + "tune": "l1=65:3 c=22:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.325673578581389, 8.755724030866405, 26.01539950339889, 9.098100516392885, 13.32363993453778, 9.59761749958738, 13.60070796470418, 4.004505169743817, 11.047555360081546, 9.78513887416291, 10.60606272244796, 10.706339469440044, 4.437361662651076, 11.809905347613082, 18.00871411636734, 10.879653225543287, 12.525138000741675, 10.043365326589443, 17.717001076875327, 14.389080732714945, 11.488886199720996, 4.9263799611566865, 12.67165312155176, 12.762461664467267, 2.7292795472628932, 12.697017410942767, 13.031493386216288, 11.333013199333706, 8.967252948947262, 10.061706661537745, 14.492032516073298], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.03498350428973, -219.12928796268113, -1225.647808493973, -102.76515481940177, -337.19565966069234, -192.3425366173667, -346.6352441944722, -63.48521313450843, -237.15999570050548, -205.12819147786269, -228.84529302237587, -160.4187765365482, -64.1999506403618, -258.10338672122646, -683.6218817019794, -209.47772363296974, -282.84877965996947, -122.79079578028373, -477.98573322917287, -645.9902654196942, -229.99645098106072, -64.8863908998658, -383.2733774620701, -199.4401730914406, -60.526837449951216, -269.01999666584493, -248.31244444721023, -259.07435611250344, -199.91835084495892, -349.133185591321, -529.5713540810028], + "butteraugli": [19.70018385449073, 25.446529431684393, 45.13662243371245, 24.45451269524637, 26.234843298280833, 22.26393429891281, 38.34344636241334, 13.987799119598003, 20.14171185628053, 27.155960855603947, 21.29731919638263, 31.114443868046106, 19.72757704863186, 24.32218828847316, 35.9620554203615, 27.99760151429756, 34.942576278064486, 36.335416971818695, 42.66203408863052, 25.529453005284022, 36.02659616179082, 16.427191918042208, 22.261974633486318, 24.427970275381313, 10.071639436394364, 38.88016413715229, 42.72327910966559, 29.11642105803988, 46.30306502748124, 35.838935542917966, 32.570269212778946], + "dssim": [0.30440668893477785, 0.30506393010405175, 0.4633434768882482, 0.16211000585817253, 0.336434216936667, 0.2419107663466888, 0.2274135226880027, 0.0852957651313278, 0.4071742623103671, 0.25718693075281984, 0.3951557455140254, 0.2642770248538253, 0.15245354148650653, 0.25950952475831746, 0.3628734009377669, 0.20803550856359204, 0.2479318536993544, 0.17442392416700464, 0.33492459099631744, 0.37173173017759586, 0.23897023063611295, 0.15232724594049785, 0.2831814827533039, 0.23790589887928354, 0.10541538244769438, 0.27539018056263087, 0.23680842066162366, 0.2885872124005934, 0.2227539881215942, 0.319942870932591, 0.3575423581541916] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L54@4 C19@3", + "tune": "l1=54:4 c=19:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.141067707746891, 8.51614653183783, 26.034060844416864, 9.128010488368071, 12.957116292932817, 9.177788100666778, 13.682760467868588, 3.5428266803654216, 10.482194801760267, 9.903248341341062, 10.256003260066544, 9.83012405496846, 4.301600815696766, 11.434020883732522, 17.982315789625506, 10.222094109269033, 11.522803881771576, 9.170589781266296, 17.08653448601419, 14.378278406736856, 10.645728512108324, 4.178931971149094, 12.6628756929579, 12.399397855174142, 2.583676988088642, 12.361112807692423, 12.411574408217426, 11.442588904857555, 7.309670292466297, 9.542033833230237, 14.395981171704992], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.11703871171085, -214.79475092875055, -1225.091696071659, -113.65377888471332, -294.35480129674045, -170.77098192867732, -397.56378588573216, -62.935010679260415, -257.99458014738065, -232.66484112051626, -234.13144321407924, -141.0055413260145, -64.0584739694435, -234.54372471493718, -695.195067224337, -203.9204015363323, -232.7374688836972, -88.72976909646636, -475.5620743457804, -676.7976138090102, -214.4071359846165, -64.32303904488333, -383.56429154995294, -200.3195051514893, -59.10831670064945, -282.829494999383, -222.35150832344624, -254.3758831693998, -151.31845097426194, -326.6354374490719, -547.3950706092817], + "butteraugli": [20.794256111675352, 23.90266644031598, 45.149299235586426, 24.55289577278168, 24.691497094571062, 21.052423931900407, 37.602530976246975, 13.017522097672805, 19.043792820222293, 27.42397406016976, 19.718996228887768, 25.094074619491224, 19.389151584635435, 21.207992462415348, 34.172374970052, 25.97633207720952, 31.222766484390473, 40.17090708099796, 42.44973173710883, 25.646460586576424, 34.11051721531921, 14.6849216937299, 22.258179171875497, 24.652477332731085, 10.12510992861308, 38.93922423733165, 35.300434688125186, 31.868103845063285, 29.201523521549266, 34.343551217615016, 32.30592407345638], + "dssim": [0.3044321383259396, 0.3047144686047516, 0.4635557437765656, 0.1554056689133329, 0.33529011731076364, 0.22127381952497366, 0.22153826356141088, 0.08455736609059578, 0.4057647463923709, 0.24727101226076104, 0.3942096377991877, 0.2503369605681859, 0.152293437130736, 0.2580968830076724, 0.36237072369074097, 0.20135707598163638, 0.22862375652433614, 0.14398147707711623, 0.3251388554124589, 0.37012386998450797, 0.22186938823069263, 0.14879421112358315, 0.279571839276357, 0.23682472725847453, 0.10142002288699875, 0.27541293778899345, 0.2226090262904039, 0.3034646461105057, 0.21558624772277002, 0.317273438180409, 0.36027552560631204] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L48@4 C17@4", + "tune": "l1=48:4 c=17:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [6.956854799620069, 8.603635419212514, 26.046883684123433, 9.034378439770315, 12.831795025566926, 9.223391705144692, 13.651721957925096, 3.311269730170714, 10.612668430568739, 10.1740560925611, 10.300546522121882, 9.706491461009543, 4.214513626892203, 11.294558624153241, 18.353960038949193, 10.509388364486199, 11.68109348415365, 9.1532519044078, 17.538546872909087, 14.23544990661862, 11.109193670212193, 4.129906713812041, 12.717430213369733, 12.13906940694042, 2.4768819751539515, 12.549489417634021, 12.243291577504282, 11.468413002887013, 7.580963473299547, 9.821702371924113, 13.925020268288181], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.69947277715923, -216.04879810247093, -1225.7460854243593, -114.57002439888527, -299.2918216445555, -189.23724412019675, -409.3988452377551, -62.936333249031634, -275.79458288287015, -253.3093777294074, -238.14009327191798, -144.1152801431569, -64.08157933238482, -242.47323160009626, -752.7503271024283, -220.60867855669096, -252.47008072778016, -105.10383429199254, -563.7687897490114, -676.8623371888411, -249.6539286442038, -64.30579347168478, -395.35360277146646, -213.61879785689075, -59.10057460616392, -305.30696369507234, -229.82382997024058, -282.69469389599954, -159.07071181057842, -352.5869416238987, -555.4852753362684], + "butteraugli": [21.571609296218785, 24.009060396070186, 45.17805854120462, 24.81761905744285, 24.701976126982633, 21.103443587399354, 38.210073063364135, 13.024649701231368, 19.05219896055107, 29.742601673096488, 19.793706793618956, 25.610088782986292, 19.208650412394515, 21.225062425325476, 36.53017435159708, 26.151128329391444, 30.51485998355142, 41.37724379994165, 46.46184182185786, 25.668111482995926, 35.477656191975804, 14.733436313796096, 22.2265977088383, 25.333497448252448, 9.79117749941222, 37.50491099920233, 35.40202255845899, 32.413927820008446, 29.633114504667606, 34.107056777501036, 31.673629489304204], + "dssim": [0.3043673450554284, 0.3049816663088122, 0.46362279932585054, 0.15628579536972387, 0.3356778846137919, 0.22604455461219758, 0.22067151006210167, 0.08435054112362045, 0.4061128434503331, 0.2558090784987138, 0.3942233743318305, 0.24963130600552336, 0.15198482012809222, 0.2580821024188311, 0.3632756466926429, 0.201533281807399, 0.23065341698029745, 0.14927112314161822, 0.32702748289398587, 0.36894730735023307, 0.22474403662128023, 0.1493499799611362, 0.28081299682249716, 0.23713779498443738, 0.10479246587399271, 0.27564807739518515, 0.22399990850631418, 0.2994645680534669, 0.2185480831191629, 0.3182936003164809, 0.35941897941002465] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L42@5 C15@4", + "tune": "l1=42:5 c=15:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.559844797336946, 8.565191003238866, 26.065591574332178, 9.371149966401898, 12.831724180839934, 9.316093894107421, 13.705552539705401, 3.2545153795521684, 10.660465703848718, 10.484644157216927, 10.319057201027816, 9.473096021545649, 4.119262172113977, 11.315154388048404, 18.495757078825168, 10.528293718625248, 11.554923335562384, 9.281643151570126, 17.84416735475403, 14.232623862393758, 11.10855632075422, 4.126033426017692, 12.868649183306706, 12.135782253523558, 2.429753487550678, 12.909176465889091, 12.330635424156908, 11.598776733215423, 7.608962965991704, 9.771205837024505, 13.93257559707766], + "ssimulacra2": [-135.40315942836602, -222.75482511221242, -1227.359848964331, -128.94769298408121, -303.4578141620556, -195.24356766869573, -419.08755778111083, -62.747214740221466, -286.31055629120306, -261.39894426020624, -230.41934343845696, -145.9658738821276, -64.05865061206566, -245.93836410723645, -774.1896005644425, -214.44577017721696, -244.2272487189677, -101.33631599620344, -589.2980890394334, -692.3707804367608, -247.03671069265386, -64.36000031414886, -397.16500785763196, -215.24122538389133, -57.928297479220134, -343.9992715858446, -245.21289830682463, -308.969209125499, -183.5754126970893, -363.0627480843914, -578.1194189677007], + "butteraugli": [22.268103605828355, 24.309823504275972, 45.14523450804759, 25.384085651065835, 24.90681931781872, 21.414438313010447, 38.152453377677524, 12.973701894600879, 19.277250398159662, 30.518964220230956, 20.128454152869185, 24.856726432083224, 19.894997800937983, 21.485853898848546, 36.193875072269115, 26.320883899717135, 30.616960232969763, 43.97907198673897, 46.0822402140858, 25.741533139451718, 35.9302898935716, 15.110283285579927, 21.659299616279885, 25.2595767146661, 9.26887584481531, 39.34168334457119, 36.17742098471654, 32.670575982837995, 29.177508072682176, 35.03381268196961, 33.63753405523485], + "dssim": [0.3043913782966007, 0.3041775163847097, 0.46384050548853745, 0.15574802014020112, 0.3348580934750878, 0.22209977650980756, 0.2201818102365634, 0.0841083314508333, 0.40636202719225206, 0.2631501884125165, 0.394039012237068, 0.24644476588803177, 0.1515157243086782, 0.257049360570626, 0.3640664726741827, 0.2001821128043222, 0.22784344290869601, 0.14198661091971426, 0.32618312685182904, 0.36872873051567284, 0.2222705270975615, 0.148835669677716, 0.287056164000412, 0.23700147654786835, 0.09898162961109969, 0.2774261576252923, 0.2233278421980633, 0.3027704112968168, 0.21757184350888598, 0.3156974507033692, 0.35720221153989984] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L46@5 C16@3", + "tune": "l1=46:5 c=16:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.477478517475116, 8.439558046810268, 26.05582945408867, 9.189528875360528, 12.958129155705072, 9.417139183684492, 13.755367601530567, 3.404721395090849, 10.602920010524498, 10.137536066997276, 10.28147200696006, 9.632699526955664, 4.201094427884247, 11.387403700607523, 18.533287323410406, 10.440143111224705, 11.541205955171753, 9.572641588613418, 17.86277954698904, 14.374501564412894, 11.106316597764238, 4.104708020573786, 12.61146883845934, 12.36903049975216, 2.540967714355208, 12.641079169864648, 12.440344687051208, 11.769753332394329, 7.447712031875232, 9.732843586538769, 14.365125993877909], + "ssimulacra2": [-135.58402246681544, -214.67546636445877, -1227.0199441525858, -114.89023416755359, -298.63706341234627, -192.2335624748739, -413.1391714523369, -62.686681088806864, -276.0124692056586, -248.3863886948526, -229.48659303141778, -143.06242744566805, -64.00947925614133, -237.94358819780427, -756.0262622644531, -215.05183569050814, -245.46903053345534, -97.1939193148138, -583.6334555116936, -693.9039012130041, -246.26189808120722, -64.31221724209416, -390.8853102691995, -211.18218141434573, -57.86366229041673, -311.9244109611904, -224.37833264425507, -299.82499657090466, -165.0303430453148, -350.27778712644135, -564.1116123887043], + "butteraugli": [22.200325802233596, 24.028549772069, 45.13060805025592, 24.677910864050773, 24.91349126969206, 21.161495213407935, 38.17699084615998, 12.937995560305993, 18.80504318106293, 29.3087866896888, 20.00472845303158, 25.110502859262127, 19.596023581687067, 20.988806519449763, 36.43657170660102, 26.05412899001991, 30.62344169258333, 44.21606598204562, 46.18563359585829, 25.799341482276912, 35.88527498395743, 14.828589317971103, 21.656609954659444, 25.24175778598465, 9.153414441510831, 38.82480050472825, 35.93794168285989, 31.57812727896418, 28.584495065621145, 34.34974030556206, 32.15429529046428], + "dssim": [0.30441665009839525, 0.30384987871258096, 0.4637538709739872, 0.15538134364117995, 0.3350624513724695, 0.22249711266660493, 0.22032798773408596, 0.08408779803816963, 0.4064142280968435, 0.2536410959697326, 0.39410664182189953, 0.2469406184853919, 0.15146942809955727, 0.2571185309816989, 0.3636758718199795, 0.2004078609220747, 0.2289738313163397, 0.14285510634077053, 0.3269706662336851, 0.3693558379254852, 0.22209287083173712, 0.14839550907767501, 0.281353672436371, 0.23701280960928456, 0.09954879050887849, 0.2765908087909047, 0.22382641485491211, 0.30229144259783036, 0.21625588501096865, 0.31527686306579605, 0.35898505654152146] + } + }, + { + "label": "48B L37@6 C13@4", + "tune": "l1=37:6 c=13:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.768067558721446, 8.879340812734176, 26.086854302757796, 9.480263529543057, 13.077664148194549, 9.582998790985934, 13.842142192958875, 3.2776960779453868, 10.857210986723594, 11.475257798914718, 10.4555788336728, 9.936809026148754, 4.175331262425991, 11.408687474814046, 18.546760197905552, 10.795821798959935, 11.725183385121856, 9.51724096768383, 17.978083443484824, 14.21010238307771, 11.43268418451167, 4.1339795001854185, 13.094012753156372, 12.25472069375162, 2.3697696361950595, 12.94252128726127, 12.623943886573455, 11.762701666906498, 7.784567197785845, 9.81740713838055, 14.308775457345329], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.27748761977287, -237.01607190055802, -1228.8652721296376, -131.93429997521662, -308.3222977393533, -205.65164329678856, -419.9686016942709, -63.01947018557934, -313.9626683007975, -313.99308300008624, -247.0296694658844, -152.18708536789546, -64.06088604170401, -262.7748309408468, -794.2402485768052, -248.61624068626674, -256.95683645123756, -102.1969994054717, -592.244571401714, -693.1713108558542, -266.7487306163637, -64.38529606957013, -410.07232199276535, -222.36501920166404, -58.031611385986224, -354.4469083258123, -262.1520438546926, -321.5729766143628, -190.3894930133908, -370.8875274438685, -597.7218229069483], + "butteraugli": [22.59119294380436, 24.60347681853777, 45.16307756268136, 25.840841202712586, 25.016650097927158, 21.589748020598012, 38.162457026396, 12.983350341761929, 19.806874572952804, 36.20257831977549, 20.653508228439694, 24.96580531976625, 20.395447483925164, 22.223115062090205, 36.32577360278529, 27.904382104359826, 31.466648064434708, 45.416687170369336, 46.48546078335781, 25.777045699444745, 36.86106889791301, 15.244809451112937, 21.98533920390837, 25.154599370049144, 8.97249274134682, 38.91991986677007, 36.65710940277689, 32.761181182853164, 29.731765675351483, 34.97296588166864, 34.02293231009455], + "dssim": [0.3044259886298848, 0.30499389835914215, 0.46392468813098625, 0.1562558262625367, 0.3347904208569108, 0.22508247894283545, 0.21960846874692813, 0.08430691993100486, 0.4067391765274292, 0.26445017456742426, 0.3938709511410998, 0.24923408367324779, 0.15145463691423905, 0.25752110529573013, 0.36463569293642784, 0.19812006865230086, 0.22940504765571973, 0.13465079281446574, 0.327898535062905, 0.3686001142587112, 0.2223752733432534, 0.14946696552177946, 0.29323587406881935, 0.23699201330810743, 0.0981988794203606, 0.2777759333940387, 0.22420996854411274, 0.30537717948058585, 0.21791474489562856, 0.3160169563305917, 0.35789663527189586] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L115@3 C40@3", + "tune": "l1=115:3 c=40:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [7.2667074910132845, 8.262348556396866, 25.880192471016077, 8.6640955283131, 13.069058430054978, 9.106462982018206, 12.887181426167857, 3.9357331595549225, 10.83824561650171, 9.66291848986287, 10.578512730823114, 10.140482599225248, 4.166729454442805, 11.356003033748008, 17.241778099072867, 10.556250920942382, 12.360903039421707, 9.434066813468807, 16.313504974664564, 14.383233667178914, 10.936554408214699, 4.8221063117803835, 11.798021189091154, 12.30525905158172, 2.6752946145472367, 11.678068268496114, 12.661720068369908, 10.180868785468007, 8.713465034065653, 9.562904319401298, 13.569331827475766], + "ssimulacra2": [-123.6913944349098, -191.43210141941233, -1208.705524024524, -93.39494909620211, -322.37764413030436, -155.9926480156068, -252.53177333527367, -63.386921483672126, -214.43928631331767, -181.65080914196108, -207.54520570303112, -136.70756464863814, -64.22908168961382, -247.59896534746366, -556.9196590591849, -197.28460454348158, -276.02821274324685, -131.8921524304746, -337.728699309321, -616.7221118827151, -211.48783415675632, -64.48414029872905, -374.98509277964104, -138.31811023077876, -59.765745899064655, -183.78626890129937, -225.56490505771342, -140.15350251598423, -195.79465701787916, -253.04285630509162, -407.08672422430163], + "butteraugli": [17.813952738560833, 22.534351293765894, 44.99980867106265, 24.064008338578052, 25.76685686744507, 25.634369338634713, 34.194594644248305, 14.116057533217017, 20.285633898647614, 26.05296777925859, 21.386369458380614, 29.75425807289047, 18.88119327233002, 23.62339568640944, 33.64279042755084, 27.484310543403, 34.10535895668752, 31.119792646706202, 42.70351599482586, 25.529137697391135, 35.24791404821266, 16.651288708519473, 22.368300115049763, 23.401338036095666, 9.551322142068353, 35.24692360369809, 38.61606867669112, 25.27152553938895, 60.57166188193313, 31.521983067211057, 31.680510003849076], + "dssim": [0.30427028342082385, 0.30517737657292443, 0.46244222226395193, 0.15882402191389522, 0.33914274453588367, 0.2458078923355223, 0.22887548421772558, 0.0854939828235044, 0.40565297370084025, 0.26155220305225646, 0.39442261370013726, 0.2692005725052812, 0.15524782783438001, 0.2594730999772793, 0.3605268783102573, 0.2101345334816619, 0.25299533641898, 0.17527450915906456, 0.3264922547025342, 0.37343033452596563, 0.2408706215267425, 0.15253753077154886, 0.2799872868403367, 0.24183764671457036, 0.10284662388127552, 0.2693686335835378, 0.2392421416198734, 0.284569682187481, 0.22664925356351756, 0.32399773095341267, 0.3545447234112833] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L96@4 C33@3", + "tune": "l1=96:4 c=33:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [7.08541157138737, 7.661080407824676, 25.94338229699733, 8.24492162090226, 12.389998471034438, 8.514056166485247, 12.56434118400707, 3.4183758737739742, 10.039896230522839, 9.363099047314142, 10.021460851841425, 8.723395465797113, 3.985868787620344, 10.789118384550498, 17.14186068707016, 9.848676938883102, 10.830561421193895, 8.5527786763339, 15.6150526683269, 14.321464499382285, 9.620879969628648, 4.027206896134458, 11.543097058075272, 11.985861452735119, 2.565660789384068, 10.980620832901934, 11.361011514095152, 10.36885772324596, 6.643073545318184, 8.766528449163458, 13.554167146228332], + "ssimulacra2": [-117.67285207044918, -152.7647390463644, -1217.6101026804436, -88.60679971839261, -246.4669837043238, -134.68180858273462, -267.9147108589237, -62.009797369617274, -203.25715245338995, -156.71823079870296, -179.38940015762734, -95.61257887156665, -63.97887688546609, -196.97690801059002, -576.0317265638807, -172.3724538408528, -197.01718511856552, -76.36297008696698, -307.98236982263484, -631.4824967214679, -164.03206199009293, -64.22939798571807, -322.6004030958169, -139.24860421012013, -57.881133732283246, -164.86267796506291, -161.11642893319447, -156.72123570412862, -123.70946413408691, -245.82187031591758, -415.672973920666], + "butteraugli": [17.56957190930915, 22.03392140166926, 45.06141297094374, 23.208370846503602, 23.461965300900854, 20.04171670152113, 33.74211662432412, 12.942874061576957, 17.8937974487383, 26.230950556708667, 19.59500780795261, 22.835230286793422, 20.71301984747983, 20.40510970678271, 32.57820632629126, 25.844178372514687, 28.022146614485745, 30.616861408261286, 36.812926769121596, 25.394526041359764, 30.56304342036218, 14.255003449972028, 21.47617918903963, 22.713529221912154, 9.571869880809379, 29.357123932921326, 32.93093648170731, 25.458340134700524, 28.011915218654185, 31.336046408700952, 29.36915803222521], + "dssim": [0.3041154604054347, 0.30138025736132834, 0.46289571237735344, 0.15148539733861255, 0.3364310730155057, 0.2129737233471018, 0.22134822332826354, 0.08442090224188542, 0.40411827726302124, 0.2255132282585846, 0.39309932863856983, 0.2454508888523339, 0.15320529475445194, 0.25642226160325554, 0.35931921845779813, 0.2028054300945079, 0.2302994672940024, 0.14403247470645036, 0.3195411336785383, 0.3711214768730837, 0.22415407588815456, 0.14917091911323027, 0.2740575589548693, 0.23785453639067655, 0.10015612521143868, 0.2655150268482508, 0.2187340345776258, 0.2957244713627257, 0.21140647098901016, 0.3094969854773101, 0.3558050867849133] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L86@4 C30@4", + "tune": "l1=86:4 c=30:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [6.909425513349513, 7.795364280794963, 25.953478655696582, 8.147696492278987, 12.146906053578872, 8.42084130705426, 12.456275451933088, 3.1041846130146085, 10.20480283155463, 9.372861235228894, 10.101025086020782, 8.638022989732814, 3.918731006517748, 10.848535885391017, 16.966706713368904, 9.890417830096423, 10.783017488755775, 8.040740813173793, 15.408249938522271, 14.23553079295114, 9.651318001176644, 3.912395341443087, 11.94447999717392, 11.537766674066495, 2.4342026147548963, 11.33626933067316, 11.162579705448316, 10.080332788397861, 6.883326061309635, 8.942501171544686, 13.078842467527048], + "ssimulacra2": [-121.29349767621716, -161.32847203029831, -1218.8693958305214, -93.11089376042983, -263.0225336014178, -138.1051020614558, -278.77702228470304, -62.43982024746373, -210.998005281575, -176.31547290976084, -193.7400345486284, -102.94543024134208, -63.95588551523832, -204.5066402265046, -589.8484474436048, -178.20212421241598, -187.1892945026891, -77.36563996786265, -302.0924813343602, -632.1322317971708, -171.15645360347867, -64.22914527882344, -341.79279619543547, -148.95091820832056, -58.099430380072874, -185.60238593230298, -178.0973938210397, -167.08347860923317, -137.02126311161203, -267.51913478200754, -442.5421003973436], + "butteraugli": [17.441356065875187, 22.346294527663385, 45.06273537669485, 23.431235820153216, 23.74632018759939, 20.16993489841477, 33.851105773920246, 12.978269031789068, 18.514280245819922, 26.09686585537932, 19.529551559601, 23.61869444726109, 19.194950664210136, 20.47578180309499, 32.68687643491593, 26.017732291129324, 28.399934026841635, 30.312963744393183, 37.41742216816567, 25.400537546225706, 30.88442511303961, 14.217559761909547, 21.605317091658936, 22.531081866769142, 9.617897379873126, 33.2025912524901, 32.87149239203776, 27.02111928912994, 28.22180140762478, 31.58702605354867, 29.01400846879679], + "dssim": [0.3042232102829956, 0.3020262803267316, 0.4630268124359785, 0.1529260077380475, 0.3355153819958788, 0.21133766516723346, 0.2206001685221643, 0.08427116527474676, 0.40517667157259757, 0.2321404502483319, 0.3935693641967066, 0.2438822466545611, 0.15264688723471903, 0.25690805464445343, 0.35926006642757335, 0.20237705356980773, 0.22893275477005953, 0.1440381508962565, 0.31559284120108655, 0.37029432596450207, 0.22373885966648882, 0.14881532804876524, 0.2802060070081941, 0.23660919227925242, 0.09975047653392316, 0.2685416076749675, 0.2171986006450688, 0.28979952543327514, 0.21259586720581392, 0.31093819135184286, 0.35579744073926856] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L75@5 C26@4", + "tune": "l1=75:5 c=26:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [6.947118686422438, 8.148198724047758, 25.9896597707116, 8.108762153250156, 12.02960876791384, 8.644194630410244, 12.42172757392247, 2.9444481410817973, 10.220810349391021, 9.249340486123618, 10.082442985034678, 8.138458504722994, 3.7935583597422298, 10.756327283399571, 17.133736238401863, 9.892226288261629, 10.749555652712543, 8.03449453242901, 15.891310518580145, 14.241326919556967, 9.784619593822544, 3.7632075250752104, 12.109234189915016, 11.608412178127079, 2.347870952700601, 11.494940344590967, 11.143356558300397, 10.280482960267522, 6.74609758711388, 9.04234337279959, 13.266681200126376], + "ssimulacra2": [-131.07670111853167, -191.7627317085723, -1221.3729723843142, -94.30749905112708, -258.56105024270556, -151.55951626581665, -287.00963418179214, -62.24729631486235, -220.37448978841064, -172.71335096833587, -208.55858742515034, -94.8278954059522, -63.86901338010202, -213.08504999921746, -618.3395036817037, -181.92319617054716, -183.76891746793694, -76.03441054686073, -349.5258988772806, -642.4376157455686, -177.57338942579418, -64.22911481520035, -345.17288110067943, -160.18639691040323, -54.37202751928106, -208.06914315501035, -176.40020199614378, -201.0701473016747, -137.27617905835092, -283.96985293115733, -495.43398288465903], + "butteraugli": [18.24860745428543, 22.952908092612592, 45.0550376298915, 23.367646945749254, 23.60374163084404, 20.02838340845489, 34.00988185283559, 12.853741668525148, 17.96847745731173, 26.131116388983983, 19.417181728468538, 21.468566132959015, 18.543754778659626, 20.095185420234667, 33.014857629901094, 25.60208719999574, 28.76250689625749, 36.002890121487695, 38.61573505173792, 25.391140049866475, 31.263139941447232, 14.235804342282828, 21.407102593083447, 22.857687741949423, 8.023003146495181, 33.65678175854779, 32.702526066090996, 28.115239859020903, 27.108255313688186, 32.91082182913296, 29.40882186967859], + "dssim": [0.30424320622373024, 0.3028044690742768, 0.4633062100707766, 0.15320572268868643, 0.33516996416316347, 0.21589979437854373, 0.22009163894380257, 0.08386092752057356, 0.40595235746470265, 0.22470520528990434, 0.3940552747686302, 0.23548453944228726, 0.15179763180671418, 0.2557377809426781, 0.3600241209599595, 0.2007001142617082, 0.22665217546000954, 0.13729064471323021, 0.3173631800436225, 0.3698234765236298, 0.22296416217235943, 0.14820754385433643, 0.2799027369134971, 0.23643508181866246, 0.09299660912722169, 0.2688303853562871, 0.21727164821650863, 0.2845037069572006, 0.21318383175841865, 0.3119184307129077, 0.3546783443690482] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L82@5 C29@3", + "tune": "l1=82:5 c=29:3 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [7.074448740761793, 7.651352905825149, 25.975035793004643, 8.38871915946165, 12.352434980613792, 8.642942547112325, 12.61589917613862, 3.28680346232455, 10.149241458663946, 9.329054682020402, 10.023221446485751, 8.322966414276104, 3.843539075858075, 10.945096119336263, 17.28744078180837, 9.786392335263677, 10.619877691886431, 8.562910682988111, 15.747327502890405, 14.314145944549317, 9.643736512848186, 3.75569286273498, 12.076238860327496, 11.93290769695619, 2.4551542005487597, 11.252063883897147, 11.413121444080714, 10.326835936281395, 6.651778236101995, 8.939380117376125, 13.733438740858366], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.33728962616897, -155.1502082021307, -1221.2309079455397, -92.37215708921994, -257.74882203186843, -141.22153955931796, -284.4510300951237, -62.312054512268105, -209.4611513859142, -170.24617752194706, -187.5593880469943, -93.36882166166123, -63.73872424758275, -196.16808037497447, -605.2004231645699, -176.2809854740787, -184.14166199037038, -74.51749308443993, -320.27900345232854, -631.0352467447594, -170.65053361892433, -64.21774668122058, -336.3358152583845, -149.39672595182574, -54.017006927348916, -190.53868710165676, -173.16210125855588, -170.3504431201559, -135.21428544674987, -268.58638417593784, -476.2087192612836], + "butteraugli": [17.274307001398622, 22.34573168915794, 45.03134158376461, 23.30208213073854, 23.47382809232846, 19.997389021911683, 33.87540209755557, 12.90759740671696, 17.97004237126848, 26.107722566161353, 19.2820294697983, 21.224331490508007, 18.391459703518937, 19.752546611851923, 32.91652262957309, 25.524048664279935, 27.931087918435832, 34.8447945131798, 38.24760238810985, 25.394475613773135, 31.202830498735437, 14.025956853097158, 21.551992203707357, 22.85678507554414, 7.739309370610599, 32.33066027945055, 32.60309425987571, 25.846787075000137, 26.702576076150354, 31.232065763073873, 29.632896427042883], + "dssim": [0.30420087989686717, 0.30096938373410287, 0.46328187996185805, 0.15204759122672845, 0.3356970637429204, 0.21313350774966477, 0.22013005724235435, 0.0840000078101652, 0.40535918321660264, 0.2267111475927031, 0.3936140470064646, 0.23900755317772782, 0.15167960146816156, 0.25568168252978274, 0.3601950066008187, 0.20002351160007442, 0.22715201053984263, 0.13805289965585033, 0.3165021504463288, 0.37072734380550054, 0.22230748565712227, 0.1483062420178145, 0.2785174731231218, 0.23700647201429526, 0.09339405942874707, 0.26793668217689903, 0.21522800199854542, 0.287084112235385, 0.21238627485182693, 0.3093341783665019, 0.35564236541863414] + } + }, + { + "label": "80B L66@6 C23@4", + "tune": "l1=66:6 c=23:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [6.951852623155842, 8.181416279913861, 26.021411378726, 8.115146928614854, 12.317793739303305, 8.644797795825378, 12.80795529096567, 3.110276866695935, 10.184881999129026, 9.404102371972485, 10.089486690842095, 8.796549663094494, 4.03656633876474, 10.858972582546757, 17.485751782438665, 9.852300273928794, 10.790158677406655, 8.170973044187265, 16.328883020269217, 14.263912114779368, 10.056132641873933, 3.7985727028840066, 12.338175109977573, 11.690293124357355, 2.3164431213972114, 11.893168576078212, 11.60333938885664, 10.611274731601407, 6.831385753084591, 9.159139923983364, 13.396276153077572], + "ssimulacra2": [-131.12962209970644, -197.33552603125327, -1224.812924233381, -94.8604296674718, -266.14144541251227, -151.7759814943595, -316.9128584428747, -62.37566374588664, -220.9394945178651, -177.20730260339366, -212.7550125038145, -103.74502907831524, -63.947961034210664, -217.9286088345736, -661.5357139078736, -181.57186789788858, -196.77858353376217, -77.46893307728837, -417.17541252288095, -646.2084585566831, -194.25839570128767, -64.22947534398062, -353.7571122159563, -181.82887510590695, -55.2614547305439, -234.6025916451107, -187.262164024068, -232.0390177890966, -139.12322221581175, -299.39640971334757, -512.2537631529663], + "butteraugli": [18.339501529387544, 23.21373147165319, 45.0830873491738, 23.361726863478157, 23.84163349869365, 20.348144184445214, 35.82869991122234, 12.82029528352605, 17.916896812906497, 26.859424519239074, 19.35521833829915, 22.972951221161654, 18.70330906614137, 20.570633651599703, 33.52974237794867, 25.680169694226937, 29.309905862649543, 39.216197250801116, 39.58127739888305, 25.34769629676454, 32.14549265321768, 14.301862725646773, 21.5621825842355, 24.030092787561017, 8.286998385508454, 34.005138192123326, 33.57103232454803, 28.065184418329977, 28.447056577655857, 33.68652743401424, 29.97922088201298], + "dssim": [0.3041280243978064, 0.3037911619208812, 0.46360150228653235, 0.15395896330502623, 0.33496796996086575, 0.21313884654117615, 0.22103224730844606, 0.08402048871721418, 0.4059642433658741, 0.22460015867777489, 0.39399617081743693, 0.24132820648532938, 0.1519562355269976, 0.25575512887228846, 0.3613513987037844, 0.2008785655839136, 0.22690120135090946, 0.13428517073294816, 0.3226032714000533, 0.3698421690925481, 0.2217704303328623, 0.14809843363121084, 0.28024495577457, 0.23623692119270373, 0.0936038773380421, 0.27245743880143547, 0.21548673646102184, 0.2877057625122579, 0.21353462972616222, 0.3125135878451254, 0.35642156972070077] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/prefix-shrink.json b/tools/comparison/results/prefix-shrink.json index e45e8c1..d0b5508 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/prefix-shrink.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/prefix-shrink.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/quant-ranges.json b/tools/comparison/results/quant-ranges.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..18dd6bd --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/quant-ranges.json @@ -0,0 +1,240 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "quant-ranges", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Re-validate the corpus-derived quantization ranges on the expanded corpus (they were locked on the old, smaller corpus): chroma AC scale maxima, the asserted-not-measured MAX_L_SCALE, and the a/b range symmetry (the a=6b/b=5b field-width asymmetry itself is wire-fixed; range asymmetry is the sweepable proxy).", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/quant-ranges.json", + "configSha256": "b0d88fedf6ec23c5f535484c3bda09199fd9c5627ffa6891fe3ed7a977893fa3", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "default (0.5 / 0.125 / 0.125)", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "max_b_scale=0.15", + "tune": "max_b_scale=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.0192816904952045, 8.996802373274656, 26.14243297888371, 10.569138604054729, 13.332004015996366, 9.867342892142206, 14.335028759430152, 3.5919840009403075, 11.059960105639565, 11.955495161043999, 10.505979326235515, 10.350584482245209, 4.120130718015487, 11.786222024913855, 18.835862855235007, 10.753157450157595, 12.249058058484321, 9.855044512611679, 18.312566250146826, 14.159825469338893, 12.074009132953012, 4.468127915521903, 12.909211910131683, 13.054689775452927, 2.3080647575865636, 13.533332266463093, 12.904957691596323, 12.293685494139549, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.799439172639364], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.55278455395856, -252.4414132060964, -1230.6251002968268, -181.77843173679003, -317.07984878995194, -239.9338328569545, -449.2860073870024, -63.318323272840445, -332.7903685019995, -342.0891520269811, -252.50602034549155, -184.8525110887985, -64.06192820871206, -281.8836136699272, -826.7740658534174, -247.10320654073263, -280.95769093136056, -120.3049930386641, -648.24515424306, -694.2902231080539, -307.70803281172476, -64.71383493353218, -414.1186133799222, -256.57540476106414, -59.537825703040824, -396.23129470847454, -273.6775718734183, -371.3909914724155, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4060618590958], + "butteraugli": [23.167607299254303, 27.02560129647775, 45.10203335274138, 28.305536000728853, 26.006821159045128, 22.122578351673695, 40.39327676106283, 13.142701019502203, 20.277412323402388, 44.23900186088264, 21.574436341916726, 32.38110009755463, 21.81489058280413, 22.19227164997101, 36.97549581175408, 27.07034482323958, 31.79803067327842, 46.43545492982796, 48.10711998380483, 25.771638377089147, 38.72711962798709, 15.703606391331858, 22.314694642854803, 27.145062823446818, 9.71371822555509, 45.234560527842824, 37.91726457076391, 37.482813090022255, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.12203954694647], + "dssim": [0.30427777185230176, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643611019492333, 0.1632362724914978, 0.33443322898365757, 0.24038241541097355, 0.22002945756843179, 0.08448201143963024, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2503698435415027, 0.39360696704092074, 0.24814466423806536, 0.1509983039930174, 0.2582490914077483, 0.3655250032737737, 0.20125062501279156, 0.2291372879165367, 0.14601378011220073, 0.3303029544682242, 0.3684661435033003, 0.22389580946871251, 0.14957904191039778, 0.2861362349829911, 0.2384853736278611, 0.1031985273512836, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22436272806940627, 0.30327312382045357, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3592220102625061] + } + }, + { + "label": "max_a_scale=0.15", + "tune": "max_a_scale=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.035759750461508, 8.996802373274656, 26.142991305903504, 10.51914825476808, 13.250814783243639, 9.806225052379803, 14.154142462707854, 3.6255436119313944, 11.059960105639565, 12.126347385945953, 10.507241181551779, 10.46584496038837, 4.088567960890925, 11.818564619967779, 18.709105959562695, 10.832630746653324, 12.261503683811652, 10.025546604437533, 18.311781758076318, 14.153289388655564, 12.10123139726457, 4.4018652438544, 12.9592606403314, 13.097397320329613, 2.323678650059476, 13.533332266463093, 12.865775532452131, 12.35102455009922, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.875505677255427], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.72444871985516, -252.4414132060964, -1230.5689473404434, -182.35406104580716, -317.1875954049363, -239.5386883861587, -449.89787410542294, -63.28883308116639, -332.7903685019995, -341.17082518698635, -252.27272846898808, -184.93084745816918, -64.06085279458625, -281.8678899267726, -828.531032082618, -248.08356624937693, -280.76823309717076, -120.40674034453357, -644.0904712812222, -695.119443861982, -307.3187246776124, -64.70984126773772, -414.70771419091466, -257.80817421379163, -59.511511206320364, -396.23129470847454, -274.3401709261901, -373.06572144111567, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.1784009016546], + "butteraugli": [23.12195885513988, 27.02560129647775, 45.10229927541843, 28.33253620997552, 25.971754180726872, 22.127249586804243, 40.306196823711346, 13.160969219078055, 20.277412323402388, 44.16637455666588, 21.598648149175332, 32.551406443522175, 21.86033896849069, 22.219876688469242, 36.875807937648496, 27.09427303041076, 31.777990842983414, 46.349508954892976, 47.973953929349825, 25.76810822046491, 38.7391221442026, 15.74733807348808, 22.30566015065848, 27.281260391633822, 9.680400464152514, 45.234560527842824, 37.974059093187634, 37.59377335708385, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.119409520149816], + "dssim": [0.3042685645078054, 0.3048715622436494, 0.464369396075355, 0.1637996270671791, 0.33442062702033093, 0.2404546904092249, 0.21986595689079164, 0.08450145321663588, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2498600884242963, 0.3936104026444359, 0.2481066715349129, 0.15101274979761287, 0.25840045924785293, 0.3655473573362914, 0.20125433380453311, 0.2293332203606651, 0.14671059241116852, 0.3286962921916958, 0.3684483481070201, 0.22413512205757646, 0.1489837441776805, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23845653642780618, 0.10328410791976178, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22450990864392978, 0.30505036901312, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3577263751488885] + } + }, + { + "label": "max_a=max_b=0.1", + "tune": "max_a_scale=0.1 max_b_scale=0.1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.003424255855527, 8.996802373274656, 26.146053086209072, 10.602148965718431, 13.255850109741743, 9.843044958566725, 14.165500739372114, 3.561926714549314, 11.059960105639565, 11.997240681360465, 10.471414665792416, 10.353141055770429, 4.100644715567469, 11.84506551493196, 18.761634779888492, 10.791695157074477, 12.271487582972616, 9.972270393322702, 18.28735097796366, 14.166329391431583, 12.090688201376972, 4.487064864970354, 12.977957488060996, 12.926805055814462, 2.292909133565717, 13.533332266463093, 12.861777806648647, 12.293685494139549, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.787933957135333], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.4447607617124, -252.4414132060964, -1230.9430523170586, -182.2833256728823, -316.21810950693595, -240.2475673402484, -450.4127023354389, -63.325660636242105, -332.7903685019995, -340.8391043237213, -252.42557061097693, -185.38551893491143, -64.05191740513473, -281.96830973521764, -827.8578176690405, -246.94790436351116, -281.59139443893685, -119.81982139034488, -647.7638801431077, -695.0780004220991, -307.33695540824453, -64.71981415385613, -414.3740968439205, -257.4494854110626, -59.53970431358553, -396.23129470847454, -273.92359048899436, -371.3909914724155, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -651.1760628980413], + "butteraugli": [23.175163938944632, 27.02560129647775, 45.1038963969766, 28.344797952122747, 25.988081011216167, 22.104437589842686, 40.28328497592483, 13.140257360221533, 20.277412323402388, 44.157056006547585, 21.609023387443717, 32.306806205502056, 21.859200884441808, 22.213660501629846, 36.99783913579458, 27.147559717203865, 31.764662733912, 46.338066449820815, 48.09675496061042, 25.7530673272436, 38.736054097815064, 15.700562034021887, 22.2982197862775, 27.16669356447875, 9.712885581431278, 45.234560527842824, 37.94509821469555, 37.482813090022255, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.04100536061575], + "dssim": [0.30427879172003913, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643827338086335, 0.161627536644382, 0.33439195152792855, 0.24007671281279946, 0.21974301528141926, 0.08448265351559886, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2484002044865532, 0.393610003299983, 0.2479163170247191, 0.1510186469897154, 0.2583611114686334, 0.36537903359375057, 0.20125904302938108, 0.22942111660174636, 0.14625433532255894, 0.33066528868227785, 0.3684708766820477, 0.22391473351111874, 0.14972025387886667, 0.2845308015252287, 0.23836929898986225, 0.10308239118305873, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22459458286392575, 0.30327312382045357, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3597228656993001] + } + }, + { + "label": "max_l_scale=0.35", + "tune": "max_l_scale=0.35", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.035326172173462, 9.035636102880659, 26.142009141163594, 10.532617594530477, 13.312520797462403, 9.866549566100701, 14.258207767995225, 3.533351237071175, 10.99247757276522, 12.044024659266363, 10.527378454203406, 10.572387227112333, 4.101938341578316, 11.81411253449122, 18.81714375196925, 10.814859505496269, 12.22193752933727, 9.948927275948872, 18.27185743814293, 14.182222715129312, 11.98141904348623, 4.3942108803249305, 12.9592606403314, 13.04205907337517, 2.33518800971857, 13.564192156060493, 12.874497757527514, 12.29803360361931, 8.426159745979927, 10.914996455901214, 14.906004607795156], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.2889216648968, -250.6743106023007, -1230.3372008488159, -185.47113933589122, -315.445599476532, -243.15590459907241, -452.5007466407583, -63.23674922433926, -325.0193353326491, -339.89588562529843, -253.50395473975288, -178.99777717212305, -64.04344109610761, -281.85085414354114, -827.364549964939, -247.0613522468114, -280.9886755406166, -119.39804542174099, -639.9584310049823, -694.3184680368547, -308.5746429294625, -64.6396122953523, -414.70771419091466, -255.6619195649261, -59.53143695544367, -401.17092270406124, -270.59384381502093, -372.2506383951561, -212.52832508972295, -438.0883763914078, -647.8818783495753], + "butteraugli": [22.382170365682928, 26.705078957682257, 45.10606814627746, 28.879409164517654, 25.344803100685, 22.448584945194796, 39.88292699191954, 13.217194785433938, 20.21279729023649, 43.857941538805655, 21.519562939501967, 34.92173464103073, 21.461352477123047, 22.175305183086607, 36.898726868473084, 27.095729626956835, 31.761200614412928, 46.6039656783758, 48.410350291109914, 25.71536891759679, 39.111542965242364, 15.864431637975983, 22.30566015065848, 26.67724604039449, 10.100106487433363, 44.61387079027992, 38.009688795375006, 37.76854671270696, 31.41208165165632, 35.79320277264164, 33.903280577215384], + "dssim": [0.30432337667111853, 0.3050310599007684, 0.4643456746691856, 0.16531471567397676, 0.33453248824532755, 0.23895017185237816, 0.22025503962356424, 0.08465058031104172, 0.40681280517965185, 0.2507718942767294, 0.3936252380001043, 0.2484215839564602, 0.15123769982564234, 0.25856483603564107, 0.36566263130647014, 0.2014595372785037, 0.22903164893188838, 0.1455228102222827, 0.3286950336216564, 0.36845272234651905, 0.22317164629175862, 0.14981480832790517, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851946822899966, 0.10370307963016945, 0.2810643907986725, 0.2246963307827845, 0.304444502204125, 0.2191505941740553, 0.32548177657869437, 0.35757874113278676] + } + }, + { + "label": "max_l_scale=0.65", + "tune": "max_l_scale=0.65", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.061718673420367, 8.96515932406893, 26.11875940124999, 10.573762538826013, 13.296663228754133, 9.83393380639447, 14.313779288068156, 3.5611770400477214, 10.975195430226789, 12.076725852177832, 10.559695634355363, 10.41487645683245, 4.118856293292959, 11.819062993022525, 18.825113817627326, 10.814859505496269, 12.242867563054263, 9.901297187360173, 18.27185743814293, 14.172188442445124, 12.114322979014197, 4.412216522185482, 12.983916500252466, 13.009934553259507, 2.3309076565634377, 13.674181445060178, 12.929788301906717, 12.392366139880025, 8.618332225460446, 10.914996455901214, 14.94490653689501], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.67973010872228, -247.36148055345376, -1230.67148843557, -182.4682201212396, -316.463864533825, -239.02012256303664, -453.6010863888755, -63.29961134426199, -323.65612784698715, -339.9005303081864, -242.522259364003, -181.22529621645634, -64.08167674531529, -282.51764824532074, -829.4130348429384, -247.0613522468114, -281.13132217484986, -120.1069459405957, -639.9584310049823, -695.5948576419756, -306.600685459239, -64.59719129736578, -415.74688609961913, -256.3958774922587, -59.581256648882544, -398.4943309839804, -273.59718319237317, -374.0038349624353, -216.26237636065974, -438.0883763914078, -645.1431835626681], + "butteraugli": [22.565681208362793, 26.843315532954843, 45.137916402716606, 28.1619328738248, 25.639031101366204, 22.31601987138781, 39.92715446130499, 13.205960950701467, 20.251598522237938, 44.26385975116065, 22.115033482180937, 31.914118171777016, 21.75540951473558, 22.070849975906047, 36.62609606988584, 27.095729626956835, 31.737729370277815, 46.380421188225, 48.410350291109914, 25.699616862253478, 38.67622542402372, 15.857219990473093, 22.36248062736574, 27.15869324535309, 9.93458235312651, 43.635450651579845, 37.90623887646526, 38.92458809853283, 32.7221584054817, 35.79320277264164, 33.69589692495675], + "dssim": [0.30432476899489336, 0.3048173118473563, 0.46404158526322126, 0.16305096413090242, 0.3345267444493477, 0.24006420256215943, 0.22039079904466624, 0.08458215049978574, 0.40674893460759104, 0.25102823311542355, 0.39352076614362796, 0.25016936756908714, 0.15108761383244101, 0.25863048445646997, 0.3656802413835415, 0.2014595372785037, 0.2287921697720468, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286950336216564, 0.3685591582688572, 0.22377693690923794, 0.1499799781215589, 0.28837704438156087, 0.23843496815036347, 0.10373910970624295, 0.28144315142253584, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30745740456515225, 0.21943129138497236, 0.32548177657869437, 0.35816398251191495] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/refine-ablation.json b/tools/comparison/results/refine-ablation.json index 1b4da2b..5247ee0 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/refine-ablation.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/refine-ablation.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/refine-grid.json b/tools/comparison/results/refine-grid.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..af1355f --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/refine-grid.json @@ -0,0 +1,383 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "refine-grid", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "The first refinement pass optimized the encoder-input grid (100 px) while a tier-0 decoder renders 32 px, and it optimized squared error while the format is judged on dE00. refine_grid=1 moves the objective onto the decoder's own render grid, scored against the ideal full-basis downsample of the source. refine_obj picks what error means there: 0 = gamma sRGB, 2 = clipped OKLAB, 3 = clipped OKLAB with L/chroma weights.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/refine-grid.json", + "configSha256": "b958500751842d0a786712342bee9cb872e729b05121590f4c843ddc1afc8cbb", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B shipped", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid0 obj0 p2 (prior)", + "tune": "refine_passes=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.086243916527437, 9.240017420144747, 26.123647251574592, 10.67402550185963, 13.463463413621554, 9.924477396972353, 14.129094200947266, 4.101146340205387, 11.180641565947559, 12.205899746668678, 10.597650874966773, 11.133228474967314, 4.331232124322308, 11.925482603174109, 18.740277858120205, 10.961108166955384, 12.369603655367252, 10.749807348093485, 18.333903491515446, 14.171143792231193, 12.143229134795407, 4.5189575441141265, 13.126879307126067, 13.128239491529309, 2.412963944568638, 13.783800465337166, 13.494166506199212, 12.568231356762427, 8.830517276274989, 11.222543322978513, 14.872641012966426], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.2431097210752, -249.55793779453177, -1231.2130171004387, -183.8549168394308, -318.16982269341395, -245.22838589829206, -454.33092532040337, -63.28849887278841, -333.93433784796196, -355.4818881028332, -249.39283929602584, -189.16308042152696, -64.0542330183352, -285.36395148344127, -834.0115794964925, -240.72468173310307, -280.7326685846494, -118.8091876842307, -643.6258470651138, -694.8874582095984, -306.3207717908675, -64.61413674713134, -420.2379518277412, -254.89572676714192, -58.53377545429447, -400.2495201328413, -287.0508008086711, -388.2216789375348, -213.1307393737835, -441.6292589694651, -646.8439860263265], + "butteraugli": [23.73500012561425, 27.325332544790026, 45.109842167184645, 29.141543178010167, 25.810188561329483, 22.48474033699001, 40.36317910115694, 13.245696133734873, 20.458944170864275, 42.04642892521816, 22.196472210318902, 28.41934594612302, 22.23935596976914, 21.956112230318595, 36.98485518880095, 27.04951307924033, 31.800897965275187, 44.60401399085554, 49.0889128330553, 25.73578089861631, 38.698785995306366, 15.859167350770633, 22.713550003983055, 26.63758766388118, 9.622837491032149, 43.458464261401254, 37.691997270075326, 34.10347405862287, 32.13594189384124, 37.01070638445884, 34.81439920011032], + "dssim": [0.3043020082271469, 0.30503064576344274, 0.46380182312106855, 0.16506929456602387, 0.3346962511286986, 0.24217393803355325, 0.2202251045985495, 0.08454941398989835, 0.4069090834278785, 0.27216532220992096, 0.3935606087113866, 0.2549514935206312, 0.15094141313265935, 0.2586165188377566, 0.3658104381716255, 0.20142684329140653, 0.22937436933522698, 0.14949843148443537, 0.33004654521909593, 0.36840259115656304, 0.22369264998162502, 0.14933893409292076, 0.28378242922579455, 0.23839098534664482, 0.1113057825970325, 0.28114255000159893, 0.23015640813346222, 0.3089024506115341, 0.22051469978413868, 0.3328871535852125, 0.3558390292479954] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj0 p2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.094258719735507, 9.243495728731848, 26.15382849074066, 10.708114804744346, 13.469804104197886, 9.994274331563041, 14.100450454570213, 4.101146340205387, 11.180641565947559, 12.509132667661056, 10.627117648974153, 11.143543262324773, 4.343365637356974, 11.925482603174109, 18.747075867707288, 10.886316106605475, 12.369603655367252, 10.696197732583505, 18.54483087971802, 14.166831060907283, 12.211923603807474, 4.547762697787745, 13.102804537304571, 13.09868668337704, 2.447192749725229, 13.75844864378135, 13.112414266603258, 12.436264893415348, 8.826246232320955, 11.236957301797716, 14.872007509698369], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.32529199968081, -253.40105358419606, -1230.5747517358836, -183.80081615283729, -318.6820776929461, -248.82185056266053, -453.50097172238736, -63.28849887278841, -333.93433784796196, -369.51272380401355, -252.6325861876918, -182.074691586759, -64.0576889471578, -285.36395148344127, -834.7064040327995, -240.73782811072937, -280.7326685846494, -118.90985273553596, -643.7848517532216, -695.2299839169514, -306.8559885481968, -64.69461533890347, -419.54003235296454, -253.45062073493432, -58.52169122573923, -401.2784679246853, -285.4041315649491, -376.03978917081133, -211.9139578315349, -441.52801601902297, -645.4054431251723], + "butteraugli": [23.77020553330009, 27.39817310574357, 45.03486218577411, 29.140331636446007, 25.83463170193328, 22.43407508352909, 40.393239366038884, 13.245696133734873, 20.458944170864275, 41.30797947014053, 21.578229965665212, 28.69766868380208, 22.23693905765491, 21.956112230318595, 36.97705411408243, 27.04173904503674, 31.800897965275187, 44.66690141880014, 48.4005024022261, 25.753304814799346, 38.71661930707118, 15.714731591115159, 22.85935763035684, 26.64488719348945, 9.57592052686414, 43.58449886972047, 37.93453903109101, 34.853392303189885, 32.369784370519234, 37.010791922950574, 34.91549398356528], + "dssim": [0.3042809767725485, 0.3050144113000173, 0.4642762335276374, 0.1652701544823416, 0.334735497770954, 0.2459727723711761, 0.22022002395061124, 0.08454941398989835, 0.4069090834278785, 0.28028554277330353, 0.3935827633883859, 0.25267847275722677, 0.15097432764238938, 0.2586165188377566, 0.36582350103396233, 0.20141484004149224, 0.22937436933522698, 0.14838902313799324, 0.32829204836923853, 0.36838797107423815, 0.22372597907650743, 0.14948287629236684, 0.28332009331535857, 0.23813051359794762, 0.11116072093108725, 0.28108671124685836, 0.22487117733947737, 0.3056346382242491, 0.21992757791059286, 0.3328421814516067, 0.35594687888401066] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj0 p4", + "tune": "refine_passes=4 refine_grid=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.094258719735507, 9.243495728731848, 26.15382849074066, 10.67046022022031, 13.469804104197886, 10.034964556820489, 14.100450454570213, 4.101146340205387, 11.180641565947559, 12.45223326376947, 10.612332910405277, 11.143543262324773, 4.343365637356974, 11.925482603174109, 18.755555245901, 10.941639675226348, 12.369603655367252, 10.696197732583505, 18.612421193650075, 14.166831060907283, 12.181388997794002, 4.547762697787745, 13.102804537304571, 13.09868668337704, 2.432934104562059, 13.7427095629748, 13.112414266603258, 12.371068519243195, 8.823641475226482, 11.254550962338783, 14.877010723477651], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.32529199968081, -253.40105358419606, -1230.5747517358836, -183.5102478947905, -318.6820776929461, -246.8447678537015, -453.50097172238736, -63.28849887278841, -333.93433784796196, -361.81438492279995, -252.40488214158268, -182.074691586759, -64.0576889471578, -285.36395148344127, -835.1317554371814, -241.51688057385593, -280.7326685846494, -118.90985273553596, -640.0774972524393, -695.2299839169514, -306.545107713111, -64.69461533890347, -419.54003235296454, -253.45062073493432, -58.54238223310463, -401.15409034016557, -285.4041315649491, -381.9926281101674, -211.6530972420764, -441.3828228723456, -648.772910826982], + "butteraugli": [23.77020553330009, 27.39817310574357, 45.03486218577411, 29.141763503147725, 25.83463170193328, 22.169567176497093, 40.393239366038884, 13.245696133734873, 20.458944170864275, 41.162793914265215, 21.59085803552252, 28.69766868380208, 22.23693905765491, 21.956112230318595, 36.98936655446417, 27.05746670097535, 31.800897965275187, 44.66690141880014, 48.127978409915386, 25.753304814799346, 38.7136429318278, 15.714731591115159, 22.85935763035684, 26.64488719348945, 9.593999092394109, 43.61396403438605, 37.93453903109101, 32.951438032632446, 32.338818758577546, 37.01571417730915, 35.12318464284248], + "dssim": [0.3042809767725485, 0.3050144113000173, 0.4642762335276374, 0.16524815689261407, 0.334735497770954, 0.24700327275779516, 0.22022002395061124, 0.08454941398989835, 0.4069090834278785, 0.28394140156448744, 0.3935957871637819, 0.25267847275722677, 0.15097432764238938, 0.2586165188377566, 0.36586478336450323, 0.2014866866677823, 0.22937436933522698, 0.14838902313799324, 0.32855487193674326, 0.36838797107423815, 0.22371435552629548, 0.14948287629236684, 0.28332009331535857, 0.23813051359794762, 0.11110143875891554, 0.2810847598631533, 0.22487117733947737, 0.3103972386771626, 0.21989826648742733, 0.33288020583784217, 0.35626591499313565] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj0 p2 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.168176057394818, 9.243495728731848, 26.8124242394639, 10.690301647456511, 13.264448412026221, 10.05473152370326, 14.086171614952827, 3.9462957017444036, 11.09651952678205, 12.312684780567714, 10.692999281500668, 11.056923329706489, 4.3078552823633185, 12.192721648127531, 18.79810277251449, 10.886316106605475, 12.369603655367252, 11.155961237424737, 18.289551265132662, 14.166831060907283, 12.211923603807474, 4.547762697787745, 13.089740369008334, 13.209071823203697, 2.363044959235461, 13.722922696981117, 13.18949933553863, 12.83735429865959, 8.786993334728125, 11.16515372202488, 15.07481033843775], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.23881636202066, -253.40105358419606, -1226.2140870376033, -187.8510172290388, -314.5581252660861, -246.3850692810878, -453.71447022407847, -63.28872993916633, -321.41590629251164, -353.9621953569118, -252.042074430375, -182.0485964277084, -64.05043204875847, -285.17513820279106, -836.6919222279582, -240.73782811072937, -280.7326685846494, -119.41274197911568, -643.0453679378552, -695.2299839169514, -306.8559885481968, -64.69461533890347, -420.3644374761458, -256.0398940925666, -58.14511758305659, -397.97663012058, -280.3415571576864, -381.0021247590657, -210.36737657655408, -439.1215900720521, -649.8201078987371], + "butteraugli": [23.651195220074882, 27.39817310574357, 44.31614802452764, 29.268516068420595, 25.232411494395866, 22.128774830550345, 40.40360375259257, 13.21856272974005, 20.455873568957973, 41.4984780400151, 21.891771793506383, 28.66890316293866, 21.9565052938147, 21.969113435728463, 36.94338536312842, 27.04173904503674, 31.800897965275187, 44.335855129494746, 48.406404241550014, 25.753304814799346, 38.71661930707118, 15.714731591115159, 22.883970277787313, 26.343308785658138, 8.95171246477787, 43.6128353759147, 37.820897821363296, 33.89602897407597, 31.75848143988276, 35.560131711000764, 33.55259149558223], + "dssim": [0.30427380631851275, 0.3050144113000173, 0.46603685419788776, 0.16285981726419924, 0.3343193867753945, 0.24881783045126155, 0.22024465578353458, 0.08452272223555668, 0.40672642953530214, 0.2772164862355213, 0.39357948625246825, 0.2527422907307192, 0.15100370804765312, 0.2579870788733173, 0.36616085238510965, 0.20141484004149224, 0.22937436933522698, 0.1528751257675542, 0.32944886789351036, 0.36838797107423815, 0.22372597907650743, 0.14948287629236684, 0.2773514307009036, 0.23841963028236735, 0.11156333250225692, 0.2808490376082956, 0.23174375363995076, 0.30109777560979745, 0.21947958347139668, 0.33237750219377915, 0.3595681692232422] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj2 p2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.462186104051657, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.42285984645081, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.277385230690689, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.527609679521309, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -185.12699432227646, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -634.9715858192021, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.611432575282606, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.1647981623166, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 32.58449241687298, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.34465508521501, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.759071651248542, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 36.011551625670876, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2481774629368882, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.32644044686747686, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10328712440796012, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3088768168156951, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj2 p2 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.569760099777666, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.489469925620234, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.266108008998516, 13.568230041049175, 12.86563892527227, 12.436259855662025, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.832453560493223], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -181.671651581238, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -635.1618729713363, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.49402966072381, -393.29818833745065, -256.9811828691136, -359.5045093583615, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -640.4452690843448], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.281314711147008, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.367438992883365, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.713197225948859, 43.62994283427522, 38.23698701553945, 36.38702021904162, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 34.19358654263967], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16557281827522602, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.3253888399256327, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10300013693086707, 0.28146081862167605, 0.2253816058462545, 0.29989129467076103, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35773589664722394] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj3 wc=2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.521238099454758, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.965784849794384, 18.182386206499384, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.291097522102557, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.449805298915438, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.21238893532916, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -121.36494630773427, -643.8743969996857, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.51631223062532, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.8674461445566, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32805719811222, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.76069373060367, 48.25244410940791, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.704249606647009, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 37.32921378975868, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16549111246943005, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14860601094687742, 0.3288836031196599, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.1032572367257763, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.30851812799156175, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj3 wc=3", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.572189098129677, 13.285259391540748, 9.820270395374596, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.965784849794384, 18.161318538654932, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2989083428852264, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.222276741256495, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.23581300411314, -316.8761376942083, -238.82848943380446, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -121.36494630773427, -641.2717028820666, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.452908439336966, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -372.6594012787921, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.45315667361216, 25.9757699529749, 22.174630394973544, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.76069373060367, 48.49534204627826, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.391057685881472, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 39.55206814046297, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16540871804831442, 0.33441199960494017, 0.23989574434152533, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14860601094687742, 0.328828356896421, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10224997702460475, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3089150369177046, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj3 wc=0.5", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=0.5", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.390211248022858, 10.49975559801947, 10.674629675496906, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 11.319723617569885, 19.489389387285, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.482107556114878, 13.041586007728672, 13.040251023384975, 2.252767054287269, 13.613164247316469, 13.11449910168336, 12.717631757373368, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.924628791944171], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -339.9483575208132, -252.4415017392709, -184.34935737187408, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.6264619545924, -635.4545299794038, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.68338741259575, -415.9761889360135, -257.2866331230767, -59.49032084850461, -394.37017318064704, -270.968059021219, -369.5988045138547, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -646.2972970433], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.279263006119216, 21.59532446667645, 32.53562241279774, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.50383940984523, 48.05440353114974, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.729930028264612, 22.428612356561974, 27.22239971965548, 9.699399746433889, 43.6397756494902, 38.748124493278446, 36.158140247315316, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 34.98763029692507], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2560304409459605, 0.39362231848709167, 0.24959932987832373, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14968131494228815, 0.3285760165372015, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.1507207074796395, 0.2858572902044034, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10383456335663804, 0.2815372134118187, 0.22330659426222665, 0.3072554242351968, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35967643957888934] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid0 obj2 p2 (prior best)", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_obj=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.016574225069967, 10.49975559801947, 10.462186104051657, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.454786256189223, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.277385230690689, 13.568230041049175, 12.870254036710458, 12.454071392631242, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.94949257052264, -252.4415017392709, -185.12699432227646, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -638.5613452751783, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.611432575282606, -393.29818833745065, -265.2605837572781, -366.7552635575674, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.801975625484964, 21.59532446667645, 32.58449241687298, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.022173941534554, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.759071651248542, 43.62994283427522, 38.35321050160255, 36.7555161655245, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514366244067081, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2481774629368882, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.32692049362211884, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10328712440796012, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22310888396445877, 0.3093391455601058, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "grid1 obj2 p2 d2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_delta=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.462186104051657, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.42285984645081, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.277385230690689, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.527609679521309, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -185.12699432227646, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -634.9715858192021, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.611432575282606, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.1647981623166, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 32.58449241687298, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.34465508521501, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.759071651248542, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 36.011551625670876, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2481774629368882, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.32644044686747686, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10328712440796012, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3088768168156951, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 base", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 grid1 obj2", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.462186104051657, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.42285984645081, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.277385230690689, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.527609679521309, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -185.12699432227646, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -634.9715858192021, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.611432575282606, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.1647981623166, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 32.58449241687298, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.34465508521501, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.759071651248542, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 36.011551625670876, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2481774629368882, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.32644044686747686, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10328712440796012, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3088768168156951, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 grid1 obj2 +dcs", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.569760099777666, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.489469925620234, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.266108008998516, 13.568230041049175, 12.86563892527227, 12.436259855662025, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.832453560493223], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -181.671651581238, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -635.1618729713363, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.49402966072381, -393.29818833745065, -256.9811828691136, -359.5045093583615, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -640.4452690843448], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.281314711147008, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.367438992883365, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.713197225948859, 43.62994283427522, 38.23698701553945, 36.38702021904162, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 34.19358654263967], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16557281827522602, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.3253888399256327, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10300013693086707, 0.28146081862167605, 0.2253816058462545, 0.29989129467076103, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35773589664722394] + } + }, + { + "label": "t1 108B base", + "tune": null, + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.460348627730683, 7.406141729320733, 25.93828271794926, 7.721771907969617, 11.611603234963079, 8.19222384581283, 12.128587206342123, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.179432134465637, 9.721910522905754, 7.946309156635416, 3.310746104779896, 10.00818452008688, 16.513662005282484, 9.056320549141937, 10.168976542833649, 7.326874893788768, 14.99276434239793, 14.051518862761734, 9.169833930389713, 3.5437465236315893, 11.343223535649768, 11.08853353981668, 1.9713466057781046, 10.940516518120177, 10.338508532607511, 9.552798757455742, 6.396827632988628, 8.522547218634148, 12.460331691337952], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.39038246477116, -141.26378717982817, -1213.3990210035383, -82.5124310139935, -213.57867395975074, -119.76020416431749, -255.95306934416647, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -156.6067020667124, -163.78643714164008, -85.55060841086765, -62.42178515044719, -176.03451197457963, -486.52996913469497, -139.47205802885406, -158.18575121654806, -68.16309306141989, -268.88217550110573, -618.1881335365836, -144.62207681711635, -64.08167150561934, -285.0746616004951, -122.11403504620318, -50.47071656960571, -167.39644324794557, -141.05986535569016, -144.67825707242122, -116.90550353876279, -211.80337272533825, -389.0563602153415], + "butteraugli": [15.363000088053326, 22.140207956557504, 44.92674237052605, 22.696167708264568, 22.273135801923193, 19.632497071497465, 33.15047179702949, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.041794385975574, 19.192371669075044, 20.927786916688547, 17.531124819288, 19.49442349952079, 31.521336640512022, 24.658012719014184, 27.66218275167182, 27.79236566090094, 36.44058949370932, 25.237605376728098, 30.35621426147402, 13.869843320365979, 20.281816826239517, 22.0380043904314, 6.692810449981778, 29.632176029877247, 31.74211558873468, 24.71893925917175, 25.720408431806362, 31.26231665184316, 27.724991890155156], + "dssim": [0.3039300594656206, 0.30068419460793383, 0.4634857347467497, 0.15308817799474772, 0.3343923236319388, 0.21053570220492518, 0.22062410242981606, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.22994482425786006, 0.39301903391134946, 0.23415739304865568, 0.15164999540525853, 0.2549507711927276, 0.35907464012548085, 0.20450477236964515, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13511731347751277, 0.31148824553831755, 0.3694858967196917, 0.21939815959732606, 0.14802542771952226, 0.2763480074974578, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0837189415281478, 0.2655606695810029, 0.21077065007893175, 0.28133726607274145, 0.21109877166596108, 0.30299290095002684, 0.35096109481830406] + } + }, + { + "label": "t1 108B grid1 obj2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=2", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.460348627730683, 7.4032697996829695, 25.932298410318307, 7.728563630978251, 11.611603234963079, 8.180602382587262, 12.084526071865954, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.09645861118875, 9.72114043025274, 7.947170965278542, 3.3100413580748964, 10.00818452008688, 16.515708543308182, 9.057836032474023, 10.168976542833649, 7.500729314919881, 14.937931125263635, 14.054516275701973, 9.169833930389713, 3.5437465236315893, 11.403914058499144, 11.08853353981668, 1.9627006253878674, 10.990646145349219, 10.364978757401095, 9.509039412516376, 6.363791711737976, 8.51789134624504, 12.46834943235043], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.39038246477116, -140.8324469354293, -1212.8711152038254, -82.34361721931015, -213.57867395975074, -119.70453166704664, -251.18688721395102, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -153.1812156093411, -163.72061822533368, -85.46777773916739, -62.45281269941836, -176.03451197457963, -487.57342852923034, -138.5258250551578, -158.18575121654806, -67.77006662079629, -258.5773065043043, -618.1043738165852, -144.62207681711635, -64.08167150561934, -284.331158220676, -122.11403504620318, -50.581721396239516, -165.03627445286935, -136.24469562298157, -141.85387087521835, -112.82661243913486, -211.6660307978093, -387.96858982405513], + "butteraugli": [15.363000088053326, 22.20364799543552, 44.929114434256945, 22.68423110241963, 22.273135801923193, 19.631147392507767, 33.223650790955524, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.45778289991244, 19.19224244277537, 20.839725325261973, 17.527851616506943, 19.49442349952079, 31.538623133130482, 24.673451150475557, 27.66218275167182, 27.303264320736854, 35.64980859475988, 25.242005103237506, 30.35621426147402, 13.869843320365979, 20.380655623259074, 22.0380043904314, 6.650456825536172, 29.684551983378736, 31.671875031904293, 24.487921636867238, 26.40216955538915, 31.284874150602878, 27.769133532081497], + "dssim": [0.3039300594656206, 0.3006571783348979, 0.46342698878786825, 0.15377483472757558, 0.3343923236319388, 0.21106973341415142, 0.22106697840290374, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.2323918726360401, 0.39300751337548656, 0.23441139035226177, 0.15171963933780902, 0.2549507711927276, 0.3589809528006107, 0.204512335973894, 0.2282961326404485, 0.1365183064592827, 0.3117443890477186, 0.36954009792369513, 0.21939815959732606, 0.14802542771952226, 0.2738913334695964, 0.2369986922374835, 0.08369379832209473, 0.2663928763298994, 0.2111065206654757, 0.280084585752834, 0.21009317462147808, 0.3033286798614142, 0.35086468903787416] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/refine-objective.json b/tools/comparison/results/refine-objective.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1e1ad15 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/refine-objective.json @@ -0,0 +1,357 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "refine-objective", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "U5 isolated: with the pixel-domain search fixed, the only thing that matters is what error means. refine_obj=3 weights the clipped-OKLAB L term by refine_wl and the chroma terms by refine_wc, so this walks the objective from pixel-accurate (wc low) to colour-accurate (wc high) and finds where dE00 stops improving. Run on the shipped 32 B layout and on the retuned 4-bit one.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/refine-objective.json", + "configSha256": "f06ba692c827e40228585d22442864ef1758199ed8032239937224c65745cfe0", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "32B shipped", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=1", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.546635271921344, 13.285259391540748, 9.81256246515075, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.056033844853099, 10.49975559801947, 10.462186104051657, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.148465567934268, 18.42285984645081, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.277385230690689, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.527609679521309, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.96226243570823, -316.8761376942083, -239.76712644630334, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.7798034706077, -252.4415017392709, -185.12699432227646, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.35760316660702, -634.9715858192021, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.611432575282606, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.1647981623166, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32103137295081, 25.9757699529749, 22.115788181604504, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.156456791375625, 21.59532446667645, 32.58449241687298, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.51511561580703, 48.34465508521501, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.759071651248542, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 36.011551625670876, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.1657082246432091, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24143345932395155, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.25032068532506346, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2481774629368882, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14838775157544565, 0.32644044686747686, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10328712440796012, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3088768168156951, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=2", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.521238099454758, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.965784849794384, 18.182386206499384, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.291097522102557, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.449805298915438, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.21238893532916, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -121.36494630773427, -643.8743969996857, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.51631223062532, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -369.8674461445566, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.32805719811222, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.76069373060367, 48.25244410940791, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.704249606647009, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 37.32921378975868, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16549111246943005, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14860601094687742, 0.3288836031196599, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.1032572367257763, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.30851812799156175, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=3", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.572189098129677, 13.285259391540748, 9.820270395374596, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.965784849794384, 18.161318538654932, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.428246817362017, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2989083428852264, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.222276741256495, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.831022244164714], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -181.23581300411314, -316.8761376942083, -238.82848943380446, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -121.36494630773427, -641.2717028820666, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69580194473835, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.452908439336966, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -372.6594012787921, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -645.9961257852303], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 28.45315667361216, 25.9757699529749, 22.174630394973544, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.76069373060367, 48.49534204627826, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.720391802580076, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.391057685881472, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 39.55206814046297, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.22559623184381], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16540871804831442, 0.33441199960494017, 0.23989574434152533, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14860601094687742, 0.328828356896421, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14983644266710688, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10224997702460475, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.3089150369177046, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3575239108956566] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=4", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.565369421424403, 13.285259391540748, 9.820270395374596, 14.206826198842295, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.429032562785876, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.204937700020224, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.418783483221148, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.314455112861145, 13.568230041049175, 12.874383888360816, 12.39539586978202, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.883109988601353], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -183.53859268129122, -316.8761376942083, -238.82848943380446, -452.8487214026924, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -183.3411743455477, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -640.9368281158568, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.71658664572661, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.354269529858726, -393.29818833745065, -269.870466827333, -374.28428678737214, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -637.1792578922943], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 29.032266888794776, 25.9757699529749, 22.174630394973544, 40.34952049577404, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 33.26455875716463, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 48.18601493707299, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.656916495854773, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.162300693827953, 43.62994283427522, 38.508955024610536, 39.484165993254095, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 35.113576071727294], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16609122070526405, 0.33441199960494017, 0.23989574434152533, 0.22026060822642313, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.24747652104985773, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.328817970200717, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991599498231745, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10383596533061662, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22361718339447106, 0.31190117469492373, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3571190471400695] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=6", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=6", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.596350410651988, 13.285259391540748, 9.83061845637208, 14.188369852578212, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.079527037945951, 10.48629559427864, 10.429032562785876, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.90459162468235, 18.204937700020224, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.418783483221148, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.3093703418321754, 13.568230041049175, 12.951677112155485, 12.304718488715203, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 14.890401968156025], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -187.81281595175415, -316.8761376942083, -239.02749197083483, -453.30521866622416, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.81216976347855, -250.6793451413256, -183.3411743455477, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.36992124848712, -640.9368281158568, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.71658664572661, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.18496677410195, -393.29818833745065, -270.95688218054784, -380.63907928509525, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -638.3818173850473], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 29.79443414599702, 25.9757699529749, 22.116912266659, 40.27228356386151, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.323900057340886, 21.58198083161606, 33.26455875716463, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 45.872641126341485, 48.18601493707299, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.656916495854773, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.061424526232651, 43.62994283427522, 37.88025878272961, 38.91467602251442, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 34.312912121613465], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16665806201149708, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24229701291918032, 0.22028028470029476, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2531143019919726, 0.39363298379045497, 0.24747652104985773, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14824318330991143, 0.328817970200717, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991599498231745, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10383471964553265, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22458887120974008, 0.30551660090250343, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35684354916292305] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=10", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=10", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14235021176035, 10.792678169631136, 13.285259391540748, 9.931807077041764, 14.261272406787903, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.069857895631872, 10.502323491384066, 10.437684387904673, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 10.041787363287698, 18.30253034766048, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.411303564327215, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.3088593556132966, 13.568230041049175, 12.942798595034054, 12.642967653471873, 8.396911812513885, 10.95077410731479, 15.066818312200631], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.2640988237217, -196.92072190406356, -316.8761376942083, -248.05053199493648, -453.9447222688457, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -348.02389168680827, -251.91470617572344, -183.68150036907417, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -117.69121385332414, -650.9972250766139, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.69108103899882, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.327091702766324, -393.29818833745065, -276.6057096259625, -392.99715141364635, -213.1355539485133, -438.3670807901947, -651.4507893472559], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.08993819825965, 29.54467908410956, 25.9757699529749, 22.425597660040708, 40.34800102596197, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 43.49956065340376, 21.834484575287643, 32.85075482146025, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.72452457170163, 47.29282202147815, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.775252841809001, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.158536239600727, 43.62994283427522, 37.8283974660882, 38.88077267196187, 33.107375510063896, 36.851507352398635, 34.06793245188292], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643388529138327, 0.16772632236378887, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24639636737674875, 0.22030923363158167, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2561972172951553, 0.39359540369085727, 0.24766472075943297, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14773205037404114, 0.330920376911635, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14980112902112114, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10394212383375295, 0.28146081862167605, 0.2246600000452344, 0.3085467118213696, 0.2191180019500546, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35596971359035945] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=3 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.558309571978771, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.206365471779776, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773480133975156, 12.223455143955883, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -181.9651698067978, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.6962479308229, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -255.04990916249488, -371.2741049854743, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.35534338089487, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.529038584882095, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 38.00188942207895, 41.17884694746785, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.1669974774636211, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32788568545087127, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22368653630105628, 0.3022322301786785, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=4 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=4 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.535113597233973, 13.266299137951359, 9.910482506350732, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.181204860721486, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773221738794684, 12.119048687494777, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -183.8988652802151, -316.44037809990544, -240.45124113635848, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.3450964448974, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -254.92658436110986, -369.38343987124426, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 27.996878090198937, 25.96052017511792, 22.091996249060674, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.16883669878437, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 37.89606803106282, 39.628647853213955, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16797610355487025, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24457638689388767, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32854761504098606, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22350922596798528, 0.3005727228494327, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=3 p4 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=4 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.56519721670397, 13.266299137951359, 9.903162775800542, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.206365471779776, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773221738794684, 12.25704932597552, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -182.04768722681752, -316.44037809990544, -238.77569341739706, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.6962479308229, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -254.92658436110986, -376.09355872015476, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.346843333849126, 25.96052017511792, 22.165314777733727, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.529038584882095, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 37.89606803106282, 39.59332633247113, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16713324201412455, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24232610722827924, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32788568545087127, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22350922596798528, 0.30677402168009427, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "obj3 wc=3 d2 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_delta=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.551360785547066, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.206365471779776, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773480133975156, 12.252146959015581, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -182.1812928247461, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.6962479308229, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -255.04990916249488, -371.9428074877422, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.680345234458233, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.529038584882095, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 38.00188942207895, 41.196063708508824, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16626971953867015, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32788568545087127, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22368653630105628, 0.30468678350309597, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "4b L28C15 wc=3 +dc+scale", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.558309571978771, 13.266299137951359, 9.89860085401169, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.206365471779776, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773480133975156, 12.223455143955883, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -181.9651698067978, -316.44037809990544, -239.80144149921114, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.6962479308229, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -255.04990916249488, -371.2741049854743, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.35534338089487, 25.96052017511792, 22.10176078000737, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.529038584882095, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 38.00188942207895, 41.17884694746785, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.1669974774636211, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24338579643669955, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32788568545087127, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22368653630105628, 0.3022322301786785, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "4b L28C15 wc=4 +dc+scale", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=4 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.535113597233973, 13.266299137951359, 9.910482506350732, 14.02831347165641, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.077124294096224, 10.49975559801947, 10.460036899687847, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.833340762788534, 18.181204860721486, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.773221738794684, 12.119048687494777, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.774654736970016], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -183.8988652802151, -316.44037809990544, -240.45124113635848, -449.20169710443884, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -340.71560847751306, -252.4415017392709, -178.95198232460837, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -119.35892253922134, -640.3450964448974, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -254.92658436110986, -369.38343987124426, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -643.7744819533875], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 27.996878090198937, 25.96052017511792, 22.091996249060674, 40.10970515770109, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.80400455250166, 21.59532446667645, 34.79310591159663, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.954575060452555, 48.16883669878437, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 37.89606803106282, 39.628647853213955, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 33.93599643328341], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16797610355487025, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24457638689388767, 0.21982555136411247, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2514245507188232, 0.39362231848709167, 0.2475473112763284, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.1464056338638679, 0.32854761504098606, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22350922596798528, 0.3005727228494327, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35681137753860404] + } + }, + { + "label": "4b L28C15 wc=6 +dc+scale", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=6 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.131615910053616, 8.996802373274656, 26.2146903340842, 10.554104191733066, 13.266299137951359, 9.903110606245276, 14.01659275845632, 3.5449224552783187, 11.045684117149495, 12.079527037945951, 10.48629559427864, 10.427623827067569, 4.101890095027436, 11.830727605860737, 18.808933382212373, 10.800436010100647, 12.216467394855112, 9.836251788793103, 18.229371800684792, 13.97655827662083, 12.082277227724957, 4.2890170230089, 13.025426936807653, 13.040251023384975, 2.2497725589466713, 13.568230041049175, 12.81015754245627, 12.092771987135512, 8.356153836034242, 10.95077410731479, 14.964024981022062], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.86436336612493, -252.4414132060964, -1227.0187005395267, -183.45579141800584, -316.44037809990544, -241.3189482395797, -453.6500040554654, -63.31284701891687, -327.6690457875978, -341.81216976347855, -250.6793451413256, -179.8591047340194, -64.06151473814805, -281.28344903124673, -828.3093380350354, -247.50626503995676, -280.72665730734684, -118.81559812342388, -641.5351037076796, -693.9597374175939, -307.28790111916857, -64.7131684968434, -415.8971289995136, -257.2866331230767, -59.48589571335933, -393.29818833745065, -259.1854024422205, -375.79049005175955, -212.41668796469003, -438.3670807901947, -661.6658643024693], + "butteraugli": [22.98454770286737, 27.02560129647775, 44.72635607442478, 28.08182018064598, 25.96052017511792, 22.0909717342177, 40.14051984001235, 13.19354059783754, 20.22669971895898, 43.323900057340886, 21.58198083161606, 36.97883548918039, 21.90530522725312, 22.18171806419967, 36.86136205933303, 27.07578156557368, 31.803964886452388, 46.415928647180785, 48.093572773091125, 25.956180753989557, 38.7412554096962, 15.764454663754742, 22.4159920710474, 27.22239971965548, 9.714763610195766, 43.62994283427522, 38.32726398013865, 38.45644804558548, 32.51416389561852, 36.851507352398635, 34.49184607151448], + "dssim": [0.3043183388773244, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4649536484759757, 0.16707477247889185, 0.3344078689847704, 0.24430830402737896, 0.22048219296865718, 0.08453685866499788, 0.4068339081966421, 0.2531143019919726, 0.39363298379045497, 0.24782616189235585, 0.15105440334257053, 0.25796530077209134, 0.36564350397742884, 0.20122394558540463, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14850976992089104, 0.32946518546441284, 0.36820780841998196, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14991080874725154, 0.2842334411519585, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10377587803577709, 0.28146081862167605, 0.22494262758819156, 0.307055282291254, 0.21899362063703665, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3577778453668407] + } + }, + { + "label": "t1 wc=3 +dc+scale", + "tune": "refine_passes=2 refine_grid=1 refine_obj=3 refine_wc=3 refine_dc=1 refine_scale=1", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.490426552561483, 7.4032697996829695, 26.009124194616195, 7.743375774427395, 11.554256282298494, 8.254259047379586, 12.008290546606965, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.068813482108, 9.720819520300774, 7.835366504693131, 3.301556052255819, 10.032664042054547, 16.515708543308182, 9.057836032474023, 10.168976542833649, 7.171197133063761, 14.771506685549486, 13.884763671832369, 9.117590471887624, 3.416535623481274, 11.439363222874363, 11.08853353981668, 1.9330477505713197, 10.960741186721064, 10.25258097653761, 9.013516051316696, 6.328530433781551, 8.51789134624504, 12.44152642151391], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.50766516819073, -140.8324469354293, -1209.7740923833335, -82.44569933375433, -213.14221613109117, -119.55614419514393, -250.70444245749394, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -154.36184566409332, -164.24029067733284, -85.5397999161741, -62.471635081182, -175.86532897013842, -487.57342852923034, -138.5258250551578, -158.18575121654806, -68.05817660177794, -260.35964613821795, -617.1038743723352, -142.72362848325076, -64.08408209817341, -286.46955781280076, -122.11403504620318, -50.18230300251054, -164.77057318669097, -140.8978104883565, -141.592787751122, -111.54729076981948, -211.6660307978093, -382.55849901548766], + "butteraugli": [15.288481761624771, 22.20364799543552, 44.580726769966255, 22.60552433285285, 22.33355197347163, 19.57480750984485, 32.96516372712967, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.443661770349905, 19.164471694415493, 20.928114254831318, 17.583508384398442, 19.484904597422943, 31.538623133130482, 24.673451150475557, 27.66218275167182, 28.178881947581402, 36.01148134138281, 25.29658105184117, 29.907365383474627, 13.86284620197871, 20.345795129627565, 22.0380043904314, 7.015281176388091, 29.69585605420387, 32.092737547466335, 25.060379770769202, 26.484526943864356, 31.284874150602878, 27.872122700344892], + "dssim": [0.3039158645525698, 0.3006571783348979, 0.46414111382940265, 0.15418418713157706, 0.334402310304592, 0.2138145195578352, 0.2208915664435947, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.23416148774929252, 0.39299055115773424, 0.23428629906193638, 0.15172534534330356, 0.2554920095322878, 0.3589809528006107, 0.204512335973894, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13780745681635193, 0.31101074440203214, 0.36927820324003136, 0.21901941000179553, 0.1479759055287952, 0.270744700953399, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0840072705010424, 0.2663679154628683, 0.21049462874402353, 0.27176575156034566, 0.20938899173311099, 0.3033286798614142, 0.3506716944150138] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/render-raster.json b/tools/comparison/results/render-raster.json index ce2c6bb..6017b51 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/render-raster.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/render-raster.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/retune-32b.json b/tools/comparison/results/retune-32b.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f6beae3 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/retune-32b.json @@ -0,0 +1,422 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "retune-32b", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "Retune the companding and encoder policy for the 4-bit-luma / 3-bit-chroma allocation that wins at 32 B. mu_L=5 / mu_C=8 were locked against the 5 b / 4 b layout, so they are not automatically right for a coarser one; aniso=1.2 and scale_fit are stacked on top of the winner.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/retune-32b.json", + "configSha256": "f93ba62a114d8f85126d9f0cdb8127dd1656dbe55cd6a6c937355d3299244b69", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "SHIPPED L26@5 C9@4", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "A L38@4 C8@3", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.700153115888159, 8.912595931750543, 26.12637937856586, 10.201045387696633, 13.73080779981809, 9.968457688979807, 14.147024931727477, 3.6054718990411727, 10.790437498800674, 11.445522045260418, 10.320533293396391, 10.36815346429736, 4.121941848536388, 11.60476367593855, 18.893210236426658, 10.555731957523411, 11.851489883496516, 10.211080956862661, 18.465267028309025, 14.179502347211773, 11.690812896485468, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.778973288317692, 2.351383154351986, 13.11953641581423, 13.16577096162637, 12.62432066438981, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.075649359888144], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.83776361247902, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6227877492252, -132.61464326345487, -319.369285887243, -215.15693170653594, -423.1331821366882, -62.96597055893267, -300.518292282055, -294.32721126125216, -244.86742937580027, -166.0519134467831, -63.981169388638875, -261.4704960734822, -820.8659974859756, -227.11353530376425, -244.80300052097436, -110.90917751779642, -593.9956716068152, -677.1551497509682, -274.4196752938118, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -241.12082463180616, -60.04107288806151, -349.11667130136925, -267.04295258809344, -367.32381405845905, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.9535321700258], + "butteraugli": [21.149976468695613, 25.989735467241832, 45.07985143311412, 26.387225690812887, 25.432174540381208, 21.49033616985284, 38.37897826746991, 13.188321785052546, 19.36460318984157, 36.659238743943654, 20.31371468600456, 27.796673243854325, 20.80758971269439, 21.89071352544754, 36.942437783618395, 26.74170665415075, 30.61739277370246, 45.12078185495064, 45.555821198951776, 25.647687239483286, 36.573357394503226, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 26.012735683731535, 10.42219463510112, 40.49235609902217, 37.62590765415828, 34.551997895041204, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.43343099123112], + "dssim": [0.3042885741415553, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643909211403664, 0.15946634301327278, 0.3347675736865815, 0.23594307907022755, 0.22066619605328225, 0.08440320072254731, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26165594754308796, 0.3939415860957996, 0.2500487961173269, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577282676551266, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20136652214569378, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1469262129751927, 0.33151934625458845, 0.36874801102994126, 0.22388648658521398, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23797656468577033, 0.0994303234645646, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565696878096558, 0.3056313746384203, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35492799100061434] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_l=3", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_l=3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.684085840396704, 9.01460185007151, 26.12562288289403, 10.221035079299906, 13.73400496741106, 9.88574828874704, 14.122061518074062, 3.6348806168834025, 10.808128254238067, 11.404080007863627, 10.317052469980766, 10.256157937353686, 4.084050354897655, 11.664976908150342, 18.946863066995665, 10.654674452909227, 11.944259292048933, 10.125688549811214, 18.45641121004505, 14.185067803835596, 11.729229779512973, 4.2720250189115525, 13.429656103486504, 12.75299015822653, 2.322831986478247, 13.143036452023496, 13.187041872608956, 12.52958445148799, 7.937198680953742, 10.139550117633947, 15.15294964337322], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.47877444726, -249.33110513767576, -1229.912422483859, -136.74268860564123, -311.8981282597542, -212.1194012679769, -425.48167891490937, -62.97880528682913, -300.3216058324651, -285.2022868203725, -238.0739004491059, -165.8653255986615, -63.96751569726658, -265.0228334168281, -820.262119812511, -229.81101027702522, -241.299856871048, -104.7862555252762, -589.1929771182764, -674.4240070880608, -280.0823344808922, -64.34362051358806, -424.2709068634431, -240.69225969591457, -60.461533161334415, -346.9450772509833, -283.5745685684254, -363.57942104885785, -195.54075038248692, -376.3737359631693, -608.7422258259357], + "butteraugli": [20.798092923197284, 25.845449538602598, 45.089468991402015, 26.3746406707125, 24.618646236245684, 21.520033161400182, 38.65653673192957, 12.998267064471468, 19.48447473202103, 36.39508535368285, 20.53915008030613, 28.489357792006047, 21.300277253058912, 22.03653283744889, 37.11472352545855, 26.81726727372403, 30.368968256595394, 45.44510589167324, 46.054384865239854, 25.634228255421352, 37.07994468448471, 15.4890595774388, 22.248280828529705, 26.014440855876, 11.068586139174007, 39.4900354025254, 38.855790281494954, 37.79269235866794, 30.334474719859106, 35.16957753717654, 33.85035621301501], + "dssim": [0.30416520736497876, 0.30481807220104806, 0.4643842662715088, 0.1599028016100783, 0.33470872272280516, 0.23675486883354357, 0.2208341994301069, 0.0843497380128741, 0.40657474187231474, 0.2646600714695718, 0.393838345423933, 0.2505861909165735, 0.15123239600399785, 0.2583218242952011, 0.36573112991453927, 0.20086521724833578, 0.22729133012522357, 0.14482958579001926, 0.3286716703579121, 0.3688650983066972, 0.22288785191127958, 0.15028077976427062, 0.29339176044989224, 0.2378382155837277, 0.09932250929106673, 0.2774250261167185, 0.2308972315457698, 0.3067673731773424, 0.21723151284379943, 0.31809235775281974, 0.3562749533564402] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_l=4", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_l=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.692591904160902, 8.969005572077293, 26.126380672628027, 10.166102035923231, 13.709161300790187, 9.924738557025266, 14.074183540601929, 3.5875912188141164, 10.777922542455041, 11.41975798589396, 10.288305712979495, 10.370201385530665, 4.065409539825494, 11.67814923945469, 18.885160332092383, 10.661278562987379, 11.852560489489404, 10.25261446390955, 18.42276633889786, 14.190596704740154, 11.653449402999366, 4.215737045303154, 13.437025965704427, 12.775177800837541, 2.3475532224939446, 13.209288491111737, 13.10016231940373, 12.603454800782394, 7.89300149273631, 10.07076612273541, 15.165227754520284], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.33376723434748, -251.629396308553, -1229.3304100464788, -133.0937387711863, -312.17990891574294, -213.31534781137174, -421.6394377269188, -62.92561338960226, -301.6463464653599, -292.12786275484336, -236.1855786353243, -167.71655912496902, -63.96062189607994, -262.3376794602764, -817.4513207776649, -230.64313139443857, -243.77217108084267, -110.94254142640708, -595.8190366443794, -676.1978833648841, -274.3057720713623, -64.32643219009367, -424.61974946613043, -239.3756356851277, -59.954893521792314, -351.05268319144244, -267.14714061340214, -366.7813140245394, -190.1531678450645, -376.27924296157835, -614.7117163199083], + "butteraugli": [21.073823618755018, 26.04864982530962, 45.06843692376513, 26.5431349016054, 25.40230132365636, 21.512670395988607, 38.53452586515729, 13.145733109337224, 19.358810197136208, 36.29486940031412, 21.1025089417501, 27.68662712869894, 20.89019466641513, 21.740119480769653, 37.077561440973795, 26.77895003568645, 30.664668275548024, 44.85460671206624, 46.39720951085334, 25.60162603190783, 37.225663253857576, 15.231901870709855, 22.217980415038273, 25.509021788168123, 10.682897252661315, 39.75590577127168, 37.457411268696724, 37.16869883974373, 29.917529388201206, 34.35332094466441, 33.83742889892654], + "dssim": [0.3042700806102221, 0.30512391487219603, 0.4644020710438425, 0.16037830710235657, 0.33446834085658594, 0.23469001830952935, 0.21988632930924235, 0.08422701451387576, 0.40658958449752475, 0.26386752284410186, 0.39386946973005815, 0.25000999830564663, 0.15126822370922266, 0.25840092519275515, 0.3653488770736363, 0.20211895707455385, 0.22805326809987087, 0.14682734462374603, 0.32964263677357963, 0.3687844773459944, 0.22159656011252604, 0.15010978546297515, 0.29202662032457094, 0.23805128107287182, 0.1001051728710704, 0.2773197357042323, 0.22747548097573872, 0.30400017767058773, 0.21703046000060777, 0.31684734579048535, 0.3569151618852433] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_l=6", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_l=6", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.703015996145596, 8.916992913539904, 26.11994950060723, 10.223934649725054, 13.746473556248484, 9.984088707135285, 14.194313594560441, 3.6545220808317764, 10.699242537824613, 11.442287648029007, 10.322921098212303, 10.264283802483883, 4.124283952215052, 11.61450171171966, 18.927542805012855, 10.533116902556838, 11.832317660035866, 10.21019756278152, 18.529893512661513, 14.177974693053216, 11.64883136479235, 4.230664907278643, 13.381589128970083, 12.799112657615149, 2.3256926538776534, 13.16898439068293, 13.095686616744462, 12.653812260713009, 7.977254657303703, 10.063808259007493, 15.035150308529964], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.5134451075195, -245.6277747849478, -1229.3948868100117, -135.92877327699836, -316.9756275502508, -217.31052963976379, -426.85429199122973, -62.9212180736059, -294.0276179829227, -296.95176746755124, -245.24995519697234, -162.15557480808815, -63.984176024517694, -260.03018973469284, -820.0808582077254, -226.39923201937575, -248.2361335096885, -106.84992026245556, -599.7768264045936, -678.1467179199585, -270.7790114769191, -64.39863358399637, -423.07324912189597, -241.69905696863447, -60.450224418891764, -350.65144916041436, -264.09110170635654, -366.8326685456915, -188.4028865011453, -380.76655654982767, -610.4729282628807], + "butteraugli": [21.099008738069596, 25.88520987171547, 45.08591787513118, 26.161514857102123, 25.013613787418205, 21.482843237297164, 38.211116251744755, 13.113722806470568, 19.74511184943327, 36.45043086178574, 20.363818741982374, 26.504514487868594, 20.82118725917761, 22.03393062821735, 36.45829799964347, 26.728700864839976, 30.937770889401648, 44.047745041125324, 45.94131257780699, 25.6406593317928, 37.0589256717507, 14.99728277879001, 22.261095003254947, 25.55626427729848, 11.294517872944738, 40.44076010724215, 37.716238559501924, 35.764852070165354, 31.45394411040842, 35.030894776790696, 34.309497461162216], + "dssim": [0.3042196367575253, 0.30483306558959633, 0.4643355969030785, 0.15971173728261046, 0.3348325616804124, 0.2334315950196505, 0.22119860682793918, 0.08426308444755098, 0.4061505975673325, 0.264371747734388, 0.3938409949035934, 0.251391711112248, 0.15138159894846992, 0.25763909141005914, 0.3656451688542935, 0.2007840299197075, 0.22723897318489145, 0.14672711682670725, 0.33455494744202896, 0.36871264441297585, 0.2225425137545039, 0.14980608335367424, 0.2933462186777276, 0.23819058639070295, 0.09798380721268879, 0.27720234089588214, 0.2260686257986801, 0.3058080351977801, 0.21710650766285328, 0.3165995116672913, 0.35460710897979175] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_l=8", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_l=8", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.699978959724401, 8.935182858605005, 26.129690163981792, 10.296777618563565, 13.7150867439618, 9.994941955860751, 14.15567859173151, 3.6401161728461107, 10.672613765429709, 11.486790932610612, 10.383710746437378, 10.141041515448615, 4.105434654627814, 11.6702734103489, 18.896655787481908, 10.573971503382545, 11.865234651853031, 10.189128718544504, 18.49011796493581, 14.19120828631568, 11.618655521410437, 4.24903642550612, 13.414225506783042, 12.782051885729423, 2.3443116638915056, 13.339445200442311, 13.157723736098456, 12.695485227416581, 7.8464676436316525, 10.08644311607436, 15.063373307383547], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.87834359973508, -244.23079653619448, -1230.3969926043144, -137.25569456137043, -317.4385227109088, -214.9933369278338, -421.36866271319013, -62.9003647110824, -299.1950605719922, -300.1454189053916, -242.0509586403943, -160.10009518821238, -64.00120487594751, -256.77467462844777, -820.1463600426437, -226.93644904891613, -250.33646263882105, -102.72650194549607, -597.0888434415248, -673.7858346815107, -274.030355906734, -64.34127591009269, -417.74925515712823, -239.87870298109033, -58.313507379238615, -358.49873188982986, -267.7387841953529, -368.77094128512056, -186.55925590473868, -375.12158077579966, -617.4103533806993], + "butteraugli": [20.845246780945605, 25.81713081299296, 45.072530941508965, 26.099644142974054, 25.399421887504335, 21.759060978569106, 38.35515882831081, 13.24964419170123, 19.729280415034683, 34.58709308354889, 20.823426363206156, 25.389710297202864, 20.57100344574796, 21.801276432559817, 36.739324071654835, 27.02194234030382, 31.077203441561966, 44.22549799528719, 46.23879651525218, 25.627384498251672, 37.540758182397234, 14.932673838865904, 22.050784387134275, 25.442766019954053, 8.69374269721595, 38.03641456773642, 38.9067329439499, 36.304333266919606, 31.356781348946427, 35.96564487876773, 33.97645442050507], + "dssim": [0.3041697145961969, 0.3048251752779011, 0.46448232212913365, 0.15928263981089685, 0.3347273149178819, 0.23025133540308745, 0.22087982837940862, 0.08434042437406669, 0.40621290026438717, 0.2794922063402979, 0.3940929146878016, 0.24951468916706265, 0.1515188019201174, 0.2579507288633376, 0.3657117190380298, 0.20125969785597125, 0.22802807744163328, 0.14415864914331733, 0.3338748168088589, 0.3690580285280498, 0.22162420730191412, 0.14980770491109663, 0.2924606721283304, 0.23808764458397025, 0.09607839237577726, 0.2771904908913684, 0.22373218796539396, 0.30606974139728615, 0.2178268978320373, 0.3161753989768622, 0.3553648486104988] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_c=5", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_c=5", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.675116153197072, 8.912595931750543, 26.126260362380958, 10.171743508390623, 13.58528660995575, 10.010744243339648, 14.248537943501844, 3.6442580035623995, 10.790437498800674, 11.489415246275096, 10.323544563295357, 10.356840831292455, 4.141738086014591, 11.604168187897045, 18.93013524068507, 10.594289738176988, 11.895682521026659, 10.26417432759356, 18.505524845260172, 14.174729093966732, 11.677146232474266, 4.167228382464581, 13.339537246239995, 12.645683438847225, 2.33144360357153, 13.11953641581423, 13.151270267446359, 12.454191233430915, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.041227823633022], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.11737985474858, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6997768380738, -132.55775978290373, -318.8525994312932, -215.29373758378733, -423.0777248370516, -62.96338166194499, -300.518292282055, -294.4828278029272, -244.58783713889568, -165.70842272687298, -63.98232785012175, -261.89634487396347, -819.3304882186231, -227.56340081402408, -245.1021341666309, -110.63127533558716, -594.2265014046898, -676.3438219872863, -274.487406490701, -64.3847213375285, -423.4209217826482, -241.4299226566456, -59.98882722347321, -349.11667130136925, -267.0406946739229, -367.1742377072906, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -613.5320169001261], + "butteraugli": [21.165788260058108, 25.989735467241832, 45.083815001128535, 26.39961250300784, 25.4139010086944, 21.48474658131369, 38.39386096695063, 13.210975556639106, 19.36460318984157, 36.65037583929535, 20.304945596522224, 27.792845840265255, 20.826697220642803, 21.905437272058567, 36.91798492989934, 26.736269489085075, 30.62439103675098, 45.05341937287216, 45.637708111607594, 25.64309438202747, 36.54933360099155, 15.212133007897611, 22.41110145540671, 25.921746002214064, 10.365193861492942, 40.49235609902217, 37.59776312261862, 34.611150624679624, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.35828684893328], + "dssim": [0.3042649802655579, 0.3049419877174867, 0.46439368278329635, 0.1592074163192067, 0.33475299192003394, 0.23705889974554134, 0.22065430559116794, 0.08434151781912841, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26164338086721217, 0.39394444422108965, 0.24983861770535348, 0.15149313085188493, 0.25774693661344206, 0.36553594205644535, 0.20138376145782044, 0.22745414873879383, 0.14730240632841002, 0.3308913483748339, 0.368708941040932, 0.22388706413474435, 0.14936952083552413, 0.29194180995909413, 0.23777516469499643, 0.09933604376869365, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22550524167287317, 0.3052556809215564, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.3556013794620583] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_c=6", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_c=6", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.6965181047219415, 8.912595931750543, 26.125284001426536, 10.17426489829936, 13.596841425551418, 9.99377698635835, 14.18940579005583, 3.613797273337076, 10.790437498800674, 11.472089107583196, 10.317967097043125, 10.362600587407327, 4.132209139944877, 11.598787605970097, 18.925702349936625, 10.590012248322866, 11.880985301250822, 10.237345683733418, 18.51723299681611, 14.1737537587532, 11.67955454416763, 4.175056791064097, 13.366839591210368, 12.743258057473836, 2.3392015648732727, 13.11953641581423, 13.170915706896526, 12.462752264326255, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.026661756169869], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.94670274785517, -251.14169641317483, -1229.5892464038334, -132.7695122248261, -319.02112722893685, -215.66291581769872, -423.48933598269684, -62.96001103467009, -300.518292282055, -294.320935367546, -244.89399991206096, -165.74146383061304, -63.98236206641573, -261.53973553756487, -819.4546916360014, -227.42044320407615, -244.9736606612626, -110.83064047412876, -592.1418170163788, -676.3254287332134, -274.5694831451604, -64.38086809941177, -424.17758248624557, -241.756326269633, -60.04293558627862, -349.11667130136925, -266.9168857980099, -367.59994830525267, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.8121282555181], + "butteraugli": [21.12491805267336, 25.989735467241832, 45.08101212906998, 26.40924130517946, 25.42851076576102, 21.494332625275174, 38.38140332933139, 13.162472298588801, 19.36460318984157, 36.65659834182757, 20.313078436487682, 27.784549115532965, 20.816012676324398, 21.875671548913303, 36.93445543938788, 26.740212836874495, 30.62668669969734, 45.10206605291617, 45.588876724523054, 25.64182812732038, 36.55151629386137, 15.22367529115389, 22.385392240701737, 25.942983750833122, 10.414776058171881, 40.49235609902217, 37.59875415495825, 34.61741758647957, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.383662168905204], + "dssim": [0.30426937891118866, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643950813027704, 0.1592945732725226, 0.3347722934743729, 0.23678078402808017, 0.22070271422593318, 0.08435134499450059, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26154022914274655, 0.3939556164334703, 0.2500412563499881, 0.15149653404033286, 0.25775615525435924, 0.36549927076175925, 0.20137735903433046, 0.22747724666547242, 0.14719903649217997, 0.3306425018684084, 0.36870840685001127, 0.22388672984865982, 0.14986614524081793, 0.2922754673879734, 0.2378519486402887, 0.09937059779036655, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22550236572012777, 0.3056433077945617, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.3558865731204326] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_c=12", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_c=12", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.705214127700943, 8.912595931750543, 26.12530945776245, 10.163052638201611, 13.773324526963087, 10.010436366948936, 14.18380526940802, 3.53776624423689, 10.790437498800674, 11.440976373033566, 10.310932180594415, 10.39258826641433, 4.115101097930829, 11.677226297618072, 18.894331403305397, 10.58210751221116, 11.85705615627934, 10.170141468642226, 18.43636039851424, 14.17655612760781, 11.677236820751974, 4.207791149261746, 13.504141857928502, 12.820880152468229, 2.3425778272322493, 13.11953641581423, 13.103276700520055, 12.457714749192279, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.090035618129118], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.88158454297397, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6050069851708, -132.28012496541623, -319.7213045752901, -215.74236276345567, -423.43781287987497, -63.00249652413672, -300.518292282055, -294.47645652473915, -245.15170514467013, -165.74827071476295, -63.97615733131852, -261.82680604902873, -820.3258477614219, -227.58885594436407, -244.5972781515519, -111.14342654893574, -592.8097787051599, -676.7317497301913, -274.954460680699, -64.38757035138747, -423.28088647235086, -241.57241449261483, -60.049729249180615, -349.11667130136925, -267.23012540991954, -362.3187482006732, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.8806696105763], + "butteraugli": [21.15719543783925, 25.989735467241832, 45.0809122143983, 26.382321595150984, 25.46158991654917, 21.50198904834781, 38.402677106304516, 13.1798035530609, 19.36460318984157, 36.67452873394473, 20.3540429420175, 27.81874234966807, 20.839320314755703, 21.90014888321264, 36.91303903218729, 26.743449738593387, 30.641029939660616, 45.195155818915914, 45.55987622501206, 25.640469599011094, 36.572751449827344, 15.213699610481031, 22.321670369963897, 25.994610638820745, 10.41278624427296, 40.49235609902217, 37.634039373029886, 34.69388441406265, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.46064294462149], + "dssim": [0.30427263045048825, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4644158216255761, 0.15974648704214128, 0.3347311957460777, 0.23750728488391099, 0.2207148991172762, 0.08439477204355939, 0.40638266861679534, 0.2617346525620441, 0.3939680198387922, 0.2501179310411633, 0.1514613662334749, 0.25772794512554564, 0.365530587547086, 0.20140129145612556, 0.2273795416120002, 0.14666802872751483, 0.33167332251730974, 0.3687554974112991, 0.22390549609028548, 0.14948704563010096, 0.29062550295393585, 0.2379872336770097, 0.09947645344510292, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22570298144158935, 0.3049109028786433, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35548676462762097] + } + }, + { + "label": "A mu_c=16", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 mu_c=16", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.710356283074657, 8.912595931750543, 26.125220033978582, 10.324846665405408, 13.748386386978355, 9.967435863807404, 14.136808133917372, 3.6099085385755783, 10.790437498800674, 11.417081077480034, 10.29189677593333, 10.425829167334536, 4.144108468988496, 11.66301957027712, 18.938597376046733, 10.542292298110654, 11.811882985797949, 10.18628967934347, 18.43696343622727, 14.181010159229302, 11.681289857492722, 4.21991268452358, 13.542037619978082, 12.868839162655217, 2.353419558337384, 13.11953641581423, 13.103062524495476, 12.472962616872344, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.11086135899645], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.90372925733345, -251.14169641317483, -1229.7258745502136, -132.51149801121733, -318.66079258454556, -215.07927768229985, -423.0873496796038, -62.9650615260567, -300.518292282055, -295.01721067436023, -244.94414676403858, -166.13035091193626, -63.97882618175598, -261.1116444490632, -819.2826386218326, -227.5995006569986, -244.93141284161646, -110.89273387268463, -593.1092587077545, -677.1095769275161, -274.83012689877273, -64.39259714160096, -424.7687343008372, -242.02499649149752, -60.03198971034581, -349.11667130136925, -267.30473596067264, -362.9313322360563, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -611.6561175635372], + "butteraugli": [21.164129076746587, 25.989735467241832, 45.08074698041221, 26.40208293354661, 25.363315427999396, 21.501692370855483, 38.39371120111824, 13.155064671656616, 19.36460318984157, 36.67194591530032, 20.33834214117064, 27.82348921272002, 20.78841083689826, 21.897815527734185, 36.904848617431846, 26.754289165020527, 30.641061910103744, 45.13513763989999, 45.570356521160626, 25.639805718470253, 36.543550536910466, 15.21950549483374, 22.28664384919932, 25.992366170448552, 10.397674929212675, 40.49235609902217, 37.657112418339615, 34.64066556125314, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.42020001106743], + "dssim": [0.3042714065363359, 0.3049419877174867, 0.46441075126334397, 0.1590110988809627, 0.3347778996169829, 0.2368411671803906, 0.2207021573777782, 0.08439830268021081, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26234893339896304, 0.3939625466493575, 0.2501943134065078, 0.15144565103914837, 0.257703293346234, 0.3655181037646976, 0.20135933952956525, 0.22733870902783998, 0.14736115911623776, 0.33183143884513866, 0.36877257481880865, 0.22381651074290665, 0.14952169157675438, 0.2919655457604925, 0.2380537229563781, 0.09961233507486916, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565799600334174, 0.30496353700015166, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.3567808075395399] + } + }, + { + "label": "B L28@4 C15@3", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "B mu_l=4", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 mu_l=4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.05271403660315, 9.07254799029084, 26.14707761853014, 10.520639710160486, 13.237227200024208, 9.838041475864419, 14.16796966807153, 3.540140413712654, 11.03125409915219, 12.029377546784, 10.447513139627466, 10.373098174493597, 4.122821554581203, 11.786909363958062, 18.807265044918143, 10.944391129171098, 12.198265228043844, 9.950409223147318, 18.258775465809222, 14.175407867608243, 11.986853076815827, 4.42219426178487, 12.95068150923099, 13.06307089385361, 2.3245535301386457, 13.575414222849213, 12.84649530563126, 12.309968734198051, 8.453660448013489, 10.97514276068978, 14.90639324958058], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.6825803442502, -256.0329347073667, -1231.1603642622629, -184.9148002301576, -316.59956142643307, -240.23953488672169, -449.654397888311, -63.28113235869023, -332.2882090859672, -339.9353770106004, -243.42162181467563, -181.94160363996298, -64.08014440585617, -278.54305643987067, -827.1994061879763, -248.73795038227234, -275.4018620928256, -121.37571403588606, -639.5911404733839, -693.996480111531, -305.896321882284, -64.5813112021803, -413.60392660746913, -255.7030210460792, -59.57213287988006, -401.82145259249177, -269.6605446993674, -371.5525186029162, -215.28184806562433, -442.1780396195468, -643.9267716633235], + "butteraugli": [22.851523806420165, 26.879907283227357, 45.10513493579665, 28.78128444313592, 25.96855119780231, 22.159505056114096, 40.43808916620087, 13.19353873614844, 20.16709813606148, 44.24492417281962, 22.965568081605994, 31.301108675787997, 21.77196712762623, 21.828244556669507, 37.12533356863201, 27.036370625079666, 31.789028577102425, 46.20104131731737, 48.35163317899563, 25.717534259059846, 38.992880782446484, 15.923313551394727, 22.377740904859426, 26.57032661384763, 9.962120405040919, 44.70027977827487, 37.85934183055715, 39.367034291667004, 31.43094375179278, 36.340516449779265, 34.523146169452616], + "dssim": [0.3043231820678297, 0.3051976816952501, 0.4643874030709745, 0.1643329458214497, 0.33432636476992705, 0.23741474335933493, 0.21967751924995765, 0.08454992952003643, 0.40709473460725787, 0.24863087667670825, 0.3934997287697929, 0.24937057412299796, 0.15106305992370284, 0.25913004078772195, 0.36552581930392947, 0.20241668311942784, 0.2293664279441155, 0.14517173445005022, 0.32851187407520677, 0.36848608733240007, 0.2225663814813637, 0.1499569050540897, 0.2854147569703115, 0.238550326700245, 0.10347937588623174, 0.28122560167067345, 0.2246870932923693, 0.30147581946859836, 0.2197299780038735, 0.32531343893353515, 0.3571796604851384] + } + }, + { + "label": "B mu_l=6", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 mu_l=6", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.046873856154801, 8.958157029842438, 26.147395445114004, 10.570046684572132, 13.29742562291169, 9.839976239478746, 14.267543071312355, 3.564901538724501, 10.973234122820681, 12.047837336001118, 10.508471868556544, 10.437303698358296, 4.134177247907161, 11.783093723327289, 18.816631292193403, 10.798531002517988, 12.170807249257992, 9.996652901699994, 18.344580495676844, 14.159755154959727, 11.983348835647458, 4.39612947162677, 12.937538346962912, 13.076073893848438, 2.324169860127141, 13.558254274169503, 12.857510749509697, 12.302808149764482, 8.526951623285902, 10.992207548083464, 14.835199273838631], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.08190846036456, -245.47270340974677, -1230.5778010729048, -182.39131568328816, -314.6779492098767, -241.4482526565439, -449.39393856895185, -63.32070817180406, -323.22233202901026, -341.05888002473034, -253.02605748623682, -179.39965687814828, -64.07674586632768, -281.9591315449205, -828.5355925350781, -245.19681837275436, -280.3783183157703, -126.27735398253404, -645.1770546784426, -694.4209639779319, -310.31018244779233, -64.66848377120658, -413.93295406678726, -256.01165483521413, -60.07354176268876, -399.45878199379626, -268.40218739722945, -372.08888187396036, -216.13656870046378, -442.22729050329247, -640.0305297831126], + "butteraugli": [22.084026496543498, 27.20859200942046, 45.09055917475215, 28.526261791766363, 25.487237436629215, 22.09321530219482, 39.80581360435042, 13.048773239423795, 20.40544708488565, 43.97863604126172, 21.665634658795714, 33.1695557486727, 21.282561882899422, 22.579482080443398, 36.62931925123499, 27.005027880196867, 32.458116203534374, 45.501860154554116, 48.301723101458144, 25.746366674183957, 39.431127650702024, 15.728279795177215, 22.199365090505598, 26.591163685504167, 10.614828784953103, 44.8285905853778, 38.08817414553001, 38.64681792310256, 32.41638163398458, 37.905243155423754, 35.124465072613624], + "dssim": [0.3042600144907882, 0.30479185908243134, 0.4643691678963733, 0.16308276735382116, 0.33450010831833893, 0.2378076061946326, 0.21969812657134596, 0.08458439417963742, 0.4067654534078092, 0.2500164267265975, 0.3935899028461026, 0.25052994435443365, 0.15114174135965852, 0.2581893005431287, 0.36565876164764444, 0.20093054065496058, 0.2287954236605929, 0.14910240965300542, 0.3300771529974623, 0.3684394923614468, 0.22331348648529425, 0.14948905854012784, 0.2868532090678818, 0.23856494577813936, 0.1018091484191726, 0.28098809351949516, 0.22447590170785853, 0.3038331902431911, 0.21943137197862045, 0.32598520410066034, 0.35708063323623584] + } + }, + { + "label": "B mu_c=12", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 mu_c=12", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.082911776088182, 8.996802373274656, 26.14526876581372, 10.515320434476408, 13.284950487840211, 9.870362877405935, 14.212770269281707, 3.5738823466087872, 11.059960105639565, 12.053086285766826, 10.482724185549957, 10.519101216434361, 4.057864925858584, 11.839859883572627, 18.69181023055866, 10.809487514371844, 12.237062620229409, 9.850239361749983, 18.284412941528053, 14.163667270904874, 12.101271963933174, 4.461748657913165, 13.051790757550888, 13.064331960557174, 2.3308074798595335, 13.533332266463093, 12.809121798455594, 12.305127110806886, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.921703140031912], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.7950234337339, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7977182671118, -183.21956751330754, -317.16975547914944, -239.65130523431634, -449.6353587549338, -63.32088304039496, -332.7903685019995, -342.4874729852918, -252.23807247202456, -185.23552053938283, -64.05466049012944, -281.0578202289498, -828.4598885047544, -247.26224707849298, -280.35563675440847, -120.33933048701073, -644.326486217348, -694.9112945376187, -307.1262853369603, -64.70166054701048, -415.72850927061995, -257.78460229089114, -59.49416236203649, -396.23129470847454, -274.10128230510844, -371.9705386365427, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -645.1548418536486], + "butteraugli": [23.127671052412737, 27.02560129647775, 45.10378731519821, 28.384030527387498, 25.974029452625047, 22.13212330042477, 40.33625975894259, 13.170495301045245, 20.277412323402388, 44.21650040842625, 21.60056447554693, 32.445938255993504, 21.87042771330007, 22.199936320653034, 36.8759602887851, 27.06232129152188, 31.80204447988822, 46.453032114986826, 47.96295937509916, 25.753608408353042, 38.70797018140643, 15.718343358755154, 22.25786560026673, 27.250808537466074, 9.703071240748903, 45.234560527842824, 38.06388851245243, 37.58934668782563, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.12989010063942], + "dssim": [0.30431586186674064, 0.3048715622436494, 0.4643810453904484, 0.1616229989505773, 0.3343713700984131, 0.24093784083668307, 0.21992500466372294, 0.08450398866616782, 0.40697665305280767, 0.2509602429756208, 0.3936262357298771, 0.24923131984437125, 0.15099439123966052, 0.25840073128010344, 0.365535676559761, 0.20124420563188178, 0.22905917063515174, 0.14614071076519924, 0.32880503685677354, 0.36846085000593587, 0.22409497852535615, 0.1489575517479489, 0.2877688544192287, 0.23842249184250897, 0.10323885581185643, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22548868718532383, 0.30488592725301167, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35975180730914635] + } + }, + { + "label": "A aniso=1.2", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.700153115888159, 8.912595931750543, 26.12637937856586, 10.201045387696633, 13.73080779981809, 9.968457688979807, 14.147024931727477, 3.6054718990411727, 10.790437498800674, 11.445522045260418, 10.320533293396391, 10.36815346429736, 4.121941848536388, 11.60476367593855, 18.893210236426658, 10.555731957523411, 11.851489883496516, 10.211080956862661, 18.465267028309025, 14.179502347211773, 11.690812896485468, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.778973288317692, 2.351383154351986, 13.11953641581423, 13.16577096162637, 12.62432066438981, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.075649359888144], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.83776361247902, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6227877492252, -132.61464326345487, -319.369285887243, -215.15693170653594, -423.1331821366882, -62.96597055893267, -300.518292282055, -294.32721126125216, -244.86742937580027, -166.0519134467831, -63.981169388638875, -261.4704960734822, -820.8659974859756, -227.11353530376425, -244.80300052097436, -110.90917751779642, -593.9956716068152, -677.1551497509682, -274.4196752938118, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -241.12082463180616, -60.04107288806151, -349.11667130136925, -267.04295258809344, -367.32381405845905, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.9535321700258], + "butteraugli": [21.149976468695613, 25.989735467241832, 45.07985143311412, 26.387225690812887, 25.432174540381208, 21.49033616985284, 38.37897826746991, 13.188321785052546, 19.36460318984157, 36.659238743943654, 20.31371468600456, 27.796673243854325, 20.80758971269439, 21.89071352544754, 36.942437783618395, 26.74170665415075, 30.61739277370246, 45.12078185495064, 45.555821198951776, 25.647687239483286, 36.573357394503226, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 26.012735683731535, 10.42219463510112, 40.49235609902217, 37.62590765415828, 34.551997895041204, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.43343099123112], + "dssim": [0.3042885741415553, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643909211403664, 0.15946634301327278, 0.3347675736865815, 0.23594307907022755, 0.22066619605328225, 0.08440320072254731, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26165594754308796, 0.3939415860957996, 0.2500487961173269, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577282676551266, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20136652214569378, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1469262129751927, 0.33151934625458845, 0.36874801102994126, 0.22388648658521398, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23797656468577033, 0.0994303234645646, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565696878096558, 0.3056313746384203, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35492799100061434] + } + }, + { + "label": "A scale_fit=1", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 scale_fit=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.7790030827329115, 8.985842351651568, 26.122478396930404, 10.201045387696633, 13.73123472527398, 10.012986623966158, 14.196796006882918, 3.585312124004284, 10.716909549515737, 11.445522045260418, 10.41422932477915, 10.463653396737245, 4.121941848536388, 11.785889893833724, 18.893210236426658, 10.609590818275567, 11.851489883496516, 10.098300310664087, 18.568898835372455, 14.179502347211773, 11.61141137841939, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.673599558659106, 2.346662214961113, 13.11953641581423, 13.232251786972068, 12.476686181882394, 8.049313318370055, 10.080284102706466, 15.193345720455739], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.03629478101666, -248.6161385509161, -1229.2497873143577, -132.61464326345487, -318.81564965783764, -215.33431890445075, -423.74023707959316, -62.89877701479867, -304.36450761338835, -294.32721126125216, -244.52350488121277, -165.91014080701132, -63.981169388638875, -261.7874340652254, -820.8659974859756, -227.4774803978687, -244.80300052097436, -108.19250955032066, -595.1397061028462, -677.1551497509682, -276.7181706358973, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -239.59688068344997, -59.627228865557214, -349.11667130136925, -266.2912520172863, -368.4613165171662, -196.45958652312595, -376.84380877404124, -614.7546279271303], + "butteraugli": [21.286123842415606, 26.101925926442117, 45.07789108233046, 26.387225690812887, 25.42038562624684, 21.504851181040333, 38.398628827932946, 13.234017918522783, 19.559463405289534, 36.659238743943654, 20.35360620825853, 27.748647899706025, 20.80758971269439, 21.878402108565712, 36.942437783618395, 26.740861419178398, 30.61739277370246, 43.218792402739844, 45.62478373232154, 25.647687239483286, 37.73010001838505, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 25.629014721364637, 10.387882011222986, 40.49235609902217, 37.640744685504835, 34.62191286253461, 30.779757476705853, 34.59246815061315, 34.3567507013771], + "dssim": [0.30428386185586986, 0.30524176176959406, 0.4643705297695873, 0.15946634301327278, 0.334756908711458, 0.23505773848287415, 0.22070437509492952, 0.08429531055779727, 0.40653863271653873, 0.26165594754308796, 0.39395473657090824, 0.25010804926826036, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577326688600309, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20134045775593346, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1473596087823234, 0.33257263400228565, 0.36874801102994126, 0.2224184737281823, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23790378013355462, 0.10009180420300812, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22593906436204048, 0.305802309566945, 0.21798984386665965, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35524687755553996] + } + }, + { + "label": "A scale_fit=2 nearest", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.700153115888159, 8.912595931750543, 26.12637937856586, 10.201045387696633, 13.73080779981809, 9.968457688979807, 14.147024931727477, 3.6054718990411727, 10.790437498800674, 11.445522045260418, 10.320533293396391, 10.36815346429736, 4.121941848536388, 11.60476367593855, 18.893210236426658, 10.555731957523411, 11.851489883496516, 10.211080956862661, 18.465267028309025, 14.179502347211773, 11.690812896485468, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.778973288317692, 2.351383154351986, 13.11953641581423, 13.16577096162637, 12.62432066438981, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.075649359888144], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.83776361247902, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6227877492252, -132.61464326345487, -319.369285887243, -215.15693170653594, -423.1331821366882, -62.96597055893267, -300.518292282055, -294.32721126125216, -244.86742937580027, -166.0519134467831, -63.981169388638875, -261.4704960734822, -820.8659974859756, -227.11353530376425, -244.80300052097436, -110.90917751779642, -593.9956716068152, -677.1551497509682, -274.4196752938118, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -241.12082463180616, -60.04107288806151, -349.11667130136925, -267.04295258809344, -367.32381405845905, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.9535321700258], + "butteraugli": [21.149976468695613, 25.989735467241832, 45.07985143311412, 26.387225690812887, 25.432174540381208, 21.49033616985284, 38.37897826746991, 13.188321785052546, 19.36460318984157, 36.659238743943654, 20.31371468600456, 27.796673243854325, 20.80758971269439, 21.89071352544754, 36.942437783618395, 26.74170665415075, 30.61739277370246, 45.12078185495064, 45.555821198951776, 25.647687239483286, 36.573357394503226, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 26.012735683731535, 10.42219463510112, 40.49235609902217, 37.62590765415828, 34.551997895041204, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.43343099123112], + "dssim": [0.3042885741415553, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643909211403664, 0.15946634301327278, 0.3347675736865815, 0.23594307907022755, 0.22066619605328225, 0.08440320072254731, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26165594754308796, 0.3939415860957996, 0.2500487961173269, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577282676551266, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20136652214569378, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1469262129751927, 0.33151934625458845, 0.36874801102994126, 0.22388648658521398, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23797656468577033, 0.0994303234645646, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565696878096558, 0.3056313746384203, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35492799100061434] + } + }, + { + "label": "A aniso+fit2+nearest", + "tune": "l1=38:4 c=8:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.700153115888159, 8.912595931750543, 26.12637937856586, 10.201045387696633, 13.73080779981809, 9.968457688979807, 14.147024931727477, 3.6054718990411727, 10.790437498800674, 11.445522045260418, 10.320533293396391, 10.36815346429736, 4.121941848536388, 11.60476367593855, 18.893210236426658, 10.555731957523411, 11.851489883496516, 10.211080956862661, 18.465267028309025, 14.179502347211773, 11.690812896485468, 4.175829363697087, 13.404089557776413, 12.778973288317692, 2.351383154351986, 13.11953641581423, 13.16577096162637, 12.62432066438981, 7.967180849538435, 10.080284102706466, 15.075649359888144], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.83776361247902, -251.14169641317483, -1229.6227877492252, -132.61464326345487, -319.369285887243, -215.15693170653594, -423.1331821366882, -62.96597055893267, -300.518292282055, -294.32721126125216, -244.86742937580027, -166.0519134467831, -63.981169388638875, -261.4704960734822, -820.8659974859756, -227.11353530376425, -244.80300052097436, -110.90917751779642, -593.9956716068152, -677.1551497509682, -274.4196752938118, -64.38251876431201, -423.61116720830034, -241.12082463180616, -60.04107288806151, -349.11667130136925, -267.04295258809344, -367.32381405845905, -188.11789102185014, -376.84380877404124, -610.9535321700258], + "butteraugli": [21.149976468695613, 25.989735467241832, 45.07985143311412, 26.387225690812887, 25.432174540381208, 21.49033616985284, 38.37897826746991, 13.188321785052546, 19.36460318984157, 36.659238743943654, 20.31371468600456, 27.796673243854325, 20.80758971269439, 21.89071352544754, 36.942437783618395, 26.74170665415075, 30.61739277370246, 45.12078185495064, 45.555821198951776, 25.647687239483286, 36.573357394503226, 15.22997463316814, 22.372656072166663, 26.012735683731535, 10.42219463510112, 40.49235609902217, 37.62590765415828, 34.551997895041204, 36.886194409964396, 34.59246815061315, 34.43343099123112], + "dssim": [0.3042885741415553, 0.3049419877174867, 0.4643909211403664, 0.15946634301327278, 0.3347675736865815, 0.23594307907022755, 0.22066619605328225, 0.08440320072254731, 0.40638266861679534, 0.26165594754308796, 0.3939415860957996, 0.2500487961173269, 0.15150369317307372, 0.2577282676551266, 0.36552450754845056, 0.20136652214569378, 0.22738278289684927, 0.1469262129751927, 0.33151934625458845, 0.36874801102994126, 0.22388648658521398, 0.14979375446854853, 0.29261040953059037, 0.23797656468577033, 0.0994303234645646, 0.2773833741570476, 0.22565696878096558, 0.3056313746384203, 0.21705782431500192, 0.3177574918858419, 0.35492799100061434] + } + }, + { + "label": "B aniso+fit2+nearest", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "SHIPPED aniso+fit2+near", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 scale_fit=2 ac_nearest=1", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/scalefactor-bands.json b/tools/comparison/results/scalefactor-bands.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1014578 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/scalefactor-bands.json @@ -0,0 +1,253 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "scalefactor-bands", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "MP3/AAC-style scalefactor bands: coefficients past floor(count·split) quantize against scale·gain. gain<1 = finer high band (clamps outliers), gain>1 = coarser high band (protects the low band).", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/scalefactor-bands.json", + "configSha256": "80ff936a89ab400f1e7f32afcbaddd2eb22b33262cc70148d7d1a8e39781c5a4", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "default (single scale)", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "gain_l=0.7", + "tune": "band_gain_l=0.7", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.064167338598006, 8.98831951759769, 26.14495981287226, 10.53974252582699, 13.262514060950062, 9.828885132555351, 14.243546588189332, 3.523606141046473, 10.98992062145335, 12.029350285120232, 10.470459523226081, 10.412181089491295, 4.116911799784093, 11.839176900695717, 18.784235899597945, 10.788564037582713, 12.214202946708694, 9.866003186342276, 18.351793298232746, 14.162567992401165, 12.044258640830476, 4.394046486608043, 12.898466535504115, 13.024988573566162, 2.329399705665359, 13.491461313580396, 12.93851825466526, 12.295719585261459, 8.447151606322285, 10.94778264536503, 14.840736234270025], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.22769557918065, -249.93054445232735, -1230.8219818681464, -183.04486006741155, -321.30689770725826, -240.1101563033784, -452.0045309533026, -63.35457488159392, -336.18510007834266, -339.0638982222231, -248.02840926044826, -179.95461090728435, -64.05891136790981, -277.40421819785513, -828.7218404117202, -240.13728398290175, -278.6035182747595, -113.72034906528461, -639.3140678674354, -693.6844561965461, -304.0280212138898, -64.57728941328926, -408.79402093204953, -256.1422859471699, -59.07881523746252, -395.72515209744324, -276.30561767204983, -375.3006092307515, -219.4252520780584, -434.8485427580978, -643.313108786224], + "butteraugli": [22.95534699785135, 26.895996642957396, 45.09946873610815, 28.66103702149842, 25.666625283703127, 22.169812774301832, 40.147874086618486, 13.078166885781746, 20.497542538794157, 44.09862167296973, 22.000836866688186, 31.288154591291505, 21.394868118208425, 22.01362270598211, 37.02424420322239, 27.140071099065352, 32.22744094305052, 45.6452232054649, 48.156478074856544, 25.737343545345755, 38.93575923846469, 15.826323879747497, 22.202830744033957, 26.822464242622107, 8.97741806467525, 44.759035172539335, 37.70331598981582, 38.067326217901076, 32.18509314005874, 36.47409846137575, 34.93031164036297], + "dssim": [0.3043281025918855, 0.30481906397001524, 0.4644124947723261, 0.16416322459805305, 0.3344647834810643, 0.24096431794222062, 0.22049981869218893, 0.08455941246784376, 0.407156621992182, 0.2496191761059145, 0.3935869776145861, 0.24830294574128114, 0.1512012263426265, 0.25814270427878827, 0.36565181779759726, 0.20181527257801096, 0.22966176898111135, 0.14458593744554027, 0.32846525682034544, 0.3684563160011629, 0.2231055736767244, 0.1490335274757773, 0.2858535401826029, 0.23840209982059318, 0.10092139709543013, 0.2810903438282468, 0.2257927956598469, 0.3030957011834131, 0.21971084868366392, 0.3272187903025653, 0.3578596424720024] + } + }, + { + "label": "gain_l=1.4", + "tune": "band_gain_l=1.4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.079531992540773, 9.065466111700756, 26.14453076781149, 10.607157411129705, 13.343209612102006, 9.824740881658228, 14.316664079838567, 3.557797098308707, 11.02377557044241, 12.093197027339246, 10.488315616159872, 10.386440308271345, 4.141404967951745, 11.73684755974674, 18.788143586088065, 10.896252274263322, 12.200447253007473, 9.852433736733852, 18.3191065597231, 14.166594435229001, 12.105306801149244, 4.4721533880426865, 12.998592173645571, 13.093229456856589, 2.3346275499975135, 13.601409696038438, 12.930137757521242, 12.316887205392108, 8.561123014034123, 11.030685982569864, 14.885027828469282], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.52217095443035, -253.9736153536661, -1230.4869703692516, -186.77454638567576, -324.7504684978651, -242.30122524598505, -452.2219249154365, -63.18871400147245, -332.20940139802445, -343.6012631403985, -247.19540865892554, -179.2999397689764, -64.0981055968337, -281.0910109743739, -829.2344358144057, -246.20551988268488, -272.42449877738875, -116.47073848984886, -647.878744738738, -694.004887317891, -309.80579707909385, -64.66402361144446, -414.1055650773642, -256.13881265116754, -59.299938223996975, -399.86488979184827, -274.3151934304582, -375.49907089320743, -225.73564775607798, -441.1698961374402, -644.6853012802343], + "butteraugli": [22.119069439769103, 26.96576454282415, 45.1011818344142, 28.808862322801193, 25.452040909124253, 22.408299170859294, 39.782970114771445, 13.373253763460497, 20.283558111580735, 43.759847028872194, 22.05694704728565, 30.103253406949012, 21.29639134727921, 22.462991832116057, 36.90704319504088, 27.344405216406688, 32.48833247352802, 45.6986114193957, 48.10270788275915, 25.761147877760653, 38.55499813840027, 16.033436834301853, 22.20167935968955, 26.519698876205524, 9.158166614841237, 45.67067783654128, 37.77828927607614, 38.086936028968246, 31.796391132187328, 37.47710268487536, 34.21210374512225], + "dssim": [0.3042672310272274, 0.30527126954223305, 0.4643859029257081, 0.1637067280440161, 0.33471587077590736, 0.23988593963929378, 0.2202403210481111, 0.0846310886252008, 0.40701563085673653, 0.2538312134911288, 0.3937002066843441, 0.25194493549780894, 0.15121032118823247, 0.2590416226928304, 0.36554760789226337, 0.2021037920557806, 0.22860977293740675, 0.14539127858918915, 0.32867757284222243, 0.3685380526103954, 0.2235880560904397, 0.14974110464796353, 0.28814677827238766, 0.2385954072050544, 0.10274995602863807, 0.28136277012198285, 0.22622309324781514, 0.30440786102465645, 0.21991653836560665, 0.3282508271231913, 0.35808714632538574] + } + }, + { + "label": "gain_c=0.7", + "tune": "band_gain_c=0.7", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.009076547943718, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.55686905020713, 13.303657890625741, 9.886955846422763, 14.198494068481507, 3.533612614986161, 11.059960105639565, 12.132902267611469, 10.508984092703889, 10.560279661889158, 4.035166736817209, 11.953032344514924, 18.845326253886693, 10.793823632384466, 12.205608207893388, 10.173769078880245, 18.248654512549553, 14.162233605706396, 12.047758134612184, 4.448964448273065, 12.982795834456647, 13.020858452012583, 2.3098351148401473, 13.533332266463093, 12.90673230457998, 12.49332821558161, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.66954303963756], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.27827099552198, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.4048227592445, -315.7533975011873, -240.29635455322784, -449.61773074630753, -63.31843635550129, -332.7903685019995, -340.8167081792943, -252.236968718872, -184.9763397755528, -64.05485185821735, -280.89500515012287, -827.6317835410408, -247.12163570976588, -280.81043765962596, -119.66750430991078, -644.6666898482998, -695.1795984726037, -307.3202782595199, -64.69850946461133, -417.90485236521545, -256.86325851819396, -59.52616195513184, -396.23129470847454, -273.11162218165776, -374.5796134342738, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -646.7327566369811], + "butteraugli": [23.050171870067484, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.323913546904503, 25.91362813710461, 22.101980091952964, 40.37852689192755, 13.191710271975296, 20.277412323402388, 44.135479623872875, 21.59654552622311, 32.4778414897556, 21.82298160021881, 22.20024143577109, 36.83890685652671, 27.106205464592268, 31.745510791021406, 46.28141369187026, 48.06559704924257, 25.75366638047663, 38.731565645982805, 15.72431775864237, 22.322901226776835, 27.179276857528787, 9.711731990372536, 45.234560527842824, 37.92286529465343, 37.48348746104721, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.00295039474864], + "dssim": [0.3042642223295674, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16409372097079022, 0.33439212795269746, 0.23955702352965824, 0.21999857522223215, 0.08452548814808375, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24943259869989376, 0.3936161222511781, 0.2460940373491326, 0.15098368756499597, 0.2585847476023535, 0.3655065073319692, 0.20122764416005484, 0.22903502517104163, 0.14567590192922614, 0.3291971406615338, 0.3684708928617454, 0.22399543593443, 0.14933516698923288, 0.288141113506467, 0.23860638081505597, 0.10306123445190213, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22462337266231064, 0.3045466046498315, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.3593036816084151] + } + }, + { + "label": "gain_c=1.4", + "tune": "band_gain_c=1.4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.975242470503102, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.605346063304522, 13.257526751831763, 9.973888976539724, 14.23343329972095, 3.556321142289211, 11.059960105639565, 12.05509090129035, 10.498608147090065, 10.4983078187507, 4.0519209808527, 11.806685339927862, 18.80020153044782, 10.809115668868134, 12.260869408486755, 10.20919876806772, 18.278783411437672, 14.1619889008283, 12.065803157810095, 4.42150858661733, 13.064265381995545, 13.198156035898773, 2.3331796179372564, 13.533332266463093, 12.79351408196176, 12.595227965521595, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 15.042325794358307], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.71546121304752, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.34730946118054, -315.64001108904193, -239.7706449742783, -448.73969885810584, -63.300966411142895, -332.7903685019995, -341.06411775079556, -252.42663884144054, -185.3083642183529, -64.0547421257337, -281.7328234371605, -828.5224688375807, -247.86868930696323, -281.44697943745024, -119.81062238315923, -647.1015299743397, -694.7018437718225, -307.44216416415037, -64.71365454473198, -420.52113493935394, -257.87026487894445, -59.4930233493032, -396.23129470847454, -274.2123219733063, -374.71201606088727, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4108204057942], + "butteraugli": [23.119041526739153, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.31370300921739, 25.937832680497035, 22.1343497655201, 40.398402905697466, 13.181523283975778, 20.277412323402388, 44.15860606775641, 21.597420214921623, 32.42598583536849, 21.85389690601461, 22.22013171213609, 36.85610040466329, 27.106145903202584, 31.75707169567127, 46.33629712767249, 48.08382060755318, 25.768581974717964, 38.74808280901045, 15.715129419882075, 22.31288762112183, 27.24036733341732, 9.681857590022064, 45.234560527842824, 37.99786634342928, 37.58322006134706, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.15228110850464], + "dssim": [0.30428634407610955, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16462926460878796, 0.3344572093188155, 0.24053234426168518, 0.21997204099773116, 0.08453453283690537, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24890133195550806, 0.3936343739156256, 0.24687858859703987, 0.15102943069464908, 0.25843548244918035, 0.3655058995932077, 0.2012326456362627, 0.22912727832219193, 0.1470306747721044, 0.32917663592724034, 0.36845536447710403, 0.2240418308846246, 0.1495878255234347, 0.28773400503662494, 0.23879497897896612, 0.10296627439775724, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22506248091883435, 0.30389245740228565, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.361246480689828] + } + }, + { + "label": "split=0.3 gain_l=0.7", + "tune": "band_split=0.3 band_gain_l=0.7", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.032187142579909, 8.93342815141822, 26.14565713883154, 10.552931631202453, 13.243945673272266, 9.850534073614963, 14.241611033076234, 3.5146203609909574, 11.024064943806737, 12.069955263789772, 10.46775712977937, 10.401956597596364, 4.128503950657685, 11.746870179115602, 18.8424937149115, 10.857556025580358, 12.22108618036957, 9.835126371312523, 18.31671524549033, 14.169209223943893, 11.996100491021629, 4.384629204137574, 12.89811052831409, 13.013243879398443, 2.335068324598312, 13.51982850871775, 12.925957124466938, 12.298883956212853, 8.431368662993753, 10.93116826638625, 14.850022233471796], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.44696658306273, -244.84261828554315, -1230.5526224439768, -183.38131236555137, -320.21317012567386, -240.88651510179255, -449.2992945117302, -63.20622789956957, -339.6913942806578, -344.6385363434569, -247.47143724638426, -181.0150867296466, -64.05307148893357, -281.6306383674088, -829.1025908733139, -242.20180023553235, -279.8725351964897, -113.35046666111162, -634.7112383498915, -694.1635454702455, -308.4324336352722, -64.57328087098199, -409.1754940296238, -255.87297907654028, -59.21558749055882, -398.09802583189855, -275.5892000937399, -371.2019177160212, -219.9726413877874, -434.09701540109506, -643.1304875872293], + "butteraugli": [22.57427401287639, 27.278288191079213, 45.10157874494896, 28.550332018313284, 25.834997058401452, 22.081458403059596, 39.93990168527707, 13.174598023408757, 20.40183920267599, 43.55467720183674, 22.33161134401566, 30.614701027382903, 21.3092367606281, 22.543487173118596, 36.85317869448511, 27.126139737835544, 31.941207737564792, 45.56062482781791, 48.5043935720032, 25.703914651495648, 39.37993135767071, 15.76396588231571, 22.15256801286775, 26.896280305849103, 8.96807319426154, 44.50043225604867, 37.607712257577354, 38.37164525466708, 32.22473372700521, 36.45134724473943, 35.03745537436237], + "dssim": [0.30428151897083366, 0.3045811742728052, 0.46441082164380587, 0.16419236696492923, 0.3345190735027531, 0.2396263506853502, 0.22001962523167412, 0.08442774222387345, 0.4072730208455201, 0.254082418910871, 0.3935420411380337, 0.2481304684232632, 0.1512465737993876, 0.2587853394726669, 0.36582383149056885, 0.20241071148850914, 0.22993641562474093, 0.14251797531389165, 0.32828254695294445, 0.3684748118211236, 0.22300677132614305, 0.14942343035493794, 0.28600202937869657, 0.23849555776761494, 0.10021347469249386, 0.2809626165619402, 0.22560996923690363, 0.3045693604294125, 0.21964946217562792, 0.3267028265309526, 0.35783730863531926] + } + }, + { + "label": "split=0.7 gain_l=0.7", + "tune": "band_split=0.7 band_gain_l=0.7", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.050817588521945, 9.02253240360822, 26.143968454905288, 10.55273417177662, 13.273588950325758, 9.854287626920865, 14.258684662102688, 3.5238201666968902, 10.983239180309715, 12.028671701498363, 10.468094353207873, 10.422297547987082, 4.131682337701872, 11.827635730509696, 18.809108554040673, 10.824121061496891, 12.192999216475881, 9.864692472554953, 18.368761370803586, 14.162329311894583, 12.071914824839583, 4.416781656086433, 12.91171521822021, 12.987422441137042, 2.3073424017870225, 13.612448771384907, 12.925736388096642, 12.28718897946401, 8.451834897956454, 10.953532013289276, 14.884185540774821], + "ssimulacra2": [-136.93872505154206, -250.64909193571026, -1230.3191700302664, -184.60837947968957, -319.98733533351844, -240.38874422326984, -451.35709681526555, -63.25302135024654, -333.1321038958715, -338.6510087466356, -248.87926732044104, -177.10808029977966, -64.05741913183971, -280.89906335681684, -830.1306851095056, -244.30399928438862, -277.9617303489735, -113.45182332595303, -638.5039384317665, -694.1667680188563, -307.6108944762853, -64.63851504054941, -410.30229197651863, -254.93462697658748, -59.62061250422033, -404.96496820025334, -271.4669691513279, -373.7390683196942, -213.2478087675974, -436.4531014180643, -645.8683609032719], + "butteraugli": [22.948608224790927, 27.170547111316257, 45.09345656582431, 28.698772331911414, 25.803601084590326, 22.063943342090855, 39.99811029735977, 13.199673857096, 20.332343190484178, 44.159934482899594, 21.747312951138863, 32.90257241115911, 21.273409622689126, 22.292721228136582, 36.85800631798984, 27.04013939977621, 32.205814387565574, 45.2927660071432, 48.20577170548696, 25.751187770749507, 38.77509863860507, 15.777184440171178, 22.122247532173798, 26.755856503931994, 9.903815503397654, 44.48496688036048, 37.57645413832676, 37.718402328274436, 31.91247175866414, 37.29462438465442, 35.010257937734146], + "dssim": [0.3043107305860461, 0.30496569454795996, 0.4643576064718541, 0.16440636199774455, 0.33442893051742745, 0.24116370337137005, 0.22043692257203729, 0.08445717125055224, 0.4070389842948434, 0.2485727619191716, 0.39368003081310227, 0.24959183008837665, 0.15116098019597762, 0.2581281879809537, 0.3656795485681099, 0.20181122938573753, 0.22946021513505638, 0.1459652500627458, 0.32837170123082193, 0.36843258702094084, 0.22374139794753917, 0.14980164833595372, 0.28628599685871836, 0.2382096432826028, 0.1032715357105305, 0.28103738067756256, 0.22465906885833237, 0.30318979728989337, 0.21977969919440993, 0.3278507175999765, 0.3576249400490322] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/selection-hv.json b/tools/comparison/results/selection-hv.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..132691d --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/selection-hv.json @@ -0,0 +1,357 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "selection-hv", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "U7 materialized: the corpus-trained selection order, as a 2-parameter family. The shipped order sorts by isotropic frequency; aniso adds the CSF oblique-effect penalty on diagonals; sel_hv adds a horizontal/vertical asymmetry (positive pushes horizontal frequencies down the order). coeff-stats put the headroom of a fully trained fixed order at +2.2 energy points over the l2-ball, so this asks how much of that a smooth 2-parameter family captures.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/selection-hv.json", + "configSha256": "7ae842cebb5510e8ab5d35a58ffa94f2048e1763789ff7bf537587225fbc8b69", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "aniso=0 hv=0 (shipped)", + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.2 hv=0", + "tune": "aniso=1.2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=0 hv=+0.15", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=0 hv=-0.15", + "tune": "sel_hv=-0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.945663678954487, 9.237581979517223, 26.135042465025375, 10.356588444062337, 13.249888807401703, 9.808228628586454, 14.126702701020783, 3.633640559060892, 11.329682081592983, 11.678743052532056, 10.467965737417073, 10.319191327195304, 4.179095999352763, 11.65127432653496, 18.721767329310733, 10.958455225539922, 12.08801340763209, 10.065218774009786, 18.43864748577153, 14.180045141771876, 11.993113027328164, 4.79148495337539, 12.746885074798858, 12.892528818267262, 2.3227631019831154, 13.525401689162571, 13.137794953778085, 12.213564416055789, 9.084969202269935, 10.405443983388311, 14.87272907412174], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.3570729966167, -264.1136126908541, -1230.5943971248962, -170.78868105904985, -316.53730872747417, -233.0063472983091, -438.6484885498687, -63.82464794107449, -380.6952799487769, -315.8218595365779, -255.31970922516933, -167.26747406243567, -64.11862159831338, -280.33142115035895, -827.8122251655957, -267.25134809799283, -283.2351980703736, -121.92789200403229, -654.0114197689735, -694.4119222804309, -301.1574290257149, -65.97295876887057, -410.54909535141974, -257.5848294397028, -59.58038993194074, -398.7717398525608, -286.78110908948827, -373.70056636077027, -228.07654923052337, -409.9273383871031, -641.8619771370641], + "butteraugli": [22.95721842749172, 26.47800181335813, 45.09894041141239, 27.822852617844305, 25.931383016605633, 21.752318842384454, 39.66365451340224, 13.344627798805751, 22.172234073164773, 38.34883927817409, 21.676005194918584, 30.904486311284035, 21.77335949068186, 23.245652688603514, 37.39411041753768, 29.143437766218018, 31.83455700860645, 46.418939307157295, 49.11363475374052, 25.709172262565392, 38.8465041922699, 16.321801066681168, 22.289572344506755, 27.109281449518495, 9.756576567127391, 44.35224664485316, 36.92702438687945, 37.77556503602715, 33.886876233185156, 34.33333643462472, 34.04211050672799], + "dssim": [0.30426689015855024, 0.3058383549798349, 0.46437948172275745, 0.16173357321381676, 0.3347332911390727, 0.24012206641472422, 0.21887011704272652, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40885434988006997, 0.26294631360406107, 0.39392432654481846, 0.2466764528010273, 0.15140988945096784, 0.25830310944803614, 0.36580578675573683, 0.19844585059533076, 0.22907008873426699, 0.15201911335566404, 0.3321834168825416, 0.3684314459676199, 0.22355605921837468, 0.14940994412071867, 0.2824838317389139, 0.23825222127185836, 0.10332512739852318, 0.28086094494735514, 0.22612978901257036, 0.302343815729315, 0.22301886481028405, 0.31837267035376227, 0.3578437075447657] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=0 hv=+0.30", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.292487038811993, 9.002153945224254, 26.152214872540352, 10.564375501085674, 13.31558759901147, 9.746283821867994, 14.238019863814527, 3.3861462652292293, 10.903735570622274, 11.956472702601188, 11.043413743331136, 9.996635065082883, 3.8176315172023036, 11.968746867493692, 18.701605123384486, 10.80811741173374, 12.197979300295481, 10.014985336859503, 18.391518353909692, 14.14585082172779, 12.03647402579225, 4.290735582245184, 13.135658557950947, 13.024967026835073, 2.2774318425730598, 13.999118862503442, 13.016175824932633, 12.694530786563897, 8.685260945167798, 11.235741543571685, 15.027566607273323], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.64286540902987, -249.97728273326635, -1232.2203742460235, -179.31604377074666, -322.13725517875304, -226.8836127498701, -445.44682698657755, -62.92952954636078, -324.682548854959, -343.9333966154285, -284.30782979631374, -174.21294701248286, -64.0235245272585, -289.02139895969674, -821.1420867014032, -247.4900078961963, -273.6415672911408, -112.56206850781814, -609.4398274391367, -694.4224698999983, -307.5668049262538, -64.50024108784095, -438.63827161633117, -259.61686700266534, -60.07401104195259, -409.5737101456013, -288.53380392151934, -393.4746910431841, -234.44172287970662, -460.8655874416029, -662.5803915616301], + "butteraugli": [22.638082345232466, 26.4998407409734, 45.119588869639095, 28.16501460057978, 25.658589209031884, 22.317181171590338, 40.00724863265925, 13.189059396246671, 19.971725249838652, 44.98215511071496, 23.222427628709408, 29.30836657835198, 21.6770050986417, 21.702442747042145, 38.022000397249236, 27.08457563622478, 31.345949815298326, 47.38632078173729, 46.83508295904676, 25.728399117878485, 38.272727086763076, 15.818095518640902, 22.639285494535475, 27.219911942059877, 10.413356257718158, 43.9011990146115, 38.90356979301468, 42.31781095642784, 32.17262828873833, 35.86488030404336, 33.256037132602074], + "dssim": [0.3042713332327095, 0.3049436393834868, 0.46440227212785934, 0.16342170271377204, 0.33445969968032074, 0.23469298637381902, 0.21957687835355927, 0.08437551351771705, 0.4067106243515058, 0.24652033869253914, 0.3943439101585547, 0.24777939604411497, 0.15095172939908058, 0.25873913842943175, 0.3656208945909366, 0.20123385172995306, 0.22882764092002145, 0.14406696655858836, 0.3280688263013877, 0.36832486691102373, 0.22396952307731932, 0.14922448939808913, 0.2903939113395255, 0.23847104447578277, 0.09920757812967484, 0.28077233286889036, 0.22892179706211002, 0.302430180360459, 0.220534831937511, 0.3265495788011531, 0.35783874781816216] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=0 hv=-0.30", + "tune": "sel_hv=-0.3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.34081495777459, 9.300581004430972, 26.14209384335239, 10.491779567417863, 13.304531932447249, 10.254911736081825, 14.396625079364048, 3.633640559060892, 11.298377111274412, 11.752710012486816, 10.43025397171475, 10.423092601591147, 4.094345035162431, 11.698835692311214, 18.820450173100166, 11.039177160482076, 12.014822302011526, 10.243081521628389, 18.341843152332277, 14.175463639734708, 12.248314938342332, 4.789926129633851, 12.86245641617543, 12.823431746970371, 2.3406629713865956, 13.744442862391756, 13.19302409252334, 12.094909382417237, 9.618198743776652, 10.395010869273978, 14.838715390959342], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.23058215492551, -268.3453438867918, -1230.5469079556112, -177.9293644851606, -316.62981081363193, -257.4326194593504, -449.9605045957735, -63.82464794107449, -377.51195481453345, -311.6551775788216, -251.92926178088817, -168.9291385344764, -64.06937406926158, -281.2732898165854, -831.9638823169394, -274.0491998903664, -279.2731900011071, -119.89212352083624, -646.2911089753684, -694.7497364665093, -313.8077514242294, -66.01724391594433, -417.83509908933456, -250.417075919568, -59.604981954440376, -422.3094526586043, -287.8984989839687, -348.8281774381743, -262.0222555655623, -406.0260499349743, -641.8089435564796], + "butteraugli": [24.72157794261412, 27.423817025772593, 45.1130203774216, 28.35026971653171, 25.932025357732115, 22.9249400240874, 40.19195487562038, 13.344627798805751, 22.551517053724904, 39.084432519132456, 21.632016049616222, 33.531568948153776, 22.279455092402277, 23.022576539975077, 36.8395482593371, 29.089290279362388, 31.907598443043316, 45.83568499173409, 49.021528427108024, 25.709442228856574, 38.851802627713624, 16.367524113754964, 22.059149903636115, 26.652140767524354, 9.761445014747101, 44.26663622155303, 37.17676881466229, 39.22510238614106, 38.19182830963032, 34.489165734956224, 34.43040200187125], + "dssim": [0.30435887099363, 0.3058093951933155, 0.46447097432761164, 0.16249925251099534, 0.3347357425818723, 0.24744215647594586, 0.22094137555686283, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40862896843878516, 0.2656413316573112, 0.3939830685571399, 0.2471110690256803, 0.15109189160945619, 0.2587547559234997, 0.3660623743071332, 0.19833727350155922, 0.22847978350138742, 0.15262950045459261, 0.33380799940075256, 0.3684707094963068, 0.22428704492502555, 0.14918984556626036, 0.2835033707959913, 0.2379140551778957, 0.10330429764737253, 0.28218163793448914, 0.22629836392438957, 0.3040896990491806, 0.2246122946754796, 0.31866039936721113, 0.3584768655608829] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.2 hv=+0.15", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.2 hv=-0.15", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=-0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.945663678954487, 9.237581979517223, 26.135042465025375, 10.356588444062337, 13.249888807401703, 9.808228628586454, 14.126702701020783, 3.633640559060892, 11.329682081592983, 11.678743052532056, 10.467965737417073, 10.319191327195304, 4.179095999352763, 11.65127432653496, 18.721767329310733, 10.958455225539922, 12.08801340763209, 10.065218774009786, 18.43864748577153, 14.180045141771876, 11.993113027328164, 4.79148495337539, 12.746885074798858, 12.892528818267262, 2.3227631019831154, 13.525401689162571, 13.137794953778085, 12.213564416055789, 9.084969202269935, 10.405443983388311, 14.87272907412174], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.3570729966167, -264.1136126908541, -1230.5943971248962, -170.78868105904985, -316.53730872747417, -233.0063472983091, -438.6484885498687, -63.82464794107449, -380.6952799487769, -315.8218595365779, -255.31970922516933, -167.26747406243567, -64.11862159831338, -280.33142115035895, -827.8122251655957, -267.25134809799283, -283.2351980703736, -121.92789200403229, -654.0114197689735, -694.4119222804309, -301.1574290257149, -65.97295876887057, -410.54909535141974, -257.5848294397028, -59.58038993194074, -398.7717398525608, -286.78110908948827, -373.70056636077027, -228.07654923052337, -409.9273383871031, -641.8619771370641], + "butteraugli": [22.95721842749172, 26.47800181335813, 45.09894041141239, 27.822852617844305, 25.931383016605633, 21.752318842384454, 39.66365451340224, 13.344627798805751, 22.172234073164773, 38.34883927817409, 21.676005194918584, 30.904486311284035, 21.77335949068186, 23.245652688603514, 37.39411041753768, 29.143437766218018, 31.83455700860645, 46.418939307157295, 49.11363475374052, 25.709172262565392, 38.8465041922699, 16.321801066681168, 22.289572344506755, 27.109281449518495, 9.756576567127391, 44.35224664485316, 36.92702438687945, 37.77556503602715, 33.886876233185156, 34.33333643462472, 34.04211050672799], + "dssim": [0.30426689015855024, 0.3058383549798349, 0.46437948172275745, 0.16173357321381676, 0.3347332911390727, 0.24012206641472422, 0.21887011704272652, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40885434988006997, 0.26294631360406107, 0.39392432654481846, 0.2466764528010273, 0.15140988945096784, 0.25830310944803614, 0.36580578675573683, 0.19844585059533076, 0.22907008873426699, 0.15201911335566404, 0.3321834168825416, 0.3684314459676199, 0.22355605921837468, 0.14940994412071867, 0.2824838317389139, 0.23825222127185836, 0.10332512739852318, 0.28086094494735514, 0.22612978901257036, 0.302343815729315, 0.22301886481028405, 0.31837267035376227, 0.3578437075447657] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.2 hv=+0.30", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.292487038811993, 9.002153945224254, 26.152214872540352, 10.564375501085674, 13.31558759901147, 9.746283821867994, 14.238019863814527, 3.3861462652292293, 10.903735570622274, 11.956472702601188, 11.043413743331136, 9.996635065082883, 3.8176315172023036, 11.968746867493692, 18.701605123384486, 10.80811741173374, 12.197979300295481, 10.014985336859503, 18.391518353909692, 14.14585082172779, 12.03647402579225, 4.290735582245184, 13.135658557950947, 13.024967026835073, 2.2774318425730598, 13.999118862503442, 13.016175824932633, 12.694530786563897, 8.685260945167798, 11.235741543571685, 15.027566607273323], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.64286540902987, -249.97728273326635, -1232.2203742460235, -179.31604377074666, -322.13725517875304, -226.8836127498701, -445.44682698657755, -62.92952954636078, -324.682548854959, -343.9333966154285, -284.30782979631374, -174.21294701248286, -64.0235245272585, -289.02139895969674, -821.1420867014032, -247.4900078961963, -273.6415672911408, -112.56206850781814, -609.4398274391367, -694.4224698999983, -307.5668049262538, -64.50024108784095, -438.63827161633117, -259.61686700266534, -60.07401104195259, -409.5737101456013, -288.53380392151934, -393.4746910431841, -234.44172287970662, -460.8655874416029, -662.5803915616301], + "butteraugli": [22.638082345232466, 26.4998407409734, 45.119588869639095, 28.16501460057978, 25.658589209031884, 22.317181171590338, 40.00724863265925, 13.189059396246671, 19.971725249838652, 44.98215511071496, 23.222427628709408, 29.30836657835198, 21.6770050986417, 21.702442747042145, 38.022000397249236, 27.08457563622478, 31.345949815298326, 47.38632078173729, 46.83508295904676, 25.728399117878485, 38.272727086763076, 15.818095518640902, 22.639285494535475, 27.219911942059877, 10.413356257718158, 43.9011990146115, 38.90356979301468, 42.31781095642784, 32.17262828873833, 35.86488030404336, 33.256037132602074], + "dssim": [0.3042713332327095, 0.3049436393834868, 0.46440227212785934, 0.16342170271377204, 0.33445969968032074, 0.23469298637381902, 0.21957687835355927, 0.08437551351771705, 0.4067106243515058, 0.24652033869253914, 0.3943439101585547, 0.24777939604411497, 0.15095172939908058, 0.25873913842943175, 0.3656208945909366, 0.20123385172995306, 0.22882764092002145, 0.14406696655858836, 0.3280688263013877, 0.36832486691102373, 0.22396952307731932, 0.14922448939808913, 0.2903939113395255, 0.23847104447578277, 0.09920757812967484, 0.28077233286889036, 0.22892179706211002, 0.302430180360459, 0.220534831937511, 0.3265495788011531, 0.35783874781816216] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.2 hv=-0.30", + "tune": "aniso=1.2 sel_hv=-0.3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.34081495777459, 9.300581004430972, 26.14209384335239, 10.491779567417863, 13.304531932447249, 10.254911736081825, 14.396625079364048, 3.633640559060892, 11.298377111274412, 11.752710012486816, 10.43025397171475, 10.423092601591147, 4.094345035162431, 11.698835692311214, 18.820450173100166, 11.039177160482076, 12.014822302011526, 10.243081521628389, 18.341843152332277, 14.175463639734708, 12.248314938342332, 4.789926129633851, 12.86245641617543, 12.823431746970371, 2.3406629713865956, 13.744442862391756, 13.19302409252334, 12.094909382417237, 9.618198743776652, 10.395010869273978, 14.838715390959342], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.23058215492551, -268.3453438867918, -1230.5469079556112, -177.9293644851606, -316.62981081363193, -257.4326194593504, -449.9605045957735, -63.82464794107449, -377.51195481453345, -311.6551775788216, -251.92926178088817, -168.9291385344764, -64.06937406926158, -281.2732898165854, -831.9638823169394, -274.0491998903664, -279.2731900011071, -119.89212352083624, -646.2911089753684, -694.7497364665093, -313.8077514242294, -66.01724391594433, -417.83509908933456, -250.417075919568, -59.604981954440376, -422.3094526586043, -287.8984989839687, -348.8281774381743, -262.0222555655623, -406.0260499349743, -641.8089435564796], + "butteraugli": [24.72157794261412, 27.423817025772593, 45.1130203774216, 28.35026971653171, 25.932025357732115, 22.9249400240874, 40.19195487562038, 13.344627798805751, 22.551517053724904, 39.084432519132456, 21.632016049616222, 33.531568948153776, 22.279455092402277, 23.022576539975077, 36.8395482593371, 29.089290279362388, 31.907598443043316, 45.83568499173409, 49.021528427108024, 25.709442228856574, 38.851802627713624, 16.367524113754964, 22.059149903636115, 26.652140767524354, 9.761445014747101, 44.26663622155303, 37.17676881466229, 39.22510238614106, 38.19182830963032, 34.489165734956224, 34.43040200187125], + "dssim": [0.30435887099363, 0.3058093951933155, 0.46447097432761164, 0.16249925251099534, 0.3347357425818723, 0.24744215647594586, 0.22094137555686283, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40862896843878516, 0.2656413316573112, 0.3939830685571399, 0.2471110690256803, 0.15109189160945619, 0.2587547559234997, 0.3660623743071332, 0.19833727350155922, 0.22847978350138742, 0.15262950045459261, 0.33380799940075256, 0.3684707094963068, 0.22428704492502555, 0.14918984556626036, 0.2835033707959913, 0.2379140551778957, 0.10330429764737253, 0.28218163793448914, 0.22629836392438957, 0.3040896990491806, 0.2246122946754796, 0.31866039936721113, 0.3584768655608829] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=1.6 hv=-0.15", + "tune": "aniso=1.6 sel_hv=-0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.945663678954487, 9.2410331730782, 26.142246303112813, 10.738692014931493, 13.262608133784513, 10.133378678947471, 14.137645937566758, 3.5805893740127206, 11.298377111274412, 11.820008005224238, 10.481554631279776, 10.449223696581528, 4.0921351588678805, 11.65127432653496, 18.62857145402422, 10.958455225539922, 12.06696636725809, 10.197253950525326, 18.23643441027254, 14.180546708008826, 12.220646644801292, 4.430617807097959, 12.995975729000769, 12.912027132072712, 2.3406629713865956, 13.525401689162571, 12.935637110337613, 12.258212454001885, 9.466896567835942, 10.405443983388311, 14.760267744117751], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.3570729966167, -260.8028424666486, -1230.873484310223, -193.7897826699641, -313.2022717582702, -258.7677902055688, -442.97371372521343, -63.378731125280154, -377.51195481453345, -318.6220742712973, -254.1843760035748, -172.6802370748572, -64.02507970415132, -280.33142115035895, -821.9301942201423, -267.25134809799283, -283.19330181516307, -120.67067571663969, -631.045245918453, -695.2444283070126, -313.96393608075834, -64.64966880969564, -409.87623261228237, -253.4497120815177, -59.604981954440376, -398.7717398525608, -273.93146955314114, -374.49938240850486, -256.5259113961968, -409.9273383871031, -641.1338866529128], + "butteraugli": [22.95721842749172, 25.91003774918921, 45.11355198705099, 28.194964132927876, 25.951288315219102, 22.921837767381096, 40.03815447138074, 13.317652381158382, 22.551517053724904, 39.512437585375615, 21.708465817221327, 32.676006445403, 21.84832540687293, 23.245652688603514, 37.109974124071435, 29.143437766218018, 31.798384266479967, 46.20665555003262, 47.4566830895722, 25.71350340098547, 38.45293425695392, 15.770201647619652, 22.228153334920165, 27.100503645825807, 9.761445014747101, 44.35224664485316, 37.2886783339047, 37.76991982071716, 39.68106530773114, 34.33333643462472, 34.429192852753275], + "dssim": [0.30426689015855024, 0.30593594159558, 0.4644786607773847, 0.16364583457497722, 0.33458132555523246, 0.23947295995195822, 0.21926581706180998, 0.08453115349036722, 0.40862896843878516, 0.26492606346661074, 0.39383781199222373, 0.2490101427592144, 0.1511164180713156, 0.25830310944803614, 0.3655183822986413, 0.19844585059533076, 0.22902471396687146, 0.15185358376848862, 0.3296913566764976, 0.36842221674612463, 0.22426837742325484, 0.15000216099911473, 0.2827820724081581, 0.23831586501261115, 0.10330429764737253, 0.28086094494735514, 0.22320887702676734, 0.3033054225844417, 0.22328825482133746, 0.31837267035376227, 0.35748709467595674] + } + }, + { + "label": "aniso=0.8 hv=-0.15", + "tune": "aniso=0.8 sel_hv=-0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.941318343407918, 9.197636149802632, 26.135042465025375, 10.356588444062337, 13.256648211941936, 9.808228628586454, 14.119653128855292, 3.633640559060892, 11.329682081592983, 11.68081038876087, 10.518943985882467, 10.319191327195304, 4.179095999352763, 11.73115307610532, 18.757761842924335, 10.89287984424192, 12.08801340763209, 10.065218774009786, 18.43864748577153, 14.162919437886197, 11.993113027328164, 4.79148495337539, 12.735686173386378, 12.61651348281955, 2.3227631019831154, 13.525401689162571, 13.137794953778085, 12.213564416055789, 9.084969202269935, 10.405443983388311, 14.87272907412174], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.79228544673464, -260.29170553670156, -1230.5943971248962, -170.78868105904985, -318.07277090740797, -233.0063472983091, -438.737678326073, -63.82464794107449, -380.6952799487769, -313.45247431062046, -258.2899074837437, -167.26747406243567, -64.11862159831338, -285.72692227204357, -829.459368274073, -279.2415952772824, -283.2351980703736, -121.92789200403229, -654.0114197689735, -694.6363181617044, -301.1574290257149, -65.97295876887057, -407.6201626598346, -244.3905650889655, -59.58038993194074, -398.7717398525608, -286.78110908948827, -373.70056636077027, -228.07654923052337, -409.9273383871031, -641.8619771370641], + "butteraugli": [22.994348741429132, 26.85126533474954, 45.09894041141239, 27.822852617844305, 26.01538953310697, 21.752318842384454, 39.744850541351425, 13.344627798805751, 22.172234073164773, 38.733038388490556, 21.096396653329304, 30.904486311284035, 21.77335949068186, 23.073085215981394, 37.31557885617781, 29.101726663432327, 31.83455700860645, 46.418939307157295, 49.11363475374052, 25.75088571351974, 38.8465041922699, 16.321801066681168, 22.227770575572023, 26.555142195368195, 9.756576567127391, 44.35224664485316, 36.92702438687945, 37.77556503602715, 33.886876233185156, 34.33333643462472, 34.04211050672799], + "dssim": [0.30434429330840074, 0.3057136368556824, 0.46437948172275745, 0.16173357321381676, 0.3348146993827801, 0.24012206641472422, 0.21892968157436804, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40885434988006997, 0.26515016610458153, 0.39396527420398286, 0.2466764528010273, 0.15140988945096784, 0.25919335624425244, 0.36579378260838413, 0.1980829234988259, 0.22907008873426699, 0.15201911335566404, 0.3321834168825416, 0.36845387631173254, 0.22355605921837468, 0.14940994412071867, 0.28274570935523624, 0.23779050404845642, 0.10332512739852318, 0.28086094494735514, 0.22612978901257036, 0.302343815729315, 0.22301886481028405, 0.31837267035376227, 0.3578437075447657] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 aniso1.2", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 aniso1.2 hv-.15", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=-0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [6.945663678954487, 9.237581979517223, 26.135042465025375, 10.356588444062337, 13.249888807401703, 9.808228628586454, 14.126702701020783, 3.633640559060892, 11.329682081592983, 11.678743052532056, 10.467965737417073, 10.319191327195304, 4.179095999352763, 11.65127432653496, 18.721767329310733, 10.958455225539922, 12.08801340763209, 10.065218774009786, 18.43864748577153, 14.180045141771876, 11.993113027328164, 4.79148495337539, 12.746885074798858, 12.892528818267262, 2.3227631019831154, 13.525401689162571, 13.137794953778085, 12.213564416055789, 9.084969202269935, 10.405443983388311, 14.87272907412174], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.3570729966167, -264.1136126908541, -1230.5943971248962, -170.78868105904985, -316.53730872747417, -233.0063472983091, -438.6484885498687, -63.82464794107449, -380.6952799487769, -315.8218595365779, -255.31970922516933, -167.26747406243567, -64.11862159831338, -280.33142115035895, -827.8122251655957, -267.25134809799283, -283.2351980703736, -121.92789200403229, -654.0114197689735, -694.4119222804309, -301.1574290257149, -65.97295876887057, -410.54909535141974, -257.5848294397028, -59.58038993194074, -398.7717398525608, -286.78110908948827, -373.70056636077027, -228.07654923052337, -409.9273383871031, -641.8619771370641], + "butteraugli": [22.95721842749172, 26.47800181335813, 45.09894041141239, 27.822852617844305, 25.931383016605633, 21.752318842384454, 39.66365451340224, 13.344627798805751, 22.172234073164773, 38.34883927817409, 21.676005194918584, 30.904486311284035, 21.77335949068186, 23.245652688603514, 37.39411041753768, 29.143437766218018, 31.83455700860645, 46.418939307157295, 49.11363475374052, 25.709172262565392, 38.8465041922699, 16.321801066681168, 22.289572344506755, 27.109281449518495, 9.756576567127391, 44.35224664485316, 36.92702438687945, 37.77556503602715, 33.886876233185156, 34.33333643462472, 34.04211050672799], + "dssim": [0.30426689015855024, 0.3058383549798349, 0.46437948172275745, 0.16173357321381676, 0.3347332911390727, 0.24012206641472422, 0.21887011704272652, 0.08466164295604495, 0.40885434988006997, 0.26294631360406107, 0.39392432654481846, 0.2466764528010273, 0.15140988945096784, 0.25830310944803614, 0.36580578675573683, 0.19844585059533076, 0.22907008873426699, 0.15201911335566404, 0.3321834168825416, 0.3684314459676199, 0.22355605921837468, 0.14940994412071867, 0.2824838317389139, 0.23825222127185836, 0.10332512739852318, 0.28086094494735514, 0.22612978901257036, 0.302343815729315, 0.22301886481028405, 0.31837267035376227, 0.3578437075447657] + } + }, + { + "label": "L28@4C15@3 aniso1.2 hv+.15", + "tune": "l1=28:4 c=15:3 aniso=1.2 sel_hv=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/selection-weights.json b/tools/comparison/results/selection-weights.json index 5a5e426..b1283cb 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/selection-weights.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/selection-weights.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window-upper.json b/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window-upper.json index e219298..5956dd0 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window-upper.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window-upper.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window.json b/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window.json index 6aa961d..b36caae 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/synthesis-window.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead-holdout.json index c0b80cd..5ec6dc5 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead-holdout.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead.json b/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead.json index e3dd619..7e1e4ca 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/thumbhash-headtohead.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-alpha.json b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-alpha.json index f91f2ba..5e5a413 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-alpha.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-alpha.json @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ "name": "v07-holdout-alpha", "split": "tune", "settings": { - "description": "SS11.12 - the single holdout validation of the alpha-mode changes. Run once, after every tune decision was settled. The incumbent is the alpha layout as shipped at the start of SS11, so the delta is what stabilizing v0.7 moves alpha mode by. The tier-0 candidate is A28@3 L22@4 C3@3 and the compact-tier candidate A16@3 L12@4 C1@3; both were chosen on tune by protecting the mostly-opaque subgroup rather than by taking the deltaE00-optimal corner. Every arm pins alpha_ac_count and alpha_ac_bits explicitly. They are applied on top of Tunables::DEFAULT, so an arm that omitted them inherited the ADOPTED A28@3 -- which is what the incumbent labelled `SHIPPED A5@4` was doing: it encoded to 40 bytes rather than 32 and reported the adopted allocation's own alpha MAE, so this sweep was scoring the adopted layout against itself with a different luma/chroma split. Same defect class as EXPERIMENTS.md 9.5's seven configs; this one was not among them.", + "description": "SS11.12 - the holdout validation of the alpha-mode changes, run after every tune decision was settled, and run again once the mislabelled incumbent below was fixed. Its holdout split can no longer be reproduced: cutout-wordmark-aflac was deleted from Wikimedia Commons (#83), so only the tune run can be re-measured. The incumbent is the alpha layout as shipped at the start of SS11, so the delta is what stabilizing v0.7 moves alpha mode by. The tier-0 candidate is A28@3 L22@4 C3@3 and the compact-tier candidate A16@3 L12@4 C1@3; both were chosen on tune by protecting the mostly-opaque subgroup rather than by taking the deltaE00-optimal corner. Every arm pins alpha_ac_count and alpha_ac_bits explicitly. They are applied on top of Tunables::DEFAULT, so an arm that omitted them inherited the ADOPTED A28@3 -- which is what the incumbent labelled `SHIPPED A5@4` was doing: it encoded to 40 bytes rather than 32 and reported the adopted allocation's own alpha MAE, so this sweep was scoring the adopted layout against itself with a different luma/chroma split. Same defect class as EXPERIMENTS.md 9.5's seven configs; this one was not among them.", "corpus": "alpha", "backdrops": "white-black-grey", "alphaFidelity": true, @@ -19,12 +19,12 @@ } }, "provenance": { - "rev": "323fdf280e85727b43c30e19dcd6170bb14009cb", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json", - "configSha256": "6d88b3784a285d7a75e0442923f4478bca5d01fc783c3f428f075d8d10b68b4a", + "configSha256": "5402ef20052b6bc1c18bf7206d6a536d4f8e131597ff6aac29196ad1e1a8c3aa", "binaries": { "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" }, diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo-holdout.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..acb20f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo-holdout.json @@ -0,0 +1,283 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "v07-holdout-photo", + "split": "holdout", + "settings": { + "description": "SS11.12 - the round-3 holdout validation of every tune-chosen change on the photographic split, run after all tune decisions were settled. It is not the split's first consultation: the same 32 images had already validated rounds 1 and 2 (SS4.5, SS7.12, SS10.3), and SS11.12 records that history. Consulting holdout per-experiment would make it a second tune set. The incumbent is the constants as shipped at the start of SS11, so the deltas are what stabilizing v0.7 actually moved the format by.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json", + "configSha256": "1883744e1254349ac225ab15e073fe28da0d7aa0a9690d633e54ae92de442f4d", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "kodak01", + "sha256": "a56e27cbf5f843c048b6af1d6e090760e9c92fadba88b7dee0205918a37523bd" + }, + { + "name": "kodak02", + "sha256": "4f4b74a79237e311d72cad958237b5f7088d8bce1c82305ebefe1a70e3022dfd" + }, + { + "name": "kodak03", + "sha256": "e25ca1ff2f0c0cb5fdfd5f9b0a0bb21ac4c3de3c84a67f35b09a85d3306249db" + }, + { + "name": "kodak04", + "sha256": "e3b946107c5d3441c022f678d0c3caf1e224d81b1604ba840a4f88e562de61aa" + }, + { + "name": "kodak05", + "sha256": "10349e963c5c813d327852f82c1795fa4148d69fedffc4c589bee458e3ac3d53" + }, + { + "name": "kodak06", + "sha256": "363510303b715d4cbc384e1ce227e466b613a09e1b71ae985882bf8e7fbd9b18" + }, + { + "name": "kodak07", + "sha256": "b77d3f006f42414bb242222e0482e750c0fb9e5ee8d4bed2f6f11c5605fe54a4" + }, + { + "name": "kodak08", + "sha256": "ba23983c76b4832ee0e8af0592664756841a16779acd69f792e268fb6d13d6e7" + }, + { + "name": "kodak09", + "sha256": "6a4361c2fc194feb4edaa9f9a4a0620fb9943e460ac7fdf037fb0f6dd6607a7d" + }, + { + "name": "kodak10", + "sha256": "9dfb70f5867c29ff9ed6313683f19b3d867849e40fbc0c4c54a4a89df341cf23" + }, + { + "name": "kodak11", + "sha256": "7936814b58b5387fce2e4e2488b4ec830dadd95fa9520f358ddb30990b50f2b6" + }, + { + "name": "kodak12", + "sha256": "d78c37c2f04f23761ed2367dd77e2db584ddd4c3950833fecf89f199a8126980" + }, + { + "name": "kodak13", + "sha256": "bc34a3ce58dea09dce1704c997171602de90cb34d0c8503a988b77f473d39b08" + }, + { + "name": "kodak14", + "sha256": "55a94550ff18f3246c4074fd32b77b0c74447c26b6ad274d564d999c0450ba6e" + }, + { + "name": "kodak15", + "sha256": "7538cbb80cb9103606c48b806eae57d56c885c7f90b9b3be70a41160f9cbb683" + }, + { + "name": "kodak16", + "sha256": "a89c7268ccd4718ba424a99fc4643c572cf692ca6eae887185ceb4e9f11d2e54" + }, + { + "name": "kodak17", + "sha256": "37afcc89fbdcb76d9518e04b2fc011027e2f4cd14b3b2f83cefd721641a47c5b" + }, + { + "name": "kodak18", + "sha256": "1a9258c365988961d87a0598725b609139c303ad48a5aad6c503c3b1a87849aa" + }, + { + "name": "kodak19", + "sha256": "b7450b264b1b0a411390d8931b112c27905a992520fc90569dc4b920aa32bbdc" + }, + { + "name": "kodak20", + "sha256": "3b46c71e3b92a563820ba32936be8330c586c41f938efd94be938386aae4328a" + }, + { + "name": "kodak21", + "sha256": "ac958597c82073f6bb65129c68f72b651db5b9efd82e11547d07350214bc268b" + }, + { + "name": "kodak22", + "sha256": "1cee58eb1f2d9c7ebb254d208a03c783ce6cf2c4d8c2cf45e235dd23b4ce1b29" + }, + { + "name": "kodak23", + "sha256": "e3111a2fd4da24af15d6459ef9eacfe54106b38e27b4a21821b75c3f5d2d5baf" + }, + { + "name": "kodak24", + "sha256": "1071c68372cc5a01435c2c225a5cf7d4bb803846ec08bb6b3d6721b156d7cb96" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-black-and-white", + "sha256": "0ea4fa6c16e8923ec0b3658a5cebb6bee4ba32ae35bca0641b69b9fe64e27f50" + }, + { + "name": "natural-egretta-thula-las", + "sha256": "00e9a470e07721ac2d384a437fe922f66ee82c27cc81c106e8a2097a14bfb6c1" + }, + { + "name": "natural-interior-cafe-commerce", + "sha256": "2bb825fed40007f83a759f4103691599fcdddb116d411648752dd8df990b7ec9" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-dwest-gen", + "sha256": "c76ccdd7cb56c1959272d57726c324998e3cb81bcaa0d658180d0d065d3bd33a" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mabrousha-cake-with", + "sha256": "fc1bc49c2b2ca9675bd87205d7b4382ef2b10d80da8346600abd9a19a637d985" + }, + { + "name": "natural-table-set-for", + "sha256": "9af6423b26141dce7d14aeeef58f94d4d980875ead7c7d6653814dec81ee756c" + }, + { + "name": "natural-walnut-tart-close", + "sha256": "68141502b2131761f963dca2c4f9ef09e43457812235f88c8a448326009f6e93" + }, + { + "name": "night-nster-liudgerhaus-und", + "sha256": "1c4dedcc5564305a8bf0bfdfde912dc45057b60c3a80caef977c2b39eaa36674" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["kodak01", "kodak02", "kodak03", "kodak04", "kodak05", "kodak06", "kodak07", "kodak08", "kodak09", "kodak10", "kodak11", "kodak12", "kodak13", "kodak14", "kodak15", "kodak16", "kodak17", "kodak18", "kodak19", "kodak20", "kodak21", "kodak22", "kodak23", "kodak24", "chroma-black-and-white", "natural-egretta-thula-las", "natural-interior-cafe-commerce", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-dwest-gen", "natural-mabrousha-cake-with", "natural-table-set-for", "natural-walnut-tart-close", "night-nster-liudgerhaus-und"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "SS10 constants (incumbent)", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.177645396246133, 5.333089098491294, 12.401022167716228, 10.362786739527253, 15.430513806163528, 8.609546312029883, 11.927110890988677, 17.02010049593965, 9.119895608770562, 8.587371863634115, 10.63279625286454, 9.27130430973671, 11.534453654262183, 13.993736321919842, 14.505549590008341, 6.948580585632925, 9.134520325396585, 12.2483191377855, 9.361188093971132, 9.211896071347452, 10.162094482053405, 11.174535491975096, 14.176377777894642, 11.773802067599416, 9.498300078143409, 8.281004070296934, 15.700007721981045, 7.46005069445734, 14.515949349098243, 12.11615557677274, 15.969740501566621, 10.900384429182983], + "ssimulacra2": [-358.83429682858696, -80.44651060416243, -210.81152869922641, -173.61416588999936, -752.9382493470525, -111.32359232892836, -343.04225855152913, -678.108570095377, -140.7274708166497, -157.55342995182895, -258.0808266945024, -92.93327344776517, -440.01766873616714, -459.09804876164276, -258.57455543544853, -88.03797748317334, -319.6764070823109, -398.07835296588655, -186.27803045035108, -153.49173718964386, -234.3136181949343, -225.90988954123014, -222.91271100121742, -413.7721132632196, -180.07700209061676, -78.99885476870662, -559.6126744436922, -93.8330736502844, -544.8592118701104, -381.0800018430755, -785.8917288542262, -336.84412247792176], + "butteraugli": [20.634302600561302, 27.214505445980876, 27.146069532010205, 22.72061466101111, 27.0636691373592, 28.69637096989689, 23.24907778589663, 32.75269553741416, 27.940576747155074, 24.896284499104766, 24.68952996272671, 30.365485998075073, 22.079458200244883, 27.257906765467226, 42.48388500460578, 20.22416209649082, 22.975747074950736, 27.341966599869547, 24.864969502703186, 36.19212405224374, 28.47082772506221, 24.959446790355887, 31.891295982443513, 27.572535545174826, 32.879911317826895, 25.027362157390545, 38.15016796848444, 18.35182273153608, 29.57981894011655, 35.18344103519343, 39.82920327566475, 28.39257171928341], + "dssim": [0.37654563820041986, 0.18740686469515438, 0.17553907548533115, 0.22704930491343916, 0.39661248639490165, 0.2798587785946912, 0.2555951271803776, 0.3921803974603431, 0.1818794186947852, 0.20547727413823585, 0.27792269679593773, 0.17487400980432094, 0.3937652712303489, 0.3382337592455522, 0.2126087721365013, 0.22036199770831993, 0.25362005437907986, 0.3182764603335957, 0.25062985913483915, 0.17411735701794157, 0.24153990469854542, 0.264049513598678, 0.17968074178621984, 0.31150958103800275, 0.18437690710144383, 0.0987332056231307, 0.34456263088049766, 0.2406943823000191, 0.3448311894367223, 0.26180886084179866, 0.3123965843173926, 0.31660709182890456] + } + }, + { + "label": "sel_hv=0.30", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.30", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.189790081537987, 5.372514276368451, 12.679946203810983, 11.261476830145774, 15.24771281036223, 8.442449632590773, 11.752463200045101, 16.82299919728448, 9.202910374140316, 8.75168305332983, 10.691430984983024, 9.270853866928276, 11.475655358299086, 13.694086435155134, 15.532390540867583, 6.996514219514282, 9.310291789911364, 12.090156035458309, 9.47315123065149, 9.152779352619287, 10.014832437106149, 10.715830326370405, 15.124606030410543, 11.744859438103711, 9.505835450169316, 8.212676355575129, 15.761079103107633, 7.466567034340321, 14.542417604967746, 12.119158161425597, 15.89742696090724, 11.037528814040027], + "ssimulacra2": [-362.9522151130021, -80.75323933396652, -213.70630763683573, -164.7588641659832, -737.8242377782902, -108.4998560467198, -342.81922316171455, -653.4466939033503, -139.63958660558723, -165.8527329240162, -255.42503170237353, -92.45013966772319, -426.8979741883321, -444.89873927885753, -290.71154208667747, -91.51071573056132, -322.43923465773287, -389.926901239443, -189.41332671620523, -144.77773837163062, -226.34363672667945, -226.4134564343201, -246.48423117999494, -405.733009877083, -180.4576412915627, -79.72880930290725, -562.756659975625, -94.17551172072322, -544.5637311375327, -361.0193920757828, -781.6768580205714, -335.9545777606514], + "butteraugli": [20.70019602225248, 26.959954705802364, 26.716212824178626, 23.811337213366073, 26.736734871741465, 26.58637265376896, 23.72763988335289, 33.13874393218714, 28.222984301760587, 25.409123999330774, 24.26657327647099, 28.40596931122586, 22.207545019031503, 26.777169914927242, 38.512955924695746, 21.455127108721843, 22.936506250160978, 28.456183738955872, 24.701339154586822, 36.042846813509975, 28.211953129143932, 24.472034376763588, 31.3346034332489, 26.759708172368278, 32.501042773206876, 26.03811179494917, 38.398970505326496, 18.265118363381447, 29.57380630091043, 35.73086253592912, 40.40253020024938, 28.19457733583343], + "dssim": [0.37651270102664475, 0.18776223470766157, 0.17329806084433957, 0.22800883209320727, 0.3966271032906568, 0.27903272780855404, 0.2558418156703227, 0.3914435031586211, 0.18183620953614693, 0.20595304646864615, 0.2783444051283903, 0.17505220543886596, 0.3936617010175878, 0.3381600776880419, 0.21451392001117225, 0.22029723473833202, 0.2533595722845058, 0.31765388998110633, 0.2508756379997267, 0.17389969296823898, 0.24128690074912568, 0.26432822994569805, 0.1807651644449138, 0.31164450373554475, 0.18427026674448793, 0.09901466529476904, 0.3444547552250531, 0.24078821383833843, 0.34493655683006574, 0.2609296269778818, 0.31441673625404964, 0.3165359260460343] + } + }, + { + "label": "isotropic (aniso=0 hv=0)", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.577900021922687, 5.349041067730056, 12.431965017742298, 10.09639572716975, 15.42790183709772, 8.752336106669121, 12.019493280271869, 17.18131120767927, 9.186195360303863, 8.65029873979867, 10.639845930598941, 9.25764916623156, 11.52321501225366, 14.169190700014202, 14.714738618347088, 7.062085072831436, 9.073055302234364, 12.410374740095909, 9.61225840702172, 9.204847846234431, 10.296497213596794, 11.226491588095408, 14.409673292170078, 11.84122398636168, 9.72563530427983, 8.196327735095453, 15.533243811090912, 7.729519515586186, 14.492967844971709, 11.934705362261308, 15.992160042251971, 11.045950758648399], + "ssimulacra2": [-444.98538391384795, -79.87769345978737, -212.7746748047221, -180.8199606092905, -772.2641398942008, -119.50516940537085, -358.02343434057536, -689.3719914316357, -156.96689195569695, -169.08090167025898, -270.62207642664754, -97.26605192390628, -440.88288955512564, -487.9431040065175, -270.5852567367558, -91.86215703885651, -311.54546654784923, -413.65655642173874, -194.82784922216234, -153.62942956081474, -250.0772448313541, -230.82979512641873, -244.78005131875113, -427.44035488407417, -189.34740617498932, -79.04087193523796, -562.7481116581613, -102.82520403096626, -539.5858994828599, -373.30772894072135, -780.032395953806, -352.52312129208326], + "butteraugli": [23.193469413092455, 26.151423146720948, 26.345741262808218, 22.68896758262211, 27.24953212142187, 27.494294688200444, 23.932247995227048, 33.10466689524363, 26.967773935630408, 24.471097102272694, 25.092998269458935, 33.50881903954906, 21.99566458415102, 28.276407209129715, 41.755565432276626, 20.569581841668512, 23.287218520818417, 26.792791731205043, 24.333215767593277, 36.13036141926557, 28.401940242661663, 25.718140648409417, 30.756936918153418, 28.625615774981252, 32.335920874840035, 24.65981929890209, 37.77056435692498, 18.44538598493457, 29.39799039876254, 35.086902897111436, 39.35029176610365, 27.713764592091], + "dssim": [0.37822676541933925, 0.18728258717004187, 0.17608867112099186, 0.2260180123192171, 0.39676024395442616, 0.27940475521878816, 0.2550705774665758, 0.39227987996195757, 0.18196395209132343, 0.20629705379595403, 0.2780280954932741, 0.17437418191795495, 0.3937344188229, 0.3381411224967432, 0.21247564404864955, 0.22102034574188906, 0.25500334024222293, 0.31915605614923215, 0.2514094168806905, 0.17411724378471088, 0.24170842220850836, 0.26401309658320415, 0.1796429854875254, 0.31187477443821465, 0.1871177643903827, 0.09943121227859963, 0.3459525388652302, 0.24109419572055507, 0.3441176099815294, 0.260849069635237, 0.3144564006122298, 0.3171184134888172] + } + }, + { + "label": "pre-adoption v0.6-derived", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [14.97060246716555, 5.609469516729318, 12.845351278355698, 11.682481073556591, 15.745117167785608, 8.742407855764363, 11.97132164007678, 17.27551065526376, 9.43395890710866, 8.939234694585961, 10.897257932728738, 9.662170508524643, 11.644909361930752, 14.550240013926281, 15.387252963074092, 7.503363259756005, 9.383929197410334, 12.439497729352466, 9.754066348852321, 9.334311111356197, 10.38392778897854, 12.017992130005902, 16.448881564148092, 12.148304075645395, 10.028909288814273, 8.643039921322279, 15.533682075917923, 8.147975140352761, 14.345438131145166, 12.766554960950563, 16.08310237946088, 11.206410866218635], + "ssimulacra2": [-445.2503973592145, -81.00475283512361, -222.7074422332762, -179.0403753809689, -772.1655635655139, -117.4121498666315, -365.0882893399145, -689.2897622445489, -158.42247340524546, -172.61457323229462, -270.96886789162875, -92.72704390964154, -445.47905711053727, -517.1634122814157, -275.1290028640853, -93.37105607708, -322.08664052150016, -419.11700637374895, -191.81279551680058, -150.78156207724237, -251.05375256788693, -243.6165797456917, -253.15735142625965, -439.0486092102716, -193.65971060282357, -82.85560394093437, -561.4251604374282, -103.03650116989971, -537.8258476450569, -383.5804218068266, -789.5518525122292, -367.8061917262152], + "butteraugli": [23.61260833635229, 27.770840742887525, 27.09176586358167, 23.024015998077754, 27.119737299131543, 26.895237795296605, 24.212074337262496, 33.07402768667264, 27.624259784617845, 24.65749284345379, 24.840971421227163, 34.229036876315426, 22.01522939081892, 30.399384550109676, 43.6775010370909, 21.557583147501017, 22.924766056934583, 27.841503148417086, 24.942789014202265, 35.55609548763177, 28.297573022978543, 26.065967590355797, 31.199406751247206, 31.696028043719846, 33.57683837732417, 25.338823248068085, 37.72866870125821, 18.839249918662045, 29.381327139174676, 35.08043154422975, 39.20212393116367, 27.792302601786687], + "dssim": [0.378477384278724, 0.18912610254475004, 0.18038687461769554, 0.22838446221673742, 0.3967225075873569, 0.2794864770392025, 0.25525356618602546, 0.3923933614286697, 0.1819614709651039, 0.2066035689792331, 0.27910867632033176, 0.1741247316904868, 0.3937120452311927, 0.33980684959437535, 0.21031535008453067, 0.22108900974018314, 0.25163550228030174, 0.3196287953186937, 0.2510112449320999, 0.17340917906268705, 0.2418067625523172, 0.26444665974283843, 0.1813982358247611, 0.3127918727026111, 0.18701818294257772, 0.09954758231965283, 0.3456191754251916, 0.24102083893927545, 0.3439373914583846, 0.26303579806191135, 0.31547634759247245, 0.3176837816320681] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L19@4 C6@3", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.88641183319647, 5.492329359267073, 14.459583263499745, 12.376452999870342, 15.903774644555453, 9.028568460388938, 12.093307767151032, 17.623098925928474, 9.912177096070804, 9.178667542391684, 11.190142141712407, 9.797142307098857, 11.868115374992014, 14.87958630545021, 16.64238671669925, 7.579836557936629, 9.868180098064363, 13.114545306715312, 10.073033860565285, 9.637232100653154, 10.633979354371515, 12.183143524001137, 17.60920943714403, 12.362307855723591, 10.264275526192577, 9.861017945862567, 15.933221296897415, 8.16879304169055, 15.004618116581481, 12.724240837032154, 16.627419976140825, 11.707513384350147], + "ssimulacra2": [-456.32313660626517, -82.91458679836586, -258.5512967067599, -185.90917300739744, -787.5051968451794, -120.83792215452729, -381.89657624403713, -710.9695805657, -180.395204361251, -178.8359862596767, -270.4674091338894, -100.24326588604666, -453.83240354511895, -525.2039960427442, -349.7628395525928, -94.18229844493709, -371.79147509935706, -434.65025129251626, -218.59733095999513, -153.20468536555083, -255.90224104029943, -249.23835347375655, -302.03887227731735, -453.76209611876584, -199.7594057567175, -93.31064423954047, -576.1489353369561, -106.37555351052106, -561.482801504011, -382.63938856432816, -814.1970922882082, -372.27195395984927], + "butteraugli": [23.612265609792903, 28.303145649712473, 29.770849940757113, 24.48918545648304, 28.187344777213088, 27.25525461713521, 25.31351333629244, 33.19045641893886, 29.23163764091082, 25.808353477272586, 25.378070115375404, 35.69276719359942, 22.37085424346066, 30.87211066696089, 44.13351242993906, 21.149089561635147, 24.587412817507765, 29.45385741230864, 26.169950955106362, 36.91484070188264, 30.52007670305207, 26.4630003123267, 35.83714990273384, 37.212912936904665, 34.16798020020831, 30.767093683249442, 39.09995894524385, 18.797242580575183, 30.618637066658295, 36.5825554608009, 40.603290410858754, 29.70100168398908], + "dssim": [0.3787893106933343, 0.18889567629642323, 0.17672289266540236, 0.2297159649076977, 0.39723848009227464, 0.2795544107727187, 0.2554921816497703, 0.393038366197829, 0.18335632664946538, 0.20665342664936065, 0.27851564506517124, 0.17481733617547707, 0.3940107212239116, 0.340026382473538, 0.2156545554783384, 0.22118156127754618, 0.25869529262297375, 0.32067152005891775, 0.25169995078997964, 0.17338811616210986, 0.24176530579197636, 0.2645793782178838, 0.18571878020843796, 0.3135169689323317, 0.18807988184960067, 0.10169296550427703, 0.34507052687906525, 0.24106644967704033, 0.34557117208272375, 0.2623051492653671, 0.317361447416767, 0.31790516941550073] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L18@4 C7@3", + "tune": "l1=18:4 c=7:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.866143735491587, 5.448964424783749, 14.010879136439469, 12.194164363890556, 15.78085042935019, 8.93012645119393, 12.48280914973947, 17.44739854607551, 9.977303519946954, 9.27463473527584, 11.263217849705208, 9.818523568452171, 11.79481706465881, 14.756433025023107, 16.576799310644315, 7.5894198454957715, 9.86584981275857, 12.797133928096175, 10.087940378666186, 9.840662430751799, 10.56116414754771, 12.104698142660187, 17.093181705139564, 12.287402648734366, 10.35639558583434, 9.909476231558083, 15.960240750387714, 8.16879304169055, 15.010734651997494, 12.734605797389378, 16.483059096588843, 11.786159084698514], + "ssimulacra2": [-456.6681138650706, -82.43300232505084, -255.27896788990142, -188.03321350415615, -785.7873260830645, -123.35272182083628, -395.4935988528808, -711.0301366435983, -183.77136147058087, -190.30020724939396, -271.9211225034666, -101.78352993221853, -451.9853547066358, -526.441317231716, -341.1308586959512, -94.6067039211317, -370.7421805970103, -439.212582485742, -216.50939747205507, -155.61361732526365, -256.0628765942023, -247.84570058439493, -302.40551472517507, -454.067490085454, -203.89451471136238, -95.6779877001591, -575.783041486925, -106.37555351052106, -562.9714810331831, -383.40115783943753, -812.444965808604, -396.04683505437976], + "butteraugli": [23.621133078827796, 28.843469168245974, 29.718795708574657, 24.420218126731054, 28.33741948646728, 27.019324069298175, 25.55991146412718, 33.18569951258517, 29.097885778391376, 25.52776079718385, 25.647509744560853, 36.62188420178665, 22.275564554115387, 31.247859300649463, 44.82988102042636, 21.6838737114678, 24.52700045387249, 29.6362628262796, 26.004444075412113, 37.39519223483923, 30.787183158084346, 26.61503037115177, 35.43186747461003, 38.865344204519694, 34.778295282348154, 31.408471022045987, 39.09693102314063, 18.797242580575183, 30.514005634130587, 36.62500256253248, 40.50875364569004, 29.101567238859257], + "dssim": [0.37882222760760126, 0.18783495538613532, 0.1821667319252141, 0.2296788486296239, 0.3971549795121056, 0.2798014385270696, 0.2563476454532402, 0.39300318006144125, 0.18359397295240237, 0.20734596293893953, 0.2786835234883529, 0.17476478120292743, 0.3940034974325433, 0.34031391494852026, 0.2158520121593006, 0.22109432263132028, 0.25855507292687807, 0.3202200072842236, 0.2516061693031022, 0.1736918450417856, 0.24174443582039046, 0.26469023848896633, 0.18543402949399085, 0.3135464611714541, 0.18846317466012552, 0.10281434621156582, 0.3450508821336998, 0.24106644967704033, 0.34524941440967805, 0.2622570409636804, 0.3151157136607078, 0.3189850919061238] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L20@4 C5@3", + "tune": "l1=20:4 c=5:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.881165904699076, 5.498461041928633, 14.322211431011157, 12.532192833361616, 15.866222128841152, 9.046861294962087, 12.074143664038331, 17.544899043918385, 9.816413958222876, 9.474903993080162, 11.156526584192186, 10.021129533817396, 11.81772420431178, 14.901938811736306, 16.770506229157252, 7.809502712608217, 9.837905229411119, 13.479250457623468, 10.092549088560247, 9.637232100653154, 10.64240252018563, 12.189129618041973, 17.460476043522835, 12.362487194604244, 10.350913795295375, 9.878560980026503, 15.931019530453119, 7.927368966295757, 15.397369004431587, 12.768373391135498, 16.577044727894087, 11.769858373771253], + "ssimulacra2": [-451.71410717960714, -82.92192412627458, -245.19339551744798, -186.12338891230758, -780.8318094519103, -121.20349873901588, -372.6553435404788, -703.5824068773434, -174.9359017552204, -177.86642711749408, -271.24355353463665, -100.30905280663629, -444.80875742357034, -526.4043016260362, -342.88009505591356, -94.68681090590391, -371.90737374890205, -438.94083067506233, -218.9563968532534, -153.20468536555083, -256.2326260184298, -249.4398656902406, -291.29434609948936, -443.321641365436, -201.49745039335562, -92.76059167443964, -572.6955157784955, -95.9200793759409, -561.4452296116654, -383.2387318612277, -810.7660299042475, -372.18224197502644], + "butteraugli": [23.495151262224756, 28.193521901872312, 29.498448008047234, 24.508557265641485, 27.75327931011839, 27.303833899324548, 24.79147048175192, 33.44743412891748, 29.68032157829279, 25.67728260761419, 25.40915216031465, 35.51858081772199, 22.1427588996392, 30.901636212311477, 45.5380877152441, 21.281149913203823, 24.602769138116404, 29.38366264311402, 26.175790627937896, 36.91484070188264, 30.557898228938324, 26.485828690738952, 36.151931792779656, 34.14861431441437, 33.299385307072924, 30.960226192164402, 38.631724304313735, 18.76591858764975, 30.91449809025795, 36.68502664309664, 40.33530767236995, 29.704525559187186], + "dssim": [0.37866140477744775, 0.1887891637630283, 0.17678863901859038, 0.2291919594311549, 0.39707637346446867, 0.27956563735407014, 0.25567081152120585, 0.3926060573828218, 0.1832685777472544, 0.20671027006457338, 0.27857409668478283, 0.17488625077196734, 0.3939098153533244, 0.34009682302188016, 0.21546469768257964, 0.22115733977144253, 0.25983158596898137, 0.321195510663265, 0.251700904239783, 0.17338811616210986, 0.2417746396848215, 0.2646525925647456, 0.1850704484612547, 0.31321941845876144, 0.1882883546710461, 0.10167703257088029, 0.3449466751664287, 0.2406709241814553, 0.3445173733411151, 0.26236714082850876, 0.317672899945212, 0.3179363228536266] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L26@3 C6@3", + "tune": "l1=26:3 c=6:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.468509355865834, 5.4738343101032205, 14.140830093984244, 12.329571239069754, 15.834799452795773, 9.350512369619285, 11.941751938587664, 17.509390572572304, 9.623504810432594, 9.300149488435824, 11.495329825435451, 9.506615993713977, 11.890291784003972, 14.59903445603038, 16.359304976130815, 7.733955758674822, 10.031973720279396, 13.008853302282212, 10.209369012746263, 10.367708347118988, 10.71417862656975, 12.388886056937874, 17.24685457220369, 12.329070069846898, 10.296389995028589, 9.323526064326806, 16.43629975133458, 7.996110712234091, 14.913946876547948, 12.879226044908945, 16.613908603704584, 11.81661198489927], + "ssimulacra2": [-368.2269090476354, -81.27546873097128, -232.70475990087078, -176.9032376066799, -766.1369572705713, -127.47556236035007, -349.36191177965696, -697.8462680551295, -151.10929634060057, -176.16553313599775, -273.7693501618694, -96.02846395102904, -454.0856227942021, -469.48894781067474, -288.30867233947833, -97.25071800605551, -348.75005123645855, -415.67561198545695, -201.063093552307, -155.61095820097333, -251.30181487670757, -252.3216788314146, -263.5980849986916, -434.182393997218, -197.4152285267386, -82.38522144073218, -593.5795897433007, -94.94703600079811, -562.8947948563804, -380.4398046044602, -800.304425760962, -355.84540468707127], + "butteraugli": [21.75682311000523, 27.788852890894407, 28.86907657882826, 24.08152277144846, 27.739855409726815, 33.98522712160655, 23.892508170017056, 33.91199784564663, 27.208157770511036, 26.515024348368257, 24.529456189535363, 30.255268552897462, 22.945565174100825, 27.834032614423005, 44.6745533104931, 24.087410389329936, 24.15105123535484, 28.841752623207412, 24.60197446466174, 41.17266338516735, 28.50025726467568, 25.867774348530702, 33.35682288413164, 33.29750447990945, 33.01443950034899, 28.078304920910778, 36.299177228568475, 19.367272917415253, 30.172327171513093, 36.48997761415924, 39.67488831883477, 28.134015782247598], + "dssim": [0.3770946667291906, 0.18937216731560724, 0.17705661437561743, 0.2288867475766051, 0.3965852594730279, 0.28131140215107475, 0.25600780404237644, 0.39239770513869154, 0.1827609421988617, 0.20646337489049232, 0.2787017719861201, 0.17514747869764347, 0.39423624338354263, 0.3405811756898073, 0.21609231193241035, 0.22148853161118215, 0.26076816669595926, 0.3206112205114443, 0.2513870896540823, 0.17404406114051624, 0.24216954025053172, 0.26553098142163456, 0.18466754083142084, 0.31257689856104764, 0.18703012993664653, 0.10026004100635028, 0.34893613498985676, 0.24074066835422397, 0.34619516051267873, 0.263266993684918, 0.3154554173180999, 0.31824624671444113] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B shipped shape", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [14.876362464113168, 5.428911237380676, 14.371871806448953, 12.780142755427509, 15.9135872158831, 9.213927848117732, 12.609593554548931, 17.927837578541997, 10.323198967012155, 9.444809384487396, 10.956050666102247, 10.299482636166228, 12.428684633368158, 15.108036094699399, 18.22810211693027, 7.787118173486649, 9.819060727611141, 13.129237250753276, 10.187692266459585, 9.942366015924025, 10.491369519575088, 12.386885114134435, 18.106222842295185, 12.405401304050933, 12.06973115675233, 10.792081923097081, 16.515318339136776, 8.103846590867294, 15.514755757134411, 13.597383972270695, 16.994973568118517, 12.036497683950893], + "ssimulacra2": [-460.31985769399694, -83.49893858366141, -270.9470132598768, -210.61899195047556, -807.5294250573473, -123.61748213385476, -426.24772551420756, -746.4700854685675, -197.20431150368626, -206.36279017419588, -278.5336511348709, -103.65680960562784, -493.66123805144855, -542.1491856115395, -407.7792726296321, -111.6218216597467, -373.6196048895994, -453.49719727359866, -214.69541663149283, -158.44922966518544, -257.0448286639687, -273.6366422954228, -328.07631954809347, -458.45838269593605, -262.5577298040075, -101.21047631185306, -601.4026326105221, -103.9548492608912, -605.3618164717535, -425.0392887932343, -827.3065393739487, -412.637443106623], + "butteraugli": [23.29259764341889, 29.282165744383963, 31.307525506217406, 25.08327516222033, 29.17904141157135, 31.64874334037111, 26.377024708491877, 36.64319517979545, 31.487425542513943, 26.385578877635663, 25.771690181573987, 38.333638856758796, 23.93488084677958, 34.90007697034255, 48.93871598560363, 27.051699945818658, 24.23882178199373, 30.94953829991391, 26.790462389053374, 38.86195897526449, 30.390499631983516, 26.758345458633414, 37.869569936641206, 37.45283601530917, 40.45407964480058, 33.9883433877422, 38.78734004244029, 19.08624235805408, 31.49177087329566, 44.64623294904328, 41.449766904004534, 30.474665159369625], + "dssim": [0.3790290485142529, 0.1877970217326414, 0.1788394601627184, 0.23361811940119726, 0.397553320971128, 0.27909572764472046, 0.25687584484474835, 0.39409469648287215, 0.1839193510393891, 0.20827673113777434, 0.2793296718822703, 0.17499207187543614, 0.3944342179662195, 0.34079044172972606, 0.226222499427865, 0.22171448652323877, 0.26378113916747115, 0.32060443432995156, 0.25149550668088805, 0.1737491246582037, 0.24172993366524742, 0.26611072405833913, 0.19162850054303676, 0.31377379222523916, 0.19544663598197642, 0.10502272375461447, 0.349086128716553, 0.24087395960424313, 0.34906643105196555, 0.26368892830047075, 0.3165549032720516, 0.31917654013473373] + } + } + ] +} diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo.json b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f8266ad --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/v07-holdout-photo.json @@ -0,0 +1,279 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "sweep", + "name": "v07-holdout-photo", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "description": "SS11.12 - the round-3 holdout validation of every tune-chosen change on the photographic split, run after all tune decisions were settled. It is not the split's first consultation: the same 32 images had already validated rounds 1 and 2 (SS4.5, SS7.12, SS10.3), and SS11.12 records that history. Consulting holdout per-experiment would make it a second tune set. The incumbent is the constants as shipped at the start of SS11, so the deltas are what stabilizing v0.7 actually moved the format by.", + "corpus": "photo", + "backdrops": "white", + "alphaFidelity": false, + "artifacts": false, + "artifactGuardRise": null, + "artifactGridEdge": null, + "forceOpaque": false, + "expectBytes": null, + "guardTolerances": { + "ssimulacra2Drop": 1, + "relativeRise": 0.02 + } + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json", + "configSha256": "1883744e1254349ac225ab15e073fe28da0d7aa0a9690d633e54ae92de442f4d", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "SS10 constants (incumbent)", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.15", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "sel_hv=0.30", + "tune": "sel_hv=0.30", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.292487038811993, 9.002153945224254, 26.152214872540352, 10.564375501085674, 13.31558759901147, 9.746283821867994, 14.238019863814527, 3.3861462652292293, 10.903735570622274, 11.956472702601188, 11.043413743331136, 9.996635065082883, 3.8176315172023036, 11.968746867493692, 18.701605123384486, 10.80811741173374, 12.197979300295481, 10.014985336859503, 18.391518353909692, 14.14585082172779, 12.03647402579225, 4.290735582245184, 13.135658557950947, 13.024967026835073, 2.2774318425730598, 13.999118862503442, 13.016175824932633, 12.694530786563897, 8.685260945167798, 11.235741543571685, 15.027566607273323], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.64286540902987, -249.97728273326635, -1232.2203742460235, -179.31604377074666, -322.13725517875304, -226.8836127498701, -445.44682698657755, -62.92952954636078, -324.682548854959, -343.9333966154285, -284.30782979631374, -174.21294701248286, -64.0235245272585, -289.02139895969674, -821.1420867014032, -247.4900078961963, -273.6415672911408, -112.56206850781814, -609.4398274391367, -694.4224698999983, -307.5668049262538, -64.50024108784095, -438.63827161633117, -259.61686700266534, -60.07401104195259, -409.5737101456013, -288.53380392151934, -393.4746910431841, -234.44172287970662, -460.8655874416029, -662.5803915616301], + "butteraugli": [22.638082345232466, 26.4998407409734, 45.119588869639095, 28.16501460057978, 25.658589209031884, 22.317181171590338, 40.00724863265925, 13.189059396246671, 19.971725249838652, 44.98215511071496, 23.222427628709408, 29.30836657835198, 21.6770050986417, 21.702442747042145, 38.022000397249236, 27.08457563622478, 31.345949815298326, 47.38632078173729, 46.83508295904676, 25.728399117878485, 38.272727086763076, 15.818095518640902, 22.639285494535475, 27.219911942059877, 10.413356257718158, 43.9011990146115, 38.90356979301468, 42.31781095642784, 32.17262828873833, 35.86488030404336, 33.256037132602074], + "dssim": [0.3042713332327095, 0.3049436393834868, 0.46440227212785934, 0.16342170271377204, 0.33445969968032074, 0.23469298637381902, 0.21957687835355927, 0.08437551351771705, 0.4067106243515058, 0.24652033869253914, 0.3943439101585547, 0.24777939604411497, 0.15095172939908058, 0.25873913842943175, 0.3656208945909366, 0.20123385172995306, 0.22882764092002145, 0.14406696655858836, 0.3280688263013877, 0.36832486691102373, 0.22396952307731932, 0.14922448939808913, 0.2903939113395255, 0.23847104447578277, 0.09920757812967484, 0.28077233286889036, 0.22892179706211002, 0.302430180360459, 0.220534831937511, 0.3265495788011531, 0.35783874781816216] + } + }, + { + "label": "isotropic (aniso=0 hv=0)", + "tune": "aniso=0 sel_hv=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.427873079138645, 9.092703515979883, 26.145684048433175, 9.727440437130454, 13.17572167254182, 9.694677886564016, 14.012848161000163, 3.645560306405534, 11.026330243873568, 12.030023853863101, 10.454179797131706, 10.257279630838367, 4.1831826007369255, 11.756156756167364, 19.022240073055, 10.98521257230849, 12.059361293672868, 10.23986900767143, 18.493739151575316, 14.158219555685086, 11.77948195194051, 4.710129892720203, 12.956735092854322, 12.696212159754134, 2.3159210787173077, 13.760677046803174, 13.198486325016093, 12.26077600280311, 8.62212294499019, 10.24215849817679, 14.925923418153097], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.1919654712584, -256.77250615252893, -1231.3650272290974, -134.87796792036545, -321.5443268177885, -233.81520100469982, -428.25775820085937, -63.807799535774336, -327.6927044114153, -338.4645050692684, -258.0536862832219, -166.5748015923478, -64.13112892274526, -288.87658966826746, -836.252092467862, -282.6354211808337, -278.96035311959633, -121.01059074805508, -652.7900714221032, -694.6852482706813, -286.8108871101176, -66.06620065380281, -425.7635338364739, -246.74250590385276, -59.57908798855573, -416.78310353365373, -297.5020609393438, -377.23225701148755, -224.8614557988068, -405.8748609764692, -642.2057988414801], + "butteraugli": [23.275282544810846, 26.21100437158526, 45.09685047161944, 26.974430563547116, 25.313837927251654, 21.932014623291295, 39.16054962026409, 13.23507878250949, 20.662049349607916, 42.939299984584316, 20.819830315534958, 29.182536578411828, 21.878861241215834, 22.427806159975393, 37.153134314446106, 28.937326944235974, 31.52163330226068, 48.48214817591406, 49.195877298529545, 25.75625016160953, 38.00678452771019, 16.24899367245908, 22.326377802308468, 25.792847950236112, 9.756814795826243, 45.37476554114911, 37.97166176494557, 36.059810293959245, 32.86587551488613, 35.0946545340049, 33.626078019177676], + "dssim": [0.30442215332107514, 0.3052064120489898, 0.46433761041854904, 0.15757975265391994, 0.33471582598427674, 0.23576964888063112, 0.2190067227367402, 0.0846500200480218, 0.406943677429025, 0.24480226057383564, 0.3937744595716291, 0.24785528035797716, 0.15140269589127398, 0.2584458564920321, 0.3657276572070379, 0.1978174015851138, 0.2286141786328269, 0.14335270691357976, 0.3327837123325298, 0.3684392631276333, 0.22489379415248173, 0.1499076545223712, 0.28648502771605044, 0.23736225223490937, 0.1031587920128832, 0.2816748614937058, 0.22953291664039605, 0.3034035752156877, 0.220965354642427, 0.31961782775442904, 0.3577266323292849] + } + }, + { + "label": "pre-adoption v0.6-derived", + "tune": "l1=26:5 c=9:4 aniso=0 sel_hv=0 scale_fit=0 ac_nearest=0", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.822168903781713, 9.227271661692745, 26.108957502760102, 10.041416140107565, 13.69890554720122, 10.07982669504708, 14.56351793571835, 3.5386890019903396, 11.305268903618268, 12.234268515829326, 10.643717173667637, 10.354643599323905, 4.240945731936542, 11.85036498503348, 19.12997350337322, 11.352669058900357, 12.323530018519545, 10.533901647435368, 18.62870814038871, 14.231742213490762, 11.966233581578969, 4.58668585319393, 13.184053305448325, 12.564828943905898, 2.4275878462260385, 13.850797185982646, 13.319112718244236, 12.507593389148953, 9.054877588305335, 10.948755634042763, 14.9761575824687], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.69257213497394, -264.3699831763988, -1231.5661192586322, -137.44590151579501, -326.4704239760289, -237.09091583654464, -435.0343927645022, -63.840241925493075, -375.0874973085241, -347.6478410026212, -255.97300766846013, -168.67876864328474, -64.13398923964547, -285.54860609512525, -852.2857990995105, -295.7390947742923, -287.0738874630836, -123.8225364872277, -658.2874936578736, -695.2887198884766, -301.3861535566096, -65.8540156398235, -440.8425360463657, -249.06357793658634, -59.02202679068972, -420.48381090834494, -303.4174461265524, -374.60906017272805, -245.05866717850427, -437.56803951386826, -679.332279182862], + "butteraugli": [23.81824965737793, 27.85936778679969, 45.20511532510648, 26.847037899900418, 25.223714663488696, 21.956908224020264, 39.24676064452671, 13.228263741371308, 21.589954971309222, 44.20559090364031, 21.53573344418942, 27.36053698423733, 21.850071175894822, 22.13560469380995, 37.69718903107378, 28.93924377308336, 31.63007750147449, 48.519471857733684, 49.48243108529433, 25.745524842611786, 39.94534242155819, 16.323330120739268, 22.38386188731938, 25.59207998225412, 9.76239317926504, 44.75633885626322, 37.1957088053602, 39.22927585833277, 39.333079477406955, 37.78458073377545, 33.5960605506696], + "dssim": [0.30444324274470747, 0.30528943403583575, 0.46394997620751066, 0.1576113044289404, 0.3350411638026558, 0.23159525869683123, 0.2190818639947918, 0.08463041132588334, 0.40862676802992065, 0.2465676201006743, 0.39356559647449113, 0.247653222000144, 0.1516902022589421, 0.2584270559951142, 0.3664006565393492, 0.197934651965069, 0.22966139961911614, 0.14655800988059003, 0.33350523319747927, 0.3686328754820176, 0.22225769829685343, 0.14944645848554794, 0.29399198569579377, 0.23747746813798737, 0.09983959759629685, 0.28259880489304323, 0.23199237679665818, 0.31117418442625067, 0.2229595782194218, 0.3250029857990322, 0.3598572038635781] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L19@4 C6@3", + "tune": "l1=19:4 c=6:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.776014504486732, 9.396455198920494, 26.166661623361254, 11.221954341669583, 13.95935092652041, 10.51263390369127, 14.916407602047487, 3.8956262618359196, 11.414922133693548, 12.651849994951462, 11.280522373086745, 10.92419901754221, 4.210537019106085, 12.723082330046312, 19.515021380252122, 11.411808282920534, 12.980793774753181, 11.721124632468488, 19.16887296175175, 14.210460951578916, 12.905414935773846, 4.781214648718981, 13.621276853624158, 13.086598506480753, 2.386244763017709, 14.32773465991485, 13.901584414941468, 13.747882789270575, 10.268129218833149, 11.60918139311934, 15.849270243373518], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.98065393566714, -273.3346190723461, -1232.7515999669945, -210.38248116946244, -326.4389073148647, -271.0954016250367, -465.43475675081675, -63.873318003379154, -396.1797420625749, -342.17118679804344, -311.0611128148512, -179.91249752799627, -64.13935327766467, -321.2804659488522, -884.5640563159362, -297.4355312798491, -317.83841509974167, -131.20218775242935, -689.4555510513823, -695.7235661408508, -339.2772453636585, -66.21941947854003, -454.03664154043634, -261.7436777424757, -59.916976573444, -461.87966240365927, -314.08946465501907, -424.2393490453853, -295.2635289812059, -489.14845117356526, -720.2610790596225], + "butteraugli": [25.013198327113415, 27.42705783248822, 45.14939604859702, 31.109843559658184, 25.84659700121607, 23.93882741334745, 41.120903626711645, 13.322643772203955, 22.87931819695711, 46.90301206420071, 25.455376447542125, 28.593152971641327, 22.70702450928349, 23.205988947378007, 37.76986444203275, 29.39043402487221, 31.71020238092608, 52.121130912660725, 49.89983413872886, 25.73022245984102, 40.944595458000514, 16.724683937220053, 22.640075632788996, 26.78062444165941, 10.101199780935383, 48.69999843165882, 40.4459369265887, 44.646248671903855, 39.260928455347134, 37.745064559234386, 35.077604609532], + "dssim": [0.3044273498619994, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46448791381267424, 0.16698112678195137, 0.3344582249611492, 0.24863070490083183, 0.2211568959477111, 0.08464748674739392, 0.4087523843747863, 0.25426033824986705, 0.3944772259450307, 0.2513307099814748, 0.15150094593172286, 0.2600049455792901, 0.3678216571540833, 0.1975533551256759, 0.23266201524735813, 0.1523964025012195, 0.33662283088673084, 0.36860540886260296, 0.2245223369436235, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2922778060441086, 0.23787318026562737, 0.10280053230244252, 0.2833021212837312, 0.23307999008545838, 0.31270891298436443, 0.22694115016689026, 0.3321907993520228, 0.35709603108854004] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L18@4 C7@3", + "tune": "l1=18:4 c=7:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.737723607614985, 9.47268167166796, 26.166661623361254, 11.913805188977133, 13.995489919279072, 10.467047929712907, 14.916886413677382, 3.7633510780451136, 11.417101135213134, 12.649783517305666, 11.28008685890894, 10.947009899891338, 4.209224114947281, 12.547747943386469, 19.378879597961646, 11.2519974307491, 12.950570871757353, 11.814792421112031, 19.183618044750347, 14.217885827072896, 12.88255953095724, 4.892132996824956, 13.621276853624158, 12.987886997617949, 2.386244763017709, 14.484523241760856, 14.401286803991953, 13.76862906030372, 10.371671046866625, 11.609009517724589, 15.74775936956847], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.55260782626942, -277.1984564498324, -1232.7515999669945, -233.0722107320267, -326.3964362045932, -270.2565379536795, -468.058759601921, -63.85997743701529, -394.6064212643355, -341.3143825703686, -309.05608332479466, -180.76181617034547, -64.12052800951787, -321.18787973713756, -880.3493480749764, -296.43772713764633, -317.78330668565565, -135.32996640291, -689.903387530626, -695.7057318816572, -340.36949372987647, -66.31159622731866, -454.03664154043634, -262.38670575928523, -59.916976573444, -478.5061951198903, -336.4201637112085, -425.5013103699257, -306.263500515709, -489.18580615854785, -727.699944835037], + "butteraugli": [25.10137629749218, 27.860238666421367, 45.14939604859702, 34.4735306641199, 25.90198989036736, 23.933927499452533, 41.58562355322876, 13.2676386843594, 22.631414908721453, 47.162107890917575, 26.34036714035682, 28.416234992103238, 23.731047071631725, 23.23558206751456, 37.628996894854694, 29.583067897925616, 31.749336511380747, 51.09736709265602, 49.93567216582667, 25.718156358416426, 42.06861461511286, 17.271979670431964, 22.640075632788996, 27.80735614836566, 10.101199780935383, 48.678444157329835, 44.78363249956587, 44.53932454230202, 38.55052225263403, 37.50867862814071, 34.74050025599721], + "dssim": [0.3043803037672186, 0.3062654600379445, 0.46448791381267424, 0.16803637053270437, 0.33445947739074855, 0.24946524177860424, 0.22096118635412604, 0.08463756270275219, 0.40872761724000634, 0.2539780306186863, 0.3943603181554147, 0.2522210102322947, 0.15142836451855352, 0.25990574774035136, 0.36754635548388104, 0.19753690348384517, 0.23258807001895998, 0.15458189612687057, 0.33692861829802434, 0.36863092310682766, 0.2242222785871939, 0.15022802137519448, 0.2922778060441086, 0.2376066426646785, 0.10280053230244252, 0.28415942248344506, 0.23158479030148482, 0.309760040691864, 0.22800031275141747, 0.33224885362981726, 0.35935888506188196] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L20@4 C5@3", + "tune": "l1=20:4 c=5:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.763777499694099, 9.396455198920494, 26.163630634023374, 11.718952500858634, 14.376511586603778, 10.50565125626405, 14.926043475585937, 3.8956262618359196, 11.37806106310801, 12.579669950813205, 11.295845219911778, 10.883470665690142, 4.201958967473265, 12.756712841356196, 19.465246396157408, 11.725627977772248, 12.93103693625874, 11.680136323938981, 19.674966186130323, 14.209497278557386, 12.522993920466785, 4.781214648718981, 13.610890367388636, 13.200929103574055, 2.3847012336616036, 14.32773465991485, 13.859240176176367, 13.743607406707872, 10.209981534732314, 11.589087597793519, 17.273916371670104], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.5397685873035, -273.3346190723461, -1233.0344957647794, -205.63581902027641, -328.09880469045873, -268.1778734453809, -467.22162430583035, -63.873318003379154, -391.4045530623564, -342.5115968486797, -312.4019575954491, -177.3431176809338, -64.13970064245208, -316.3853752519705, -879.8044804100572, -299.8010529554094, -315.55667136786485, -131.70923804502425, -693.5550479484543, -695.3992222737014, -318.9363904602873, -66.21941947854003, -452.77846378975244, -260.9318404943001, -59.50173685038982, -461.87966240365927, -312.7543317540659, -423.78103387380577, -290.2765093472073, -486.79093276640685, -707.7761923140191], + "butteraugli": [24.183231197959383, 27.42705783248822, 45.13728028941953, 29.88924002135816, 25.73296874776132, 23.73782778543684, 41.239459437748174, 13.322643772203955, 22.86466505978079, 46.351987435827105, 25.593200662957372, 28.65848585141971, 22.609233684284167, 23.387873918264898, 37.930744704645484, 29.34893690556845, 31.693936468964214, 51.02070027246848, 50.10573511652063, 25.743819329170208, 39.437531767845094, 16.724683937220053, 22.608150262120073, 26.95427254248288, 9.782452609010695, 48.69999843165882, 40.0223133580099, 44.37756740755142, 39.33238129244103, 37.81510142526986, 33.779618511246134], + "dssim": [0.3044071898931534, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46449446967788155, 0.1664535154675253, 0.33475315626206414, 0.24715335465403698, 0.2211599708808188, 0.08464748674739392, 0.40871918151208103, 0.24962287276916678, 0.39444804915641424, 0.2509850801200686, 0.15145340862296414, 0.26009516417787426, 0.3678081706230051, 0.19757970284673143, 0.23258796667734782, 0.15108456085360727, 0.33798563675750837, 0.36856592355654916, 0.22431775492802308, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2924699301683229, 0.23814315753749865, 0.10276248559949908, 0.2833021212837312, 0.2323403629701491, 0.312550697530814, 0.22661782867729102, 0.33159837484309584, 0.36065752157655284] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B L26@3 C6@3", + "tune": "l1=26:3 c=6:3", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.789996965818432, 9.509303649426176, 26.161153127790435, 11.46431740841868, 14.112771901805027, 10.675537204791558, 14.924901176198857, 4.132798273545847, 11.161064556207688, 12.585444431321209, 10.80137684616956, 11.398068152845925, 4.354356077638649, 12.592614011912532, 19.27460803376736, 11.714274872027177, 13.027025552935562, 11.690365225910364, 19.344476279281313, 14.215118841825992, 12.791973152638569, 5.048202224259061, 13.566948444464714, 13.238739084537348, 2.5714424107516374, 14.327842978943108, 13.93097011558394, 13.457511989425152, 9.734677450727943, 11.545762936903708, 15.861261525865965], + "ssimulacra2": [-139.91260650385158, -262.7287227341097, -1231.2498772737717, -204.23084378274729, -337.2459129743603, -272.67696204191367, -464.3291028458009, -63.739385366866344, -322.69841333044184, -367.0780490765004, -261.3042583054474, -191.22395859775588, -64.17331651566994, -299.12727121781785, -853.5625088009467, -289.29731580542915, -310.2125619765775, -126.00841663268915, -705.346083454406, -696.0564513913814, -313.0588896367715, -64.93856138318512, -448.0030871049165, -266.6613322232743, -60.94283839504385, -451.4915590332338, -317.94529619184544, -402.5288161743634, -265.5128670608374, -479.2539908760516, -685.6816336854254], + "butteraugli": [24.36636663779278, 26.482703242371286, 45.11276098075425, 29.70951445410692, 27.319681083120248, 23.41508253545705, 40.43483262201002, 13.704636535712373, 21.009755940322236, 45.71407338159412, 22.97824460987492, 34.25671275604575, 20.887311844278702, 22.647115657901818, 38.6948792443415, 29.773884947159967, 39.59396364647787, 47.95119069820807, 48.76551649791154, 25.8074724087554, 40.07216434923981, 16.603445785491036, 22.733871255931316, 28.270599953700966, 10.329642526782338, 46.9679246023609, 44.9334863792325, 43.22105490876914, 66.88336136134964, 36.286545983998046, 33.66955235843966], + "dssim": [0.30441337123768286, 0.30645261905665866, 0.46451907894857075, 0.167680994666691, 0.334804581739622, 0.24928247788441765, 0.2221449889358631, 0.08506675655306378, 0.40686926072516927, 0.25062832885245767, 0.39369336020268575, 0.2532418815702677, 0.15185230762552004, 0.26195621480310993, 0.3664860538367577, 0.2015417984780385, 0.2322627407355664, 0.15543158457309686, 0.3448099440843668, 0.3686105178858582, 0.2227928884320342, 0.15233693502596507, 0.290559086364511, 0.2387675669432946, 0.10558315805174284, 0.2828376629841296, 0.24099235544382996, 0.31547473084890076, 0.22245075564110506, 0.32803653531431054, 0.3594028729910488] + } + }, + { + "label": "compact 21B shipped shape", + "tune": "l1=13:5 c=6:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.802567438375611, 9.631046321527355, 26.163474118916067, 12.319677748049743, 14.078506922571172, 10.715024235912601, 16.123462015439873, 3.979994833417248, 11.64249083513821, 12.548705689722603, 11.365208149257532, 12.629244777699032, 4.366169196396628, 12.839082535919845, 19.768620470124567, 12.038748652049055, 13.744492116082757, 11.946903347514692, 20.133005994238907, 14.231173475994732, 13.710262692960104, 5.098772046502733, 13.669289862371977, 13.32910868985814, 2.544338708499802, 14.856850806554801, 14.991455710461473, 14.334947048701146, 10.499629208584947, 12.635069071605884, 16.02589935897146], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.11668825807146, -277.538037935779, -1232.3883464869562, -287.7669683703606, -343.42610901386, -280.6992703916478, -485.95442432988216, -64.10882143882395, -425.59027862211576, -337.3143940182342, -313.39769386324485, -278.3939673116629, -64.2291528140442, -338.5837681815891, -902.5639015852839, -315.3601183435001, -348.2549669899105, -129.70661149423037, -798.0052965198577, -700.7841460765758, -373.5682445644426, -66.9795550583517, -456.2750061546775, -280.2268781999189, -61.38104875109602, -498.10936398270405, -361.1955145582333, -445.18138863302147, -331.9661747477829, -511.9626779495122, -754.7886967444379], + "butteraugli": [26.28424188615709, 26.794186311051067, 45.15877737141196, 39.656972332610145, 27.005608815392566, 24.2515381179966, 42.9528780358072, 13.311817892462082, 23.006650912031642, 49.72846684290524, 27.32075492910256, 41.307398367695086, 25.900214372550426, 23.452465775501334, 39.50109056150897, 30.060007658867466, 37.91341997588599, 52.430850934275014, 53.21703888018049, 25.879683001884505, 44.019935425907455, 17.05818892090237, 24.017513962037853, 27.750383752325032, 10.061489344702705, 47.26321359687501, 48.71079398373991, 50.67090007635172, 42.062520781530175, 44.07663650448345, 34.85945565711023], + "dssim": [0.30458816711662606, 0.3061548962735391, 0.4640926139631083, 0.17548003663262557, 0.33506890310160065, 0.24855505219115054, 0.22114330953266287, 0.08512382248589095, 0.40986051491472913, 0.24321782073247378, 0.39436426412541803, 0.2533361027886366, 0.15153564096011274, 0.2616800930397559, 0.3684669408321648, 0.19880550809703385, 0.23346877636214464, 0.1530378794109457, 0.3426078452915901, 0.36851731746295624, 0.22635956165902815, 0.15047911203349934, 0.29052563236465645, 0.23851747400832118, 0.11206255577543911, 0.28467502400402367, 0.23586058787509157, 0.3414649713426295, 0.23009212684827413, 0.34248332764723255, 0.36240641679636343] + } + } + ] +} From 6ae7d6f17cdcd736eaf60a02ece5552747ebcbe8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 02:47:23 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 4/9] test(comparison): re-record rd-budget on holdout at the re-measure commit MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Per-image identical to the result it replaces; only the recorded revision moves, to e310475 with the rest of the §6 set. --- tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-holdout.json | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-holdout.json b/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-holdout.json index 5cc3798..7c6c96f 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-holdout.json +++ b/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-holdout.json @@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ "jxl": false }, "provenance": { - "rev": "c070e1794d867bc69f45b79ece0cb3c9bf5abc65", + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", "dirty": false, "dirtyPaths": [], "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", From 2a1b3d243ecb5b1396e261efabce5e5d4754d4fe Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 02:59:40 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 5/9] test(comparison): record rd-budget on the tune split MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit §6 has listed the tune run since round 1, and #73 committed only the holdout one. Recorded from a clean tree at e310475, the re-measure commit, alongside the holdout run: §2's tune figures at ~1.6 kB and §11.14's tune cross-check (8.785 against WebP's 8.944 at ~190 B) come from it. --- tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-tune.json | 993 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 993 insertions(+) create mode 100644 tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-tune.json diff --git a/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-tune.json b/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-tune.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3e76001 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/comparison/results/rd-budget-tune.json @@ -0,0 +1,993 @@ +{ + "schema": 1, + "tool": "rd-budget", + "name": "rd-budget-tune", + "split": "tune", + "settings": { + "budgets": [12, 16, 18, 21, 24, 28, 32, 40, 48, 64, 80, 108, 192, 411, 1623], + "formats": null, + "jxl": false + }, + "provenance": { + "rev": "e3104757d19ea3b0a00f932ab3ec3e7ff937895d", + "dirty": false, + "dirtyPaths": [], + "iqaCli": "iqa-cli 1.2.1", + "config": "tools/comparison/src/rd-budget.ts", + "configSha256": "409364157959084f43f9695e220c3aea3ed4b704641a2b5832c81811f6e158ad", + "binaries": { + "rust/target/release/examples/encode_stdin": "4089c0fadd155363308828968b516999580bae7e53d3d275941d56cb66b14888" + }, + "node": "v22.23.1", + "codecs": { + "aom": "3.9.1", + "archive": "3.7.4", + "cairo": "1.18.0", + "cgif": "0.4.1", + "exif": "0.6.24", + "expat": "2.6.2", + "ffi": "3.4.6", + "fontconfig": "2.15.0", + "freetype": "2.13.2", + "fribidi": "1.0.15", + "glib": "2.81.1", + "harfbuzz": "9.0.0", + "heif": "1.18.2", + "highway": "1.2.0", + "imagequant": "2.4.1", + "lcms": "2.16", + "mozjpeg": "4.1.5", + "pango": "1.54.0", + "pixman": "0.43.4", + "png": "1.6.43", + "proxy-libintl": "0.4", + "rsvg": "2.58.93", + "spng": "0.7.4", + "tiff": "4.6.0", + "vips": "8.15.3", + "webp": "1.4.0", + "xml": "2.13.3", + "zlib-ng": "2.2.1", + "sharp": "0.33.5" + }, + "corpus": [ + { + "name": "chroma-glass-reinforcements", + "sha256": "7dc132db36c390e2be4b2b343a52b09525e24a8cbeb671113bfc4072bed707eb" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-the-old-monochrome", + "sha256": "b6e5db7f2b2225939b08ea4d7de2c0e5ba2fa590a6c1dda7bc682de5c759024b" + }, + { + "name": "chroma-windows-toronto-city", + "sha256": "ebd77b5d88886ee03a4f38be2a87c88ab364beab124270c20a3e52c9a8df1027" + }, + { + "name": "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", + "sha256": "04c47c24d08d713222691350748206f79cbbf40b14ce0833110c13f495b39b40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-andrew-jackson-state", + "sha256": "9756e13cbf24c588ce74fce684c8917d10e63545b057c59bcbbcba22b5fffa08" + }, + { + "name": "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", + "sha256": "bf2a30c065bc167f8d7a364b05412af44b106f780087cda1b196e4d96573c012" + }, + { + "name": "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", + "sha256": "cacedc4705bfd6433849756addb692920b1819db2b187dd8ef3c7922f9d35017" + }, + { + "name": "natural-fishing-the-coast", + "sha256": "7497c8976f59942a24cefbd7fa94e2097ae2504e6f295e4453fa6082384f6fcf" + }, + { + "name": "natural-forest-road-slavne", + "sha256": "54f1fae4f6195bbb1092e5ce87abe946fc691cb17ebfcdcacc916f181936f07d" + }, + { + "name": "natural-hard-rock-cafe", + "sha256": "fe9f5c50d1c5c7439526f45de71e211c7d46b6486c3ddbd469f4be5999c07a62" + }, + { + "name": "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", + "sha256": "8600924344d252eeed2d5bfeb8502c77dedca362bcb4f996f63d94e8b5081b01" + }, + { + "name": "natural-lmen-umland", + "sha256": "1330a32f865b6d3d713336bade56cb97d6b2c77a4d5b4506f309136de8bce3e6" + }, + { + "name": "natural-maidens-tower", + "sha256": "6e2003530320c4b0f943940b9038ce56f80da238811a059fbfe6ce8cc3bb3d40" + }, + { + "name": "natural-mid-1920s-house", + "sha256": "b71252c8ce94143164c38900d53f522d9e987e72eb00dd33384ae1d331bf95ec" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", + "sha256": "10030c1934c2753f6fd77451a45af8a8c94494252e0213df646b08b9d2d2185e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", + "sha256": "26f7412b89e183810ab9fe77142290296d87d3d65e7b7464340cb66a24ed3405" + }, + { + "name": "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", + "sha256": "0ac1145f61da508d18f9b8b79fbb3e5c602c6618f641c88924444c9443dc3940" + }, + { + "name": "natural-obama-center-library", + "sha256": "c849e4ca78b07c8e51f28c9aee920a48a12f9ac04d7eb9e40c2082ccc3cd5195" + }, + { + "name": "natural-pike-place-market", + "sha256": "be45216f8c7cdbf31997ebacce9f297a0e20b3c5b4a5b07b7bc33fc3e674ef0e" + }, + { + "name": "natural-roof-tiles-packed", + "sha256": "7832fed7d5f12a8aec3d36393d9f646b11d601a445d858eb214b916cb04d2688" + }, + { + "name": "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", + "sha256": "7eac9625191027dc861c05e4b548f8fe2fa6b7abc37bcba5b0ac1270116b5c54" + }, + { + "name": "natural-trees-rising-out", + "sha256": "31f10ec471cd35b2467469feac2c75b803e422f32e042c05ae2ac50250b54c18" + }, + { + "name": "night-bas-lica-notre", + "sha256": "accfac7a9eb21d983456dc80936c7797dd3496cd5c0b4d6e387f3605bd3210de" + }, + { + "name": "night-long-island-city", + "sha256": "f009409b13acdd9a1aba85fa81309fe7c29681ab284a029c9cf7552a8f92a591" + }, + { + "name": "night-night-sky-milky", + "sha256": "a84ed4e7b6b81b0deaec580b6def472b74b031300d17712def354847900c7eef" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-lady", + "sha256": "84d789fe7a5ef4f3713c596a5fdb562cdc11a2d0c6c903a13ccc8495f71beba9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", + "sha256": "b42b667d11aaeeca9a2b57c34c1bd5ec502935ad9565da8c4c1ffd12101d80cb" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-imene6", + "sha256": "1c338666388eaba2b821ff9f1e136179bc1ac50f78e13cd13ace9d78ca563fd9" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-mother-and-child", + "sha256": "0edca0e3a38b7670be967cb78c33ce1ed79c5a88e88ec4282970080a9766b8e0" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", + "sha256": "3db3587f2612133fc4859adc0b3097fb833bbe644e2b92617ee8fa60b9166fd4" + }, + { + "name": "portrait-sideshow-bob-love", + "sha256": "1967684f3043484bb14543e2596c8bc94563a59094b510ca55bf2b82527597f0" + } + ] + }, + "imageNames": ["chroma-glass-reinforcements", "chroma-the-old-monochrome", "chroma-windows-toronto-city", "natural-agraulis-vanillae-isla", "natural-andrew-jackson-state", "natural-bird-cherry-ermine", "natural-dish-meatloaf-served", "natural-fishing-the-coast", "natural-forest-road-slavne", "natural-hard-rock-cafe", "natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge", "natural-lmen-umland", "natural-maidens-tower", "natural-mid-1920s-house", "natural-nnov-shcherbinki-produce", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie-2", "natural-nster-westdeutsche-lotterie", "natural-obama-center-library", "natural-pike-place-market", "natural-roof-tiles-packed", "natural-studioarrangement-for-product", "natural-trees-rising-out", "night-bas-lica-notre", "night-long-island-city", "night-night-sky-milky", "portrait-african-lady", "portrait-african-woman-rusinga", "portrait-imene6", "portrait-mother-and-child", "portrait-portrait-femme-tenue", "portrait-sideshow-bob-love"], + "rows": [ + { + "label": "ChromaHash@12B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 12, + "tune": "l1=5:5 c=2:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.893383852142513, 11.240444103364696, 26.188207225691258, 13.441812109896802, 15.8626968232138, 14.016145009758226, 17.480450751645815, 4.974706702018013, 13.068366932864606, 13.223311392367187, 12.116832886076532, 17.252523838154318, 4.662587035967085, 13.64621732383759, 21.113179200020202, 13.890359662657007, 14.946052179832337, 14.302787591323824, 22.296571723707626, 14.26543295973124, 15.860824609112576, 6.456164440194768, 14.174501166761912, 14.285117711012001, 2.981479820648168, 15.894020849999439, 19.262347615158095, 16.378420308234734, 13.223543635569374, 15.588365230225108, 19.27495855299418], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.495388235819, -311.027400651758, -1233.9217244540296, -276.55609338030615, -369.28260854045243, -450.753148929065, -531.8875954333344, -64.21496494670433, -486.44060945401304, -380.6022124653865, -337.97389561604746, -429.67112447754505, -64.2322433565102, -369.170599168908, -964.8754712868315, -353.70686502542264, -381.1523451578761, -159.19648407035965, -877.9138865160644, -709.0118300677468, -410.6153749478725, -69.36739297820708, -468.7565018406825, -306.99780776118615, -62.941793557206836, -526.5115527959788, -521.1899483259962, -526.5161982908114, -394.2255562275659, -585.0910056542061, -806.6058889369908], + "butteraugli": [28.187810807905365, 36.593547798126465, 45.152716520132316, 41.13091380533374, 33.99422256083666, 37.75062000814523, 43.65962106505312, 14.25608907487574, 26.493077919212876, 53.96702243560003, 29.417811156564436, 54.48584851881361, 27.811164435401967, 27.07265490466175, 44.15739134782107, 37.5921991166587, 42.57285394465405, 63.60280132306517, 58.280746070750105, 26.11649858764822, 53.246604849569984, 20.207823593178254, 24.79349640116767, 29.307210354697734, 13.397857580553305, 67.85359155094854, 66.86867505103702, 53.6359234912768, 49.82154972591423, 59.572867212989784, 36.33765597505475], + "dssim": [0.3047059907496753, 0.30890084711403853, 0.46401292345459555, 0.18021136651365488, 0.33635007576006026, 0.2766391335566729, 0.22252148397030208, 0.08552866916673935, 0.410134097814477, 0.263074370326296, 0.39522409028409955, 0.2697861769647737, 0.15159032795869914, 0.2651368269343415, 0.3719288254133256, 0.20022623728826155, 0.23654640688356487, 0.1884616759942867, 0.35856951322254116, 0.3686327766954769, 0.2327884703701461, 0.15249965209587923, 0.29650131603144303, 0.24003635339523305, 0.14489856644520072, 0.2857768381030663, 0.25221209237487496, 0.3637767466424493, 0.2356649893046276, 0.35701843555647805, 0.36561912757448345] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@16B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 16, + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=3:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16, 16], + "ciede2000": [7.805637254336601, 10.235681274550464, 26.174878527452226, 13.001110469694803, 14.879039743576703, 13.193536412231007, 16.29139391609486, 4.65321075207778, 12.24153675515318, 12.698899075241911, 11.419762080280544, 14.89140372984164, 4.617369591654414, 13.268281576154132, 20.13206289790416, 12.249581524281444, 14.207171107464799, 12.63826324626805, 21.194723028605427, 14.252800667383362, 14.682359092832307, 5.5675942627040245, 13.83778980238286, 13.341373856417777, 2.761291812110995, 15.073817920903343, 16.691636316443773, 14.734597597745998, 10.506553996456669, 13.049241802938578, 18.53255535977019], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.78520676249093, -297.81759555772595, -1233.315478119896, -277.38316361747695, -362.10627346718275, -387.57095979305916, -502.6404603924848, -64.17557026182098, -453.66981344707597, -349.7690406002604, -324.2179308395673, -315.41965158254345, -64.22920851496082, -347.6211526455504, -906.6780154029143, -323.58606640424443, -349.0745826342228, -144.30265161742128, -821.3583349670943, -703.4996966153609, -378.6522772924218, -67.43648866179652, -466.00935768356237, -274.88256027767926, -61.74875697832971, -507.9465392871705, -449.13422177181883, -459.71299469228825, -330.35828066811496, -535.6976346247698, -784.8458097664645], + "butteraugli": [26.422028617643424, 28.113023728042545, 45.17545643102403, 39.5389048337588, 29.236486220920227, 32.891362415884764, 42.280619850261495, 13.667142722534578, 24.61367244092648, 50.5480597373322, 31.447155270174875, 50.32385863272821, 25.675316300522038, 23.717386833194485, 39.725499333079114, 31.651890607114137, 37.90202324413578, 56.04772001919846, 55.32170687764248, 25.947210519462214, 48.400846585057, 17.414993687898406, 24.80077857686571, 28.731576320991135, 10.49642766700042, 51.21337827969128, 51.538334057096044, 49.226823144670675, 45.170113658666, 45.51340586316891, 35.4468130349312], + "dssim": [0.3045554260000868, 0.3073746291629319, 0.46403771702481084, 0.18087296337881265, 0.33596103950078926, 0.2698051433288362, 0.2216434802384551, 0.08524370396548742, 0.4097248795847127, 0.25128633068760675, 0.3946860137519754, 0.2679046131469167, 0.15154249841226952, 0.26209170039366403, 0.3687158982774047, 0.19822401542679274, 0.23368410846885707, 0.16189082970113872, 0.3481786719219844, 0.3685080638659375, 0.2292959380164738, 0.15093333842868323, 0.2940815643545034, 0.23776987043484282, 0.11736995962245372, 0.28435335443937926, 0.2423861911663599, 0.34470116905003056, 0.2295547994861551, 0.34548297363524366, 0.3645322465820203] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@18B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 18, + "tune": "l1=10:5 c=5:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18, 18], + "ciede2000": [7.807788640750189, 10.235681274550464, 26.174878527452226, 12.902219421644514, 14.766165452201733, 13.1601430526038, 16.210545480628223, 4.172900336238512, 12.24153675515318, 12.734562443422176, 11.389548412064544, 14.47367134663168, 4.362190590723121, 12.98191592814195, 19.897596201283363, 12.179549556320302, 14.037183435395756, 12.803686860687618, 20.75889073775165, 14.235092188449938, 14.44582301009769, 5.271750268289664, 13.689528362128513, 13.284562634018114, 2.612227906051703, 15.073817920903343, 16.484610609359965, 14.606567659687617, 10.506553996456669, 13.049241802938578, 18.07504634066842], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.9495833794864, -297.81759555772595, -1233.315478119896, -276.8972467796363, -362.5215694739262, -386.7257111479253, -503.0234432714375, -64.1646389974849, -453.66981344707597, -348.5042880062556, -324.3452309552435, -316.4386528918262, -64.22922056656435, -346.4996329838896, -906.6430272311711, -323.88673283008865, -348.35926990535836, -142.56170436307724, -815.9849206028493, -703.6831167473738, -377.04921795139427, -67.16738791375991, -466.5933173976249, -275.01866424562627, -61.72094245108528, -507.9465392871705, -448.4010311972345, -459.29821378147085, -330.35828066811496, -535.6976346247698, -784.3111141532391], + "butteraugli": [26.424131917900628, 28.113023728042545, 45.17545643102403, 39.636889114816206, 29.173135497101185, 32.9045588250492, 42.23905739865179, 13.609795701119284, 24.61367244092648, 50.4835468108872, 31.317278319790677, 49.95830458225033, 25.91079770111533, 23.64393427829687, 39.733439777698585, 31.63736752725576, 38.04697302905288, 55.588207854151335, 55.4317607884736, 25.95303760514611, 48.4556375353985, 17.03289559552928, 24.849475301778728, 28.751840077861562, 10.4734231573145, 51.21337827969128, 51.506586727214824, 49.219724703911595, 45.170113658666, 45.51340586316891, 35.286591829732835], + "dssim": [0.30456853925286576, 0.3073746291629319, 0.46403771702481084, 0.17930062247784145, 0.33597976357480486, 0.270254356868072, 0.22166281830858492, 0.08516871201504417, 0.4097248795847127, 0.24707707265558437, 0.39467372884312657, 0.26432785066879516, 0.15151998932295713, 0.261944876942487, 0.36875209163236755, 0.19820566299243353, 0.23373083879825068, 0.16194042943226378, 0.3465934257833053, 0.3684601925234915, 0.2291964512221638, 0.15095704756686895, 0.2929151920680404, 0.23775989126216285, 0.1167722812606366, 0.28435335443937926, 0.24201244593859744, 0.337691864322727, 0.2295547994861551, 0.34548297363524366, 0.36939169462169996] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@21B", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 21, + "tune": null, + "tier": 0, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [7.776014504486732, 9.396455198920494, 26.166661623361254, 11.221954341669583, 13.95935092652041, 10.51263390369127, 14.916407602047487, 3.8956262618359196, 11.414922133693548, 12.651849994951462, 11.280522373086745, 10.92419901754221, 4.210537019106085, 12.723082330046312, 19.515021380252122, 11.411808282920534, 12.980793774753181, 11.721124632468488, 19.16887296175175, 14.210460951578916, 12.905414935773846, 4.781214648718981, 13.621276853624158, 13.086598506480753, 2.386244763017709, 14.32773465991485, 13.901584414941468, 13.747882789270575, 10.268129218833149, 11.60918139311934, 15.849270243373518], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.98065393566714, -273.3346190723461, -1232.7515999669945, -210.38248116946244, -326.4389073148647, -271.0954016250367, -465.43475675081675, -63.873318003379154, -396.1797420625749, -342.17118679804344, -311.0611128148512, -179.91249752799627, -64.13935327766467, -321.2804659488522, -884.5640563159362, -297.4355312798491, -317.83841509974167, -131.20218775242935, -689.4555510513823, -695.7235661408508, -339.2772453636585, -66.21941947854003, -454.03664154043634, -261.7436777424757, -59.916976573444, -461.87966240365927, -314.08946465501907, -424.2393490453853, -295.2635289812059, -489.14845117356526, -720.2610790596225], + "butteraugli": [25.013198327113415, 27.42705783248822, 45.14939604859702, 31.109843559658184, 25.84659700121607, 23.93882741334745, 41.120903626711645, 13.322643772203955, 22.87931819695711, 46.90301206420071, 25.455376447542125, 28.593152971641327, 22.70702450928349, 23.205988947378007, 37.76986444203275, 29.39043402487221, 31.71020238092608, 52.121130912660725, 49.89983413872886, 25.73022245984102, 40.944595458000514, 16.724683937220053, 22.640075632788996, 26.78062444165941, 10.101199780935383, 48.69999843165882, 40.4459369265887, 44.646248671903855, 39.260928455347134, 37.745064559234386, 35.077604609532], + "dssim": [0.3044273498619994, 0.3058631808273963, 0.46448791381267424, 0.16698112678195137, 0.3344582249611492, 0.24863070490083183, 0.2211568959477111, 0.08464748674739392, 0.4087523843747863, 0.25426033824986705, 0.3944772259450307, 0.2513307099814748, 0.15150094593172286, 0.2600049455792901, 0.3678216571540833, 0.1975533551256759, 0.23266201524735813, 0.1523964025012195, 0.33662283088673084, 0.36860540886260296, 0.2245223369436235, 0.1496626312397356, 0.2922778060441086, 0.23787318026562737, 0.10280053230244252, 0.2833021212837312, 0.23307999008545838, 0.31270891298436443, 0.22694115016689026, 0.3321907993520228, 0.35709603108854004] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@24B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 24, + "tune": "l1=18:5 c=6:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24], + "ciede2000": [7.756160025074615, 9.488730682417886, 26.152966111944117, 12.023007340249013, 13.800375509732584, 10.570717340610342, 14.944149489087032, 3.8315593467240667, 11.43189553071623, 12.512859169378409, 11.262090673347947, 11.143040266097533, 4.141846857609597, 12.66075261817887, 19.524961224608315, 11.618437212158188, 12.907693538139311, 11.580355371129594, 19.160277649677933, 14.21690176491383, 12.847307957063908, 4.743597970899144, 13.51466396543694, 13.063858919684229, 2.3571229885255818, 14.529166117827971, 14.413832753868503, 13.504594537130297, 10.17244252487284, 11.581188505840522, 15.58282758006256], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.26650402119895, -272.49126150586085, -1232.4986573053127, -234.3053254809093, -324.8910389930313, -271.75592386320574, -465.52102724534393, -63.875684120318056, -393.2728942399632, -340.3935156351954, -306.21113969588805, -186.63656701983405, -64.10188910670567, -315.1221263635906, -882.0616309194802, -298.5483873977873, -320.2391277443922, -130.5296473827804, -690.7725881160694, -695.8124908982886, -339.54996994395594, -66.02210667013105, -451.8917776860218, -263.0639459056334, -59.61635986124628, -479.0387722393192, -337.491961285656, -416.79352129670997, -304.9796222517424, -484.36382086289746, -726.9796104490678], + "butteraugli": [24.36423752824217, 27.973349709727724, 45.153113408834336, 35.359211289386856, 25.339002814532837, 23.885431193185244, 41.62548896607172, 13.25782045584406, 22.122848183633426, 46.98922078801582, 26.676583577133584, 30.8770945772789, 23.631230399373646, 23.17581262023953, 37.616784808065965, 29.257516053513502, 31.750987482587732, 51.17329773619863, 49.59761294939897, 25.711217377341768, 41.50721964604994, 17.26073723536275, 22.69591465009803, 27.899022008072695, 9.711864706146459, 46.928499958556806, 44.8374624303533, 45.590093143814606, 37.80365086057043, 37.942137557510286, 34.905688648644905], + "dssim": [0.304410940004601, 0.3060439871573999, 0.46432608313672363, 0.1689201288336944, 0.3344403925958987, 0.24665521068405694, 0.22046214371370104, 0.08471283027142856, 0.40881232483834745, 0.2507204930160972, 0.3942290568122611, 0.2516644994862096, 0.15133245965962888, 0.260081881254441, 0.3676993837968804, 0.19859797093474346, 0.2326268500638753, 0.15170310096475575, 0.33729585034174103, 0.3687209714794467, 0.22435989557894614, 0.15016629953744487, 0.291302866462706, 0.23801233794553728, 0.09813045356828692, 0.28427619135569837, 0.23645986427014432, 0.3144820232360427, 0.2276589232981583, 0.33049429051714174, 0.35837388074575516] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@28B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 28, + "tune": "l1=21:5 c=8:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28, 28], + "ciede2000": [7.7045252655436505, 9.423766895544913, 26.148108151317757, 10.901401624057742, 13.670694246491655, 10.49101147514264, 14.776248772822441, 3.5367225419434236, 11.406598027358745, 12.357787753025171, 11.2259457459951, 10.985698316991561, 4.1454479827365045, 12.146635665117524, 19.277105448796913, 11.397151288343167, 12.680269216400465, 10.677955917111367, 19.01142669848858, 14.212580744165871, 12.26722129465974, 4.631464053277349, 13.657076107945475, 12.772261392483689, 2.3252645685397964, 14.209201281916874, 13.522633780425197, 13.460438455876483, 9.987496076920438, 11.46878336375479, 15.177097873730407], + "ssimulacra2": [-141.65304472456745, -271.20451865658526, -1233.088078476514, -192.90064688149744, -323.46917407136743, -267.57394494271637, -462.14051798767605, -63.83746656429662, -389.20998505263526, -341.0628805432048, -307.89851243330276, -183.63179501284714, -64.11633846555566, -303.3721124087251, -873.3535824417517, -290.8590806467006, -308.4246062098146, -126.28990274137817, -686.7481474830664, -696.2682376401727, -307.61630884924057, -65.89034061797659, -451.02560799540663, -257.4768061463491, -59.26561152079097, -440.8097074208497, -311.6191768508021, -412.1482829537754, -290.2309984674613, -481.0629803347663, -689.2376973188284], + "butteraugli": [23.533783949536627, 27.236446688649348, 45.178358468929105, 28.763044749447502, 25.331599236161026, 23.685906524600682, 41.449443489625345, 13.140455780227251, 22.102172878479067, 46.11081480571401, 24.473441243282235, 30.764532239209142, 23.029427393440915, 22.728370116838757, 37.702904004788444, 29.132440178519847, 31.559576976893613, 50.625292518621485, 49.84960968877963, 25.727057573577763, 40.037156966755866, 16.6859000035287, 22.66751283433864, 27.11918876238967, 9.486549159882165, 45.394837826853234, 39.73075665216193, 44.8269205095606, 38.87285536340465, 36.95929561685649, 33.467952625122294], + "dssim": [0.3043883081214668, 0.3059323367738861, 0.46432731637583985, 0.16476751706244502, 0.33455754824656275, 0.24001219818295821, 0.22081210924931893, 0.08460134977389266, 0.4088860497079169, 0.24408209920186758, 0.39447551554338733, 0.2506420424324729, 0.1511996266699141, 0.2598307977456148, 0.3672870941495794, 0.19868087434144477, 0.23044186961455865, 0.1456186299921431, 0.3360696842064358, 0.36862423087567353, 0.22233839776468628, 0.14878408353275657, 0.29394206800095835, 0.23793001920818446, 0.09866140330846357, 0.2826173507125982, 0.2297388695435978, 0.3132254100781968, 0.2262850844988869, 0.3269363046382241, 0.35769256484913503] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@32B", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 32, + "tune": null, + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32, 32], + "ciede2000": [7.036814247986822, 8.996802373274656, 26.14330149704278, 10.578614675265177, 13.285259391540748, 9.830979030129505, 14.22846157186252, 3.5449224552783187, 11.059960105639565, 12.047640757948082, 10.49975559801947, 10.435962578989535, 4.082385625145311, 11.80729995122937, 18.808933382212373, 10.803899547017984, 12.216467394855112, 9.901297187360173, 18.311781758076318, 14.15700987274767, 12.082277227724957, 4.432622844075262, 12.9592606403314, 13.040251023384975, 2.3227631019831154, 13.533332266463093, 12.929788301906717, 12.277176241411373, 8.465540272078814, 10.95077410731479, 14.882300992375443], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.5325962443, -252.4414132060964, -1230.7177029788236, -182.52028422649676, -316.8761376942083, -239.87106694403724, -450.67516165640484, -63.31284701891687, -332.7903685019995, -341.2390786252118, -252.4415017392709, -184.6099205453085, -64.0592519076614, -282.3527427291605, -828.3093380350354, -247.17588528568274, -280.72665730734684, -120.1069459405957, -644.0904712812222, -694.3614059809267, -307.28790111916857, -64.70038483525613, -414.70771419091466, -257.2866331230767, -59.58038993194074, -396.23129470847454, -273.59718319237317, -372.1105176390649, -213.27123521516648, -438.3670807901947, -648.4726090240871], + "butteraugli": [23.14528201392527, 27.02560129647775, 45.1030524056919, 28.362982103852925, 25.9757699529749, 22.13201443977461, 40.329681537432094, 13.19354059783754, 20.277412323402388, 44.17692163391468, 21.59532446667645, 32.56131909881923, 21.84082134133712, 22.212945246144695, 36.86136205933303, 27.082425314477888, 31.803964886452388, 46.380421188225, 47.973953929349825, 25.757892382455356, 38.7412554096962, 15.72818507821808, 22.30566015065848, 27.22239971965548, 9.756576567127391, 45.234560527842824, 37.90623887646526, 37.53192428357084, 31.494453543021166, 36.851507352398635, 35.13667458667131], + "dssim": [0.3042620966349592, 0.3048715622436494, 0.46436939455788495, 0.16381389902519966, 0.33441199960494017, 0.24060939151837918, 0.21988259101675994, 0.08453685866499788, 0.40697665305280767, 0.24965771535389208, 0.39362231848709167, 0.248070806565383, 0.15104179380493782, 0.2584292259374963, 0.36564350397742884, 0.2012576462899413, 0.22914357328004592, 0.14626885954337315, 0.3286962921916958, 0.36848902375848425, 0.2241020310657813, 0.14968773765587834, 0.2871019543401534, 0.23851142688950194, 0.10332512739852318, 0.2812584544440796, 0.22424208050073086, 0.30344629246116817, 0.2190437586520111, 0.3262539759357569, 0.35779395947682213] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@40B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 40, + "tune": "l1=34:5 c=12:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40, 40], + "ciede2000": [7.268102044040244, 8.9055824502873, 26.117649924707063, 10.296139707111612, 13.393495561541654, 9.725642499056224, 14.277821768921504, 3.264419915073826, 10.810832478394182, 11.485207439009585, 10.390498902858715, 9.92764347839353, 4.038548347890408, 11.455803654910516, 18.77486754020099, 10.685176278182983, 11.939755567708726, 9.611375594016163, 18.17553818097274, 14.173685050193882, 11.68184892356476, 4.098846592025153, 13.423338307829916, 12.351936890386225, 2.210328436480779, 13.296887816007809, 12.686746951900687, 12.261575608926387, 7.769004152877099, 10.066910996411195, 14.26195347688062], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.44003209993105, -244.91585744612087, -1230.1397493629156, -162.40173883774287, -315.06318856407995, -216.12277587296722, -432.9858541760111, -62.789790734223516, -314.12303775663185, -308.1550440907538, -237.31853292441303, -163.40452924997624, -64.03840218199792, -265.5126434878373, -813.4203221204352, -236.0392277060248, -260.2484988902123, -105.8016697079577, -599.1964116065293, -692.9393364315536, -289.2222956373089, -64.33364366312856, -418.0640084714522, -237.18409349049523, -58.870631718992826, -360.92169028766864, -265.8621098958111, -363.04641430011225, -186.1700338130558, -381.35774320746015, -626.9884707379309], + "butteraugli": [21.50101322097859, 27.36945016108614, 45.08669898160331, 27.36613798491734, 24.841892354603214, 21.483785161883915, 38.854537719922845, 13.020283024958474, 19.531301461855872, 36.41643718185145, 21.52978559843881, 29.205355583022783, 21.05111550963051, 21.73470249360949, 37.658002337508854, 26.95073047941487, 31.321460714106326, 45.06447019831392, 46.658182741046765, 25.73190094308832, 37.94619078711231, 15.366433432858296, 21.890945086114428, 26.459171845655387, 9.838838333107484, 39.1345495051978, 36.972052650009886, 37.5633920279651, 31.343531855992495, 35.30291565334368, 33.748624242678275], + "dssim": [0.3043219203531713, 0.3044765561109696, 0.4642728637447452, 0.16083091188264215, 0.3348036503400501, 0.22731831071045744, 0.22017107930611113, 0.08414068821116255, 0.40657566193835576, 0.2656194983592749, 0.39376885370993914, 0.24582750175875484, 0.15108647508184592, 0.25808660707525677, 0.36542882278680766, 0.20166846103424357, 0.22752913867482255, 0.14297832871027055, 0.32747016661031325, 0.36857084178861677, 0.2218567242363791, 0.14922864084517123, 0.2944853648659843, 0.23755821524241277, 0.09261990195227815, 0.2780599496004754, 0.22565131981585962, 0.3062160541916371, 0.2173032116138619, 0.31625920825583564, 0.3590378867270373] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@48B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 48, + "tune": "l1=42:5 c=15:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [6.939310176474939, 8.626663603823694, 26.10343756271202, 9.773750845311696, 12.793709513012395, 9.458317129427375, 13.658789726171435, 3.2195319012305856, 10.57331307117001, 11.24169746197776, 10.17434584301028, 9.491648461485008, 4.016934391209827, 11.420392313936008, 18.488854464065664, 10.498759057937901, 11.491097531577728, 9.189352157781192, 17.56053570732956, 14.138979202987656, 10.7005585168757, 3.9561005430458955, 12.864101111126038, 12.323680594942273, 2.188402035478323, 13.054767242808955, 12.389679471136349, 11.971154957688439, 7.597350830260108, 9.990506352578404, 14.072403335597619], + "ssimulacra2": [-132.9316869423771, -224.93097990248037, -1228.8259461653315, -132.3010277486628, -301.4016733476415, -199.9213442094698, -421.47953482484115, -62.619285579346354, -286.5494121940833, -286.77364916082126, -230.41532353253302, -131.71006693332916, -63.999730124214295, -245.94574456209642, -792.746362428432, -224.98426358061704, -245.46286326813907, -104.00647538624727, -559.001477344553, -663.4488014173941, -225.61946157563227, -64.24867816754741, -401.3744409400638, -232.7920235759077, -57.4723175862363, -332.68371497047434, -253.70774734090622, -333.54252737784384, -184.70244397639863, -368.1310949813351, -594.4357204079887], + "butteraugli": [19.586042826390727, 24.86355990008052, 45.074552382459764, 25.797320127922223, 24.341982973952486, 20.784084889559125, 38.10048566399058, 12.884467440063572, 18.79411815183108, 35.100278672845214, 20.06191287627996, 28.890621445783452, 20.316453086738942, 21.20686938010564, 36.54871524399272, 26.74419670710792, 30.548335357353448, 42.965500409377846, 45.63531701407165, 25.558689181673156, 34.85365759981573, 14.738489173258083, 21.66546178408842, 25.61828853514849, 8.99598082719141, 38.389080345387356, 36.75854221538998, 37.34763021398763, 32.58043887674546, 34.672212515927136, 33.150022318653534], + "dssim": [0.304144426240604, 0.304008223673385, 0.46415099743417865, 0.15860621089756122, 0.33430106816613736, 0.22566092456603454, 0.22107389500048846, 0.08408094348577605, 0.40656779662976333, 0.2666623788160839, 0.3940428031968001, 0.24259426603078715, 0.15129037019850977, 0.25676711107815864, 0.36451030852168953, 0.20126463494850805, 0.22752212802011823, 0.14543432100077974, 0.3281094112002969, 0.36886587843148777, 0.21984186111181664, 0.1484924127533454, 0.28727206127674665, 0.2377036206331608, 0.09377693185337116, 0.2773926222466523, 0.22403261159372817, 0.3051472499469241, 0.21671187467331743, 0.31624909211574415, 0.35802344501748096] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@64B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 64, + "tune": "l1=58:5 c=21:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64], + "ciede2000": [6.679443024231375, 8.206505118513153, 26.077437842944455, 8.838277835764028, 12.347923784351401, 8.940681421221514, 13.340504616395414, 2.9388776151236615, 10.317582317896871, 10.298196972177342, 9.962603994531035, 8.50635908500373, 3.6411553230853055, 10.97821365613106, 17.75824413789839, 10.081459215544834, 11.005499425221586, 8.454872930754272, 16.574146763520524, 14.09350151544774, 10.129952260370677, 3.753245509460731, 12.579958093421576, 11.877491766747113, 2.1249848483691185, 12.248422222448868, 11.670594630722684, 11.257368543788928, 7.32650746789802, 9.30984317670196, 13.657769547562507], + "ssimulacra2": [-120.44678167859706, -189.1237343384695, -1228.2147597440483, -107.35602835219666, -282.4889436360889, -168.03863979687412, -392.10980150327856, -61.689439299173046, -255.21650082097636, -226.90563831090202, -199.3877719691397, -106.76171424452718, -63.845840339733, -227.41294222668648, -698.5152239677536, -195.39808047245407, -216.02890031997202, -81.54009754734943, -450.40937568740856, -640.6215496989165, -192.00376423604712, -64.22871082504543, -373.3902543234087, -195.26356657630947, -56.308387050504905, -262.4059045890233, -220.4715427361731, -272.9486458113121, -171.84326634949406, -311.0761486244207, -543.0124985139697], + "butteraugli": [18.14910969162419, 23.732055140806818, 45.06892327266642, 24.71925445642869, 23.47754573770847, 20.778807769453582, 38.01987782591033, 12.86984280120415, 18.6608788543778, 29.90454586410392, 19.520071389613978, 24.466122839090264, 19.226635542127028, 20.7152804259806, 34.25866294787851, 26.13487362365001, 30.56546820404574, 38.90159975477382, 41.11783836522344, 25.349797305230492, 33.088181150935945, 14.44403866187308, 21.750065945932107, 24.70871407997127, 8.431721183902523, 36.4553948312282, 34.719421001782905, 31.556308248643717, 28.738440443651765, 33.45623145382712, 32.81699243743657], + "dssim": [0.30405499855224993, 0.30245849535006886, 0.4640648898639123, 0.15561822516209328, 0.3349850434030972, 0.22010039368591722, 0.22189453543939575, 0.08379520780147742, 0.405245557964894, 0.2628673274128175, 0.39421782465734523, 0.2362783331614619, 0.15131959337941553, 0.25569913079327167, 0.36178667689639865, 0.20184127418877834, 0.22707084054599047, 0.13590841537698212, 0.32335264303086486, 0.3689243548487615, 0.21964943302889978, 0.14820092413894087, 0.28073819484355, 0.23737538451702084, 0.08814551442808277, 0.27396774411678537, 0.2188725871610797, 0.29988461018048806, 0.21650879007809787, 0.31436704659621606, 0.35641694386268796] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@80B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 80, + "tune": "l1=74:5 c=27:4", + "tier": 1, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [6.607844509393269, 7.689676783386836, 26.032040076664572, 8.263003600848169, 12.201793640174763, 8.66965076051215, 13.139511276944198, 2.8479172686927536, 10.025093877228121, 9.830719366317473, 9.83421597489395, 8.117331821103381, 3.459294123230944, 10.498388550300964, 17.312161791790235, 9.449388713520527, 10.660059019744288, 8.056839657043673, 16.116569572312628, 14.067405457641884, 9.668209544115639, 3.659353180885116, 11.763015712995383, 11.692701729551471, 2.0106892384085207, 11.847539731943193, 10.91872754282017, 10.522336707133459, 6.8853873894015605, 9.15040165701324, 13.01542853808006], + "ssimulacra2": [-114.82147780392876, -156.37838844536185, -1223.96311919245, -97.72689325996117, -266.7267166238987, -143.65321662254757, -364.40541945418283, -60.998871952606976, -206.47827484262297, -203.83601621507358, -178.92360247956043, -90.03958774268457, -63.63197088078482, -198.77501342690584, -620.9434943820424, -154.6898773046288, -203.47812662365573, -75.0562457782145, -378.36410189998026, -632.5309449434559, -170.20649312903294, -64.21809632829078, -329.06730034554914, -174.91888916449795, -52.833269562145915, -227.96177083434486, -175.17622958450045, -227.77702330463592, -143.31211678729727, -293.9769331580411, -465.4359630694113], + "butteraugli": [16.995865221519693, 22.39264679976004, 45.021516598507766, 23.79615873443358, 22.882365717866993, 20.198955489805364, 36.97934280965165, 12.721173379620813, 17.732623812625615, 28.769921345048562, 19.215731037085824, 22.05325902283189, 18.34083845182356, 19.83031222190763, 33.41125154657092, 25.13330367429948, 29.70382360584901, 34.14781574820138, 39.533383320588136, 25.346726339076866, 33.571890914931295, 14.09604181944267, 21.17367035882828, 23.426847482393054, 7.2178987209851, 34.208754464264025, 32.36909494119738, 29.458760022658055, 27.072034810725572, 32.556330074766215, 29.52134357804158], + "dssim": [0.3040486873003875, 0.3011106298480929, 0.4638235684523775, 0.15526016520779945, 0.33546344252430427, 0.21553826747804467, 0.2232657133202413, 0.08379364262179773, 0.4044157777091742, 0.24492770623526927, 0.3936470670164335, 0.23524120924212755, 0.1513852925069507, 0.25546179141529457, 0.36039093152050317, 0.20195482480572396, 0.2264043269377145, 0.1375251314558465, 0.3177728222414453, 0.3691864555213471, 0.2189081432768522, 0.1480159985666918, 0.27853651214083086, 0.23782596913308102, 0.08582130407561478, 0.27282426316585495, 0.21603091464719326, 0.28908598198123425, 0.21411679102279868, 0.31310081765125364, 0.35492057034389685] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@108B", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 108, + "tune": null, + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.460348627730683, 7.406141729320733, 25.93828271794926, 7.721771907969617, 11.611603234963079, 8.19222384581283, 12.128587206342123, 2.787991858730289, 9.835861112034245, 9.179432134465637, 9.721910522905754, 7.946309156635416, 3.310746104779896, 10.00818452008688, 16.513662005282484, 9.056320549141937, 10.168976542833649, 7.326874893788768, 14.99276434239793, 14.051518862761734, 9.169833930389713, 3.5437465236315893, 11.343223535649768, 11.08853353981668, 1.9713466057781046, 10.940516518120177, 10.338508532607511, 9.552798757455742, 6.396827632988628, 8.522547218634148, 12.460331691337952], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.39038246477116, -141.26378717982817, -1213.3990210035383, -82.5124310139935, -213.57867395975074, -119.76020416431749, -255.95306934416647, -59.69348919671569, -187.8632323369846, -156.6067020667124, -163.78643714164008, -85.55060841086765, -62.42178515044719, -176.03451197457963, -486.52996913469497, -139.47205802885406, -158.18575121654806, -68.16309306141989, -268.88217550110573, -618.1881335365836, -144.62207681711635, -64.08167150561934, -285.0746616004951, -122.11403504620318, -50.47071656960571, -167.39644324794557, -141.05986535569016, -144.67825707242122, -116.90550353876279, -211.80337272533825, -389.0563602153415], + "butteraugli": [15.363000088053326, 22.140207956557504, 44.92674237052605, 22.696167708264568, 22.273135801923193, 19.632497071497465, 33.15047179702949, 12.640375636468304, 17.36478545530412, 25.041794385975574, 19.192371669075044, 20.927786916688547, 17.531124819288, 19.49442349952079, 31.521336640512022, 24.658012719014184, 27.66218275167182, 27.79236566090094, 36.44058949370932, 25.237605376728098, 30.35621426147402, 13.869843320365979, 20.281816826239517, 22.0380043904314, 6.692810449981778, 29.632176029877247, 31.74211558873468, 24.71893925917175, 25.720408431806362, 31.26231665184316, 27.724991890155156], + "dssim": [0.3039300594656206, 0.30068419460793383, 0.4634857347467497, 0.15308817799474772, 0.3343923236319388, 0.21053570220492518, 0.22062410242981606, 0.08357883019513207, 0.40395537662844366, 0.22994482425786006, 0.39301903391134946, 0.23415739304865568, 0.15164999540525853, 0.2549507711927276, 0.35907464012548085, 0.20450477236964515, 0.2282961326404485, 0.13511731347751277, 0.31148824553831755, 0.3694858967196917, 0.21939815959732606, 0.14802542771952226, 0.2763480074974578, 0.2369986922374835, 0.0837189415281478, 0.2655606695810029, 0.21077065007893175, 0.28133726607274145, 0.21109877166596108, 0.30299290095002684, 0.35096109481830406] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@192B (resized)", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 192, + "tune": "l1=47:5 c=17:4", + "tier": 2, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193, 193], + "ciede2000": [6.244919603781718, 6.854901402182585, 22.758265404550816, 6.790297439048023, 11.008476008934634, 7.270051902470607, 11.023229756772215, 2.6488822572093986, 9.555972408560446, 8.187621560958533, 9.311872789457182, 7.555672858729924, 3.123627527805082, 9.470814769765942, 15.011598776576681, 8.114655742643201, 9.295158874553982, 6.4605329365739514, 13.300078248192516, 13.839353153156994, 8.221564364795691, 3.4638069953543305, 10.042565526468481, 9.277931379008198, 1.9315646526394612, 9.705256667517759, 9.21264141260899, 8.323525919235609, 5.424349165855769, 7.628343819969231, 11.275588201094449], + "ssimulacra2": [-97.20106324880999, -98.80813163238622, -730.8417922236787, -70.39170908921989, -167.90525299297593, -85.63349641645783, -160.5387212373201, -55.364009261341465, -133.07487971449308, -90.99816948785747, -119.13174115530131, -74.29979489315969, -60.463878686895924, -128.77868333543597, -310.17901179613887, -97.97500877303094, -104.43427798691943, -65.01219980313408, -171.74469729335334, -514.6999087910955, -95.95841166730821, -63.72628200423594, -196.68130719740594, -72.85596061029281, -48.857753695342836, -101.70126085144216, -96.30609156457663, -87.73348440755069, -73.11835388391768, -130.47748879011988, -220.5871159875241], + "butteraugli": [14.516252157686267, 20.145276215876294, 42.04401760352581, 21.553233072030995, 21.801327874483253, 19.129973444333018, 30.325037687417446, 12.327320024811987, 16.537883706362038, 23.619803141754044, 18.29860206925616, 19.552817423454886, 16.31314989248583, 18.771350065723357, 29.86585862536614, 24.000745996812743, 24.570375786934196, 24.34076921889246, 32.11411996052416, 24.97716248656673, 27.038620106186908, 13.27805119823329, 18.317157660857355, 20.269574867049354, 6.383791865178783, 27.096712424388347, 29.77200183143016, 22.599427066365774, 23.826976878102837, 26.02852164289921, 25.668871664073254], + "dssim": [0.30374324553803844, 0.29840245246120534, 0.45042489918721945, 0.1508396247250346, 0.3345590965945817, 0.1972456610195052, 0.2204870775314054, 0.08304218212790815, 0.4020347761968856, 0.20939081658057734, 0.3913760780048687, 0.23304513037278873, 0.15200018376945928, 0.25372518684706047, 0.3536920161991654, 0.20169924341597023, 0.22677449573344222, 0.13153697676383458, 0.3026206308148316, 0.36887286830803945, 0.2218074118765485, 0.14877307005702228, 0.268074962924825, 0.23467254560474649, 0.08189045127743672, 0.26011105816875535, 0.20394143259293562, 0.268115536182836, 0.20281782922043579, 0.2916509519569215, 0.34109424108636444] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@411B", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 411, + "tune": null, + "tier": 3, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411, 411], + "ciede2000": [5.992568117849593, 6.118094915242893, 17.683609567003014, 6.164949519494134, 10.387323247493386, 6.418941273925112, 9.061010218358545, 2.574122718692297, 9.193573764961503, 6.848408241521188, 9.076892476950947, 7.133046472462339, 3.019723944106072, 8.706353407158554, 12.996584622500379, 7.060656042217775, 8.568213801224148, 5.333490327268093, 11.050417517495664, 13.671486987140867, 7.083254699947777, 3.450658506047531, 9.281816312136947, 8.573664254406916, 1.8836329053651748, 8.97498913058221, 8.13169915577608, 6.8835165320569, 4.726244192215543, 6.535950770306044, 10.092334543815866], + "ssimulacra2": [-80.21168281657881, -69.07578593101985, -186.60102968153205, -64.32464225281717, -109.212403903813, -64.80534338488465, -70.74609618949253, -47.82855118876961, -84.94844419339543, -64.37216398685166, -88.04234274821806, -65.48358431996886, -58.189890999520514, -80.9350610288507, -105.62334036319095, -65.20327597358954, -81.29559277251727, -64.22610552874056, -71.5157295141394, -448.33089884977494, -67.06178589447256, -62.934608710595626, -116.70165259085533, -64.64710406138298, -47.5947441633987, -76.25658587008118, -66.24281912483269, -64.49901851800462, -64.36882735428037, -71.20643020747266, -102.37798105552315], + "butteraugli": [13.24147739891796, 18.015873342202692, 31.52152789540297, 19.262350597957138, 21.21737899702937, 17.32545402489334, 25.998306273225534, 11.824349247770229, 15.140861033166772, 18.14324406839519, 16.508107060172588, 17.556291018915232, 14.76926452305672, 17.694307020978652, 24.62186702132046, 21.553037985442174, 22.47182868443792, 23.1265750983011, 25.396075782538052, 24.713759990819344, 22.812207137826945, 12.408636472662508, 16.989954766503995, 17.19739613840439, 5.8377909642816626, 22.284472728239322, 24.29372525356037, 18.745521005011355, 20.060817720318557, 21.445633178419456, 23.365508052094402], + "dssim": [0.303280176049194, 0.29329052007191236, 0.4215395212730095, 0.15072213895174835, 0.33346307458702223, 0.18469270971924728, 0.21690232276610227, 0.08210026250389113, 0.3989874076078871, 0.19179020026499266, 0.38916061127939156, 0.231373051680636, 0.15312284496676587, 0.25105291470980584, 0.3412780288809618, 0.20800646928200073, 0.23049535060025123, 0.12575519383608685, 0.28527390867126756, 0.3694867068986336, 0.21939078767321146, 0.15083818202019672, 0.26111899437910113, 0.23038660364127156, 0.07984276737898627, 0.2551515299445808, 0.19896198450305164, 0.24667043477992007, 0.1934826820324846, 0.271294479382594, 0.32819189002310367] + } + }, + { + "label": "ChromaHash@1623B", + "family": "ChromaHash", + "targetBytes": 1623, + "tune": null, + "tier": 4, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623, 1623], + "ciede2000": [5.885134433195907, 5.280655520916247, 10.946703359552426, 5.571589496272657, 9.80912184853362, 5.398891172959045, 7.139445845959318, 2.569077322750141, 8.604362681517221, 5.636950431719094, 8.577259775431171, 6.976086109757513, 2.920513918762942, 7.693990342932977, 10.121404136275432, 6.327686117839536, 7.997886426022528, 4.763886451678346, 8.50367377328024, 11.012606635349945, 6.133317917802253, 3.489863846768714, 8.558397799247192, 7.886468656181903, 1.8730547590022857, 8.140911071061497, 7.108728236999824, 5.566967153436975, 4.3559308093709115, 5.627758986277434, 8.017084887647908], + "ssimulacra2": [-73.41753424215884, -64.22911460462143, -64.19189072924726, -61.439484987628475, -76.94393292450809, -63.16538401908957, -62.49350796686966, -45.31693817044649, -64.2422420328354, -61.15087139039946, -64.39483758481114, -64.46474667756081, -52.453809988836724, -64.34706252085346, -63.467710942936606, -64.21484021889535, -70.15366208650863, -64.24226220499708, -61.94719101138702, -90.41100973843643, -64.22813046865954, -62.70520053980397, -68.79323412536465, -62.017750786837155, -47.11221373776442, -64.33874331681136, -64.22920030039452, -56.357847356122164, -64.1366343292249, -64.21090968918855, -63.40856630754138], + "butteraugli": [12.488436733592522, 14.554697115173333, 22.573034608196195, 13.572805081950415, 16.79191716539076, 14.179395159445415, 18.46609558225442, 11.071252989888032, 13.124197338470681, 13.248328386050995, 14.055714419427426, 17.527887214433964, 9.93756180847276, 14.412525923241475, 16.42995210589488, 17.81661183269092, 19.160990019447112, 17.10827386418821, 17.093036086894404, 20.473742941757987, 17.831471961681075, 11.37939335228146, 13.992910038931607, 11.84870495904719, 5.809967363483035, 19.66004251286996, 19.23940446906789, 12.666892114739824, 19.956073620314022, 17.51018774299513, 16.203985478553225], + "dssim": [0.3021209453939455, 0.2799544756646061, 0.3313538292498116, 0.15000474072429965, 0.33319609361341573, 0.18246445861757382, 0.20043699073012844, 0.08188897339473988, 0.38361387513709777, 0.17933335968681569, 0.37907353169648245, 0.24774418110288193, 0.1553384717345212, 0.24824105670453384, 0.302338297856379, 0.2204262745253565, 0.24727736493430813, 0.1376980978909696, 0.24899142924380124, 0.33848241913534394, 0.22347077562872109, 0.15713556571476528, 0.26317391277658875, 0.2204004555456523, 0.07974956654565796, 0.25418444054796174, 0.19642773295403754, 0.2162481083309407, 0.1874968456330957, 0.24782975006450414, 0.2654883369049085] + } + }, + { + "label": "ThumbHash", + "family": "ThumbHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [24, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 19, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 19, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 24, 19, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21], + "ciede2000": [8.023151520249044, 10.248415458432106, 26.834639835911943, 12.711244834122319, 14.498740834543723, 11.969255305087371, 14.935018477466592, 4.851257428914367, 12.260180146548992, 12.97774477939248, 10.987368920187665, 13.453275047708884, 4.899856827580701, 13.757764322073553, 20.316121417210244, 12.827501014219122, 14.042645279650046, 14.873833083735198, 21.165840794854667, 14.333709766305622, 14.08599253785729, 5.745878559433417, 13.657916230022765, 13.962285032269454, 3.160568030784885, 15.04919039556728, 15.959802635173288, 15.214569872835684, 11.177381470586525, 12.856085800297073, 17.461187915923936], + "ssimulacra2": [-140.19159878119285, -271.42276476856625, -1223.0182397580402, -206.2574716177163, -329.68982841965897, -315.03893812703717, -461.21545304586766, -64.08114892636772, -436.0551018005766, -381.86747917464356, -271.13422622172016, -208.4142760856305, -64.12374522654758, -316.0240660973967, -878.6425160086153, -312.021718289848, -324.82705173114175, -126.64594235871908, -789.2038048868883, -712.1812655771605, -320.07308431763414, -66.7218076567153, -438.78157973900795, -271.89399135764404, -60.29693676192261, -468.54215659849604, -374.51296396721546, -441.69395884968753, -319.06539446673355, -481.84467889959785, -722.2641017759206], + "butteraugli": [25.042860521733644, 29.727658711967052, 43.13020636762183, 31.359359849701978, 28.081635067627932, 27.06769664754654, 40.707536663291265, 15.037601710647598, 24.56012286266567, 44.61746272415587, 25.42341161262596, 32.35931909097767, 24.24211163275933, 24.268496516915178, 40.09987953009149, 31.39527575428828, 33.71770693865813, 55.36991486338004, 51.37002419619156, 26.464881905752463, 39.45648778617694, 18.645273895193665, 23.399124345400676, 28.281616109076953, 10.96181196721926, 44.21693358842339, 43.21207919076205, 49.029599214993084, 41.1271456563912, 38.572090235307364, 37.101923159566155], + "dssim": [0.3044670527492779, 0.30656431793993355, 0.4673818623602375, 0.16856848671912655, 0.33562856560211385, 0.2617217746476749, 0.22062010061856996, 0.08575160974811386, 0.40972205430778874, 0.2873169212278116, 0.3936513846262957, 0.2523280420241304, 0.1512225799916418, 0.26150421226356024, 0.36846831366590305, 0.1997927322029583, 0.23364900157068824, 0.1698098238822618, 0.35885758709618965, 0.36927556667078854, 0.22634867117961005, 0.14963919298116823, 0.2759205909127168, 0.23931677251716554, 0.12945602514581855, 0.28342452126370044, 0.236788653072679, 0.3699777832476756, 0.22903619892314464, 0.3353584969222374, 0.3593698694297158] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 2x2", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [8.118013818294047, 12.890018927120495, 30.9968118880579, 15.88860752543934, 16.668931041564555, 18.30277423846831, 17.862637373025954, 5.75508156951684, 15.303679595237032, 21.73865292118411, 14.635025603689646, 20.146086455258406, 5.065336002834871, 14.540790462797622, 22.48335069871682, 17.44990235507184, 21.73817022962991, 21.569142743570982, 29.00658620774969, 13.494182160310416, 20.513887903359798, 7.041819170622868, 21.134606495391814, 15.039446283168669, 5.048487720912246, 17.810112867552736, 29.27321039576034, 20.729073202221844, 21.464519555002052, 19.420479358931072, 20.686761226624082], + "ssimulacra2": [-149.95058178957856, -332.85991884435674, -1195.081090598351, -283.9696127137532, -381.3820612235188, -501.97344318838327, -549.4606104323295, -64.22899075697649, -500.0592121321763, -440.42343769774607, -394.43611403186105, -452.8654739980235, -64.23673146675984, -385.7303151355726, -974.0243670710565, -383.523831403225, -411.07302100258323, -199.51079092490102, -955.9045205889788, -710.6782256202115, -409.67968155010124, -70.26100703005591, -523.3590511579399, -309.8874915445759, -64.22684506987761, -563.4160123904489, -586.3415399283717, -613.5537534413767, -418.50770373845626, -642.3016653182253, -828.6205511130049], + "butteraugli": [31.7387469909908, 39.67253973218347, 48.53893867265535, 52.251829255169234, 34.08647514008516, 43.49456847548212, 50.95364632232671, 15.505695996620972, 34.70054577426964, 49.277661600718204, 34.65941398966782, 58.856902061872724, 29.42012429861283, 28.469444841150885, 43.81856573155943, 49.38898067345224, 51.40996661016678, 69.26900376789725, 68.3008050388895, 28.671978655788475, 53.20398112114935, 22.031865654781257, 43.634693188544816, 31.03661956959552, 15.862437131316762, 71.1996721833928, 89.96669128674584, 64.8894063942176, 73.11794466845443, 53.02079725877482, 46.659305553711825], + "dssim": [0.3050103798294035, 0.31119937505284045, 0.47173053247327956, 0.1914977707274374, 0.33692803257410675, 0.3260533399450892, 0.221007460907636, 0.08687729448914833, 0.4130542488324162, 0.34517366817468653, 0.39716386507082146, 0.270927902689755, 0.15166966922089342, 0.273760903164357, 0.3756935982520253, 0.20728068416100276, 0.26924969273378574, 0.210966806076554, 0.37361651157256126, 0.3679151195393384, 0.246475000584419, 0.15448449734151265, 0.3130384837589735, 0.23959528402859714, 0.2199350888884371, 0.28677867510090504, 0.2886597330429935, 0.4045328751080399, 0.2519620070046815, 0.37186411106677, 0.37802670832410257] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 3x3", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22, 22], + "ciede2000": [7.732741901170555, 11.935966108693606, 30.98862549718027, 14.844405605740862, 15.174696446516819, 15.909972792169834, 15.800917141884383, 4.740597906458508, 13.070788749173119, 20.189904416101584, 12.429015152507645, 17.295558219176762, 4.745666772756253, 14.434661778857745, 21.704594949353602, 15.057387833566402, 16.142634566438982, 20.883701738874198, 27.240214234059298, 13.468080208455177, 18.463599485912905, 6.143031070439149, 18.054093889957, 13.88315081437765, 3.6526553625581246, 15.757249730807445, 22.766628302819733, 16.614693926979676, 14.270979223250404, 16.941408320853668, 18.745142027242338], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.40394292316364, -350.9835677020458, -1194.9051028187703, -285.0352224613454, -370.2515938044032, -451.5212763425899, -503.87206544802507, -64.20586284738334, -459.06382576965666, -514.0332232368964, -328.869466901324, -447.04427954320306, -64.23167478714444, -379.72353370934974, -949.2712654398979, -351.6056394677544, -411.0933933174164, -213.92385002072945, -952.8246596698032, -703.173995847317, -447.70583201312195, -67.89251029383149, -495.09576741172214, -279.1845883123092, -64.07005295840477, -527.5111196594404, -535.744868766738, -512.919872953443, -429.83711393979297, -625.5858466399071, -796.7058422638797], + "butteraugli": [29.513801622532117, 38.75400078618565, 48.43581682559142, 51.45598878394933, 32.57823268480117, 37.9888900466106, 44.22845749043706, 14.39057833112994, 27.957582453522534, 45.808472865791764, 31.04438965024596, 45.360035751771825, 28.941282302370443, 27.33133831831211, 41.025507724209795, 42.842448168509414, 39.99319389208954, 64.83882874232432, 65.95488808962153, 28.266472229317145, 51.423527646244004, 20.398244311723403, 35.899190462819476, 29.386037439287378, 13.299984828481096, 49.61928527579787, 69.00674399819765, 49.1835451126449, 52.82332401985921, 48.65620253974904, 42.659626957813536], + "dssim": [0.30458226360097274, 0.312968594397697, 0.47179076107228773, 0.18722560205577915, 0.3361265428762583, 0.31208811204573916, 0.21980118112452524, 0.08579916984305402, 0.4102295807223358, 0.35123779160311486, 0.3947115117374729, 0.27415696821232116, 0.151487744718181, 0.26848130820400096, 0.3737720986233982, 0.20235338062564562, 0.2714878461119643, 0.24131428310616498, 0.36897684495373406, 0.36778314906759246, 0.2455579354310754, 0.15602547677941153, 0.3033280836881507, 0.23781437071591033, 0.17683288109672368, 0.28380914911925714, 0.27212229290275036, 0.3791464848502762, 0.24770316118410185, 0.36110502016774443, 0.37334665730149497] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 4x4", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36, 36], + "ciede2000": [7.737302674040716, 9.838465781441482, 30.998521268586742, 13.656091302539226, 15.019121496359851, 14.32603147366991, 15.688566854616774, 4.708369836414776, 12.760921582908777, 19.013570397242656, 12.299400039739796, 14.49788156852009, 4.796389552187827, 13.643027221566342, 21.195498541900434, 14.457154069246567, 15.671565646008723, 20.001643607459346, 26.440943329202536, 13.440977820202441, 16.713847543124277, 5.712590301668673, 18.019381545315362, 13.61318040594575, 3.3279475222574524, 15.176296118711553, 20.039852534434452, 16.142656036988758, 12.615530717999269, 15.651705919310618, 16.809150598014252], + "ssimulacra2": [-142.67538757967384, -277.4343776131457, -1193.6476811576435, -274.43478258418065, -366.8286273844047, -363.51171706104, -503.3432452778153, -64.15240255868093, -434.9048159035367, -431.04666417814985, -327.32866187147323, -281.4843953828507, -64.23293437076381, -362.4389089555796, -911.6081581862273, -338.27844238152244, -413.81530737246396, -227.96850780170018, -943.2946847907231, -699.042230571277, -421.5325732936816, -67.16616738029307, -483.28768594162455, -265.3233901468242, -62.15458587522153, -498.72228605667203, -510.1328764481601, -533.1779244118405, -374.05802234443934, -564.3967240552438, -770.2145296473122], + "butteraugli": [29.884801864492232, 34.67308037506627, 48.398838597991706, 46.32501989857817, 33.31296286762218, 32.70646751269553, 43.76359414246715, 14.281884599861923, 27.900173882520903, 45.980672914790716, 29.75791889778472, 37.958936653441384, 29.070668244073286, 27.06172413540347, 38.69885496727798, 42.37889276754755, 38.898304598383085, 59.23483640284431, 65.98546627190566, 27.855988024777332, 43.25917428956092, 18.581819687504495, 33.820132628272056, 28.627992962524814, 11.45889621395316, 48.13262082454608, 59.687601420009855, 53.23946170727698, 48.52555113542027, 42.82537568519643, 43.28341797269953], + "dssim": [0.3045578823440023, 0.3060085473499178, 0.4717768972046499, 0.18418863387798973, 0.33625320706946793, 0.30058727221500636, 0.22025117690458412, 0.08576650716506179, 0.40999569699458355, 0.3488641345715394, 0.3945666631042363, 0.26928756939836185, 0.15137712480662335, 0.27171381211719847, 0.37225851594445547, 0.20190259015405548, 0.2675303454651774, 0.237041827423922, 0.36638861002649215, 0.36764991804519553, 0.2374634123736752, 0.15432728038995042, 0.30293496992121316, 0.2375463322675318, 0.1508285090355752, 0.28285401867244053, 0.26380120755064307, 0.3733538783581993, 0.25044156403290374, 0.36437795735807377, 0.37069544127913967] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 5x5", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54, 54], + "ciede2000": [6.983823350350752, 9.442690814120942, 30.992420337702665, 13.316101273637708, 14.393928322597377, 14.443758043978413, 14.842690184796128, 4.441533968921087, 12.18468071174492, 19.366359439203734, 11.82385231061791, 13.338500890962832, 4.324156744617197, 13.106392581532093, 20.684728996838626, 14.133258139656924, 15.147017509624769, 20.272336878641497, 25.82982514001817, 13.419217673058315, 16.43650578513524, 5.420821818695842, 16.95886013250321, 13.430444144630139, 3.221158517965889, 14.878262435647851, 20.24087010022032, 15.66562865837474, 11.823656023847704, 15.009587627520487, 16.528819512409708], + "ssimulacra2": [-138.67085559134662, -275.5801196319793, -1193.1312698329773, -222.44417256728104, -348.23697831700935, -350.4946913028244, -472.7419811448608, -64.01688974936809, -363.87328443213136, -554.8656634173435, -298.86344764615416, -238.84687207819945, -64.03191618761295, -311.9457023548166, -896.9062511667569, -314.1295462220774, -318.652265000878, -262.8531837587991, -843.9019870049799, -694.8430026558372, -383.754958053376, -66.04551441767694, -444.6075788078331, -257.17114185029095, -62.18297974763087, -464.9686683828984, -502.23181158578893, -475.32513726116736, -334.31433940418356, -609.2950056752846, -761.2765943000566], + "butteraugli": [29.289863428571532, 31.443501454296932, 48.250602739342206, 43.28441772060176, 30.233455758347855, 30.28149608800003, 42.05958039910475, 14.129237666918735, 26.052098568222505, 45.671293261343145, 28.785531608120845, 34.547073631586905, 24.97905572206763, 25.29442262522025, 38.47338394366455, 43.354434190146314, 34.61351039777801, 52.94058437804413, 63.13828172409304, 27.739201163051334, 42.58404015539178, 18.186124233717944, 30.676011869817643, 27.572473263248806, 10.737567740859111, 47.31024539933974, 57.73226448512958, 51.02433112137974, 44.59337680414681, 41.41159349764343, 42.15685696603749], + "dssim": [0.304370737889606, 0.3065279375133998, 0.4718058705978551, 0.18251364528971364, 0.3360368345416035, 0.3011541903694007, 0.2193346361339607, 0.08537190593648963, 0.4083325924918297, 0.35546303899216936, 0.3939397919945084, 0.2687944340919429, 0.15076195673854648, 0.2719129503557116, 0.37188074476127364, 0.2014464630145435, 0.2383681048057682, 0.24945081432546856, 0.36678902357416066, 0.3676310380408736, 0.23455451329262655, 0.15421890647826803, 0.30168311216804145, 0.23834978552220337, 0.1493500579410742, 0.28165161129846916, 0.2672179302740839, 0.37228960547060763, 0.2540414946124977, 0.3589170384990432, 0.37096695377618216] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 6x6", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76, 76], + "ciede2000": [6.909320098575036, 9.19103955012955, 30.993695900649122, 12.81824450854902, 14.080775461628045, 14.002974923229882, 14.695815827101342, 4.262915205730189, 12.10717930387055, 19.30607277356943, 11.7517466274413, 13.224123092590869, 4.113906806905443, 12.897592065857735, 19.816324127363036, 13.674973410344112, 15.246464758923059, 20.553793612636962, 25.633968273208225, 13.415780116995014, 15.925773121018372, 5.1915204467570195, 16.965215566158854, 13.280881214784703, 3.221238004114483, 14.430321095911362, 19.25261121199764, 15.392505133877236, 11.611071352892361, 14.911346097862497, 16.091573963236172], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.84820164537197, -257.21265413155186, -1192.3775131586826, -191.7334232252511, -318.6375864657109, -332.27012276523726, -463.8288194838817, -63.57707568263294, -362.71486852120637, -589.562896740818, -288.15535424957466, -230.22130814110756, -63.97417182848838, -301.1371180613013, -835.3068352357503, -270.5806093359811, -333.32092174557664, -256.54170981003904, -798.0955854108558, -695.0660295879172, -378.8591484580651, -64.53641366002472, -441.4805837612396, -242.86060247338366, -61.674649328191975, -437.1868753314295, -454.3077204166484, -414.2921065658404, -334.7669718255341, -572.9578861853691, -733.5824351899898], + "butteraugli": [29.03875380031559, 30.983595641762793, 48.218872486202606, 41.6293724151754, 29.97827841201166, 30.491768253609028, 42.27377423611426, 14.337849148217671, 25.608744430330542, 48.19079213886028, 29.159356974898994, 33.67316891920471, 25.08647692548455, 24.668552855541947, 38.28639450481159, 38.08752306705654, 33.0784095036781, 49.628468521562695, 56.19609218758122, 27.789681837869296, 39.68990941270415, 17.871363837731174, 30.94246173378436, 25.852534994227568, 10.49196321505933, 44.87256802920904, 62.9783182433305, 46.898306391602524, 42.93305230518331, 41.394554634588125, 39.37183999455532], + "dssim": [0.30441362078433565, 0.305774640315177, 0.47178593092838017, 0.1796229288328603, 0.33552573209844017, 0.2946275291791972, 0.22027861531106563, 0.08529140586374262, 0.40818672225992303, 0.3541945890389053, 0.3938572250958229, 0.26917364847285563, 0.15065159243084364, 0.27669756464179807, 0.3705717174748199, 0.20382646415268835, 0.23997008261856306, 0.2484655497893129, 0.36827748548888894, 0.3676088677131151, 0.23719567924565615, 0.15330106067273336, 0.30213828641685825, 0.23789038937419899, 0.1494377639249141, 0.2795053618425898, 0.263630607645873, 0.3686480760700216, 0.254483246959717, 0.35423130047911977, 0.36670934975241887] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 7x7", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102, 102], + "ciede2000": [6.87206490076955, 8.953996974382896, 30.97890278828489, 12.385730462189857, 13.940483209810397, 13.549012525503622, 14.358376275970718, 4.314421851605134, 11.956251315011876, 18.82033994649097, 11.61497282300722, 13.192246848038465, 4.057880386608155, 12.487668414302144, 19.399113281972742, 13.537293221971957, 15.099425855766277, 19.535655830172935, 24.963755398057614, 13.40478625031311, 14.938615278487932, 5.22468888897456, 15.783593396268142, 13.131926240132687, 3.208259771218046, 14.125740759128814, 18.99592495934254, 15.064862693664132, 11.161529963504163, 14.576577552921778, 15.348196107170684], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.30012065814032, -244.56385775867938, -1191.2016152544004, -167.7328255726773, -304.01682086359233, -309.9017258340936, -426.0244244705466, -63.38722053801999, -333.3894302799431, -615.9333900761886, -262.06612544099266, -216.84992983143042, -63.89377511516699, -278.49101112619854, -781.9053810075444, -261.4611736528732, -330.0479107981633, -262.1411537084217, -729.0988878240066, -685.1517761093025, -305.0472762104065, -64.59960646713807, -388.63255665670005, -236.9456258431229, -61.15450917082836, -399.470014201362, -437.4218838851898, -423.5057925628372, -310.8931419436087, -539.7764306629742, -657.6920892772657], + "butteraugli": [28.879461779805727, 30.124599152051502, 48.162136532261066, 42.80998315223889, 29.867509403241286, 29.421063026941663, 40.99712899782215, 14.220388867541864, 24.970474616392565, 45.67054916236776, 27.505134481197654, 31.402972950468996, 23.969920816975712, 22.82677655957218, 36.77350946437506, 37.861735513434155, 32.51798390491154, 48.70572267357008, 55.827254322384796, 27.62412811654994, 37.29158985949982, 17.500921152848225, 29.011719164497304, 25.67020762536573, 10.03345856077071, 43.1717385758238, 60.67033747326625, 45.40093887914251, 41.02850098591312, 38.81413303705711, 37.59490420682858], + "dssim": [0.30443239547116996, 0.30531946559625256, 0.47177811251362306, 0.17470333643322022, 0.3355624753476495, 0.29128793101932593, 0.2196178471052736, 0.08525665987094655, 0.40795072146273337, 0.3533533223496147, 0.3934829856021819, 0.26944631319209456, 0.15057929603396253, 0.26982304995635487, 0.3693412792976756, 0.20349361974697205, 0.24064820137564774, 0.2505059459083089, 0.36409956595677606, 0.36759127223766597, 0.23712202491901496, 0.15336104913887572, 0.2991334657382273, 0.23796076719503984, 0.14568707064507386, 0.27734154108599396, 0.2599347327359839, 0.3669491167684481, 0.2523844856436711, 0.3569718634957889, 0.36494969422906987] + } + }, + { + "label": "BlurHash 8x8", + "family": "BlurHash", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132, 132], + "ciede2000": [6.857926761891357, 8.856736741680526, 30.959041601872748, 12.08137439434102, 13.855771078885056, 13.411289092601459, 14.089594323369495, 4.25802738720951, 11.871479466018183, 16.300451728044344, 11.502130455343105, 12.91031962631057, 4.029713060296897, 12.521959926548648, 19.2300824296526, 13.36033676477694, 14.793291766556372, 19.361099874555475, 24.65582653936594, 13.373396096387095, 14.80412183522249, 5.036928820298175, 15.802418881704615, 13.02771139164443, 3.242044891692571, 13.530293772907516, 18.627707922801672, 14.826823636878395, 10.424786124430328, 14.441931621546747, 14.971234571598764], + "ssimulacra2": [-135.84087557544836, -235.98443020527276, -1187.3097777241435, -153.01887619265503, -294.286884346837, -285.17866118527127, -399.15179017778536, -63.26335541420744, -316.18632436614, -359.2789689371567, -243.48570980475182, -199.47424734391086, -63.892900541036255, -274.6551367526507, -735.9934011305556, -240.70849850358638, -312.9364977940218, -275.5623321103024, -695.3731780920277, -671.3220969881984, -285.5625703725864, -64.24451133314057, -383.1810876287733, -211.3795109996085, -61.32778565482812, -332.548044109791, -379.5468470872794, -374.71872662322136, -293.38304400739423, -528.7809967878668, -606.2513374228429], + "butteraugli": [28.12651536444986, 29.52713833720394, 48.18275142005203, 41.792462234447235, 28.54416359566677, 30.050055918428786, 40.78366374338653, 14.271350609394823, 24.795533427986395, 39.878296619716735, 26.705244585371855, 29.69411016786948, 24.0671807690822, 22.250265456998495, 36.30355386847825, 38.37340538309249, 32.04167432914571, 49.29809022956008, 54.85253277090269, 27.430978602288445, 36.14147169177401, 17.397357612312465, 30.056155740084233, 25.536150610934726, 9.42234682708952, 41.12990964934942, 60.02266496350453, 42.84123862728101, 38.34689605438325, 39.531166513299326, 38.272433611767596], + "dssim": [0.30434440534253004, 0.3059420075294448, 0.47174262792118077, 0.1749989841728738, 0.3354045998769436, 0.29201679732959795, 0.22052271851423116, 0.0854204320277529, 0.40771826161178915, 0.3496779960130276, 0.39355602246802585, 0.27368356569870644, 0.15056170239884237, 0.2718623985653851, 0.3686557168527708, 0.20241900230332582, 0.2395887472805318, 0.25339135632133025, 0.3636286721677702, 0.3674769131851163, 0.23830816308686836, 0.15314519617125716, 0.29974651563951615, 0.23825927443559486, 0.14464076227654016, 0.27608040036196624, 0.2569058871146026, 0.3705656846497, 0.24166593960626093, 0.3564359766756262, 0.36338953063749646] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r8", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [56, 60, 48, 68, 60, 72, 66, 58, 56, 68, 60, 68, 56, 66, 70, 58, 64, 80, 80, 60, 66, 66, 68, 70, 52, 64, 66, 76, 64, 64, 74], + "ciede2000": [8.258231906724609, 9.043338828680845, 26.74022814792636, 12.464727374126756, 15.852661748466632, 11.004077988995283, 15.812089196111616, 7.855398600094192, 11.485947157274985, 13.973155219547989, 11.383861239897906, 14.473227409683375, 6.832009090951657, 14.45571724998681, 20.17819617981451, 13.719737406851031, 13.433896998928308, 13.291488506725445, 20.865063990015585, 14.329477154312078, 13.583009979797872, 6.273633623201161, 14.458332506157683, 15.755614270741496, 2.928617730318323, 13.652663446464055, 15.259837680416682, 14.521033738722759, 8.907274608130175, 10.691087336089701, 16.039171157303766], + "ssimulacra2": [-145.52141076276283, -255.62740623877482, -1215.6101761252316, -184.21728650942492, -326.6115180392727, -255.99252646238097, -437.19651658126804, -64.21340759500862, -387.65795480755094, -290.55454726331254, -261.17645755315823, -179.58460458289352, -64.22733254932717, -305.134029781782, -812.2282366782265, -317.9319527891119, -292.6675557111132, -110.68345730178942, -715.9787238629478, -711.3681061024031, -319.1944005947565, -66.74201674898754, -448.2655145686052, -280.34461413894735, -62.175913064518795, -375.78746361616834, -321.4492654941906, -376.74172047262465, -222.22761019490662, -411.38993145503633, -657.314593224816], + "butteraugli": [23.230281240262382, 29.03074038033831, 43.078299091399536, 29.21706909394176, 25.939547433549425, 24.16499035778251, 40.668421281826205, 15.856696919407364, 23.321083310754016, 35.959457127760885, 22.614785382477976, 27.895502694829798, 24.67271813468795, 23.913783034283927, 38.649444842001344, 34.97129312546557, 34.913998764948566, 45.04027883815428, 47.092855029328064, 26.207611072781436, 43.17904113016925, 19.811872486339094, 23.90397946006217, 27.92808146028979, 11.609709630119049, 41.51028160829635, 41.305336041046395, 38.297905028979244, 49.47260641078609, 34.028615564561655, 35.77154002539296], + "dssim": [0.3045660436655685, 0.30493517654396285, 0.46692255465983723, 0.16698306297675675, 0.3349904927359242, 0.2523293914028605, 0.2192372258517477, 0.08669260080315944, 0.40860078287805873, 0.2801171185780319, 0.39375933366482097, 0.25399211297780844, 0.15198588094907772, 0.25988069097323774, 0.3668726809540771, 0.19963912982538895, 0.23257047462897623, 0.15106638148297707, 0.34745469667825235, 0.368586771770382, 0.2266343823382802, 0.1502603222097278, 0.29430423220547886, 0.23978736736387435, 0.13585316722691498, 0.2786733262567186, 0.23067707350279582, 0.33334654991040613, 0.21973278187056772, 0.32560608107359246, 0.3576647551802501] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r12", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [58, 74, 56, 78, 74, 78, 84, 58, 68, 90, 68, 80, 58, 78, 84, 68, 78, 88, 96, 64, 80, 72, 78, 74, 56, 82, 80, 80, 78, 76, 88], + "ciede2000": [7.64824045749366, 8.126722007667489, 26.729920059284247, 10.390773526067932, 14.628717131051276, 10.04275059305206, 13.733525974590114, 6.473305070198358, 10.835603567842613, 12.179735280316402, 10.972919734729404, 11.547764795535281, 5.813736189606362, 13.153485997550858, 19.408294448030055, 11.318814373205019, 12.560066008411544, 13.72776408509156, 18.30780742821659, 14.283821938166229, 11.355401023228271, 6.520861490512746, 13.926777726164026, 14.669811579961019, 2.876131652429834, 12.209659058867608, 14.996019133880402, 11.964664825451303, 7.343665659840226, 9.5075684939769, 15.24783080817546], + "ssimulacra2": [-124.47348438629501, -175.9053612598318, -1214.8186087338686, -126.35374411039695, -299.42123849255336, -212.4984875429318, -281.50265510140423, -64.164678840612, -271.9914360044919, -212.7710369365409, -220.4336936682596, -126.11888369168054, -64.14069230377049, -251.27103553095026, -633.8544954966958, -198.12614977002374, -233.47800898254923, -79.69336289480569, -419.0734708556771, -694.2400481617095, -186.8994325643775, -64.85079565718286, -386.50557534422694, -245.8666676440423, -62.685228600928156, -252.16158180290478, -207.48356219789792, -241.04831332151332, -153.76710479562132, -302.0336919731766, -525.9108070559106], + "butteraugli": [22.18971718816269, 22.339830537537107, 43.16383733436146, 24.847995128794583, 24.864620600515067, 22.156596305915567, 36.81451382865916, 13.851713190519334, 20.206242436583864, 28.485046086843397, 20.62214447267327, 24.723856573285815, 24.070997847139108, 21.782139907144323, 33.455374557767165, 26.304649608259478, 30.866641997063553, 37.36815189232445, 40.25252436040375, 26.203378293197435, 33.1518229014768, 16.200621744256342, 22.328318409570098, 26.16897612014905, 9.306803318290301, 37.241056963676044, 35.729560101055554, 27.683638731644, 30.664567516765853, 30.6779723764141, 33.985556962198864], + "dssim": [0.30422836725944946, 0.30333394036205474, 0.4669294898394769, 0.16132194380813542, 0.33400755509295965, 0.2445523300176739, 0.21819232679816486, 0.08512022042793937, 0.4065582929543591, 0.2662897669271789, 0.3935053704641672, 0.24796665625248437, 0.15161170934836649, 0.2579981909334573, 0.3613288792174614, 0.20011210394265083, 0.227914782382395, 0.1471756281267358, 0.33723052071690796, 0.36856673377452376, 0.21891155165816656, 0.14883178240521627, 0.2926610299597855, 0.23773976278065562, 0.14367256984631038, 0.27129096010148335, 0.22559284992355505, 0.31732376731342726, 0.21502271390812605, 0.31674303098768475, 0.3563575667514399] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r16", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [58, 80, 54, 86, 80, 84, 104, 60, 68, 98, 76, 88, 66, 86, 98, 72, 88, 100, 118, 66, 94, 74, 96, 84, 58, 104, 106, 96, 90, 88, 104], + "ciede2000": [7.612229662949557, 7.57213337792874, 26.847948242411046, 10.041473031408392, 15.229547748545864, 9.563855100804552, 13.429426342172677, 4.2789003733466835, 10.350286307612059, 11.775969695282301, 10.738934977412997, 9.680065373049096, 5.723823314416884, 12.35052332317116, 18.352793351950417, 11.620293249096774, 11.604020292639579, 9.42878975352746, 17.214874121042765, 14.246119937445577, 10.471434403026143, 5.138801877382324, 13.083252472092305, 13.605669126280418, 2.7694045787205153, 10.872846439627404, 11.791464939261937, 11.809851340586457, 6.750423097152592, 8.624851288906097, 13.385138258164721], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.35982595186366, -127.17364416792094, -1212.135945321893, -96.44769493946711, -254.82944763880528, -150.20358079667722, -187.9480222405678, -63.4304007797399, -232.48418817972322, -160.2275793482287, -188.15782599313297, -85.6616879941171, -64.14198224909438, -211.41914291350724, -500.9417750794329, -182.54580284235442, -148.34519281424292, -66.80998010424946, -299.62518116065553, -677.5930477139543, -138.91180514280614, -64.23623003162379, -294.32755006750335, -161.62085379614768, -58.026005183244905, -160.27134385542774, -141.55725289577208, -161.82364525456597, -111.32508498567745, -213.16540187046462, -377.4542579686545], + "butteraugli": [18.159409975329886, 21.610654644840377, 42.850490610132645, 23.715433816415924, 23.50708541806635, 20.509259100832423, 32.05948570897407, 13.332955194437682, 19.129443949758592, 25.232599500749632, 19.533010637767664, 21.193635089547982, 21.69176581516355, 20.99180018561444, 31.49617881812739, 25.379587757589075, 26.7412565444255, 28.640937147930856, 36.210846090808296, 25.874143025317306, 29.568185350887898, 15.027628614258148, 19.6865583085015, 23.824043160472517, 6.977426738013638, 27.410817242789022, 31.18967899274993, 25.759372779161826, 28.530111796728402, 27.529204356618653, 27.28156675226856], + "dssim": [0.304276615737881, 0.29990800009999175, 0.4674206446671696, 0.16237446270758066, 0.33532512347038146, 0.23295705453122345, 0.2185850164459206, 0.08443534319901502, 0.40507471803079376, 0.25937684835647645, 0.39255602745516416, 0.2487857042002361, 0.1517507889477845, 0.2564549201691997, 0.35896469081546767, 0.2009256054644175, 0.22657971402358085, 0.1407505097270913, 0.32731367237279285, 0.36878550158549206, 0.219628409939715, 0.14881935319465023, 0.28082990285078535, 0.23727520650585143, 0.148225876688647, 0.2615438866530675, 0.22027519127213163, 0.3037167761589088, 0.20972068525798876, 0.3126963698640972, 0.3518533658135208] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r24", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [96, 146, 174, 134, 152, 138, 192, 90, 118, 168, 130, 134, 96, 164, 184, 116, 150, 144, 200, 116, 146, 108, 192, 134, 72, 154, 168, 156, 132, 146, 180], + "ciede2000": [7.457231407463166, 6.770574670542459, 22.24987153330021, 10.249518484534958, 13.542030352454526, 9.051209283953616, 10.764520520247837, 4.51033783324801, 9.959085806616685, 10.198384082937755, 9.92375140041235, 9.386942497710697, 5.0659339980332945, 12.064422523395356, 16.97144601795796, 10.202514721880195, 10.907532537095157, 7.967306649422928, 14.91609215588951, 14.001354396426462, 9.827283030192831, 4.635803200427067, 12.033608477915976, 12.044670582972783, 2.560444565355237, 9.837360880348351, 11.296643138146761, 10.140212384614653, 5.547307186991537, 7.564123997974516, 11.993324846001562], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.066998440319, -90.44971091887294, -487.4451606318901, -72.3848396306276, -197.42933207373073, -105.7019642636684, -85.6245383911749, -62.74718556964726, -177.19896815768072, -92.98295673279137, -133.0923151416741, -75.66923604158177, -63.842274748619275, -157.8321410293242, -302.99150138926706, -100.51018835205485, -106.06253092949217, -64.22911458285432, -138.57415027689467, -648.7705068094674, -91.07340340954602, -64.22905461753152, -208.8067702757039, -102.96451286983955, -59.03438126346455, -103.05021145894077, -90.93494352834765, -100.74125256607283, -77.19001698928818, -126.22805215723577, -229.72096312045272], + "butteraugli": [15.446081156650243, 19.988818426904768, 37.89814039635702, 22.18226755842453, 22.29426843684541, 18.80042266869677, 28.36708470918805, 13.690858565337654, 17.6828912356418, 23.7811781282788, 18.75122303683597, 19.75508547977522, 19.899441063994928, 21.32764543411562, 27.843242663931893, 24.85407732658119, 23.925178690032315, 25.506233682960737, 30.62429458200582, 25.895950254440873, 26.452948399192774, 14.809213731072182, 18.205548439822234, 21.778038886580177, 9.429209390569248, 26.908606408003283, 28.042766439488755, 21.507930511953585, 23.267141278413675, 23.21989868028705, 25.738549304238973], + "dssim": [0.3038649548822522, 0.29812393873887466, 0.45189046401910277, 0.15959264774950577, 0.33292024274393783, 0.22627412049758677, 0.21146775296726955, 0.08462781964028582, 0.4041722316215154, 0.2336534143171271, 0.39130498594429836, 0.23651985399374958, 0.15178695235331646, 0.25331043363893146, 0.35311436892462567, 0.20120569736368227, 0.22956675274002447, 0.13125763071699437, 0.3151012201015694, 0.36877946099519243, 0.21925248170939343, 0.14924914216998814, 0.2745597748642218, 0.23549104275942306, 0.11970465994750851, 0.25926735039401827, 0.20669483460384402, 0.2904049361272223, 0.20325777783545956, 0.30243881397980077, 0.3414375539659802] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r32", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [96, 184, 268, 190, 180, 162, 254, 100, 138, 182, 184, 166, 110, 198, 282, 144, 196, 180, 262, 194, 206, 122, 224, 164, 82, 200, 254, 220, 174, 186, 224], + "ciede2000": [7.622322485571849, 6.206505796550819, 19.281840063523944, 8.44969925008541, 12.044007503006421, 8.355084083767874, 9.60477060365899, 4.607125299438156, 9.586075108536111, 9.24570673255599, 9.683524813294131, 9.108304748764768, 5.471446321668385, 11.392721038529602, 15.765764357093282, 9.881942157915242, 9.769504267815439, 7.26243004588397, 13.693494890847527, 13.689448418714719, 8.688345854212834, 3.8940421029000225, 11.50357290012689, 10.96380583145717, 2.616080571800272, 9.447398351243667, 10.167458792459827, 9.511847771251977, 4.774859627659825, 6.8358025659187245, 11.786693154201483], + "ssimulacra2": [-97.37063196284268, -69.4912978139721, -197.7975007349395, -64.50799384114677, -118.22563114385832, -79.17539686831833, -64.87572837586282, -62.0716144495683, -135.24005607394216, -75.2629727048108, -102.66324679326937, -66.09435303171966, -61.33098515216571, -101.35111879384249, -123.47771109047247, -73.94065109071207, -79.88524496214225, -63.56739030803692, -89.19572849292967, -472.3032341305329, -71.4523448025474, -63.90920432104423, -120.98863631488638, -70.31211507290703, -55.781500581140364, -89.6485419387393, -68.26086300584774, -71.7564682182691, -65.37154597905416, -79.3153367622557, -153.08682588485271], + "butteraugli": [15.616810465962876, 17.82131906162282, 34.23841046169849, 19.46218234963113, 20.133230353344814, 17.623648910792905, 25.70748419729512, 13.07634074416517, 16.965461635932076, 21.051863986732393, 16.975129249602748, 18.453760050288732, 15.893600564485865, 18.370492960752546, 23.48008655588944, 22.116927872830278, 22.974942837280324, 22.9214413129845, 26.26055131625058, 24.827776009963753, 24.323970067745634, 14.43633739969973, 17.376004263389987, 20.392050859916584, 7.479129899970263, 25.791624576805663, 25.997944164094253, 19.701390173965077, 21.34930546454524, 21.211292871034136, 24.54104127021095], + "dssim": [0.3039014063414689, 0.29271978429679824, 0.43464053234451056, 0.15634141733396328, 0.33215708582055814, 0.2176517373483305, 0.2025139552725283, 0.08397595906548933, 0.4013475220760836, 0.21997940859637471, 0.38898821806226225, 0.22866010313599722, 0.15262837276152325, 0.2530432325290699, 0.34339105628870653, 0.20091821334014198, 0.22428500234606202, 0.1315988123062432, 0.2994305074135656, 0.3671933377660501, 0.21699795422080614, 0.1485413148650931, 0.27419713173818583, 0.23206524169299936, 0.10974865746661017, 0.258092168961207, 0.1974933721251429, 0.2769347949026443, 0.19382177192490996, 0.2860206872660058, 0.3355285861827403] + } + }, + { + "label": "lqip-modern r48", + "family": "lqip-modern", + "targetBytes": null, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [172, 296, 528, 298, 312, 272, 382, 126, 248, 266, 290, 260, 144, 328, 446, 260, 316, 216, 420, 458, 280, 150, 426, 270, 96, 328, 390, 330, 286, 320, 422], + "ciede2000": [6.940280918448682, 5.378143064378918, 15.211936912616713, 7.123927409741766, 10.906555502143265, 7.478071590162527, 8.16396071007331, 3.666600115941727, 8.99842773034187, 7.765189925097275, 9.006770577329435, 7.59204473043852, 3.8919625829296236, 9.598891620777023, 13.858445819443014, 7.097617622374664, 8.15215534810862, 5.927716312763176, 11.58086899669775, 12.160369008809646, 7.294218403797638, 3.378649888031443, 9.28912700409991, 9.506664856084567, 2.349294111438859, 8.158063946708374, 8.30509181507801, 7.531107360924761, 3.8382061792598132, 5.6798524213399215, 9.193260878574613], + "ssimulacra2": [-75.27072681203714, -64.23143091243602, -70.45471662352048, -63.739021872003434, -77.94172982303536, -64.24567891170193, -63.32865927190784, -57.011908629900375, -74.00732024218595, -64.2352173328992, -80.18092296708699, -64.19813179887879, -54.4708417357929, -67.23756873553441, -67.19477790955548, -64.10803288384844, -64.48315390081012, -56.26821365181894, -64.40090764018876, -163.70462854002955, -64.23001822751925, -61.431171584936834, -71.58548333242135, -64.32623853966251, -50.483359952066536, -64.78477504689678, -63.69284156289555, -64.22256076439058, -63.09710903314752, -64.24807315225519, -65.38311451020394], + "butteraugli": [13.905183309455495, 15.364964634078278, 26.823325688917123, 16.061442984729684, 18.062115154795823, 15.22086165113709, 20.406003459208566, 11.090418588627776, 15.10701436636323, 15.273883474291983, 15.302061028183536, 15.553736762880163, 13.601526511567792, 15.812391329269573, 19.842073439697234, 18.196819199007248, 18.330496903037574, 17.7302657796628, 21.23163380886861, 21.63773144222181, 19.03411403792974, 12.582809775218081, 15.42476699040194, 16.269970485154523, 6.715623961737999, 21.186832014697416, 18.78314062186553, 15.48450435890102, 16.791184827961715, 17.483750690656503, 18.929841813235782], + "dssim": [0.30155795912289474, 0.2820593232310644, 0.39303334873011647, 0.14716944151490136, 0.3269052196346647, 0.1930179394110148, 0.18362813183219667, 0.08355182851183707, 0.3943581457453199, 0.1937786820386953, 0.38487622473446265, 0.22454420840845685, 0.15159874858779804, 0.24431226114821675, 0.32478917715934996, 0.19207387806654003, 0.21514136628110042, 0.1141151695643961, 0.2719498859894016, 0.3443057277239898, 0.20408728742475307, 0.14651814641416117, 0.25135881377321656, 0.2235855030062438, 0.10417497313906582, 0.24227502440019033, 0.17389651438913645, 0.23989042878552663, 0.17189280008348296, 0.25960828135885095, 0.29330847800174875] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@12B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 12, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [8, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 4, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 8, 4, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [8.36817380995832, 11.984391534746464, 26.735712854073213, 13.355465131131735, 15.109884808803619, 14.941472756445359, 16.490278104621346, 4.920078310247553, 13.757143582421993, 14.541018002145611, 12.696772828246564, 18.260187421487164, 5.385666228127255, 13.770765045428996, 21.482382781284613, 14.456832751748927, 16.137290294174267, 12.724972536344357, 21.79397500160793, 13.950891959025567, 17.81991228506406, 6.550732807083372, 14.545774494522545, 20.15287544525608, 3.6808390362345578, 16.135560694654977, 20.194772975913672, 17.012224132040693, 15.386064098920388, 16.410467631917417, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-150.40906861659954, -320.048332315699, -1221.9960992720025, -268.3184990086536, -358.4517323206083, -434.2045973728282, -515.6299341906481, -64.22583895510556, -493.7508570575993, -368.5090313363644, -349.78954344003347, -481.8898130655266, -64.23590739403386, -365.6967161622225, -971.0920800038832, -354.22668473346, -399.54883784926557, -134.46150500934004, -835.7655667882152, -711.4716011148917, -406.5061828330693, -69.47377490045827, -483.2889889858126, -344.31647439144876, -63.60841024032533, -527.991559588771, -490.80544418380055, -538.4847154709128, -369.8395461625276, -591.3023133757074, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [31.96357159876808, 35.15900919539589, 43.34851140283396, 43.328231718650635, 30.89605728148543, 41.654082001039114, 42.61334132146843, 14.340145929483818, 28.278558260000878, 56.65694163012913, 28.305591356192974, 63.13108062438778, 28.38410226689152, 27.477945873695592, 42.27032819952904, 41.511878982365296, 41.87737107333614, 59.32912830409535, 56.8369286807094, 27.156870387437593, 55.13876258339636, 20.76325565891391, 28.709051585853047, 34.926772371425464, 14.119667061415148, 70.28233503588865, 68.83920869890834, 51.81951300198898, 81.64884808036999, 56.369672311842145, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3051145738583616, 0.3091815196530181, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17556535265259027, 0.33603474413537016, 0.2786216714295473, 0.22113682659380668, 0.08581754313276663, 0.41056333725664707, 0.246666920391386, 0.3956427887577603, 0.27347098018010363, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2636473297865667, 0.37229412025699404, 0.20013336279672922, 0.24019086099003012, 0.1605076721187817, 0.3581565724653528, 0.36868191345081647, 0.23774791663104505, 0.15329113522534527, 0.2977467446892862, 0.24505747826183144, 0.17394826276352426, 0.2854989674298969, 0.25222642341173385, 0.3826215338435534, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3558313136160839, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@16B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 16, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [8, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 8, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [8.36817380995832, 11.984391534746464, 26.735712854073213, 13.355465131131735, 15.109884808803619, 14.941472756445359, 16.490278104621346, 4.920078310247553, 13.757143582421993, 14.541018002145611, 12.696772828246564, 18.260187421487164, 5.385666228127255, 13.770765045428996, 21.482382781284613, 13.447395583406127, 16.137290294174267, 12.724972536344357, 21.79397500160793, 13.950891959025567, 17.81991228506406, 6.550732807083372, 14.545774494522545, 14.13824249587424, 3.6808390362345578, 16.135560694654977, 20.194772975913672, 17.012224132040693, 15.386064098920388, 16.410467631917417, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-150.40906861659954, -320.048332315699, -1221.9960992720025, -268.3184990086536, -358.4517323206083, -434.2045973728282, -515.6299341906481, -64.22583895510556, -493.7508570575993, -368.5090313363644, -349.78954344003347, -481.8898130655266, -64.23590739403386, -365.6967161622225, -971.0920800038832, -351.9115427119369, -399.54883784926557, -134.46150500934004, -835.7655667882152, -711.4716011148917, -406.5061828330693, -69.47377490045827, -483.2889889858126, -304.60889933670217, -63.60841024032533, -527.991559588771, -490.80544418380055, -538.4847154709128, -369.8395461625276, -591.3023133757074, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [31.96357159876808, 35.15900919539589, 43.34851140283396, 43.328231718650635, 30.89605728148543, 41.654082001039114, 42.61334132146843, 14.340145929483818, 28.278558260000878, 56.65694163012913, 28.305591356192974, 63.13108062438778, 28.38410226689152, 27.477945873695592, 42.27032819952904, 46.8111816767883, 41.87737107333614, 59.32912830409535, 56.8369286807094, 27.156870387437593, 55.13876258339636, 20.76325565891391, 28.709051585853047, 30.076884362665293, 14.119667061415148, 70.28233503588865, 68.83920869890834, 51.81951300198898, 81.64884808036999, 56.369672311842145, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3051145738583616, 0.3091815196530181, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17556535265259027, 0.33603474413537016, 0.2786216714295473, 0.22113682659380668, 0.08581754313276663, 0.41056333725664707, 0.246666920391386, 0.3956427887577603, 0.27347098018010363, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2636473297865667, 0.37229412025699404, 0.20021387784361488, 0.24019086099003012, 0.1605076721187817, 0.3581565724653528, 0.36868191345081647, 0.23774791663104505, 0.15329113522534527, 0.2977467446892862, 0.23989648498523192, 0.17394826276352426, 0.2854989674298969, 0.25222642341173385, 0.3826215338435534, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3558313136160839, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@18B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 18, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [18, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 18, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.794167062604058, 11.984391534746464, 26.735712854073213, 13.355465131131735, 15.109884808803619, 14.941472756445359, 16.490278104621346, 4.920078310247553, 13.757143582421993, 14.541018002145611, 12.696772828246564, 18.260187421487164, 5.385666228127255, 13.770765045428996, 21.482382781284613, 13.447395583406127, 16.137290294174267, 12.724972536344357, 21.79397500160793, 13.950891959025567, 17.81991228506406, 6.550732807083372, 13.766086273673773, 14.13824249587424, 3.6808390362345578, 16.135560694654977, 20.194772975913672, 17.012224132040693, 15.386064098920388, 16.410467631917417, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.760588089784, -320.048332315699, -1221.9960992720025, -268.3184990086536, -358.4517323206083, -434.2045973728282, -515.6299341906481, -64.22583895510556, -493.7508570575993, -368.5090313363644, -349.78954344003347, -481.8898130655266, -64.23590739403386, -365.6967161622225, -971.0920800038832, -351.9115427119369, -399.54883784926557, -134.46150500934004, -835.7655667882152, -711.4716011148917, -406.5061828330693, -69.47377490045827, -469.02757360167027, -304.60889933670217, -63.60841024032533, -527.991559588771, -490.80544418380055, -538.4847154709128, -369.8395461625276, -591.3023133757074, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [28.431998415065465, 35.15900919539589, 43.34851140283396, 43.328231718650635, 30.89605728148543, 41.654082001039114, 42.61334132146843, 14.340145929483818, 28.278558260000878, 56.65694163012913, 28.305591356192974, 63.13108062438778, 28.38410226689152, 27.477945873695592, 42.27032819952904, 46.8111816767883, 41.87737107333614, 59.32912830409535, 56.8369286807094, 27.156870387437593, 55.13876258339636, 20.76325565891391, 25.07652036859061, 30.076884362665293, 14.119667061415148, 70.28233503588865, 68.83920869890834, 51.81951300198898, 81.64884808036999, 56.369672311842145, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3047234367804218, 0.3091815196530181, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17556535265259027, 0.33603474413537016, 0.2786216714295473, 0.22113682659380668, 0.08581754313276663, 0.41056333725664707, 0.246666920391386, 0.3956427887577603, 0.27347098018010363, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2636473297865667, 0.37229412025699404, 0.20021387784361488, 0.24019086099003012, 0.1605076721187817, 0.3581565724653528, 0.36868191345081647, 0.23774791663104505, 0.15329113522534527, 0.2916584880884886, 0.23989648498523192, 0.17394826276352426, 0.2854989674298969, 0.25222642341173385, 0.3826215338435534, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3558313136160839, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@21B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 21, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [18, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 18, 16, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.794167062604058, 11.984391534746464, 26.735712854073213, 13.355465131131735, 15.109884808803619, 14.941472756445359, 16.490278104621346, 4.920078310247553, 13.757143582421993, 14.541018002145611, 12.696772828246564, 18.260187421487164, 5.385666228127255, 13.770765045428996, 21.482382781284613, 13.447395583406127, 16.137290294174267, 12.724972536344357, 21.79397500160793, 13.950891959025567, 17.81991228506406, 6.550732807083372, 13.766086273673773, 14.13824249587424, 3.6808390362345578, 16.135560694654977, 20.194772975913672, 17.012224132040693, 15.386064098920388, 16.410467631917417, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.760588089784, -320.048332315699, -1221.9960992720025, -268.3184990086536, -358.4517323206083, -434.2045973728282, -515.6299341906481, -64.22583895510556, -493.7508570575993, -368.5090313363644, -349.78954344003347, -481.8898130655266, -64.23590739403386, -365.6967161622225, -971.0920800038832, -351.9115427119369, -399.54883784926557, -134.46150500934004, -835.7655667882152, -711.4716011148917, -406.5061828330693, -69.47377490045827, -469.02757360167027, -304.60889933670217, -63.60841024032533, -527.991559588771, -490.80544418380055, -538.4847154709128, -369.8395461625276, -591.3023133757074, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [28.431998415065465, 35.15900919539589, 43.34851140283396, 43.328231718650635, 30.89605728148543, 41.654082001039114, 42.61334132146843, 14.340145929483818, 28.278558260000878, 56.65694163012913, 28.305591356192974, 63.13108062438778, 28.38410226689152, 27.477945873695592, 42.27032819952904, 46.8111816767883, 41.87737107333614, 59.32912830409535, 56.8369286807094, 27.156870387437593, 55.13876258339636, 20.76325565891391, 25.07652036859061, 30.076884362665293, 14.119667061415148, 70.28233503588865, 68.83920869890834, 51.81951300198898, 81.64884808036999, 56.369672311842145, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3047234367804218, 0.3091815196530181, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17556535265259027, 0.33603474413537016, 0.2786216714295473, 0.22113682659380668, 0.08581754313276663, 0.41056333725664707, 0.246666920391386, 0.3956427887577603, 0.27347098018010363, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2636473297865667, 0.37229412025699404, 0.20021387784361488, 0.24019086099003012, 0.1605076721187817, 0.3581565724653528, 0.36868191345081647, 0.23774791663104505, 0.15329113522534527, 0.2916584880884886, 0.23989648498523192, 0.17394826276352426, 0.2854989674298969, 0.25222642341173385, 0.3826215338435534, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3558313136160839, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@24B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 24, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [18, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 16, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 18, 16, 24, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.794167062604058, 10.756488369866544, 26.735712854073213, 11.116692204633171, 14.24236716269222, 12.59311669997256, 15.28434085786904, 4.130915092927303, 13.757143582421993, 13.631428350076362, 11.760346635728936, 15.900405303421644, 5.385666228127255, 12.9050128495697, 20.293524515535378, 13.447395583406127, 14.231706598449072, 11.549099644192236, 21.79397500160793, 13.972977880277893, 14.729303478766333, 5.551471845903917, 13.766086273673773, 14.13824249587424, 2.992400546315891, 15.523809325761817, 16.95502898514776, 14.437272768769576, 15.386064098920388, 13.18071534800403, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.760588089784, -299.0889459603176, -1221.9960992720025, -241.36022620480338, -355.30686640829634, -347.9106839878963, -501.64762061340366, -64.17476218389399, -493.7508570575993, -383.1127748374395, -327.3177617423738, -402.0102249484838, -64.23590739403386, -347.40895385972436, -945.1379237072435, -351.9115427119369, -358.7656146726783, -127.39865805095877, -835.7655667882152, -706.0342233724505, -359.61118211808594, -68.0989669843618, -469.02757360167027, -304.60889933670217, -63.169778402949646, -512.0424040642569, -455.93902800975434, -469.6963433871073, -369.8395461625276, -525.9701745958124, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [28.431998415065465, 33.1745463868603, 43.34851140283396, 35.10425277414169, 28.882121148766476, 33.74613479575456, 41.67652262520659, 13.481349335862385, 28.278558260000878, 53.1120143060042, 26.46411124418812, 49.43114225714595, 28.38410226689152, 24.28048224753677, 39.882899948566624, 46.8111816767883, 35.870132785174654, 53.2723492876319, 56.8369286807094, 26.37515159607589, 46.316181315095996, 19.331548819537602, 25.07652036859061, 30.076884362665293, 13.258307546489585, 52.681877222896105, 61.40609679597461, 43.58919377951113, 81.64884808036999, 41.62192550989452, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3047234367804218, 0.30774327322508044, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17006792965945106, 0.33554993517049203, 0.25468499669301925, 0.22165746512865847, 0.08513702955240227, 0.41056333725664707, 0.24847774680619528, 0.39467290645519504, 0.26738334857556467, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2603184094413181, 0.3707128568318093, 0.20021387784361488, 0.2360768873235366, 0.1548861757725047, 0.3581565724653528, 0.3684625615048053, 0.22705891796433125, 0.14996238681750756, 0.2916584880884886, 0.23989648498523192, 0.16090616378854267, 0.28454740894387187, 0.2433170893477969, 0.3360945277974614, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3396573546911912, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@28B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 28, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [18, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 16, 24, 24, 12, 24, 24, 24, 18, 16, 24, 24, 24, 24, 12, 24, 12], + "ciede2000": [7.794167062604058, 10.756488369866544, 26.735712854073213, 11.116692204633171, 14.24236716269222, 12.59311669997256, 15.28434085786904, 4.130915092927303, 13.757143582421993, 13.631428350076362, 11.760346635728936, 15.900405303421644, 5.385666228127255, 12.9050128495697, 20.293524515535378, 13.447395583406127, 14.231706598449072, 11.549099644192236, 21.79397500160793, 13.972977880277893, 14.729303478766333, 5.551471845903917, 13.766086273673773, 14.13824249587424, 2.992400546315891, 15.523809325761817, 16.95502898514776, 14.437272768769576, 15.386064098920388, 13.18071534800403, 18.788784898939525], + "ssimulacra2": [-144.760588089784, -299.0889459603176, -1221.9960992720025, -241.36022620480338, -355.30686640829634, -347.9106839878963, -501.64762061340366, -64.17476218389399, -493.7508570575993, -383.1127748374395, -327.3177617423738, -402.0102249484838, -64.23590739403386, -347.40895385972436, -945.1379237072435, -351.9115427119369, -358.7656146726783, -127.39865805095877, -835.7655667882152, -706.0342233724505, -359.61118211808594, -68.0989669843618, -469.02757360167027, -304.60889933670217, -63.169778402949646, -512.0424040642569, -455.93902800975434, -469.6963433871073, -369.8395461625276, -525.9701745958124, -800.2480753532312], + "butteraugli": [28.431998415065465, 33.1745463868603, 43.34851140283396, 35.10425277414169, 28.882121148766476, 33.74613479575456, 41.67652262520659, 13.481349335862385, 28.278558260000878, 53.1120143060042, 26.46411124418812, 49.43114225714595, 28.38410226689152, 24.28048224753677, 39.882899948566624, 46.8111816767883, 35.870132785174654, 53.2723492876319, 56.8369286807094, 26.37515159607589, 46.316181315095996, 19.331548819537602, 25.07652036859061, 30.076884362665293, 13.258307546489585, 52.681877222896105, 61.40609679597461, 43.58919377951113, 81.64884808036999, 41.62192550989452, 36.68491610819843], + "dssim": [0.3047234367804218, 0.30774327322508044, 0.4665351152819519, 0.17006792965945106, 0.33554993517049203, 0.25468499669301925, 0.22165746512865847, 0.08513702955240227, 0.41056333725664707, 0.24847774680619528, 0.39467290645519504, 0.26738334857556467, 0.15168552062640445, 0.2603184094413181, 0.3707128568318093, 0.20021387784361488, 0.2360768873235366, 0.1548861757725047, 0.3581565724653528, 0.3684625615048053, 0.22705891796433125, 0.14996238681750756, 0.2916584880884886, 0.23989648498523192, 0.16090616378854267, 0.28454740894387187, 0.2433170893477969, 0.3360945277974614, 0.23781218521145808, 0.3396573546911912, 0.3747430401547963] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@32B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 32, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 24, 30, 24, 24, 24, 24, 24, 30, 24, 24, 24, 30, 24, 24, 30, 30, 24, 30, 24, 24, 24, 32, 16, 24, 30, 24, 30, 30, 30, 30], + "ciede2000": [7.731611324088013, 10.756488369866544, 26.807702272748973, 11.116692204633171, 14.24236716269222, 12.59311669997256, 15.28434085786904, 4.130915092927303, 11.897743684913745, 13.631428350076362, 11.760346635728936, 15.900405303421644, 4.988184072172402, 12.9050128495697, 20.293524515535378, 12.603637098327209, 13.726965093788179, 11.549099644192236, 19.88285464292511, 13.972977880277893, 14.729303478766333, 5.551471845903917, 13.338810519477015, 14.13824249587424, 2.992400546315891, 15.356297536678031, 16.95502898514776, 14.337774007889976, 10.877826897795456, 12.913021659895865, 15.711463941452678], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.17386219356737, -299.0889459603176, -1222.1162731866561, -241.36022620480338, -355.30686640829634, -347.9106839878963, -501.64762061340366, -64.17476218389399, -402.1466573532919, -383.1127748374395, -327.3177617423738, -402.0102249484838, -64.23521273203562, -347.40895385972436, -945.1379237072435, -335.5975116980776, -340.35459771609084, -127.39865805095877, -774.0608058922966, -706.0342233724505, -359.61118211808594, -68.0989669843618, -458.7220068580755, -304.60889933670217, -63.169778402949646, -511.03805136064534, -455.93902800975434, -468.42965409957674, -319.4966965312148, -505.1792131201162, -732.0833664548018], + "butteraugli": [26.807486408768302, 33.1745463868603, 43.38630033821423, 35.10425277414169, 28.882121148766476, 33.74613479575456, 41.67652262520659, 13.481349335862385, 22.73845812299915, 53.1120143060042, 26.46411124418812, 49.43114225714595, 27.17996981009445, 24.28048224753677, 39.882899948566624, 35.83234078658504, 35.70906626427603, 53.2723492876319, 52.08388494932967, 26.37515159607589, 46.316181315095996, 19.331548819537602, 23.839539332822657, 30.076884362665293, 13.258307546489585, 54.831768035623014, 61.40609679597461, 43.671762118479705, 60.049337787358525, 39.59046900907432, 34.69750615095253], + "dssim": [0.30460432596903875, 0.30774327322508044, 0.4664302069767615, 0.17006792965945106, 0.33554993517049203, 0.25468499669301925, 0.22165746512865847, 0.08513702955240227, 0.40876707502289505, 0.24847774680619528, 0.39467290645519504, 0.26738334857556467, 0.1517285563247095, 0.2603184094413181, 0.3707128568318093, 0.198763132305675, 0.232707449553946, 0.1548861757725047, 0.34469490157736715, 0.3684625615048053, 0.22705891796433125, 0.14996238681750756, 0.2927557179117555, 0.23989648498523192, 0.16090616378854267, 0.28471582767104986, 0.2433170893477969, 0.33344482721414026, 0.2292066448714048, 0.33690883987729786, 0.37128518662073273] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@40B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 40, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 40, 30, 24, 40, 24, 40, 24, 30, 40, 40, 24, 30, 40, 40, 30, 30, 24, 30, 40, 24, 24, 32, 36, 24, 30, 24, 30, 30, 30, 30], + "ciede2000": [7.731611324088013, 9.94597863296912, 26.807702272748973, 11.116692204633171, 13.418747993311738, 12.59311669997256, 14.487255301050217, 4.130915092927303, 11.897743684913745, 12.915144635764825, 11.020334892990773, 15.900405303421644, 4.988184072172402, 12.045875440337383, 19.750317245826658, 12.603637098327209, 13.726965093788179, 11.549099644192236, 19.88285464292511, 13.927710153156447, 14.729303478766333, 5.551471845903917, 13.338810519477015, 12.859032684553107, 2.992400546315891, 15.356297536678031, 16.95502898514776, 14.337774007889976, 10.877826897795456, 12.913021659895865, 15.711463941452678], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.17386219356737, -285.2550585121762, -1222.1162731866561, -241.36022620480338, -347.66831360849676, -347.9106839878963, -466.0369893547421, -64.17476218389399, -402.1466573532919, -337.8969043255398, -286.37701481072986, -402.0102249484838, -64.23521273203562, -325.4015140411838, -909.6818282331112, -335.5975116980776, -340.35459771609084, -127.39865805095877, -774.0608058922966, -698.8138209901115, -359.61118211808594, -68.0989669843618, -458.7220068580755, -259.658323630969, -63.169778402949646, -511.03805136064534, -455.93902800975434, -468.42965409957674, -319.4966965312148, -505.1792131201162, -732.0833664548018], + "butteraugli": [26.807486408768302, 29.827990804109323, 43.38630033821423, 35.10425277414169, 28.892550015817864, 33.74613479575456, 40.34179550748109, 13.481349335862385, 22.73845812299915, 47.11778093438872, 26.41569650519592, 49.43114225714595, 27.17996981009445, 23.542443225185533, 39.12749658626388, 35.83234078658504, 35.70906626427603, 53.2723492876319, 52.08388494932967, 26.168331657580875, 46.316181315095996, 19.331548819537602, 23.839539332822657, 26.181212324066113, 13.258307546489585, 54.831768035623014, 61.40609679597461, 43.671762118479705, 60.049337787358525, 39.59046900907432, 34.69750615095253], + "dssim": [0.30460432596903875, 0.30613875053015505, 0.4664302069767615, 0.17006792965945106, 0.33553113361404174, 0.25468499669301925, 0.2192989906393369, 0.08513702955240227, 0.40876707502289505, 0.23828328851846048, 0.39374032467681025, 0.26738334857556467, 0.1517285563247095, 0.25945676845925336, 0.3689170694260084, 0.198763132305675, 0.232707449553946, 0.1548861757725047, 0.34469490157736715, 0.36839624141166805, 0.22705891796433125, 0.14996238681750756, 0.2927557179117555, 0.23795498288168843, 0.16090616378854267, 0.28471582767104986, 0.2433170893477969, 0.33344482721414026, 0.2292066448714048, 0.33690883987729786, 0.37128518662073273] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@48B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 48, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [32, 40, 48, 48, 40, 48, 40, 48, 48, 40, 40, 48, 48, 40, 40, 30, 48, 48, 48, 40, 48, 48, 32, 36, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.731611324088013, 9.94597863296912, 26.864787233284094, 9.957316435772102, 13.418747993311738, 10.645412724114395, 14.487255301050217, 3.9237885688088645, 11.873164281243506, 12.915144635764825, 11.020334892990773, 12.123883573581598, 4.676354430963062, 12.045875440337383, 19.750317245826658, 12.603637098327209, 13.144106992502016, 9.809138625835034, 18.94699810685781, 13.927710153156447, 13.35370427337465, 4.751672699479555, 13.338810519477015, 12.859032684553107, 3.020274522445265, 14.494617889045553, 14.166935438505522, 12.763593770643427, 10.054166395542055, 11.889428919144851, 14.705900133486445], + "ssimulacra2": [-143.17386219356737, -285.2550585121762, -1222.3466044558213, -181.16308129361772, -347.66831360849676, -272.301465261129, -466.0369893547421, -63.917665481812605, -412.48840283325615, -337.8969043255398, -286.37701481072986, -245.03810192431797, -64.22938781166471, -325.4015140411838, -909.6818282331112, -335.5975116980776, -317.88418275787126, -110.27696543659033, -739.514093451098, -698.8138209901115, -358.36465990156, -65.5034406466101, -458.7220068580755, -259.658323630969, -61.364288563576, -445.9517513667445, -353.40952112339636, -396.20068068232393, -276.20196634462206, -469.6901260312834, -686.6671599328799], + "butteraugli": [26.807486408768302, 29.827990804109323, 43.339728658333165, 30.67033793193919, 28.892550015817864, 24.397140843271206, 40.34179550748109, 13.210225407039312, 22.145225255104478, 47.11778093438872, 26.41569650519592, 34.559882480424584, 26.624598991148176, 23.542443225185533, 39.12749658626388, 35.83234078658504, 33.343197569922616, 50.32544675185675, 50.5261388662044, 26.168331657580875, 43.565556533571005, 16.820029275810374, 23.839539332822657, 26.181212324066113, 10.083840285375096, 46.62247515083286, 41.43496393310905, 38.23465604831468, 46.22649834336704, 37.13755627125895, 33.16591333808861], + "dssim": [0.30460432596903875, 0.30613875053015505, 0.46657428865903827, 0.16233967622276463, 0.33553113361404174, 0.2475415957873192, 0.2192989906393369, 0.08475174987927464, 0.40957717716024755, 0.23828328851846048, 0.39374032467681025, 0.25504240779891296, 0.15153992573800484, 0.25945676845925336, 0.3689170694260084, 0.198763132305675, 0.23319711602468446, 0.14635350033699185, 0.3444259294919475, 0.36839624141166805, 0.22396389886477308, 0.1483114805834938, 0.2927557179117555, 0.23795498288168843, 0.14272039837700362, 0.2825638651951825, 0.22854820146521748, 0.3121259564838317, 0.22521348757709525, 0.33213227799212874, 0.3653931355280702] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@64B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 64, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [50, 60, 48, 48, 60, 48, 60, 48, 48, 40, 40, 48, 48, 40, 40, 56, 48, 48, 48, 40, 48, 48, 50, 64, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48], + "ciede2000": [7.146225870804935, 9.419378033369966, 26.864787233284094, 9.957316435772102, 12.717792481443034, 10.645412724114395, 14.057309201582221, 3.9237885688088645, 11.873164281243506, 12.915144635764825, 11.020334892990773, 12.123883573581598, 4.676354430963062, 12.045875440337383, 19.750317245826658, 11.745745771469016, 13.144106992502016, 9.809138625835034, 18.94699810685781, 13.927710153156447, 13.35370427337465, 4.751672699479555, 11.853444908552895, 12.117946732651488, 3.020274522445265, 14.494617889045553, 14.166935438505522, 12.763593770643427, 10.054166395542055, 11.889428919144851, 14.705900133486445], + "ssimulacra2": [-137.90236390615277, -266.0774239828086, -1222.3466044558213, -181.16308129361772, -322.7481069765545, -272.301465261129, -435.50759734517237, -63.917665481812605, -412.48840283325615, -337.8969043255398, -286.37701481072986, -245.03810192431797, -64.22938781166471, -325.4015140411838, -909.6818282331112, -297.96301260261305, -317.88418275787126, -110.27696543659033, -739.514093451098, -698.8138209901115, -358.36465990156, -65.5034406466101, -405.4309821149899, -230.3722657065798, -61.364288563576, -445.9517513667445, -353.40952112339636, -396.20068068232393, -276.20196634462206, -469.6901260312834, -686.6671599328799], + "butteraugli": [25.44703422358484, 28.338491278005005, 43.339728658333165, 30.67033793193919, 25.5641478177243, 24.397140843271206, 39.49669087965738, 13.210225407039312, 22.145225255104478, 47.11778093438872, 26.41569650519592, 34.559882480424584, 26.624598991148176, 23.542443225185533, 39.12749658626388, 29.92855785458563, 33.343197569922616, 50.32544675185675, 50.5261388662044, 26.168331657580875, 43.565556533571005, 16.820029275810374, 22.763242887218638, 25.68601846197176, 10.083840285375096, 46.62247515083286, 41.43496393310905, 38.23465604831468, 46.22649834336704, 37.13755627125895, 33.16591333808861], + "dssim": [0.30439959598790867, 0.3052237989137897, 0.46657428865903827, 0.16233967622276463, 0.33475043669170845, 0.2475415957873192, 0.21802867904276485, 0.08475174987927464, 0.40957717716024755, 0.23828328851846048, 0.39374032467681025, 0.25504240779891296, 0.15153992573800484, 0.25945676845925336, 0.3689170694260084, 0.19756273761365067, 0.23319711602468446, 0.14635350033699185, 0.3444259294919475, 0.36839624141166805, 0.22396389886477308, 0.1483114805834938, 0.2771967393435598, 0.237256165168085, 0.14272039837700362, 0.2825638651951825, 0.22854820146521748, 0.3121259564838317, 0.22521348757709525, 0.33213227799212874, 0.3653931355280702] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@80B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 80, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [72, 70, 80, 70, 70, 70, 70, 70, 80, 70, 70, 70, 80, 70, 70, 56, 80, 70, 80, 70, 70, 70, 72, 64, 70, 80, 70, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [7.021219922072678, 9.162358007609374, 26.790540286917967, 9.32677249789699, 12.412938064086822, 9.703502483094839, 13.771311660105605, 3.658399044793065, 11.423563193521572, 11.985346123237415, 10.50696409963725, 9.560060478248943, 4.130706815350984, 11.170182843878267, 18.399550214305076, 11.745745771469016, 11.902096180884609, 9.45150272099619, 18.00769740322444, 13.906048910737498, 12.04416320561022, 4.558020186628285, 11.760376032202084, 12.117946732651488, 2.552572992811054, 13.559081673734052, 12.788228818511206, 11.772709276418372, 8.75068655760106, 10.92395996169785, 13.82782508558486], + "ssimulacra2": [-134.61795290552521, -244.27605487865628, -1220.8558236017402, -149.24567532249745, -305.99365199643626, -222.1322812879082, -410.71901218440973, -63.87425127062767, -356.73996419973554, -335.82528913569865, -255.6913201649789, -143.42633342070482, -64.17322321235679, -272.8320970097044, -803.6105415462537, -297.96301260261305, -263.4800657734454, -97.13865042083455, -659.8162899437102, -694.1515044442333, -304.10843642899124, -66.1880891675687, -391.9561989854162, -230.3722657065798, -59.05010188082966, -368.7993062741882, -294.94729107727574, -339.06633541352005, -211.63286118551667, -408.26539270479594, -609.1510818414571], + "butteraugli": [23.031391823455447, 26.245030723397264, 43.22721570970905, 27.168480120665265, 24.97227067336426, 21.52696351422485, 39.294857930039704, 13.04223076054574, 21.337691092568814, 43.05666632870068, 22.196884567919493, 25.969687658096934, 23.34744340911469, 21.64685984403316, 36.52463209622794, 29.92855785458563, 31.747275219616046, 47.293814033942205, 48.15900320230289, 26.023625231163194, 38.812649389222926, 16.39118723304003, 22.62875109300049, 25.68601846197176, 9.259068883368604, 42.490724614313, 39.91118801575259, 31.714516687107206, 38.843357155922426, 33.529088259099275, 34.25500488052159], + "dssim": [0.304377235059782, 0.30434474801907074, 0.46676532521802383, 0.15785079974653, 0.334737426024007, 0.23746670824719712, 0.21677864912600908, 0.08474410351885098, 0.40837551900881897, 0.22624367526518396, 0.39361823192537454, 0.2413521838259493, 0.15104590746164065, 0.2563401868608699, 0.3659633245070829, 0.19756273761365067, 0.2280708810121192, 0.14210228419851467, 0.3351098543514551, 0.36839090969760047, 0.2205746473827394, 0.14829227653094917, 0.27345325783476904, 0.237256165168085, 0.1327560184779934, 0.27755017466691967, 0.2242070715527426, 0.3042502564436532, 0.21986945798892066, 0.3237295216339884, 0.361225449685564] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@108B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 108, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [98, 96, 108, 108, 96, 108, 96, 108, 80, 96, 96, 108, 108, 96, 96, 90, 108, 108, 108, 96, 108, 108, 72, 100, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108], + "ciede2000": [6.721757420025044, 9.138936981758414, 26.83852975840306, 8.282077848087615, 12.068665051463277, 9.063740872956524, 13.254700040064295, 3.2779688767410544, 11.423563193521572, 10.767007092302629, 10.400361263917908, 8.844449158284887, 3.8662480819545353, 10.693841512396295, 17.81871693809016, 10.684605013929986, 11.345463960745708, 8.853860917839127, 16.6651136575023, 13.897224007999549, 11.010112436654815, 3.8250433835178868, 11.760376032202084, 11.491129733239383, 2.7643682979781383, 13.142469357463384, 11.86562109463925, 11.133688189207295, 8.201048400285796, 10.442673241127086, 13.109013372539957], + "ssimulacra2": [-130.02697164080922, -234.50943549114078, -1219.8189725992913, -111.11900460485214, -284.1758042249177, -182.99148739143516, -402.86707746503913, -62.82080209945633, -356.73996419973554, -251.81592896716415, -247.70322154656515, -126.74390668765173, -63.90533474078518, -250.54184290246405, -755.4191215252663, -238.8179485199148, -227.49605517800063, -86.52324936775545, -516.0994808901712, -685.0189637546844, -237.93583874232462, -64.2687766812725, -391.9561989854162, -183.56492410085013, -59.233189127010576, -332.95175409071476, -249.59612494329815, -288.2733160959765, -174.9900966697731, -364.76331794221755, -555.2475220423763], + "butteraugli": [22.402175389415152, 25.777176904335317, 43.18820294987256, 24.617793278417725, 24.241850284597657, 21.07370821917905, 38.43012312841759, 13.078486077887485, 21.337691092568814, 35.0912292652054, 21.478651556301667, 23.23521518486911, 22.418700361848295, 21.380558265138788, 35.55140067674886, 28.061205504310198, 30.43173401503998, 41.830779649573685, 44.94865012065386, 25.871839868937467, 35.31951575211849, 15.126973132654435, 22.62875109300049, 24.796718524019656, 8.646787295388538, 41.24185266082719, 37.809557591181566, 30.19256927642488, 34.009138602964505, 34.14465392588662, 30.728859708849928], + "dssim": [0.304358636620656, 0.30438255842757467, 0.46680248423407633, 0.15453574103830442, 0.3344827589501119, 0.22848663553060716, 0.21804009730928525, 0.08407057172013738, 0.40837551900881897, 0.21614027256509677, 0.39363797026772035, 0.23688661770088804, 0.15091235480925652, 0.2552701303262551, 0.36390977592966156, 0.1963294128580449, 0.22624039387305767, 0.1393175712174211, 0.32584521823207047, 0.3682383253450112, 0.2191187895101771, 0.14718007452422527, 0.27345325783476904, 0.23597789529469387, 0.13393780395904437, 0.2757709641826599, 0.2219069732140051, 0.2930198911577896, 0.2179966256886155, 0.3194040875845855, 0.3572887669041249] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@192B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 192, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [180, 176, 192, 192, 176, 192, 176, 192, 154, 176, 176, 192, 192, 176, 176, 182, 192, 192, 192, 176, 192, 192, 180, 144, 192, 192, 192, 192, 192, 192, 192], + "ciede2000": [6.559850427047269, 8.459065863881497, 26.802436411512602, 7.415782502762913, 11.419445258537642, 8.26156710211499, 11.834152822766205, 3.145353324650569, 10.49757360908093, 9.346369920177782, 10.018390051368945, 8.379096522089116, 3.6265922335340233, 9.876271774754853, 16.27291939379809, 9.04590316943014, 10.56387201976858, 7.586424312511412, 14.761289309455186, 13.838327634763651, 9.380059793491151, 3.5936117826663345, 9.907735194309321, 10.91472137287361, 2.3726311516525542, 11.908337932456622, 10.501034943234213, 9.648457399804547, 7.1940314237897285, 9.58772726253066, 12.207745202638181], + "ssimulacra2": [-125.6663815216312, -196.90104819969594, -1223.3435347173722, -91.70154463665224, -246.62024272176035, -132.68406034283362, -286.79448591419117, -62.63699778260457, -239.11229068711248, -184.32918498087395, -210.98566497448275, -105.50741719373053, -63.07576663343215, -212.5326206992974, -595.2882911573049, -154.94155710669827, -174.89359511428063, -71.34591621565022, -323.9032549229653, -653.948951896587, -149.4788915163822, -64.22935049983639, -282.7423995348, -169.65731606844486, -54.705363928986, -213.6749736466104, -160.032018802033, -185.8096139458542, -132.561013057666, -255.9669739546942, -439.0665798083726], + "butteraugli": [20.10200574219334, 23.459467882508594, 43.22943785216831, 23.462677508584296, 23.27119360031502, 19.771096142020955, 35.84117290473707, 12.939844915036034, 18.305449936988676, 28.61780909757465, 19.85006984768956, 22.383020261284404, 19.838231172679045, 20.296617125000296, 32.517051523173215, 25.232955333792173, 28.632251175699405, 36.06999847351843, 39.8166579857753, 25.470422102712064, 30.697992698424475, 14.412512270689623, 20.81667576415912, 24.539459957802833, 7.426442730494107, 34.205615559656685, 34.41676407290225, 25.70977686108174, 28.209689923956564, 29.636078696849722, 29.5491849153678], + "dssim": [0.3039943566937605, 0.30319823483714814, 0.4668187436281554, 0.15039654782436934, 0.33474360969876715, 0.21576245240866365, 0.21677402425584663, 0.08423398031728208, 0.4055598354051289, 0.21125122042460315, 0.393246797868051, 0.24027682531712313, 0.15041799545307066, 0.2537048053731543, 0.360141828550924, 0.1980205621163793, 0.22414274114082572, 0.1374678387018437, 0.3148774108626604, 0.3683429724936197, 0.21549578677217335, 0.1471158063757067, 0.26210711789455, 0.23605652085198486, 0.12409057618386315, 0.2694826519831991, 0.2145496463460499, 0.2767728575283086, 0.2131589021236317, 0.3087374396576079, 0.3516421518757967] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@411B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 411, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [364, 384, 374, 352, 384, 352, 384, 352, 374, 384, 384, 352, 374, 384, 384, 360, 374, 352, 374, 384, 352, 408, 364, 400, 352, 374, 352, 374, 374, 374, 374], + "ciede2000": [6.231677172504294, 7.31296889033014, 26.351519750330457, 6.541910656069998, 10.587762961707696, 7.374473583255899, 10.176682590733497, 2.9558382010639694, 10.011066988093118, 8.433972838307922, 9.540458490344017, 7.335335259917556, 3.5539689277180138, 8.847494284814639, 14.733656234166398, 8.240748309574782, 9.452350836787351, 6.201969262168356, 12.589735332456096, 13.722489413443911, 8.475358000345487, 3.197877166346075, 9.17088155287447, 8.515957246299838, 2.330886445835442, 10.632149298546716, 9.240803039418873, 8.17891409189974, 6.159238289810764, 8.418350340806482, 10.770194925028536], + "ssimulacra2": [-101.73470494416136, -100.0594737968155, -1135.7946940283098, -72.86527463583138, -168.3760538178571, -85.57281177091761, -153.19202946651077, -58.64687737946565, -161.11263154162776, -115.59679094916675, -131.18361790536005, -73.45647453255, -62.45264953320424, -138.55866241680062, -382.95714107432923, -113.42729569494551, -107.40974139937805, -64.3083435154146, -176.90478556370618, -596.9682341312914, -107.129580060249, -62.95627703148256, -223.1668625843633, -81.07610295431638, -49.78718343202215, -128.68650906477737, -102.80537291194261, -105.81708763539302, -86.79817258950735, -145.93218363915068, -264.0767902825899], + "butteraugli": [16.202165460670496, 20.528270952109253, 42.4772504920993, 21.682009350470267, 21.969625507582435, 18.805540313006414, 30.834003261312827, 12.685836172531438, 17.367287633492694, 24.70275691145204, 18.539191023108696, 19.227843672363036, 18.483951533283037, 18.957941287324996, 30.70527100341631, 24.61769726438035, 25.30497669701445, 26.29228604096204, 33.69183375422663, 25.1594786882674, 27.58400431699752, 13.133155783793294, 19.134313435092412, 21.795364577153507, 6.401179867837537, 28.14372515003656, 30.350908736282975, 23.31272381006356, 25.108256074459238, 27.14991450062946, 26.91423353808143], + "dssim": [0.3035531301193978, 0.29837072038223555, 0.4654890482424265, 0.14918478353676273, 0.3338477371526244, 0.20566309344394734, 0.2157968649136025, 0.08324369746384336, 0.40450285715117357, 0.20940313425718987, 0.3916358265989791, 0.23418066341649757, 0.15101659927547395, 0.2502965515654433, 0.35399251166182866, 0.19888863941521318, 0.22333349133603675, 0.12341445655691013, 0.29847307548592783, 0.36828929346926675, 0.21538635762026953, 0.14661997341563598, 0.25243659965724996, 0.23363579740422907, 0.1191434088856369, 0.26033234733608235, 0.2024404503542036, 0.25710582519838077, 0.20538254629949543, 0.29721944030032343, 0.3419124973622903] + } + }, + { + "label": "RawRGB565@1623B", + "family": "RawRGB565", + "targetBytes": 1623, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1566, 1536, 1610, 1564, 1536, 1564, 1536, 1564, 1540, 1536, 1536, 1564, 1610, 1536, 1536, 1596, 1610, 1564, 1610, 1536, 1564, 1518, 1566, 1600, 1564, 1610, 1564, 1610, 1610, 1610, 1610], + "ciede2000": [5.838927557167017, 6.063953154435079, 17.859788384823666, 4.919135090287848, 9.33768604822126, 5.40849836479294, 6.949833603094781, 2.508704242347468, 9.200810831658929, 6.54044063078712, 8.864181637769832, 6.280160663560795, 3.1709450454675383, 7.310068896238936, 11.164650690140304, 6.249595784346185, 7.52610378549301, 4.282597986535294, 8.698893887819054, 12.944651618406256, 6.331559211088901, 2.7885244102308473, 7.070384650703557, 6.990014244907121, 2.110611955912305, 8.6424590349156, 6.331720416205751, 5.442547577641389, 4.23807430691511, 6.484623668896943, 8.200129110820082], + "ssimulacra2": [-75.90725673047902, -64.27833858451865, -130.13970888264495, -62.46665618220689, -79.61116095633406, -63.93597953330442, -64.18273632177747, -37.33093589336016, -69.44659982612464, -64.22911383550809, -69.67223822035706, -64.17904168682182, -45.80575038452142, -65.27851677958671, -73.35544005275045, -64.10189767458922, -64.30641730214825, -50.64398913448369, -64.25687255285541, -367.33583845943474, -64.22718910914483, -50.96888237609829, -73.11389307719239, -64.20305698435826, -37.426218189894655, -65.47237744967376, -63.79736160172524, -63.48387378934581, -62.59252274604074, -64.24985302030075, -69.10867597178003], + "butteraugli": [14.417012904149404, 16.617911455747862, 31.26612660924393, 16.86969879471274, 19.23300889841569, 15.799786640524296, 23.826669467429966, 9.773587008706217, 15.006420074201491, 20.17799880532895, 15.935362443977562, 16.09250991392842, 15.196154698695258, 16.655205682488695, 21.774582372424707, 19.205438237503273, 19.71784706249167, 18.23203826198883, 22.460376987910042, 23.969349246218073, 20.158228787068385, 11.537076424936714, 16.036858340518226, 16.910684009568183, 4.9927352894637105, 21.444681209364315, 22.60012581228047, 16.2904957768784, 17.857852152645815, 18.871214471481938, 20.66951320089514], + "dssim": [0.3028734402612505, 0.2883654119374799, 0.4231661377522508, 0.1388244901380597, 0.3290620677889896, 0.1838006557303366, 0.19256754438680512, 0.08107795763442877, 0.3948358983170158, 0.17874135225018578, 0.3857513378130954, 0.22094359049257056, 0.149151098819647, 0.23917245473406762, 0.33340394732892353, 0.19585320770325132, 0.21458350256776704, 0.10788256636811927, 0.2546597988071265, 0.363375600655482, 0.20626308256759723, 0.14494295992131323, 0.23554771053263918, 0.22080644922628645, 0.11474035402768751, 0.2434670679995335, 0.1712639055508785, 0.2119761443129316, 0.17549266754381837, 0.2564452403341918, 0.3049986808527282] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@48B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 48, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [48, null, 48, null, 48, null, 48, 48, 48, 48, 48, null, 48, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, 46, 48, null, null, null, null, null, null], + "ciede2000": [8.818261904315365, null, 26.60424585829344, null, 16.143054724507564, null, 16.567041098101082, 8.216716698043362, 13.854893450329897, 13.828533070867067, 12.448804419351378, null, 7.550283285530561, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, 21.94447100123936, 2.9090447502920145, null, null, null, null, null, null], + "ssimulacra2": [-146.41654170100213, null, -1221.7597843862272, null, -348.3186075337181, null, -514.2937914462996, -64.22908789604173, -480.44928634677694, -407.09794601422, -324.59152379419436, null, -64.23550086541911, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, -348.40993419431516, -63.3250989962911, null, null, null, null, null, null], + "butteraugli": [29.18722400945695, null, 43.46136327253864, null, 28.00772582767192, null, 42.37893849021316, 15.904573186014304, 32.5943619175189, 54.751793214913825, 30.137560144414767, null, 28.261286798604676, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, 41.31757702356016, 13.945806120393655, null, null, null, null, null, null], + "dssim": [0.30478489501195216, null, 0.4657801915557354, null, 0.33520311410429227, null, 0.21992942623680067, 0.0867088871167403, 0.4107227200203086, 0.2757847312317887, 0.39504499555915384, null, 0.15197428449991107, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, null, 0.24852481646224928, 0.1597064371534916, null, null, null, null, null, null] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@64B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 64, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 64, 62, 60, 62, 64], + "ciede2000": [7.443936588065219, 8.247854669878317, 26.649111145064044, 11.619770185097224, 15.031503537894055, 10.505892652828518, 15.138410844817345, 4.517250090644204, 10.5796197080158, 12.638500463922258, 10.986850230350635, 12.939133845681107, 4.685022353683987, 12.87228092364108, 18.87021736786085, 11.155796576705828, 12.009265422271204, 10.36353524849902, 21.808583850374955, 14.062256604130711, 12.820816418591019, 5.894825085754076, 14.062990747739759, 14.136327825360421, 2.520257093849916, 13.6805915250885, 14.26700173108447, 15.035725411826174, 8.648198017217862, 9.731537833599686, 18.26765108611722], + "ssimulacra2": [-113.94995722126617, -182.48686867154925, -1220.3770866002003, -128.86081051323862, -285.60893149380803, -207.3641860844288, -347.0396051899167, -63.48801374951054, -263.2907957031276, -341.30129428094676, -228.10400982550402, -156.07340832163356, -64.04949484588772, -272.05920046927406, -689.7919867388377, -190.13537453073707, -224.50946195746354, -93.3320651579028, -745.1152524143275, -681.601808199578, -223.5659730737948, -66.04167672041737, -396.295061266388, -225.64550063580361, -55.52158488505688, -378.59341823539773, -307.0080330754714, -357.60867802137994, -223.06139469820596, -309.2787782159393, -690.5829834266574], + "butteraugli": [17.47547536918879, 24.136127264359747, 43.31364937489383, 25.85005103563316, 23.869935854319248, 21.972130645109953, 37.96194760220724, 13.438708645679762, 19.07425191383029, 44.35197966429695, 21.142865964988196, 26.490514377130893, 22.182210622004025, 23.768280117855245, 33.90733955782685, 26.678660346325486, 31.301518736693122, 45.536620124051375, 47.01997145773111, 25.793389569391056, 36.754741407055015, 16.534775414224477, 22.13827014093067, 26.078064315937024, 7.8260365162676955, 42.169651651052234, 38.46495519166417, 34.65089012894928, 33.04687924243716, 30.094544566973706, 35.91328414883551], + "dssim": [0.30418285733422634, 0.3027305746199621, 0.466450053898003, 0.16066557868949866, 0.3342413813950329, 0.2402843079313538, 0.21865457513095404, 0.08474827480539265, 0.4057541117662602, 0.2655749380197908, 0.39370702442789435, 0.2505158949938221, 0.15140057374460075, 0.258946500853353, 0.3643505745123553, 0.20226882930795592, 0.2318617761994124, 0.1461640330839642, 0.35302917093885744, 0.3685514001203516, 0.2262347884342935, 0.15019080746811347, 0.2954904279760092, 0.23740029309903848, 0.1188803819189021, 0.27879285805872533, 0.23249243100182798, 0.32023552806556344, 0.2208431841570288, 0.32138120916522583, 0.36241055105037423] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@80B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 80, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [80, 80, 64, 80, 80, 78, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 78, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 78, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80, 80], + "ciede2000": [7.488915068484673, 7.57213337792874, 26.649111145064044, 10.572914979608464, 14.132429079133885, 9.520310986681203, 13.972073514999144, 4.101476822983832, 10.041783920561265, 10.516317402087848, 10.193161832549693, 11.644478770725332, 4.5362436366973276, 12.42935286467668, 18.453260111911547, 10.806024002860319, 11.099350947445958, 9.385912834721873, 19.143241800717917, 14.010834007754868, 11.349677370340892, 4.136665715749304, 13.33069858526529, 13.469160712753947, 2.3652866525759753, 11.647018682631481, 12.946080105917437, 12.362427155607904, 7.113554206649269, 8.860453188572286, 16.342279999657794], + "ssimulacra2": [-105.3381206363444, -127.17364416792094, -1220.3770866002003, -118.4647111606447, -311.529467911871, -156.0687210649561, -302.2509274648565, -61.59047679117006, -197.36381661551366, -193.97160374177764, -173.96866173310286, -125.67402132598983, -63.79377023883592, -210.1847881226019, -611.0588718579901, -193.87287405257933, -159.5225764482621, -70.20377248507813, -456.8784842401026, -696.9107339635241, -160.10737867834308, -64.22912928503948, -321.64434853738777, -160.74565713193954, -53.171025861381, -204.69588859781334, -192.83534826301752, -263.84840702156424, -137.96825922371826, -240.74306924129104, -573.3526449167784], + "butteraugli": [17.105163101182068, 21.610654644840377, 43.31364937489383, 24.726318802985386, 25.265421938961044, 20.324813505263815, 35.8310105493377, 13.100085975686108, 17.794781417820406, 26.724167184030318, 19.54520860922916, 24.261383679082865, 20.58748612898435, 21.03948494134949, 32.67651668263861, 26.030860145363324, 28.523403700563946, 30.829353031775998, 42.9945901491785, 26.058709916417712, 30.857868798865862, 14.393779590984863, 20.467902079097367, 23.897957256660366, 7.343469692758368, 30.671465792527815, 33.0016166048404, 27.2409171247762, 28.64734263182731, 28.625306514609132, 31.617027197112453], + "dssim": [0.30399570522632635, 0.29990800009999175, 0.466450053898003, 0.1585047100151506, 0.3349828684835561, 0.23260459193683297, 0.21934588774604108, 0.08383100443271346, 0.4047183936028062, 0.25742224171364436, 0.39257855240209333, 0.24464270534386312, 0.15129112463762123, 0.2567773033835421, 0.36160209380463715, 0.19819864220743777, 0.2263549759391102, 0.13759052133891037, 0.340726756268115, 0.3683819530919795, 0.2229585296304376, 0.14792745899676502, 0.2884222193054303, 0.237088235959443, 0.1037791831329618, 0.26777770783149835, 0.22325610633244214, 0.3150835185210179, 0.21549762718047466, 0.31278898002187006, 0.35780506695941106] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@108B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 108, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [108, 108, 64, 108, 104, 108, 108, 104, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 106, 102, 108, 104, 106, 108, 108, 108, 108, 106, 108, 108, 108, 108, 108, 106], + "ciede2000": [6.561312164363781, 7.084830349885741, 26.649111145064044, 9.009933835797915, 12.839810623420789, 8.929270660616883, 12.83049480438016, 3.3555221667513573, 9.872813850695255, 10.638235276225823, 9.722888758268498, 9.417328064866933, 3.896359163957487, 11.439259353263973, 17.887097494293865, 9.86534821757428, 10.816157544596715, 8.165891631459738, 17.381288704184904, 13.897530381096567, 10.359498000598194, 3.7256682363754425, 12.67276733453862, 12.667429953279335, 2.2207435594629503, 10.77821816080221, 11.981349328889692, 11.238624249367762, 5.953891714151832, 8.324943564705265, 13.550991946297884], + "ssimulacra2": [-97.85511282931171, -110.72988988692236, -1220.3770866002003, -83.96973376581028, -211.8193518186455, -114.99716318522005, -279.6968159200088, -60.55425523101363, -183.8404460198916, -162.06867875946733, -144.15725849979478, -83.73398467340331, -63.43304764258207, -186.39811779867478, -584.8444144818968, -149.1129573538314, -154.93904755256187, -65.14385481829027, -322.5341284570617, -620.3637834478734, -128.8199611571466, -64.26547809826661, -358.67067631394184, -136.37675723566232, -54.74521926698003, -154.29592820313655, -134.77972474474316, -147.05335415954886, -91.61128170357614, -186.55196781634277, -377.3951835852274], + "butteraugli": [17.133154892569177, 20.696236931609903, 43.31364937489383, 22.238708766665553, 22.631099742506382, 19.442406882812644, 35.17943476998072, 12.831107396641015, 17.590351773717533, 25.509389605473075, 18.741579714374396, 20.77662564573637, 18.763982922832295, 20.21426966887523, 31.586174690267757, 24.654429794896725, 25.94499582520915, 27.902935066972635, 36.725904670394314, 25.749845465551445, 28.734133932769037, 14.88941883244666, 21.849195631611085, 22.991191828890994, 7.6039909461362285, 27.982774636865134, 32.035825285627105, 24.358523119527987, 25.26462402892137, 27.15089788814109, 27.627801080142245], + "dssim": [0.3039068391667311, 0.29935438001172643, 0.466450053898003, 0.15743592473643547, 0.3338585534362942, 0.21561518278467712, 0.2180854810359485, 0.08356854228758098, 0.4042539907719111, 0.24364124016484873, 0.39197454678462706, 0.24496544440720514, 0.15128569135922315, 0.2546649355254502, 0.36039530162431643, 0.19978617263061066, 0.22686235014030975, 0.12759822623747347, 0.3298248446210904, 0.36855377758247987, 0.21772490237879105, 0.14746502915650028, 0.2836701027345565, 0.23586703071736653, 0.10870542395048144, 0.2620695947078332, 0.216565446870651, 0.3056555924690324, 0.20690326281673493, 0.30516310706607996, 0.3529258777347185] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@192B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 192, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [180, 176, 170, 190, 192, 192, 190, 180, 192, 192, 192, 192, 192, 188, 190, 188, 190, 184, 190, 184, 186, 192, 190, 192, 186, 184, 192, 188, 192, 186, 172], + "ciede2000": [6.37868135290826, 6.007734644923739, 20.14198366222322, 7.898409834358988, 11.81011122358207, 8.031825611289246, 10.370825675933068, 2.948097632706379, 9.242559315805327, 7.988975149152914, 9.240556183658589, 7.791967914615922, 3.3993640075625473, 10.426366604790076, 16.11050987491595, 8.348810226308364, 9.718631244207742, 6.122450723846547, 14.895255540342628, 13.215867422980418, 8.52110381367833, 3.19419131997963, 11.090625857839663, 10.265507817848695, 1.8891152974866527, 9.12027937924052, 10.706553545799293, 9.169443423564427, 4.496757846095064, 6.469710075378864, 12.250367060758807], + "ssimulacra2": [-94.92195455128734, -68.25848500304446, -254.67019677838505, -64.27100643277333, -181.59181757799053, -80.41348804418357, -74.72566826802745, -59.364809992434914, -99.15129153090393, -65.83158367704516, -99.95383136794189, -66.04457439177207, -58.44865881833991, -159.42095397288017, -202.39839510900237, -64.24154840511008, -80.58408082858506, -57.00159097154261, -149.9601715147336, -414.6046930209227, -65.13784303153955, -62.67310783088121, -226.42251122597798, -67.9620664701878, -38.55571239595744, -79.96127258416067, -114.15061403624168, -69.50704251455105, -64.3282179480187, -74.29323051098973, -165.19248630125645], + "butteraugli": [16.917944957668876, 17.771244283882034, 35.93261378571006, 18.177797859949507, 22.044295421695107, 17.93576676328152, 27.5554282697038, 12.621376167072919, 15.631719566077697, 16.179945095673215, 16.922591044840164, 17.45955931304844, 16.374629573487628, 19.578984224280465, 26.44859774608106, 19.237362440212905, 22.721762253344025, 20.685184851855265, 30.570410230425278, 23.854483446476536, 22.321437949563872, 12.751870323146454, 18.68409891516991, 18.776647671694658, 4.610512525790463, 23.82934670999758, 31.357804864517785, 18.917946031292427, 19.323466099357045, 21.42227502900617, 23.348148136096103], + "dssim": [0.3037625312009895, 0.2907948754649894, 0.4403813739364024, 0.14962617541557838, 0.33351507649405454, 0.2104593563048643, 0.21115043761630803, 0.08314049265766355, 0.3972849150579461, 0.19755091111700152, 0.38960830487585785, 0.22659364649683805, 0.15119906344788764, 0.2524805386992659, 0.349950008512772, 0.19474477807918106, 0.2246362853326404, 0.10753974796593924, 0.31398883063821925, 0.3600285316632852, 0.2093358772344049, 0.1464966029799104, 0.2778858953234863, 0.22812196509349203, 0.08571173984467356, 0.25615269929108997, 0.20675395224045295, 0.2657472115216859, 0.18595332680659332, 0.28189519001779006, 0.3299907518583215] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@411B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 411, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [406, 410, 394, 402, 398, 410, 404, 384, 410, 410, 410, 410, 396, 410, 386, 404, 408, 404, 410, 402, 410, 410, 408, 408, 388, 410, 408, 402, 406, 410, 406], + "ciede2000": [5.92083249843271, 4.876232983411888, 15.328749718052165, 6.337538173200787, 10.325028989395127, 6.513402810368796, 7.865474866328974, 2.3968003039722676, 8.56817469075077, 6.813122171990539, 8.792248448706546, 6.370821811293551, 2.876885660984552, 8.83275938175167, 13.63420678106025, 6.599277300548674, 7.987112874406066, 4.010505693013513, 11.849582891765944, 11.612927710060012, 6.675925572459218, 2.8416622727351974, 9.139885616402529, 8.43606725112029, 1.7617541666220748, 7.850166075967363, 7.865896146447901, 7.218561998043554, 3.3177067098842117, 5.287024817396718, 9.580591017985526], + "ssimulacra2": [-72.64844992897284, -62.97704858748429, -78.23231419838464, -58.21887194551874, -86.7565247296065, -63.547844750777756, -62.35896460321567, -24.636477799256383, -64.68246035818402, -62.914065286863234, -64.48539825366512, -62.9208221662864, -31.71954501724963, -64.22865397079318, -69.62903828765886, -62.41057098163634, -64.22861176995502, -32.73794780016874, -64.66252273083344, -99.9020829933927, -63.901729443692005, -55.47930317403899, -72.25000243592916, -64.17580944678062, -30.936610927710234, -64.3063098530686, -63.29034409789597, -64.09723235691246, -57.35205173082832, -63.725300510343715, -65.59516839890938], + "butteraugli": [14.488240840202735, 12.748209076006106, 28.29038624762971, 14.611002052459455, 19.478993224845897, 13.302455165593221, 18.865556278158362, 8.91093113689094, 13.33651909766406, 12.960657159248619, 13.830025203360611, 14.636778998832105, 9.601057214736485, 13.429389598448674, 20.24177609021473, 17.219282196750054, 16.532533375692974, 13.049887451022562, 21.343140750661775, 19.702501196186034, 17.52105907912099, 11.792458479334423, 15.811320000428495, 15.535010598552574, 4.421444841924154, 18.424630456023568, 17.979878611772325, 13.114767257889673, 13.888526632764055, 15.608562733231146, 18.957836856001684], + "dssim": [0.30217256501500356, 0.2705053880329841, 0.3989394058038622, 0.13657946353700795, 0.329605426791, 0.17848338609493947, 0.180256227262034, 0.07807193942587154, 0.3848178488188504, 0.17621850525800647, 0.37612720662885374, 0.2126958594488237, 0.14544311832562223, 0.2315492789746501, 0.3242808909297368, 0.1870835886898548, 0.20575561417173355, 0.08838082415093046, 0.27272587881898547, 0.32652777010569023, 0.19826527104718966, 0.14485097379952716, 0.25352340471051515, 0.22050902035225234, 0.07963616090480335, 0.23522732732579338, 0.17080690460696935, 0.23848755027432994, 0.15757360414910565, 0.2445594910583097, 0.29586350766914193] + } + }, + { + "label": "WebP@1623B", + "family": "WEBP", + "targetBytes": 1623, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1532, 1608, 1610, 1568, 1612, 1526, 1574, 1206, 1618, 1536, 1582, 1608, 1280, 1582, 1586, 1590, 1550, 1622, 1616, 1590, 1622, 1572, 1604, 1582, 786, 1570, 1584, 1586, 1554, 1570, 1618], + "ciede2000": [5.3205755839224205, 4.30849973526395, 11.921962001424241, 4.315982570176274, 8.566339320453793, 4.785874352415873, 5.501232481427764, 2.012356327740362, 8.061613333877018, 5.537987376513027, 7.9642982371367586, 5.264283312739503, 2.51862110805234, 6.675615597748927, 10.322351568528198, 4.957172703102612, 6.431024750790771, 2.912453040476381, 8.203763532201988, 9.711040885660355, 5.012058009689535, 2.393985610057178, 6.790306143271254, 6.82921507739799, 1.6022453121880387, 6.887719026329571, 5.623128478622237, 5.253455124966955, 2.52205504583754, 4.431855451604447, 6.8162680001233], + "ssimulacra2": [-63.98198431830312, -46.4994800982133, -64.1828768793917, -38.92280995515699, -63.956684783635325, -46.77081707018391, -37.26907905199346, -0.28210940619831604, -62.91864752320211, -48.96553806339173, -62.49459107801201, -50.28949288213886, -20.274473060767363, -52.309390254250474, -60.4997645922802, -43.52013831631834, -61.49601688176389, -13.819546935062945, -56.73232168105693, -64.07243181192086, -48.17896867476506, -21.118667184318255, -62.46144101190362, -56.30998499471963, -21.820338531331416, -62.52204135126635, -38.26581948850239, -49.56867769532877, -24.641695254375946, -51.27708294866795, -53.92033440834186], + "butteraugli": [11.049987988055781, 10.451500455361375, 21.425856917482452, 12.247410475290115, 14.048576198756995, 11.966368250635336, 15.944805461369404, 6.5462682358134, 11.594951625976186, 11.93230057394429, 12.118817423792137, 12.500562672092508, 9.230706808726017, 9.772121443658726, 14.535123258775812, 14.22322335044631, 14.838050411863625, 12.479487204730333, 15.39361725088491, 15.18531667759712, 13.511294883249187, 8.829190539835848, 11.638209756342782, 11.913168751884358, 4.112676360796065, 16.073922685120557, 12.909573200336382, 10.314222050813731, 11.408770230888555, 13.756985932759648, 13.41234503613186], + "dssim": [0.27976310203079546, 0.2570906992457703, 0.3536961826433871, 0.11991412723235223, 0.30807359308035365, 0.1434652077935697, 0.15493171352181534, 0.07388185387386237, 0.37343065444610146, 0.14976839538161674, 0.3663616087202263, 0.1935857076742944, 0.14317456258287925, 0.21216669222013546, 0.2890928777194275, 0.16812643628719348, 0.19241514102599583, 0.07473709040148857, 0.2248816907663002, 0.28605628609878775, 0.1756440456114915, 0.13781503552022362, 0.22084838327232753, 0.20661901912594205, 0.07391866889184517, 0.21378498923709283, 0.13419696028374856, 0.19352332485787754, 0.12928066573804026, 0.20741492184096816, 0.23247776604804876] + } + }, + { + "label": "JPEG@411B", + "family": "JPEG", + "targetBytes": 411, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [411, 405, 401, 411, 411, 409, 406, 409, 410, 411, 411, 410, 407, 410, 411, 410, 410, 409, 410, 407, 411, 409, 410, 408, 402, 407, 411, 411, 409, 408, 410], + "ciede2000": [6.224826330026287, 6.826308982142955, 21.0981014957478, 8.549572550863838, 12.669340872176134, 8.534037506215622, 11.77178814610672, 3.2288896994871212, 9.591926057563713, 9.838221931444439, 9.487466528274929, 8.219032297048454, 3.65232042122722, 11.06708224903498, 16.90689541683792, 9.230517367781218, 10.056027562562617, 7.358462097446013, 16.100619753418506, 13.816865900002151, 9.66812167641243, 3.34181220975723, 11.99340618131453, 10.974399507626018, 2.1335079309248517, 9.86393008657246, 11.540611383851541, 10.435599473506448, 5.41392152021375, 7.4643511668151605, 12.864374903828573], + "ssimulacra2": [-89.84988192016021, -99.90728481814699, -364.82156118352236, -71.29225698396641, -192.76766657728717, -103.86411641644878, -138.35427937477579, -58.44658008838263, -135.94431975448262, -166.3891031852865, -125.97318611256026, -86.30411462920765, -61.699281345115054, -188.8489983127015, -403.11337213887896, -100.54131848106044, -120.33776467956758, -64.22883324301623, -202.20071195601122, -522.3742636174368, -98.36642194075273, -63.93914170586697, -290.81408766688037, -79.31503235993961, -51.97783050513581, -106.81922227889586, -162.94984384214183, -108.96792771943595, -72.04701707614916, -124.2360973914466, -303.3342457251764], + "butteraugli": [14.645979097000861, 20.49693355942857, 38.759428919367664, 21.51834764088439, 21.566730962961362, 18.909596911835486, 34.20603314517652, 13.048330593197221, 16.539163632748696, 26.248215796258012, 18.378452277416574, 19.998370665605993, 17.220465799132047, 20.83582135445602, 30.173672566054126, 23.604761550735475, 25.61107238974945, 24.0593504540273, 35.766281467850256, 24.88417719791703, 27.13499428231673, 13.665065407817496, 20.529994364435943, 21.02048631883638, 7.011124857016804, 27.267624040831418, 32.92379541397303, 23.19209301181697, 24.572146297440526, 24.361290822457022, 26.385595110602026], + "dssim": [0.30385500977846935, 0.2984656894847473, 0.4437282171093709, 0.15533052862671864, 0.33354819860219775, 0.21960206994138026, 0.2235714438497351, 0.08335317079604382, 0.40238188174407485, 0.2352786586576603, 0.3917930484741831, 0.23642527491929277, 0.15164062610274792, 0.2539836198599824, 0.35802715999092005, 0.2011611062871002, 0.22646830905720977, 0.13511767932401236, 0.3191074180757727, 0.3681315379803174, 0.22040801432225204, 0.14721110432091938, 0.28024833966158125, 0.2338430907209706, 0.10022323356282942, 0.26227623027514135, 0.21700926247368174, 0.29068975012187914, 0.2056974260528598, 0.2971188361421667, 0.34664400177318677] + } + }, + { + "label": "JPEG@1623B", + "family": "JPEG", + "targetBytes": 1623, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1604, 1608, 1617, 1598, 1583, 1569, 1601, 1506, 1606, 1622, 1610, 1574, 1546, 1619, 1592, 1591, 1575, 1581, 1600, 1610, 1586, 1598, 1569, 1504, 1509, 1599, 1600, 1596, 1556, 1623, 1601], + "ciede2000": [5.345820051856291, 4.3993945690140395, 12.161431267226682, 4.4765294865776, 8.679028291383728, 4.93856221762202, 5.932019451360081, 1.9546452138723116, 8.105579405733966, 5.681251329058135, 7.943223581238648, 5.253855273598308, 2.487865896655358, 6.781277271543481, 10.495472191224739, 5.148237856079103, 6.535405608716714, 2.8760060676285297, 8.578521691145022, 9.986479885716106, 5.187331630274854, 2.3929494467474766, 7.08644359170937, 6.868861958044297, 1.5282912728302567, 7.009292884011808, 5.931152280966696, 5.46557583956818, 2.6698810924867873, 4.548478923458335, 7.219659955362047], + "ssimulacra2": [-64.21709949512297, -50.746705909746765, -64.22505700763566, -43.94765209063618, -64.21635218046384, -51.42199699076605, -48.69065120794187, -2.2360501560834365, -63.30072738287387, -54.266484435281626, -63.470636479956084, -52.907379852681146, -21.335624432208945, -57.54067769791723, -63.14747025804306, -47.448947788678794, -62.8540769777228, -18.08334845808018, -60.466459883098594, -64.22981418417893, -53.72777090333963, -25.22352493204474, -64.03184432113818, -57.9563606802316, -20.231151617989923, -63.191627340036376, -49.33398133107289, -54.14879331530429, -32.258599191906825, -54.32058603318421, -60.17284304911345], + "butteraugli": [11.254168636694368, 10.755743980683194, 21.92912217526444, 13.09882057271153, 14.263426566867636, 12.397969931408333, 16.920374456367814, 6.688165786912513, 11.728294849550457, 12.42366694260676, 12.743874045688392, 12.677333055528946, 9.289656609697534, 10.488602614424131, 15.756613998403934, 14.438583773232855, 15.227509203528706, 12.566471463146003, 16.411649665446287, 15.754948181528647, 14.299490517784141, 9.026317193269092, 12.581659715445006, 12.17022483029227, 4.099514203876347, 16.33882144601816, 14.475696956980846, 10.854095090192956, 11.877356869807215, 14.018247636242819, 14.522956718514616], + "dssim": [0.2844559988314448, 0.2613007270940111, 0.358388429728119, 0.12457652096797833, 0.3120833480349263, 0.15016265910312193, 0.1693129026963609, 0.07448089221924553, 0.37513262065679837, 0.1568482596045349, 0.3693557241376013, 0.1977891510804426, 0.14377742767253082, 0.21992739494507912, 0.30136458697834156, 0.17350664245902908, 0.1984890149547704, 0.07917614025694891, 0.2378506332594965, 0.29739119145901305, 0.18369384867448918, 0.1397755540372529, 0.22963133294045135, 0.20858084819038353, 0.072042109981731, 0.21826826417873435, 0.14775968427483122, 0.20472873936083696, 0.13824266899181986, 0.21577871077907357, 0.2524160358080151] + } + }, + { + "label": "AVIF@1623B", + "family": "AVIF", + "targetBytes": 1623, + "tune": null, + "tier": null, + "version": null, + "perImage": { + "bytes": [1602, 1617, 1621, 1598, 1605, 1605, 1608, 1565, 1613, 1601, 1616, 1574, 1485, 1562, 1602, 1564, 1619, 1617, 1589, 1588, 1617, 1512, 1585, 1607, 1502, 1591, 1609, 1561, 1603, 1601, 1617], + "ciede2000": [5.135615190691574, 4.319915218631857, 11.870573525950958, 4.009238876877921, 8.224246803251928, 4.372243769206249, 5.195863860216305, 1.8213132178053193, 8.067879322629729, 4.767440908864016, 7.902004706604974, 5.106429680072293, 2.374590559381148, 6.020015966698974, 9.836496696919196, 4.6400333553613855, 6.107492598360926, 2.3814949987890066, 7.342248727612647, 8.76175958492979, 4.8277879837400315, 2.2798002815231198, 6.0979900092178445, 6.200448149395351, 1.4902963513339424, 6.908054435594145, 5.1345932078458345, 4.582881814020639, 2.5218318576819723, 4.434243519740952, 6.457621172328143], + "ssimulacra2": [-63.96542107463492, -47.30730385711655, -64.17232780512623, -36.73634436776456, -63.9835508263277, -44.85739309970796, -37.16357287106601, 1.5471545555003559, -62.993061453494505, -45.000398008766126, -62.7091526958441, -50.04844870761977, -19.32940423077079, -52.82682385878974, -61.141402117634414, -42.68446861841517, -61.272907947933334, -11.88205207710385, -56.737068601274785, -63.678150176521626, -48.56630491203933, -21.61034678032445, -62.62026848125285, -55.41537207402311, -19.94964018170178, -62.59075687581651, -39.01785455622158, -41.27224924181033, -24.99676718324517, -51.329728889450195, -56.0705208885756], + "butteraugli": [11.001744120752027, 10.44319652007938, 21.16981078904301, 12.039257665695713, 14.102869502826701, 11.902550326690237, 15.975927785411818, 6.445024044549576, 11.622023262947105, 11.802131735278328, 12.288080260482346, 12.501854759468726, 9.202822596431396, 9.85157994549237, 14.815679419396213, 14.218527418055638, 14.83225420213086, 12.328340358742153, 15.57327083462649, 15.044381350932447, 13.518752330397268, 8.798150663946359, 11.56160012673996, 11.918107472131183, 4.086103293193884, 16.096886729183108, 13.10005258528104, 9.964345133661352, 11.434092771320143, 13.812048642020434, 13.898986033745539], + "dssim": [0.2790351814140736, 0.25769621831810374, 0.35431425137057526, 0.11758878840618997, 0.30794400937079214, 0.14023081254947672, 0.15553179546564033, 0.07336899918761636, 0.3737252609058234, 0.13681886817616645, 0.3665793679606917, 0.19363191656304246, 0.14250263821929493, 0.2089373201341414, 0.2905739251626286, 0.1678620296908771, 0.19219827096555436, 0.07169461521216497, 0.22487224357082736, 0.2848539772568439, 0.17608012075645524, 0.13712197551452388, 0.21210795548643707, 0.2034068899722586, 0.07124582099441956, 0.21449154814264937, 0.13112930935487072, 0.18637594821188413, 0.12972652257089007, 0.2078446553872617, 0.23739703242531557] + } + } + ] +} From ba05b69e765cf3041af530d90d039232919d4e57 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 03:00:21 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 6/9] docs(spec): re-bind EXPERIMENTS.md to the one-commit re-measure, and correct what no longer holds MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Every table verify:experiments binds agrees with the re-recorded results, and the tables those results made bindable are now bound (1040 → 1229 checked cells): - §1 labels its 32 B column as the ladder's 26:9 shape and adds the shipped L28@4 C15@3 default beside it (11.47 / 11.30); §9.5's row is relabelled the same way. - §4.5 and §7.12's pre-adoption rows were the retired corpus's §2 ladder, so every Δ under them compared two corpora; they are now measured arms of budget-ladder-tuned, bound with their Δ rows. The 28-byte claim survives on both splits, and §7.12/§8.3 restate the 20% equal-quality saving, which holds on holdout and not on tune. - §11.12 binds both columns of its photographic table to v07-holdout-photo on each split, fixes the positioning table's resolver (it read the format name as the byte count), states which rule admitted the compact tier at −2.78%, and replaces "consulted once" with the holdout's actual history. - §11.3 replaces a FAIL in the αMAE column with the value, and binds the subgroup table on the post-hoc 35% cut (now disclosed as such) and on a median cut fixed by the corpus; the adopted row ranks first on both. - §11.10 reports compact-tier-alpha, which §6 called never run. - §11.14 gains the ~1.6 kB rows; spec/README §14.1's RGB565 claim is restated from them (pixels beat code 4 on holdout ΔE00, not on tune) and registered in verify-claims, and §2's note and §9.5's row say the same. - §12.2 states the rule as "no guard regresses"; §13.3/§13.4 stop reading a relationship into correlations that are not significant at n = 31 and stop calling codes 1 and 4 equal-fidelity. - §4.6, §4.8 and §7.10 carried retired-corpus figures; re-derived. - §6 lists the tune commands, drops the "never run" claim, and says where the results live; §9.5 and §13.5 carry current counts, and §13.5's resample change is #88. - spec/README §15 records the measured outcomes of weighting matrices and progressive tiers. --- spec/EXPERIMENTS.md | 523 +++++++++++++++------ spec/README.md | 26 +- tools/comparison/src/verify-claims.ts | 28 ++ tools/comparison/src/verify-experiments.ts | 432 +++++++++++++++-- 4 files changed, 819 insertions(+), 190 deletions(-) diff --git a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md index 2fe315d..73b1d97 100644 --- a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md +++ b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md @@ -77,20 +77,27 @@ but nothing could decode one. Four tooling changes opened that surface: ## 1. The rate–distortion curve of v0.7 The constants that ship today (post-§10 adoption), AC layout resized to each -budget at the shipped 26:9 luma:chroma count ratio and 5 b luma / 4 b chroma -precision (`sweeps/budget-ladder.json`, both splits). Points ≤ 80 B render at -the default tier's raster, ≥ 108 B at the next one up — that is the tier's -*raster*, not its byte budget, which the layout override sets directly. +budget at the upper tiers' 26:9 luma:chroma count ratio and 5 b luma / 4 b +chroma precision (`sweeps/budget-ladder.json`, both splits). Points ≤ 80 B +render at the default tier's raster, ≥ 108 B at the next one up — that is the +tier's *raster*, not its byte budget, which the layout override sets directly. + +That shape is what codes 2–4 ship at 108, 411 and 1623 B. It is **not** what +the two lower tiers ship: the default tier (32 B) is `L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3` and +the compact tier (21 B) `L 19 @ 4 / C 6 @ 3`, both off this curve and both +better than it at their budget. So the 32 and 21 B columns below are the +ladder's shape at those budgets, not the tiers; the third table gives the +shipped default beside it. Both splits were re-measured together for v0.7. §4.5 and §7.12 quote an **earlier** ladder, taken against the pre-adoption v0.6-derived constants, and keep those numbers: they are what the round-1 and round-2 candidates were measured against. -| Bytes | 10 | 12 | 14 | 16 | 18 | 21 | 24 | 28 | **32** | 40 | 48 | 64 | 80 | +| Bytes | 10 | 12 | 14 | 16 | 18 | 21 | 24 | 28 | 32 | 40 | 48 | 64 | 80 | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| ΔE00 tune | 15.51 | 14.17 | 13.59 | 13.19 | 13.05 | 12.57 | 12.16 | 11.92 | **11.65** | 11.25 | 10.97 | 10.48 | 10.13 | -| ΔE00 holdout | 14.96 | 13.88 | 13.49 | 13.00 | 12.75 | 12.49 | 12.14 | 11.85 | **11.54** | 11.17 | 10.81 | 10.36 | 9.98 | +| ΔE00 tune | 15.51 | 14.17 | 13.59 | 13.19 | 13.05 | 12.57 | 12.16 | 11.92 | 11.65 | 11.25 | 10.97 | 10.48 | 10.13 | +| ΔE00 holdout | 14.96 | 13.88 | 13.49 | 13.00 | 12.75 | 12.49 | 12.14 | 11.85 | 11.54 | 11.17 | 10.81 | 10.36 | 9.98 | | Bytes | **108** | 129 | 161 | 189 | 246 | 310 | **411** | 512 | 767 | 1017 | **1623** | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| @@ -103,9 +110,16 @@ Marginal value collapses far faster than 1/bytes (tune split): |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | ΔE00 gained per byte | 0.096 | 0.037 | 0.0166 | 0.0084 | 0.0030 | 0.00118 | -Each doubling of the budget buys 36–51% of what the previous one did. The five -shipped tier anchors are five points on this one smooth curve; there is nothing -special about 21/32/108/411/1623 B beyond ×4 arithmetic above the default. +Each doubling of the budget buys 36–51% of what the previous one did. The three +upper tier anchors are points on this one smooth curve, and there is nothing +special about 108/411/1623 B beyond ×4 arithmetic above the default. The two +lower tiers sit below the curve, because their layouts were re-derived for +their budgets (§4.2, §11.10) and the ladder's were not: + +| 32 B layout | ΔE00 tune | ΔE00 holdout | +|---|---|---| +| ladder shape, L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4 | 11.65 | 11.54 | +| **shipped default, L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3** | **11.47** | **11.30** | ## 2. Cross-format at equal bytes, same corpus, same scoring @@ -179,10 +193,15 @@ Three things this says that `RATIONALE.md` does not: > and the figures in them are the retired set's. Claim 1 survives and §11.14 > restates it at the shipped anchors. Claim 2's current form is in §4.3, where > the shipped shape still wins ΔE00 and still loses SSIMULACRA2 and Butteraugli. -> **Claim 3 no longer holds**: measured now, tier 3 is **6.73** against RGB565's -> **6.96**, so the coding machinery does still pay for itself at the top of the -> ladder. What beats tier 3 at ~1.6 kB is a real codec — WebP 5.79, JPEG 5.93, -> AVIF 5.46 — which is §11.14's finding rather than this one. +> **Claim 3 now depends on the split.** On tune, tier 3 is **6.73** against +> RGB565's **6.96**, so the coding machinery pays for itself at the top of the +> ladder. On holdout it does not: RGB565 scores **6.57** against tier 3's +> **6.77** on ΔE00, though tier 3 still takes SSIMULACRA2 and Butteraugli and +> the two tie on DSSIM (§11.14). This note used to say the claim no longer +> held, from the tune figures alone; `rd-budget` had only been committed for +> holdout, and nothing compared the two. Either way the margin is about 3%, and +> what clearly beats tier 3 at ~1.6 kB is a real codec — on tune WebP 5.79, JPEG +> 5.93, AVIF 5.46 — which is §11.14's finding rather than this one. ## 3. The optimal budget @@ -276,9 +295,9 @@ and 108 B): | Allocation | 32 B ΔE00 | 108 B ΔE00 | |---|---|---| | L26@5 C9@4 — **shipped** | 11.655 | **9.721** | -| L28@4 C15@3 | 11.546 (−0.9%) | 9.913 (+2.0%) | +| L28@4 C15@3 | 11.546 (−0.9%) | 9.912 (+2.0%) | | L38@4 C8@3 | **11.458** (−1.7%) | 9.927 (+2.1%) | -| L28@4 C11@4 | 11.542 (−1.0%) | 9.767 (+0.5%) | +| L28@4 C11@4 | 11.541 (−1.0%) | 9.767 (+0.5%) | | L44@3 C11@3 | 11.660 (+0.0%) | 10.721 (+10%) | | L29@5 C9@3 | 11.608 (−0.4%) | 9.833 (+1.2%) | @@ -415,30 +434,59 @@ vector even though the decoder is untouched. Applying the findings across the whole ladder (`sweeps/budget-ladder-tuned.json`: per-budget luma precision from §4.2, chroma -one bit under luma, plus the stack): +one bit under luma, plus the three-knob stack, `sel_hv` pinned to 0). The +`pre-adoption shipped` rows are arms of the same sweep: the v0.6-derived format +resized to each budget as §1 resizes it, with the four selection/encoder knobs +pinned off, so both rows of each pair are scored on the same images in the same +run: | Bytes | 12 | 16 | 21 | 24 | 28 | 32 | 48 | 64 | 108 | 246 | 411 | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| tune, pre-adoption shipped | 13.79 | 12.35 | 11.70 | 11.14 | 10.80 | 10.43 | 9.73 | 9.32 | 8.57 | 7.67 | 7.09 | -| tune, tuned | 13.60 | 12.78 | 12.15 | 11.93 | 11.67 | 11.41 | 10.76 | 10.48 | 9.67 | 8.45 | 7.90 | -| tune Δ | −8.4% | −4.8% | −5.8% | −4.1% | −3.7% | −2.3% | −1.5% | −1.1% | −1.9% | −2.5% | −2.4% | -| holdout, pre-adoption shipped | 13.84 | 13.07 | 12.61 | 12.14 | 11.79 | 11.55 | 10.72 | 10.24 | 9.44 | 8.31 | 7.79 | -| holdout, tuned | 13.40 | 12.67 | 12.15 | 11.88 | 11.55 | 11.38 | 10.67 | 10.35 | 9.51 | 8.39 | 7.82 | -| holdout Δ | −4.0% | −3.3% | −4.0% | −2.9% | −2.7% | −2.7% | −1.9% | −1.0% | −1.9% | −1.9% | −2.1% | - -The gain is largest exactly where the shipped constants were never checked. The -compact way to say it: **the retuned encoder reaches today's tier-0 quality in -28 bytes instead of 32** (tune 10.40 vs 10.43; holdout 11.47 vs 11.55) — a 12.5% -byte saving at equal quality, with no wire-format change beyond the layout -table. +| tune, pre-adoption shipped | 14.24 | 13.20 | 12.70 | 12.23 | 11.95 | 11.65 | 10.96 | 10.51 | 9.72 | 8.63 | 7.91 | +| tune, tuned | 13.60 | 12.72 | 12.18 | 11.98 | 11.60 | 11.43 | 10.80 | 10.49 | 9.66 | 8.48 | 7.91 | +| tune Δ | −4.5% | −3.6% | −4.1% | −2.0% | −2.9% | −1.9% | −1.5% | −0.2% | −0.7% | −1.8% | 0.0% | +| holdout, pre-adoption shipped | 14.23 | 13.28 | 12.73 | 12.29 | 11.97 | 11.74 | 10.94 | 10.51 | 9.70 | 8.57 | 8.00 | +| holdout, tuned | 13.40 | 12.73 | 12.20 | 11.92 | 11.61 | 11.39 | 10.72 | 10.40 | 9.53 | 8.38 | 7.81 | +| holdout Δ | −5.8% | −4.2% | −4.1% | −3.0% | −3.1% | −3.0% | −2.1% | −1.0% | −1.7% | −2.2% | −2.3% | + +The gain is largest exactly where the shipped constants were never checked: +−4.5% tune and −5.8% holdout at 12 B, falling to −0.2% and −1.0% at 64 B. The +compact way to say it: **the retuned encoder reaches the pre-adoption default's +quality in 28 bytes instead of 32** (tune 11.60 against 11.65; holdout 11.61 +against 11.74) — a 12.5% byte saving at equal quality, with no wire-format +change beyond the layout table. + +> **This table was wrong on two counts until the 2026-09 re-measure.** Its +> `pre-adoption shipped` rows were §2's ladder on the *retired* corpus, set +> beside `tuned` rows measured on the current one, so every Δ below them +> compared two corpora: −8.4% at 12 B was a corpus difference, and at 16–411 B +> the printed Δs did not follow from the cells above them at all (16 B read +> −4.8% between 12.35 and 12.78, which is +3.5%). And the `tuned` arms set every +> round-1 knob but `sel_hv`, so they inherited the adopted 0.15 and measured the +> round-2 recipe — at 21–411 B they equalled §7.12's `optimized` row to the +> digit. The arms now pin `sel_hv = 0`, and the pre-adoption rows are measured +> in the same run. The 28-byte claim survives on both splits; the figures it +> quoted (10.40 against 10.43) were the retired corpus's. +> +> From 108 B up the two rows also differ in raster: the tuned arms render at the +> default tier's 32 px and the pre-adoption ones at the upper tier's, which +> §4.1 prices at 0.92% at 411 B. So the upper-budget Δs understate the recipe +> by up to that much, which is consistent with tune reading 0.0% at 411 B. ### 4.6 Companding retune at the new allocation — no effect µ_L=5 / µ_C=8 were locked against a 5 b / 4 b layout. Re-swept against the 4 b / -3 b winner (`sweeps/retune-32b.json`, tune): µ_L ∈ {3,4,6,8} spans 10.229–10.286 -against 10.238 at µ_L=5; µ_C ∈ {5,6,12,16} spans 10.246–10.275. The plateau -`RATIONALE.md` reports survives the change of bit depth — µ-law is not the -binding constraint at any of these depths. +3 b winner (`sweeps/retune-32b.json`, tune, on `L38@4 C8@3`): µ_L ∈ {3,4,6,8} +spans 11.406–11.415 against 11.408 at µ_L=5; µ_C ∈ {5,6,12,16} spans +11.401–11.416. The plateau `RATIONALE.md` reports survives the change of bit +depth — µ-law is not the binding constraint at any of these depths. + +(Re-transcribed in the 2026-09 re-measure, the first time this sweep's result +was committed. The figures this paragraph carried until then, 10.229–10.286 +and 10.246–10.275, were the retired corpus's, which §9.5 did not re-run. The +sweep's arms inherit today's selection and encoder knobs — it is one of §9.5's +disclosed `unpinnedLabels` configs — so this is the plateau on top of the +adopted stack; every arm shares that base, so the spread is still the µ effect.) ### 4.7 Per-image adaptive layout — sized, and small @@ -466,23 +514,35 @@ the low budgets, where the fixed layout is furthest from right. `cfl-probe`, tune split, 26 coefficients per channel with L and chroma sharing one selection order so index *i* is the same (cx, cy) in all three channels: -* mean |ρ(a, L)| = 0.457, mean |ρ(b, L)| = 0.504 +* mean |ρ(a, L)| = 0.463, mean |ρ(b, L)| = 0.579 * after a **per-image least-squares** predictor — itself an oracle, since α - would have to be signaled — residual energy is **71.5%** (a) and **63.2%** (b) - (the one grayscale photograph in the split has an identically-zero `a` AC set, - for which both statistics are 0/0; the probe now excludes such a channel - instead of scoring it as ρ = 0, residual = 100%) - -The sign of the correlation flips between images (−0.81 on `chroma-yellow-wall`, -+0.75 on `natural-building`), so a fixed gain is useless. A 24–38% energy -reduction is ≈0.2–0.35 bit/coefficient; at tier 0 that is ~4–6 bits across 18 -chroma coefficients, against ~10 bits to signal two gains. **CfL does not pay at -tier 0.** Reopen at tier 2–3, where per-image gains amortize over hundreds of -coefficients. + would have to be signaled — residual energy is **74.1%** (a) and **57.6%** (b) + (five photographs in the split have an identically-zero chroma AC set, for + which the statistics are 0/0; the probe excludes them from the means instead + of scoring them as ρ = 0, residual = 100%) + +The sign of the correlation flips between images (−0.94 on +`natural-landschaftsschutzgebiet-volkspark-rehberge`, +0.86 on +`night-bas-lica-notre`, both for `a`), so a fixed gain is useless. A 26–42% +energy reduction is ≈0.2–0.4 bit/coefficient; across the default tier's 2 × 15 +chroma coefficients that is ~9 bits, against ~10 bits to signal two gains. **By +this estimate CfL does not pay at tier 0**, though by a narrower margin than +round 1 read, and the estimate is not what decides it: §7.10 built CfL and +measured the paid form directly. Reopen at tier 2–3, where per-image gains +amortize over hundreds of coefficients. + +(Re-derived in the 2026-09 re-measure. The figures this section carried — +mean |ρ| 0.457 / 0.504, residual 71.5% / 63.2%, and two example images that +are not in the current corpus — were the retired corpus's, and §9.5 did not re-run the +probe. The probe is not a sweep, so nothing binds these; `cfl-probe --split +tune` reproduces them.) ### 4.9 Entropy headroom, measured -`coeff-stats`, tune split, shipped tier-0 layout, µ-law codes: +`coeff-stats`, tune split, µ-law codes, on the `L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4` layout the +tool calls "shipped tier-0" — the pre-adoption default row, and the base codes +2–4 still ship, but not today's `L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3` default (re-run in the +2026-09 re-measure; every figure below reproduces): | | luma (5 b field) | chroma (4 b field) | |---|---|---| @@ -575,8 +635,8 @@ decoder must understand. # Round 1 — the byte-budget study (§1–§4) mise run sweep budget-ladder # R-D ladder, shipped constants mise run sweep budget-ladder --split holdout -mise run sweep budget-ladder-tuned # round-1 recipe -mise run sweep budget-ladder-tuned --split holdout # §4.5 +mise run sweep budget-ladder-tuned # §4.5, §7.12 round-1 recipe + pre-adoption ladder +mise run sweep budget-ladder-tuned --split holdout # §4.5, §7.12, §8.3 mise run sweep render-raster # §4.1 mise run sweep allocation-grid # §4.2, §4.7 mise run sweep precision-by-budget # §4.2 @@ -629,10 +689,12 @@ mise run sweep quant-ranges # §11.8 mise run sweep scalefactor-bands # §11.9 mise run sweep compact-tier # §11.10 mise run sweep compact-tier-graphics # §11.10 -mise run sweep compact-tier-alpha # §11.12 compact tier, alpha corpus +mise run sweep compact-tier-alpha # §11.10 compact tier, alpha row mise run sweep alpha-tier1 # §11.11 +mise run sweep v07-holdout-photo # §11.12 tune column mise run sweep v07-holdout-photo --split holdout # §11.12 -mise run sweep v07-holdout-alpha --split holdout # §11.12 +mise run sweep v07-holdout-alpha # §11.12 tune column +mise run sweep v07-holdout-alpha --split holdout # §11.12 (cannot run: #83) mise run sweep adopted-defaults # §10.3 mise run sweep adopted-defaults --split holdout # §10.3 @@ -679,15 +741,27 @@ already carried — §11.14's is the current cross-format record. Nothing said s so the block could not reproduce three of its own tables and still exited 0. **A SKIP is not a pass** — read the skip list, or run with `--strict`, which turns one into a failure. -Six configs in `tools/comparison/sweeps/` are **not** written up above, and are + +Every `sweep` and `rd-budget` line above writes its result to +`tools/comparison/results/[-holdout].json`, which is committed, and every +one of them was re-run from a clean tree at one commit, `e310475`, for the +2026-09 re-measure: 54 results, per-image scores and provenance only. +`verify:experiments --strict` checks this file against them in CI. The three +`node .../dist/*.js --split tune` probes (`cfl-probe`, `coeff-stats`, +`entropy-budget`) and `main.js` are not sweeps, write to the gitignored +`output/`, and are not part of that record. + +Five configs in `tools/comparison/sweeps/` are **not** written up above, and are listed here so their absence is not mistaken for a result being withheld: `low-budget-allocation` and `v06-vs-v1` were run and superseded before this file's round-3 numbers were taken, and their outputs no longer survive on disk; -`capped-tier1-vs-tier0`, `compact-tier-alpha`, `scalefactor-bands-t1` and -`tier-precision-vs-count` were written but never run — `compact-tier-alpha` is -listed as a command above but has never produced an output. None of them informed an -adopted constant. `mise run verify:experiments` checks the tables that *are* here -against the outputs that produced them. +`capped-tier1-vs-tier0`, `scalefactor-bands-t1` and `tier-precision-vs-count` +were written but never run. None of them informed an adopted constant. +`compact-tier-alpha` was listed here too, as written but never run. That was +wrong in the way that matters: its committed result reproduces the tune figure +§11.12 quotes for the adopted compact alpha row to the digit, so the run that +figure came from scored these encodes, and no output of it was kept. §11.10 now +reports the sweep. `aniso-selection` and `aniso-extended`, named in §11.5, were deleted when `selection-weights` replaced them; their outputs survive only in the gitignored @@ -1019,8 +1093,8 @@ away a paradox: range a small gain. Quantized gains are not the problem, and were never the problem. 2. **The predictor does work.** Residual *energy* after the least-squares gain - is 71.5% (a) / 63.2% (b) of the original (§4.8) — an amplitude ratio of - ≈0.85 / 0.79, so the scale field really does shrink. + is 74.1% (a) / 57.6% (b) of the original (§4.8) — an amplitude ratio of + ≈0.86 / 0.76, so the scale field really does shrink. 3. **Coefficient error really does improve.** Simulating the µ-law path, RMS coefficient error falls from 0.0376 → 0.0356 (a) and 0.0375 → 0.0306 (b), *including* the α·(luma quantization error) the predictor imports. (Points 2 @@ -1108,21 +1182,28 @@ The whole ladder under the constants-only recipe | Bytes | 12 | 16 | 21 | 24 | 28 | 32 | 40 | 48 | 64 | 80 | 108 | 161 | 246 | 411 | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| tune, pre-adoption shipped | 13.79 | 12.35 | 11.70 | 11.14 | 10.80 | 10.43 | 10.03 | 9.73 | 9.32 | 8.98 | 8.57 | 8.07 | 7.67 | 7.09 | +| tune, pre-adoption shipped | 14.24 | 13.20 | 12.70 | 12.23 | 11.95 | 11.65 | 11.29 | 10.96 | 10.51 | 10.17 | 9.72 | 9.19 | 8.63 | 7.91 | | tune, optimized | 13.50 | 12.68 | 12.15 | 11.93 | 11.67 | 11.41 | 11.09 | 10.76 | 10.48 | 10.14 | 9.67 | 9.05 | 8.45 | 7.90 | -| holdout, pre-adoption shipped | 13.84 | 13.07 | 12.61 | 12.14 | 11.79 | 11.55 | 11.14 | 10.72 | 10.24 | 9.85 | 9.44 | 8.85 | 8.31 | 7.79 | +| holdout, pre-adoption shipped | 14.23 | 13.28 | 12.73 | 12.29 | 11.97 | 11.74 | 11.31 | 10.94 | 10.51 | 10.11 | 9.70 | 9.11 | 8.57 | 8.00 | | holdout, optimized | 13.30 | 12.72 | 12.15 | 11.88 | 11.55 | 11.38 | 10.98 | 10.67 | 10.35 | 9.99 | 9.51 | 8.92 | 8.39 | 7.82 | (The 32 B row of this ladder uses the ratio-derived `L33@4 C11@3`; the *measured* optimum `L28@4 C15@3` is better still — 11.298 on holdout, in the table above.) -> **The two `pre-adoption shipped` rows are round 2's baseline and are not on -> this corpus.** Their sweep no longer exists: `budget-ladder` resizes the -> layout but inherits today's adopted knobs, so it is a ladder of the format -> that ships rather than the one round 2 compared against. Read the `optimized` -> rows against each other, not across the pair — and see §8.3, where the -> equal-quality byte saving that used to be stated here is withdrawn for the -> same reason. +The `pre-adoption shipped` rows are §4.5's, the pre-adoption arms of +`budget-ladder-tuned` on this corpus. (Until the 2026-09 re-measure they were +the retired corpus's §2 ladder, which no run could reproduce, and this note told +the reader not to compare across the pair. The pair is now comparable.) The +optimized recipe beats the pre-adoption format at every budget on holdout, by +6.5% at 12 B and 1.2–4.6% from 16 to 108 B; above that the raster caveat under +§4.5's table applies. + +**The equal-quality byte saving, restated.** The adopted 32-byte recipe +(`L28C15 stack`, 11.298 on holdout, the table above) scores better than the +pre-adoption format at **40 bytes** (11.31), so it matches that format with 20% +fewer bytes — the figure round 2 reported, now measured on this corpus and in +one run. On tune it does not reach that far: 11.473 against 11.29 at 40 B, so +there the saving is less than 20%, and the holdout figure is the one to quote. ### 7.13 U11 — entropy-coded AC, with a real coder instead of an entropy @@ -1209,7 +1290,8 @@ again once restored. > nothing (ThumbHash on "tune": 11.17 before, 12.04 after). Treat any future > addition the same way — re-run §6 in full, or do not add it. -**U18 — a CI quality gate.** `mise run rd:gate` encodes 8 pinned photos at tier 0 and +**U18 — a CI quality gate.** `mise run rd:gate` encodes 8 pinned photos at the +32-byte default (tier 0 in this file's old numbering, code 1 as shipped) and compares mean ΔE00 against `tools/comparison/baselines/rd-gate.json` with a **two-sided** ±1% tolerance (an unexplained improvement also fails — a stale baseline gates nothing), and asserts every hash is exactly 32 bytes. Wired into @@ -1260,7 +1342,10 @@ changes that, and adding two more computed metrics arguably raises the stakes. ## 8. The optimized algorithm and its default parameters What survived, in the form a spec revision would take. Everything below is -validated on the never-tuned holdout split with all four metrics improving. +validated on the holdout split with all four metrics improving. That split was +never tuned on directly, but it was not unread either: round 1 had already +consulted it, and `sel_hv = 0.15` was chosen on it (§11.12 records how often it +has been read). ### 8.1 Constants-level (every implementation must adopt these together) @@ -1285,9 +1370,13 @@ unchanged. (12.129 vs 12.146) — both beat ThumbHash on all four metrics, and the choice between them should be re-made against the alpha-mode layout before a compact tier is written down. -**Not yet measured:** the alpha-mode layout. The arithmetic points at -`L 22 @ 4 b, a/b 14 @ 3 b` at tier 0 (255 bits), but the photographic corpus has -no alpha, so this needs its own sweep before it is written down. +**Not yet measured** when this was written: the alpha-mode layout. The +arithmetic points at `L 22 @ 4 b, a/b 14 @ 3 b` at tier 0 (255 bits), but the +photographic corpus has no alpha, so this needs its own sweep before it is +written down. *Measured since* in §11.1 and §11.3: that arithmetic is not among +the layouts that beat the old alpha row after Holm (§13.5), and the row that +shipped is `A 28 @ 3 b, L 22 @ 4 b, a/b 3 @ 3 b`, which moves the budget into +the alpha channel instead. The compact tier's alpha row is §11.10's. **2. Selection weights** `aniso = 1.2`, `sel_hv = 0.15` — key `priority · (1 + 1.2·sin²2θ) · (1 + 0.15·cos2θ)`. Worth **−0.36 pp** of the @@ -1345,13 +1434,14 @@ against `adopted-defaults`, which reconstructs the pre-adoption constants by hand rather than inheriting them — the only way the comparison stays meaningful now that §10 has made the optimized recipe the default. -> **The equal-quality byte saving is not restated here.** Round 2 put it at 20% -> — the optimized 32-byte encode matching the shipped format at 40 bytes — read -> off a ladder of the *pre-adoption* signal path. No current sweep produces that -> ladder: `budget-ladder` resizes the layout but inherits today's adopted -> knobs, so it is a ladder of the format that ships, not of the one the saving -> was measured against. The −3.72% above is what the corpus still supports; the -> byte figure needs a pre-adoption ladder nobody has run. +> **The equal-quality byte saving, measured again.** Round 2 put it at 20% — +> the optimized 32-byte encode matching the pre-adoption format at 40 bytes — +> and this section withdrew it, because no sweep produced a pre-adoption ladder +> on this corpus. `budget-ladder-tuned` now does, and §7.12 restates it: on +> holdout the adopted recipe at 32 B (11.298) is better than the pre-adoption +> format at 40 B (11.31), so the 20% holds there. On tune it does not reach +> 40 B, so the saving there is smaller. The −3.72% above remains the figure the +> pre-registered rule is judged on. At the proposed 21-byte compact tier the format beats ThumbHash on **all four metrics** on holdout (§7.6), which the shipped constants do not. @@ -1585,7 +1675,7 @@ reproduces what did not change is measuring the corpus rather than the weather. | Measurement | Curated (§9) | Wikimedia | Verdict | |---|---|---|---| -| Tier 1, tune / holdout ΔE00 | 10.28 / 11.38 | 11.65 / 11.54 | Tune is 13.3% harder; **holdout only 1.4%**, being three-quarters Kodak24 | +| §1's 32 B ladder point (`L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4`, not the shipped default), tune / holdout ΔE00 | 10.28 / 11.38 | 11.65 / 11.54 | Tune is 13.3% harder; **holdout only 1.4%**, being three-quarters Kodak24 | | R-D gate, mean of 8 | 8.8459 | 11.1369 | +25.9%, and 0.00% drift against its own baseline | | §8 recipe on holdout | −3.50% | **−3.72%** | grew — still clears the pre-registered ≥3%, and this is the figure the repo quotes (§7.12, §10.3) | | Compact tier vs ThumbHash, holdout | wins all four | wins all four | unchanged | @@ -1605,7 +1695,7 @@ reproduces what did not change is measuring the corpus rather than the weather. | Metric-targeted RDO optimum | −0.80% | **−0.07%** | **evaporated** (§7.2) | | `fit2+nearest` at 32 B | −0.43% | −0.30% | narrowed; mode 1 / mode 2 order reversed (§4.4) | | Count-vs-precision at 32 B | −2.0% | −1.7% | thesis intact, restated (§4.2) | -| Tier 3 vs raw RGB565, ~1.6 kB | pixels win, 5.80 vs 6.26 | **ChromaHash wins, 6.73 vs 6.96** | **inverted** (§2) | +| Tier 3 vs raw RGB565, ~1.6 kB | pixels win, 5.80 vs 6.26 | ChromaHash wins on tune, 6.73 vs 6.96; **pixels win on holdout**, 6.57 vs 6.77 | **split-dependent** (§2, §11.14; this row read "inverted" from tune alone) | **Nothing that ships changed, and two things that were concluded did.** Every adopted constant in §8.1 still clears its bar and every item in §8.4 is still @@ -1744,6 +1834,13 @@ still the obvious next thing to build. > `compact 21B shipped shape` — name nothing readable and were found by reading > the config, not by running the gate. Read a passing run as a statement about > 481 arms. +> +> **The counts above are the ones this note was written against.** At the +> 2026-09 re-measure the gate reads 831 arms in 51 configs: 481 enforceable, +> 103 exempt, 247 unreadable. All 24 arms added since are unreadable: the ten +> of the two §13 ladder configs, whose labels name tiers rather than constants, +> and the 14 pre-adoption arms `budget-ladder-tuned` gained for §4.5, labelled +> in §1's `L26/C9` form, which the gate does not read. 5. **A column nobody checks, inside a table that passes.** `verify:experiments` binds *columns*, not tables, and a table is reported green when the columns @@ -1935,9 +2032,12 @@ because each of them changed what a measurement means: | **Alpha scored as alpha** (§11.0) | Both sides were composited over opaque white before any metric ran, so alpha error was folded into colour error against one background. | | **`forceOpaque` control** | The alpha corpus is cut-outs and line art — graphic-like content — and the graphics corpus independently prefers more luma. Without a control, "alpha mode wants a different layout" and "this content wants a different layout" are the same measurement. | -Every decision below is taken on the **tune** split. Holdout is consulted once, -at the end (§11.12), for the assembled candidate — repeatedly consulting it -would make it a second tune set. +Every decision below is taken on the **tune** split. Within this round holdout +is consulted once, at the end (§11.12), for the assembled candidate. Across the +file it is not: the same 32 images had already validated rounds 1 and 2, and +§11.12 sets out every time they were read and what each reading decided. +Repeatedly consulting a holdout makes it a second tune set, and this one has +been consulted enough that it has partly become one. ### 11.0 What the measurements needed first @@ -2255,6 +2355,29 @@ and it is the layout §8.1 chose on tune and the one that shipped. Read carefully, that is a tie-break rule failing and the conclusion surviving on other grounds — not a rule confirming itself twice. +**The alpha row.** Alpha mode spends 9 more prefix bits, so the opaque 21-byte +layouts do not fit it. `sweeps/compact-tier-alpha.json` measures 23 alpha +allocations at exactly 21 bytes on the 16 alpha tune images, against the +opaque row's shape resized to alpha mode. §6 used to list this sweep as never +run. Its committed result reproduces the tune figure §11.12 quotes for the +adopted row, −13.00%, to the digit: + +| alpha layout, 21 B | ΔE00 | Δ% | αMAE | more-opaque half (8) | paired CI vs the adopted row | guards (CI) | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| shipped shape A5@4 L9@5 C5@4 | 15.974 | — | 0.2625 | — | [−2.794, −1.361] | — | +| A12@3 L15@4 C1@3 | 14.615 | −8.51% | 0.2144 | −7.67% | [−1.109, −0.378] | ok | +| **A16@3 L12@4 C1@3** (adopted) | **13.898** | **−13.00%** | 0.1851 | **−9.42%** | — | ok | +| A20@3 L9@4 C1@3 | 13.831 | −13.42% | 0.1795 | −9.03% | [−0.079, +0.221] | ok | +| A24@3 L5@4 C2@3 | 13.738 | −14.00% | 0.1726 | −9.23% | [−0.096, +0.401] | ok | + +The adopted row is not the mean's best: `A24@3` is 1.0 pp ahead, and so is +`A20@3` by 0.4 pp. But both paired intervals against the adopted row include +zero, so on this corpus the three are a plateau, as the opaque rows above are. +Within it the adopted row gives the more-opaque half of the images the largest +gain of all 23 arms, which is the same rule §11.3 chose the default tier's alpha +row by. (The paired CI is `adopted − row`, so a positive bound favours the +row.) + > **Superseded.** The paragraph below records the code-4 placement as it was > built. It did not ship that way: `f6417d3` reordered the tier codes by quality before > release, so the compact tier is code **0**, `MAX_TIER` is 4, and @@ -2322,7 +2445,11 @@ to the point where the budget runs out. It is monotone for a long way: | **A28@3 L22@4 C3@3** | **13.005** | **−17.10%** | **−339.9** | 44.48 | 0.1632 | | A40@3 L13@4 C3@3 | 12.906 | −17.74% | −344.8 | 43.38 | 0.1515 | | A48@3 L7@4 C3@3 | 12.885 | −17.87% | −349.1 | 43.34 | 0.1423 | -| A32@2 L24@4 C5@3 | 13.880 | −11.53% | −366.1 | 61.43 | **FAIL** | +| A32@2 L24@4 C5@3 (fails Butteraugli) | 13.880 | −11.53% | −366.1 | **61.43** | 0.1901 | + +(The last row's αMAE cell used to read **FAIL**. That was a guard verdict in a +measurement column: the arm's alpha error is 0.1901, and what fails is its +Butteraugli, 61.43 against the incumbent's 57.38.) Three things fall out. @@ -2340,22 +2467,37 @@ Three things fall out. is that chroma is nearly inert here, not that less of it is always better. 3. **The mean hides a trade, and the trade decides the constant.** -| allocation | all | mostly opaque (<35% transparent) | mostly transparent | -|---|---|---|---| -| A28@3 L22@4 C3@3 | −17.10% | **−7.42%** | −22.60% | -| A32@3 L19@4 C3@3 | −17.19% | −6.79% | −23.09% | -| A40@3 L13@4 C3@3 | −17.74% | −5.68% | −24.58% | -| A48@3 L7@4 C3@3 | −17.87% | −3.86% | −25.82% | +| allocation | all | <35% transparent (4 images) | ≥35% transparent (12) | more-opaque half (8) | more-transparent half (8) | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| **A28@3 L22@4 C3@3** (adopted) | −17.10% | **−7.42%** | −22.60% | **−12.28%** | −24.42% | +| A32@3 L19@4 C3@3 | −17.19% | −6.79% | −23.09% | −11.87% | −25.27% | +| A40@3 L13@4 C3@3 | −17.74% | −5.68% | −24.58% | −12.04% | −26.38% | +| A48@3 L7@4 C3@3 | −17.87% | −3.86% | −25.82% | −11.28% | −27.87% | +| A28@2 L29@4 C3@3 (fails Butteraugli) | −11.76% | −8.52% | −13.59% | −9.63% | −14.98% | Pushing the alpha count higher buys transparent images at the expense of opaque ones, and the mean is driven by this corpus being three-quarters transparent — a property of the corpus, not of the world. **`A 28 @ 3 b, L 22 @ 4 b, a/b 3 @ 3 b`** is adopted: it takes −17.10% overall while giving the at-risk opaque-ish subgroup the largest gain of any **guard-passing** arm (three 2-bit -arms score higher there — −7.5% to −8.5% — but all three fail Butteraugli), -posts the best SSIM2 of the whole sweep, and carries *more* luma than the layout it replaces (22 vs 20). -Choosing the ΔE00-optimal corner instead would trade 0.8 pp of mean for 3.6 pp -of the subgroup most exposed to a different corpus mix. +arms score higher there on the 35% cut — −7.5% to −8.5% — but all three fail +Butteraugli), posts the best SSIM2 of the whole sweep, and carries *more* luma +than the layout it replaces (22 vs 20). Choosing the ΔE00-optimal corner instead +would trade 0.8 pp of mean for 3.6 pp of the subgroup most exposed to a +different corpus mix. + +> **The 35% cut was chosen after the sweep was read, and it holds four +> images.** No record fixes it in advance, and a cut picked while looking at +> the arms can be picked to favour one. So the table also splits the same 16 +> images at their median non-opaque fraction (0.527), a cut the corpus fixes +> before any arm is scored. On that cut the adopted row still gives the +> more-opaque half the largest gain of all 33 arms in `alpha-ceiling`, 2-bit +> arms included: −12.28%, against −12.10% for the next, `A28@3 L19@4 C5@3`, and +> −9.63% for the best 2-bit arm. The margin over the next arm is 0.18 pp on +> eight images, and nothing here tests it, so this is a ranking and not a +> separation. What the median cut shows is that the ranking the adoption rests +> on does not depend on where the line was drawn. Both cuts are bound, so a +> re-run re-derives them. Not a corpus artifact, checked two ways. **Every one of the 16 images improves**, including those only 15–22% transparent. And §11.2's control shows the direction @@ -2411,12 +2553,46 @@ tier 1 — 0.06% behind `A24@3 L22@4 C5@3` — so **one row still serves tiers 1–3** and the `4^(tier−1)` structure is intact. Alpha AC counts are now 16 / 28 / 112 / 448 / 1792 across compact / 0 / 1 / 2 / 3 — monotone, which `validate.py` asserts. -### 11.12 The holdout, consulted once - -Every decision above was taken on tune, with holdout untouched until they were -all frozen. It rejected half of them. -`sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json` and `sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json`, both run -with `--split holdout`. +### 11.12 The holdout, and how often it has been read + +Every decision in this round was taken on tune, with holdout untouched until +they were all frozen. It rejected half of them. `sweeps/v07-holdout-photo.json` +and `sweeps/v07-holdout-alpha.json`, both run with `--split holdout`; the tune +column is the same configs run on tune. + +That is the round's own discipline, and it is not the holdout's history. This +section used to be titled "consulted once", and §11's introduction said the +same. The photographic holdout had in fact been read, and had informed a +decision, in every round before this one: + +1. **Round 1** (§4.3, §4.5): `thumbhash-headtohead` and `holdout-candidates`. + It cleared `L28@4 C15@3` + stack against the ≥3% rule, and made the compact + tier a candidate. +2. **Round 2** (§7.6, §7.12): `final-candidates` and `budget-ladder-optimized`. + It chose `sel_hv = 0.15` over 0 and 0.30 on the holdout ordering, which is + the only evidence that weight has (§7.12), and priced the optional + refinement. +3. **§8.1**: the compact candidates. The holdout preferred `L26@3 C6@3`, and + the compact layout was deferred on it. +4. **§10.3**: `adopted-defaults`. It verified that adoption reproduced the + measured change, and chose nothing. +5. **Round 3** (this section): `v07-holdout-photo` and `v07-holdout-alpha`. It + rejected `sel_hv = 0.30`, the isotropic weights and `alpha_ac_fit`, and + adopted the alpha row and the compact tier. +6. **§11.14**: `rd-budget`. It is the cross-format positioning the spec states + (spec §14.1). + +Its composition moved under it as well. The curated part went from 4 images to +8 in §9, and was replaced by Wikimedia photographs in §9.5; only Kodak24 has +been in it throughout, and every holdout sweep has been re-run on each version. + +Two things follow. First, `sel_hv = 0.15` was **selected** on this split, so the +split cannot also validate it: that value has no out-of-sample evidence at all. +Second, the other readings each saw a holdout that earlier readings had already +steered the candidates towards, so none of them is the clean one-shot test the +pre-registered rule assumes. A result in this file that says "never-tuned +holdout" is describing how the split was meant to be used. The fix is a fresh +split read once, not a rewording (#76). **Photographic holdout (32 images):** @@ -2425,7 +2601,18 @@ with `--split holdout`. | `sel_hv` 0.15 → 0.30 | +0.40%, CI straddles (§11.5) | **+0.56%** | **rejected** | | isotropic weights | −0.17%, CI straddles | +0.62%, guards fail | rejected | | pre-adoption v0.6-derived | +1.59% | +3.87% | (confirms §8 out of sample) | -| compact 21 B `L19@4 C6@3` | −3.39% | −2.78% vs the shipped shape | adopted | +| compact 21 B `L19@4 C6@3` | −3.39% | −2.78%, vs the shipped shape | adopted | + +**The compact row is adopted at −2.78%, below the ≥3% the rule asks for, and +the rule did not apply to it.** `RATIONALE.md`'s rule governs changing a +constant that ships. The compact tier was a new tier code with no incumbent, and +its "shipped shape" is the 26:9 layout resized to 21 bytes, a format nobody +shipped; the −2.78% is reported against it rather than gated on it. The +criterion it was admitted on is the one §8.1 and §8.6 set out before this round +ran: beat ThumbHash on all four metrics, out of sample, at 21 bytes. It does +(the table at the end of this section). That criterion was never written into +`RATIONALE.md` as a rule, which is a gap in the record rather than in the +measurement. Holdout ranks the compact plateau differently from tune — `L26@3 C6@3` leads it at 12.129 against the adopted layout's 12.146 — which is the same tune/holdout @@ -2562,8 +2749,13 @@ neighbourhood. | 271.5 | lqip-modern r48 | 8.321 | −66.3 | 15.83 | 0.2411 | | 404.8 | **WebP** | **7.518** | **−62.6** | **14.21** | **0.2349** | | 411 | ChromaHash tier 3 | 7.783 | −76.8 | 17.94 | 0.2507 | +| 1574.0 | RawRGB565 | 6.570 | −65.5 | 16.47 | 0.2400 | +| 1576.4 | WebP | 5.906 | −47.1 | 11.56 | 0.2165 | +| 1576.6 | JPEG | 6.078 | −51.6 | 12.01 | 0.2225 | +| 1595.6 | **AVIF** | **5.471** | **−47.1** | **11.53** | **0.2157** | +| 1623 | ChromaHash tier 4 | 6.768 | −62.1 | 13.99 | 0.2400 | -Four things this settles. +Four things this settles, and a fifth about the top of the ladder. 1. **The compact tier beats ThumbHash on all four metrics at its own size**, out of sample. That is the positioning claim §8.6 wanted and no shipped @@ -2586,6 +2778,14 @@ Four things this settles. WebP does lead all four. The same ordering holds on tune (8.785 vs 8.944 at ~190 B). §14.1 of the spec states this rather than arguing around it. +5. **At ~1.6 kB every real codec leads, and so, on ΔE00, do raw pixels.** AVIF + leads all four metrics, and WebP and JPEG beat code 4 on all four as well. + ΔE00 goes to AVIF by 19% (5.471 against 6.768). Uncoded RGB565 also beats + code 4 on ΔE00 here (6.570), while losing SSIMULACRA2 and Butteraugli to it + and tying DSSIM. That half is split-dependent: on tune code 4 beats RGB565, + 6.726 against 6.960 (§2). These rows were added in the 2026-09 re-measure; + the table used to stop at 411 B, and the spec's claim about 1.6 kB (§14.1) + cited round 1's §2 instead. The structural weakness §2 identified is narrowed but not gone: lqip-modern still takes SSIMULACRA2 and Butteraugli at ~84 B, where ChromaHash wins ΔE00 by @@ -2692,8 +2892,9 @@ Four things this settles. `w_min 0.85`'s interval clears zero by a margin a different bootstrap seed can erase, and on intervals its guards are `inconclusive` rather than failed.) The - pre-registered rule wants ≥3% ΔE00 *improvement* with all guards improving; - this is the opposite sign. **The v0.6 rejection stands — and now it stands on + pre-registered rule wants ≥3% ΔE00 *improvement* with no guard regressing + (the guards must hold, not improve); this is the opposite sign, and the + guards regress as well. **The v0.6 rejection stands — and now it stands on evidence rather than on an instrument that could not see the other half.** 3. **The effect is entirely luma.** `luma only` reproduces the both-channel arm almost exactly (spurious 1.90 vs 1.80, ΔE00 +1.53% vs +1.51%), while @@ -3010,13 +3211,19 @@ fixed across arms; `r` is Pearson over all 31. | code 3 | 3.95 | 4.50 | 4.22 | +0.03 | | code 4 | 3.81 | 4.79 | 4.12 | **0.00** | -**The correlation does not survive the ladder.** At the low tiers the format -invents most on the *smooth* photographs — a handful of coefficients laid across -a near-flat field, which is the classic low-order-basis banding, and which is -also why ringing is highest on smooth content at every tier (r = −0.13 to -−0.30). At the upper tiers that relationship is simply gone: r reaches +0.03 and -0.00, and the bins stop being monotone in either direction, peaking on the -middle tercile and falling back on the most textured one. +**No tier's correlation with detail is distinguishable from zero.** At +n = 31, |r| must reach 0.355 to differ from zero at 0.05, and the largest here is +−0.29 at code 0, with a 95% interval of [−0.59, +0.07]. This table used to say +the correlation "does not survive the ladder", which reads a relationship into +the low tiers that the sample never established: there was nothing to survive. +What remains is descriptive, and is read as a lean rather than a finding. At +the low tiers the bins lean towards inventing most on the *smooth* photographs +(r = −0.29, −0.17, −0.20 at codes 0–2) — a handful of coefficients laid across a +near-flat field would do that, as low-order-basis banding — and ringing leans +the same way at every tier (r = −0.13 to −0.30, none significant). At the upper +tiers even the lean is gone: r is +0.03 and 0.00, and the bins stop being +monotone in either direction, peaking on the middle tercile and falling back on +the most textured one. An earlier form of this table read as a clean sign change — the invention following the texture at codes 3 and 4 — and that reading was an artifact of the @@ -3024,29 +3231,34 @@ instrument, not of the format. The pinned grid was double-quantizing every decode whose raster sat above it, which inflated the upper tiers' spurious scores in proportion to how far they had been pinned; `metrics/spurious.ts` records the defect and `selftest:metrics` now pins it shut. What is left is -weaker and stranger than the sign change, and it is what the corpus actually -says: whatever selects the smooth photographs at the low tiers stops operating -by code 3, and nothing legible replaces it. +weaker than the sign change, and at this sample size it is not a relationship +at all: a lean at the low tiers that no test here can tell from noise, and no +lean above them. -That still leaves two different defects wearing one number, and they still want -two different answers — but only the low-tier one has a shape this corpus can -describe. Nothing above distinguishes them, and no aggregate could. +Whether low-tier banding and upper-tier invention are two different defects, +wanting two different answers, is therefore still open. This corpus cannot +separate them by detail, and no aggregate could. Two supporting axes, same sweep: -* **Chroma.** Spurious tracks mean C* strongly at the low tiers (r = +0.44, - +0.41, +0.53 at codes 0–2) and about half as strongly above them (+0.19, - +0.25). Saturated content drives invented structure hardest where the chroma - budget is tightest — 6 coefficients at code 0, 15 at code 1 — and this is the - one covariate that keeps pointing the same way all the way up the ladder. -* **Lightness.** Spurious is lowest on high-key photographs at every tier +* **Chroma.** This is the one axis that reaches significance. Spurious tracks + mean C* at the low tiers (r = +0.44, +0.41, +0.53 at codes 0–2, all three + past the 0.355 threshold, though only code 2's survives Holm across the five + tiers) and about half as strongly above them (+0.19, +0.25, neither + significant). Saturated content drives invented structure hardest where the + chroma budget is tightest — 6 coefficients at code 0, 15 at code 1 — and the + sign is the same all the way up the ladder. +* **Lightness.** Spurious leans lowest on high-key photographs at every tier (r = −0.03 to −0.36), which is the DC-dominated case: little AC amplitude to - get wrong. + get wrong. Only code 2's −0.36 reaches the threshold, and it does not survive + Holm. -And the fidelity side, for contrast: ΔE00's correlation with detail *strengthens* -monotonically with tier, +0.23 at code 0 to **+0.56** at code 4. The upper tiers -help smooth photographs far more than textured ones — so the format's error is -becoming more content-dependent as the budget grows, not less. +And the fidelity side, for contrast: ΔE00's correlation with detail rises with +tier, +0.23 at code 0 to **+0.56** at code 4, and is significant only at codes 3 +and 4 (+0.44 and +0.56, both surviving Holm). There the upper tiers help smooth +photographs more than textured ones, so the format's error becomes more +content-dependent as the budget grows, not less. Below code 3 the sample cannot +say. ### 13.4 What this says for v0.8, and what it does not @@ -3064,16 +3276,22 @@ Stated as measurements, not as a plan. Nothing here adopts anything. paired interval that excludes zero. A taper judged there is judged where there is least invented structure for it to remove. The interesting measurement — the same taper at codes 3 and 4 — has not been made. -* **Two defects, not one.** A change that suppresses low-order banding on smooth - content and a change that stops the basis fighting real texture are different - changes, and §13.3 says a single corpus mean will always report their sum. +* **Possibly two defects, not one.** A change that suppresses low-order banding + on smooth content and a change that stops the basis fighting real texture + would be different changes, and a single corpus mean would report their sum. + But §13.3 does not show that both exist: at n = 31 no tier's correlation with + detail differs from zero. Telling them apart needs a larger or stratified + corpus, not this one. * **U19 is still the ceiling, and this round raises it again.** §12.5 said so of two metrics; there are now three, and §13.2's central claim — that a 1:1 - invention-to-deficit ratio is *worse* than a 1:7 one at the same ΔE00 — is a - claim about human judgement that nothing in this repo has ever validated. - (1:1 and 1:7 are §13.1's 0.92 at code 4 and 0.14 at code 1 — the same two - figures the first bullet quotes, and the only ratios either table supports.) - It is stated as an exchange rate rather than a verdict for that reason. + invention-to-deficit ratio is *worse* than a 1:7 one — is a claim about human + judgement that nothing in this repo has ever validated. (1:1 and 1:7 are + §13.1's 0.92 at code 4 and 0.14 at code 1 — the same two figures the first + bullet quotes, and the only ratios either table supports.) Nor are the two + ratios at the same fidelity: code 4's ΔE00 is 6.726 and code 1's 11.473, so the + comparison is between two different amounts of error split two different ways, + not between two splits of one amount. It is stated as an exchange rate rather + than a verdict for both reasons. ### 13.5 The statistics behind every table, re-read (2026-09) @@ -3120,7 +3338,7 @@ against its incumbent: | sweep | arms | ΔE00 p < 0.05 | after Holm | guards (CI) ok | inconclusive | FAIL | ok on means, not on CI | FAIL on means, not shown on CI | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| -| all committed sweeps | 504 | 391 | 354 | 282 | 114 | 108 | 48 | 66 | +| all committed sweeps | 839 | 617 | 562 | 507 | 168 | 164 | 83 | 85 | | `selection-weights` | 28 | 12 | 1 | 0 | 27 | 1 | 12 | 15 | | `alpha-layout` | 33 | 22 | 10 | 20 | 4 | 9 | 0 | 4 | | `refine-ablation` | 16 | 9 | 4 | 7 | 9 | 0 | 3 | 6 | @@ -3130,6 +3348,10 @@ against its incumbent: | `holdout-candidates-holdout` | 13 | 13 | 13 | 8 | 0 | 5 | 0 | 0 | | `final-candidates-holdout` | 16 | 16 | 16 | 13 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 1 | +(The first row sums every committed result, so it grew from 504 arms to 839 +when the 2026-09 re-measure committed the §6 sweeps no table had bound. The +eight rows below it did not move: those sweeps re-ran per-image identical.) + What it says: 1. **Both adoptions stand on the stricter reading.** Every arm §4.5 and §7.12 @@ -3173,20 +3395,23 @@ So every arm of a sweep, all scored over one image list, is resampled with the *same* indices. The intervals in one table are therefore not independent Monte Carlo draws: their resampling errors move together rather than averaging out. That is deliberate, because it makes every quoted interval reproducible to the -digit. Its cost was measured once with `mise run arms --seed-sensitivity`, which -re-derives all 504 committed ΔE00 intervals against their incumbents under 20 -other seeds: +digit. Its cost is measured with `mise run arms --seed-sensitivity`, which +re-derives every committed ΔE00 interval against its incumbent under 20 other +seeds. Over the 54 results of the 2026-09 re-measure that is 839 intervals +(it was 504 over the 36 results this section was first written against): -* The largest move of either bound is 0.164 ΔE00, which is 15.5% of that - interval's width. -* 14 arms' intervals change whether they exclude zero under some seed. -* 10 arms change their Holm verdict. +* The largest move of either bound is 0.295 ΔE00, and the largest move relative + to its own interval's width is 15.5%. (These are two separate maxima; this + list used to print them as one interval's.) +* 23 arms' intervals change whether they exclude zero under some seed. +* 14 arms change their Holm verdict. Among the rows this file quotes, §12.2's `w_min 0.85` [−0.077, −0.003] is one -of the 14, and §11.1's `L22@4 C14@3` is one of the 10. An interval whose bound sits within about a tenth of its width of -zero is decided by the seed as much as by the data. The -remedy is more resamples, not another seed. It would move every interval this -file quotes, so it belongs with the next full re-measure rather than here. +of the 23, and §11.1's `L22@4 C14@3` is one of the 14. An interval whose bound +sits within about a tenth of its width of zero is decided by the seed as much as +by the data. The remedy is more resamples, not another seed. It would move every +interval this file quotes, and the 2026-09 re-measure kept the method fixed so +that its intervals stay comparable with this section's; the change is #88. **Correlations.** `stratify` now prints a Fisher-z interval for each `r`, the t-test p, a Holm p across the five tiers, and the threshold for its n: at diff --git a/spec/README.md b/spec/README.md index de23211..5098f35 100644 --- a/spec/README.md +++ b/spec/README.md @@ -1505,10 +1505,11 @@ compatibility** with the v0.6 bitstream. The framing changes are: Together the four constants-level and encoder-side changes above are worth **−3.72% mean ΔE00** at the default tier on a never-tuned holdout split, with SSIMULACRA2, Butteraugli and DSSIM -all improving. `spec/EXPERIMENTS.md` §8 records the measurements and what was rejected — -including the equal-quality byte saving this paragraph used to quote (the optimized 32-byte -encode matching the v0.6 constants at 40 bytes), which §8.3 withdrew: it was read off a -ladder of the *pre-adoption* signal path, and no current sweep produces one. +all improving. `spec/EXPERIMENTS.md` §8 records the measurements and what was rejected. +The equal-quality byte saving this paragraph used to quote (the optimized 32-byte encode +matching the v0.6 constants at 40 bytes) was withdrawn for want of a pre-adoption ladder on +the current corpus, and has since been re-measured in `EXPERIMENTS.md` §7.12: it holds on +the holdout split and falls short of 40 bytes on the tune split. The DCT, OKLAB color pipeline, ℓ2-ball candidate set, µ-law quantizer, decode-aware DC search, and gamut handling are **inherited from the v0.6 algorithm** (now parameterized by @@ -1636,11 +1637,14 @@ SSIMULACRA2 off size-matched WebP. Below 48 bytes no general codec can produce o all, which is the compact and default tiers' whole argument. Codes 3 and 4 are **not** justified that way, and this specification does not claim they -are. Measured at equal bytes on the same corpus, WebP overtakes ChromaHash somewhere -around 300 bytes, and by ~1.6 kB even uncoded RGB565 pixels score better than code 4 -(`EXPERIMENTS.md` §2, §3). Entropy coding would recover roughly 4% — nowhere near the -20–40% gap, and it would cost the O(1) length check that *is* this format's validity -check (§2.6). +are. Measured at equal bytes on the same corpus (`EXPERIMENTS.md` §11.14, holdout split), +WebP overtakes ChromaHash on ΔE00 between 193 and 411 bytes. At ~1.6 kB AVIF scores +5.471 mean ΔE00 against code 4's 6.768, and WebP and JPEG also beat code 4 on every +metric. Even uncoded RGB565 pixels edge code 4 on ΔE00 there, 6.570, though not on +SSIMULACRA2 or Butteraugli, and not on the tune split, where code 4 wins (§2). +Entropy coding would recover a few percent (§7.13: 1.6% at 32 B, 4.8% at 108 B) — well +short of that gap, and it would cost the O(1) length check that *is* this format's +validity check (§2.6). They are kept for the operational properties they share with the rest of the format, and those are real: no codec dependency, no decoder CVE surface, no container or metadata @@ -1669,12 +1673,12 @@ is a few hundred bytes and the target is intentionally low-pass. | Gaborish | Small post-decode smoothing convolution | **Re-evaluated, still off** — the decode-side synthesis window (`window_weights`, a Hann taper, disabled by default). `EXPERIMENTS.md` §12.2–§12.3 measured it at codes 1 and 2 with artifact metrics that did not exist when v0.6 rejected it: it removes up to 73% of the invented structure and costs ΔE00 and SSIMULACRA2 monotonically, failing the guards at every strength. At code 2 the lightest taper is statistically free on ΔE00 and fails on SSIMULACRA2 alone. | | Edge-preserving filter (EPF) | Adaptive deringing loop filter | **Reject** — a blurred placeholder has few edges to preserve. | | DC image + DC predictors | Separate DC plane with spatial predictors | **N/A** — chromahash has a single average-color DC per channel, already chosen by the decode-aware DC search (§10.3). | -| **Quantization weighting matrices (HVS/CSF)** | Frequency-dependent quant step | **Evaluate / adopt** — a frequency-shaped bit allocation generalizes the existing two-tier `AcLayout` L split; cheap and on-trend with HVS sensitivity. | +| **Quantization weighting matrices (HVS/CSF)** | Frequency-dependent quant step | **Built as scalefactor bands; below threshold, not adopted** — `EXPERIMENTS.md` §11.9 measured a frequency-shaped scale split on the current corpus: the best arm is −0.13% ΔE00, far under the ≥3% retune rule and unable to pay for signalling it. This row read "evaluate / adopt" until that sweep ran, and is kept as the prediction it scored against. | | **Entropy coding (rANS + context modeling + clustering, HybridUint tokens)** | Adaptive entropy coding of quantized coefficients | **Highest-impact v0.8+** — fixed-width µ-law leaves the most on the table; many high-frequency coefficients quantize to zero and would cost almost nothing under an entropy coder, raising the quality ceiling per byte. Heaviest to make bit-exact across all language bindings (incl. the hand-written TS decoder) and it trades away the fixed-per-tier length, so it is deferred deliberately. | | Coefficient ordering / scan + nonzero context | Frequency-ordered scan, run/EOB modeling | **Already frequency-ordered** — the top-K isotropic selection is exactly this; pairs naturally with entropy coding when added. | | Patches / splines / dots | Reference repeated elements / smooth gradients / point sources | **Reject** — no repeated elements or point sources in a placeholder; the DCT already models smooth gradients compactly. | | Noise synthesis | Add a per-image perceptual noise model at decode | **Low-priority option** — a few bits of noise amplitude could add cheap perceptual texture; minor. | -| **Progressive / responsive passes** | DC-first, then refinement passes (embedded scalability) | **Compelling v0.8 direction** — make higher tiers *embedded* (the default-tier bytes are a prefix of code 2, etc.) so one stored hash serves both an instant preview and an on-demand detailed render. Constrains the layout but is very LQIP-appropriate. | +| **Progressive / responsive passes** | DC-first, then refinement passes (embedded scalability) | **Built; an operational feature, not a quality one** — `EXPERIMENTS.md` §7.11 implemented embedded tiers (interleaved AC codes, any prefix decodable). The first 32 bytes of a 108-byte hash score 4.21% worse ΔE00 than a native 32-byte encode, so one stored hash can serve both sizes at that price. This row read "compelling v0.8 direction" until that sweep ran; whether the operational gain is worth ~4% is a v0.8 decision, not a measurement. | | Upsampling (2×/4×/8×) | Store small, upsample at decode with a fixed kernel | **Already covered** — the DCT renders at any target size and `decodeCapped` band-limits (§6.4, §11.3). | **Summary of the roadmap, as written for v1 — and how it scored.** The four directions diff --git a/tools/comparison/src/verify-claims.ts b/tools/comparison/src/verify-claims.ts index eeb9953..75492b0 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/src/verify-claims.ts +++ b/tools/comparison/src/verify-claims.ts @@ -359,6 +359,34 @@ const REGISTER: Claim[] = [ return ((webp - t2) / webp) * 100; }, }, + // The spec's case against codes 3–4 at ~1.6 kB. It used to cite round 1's + // §2 for "even uncoded RGB565 pixels score better than code 4", which §2's + // own note had marked as no longer holding on tune, while nothing checked + // holdout. §11.14 now carries the 1.6 kB rows, and the sentence quotes them. + { + file: "spec/README.md", + what: "AVIF at ~1.6 kB on holdout", + pattern: /At ~1\.6 kB AVIF scores\n([\d.]+) mean ΔE00/, + section: "11.14", + row: "1595.6", + column: "ΔE00 ↓", + }, + { + file: "spec/README.md", + what: "code 4 on holdout", + pattern: /mean ΔE00 against code 4's ([\d.]+),/, + section: "11.14", + row: "1623", + column: "ΔE00 ↓", + }, + { + file: "spec/README.md", + what: "raw RGB565 at ~1.6 kB on holdout", + pattern: /edge code 4 on ΔE00 there, ([\d.]+),/, + section: "11.14", + row: "1574.0", + column: "ΔE00 ↓", + }, // ── The AC bit-depth trade, §7.4 of the spec ───────────────────────────── { diff --git a/tools/comparison/src/verify-experiments.ts b/tools/comparison/src/verify-experiments.ts index e14397c..6dcdf2e 100644 --- a/tools/comparison/src/verify-experiments.ts +++ b/tools/comparison/src/verify-experiments.ts @@ -68,6 +68,7 @@ import { readFileSync, readdirSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; import path from "node:path"; import { parseArgs } from "node:util"; +import { ALPHA_IMAGES } from "./alpha-images.ts"; import { type DocTable, cells, @@ -364,6 +365,40 @@ interface RowBinding extends CommonBinding { * say this. Column overrides win where both apply. */ rowBaselines?: Partial>; + /** + * Per-column image subset, for a column that restates a Δ% over part of the + * corpus. The column's metric must be `ciedeDeltaPct`, and it is recomputed + * as the ratio of the two arms' mean ΔE00 over the images the predicate + * keeps. §11.3's subgroup table is the case: its cut decides a constant, and + * until it was bound nothing re-derived it. + */ + subsets?: Partial>; +} + +/** Whether `image` belongs to a subset of `images`, the result's whole list. */ +type ImageSubset = (image: string, images: readonly string[]) => boolean; + +/** + * Mean-ΔE00 Δ% of `row` against `baseline` over the images `subset` keeps, or + * null when it keeps none that both arms scored. + */ +function subsetDeltaPct( + row: SweepRow, + baseline: SweepRow, + subset: ImageSubset, +): number | null { + let r = 0; + let b = 0; + let n = 0; + for (const [i, name] of row.imageNames.entries()) { + const rv = row.perImageCiede[i]; + const bv = baseline.perImageCiede[i]; + if (rv == null || bv == null || !subset(name, row.imageNames)) continue; + r += rv; + b += bv; + n++; + } + return n > 0 && b !== 0 ? ((r - b) / b) * 100 : null; } /** @@ -372,7 +407,18 @@ interface RowBinding extends CommonBinding { * per byte budget. */ type ColumnSeries = - | { docRow: string; sweep: string; metric: Metric; baseline?: string } + | { + docRow: string; + sweep: string; + metric: Metric; + baseline?: string; + /** + * Per-series override of the binding's `resolve`. §4.5 and §7.12 put two + * ladders from one sweep in one table, both indexed by byte budget, so + * the budget alone cannot say which arm a row means. + */ + resolve?: Resolver; + } /** * A row the document derives from two others, e.g. "tune Δ" beneath * "tune, shipped" and "tune, tuned". Checking these is the point: §4.1 @@ -797,12 +843,15 @@ function checkRowTable( const metric = b.columns[header]; if (!metric) continue; const overrideBase = b.baselines?.[header] ?? b.rowBaselines?.[docLabel]; - const measured = measure( - metric, - sweepRow, - overrideBase ? findRow(sweep, overrideBase) : baseline, - sweep, - ); + const base = overrideBase ? findRow(sweep, overrideBase) : baseline; + const subset = b.subsets?.[header]; + if (subset && metric !== "ciedeDeltaPct") { + return `§${b.section} table ${table.index} [${header}]: a subset column must be ciedeDeltaPct`; + } + const measured = + subset && base + ? subsetDeltaPct(sweepRow, base, subset) + : measure(metric, sweepRow, base, sweep); if (measured === null) continue; compare( { @@ -934,8 +983,9 @@ function checkColumnTable( for (const [i, colLabel] of table.header.entries()) { if (i === 0) continue; + const resolve = series.resolve ?? b.resolve; const sweepRow = - b.resolve?.(sweep.rows, [colLabel]) ?? + resolve?.(sweep.rows, [colLabel]) ?? findRow(sweep, b.aliases?.[colLabel] ?? colLabel); if (!sweepRow) { failures.push({ @@ -1025,6 +1075,23 @@ const byBudget: Resolver = (rows, docCells) => { return rows.filter((r) => r.bytes === want).at(-1); }; +/** + * {@link byBudget} restricted to the arms whose label contains `marker`: the + * byte budget picks the column, the marker picks which of the sweep's ladders. + * Exactly one arm must match, so a second ladder added at the same budget + * fails the row rather than silently choosing one of them. + */ +const byBudgetIn = + (marker: string): Resolver => + (rows, docCells) => { + const want = Number((docCells[0] ?? "").replace(/[*\s]/g, "")); + if (!Number.isFinite(want)) return undefined; + const hits = rows.filter( + (r) => r.bytes === want && r.label.includes(marker), + ); + return hits.length === 1 ? hits[0] : undefined; + }; + /** * §11.14 lists a format at several budgets, so the format name alone is * ambiguous. Key on the name plus the byte column, allowing the rounding the @@ -1048,6 +1115,16 @@ const byFormatAndBytes: Resolver = (rows, docCells) => { .find((r) => Math.abs((r.bytes ?? 0) - bytes) < 1); }; +/** + * {@link byFormatAndBytes} for a table that names the format in its first cell + * and the budget in its second (§11.12's positioning table). Handing that row + * to the §11.14 resolver as-is read the format name as the byte count: the + * resolver found nothing, and every row was matched by the label fallback + * instead, so the byte column never took part in choosing the row. + */ +const byFormatThenBytes: Resolver = (rows, docCells) => + byFormatAndBytes(rows, [docCells[1] ?? "", docCells[0] ?? ""]); + /** * §11.12's alpha rows, shared by its two bindings: the `tune` and `holdout` * columns are the same candidates measured by two runs of one config. @@ -1067,6 +1144,63 @@ const ALPHA_HOLDOUT_ALIASES: Record = { "compact alpha A16@3 L12@4 C1@3": "compact 21B ADOPTED A16@3 L12@4 C1@3", }; +/** + * An alpha image's pinned non-opaque fraction. Throws rather than returning + * NaN: a subset that silently dropped an unknown image would be a different + * cut of a different corpus. + */ +function nonOpaqueFraction(image: string): number { + const f = ALPHA_IMAGES.find((a) => a.label === image)?.nonOpaqueFraction; + if (f === undefined) { + throw new Error(`no nonOpaqueFraction pinned for ${image}`); + } + return f; +} + +/** Images less than `cut` transparent, or (`above`) at least `cut`. */ +const transparency = + (cut: number, above: boolean): ImageSubset => + (image) => + above ? nonOpaqueFraction(image) >= cut : nonOpaqueFraction(image) < cut; + +/** + * The more-opaque or more-transparent half of the images a result scored, + * split at their median non-opaque fraction. The cut is a property of the + * corpus alone, fixed before any arm is read. + */ +const transparencyHalf = + (above: boolean): ImageSubset => + (image, images) => { + const sorted = images.map(nonOpaqueFraction).sort((a, b) => a - b); + const mid = sorted.length / 2; + const median = + sorted.length % 2 === 0 + ? ((sorted[mid - 1] ?? 0) + (sorted[mid] ?? 0)) / 2 + : (sorted[Math.floor(mid)] ?? 0); + return transparency(median, above)(image, images); + }; + +/** §11.3's subgroup columns, by header. */ +const ALPHA_SUBSETS: Record = { + "<35% transparent (4 images)": transparency(0.35, false), + "≥35% transparent (12)": transparency(0.35, true), + "more-opaque half (8)": transparencyHalf(false), + "more-transparent half (8)": transparencyHalf(true), +}; + +/** §11.12's photographic rows, shared by its tune and holdout bindings. */ +const V07_PHOTO_ALIASES: Record = { + "`sel_hv` 0.15 → 0.30": "sel_hv=0.30", + "isotropic weights": "isotropic (aniso=0 hv=0)", + "pre-adoption v0.6-derived": "pre-adoption v0.6-derived", + "compact 21 B `L19@4 C6@3`": "compact 21B L19@4 C6@3", +}; + +/** As {@link ALPHA_HOLDOUT_ROW_BASELINES}: a 21 B row is read against the 21 B shape. */ +const V07_PHOTO_ROW_BASELINES: Record = { + "compact 21 B `L19@4 C6@3`": "compact 21B shipped shape", +}; + /** * §13's ladder rows. The document names a tier by its code and role; the sweep * labels carry the byte count too, because a decision table read on its own @@ -1116,6 +1250,82 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ }, }, + // §4.2 — one base allocation at two budgets, so each column is a different + // arm of allocation-grid and each gets its own binding. The parenthesised + // Δ in each cell restates the score against the shipped row; the score is + // what is checked. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "4.2", + table: 0, + sweep: "allocation-grid", + columns: { "32 B ΔE00": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { + "L26@5 C9@4 — **shipped**": "32B SHIPPED L26@5 C9@4", + "L28@4 C15@3": "32B L28@4 C15@3", + "L38@4 C8@3": "32B L38@4 C8@3", + "L28@4 C11@4": "32B L28@4 C11@4", + "L44@3 C11@3": "32B L44@3 C11@3", + "L29@5 C9@3": "32B L29@5 C9@3", + }, + }, + { + kind: "rows", + section: "4.2", + table: 0, + sweep: "allocation-grid", + columns: { "108 B ΔE00": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { + "L26@5 C9@4 — **shipped**": "108B SHIPPED (t1)", + "L28@4 C15@3": "108B L28@4 C15@3", + "L38@4 C8@3": "108B L38@4 C8@3", + "L28@4 C11@4": "108B L28@4 C11@4", + "L44@3 C11@3": "108B L44@3 C11@3", + "L29@5 C9@3": "108B L29@5 C9@3", + }, + }, + + // §4.4 — the encoder levers, one column per lever, so one binding per + // column as §4.2. A "—" cell is a lever the sweep does not run at that + // budget. + ...( + [ + [ + "shipped", + { + "21 B": "21 B shipped-quant", + "32 B": "32 B shipped", + "108 B": "108 B shipped-quant", + "411 B": "411 B shipped-quant", + }, + ], + ["ac_nearest", { "32 B": "32 B ac_nearest" }], + ["scale_fit=1", { "32 B": "32 B scale_fit=1" }], + ["scale_fit=2", { "32 B": "32 B scale_fit=2" }], + [ + "fit2 + nearest", + { + "21 B": "21 B fit2+nearest", + "32 B": "32 B fit2+nearest", + "108 B": "108 B fit2+nearest", + "411 B": "411 B fit2+nearest", + }, + ], + ] as const + ).map( + ([column, aliases]): RowBinding => ({ + kind: "rows", + section: "4.4", + table: 0, + sweep: "encoder-compute", + columns: { [column]: "meanCiede" }, + aliases, + skipRows: ["21 B", "32 B", "108 B", "411 B"].filter( + (budget) => !(budget in aliases), + ), + }), + ), + // §1 — the rate–distortion ladder, one column per byte budget. { kind: "columns", @@ -1151,6 +1361,31 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ }, ], }, + // §1's 32 B column is the ladder's own 26:9 arm, which is not the layout the + // default tier ships (L28@4 C15@3). The shipped arm is the ladder's + // incumbent, and this table puts the two side by side on both splits. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "1", + table: 3, + sweep: "budget-ladder", + columns: { "ΔE00 tune": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { + "ladder shape, L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4": "32 B t0 L26/C9", + "**shipped default, L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3**": "32 B t0 SHIPPED", + }, + }, + { + kind: "rows", + section: "1", + table: 3, + sweep: "budget-ladder-holdout", + columns: { "ΔE00 holdout": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { + "ladder shape, L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4": "32 B t0 L26/C9", + "**shipped default, L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3**": "32 B t0 SHIPPED", + }, + }, // §4.3 — the 21 B head-to-head against ThumbHash, both splits. { @@ -1228,20 +1463,47 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ kind: "columns", section: "4.5", table: 1, - resolve: byBudget, series: [ + { + docRow: "tune, pre-adoption shipped", + sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned", + metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("pre-adoption"), + }, { docRow: "tune, tuned", sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned", metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("tuned"), + }, + { + docRow: "tune Δ", + pctFrom: { + base: "tune, pre-adoption shipped", + cand: "tune, tuned", + }, + }, + { + docRow: "holdout, pre-adoption shipped", + sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned-holdout", + metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("pre-adoption"), }, { docRow: "holdout, tuned", sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned-holdout", metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("tuned"), + }, + { + docRow: "holdout Δ", + pctFrom: { + base: "holdout, pre-adoption shipped", + cand: "holdout, tuned", + }, }, ], - note: "The `pre-adoption shipped` rows, and the Δ rows derived from them, are round 1's baseline — the v0.6-derived constants, whose ladder run no longer exists on disk. §1 carries the ladder for the constants that ship today.", + note: "Both ladders are arms of budget-ladder-tuned: the round-1 recipe, and the v0.6-derived format resized to each budget with the four selection/encoder knobs pinned off. The pre-adoption rows once quoted the retired corpus's §2 ladder, which put every Δ below them on two different corpora.", }, // §7 — the roadmap items, each behind its own tunable. @@ -1371,18 +1633,30 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ table: 1, resolve: byBudget, series: [ + { + docRow: "tune, pre-adoption shipped", + sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned", + metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("pre-adoption"), + }, { docRow: "tune, optimized", sweep: "budget-ladder-optimized", metric: "meanCiede", }, + { + docRow: "holdout, pre-adoption shipped", + sweep: "budget-ladder-tuned-holdout", + metric: "meanCiede", + resolve: byBudgetIn("pre-adoption"), + }, { docRow: "holdout, optimized", sweep: "budget-ladder-optimized-holdout", metric: "meanCiede", }, ], - note: "As §4.5: the `pre-adoption shipped` rows are round 2's baseline and are not reproducible from a current build.", + note: "The `pre-adoption shipped` rows are the same arms as §4.5 table 1's, from budget-ladder-tuned.", }, // §10.3 — what adoption bought, on both splits. @@ -1480,6 +1754,7 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ aliases: { "shipped A5@4 L20@5 C9@4": "SHIPPED A5@4 L20@5 C9@4", "**A28@3 L22@4 C3@3**": "A28@3 L22@4 C3@3", + "A32@2 L24@4 C5@3 (fails Butteraugli)": "A32@2 L24@4 C5@3", }, skipRows: ["A12@4 L18@4 C9@4", "A20@4 L20@5 C1@4"], note: "The ladder is assembled from two sweeps; the two lower rungs come from alpha-ac-count and are bound below.", @@ -1504,9 +1779,29 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ "**A28@3 L22@4 C3@3**", "A40@3 L13@4 C3@3", "A48@3 L7@4 C3@3", - "A32@2 L24@4 C5@3", + "A32@2 L24@4 C5@3 (fails Butteraugli)", ], }, + // §11.3's subgroup table: the cut the adopted alpha row was chosen on, and + // a second cut fixed by the corpus alone. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.3", + table: 2, + sweep: "alpha-ceiling", + columns: { + all: "ciedeDeltaPct", + "<35% transparent (4 images)": "ciedeDeltaPct", + "≥35% transparent (12)": "ciedeDeltaPct", + "more-opaque half (8)": "ciedeDeltaPct", + "more-transparent half (8)": "ciedeDeltaPct", + }, + subsets: ALPHA_SUBSETS, + aliases: { + "**A28@3 L22@4 C3@3** (adopted)": "A28@3 L22@4 C3@3", + "A28@2 L29@4 C3@3 (fails Butteraugli)": "A28@2 L29@4 C3@3", + }, + }, // §11.10 — the compact tier, on the photographic corpus and cross-checked // against graphics. @@ -1546,14 +1841,36 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ "L26@3 C6@3": "L26@3 C6@3 (§8.1 hold)", }, }, + // The compact tier's alpha row, on the alpha tune split. compact-tier-alpha + // had never been committed; its result is the tune half of §11.12's + // `compact alpha` row. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.10", + table: 2, + sweep: "compact-tier-alpha", + columns: { + ΔE00: "meanCiede", + "Δ%": "ciedeDeltaPct", + αMAE: "meanAlphaMae", + "more-opaque half (8)": "ciedeDeltaPct", + "paired CI vs the adopted row": "ci", + "guards (CI)": "guardsCi", + }, + subsets: { "more-opaque half (8)": transparencyHalf(false) }, + baselines: { "paired CI vs the adopted row": "A16@3 L12@4 C1@3" }, + aliases: { + "**A16@3 L12@4 C1@3** (adopted)": "A16@3 L12@4 C1@3", + }, + }, - // §11.12 — the holdout, consulted once. + // §11.12 — the holdout, in the round that consulted it last. { kind: "rows", section: "11.12", table: 2, sweep: "rd-budget-holdout", - resolve: byFormatAndBytes, + resolve: byFormatThenBytes, labelColumn: 0, columns: { bytes: "bytes", @@ -1584,6 +1901,34 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ "L22@4 C14@3 (the arithmetic in §8.1)": "L22@4 C14@3 (arithmetic)", }, }, + // §11.2 — the control: its two columns are two sweeps over the same images. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.2", + table: 0, + sweep: "alpha-layout-control", + columns: { "opaque mode (control)": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { + "v0.6 shape L26@5 C9@4": "v0.6 shape L26@5 C9@4", + "**the photographic winner** L28@4 C15@3": "DEFAULT L28@4 C15@3", + "L46@4 C2@3 (chroma-starved)": "L46@4 C2@3", + }, + skipRows: ["L39@4 C2@3 (chroma-starved)"], + }, + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.2", + table: 0, + sweep: "alpha-layout", + columns: { "alpha mode (§11.1)": "meanCiede" }, + aliases: { "L39@4 C2@3 (chroma-starved)": "L39@4 C2@3" }, + skipRows: [ + "v0.6 shape L26@5 C9@4", + "**the photographic winner** L28@4 C15@3", + "L35@3 C16@3", + "L46@4 C2@3 (chroma-starved)", + ], + }, { kind: "rows", section: "11.4", @@ -1718,6 +2063,28 @@ const BINDINGS: Binding[] = [ // itself. The document's figures were right -- they predate the drift -- and // reproduce to the digit once the arms are pinned. Nothing noticed for the // usual reason: the table was unbound. + // §11.12's photographic verdicts: the same config on both splits, so the + // two columns are one measurement taken twice. The holdout column had been + // bound nowhere — the table's note sent the reader to §11.5 and §7.12, which + // are different sweeps — and v07-holdout-photo had no committed result. + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.12", + table: 0, + sweep: "v07-holdout-photo", + columns: { tune: "ciedeDeltaPct" }, + aliases: V07_PHOTO_ALIASES, + rowBaselines: V07_PHOTO_ROW_BASELINES, + }, + { + kind: "rows", + section: "11.12", + table: 0, + sweep: "v07-holdout-photo-holdout", + columns: { holdout: "ciedeDeltaPct" }, + aliases: V07_PHOTO_ALIASES, + rowBaselines: V07_PHOTO_ROW_BASELINES, + }, { kind: "rows", section: "11.12", @@ -1942,15 +2309,14 @@ function mergeCoverage(list: Coverage[]): Map { * "deliberately not bound, and here is the reason". */ const UNBOUND_COLUMN_NOTES: Record = { - "4.5#1": - "the `pre-adoption shipped` rows are round 2's baseline, which no current build reproduces; the two Δ rows derive from them", - "7.12#1": "as §4.5 table 1, same rows and same reason", "7.5#0": "`bits saved` is a property of the header layout each arm sets, not a measurement the sweep makes", "7.10#0": "every row names a *different* control, and two state it in prose inside the cell (\u201c-0.04% vs the same layout without CfL\u201d). rowBaselines could address the first half; the prose cells would still need the sentence parsed, and a binding that silently checked five rows of seven would recreate the problem this listing exists to expose", "11.10#1": "ranks, derived by ordering two other sweeps' results rather than read from either", + "11.12#0": + "`verdict` is the section's conclusion in words, not a measurement", "11.12#1": "`verdict` is the section's conclusion in words, not a measurement. `holdout` is UNREPRODUCIBLE: one of the alpha holdout images, cutout-wordmark-aflac, was deleted from Wikimedia Commons on 2026-08-25 as a copyright violation and has no archived copy, so v07-holdout-alpha --split holdout cannot be re-run and has no committed result (#83)", "13.1#1": @@ -1979,27 +2345,40 @@ const UNBOUND_COLUMN_NOTES: Record = { * +3 and +4, §11.5 +8, §11.10 +8, §12.2 +7, §12.3 +5), and two new tables: * §13.2's paired spurious differences (5 rows × 3) and §13.5's tally (9 rows × * 8). + * + * The 2026-09 re-measure committed a result for every §6 sweep, and bound what + * those results made bindable: §1 table 3 (the shipped 32 B arm beside the + * ladder's, 4), §4.2 (12), §4.4 (11), §11.2 (5), §11.3's subgroup table (25), + * §11.10's compact alpha row (26) and §11.12's photographic verdicts (8); §4.5 + * and §7.12's ladders gained their pre-adoption and Δ rows (22 → 66, 28 → 56); + * §11.3 table 1's αMAE cell that read FAIL now holds a number (+1); and §11.14 + * gained the ~1.6 kB neighbourhood (+25). */ const EXPECTED_CELLS: Record = { "1#0": 26, "1#1": 22, "1#2": 6, + "1#3": 4, "4.1#0": 12, + "4.2#0": 12, "4.3#0": 25, "4.3#1": 25, + "4.4#0": 11, "4.5#0": 61, - "4.5#1": 22, + "4.5#1": 66, "7.1#1": 9, "7.5#0": 21, "7.8#0": 18, "7.10#0": 14, "7.11#0": 15, "7.12#0": 93, - "7.12#1": 28, + "7.12#1": 56, "10.3#0": 27, "11.1#0": 21, + "11.2#0": 5, "11.3#0": 32, - "11.3#1": 37, + "11.3#1": 38, + "11.3#2": 25, "11.4#0": 13, "11.4#1": 17, "11.5#0": 41, @@ -2007,10 +2386,12 @@ const EXPECTED_CELLS: Record = { "11.7#0": 7, "11.10#0": 33, "11.10#1": 6, + "11.10#2": 26, "11.11#0": 34, + "11.12#0": 8, "11.12#1": 3, "11.12#2": 10, - "11.14#0": 85, + "11.14#0": 110, "12.2#0": 67, "12.3#0": 55, "13.1#0": 35, @@ -2102,11 +2483,8 @@ const UNBOUND_NOTES: Record = { "superseded by §11.14 — the record of a round whose run is gone; its ChromaHash rows used a synthesized layout that no longer exists, and its competitor rows predate the cached rd-budget run", "8.6#0": "superseded by §11.14, same reason as §2", - "4.2#0": "an allocation grid quoted at two budgets from one sweep", "4.2#1": "a precision-by-budget matrix: columns are budgets, rows are precisions, and every cell names a different arm", - "4.4#0": - "encoder levers quoted as a budget x lever matrix over encoder-compute.json", "4.7#0": "per-image oracle analysis derived from allocation-grid's perImageCiede, not a sweep row", "4.9#0": "coeff-stats output, not a sweep", @@ -2125,12 +2503,6 @@ const UNBOUND_NOTES: Record = { "curated-corpus vs Wikimedia-corpus figures; the curated corpus no longer exists, same reason as §9.3", "10.2#0": "decode timings, not a corpus measurement", "11.0#0": "a two-row scoring demonstration on one synthetic fixture", - "11.2#0": - "a control table whose two columns are two different sweeps, one arm each", - "11.3#2": - "an alpha subgroup breakdown computed from alpha-ceiling's perImageCiede", - "11.12#0": - "verdict prose: tune and holdout deltas quoted side by side from two sweeps, and bound in §11.5 and §7.12 respectively", "13.3#0": "stratify output, not a sweep: bin means over per-image scores joined to natural-images.ts's covariates. Reproduce with `mise run stratify artifact-ladder-common-grid --metric spurious --by detail`", }; From 4752ea46f55f06a0743a6eb5c120e60eec248fec Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 03:01:09 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 7/9] docs(spec): say where RATIONALE's sweep results live, and flag its unattributable holdout figure MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit RATIONALE still sent readers to the gitignored output/sweeps/ for results that are now committed under tools/comparison/results/. And its account of the v0.6 tune/holdout gap quotes 11.36 (CI 10.3–12.5) as v0.6's holdout score, which matches the v1 row of its own version table (11.364 [10.30, 12.45]) rather than the v0.6 row (11.312 [10.25, 12.39]). No record says which run produced it and the corpus is gone, so the figure is flagged rather than changed. --- spec/RATIONALE.md | 14 +++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 11 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/spec/RATIONALE.md b/spec/RATIONALE.md index f0cae6c..d05102c 100644 --- a/spec/RATIONALE.md +++ b/spec/RATIONALE.md @@ -5,8 +5,10 @@ considered and rejected. Normative text lives in [`README.md`](README.md); this file records the *evidence*. Sweep numbers come from the decision tables produced by `mise run sweep ` -(configs in `tools/comparison/sweeps/`, results in -`tools/comparison/output/sweeps/`) on the **tune split** of the expanded corpus +(configs in `tools/comparison/sweeps/`; results were written to the gitignored +`tools/comparison/output/sweeps/` when this file's figures were taken, and are +now committed under `tools/comparison/results/`, for the current corpus only) +on the **tune split** of the expanded corpus (74 images: 43 synthetic + 31 curated photos; the 32-image holdout — Kodak24 + held-out curated photos — is reserved for validating winners, per the pre-registered rule below). The curated set grew from 26 to 39 photographs in @@ -458,7 +460,13 @@ encoding. corpus. The split immediately quantified the damage: mean ΔE00 6.48 (CI 4.6–8.4) on the tune split vs **11.36 (CI 10.3–12.5) on the never-tuned holdout**. All v1 experiments tune on `tune` and validate on - `holdout` under the pre-registered ≥3%-with-guards rule. + `holdout` under the pre-registered ≥3%-with-guards rule. (The holdout + figure and its interval match the **v1** row of the version table above, + 11.364 [10.30, 12.45], rather than its v0.6 row, 11.312 [10.25, 12.39], + which is what this bullet describes. No record says which run produced + them, and the corpus both were taken on has since been replaced, so neither + can be re-derived; read the pair as the size of the gap, not as v0.6's + score. `EXPERIMENTS.md` §11.12 records how the holdout has been used since.) ## Future work / open questions Explicitly unresolved, so nothing evaluated-in-thought silently disappears: From 62568d538db7a0efdf1aa68869b8ce82164826d0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 03:11:56 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 8/9] docs(spec): record which probe figures the re-measure re-derived, and which label is not today's default MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit §6 no longer claims the one alpha holdout run that cannot be recorded (#83) was re-run. §7.13, like §4.9, reads coeff/entropy figures off the L26@5 C9@4 row the tools call shipped, which is not today's default; both say so, and both reproduced to the digit. §9.5's list of what the Wikimedia re-run left stale gains the two it missed, §4.6 and §4.8. §1 points at its new table by position correctly. --- spec/EXPERIMENTS.md | 18 +++++++++++++----- 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md index 73b1d97..7a74332 100644 --- a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md +++ b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md @@ -86,8 +86,8 @@ That shape is what codes 2–4 ship at 108, 411 and 1623 B. It is **not** what the two lower tiers ship: the default tier (32 B) is `L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3` and the compact tier (21 B) `L 19 @ 4 / C 6 @ 3`, both off this curve and both better than it at their budget. So the 32 and 21 B columns below are the -ladder's shape at those budgets, not the tiers; the third table gives the -shipped default beside it. +ladder's shape at those budgets, not the tiers; the last table in this section +gives the shipped default beside it. Both splits were re-measured together for v0.7. §4.5 and §7.12 quote an **earlier** ladder, taken against the pre-adoption v0.6-derived constants, and @@ -744,8 +744,9 @@ turns one into a failure. Every `sweep` and `rd-budget` line above writes its result to `tools/comparison/results/[-holdout].json`, which is committed, and every -one of them was re-run from a clean tree at one commit, `e310475`, for the -2026-09 re-measure: 54 results, per-image scores and provenance only. +one of them that can still run was re-run from a clean tree at one commit, +`e310475`, for the 2026-09 re-measure: 54 results, per-image scores and +provenance only. The one that cannot is the alpha holdout run (#83). `verify:experiments --strict` checks this file against them in CI. The three `node .../dist/*.js --split tune` probes (`cfl-probe`, `coeff-stats`, `entropy-budget`) and `main.js` are not sweeps, write to the gitignored @@ -1211,7 +1212,10 @@ there the saving is less than 20%, and the holdout figure is the one to quote. `entropy-budget.ts` re-asks §4.9's question with two changes: the code stream is actually coded (sequentially, per image, against a Laplace-smoothed adaptive model) rather than assigned its pooled entropy, and the model is scored -**leave-one-image-out** so the table's own fitting cost is paid. +**leave-one-image-out** so the table's own fitting cost is paid. (As in §4.9, +"shipped" below is the `L 26 @ 5 / C 9 @ 4` row the tool calls shipped, not +today's `L 28 @ 4 / C 15 @ 3` default. Re-run in the 2026-09 re-measure, every +figure in this section reproduces.) | Model | AC bits (of 202 fixed) | vs fixed | honest? | |---|---|---|---| @@ -1890,6 +1894,10 @@ Stated so their absence is not mistaken for agreement: says so in place. **§11.0, §11.2 and §11.3** are the synthetic fixture and the alpha corpus, which the re-source did not touch. `verify:experiments --list-unbound` is the full list. +* **§4.6 and §4.8 were missed by that list**, and still carried the retired + corpus's figures until the 2026-09 re-measure (§6), which re-ran every sweep + at one commit, re-ran the `cfl-probe`, `coeff-stats` and `entropy-budget` + probes, and re-derived both. §4.9, §4.10 and §7.13 reproduced to the digit. ## 10. Adoption: making §8 the default (2026-08) From 1e0895ff0c364f4556e68f76c935413c3fe7416f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Justin Chung Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 12:30:37 -0400 Subject: [PATCH 9/9] docs(spec): state the 32 B vs 40 B equal-quality saving as not separable on holdout MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit The holdout pairing (adopted 32 B minus pre-adoption 40 B) is -0.009 with paired CI [-0.098, +0.082] and 15/32 wins, while tune separates the other way (+0.182, CI [+0.066, +0.308]). Restate §7.12, §8.3 and spec/README.md accordingly: the saving is at most 20%, a match on holdout rather than an improvement. --- spec/EXPERIMENTS.md | 39 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---------- spec/README.md | 5 +++-- 2 files changed, 32 insertions(+), 12 deletions(-) diff --git a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md index 3dd1c1b..9516ef5 100644 --- a/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md +++ b/spec/EXPERIMENTS.md @@ -1199,12 +1199,28 @@ optimized recipe beats the pre-adoption format at every budget on holdout, by 6.5% at 12 B and 1.2–4.6% from 16 to 108 B; above that the raster caveat under §4.5's table applies. -**The equal-quality byte saving, restated.** The adopted 32-byte recipe -(`L28C15 stack`, 11.298 on holdout, the table above) scores better than the -pre-adoption format at **40 bytes** (11.31), so it matches that format with 20% -fewer bytes — the figure round 2 reported, now measured on this corpus and in -one run. On tune it does not reach that far: 11.473 against 11.29 at 40 B, so -there the saving is less than 20%, and the holdout figure is the one to quote. +**The equal-quality byte saving, restated.** Round 2 reported that the adopted +32-byte recipe matches the pre-adoption format at **40 bytes**, a 20% saving. +Paired per image over the same split (adopted minus pre-adoption 40 B, ΔE00, +`bootstrapCI`'s default seed and resamples), the two splits disagree: + +- **Holdout:** 11.298 against 11.307, a difference of −0.009 with CI + [−0.098, +0.082]; the adopted recipe wins on 15 of 32 images. The two are + **not separable**. That is consistent with "matches at 40 B", and it does not + support "better than". +- **Tune:** 11.473 against 11.291, a difference of +0.182 with CI + [+0.066, +0.308]; the adopted recipe wins on 9 of 31. Here the 40-byte + pre-adoption format is **better**, so the saving on tune is less than 20%. + The adopted recipe does separate from the pre-adoption format at 32 B on tune + (−0.182, CI [−0.282, −0.085]), so the tune saving lies strictly between 0 and + 20%. The ladder has no arm between 32 and 40 B to place it more precisely. + +So the evidence bounds the saving at no more than 20%, and reaches 20% only on +the split where the two arms cannot be told apart. Neither split's figure is the +one to quote alone; a statement of the saving carries both. (The holdout pairing +uses `final-candidates-holdout`'s `32B L28C15 stack` against +`budget-ladder-tuned-holdout`'s `40B pre-adoption L34/C12`; the same run's +`32B SHIPPED (ref)` arm gives identical per-image scores.) ### 7.13 U11 — entropy-coded AC, with a real coder instead of an entropy @@ -1442,10 +1458,13 @@ now that §10 has made the optimized recipe the default. > the optimized 32-byte encode matching the pre-adoption format at 40 bytes — > and this section withdrew it, because no sweep produced a pre-adoption ladder > on this corpus. `budget-ladder-tuned` now does, and §7.12 restates it: on -> holdout the adopted recipe at 32 B (11.298) is better than the pre-adoption -> format at 40 B (11.31), so the 20% holds there. On tune it does not reach -> 40 B, so the saving there is smaller. The −3.72% above remains the figure the -> pre-registered rule is judged on. +> holdout the adopted recipe at 32 B (11.298) and the pre-adoption format at +> 40 B (11.307) are not separable (paired CI [−0.098, +0.082]), so the 20% is an +> equal-quality match there and no better. On tune the 40-byte pre-adoption +> format is separably better (paired CI [+0.066, +0.308]), so the saving there is +> less than 20%. The saving is therefore at most 20%, and no single split's +> figure stands for it. The −3.72% above remains the figure the pre-registered +> rule is judged on. At the proposed 21-byte compact tier the format beats ThumbHash on **all four metrics** on holdout (§7.6), which the shipped constants do not. diff --git a/spec/README.md b/spec/README.md index e9c094a..9331bd5 100644 --- a/spec/README.md +++ b/spec/README.md @@ -1511,8 +1511,9 @@ Together the four constants-level and encoder-side changes above are worth **− all improving. `spec/EXPERIMENTS.md` §8 records the measurements and what was rejected. The equal-quality byte saving this paragraph used to quote (the optimized 32-byte encode matching the v0.6 constants at 40 bytes) was withdrawn for want of a pre-adoption ladder on -the current corpus, and has since been re-measured in `EXPERIMENTS.md` §7.12: it holds on -the holdout split and falls short of 40 bytes on the tune split. +the current corpus, and has since been re-measured in `EXPERIMENTS.md` §7.12: on the +holdout split the two are indistinguishable (a match, not an improvement), and on the tune +split the 40-byte v0.6 encode is measurably better, so the saving is at most that figure. The DCT, OKLAB color pipeline, ℓ2-ball candidate set, µ-law quantizer, decode-aware DC search, and gamut handling are **inherited from the v0.6 algorithm** (now parameterized by