From 3927f40befb75694b1efaa7b994c2bacf0a41ece Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?Topi=20J=C3=A4rvinen?= Date: Fri, 11 Sep 2026 09:45:18 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] chore: record ITEM5-B repair delivery and next decision --- docs/kit-handoff.md | 52 ++++++++++--------- saved_plans/codex-parity-plan_2026-08-23.md | 8 +-- ...item5-b-acceptance-execution_2026-09-10.md | 5 +- ...item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md | 13 ++--- ...5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md | 5 +- ...-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md | 46 +++++++++++++--- ...em5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md | 3 +- 7 files changed, 88 insertions(+), 44 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/kit-handoff.md b/docs/kit-handoff.md index 47054d65..db369767 100644 --- a/docs/kit-handoff.md +++ b/docs/kit-handoff.md @@ -14,32 +14,36 @@ > Older session blocks graduate to [`kit-handoff-history.md`](kit-handoff-history.md) once > this file crosses its line budget (`scripts/check_doc_budget.py`). -Last updated: 2026-09-11 — approved ITEM5-B review follow-up applied; operator merge hold. +Last updated: 2026-09-11 — ITEM5-B kit repair merged; retained-update decision remains separate. Phase 5 delivery item 5 remains incomplete; item 6's replay remains complete. -## Latest session — 2026-09-11 (ITEM5-B review follow-up, in Codex) - -The operator approved ITEM5-B-KIT-REVIEW-02 as scoped. The [execution record](../saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) -binds authority, pre-fix review receipts, original bytes and applied hashes. The kit -documents the accepted inherited special-file-root limitation and adds root-symlink -compatibility tests with the supplied release manifest. A FIFO can still obstruct -engine state persistence; the approval does not claim that mechanism is repaired. - -`make test` in `/Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit` at -`1d6c5413148c46ee7a0a4cf86e47e403632610fb` on 2026-09-11 reached pytest's terminal summary with the disclosed #393 -failure. The execution evidence retains the actual result, manifest self-check and -separate #561 shell parses. [PR #731](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731) -owns the final full-panel reports, hosted results and exact head-bound disposition. -Repair merge remains operator-held; an earlier review is not evidence for a later head. - -No retained update, baseline refresh, initialization, client/profile/tracker exercise -or fixture merge was performed. Ownership acceptance does not establish functionality -or field exit. Item 6's replay, #723's deferral, #585's earlier placement and #724's -delivered #722 batch are preserved. The friction sweep stays parked. - -▶ Next: `$session-start` — read back PR #731's final review/CI disposition and exact -reviewed head, then decide operator merge. Keep retained updates separately scoped; -do not repeat UPDATE-01 or the completed replay. +## Latest session — 2026-09-11 (ITEM5-B repair delivery, in Codex) + +The operator approved ITEM5-B-KIT-REVIEW-02 and subsequently said “merge when ready.” +[PR #731](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731) merged as +`e6d6e77d118454349f8e8bb046e99ef3009c5f5c`, from reviewed head +`1bd4e10b423b0b4b230fb1a481bbc477de784a61`. The +[merge checkpoint](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5629015678) +retains the exact-head merge, forge readback and completed review disposition. +The [execution record](../saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) +links the complete panel reports and distinguishes hosted success from the disclosed +local #393 failure. The accepted inherited special-file-root limitation remains; +separate shell parses covered #561's omitted checks without repairing its recipe. + +The resume readback used `gh pr view 731` and `gh run list` with the kit repository +and merge SHA from `/Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit` at +`1bd4e10b423b0b4b230fb1a481bbc477de784a61` on 2026-09-11: merge confirmed and +[post-merge Test run](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/actions/runs/34558574354) succeeded. +This record follow-up began from that protected-main merge. + +Ownership acceptance does not establish functionality or field exit. The repair did +not update the retained installation. Item 6's replay, #723's deferral, #585's earlier +placement and #724's delivered #722 batch are preserved. The friction sweep stays parked. + +▶ Next: prepare the exact retained-update decision packet for the merged #731 repair, +starting from the post-acceptance checkpoint linked in the execution record. Preparation +is authorized; execution needs its own exact decision. Do not repeat UPDATE-01 or the +completed replay, refresh the baseline, exercise clients/profiles/trackers, or merge the fixture PR. ______________________________________________________________________ diff --git a/saved_plans/codex-parity-plan_2026-08-23.md b/saved_plans/codex-parity-plan_2026-08-23.md index eb77d020..8c6d67a3 100644 --- a/saved_plans/codex-parity-plan_2026-08-23.md +++ b/saved_plans/codex-parity-plan_2026-08-23.md @@ -447,11 +447,13 @@ historical observation it was and is not silently refreshed. PR-01 is paused at the recorded P2 inherited detector gap and P3 wording imprecision. The [kit-only repair decision](phase5-item5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md) was approved on 2026-09-10. The [kit repair execution](phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md) - carries the applied kit scope and operator merge hold. Its panel recorded a P2 + carries the applied kit scope and pre-fix review receipts. Its panel recorded a P2 inherited FIFO-root gap and P3 root-symlink coverage gap; the [follow-up packet](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md) was approved as ITEM5-B-KIT-REVIEW-02 on 2026-09-11. The [follow-up execution](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) - owns the applied scope and exact reviewed-head operator merge decision. No retained update is authorized - by that approval. Fixture merge remains excluded; the nonfunctional custom + records the applied scope, final panel and separately authorized merge of kit #731 as + `e6d6e77d118454349f8e8bb046e99ef3009c5f5c`. Prepare the next exact retained-update + decision packet; neither repair approval nor kit merge authorizes its execution. + Fixture merge remains excluded; the nonfunctional custom wrap-up carries ownership acceptance only. No original continuity or prior field credit was recreated. Delivery item 6 is independent of these paths. The approved diff --git a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-acceptance-execution_2026-09-10.md b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-acceptance-execution_2026-09-10.md index 87df5308..594e1249 100644 --- a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-acceptance-execution_2026-09-10.md +++ b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-acceptance-execution_2026-09-10.md @@ -198,8 +198,9 @@ preserves completed item 6 and its replay evidence, cs-toolkit #2222/#2223/#2255 The friction-log sweep remains parked; no tracker payload or new intake was started. **Next:** follow the [approved kit repair execution](phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md) -through the approved REVIEW-02 follow-up to its operator merge decision. A later retained-fixture update still needs its own -exact decision; keep the systemize field-exit matrix and fixture merge separate. +through its REVIEW-02 execution record's verified #731 merge, then prepare the exact +retained-update decision packet. Retained execution still needs its own exact decision; +keep the systemize field-exit matrix and fixture merge separate. ## Kit record review amendment diff --git a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md index be727c2e..f310924b 100644 --- a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md +++ b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-kit-repair-execution_2026-09-10.md @@ -51,10 +51,10 @@ retain argv, directory, revision, timestamps, environment and output hashes. and `sh -n init.sh` exited successfully. These explicitly cover #561's omitted parses; they do not repair the recipe or establish shell behavior. -The independent adversarial/correctness reports, actual rollout compute, mutations, -restoration evidence, hosted results and final exact-head disposition belong on the -repair PR. Read that disposition and revalidate its head before any merge decision; -an earlier fixture or record panel does not review this implementation. +The [follow-up execution](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) +links the repair PR's final independent reports, actual rollout compute, mutations, +restoration evidence, hosted results and exact-head disposition. It also records the +subsequently authorized merge; earlier fixture or record panels do not review this implementation. ## Preservation, limits and rollback @@ -90,5 +90,6 @@ pre-fix receipts remain in the [follow-up packet](phase5-item5-b-review-followup The operator approved that follow-up on 2026-09-11; its [execution record](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) owns the subsequent payloads and review handoff. The earlier panel is not a receipt for a later head. -**Next:** follow that execution to PR #731's exact reviewed-head operator merge decision. -A retained update still needs a separate exact decision; UPDATE-01 is consumed and fixture merge is excluded. +**Next:** follow that execution's verified #731 merge and prepare the exact retained-update +decision packet. A retained update still needs a separate exact execution decision; +UPDATE-01 is consumed and fixture merge is excluded. diff --git a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md index f13e4e48..9994c1fa 100644 --- a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md +++ b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md @@ -4,7 +4,10 @@ question below. The [execution record](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) binds that authority to the unchanged proposal ledger and applied payloads. The preparation evidence retains its historical approval fields and hashes. The inherited -special-file-root limitation is accepted for this repair; it is not fixed. Merge remains operator-held. +special-file-root limitation is accepted for this repair; it is not fixed. +**Delivery amendment, 2026-09-11:** the operator later said “merge when ready”; the +execution record links the verified #731 merge. That separate authorization discharged +the merge hold without changing the preserved approval question or repair ledger. The preserved proposal and its verification/rollback requirements follow. diff --git a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md index d4a8d25c..ebee4cc2 100644 --- a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md +++ b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md @@ -42,10 +42,36 @@ The following ran in `/Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit` at `1d6c5413148c46ee7a The [evidence index](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution-evidence_2026-09-11/sha256.json) retains complete command metadata, raw output, authority, original bytes, applied hashes -and compressed retention checkpoints. A fresh full adversarial/correctness panel and -hosted CI are required at the published review head. Their complete reports, actual -rollout compute and final head-bound disposition belong on PR #731; read them back -before deciding merge. No earlier receipt automatically covers that head. +and compressed retention checkpoints. + +## Final review and separately authorized delivery + +The full [adversarial report](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5628936492) +and [correctness report](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5628930335) +reviewed `1bd4e10b423b0b4b230fb1a481bbc477de784a61` against +`f408039dc3a9b0d2e0e8d246c126af892839cee8` on 2026-09-11. Their complete command +records name the private directories, actual rollout compute, terminal `make test` +results, behavioral mutations and restoration checks. Each local suite reached the +disclosed #393 failure; the reports do not claim a passing local suite. The +[panel disposition](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5628956860) +binds their findings to that exact head. CodeRabbit declined the full-review request; +the [refusal disposition](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5628983875) +records why the completed panel remains the independent review evidence. + +The operator subsequently said “merge when ready.” The +[merge checkpoint](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/pull/731#issuecomment-5629015678) +records the `gh pr merge 731 --squash --match-head-commit` operation, final non-persisting +watch result and forge readback from `/Users/topi/Coding/agentic-dev-kit` at that reviewed +SHA on 2026-09-11. PR #731 merged as `e6d6e77d118454349f8e8bb046e99ef3009c5f5c`. +This later authorization discharged the merge hold; it did not widen the repair ledger. + +Resume reads on 2026-09-11 in the same cockpit at the reviewed SHA used +`gh pr view 731 --repo topij/agentic-dev-kit --json url,state,isDraft,headRefOid,mergedAt,mergeCommit,baseRefName` +and `gh run list --repo topij/agentic-dev-kit --commit e6d6e77d118454349f8e8bb046e99ef3009c5f5c --json databaseId,name,status,conclusion,url,headSha`. +They confirmed the merge and the successful terminal +[post-merge Test run](https://github.com/topij/agentic-dev-kit/actions/runs/34558574354). +`gh api repos/topij/agentic-dev-kit/branches/main` confirmed that merge as protected main. +The ordinary record follow-up began from this merge, preserving the reviewed repair head. ## Preservation and next action @@ -66,6 +92,12 @@ field exit are separate. Item 6's completed replay is preserved without repeat o credit for cs-toolkit #2222/#2223/#2255. Kit #723 remains the approved upstream deferral; #585 stays earlier outside Phase 6; #724 delivered the #722 batch. The friction sweep stays parked. -**Next:** read PR #731's final review/CI disposition and decide operator merge of its -exact reviewed head. This execution approval excludes merge. A later retained update -needs its own exact decision; UPDATE-01 is consumed and fixture PR merge is excluded. +**Next:** prepare the exact retained-update decision packet for the merged #731 repair. +Revalidate read-only against the +[post-acceptance retention checkpoint](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-evidence_2026-09-10/retained-final.json.gz) +and [fixture forge checkpoint](phase5-item5-b-acceptance-execution-evidence_2026-09-10/forge-after-exit.json). +Use the current checkpoint inventory/identity comparison, not the historical UPDATE +FINAL equality assertions as a current-state check. Preserve the original missing paths. +Preparation is authorized; retained execution needs its own exact write ledger and +decision. UPDATE-01 is consumed; baseline refresh, initialization, client/trust/profile +exercises, tracker payloads and fixture PR closure/merge retain their separate decisions. diff --git a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md index 3f7bc07c..21b46df2 100644 --- a/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md +++ b/saved_plans/phase5-item5-b-review-repair-decision_2026-09-10.md @@ -6,7 +6,8 @@ owns the subsequent application and review handoff. The proposal ledger and evid retain their preparation-time fields and hashes; the execution authority record binds the approval without rewriting that historical input. The [review follow-up](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-decision_2026-09-10.md) was approved on 2026-09-11; its [execution](phase5-item5-b-review-followup-execution_2026-09-11.md) -owns the subsequent review handoff. Repair merge remains operator-held. +owns the subsequent review and verified #731 merge. The operator separately authorized +that merge on 2026-09-11; the preserved proposal below retains its original merge hold. The preserved preparation scope follows. `ITEM5-B-KIT-REVIEW-01` is separate scope. ACCEPT-01 accepted the preserved-file ownership outcomes. PR-01 applied its exact fixture