diff --git a/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Ids.scala b/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Ids.scala index 13803dc9..77b476b1 100644 --- a/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Ids.scala +++ b/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Ids.scala @@ -2,15 +2,16 @@ package chimp.protocol import io.circe.{Codec, Decoder, Encoder, Json} -opaque type RequestId = String | Int +opaque type RequestId = String | Int | Long object RequestId: - def apply(value: String | Int): RequestId = value - def unapply(id: RequestId): Option[String | Int] = Some(id) + def apply(value: String | Int | Long): RequestId = value + def unapply(id: RequestId): Option[String | Int | Long] = Some(id) given encoder: Encoder[RequestId] = Encoder.instance: case s: String => Json.fromString(s) case i: Int => Json.fromInt(i) + case l: Long => Json.fromLong(l) given decoder: Decoder[RequestId] = Decoder.instance: c => - c.as[String].map(RequestId(_)).orElse(c.as[Int].map(RequestId(_))) + c.as[String].map(RequestId(_)).orElse(c.as[Int].map(RequestId(_))).orElse(c.as[Long].map(RequestId(_))) given codec: Codec[RequestId] = Codec.from(decoder, encoder) opaque type ProgressToken = String | Int diff --git a/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Versioning.scala b/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Versioning.scala index 9a5cacb4..7600a3c6 100644 --- a/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Versioning.scala +++ b/core/src/main/scala/chimp/protocol/Versioning.scala @@ -18,6 +18,7 @@ object ProtocolMeta: val ProtocolVersionKey: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/protocolVersion" val ClientInfo: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/clientInfo" val ClientCapabilities: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/clientCapabilities" + val LogLevel: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/logLevel" val ServerInfo: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/serverInfo" val SubscriptionId: String = "io.modelcontextprotocol/subscriptionId" @@ -29,6 +30,14 @@ object ProtocolMeta: data = Some(Json.obj("requested" -> requested.asJson, "supported" -> supported.asJson)) ) + /** A `MissingRequiredClientCapability` error (`-32021`) naming the capabilities the client must declare to make the request. */ + def missingClientCapabilityError(required: ClientCapabilities): JSONRPCErrorObject = + JSONRPCErrorObject( + code = JSONRPCErrorCodes.MissingRequiredClientCapability.code, + message = "Missing required client capability", + data = Some(Json.obj("requiredCapabilities" -> required.asJson.deepDropNullValues)) + ) + /** The type of a modern (2026-07-28+) result: `complete` for a finished result, `incomplete` for one that needs another round trip (MRTR * input-required). */ diff --git a/docs/server/capabilities.md b/docs/server/capabilities.md index 092db3d1..be4b790b 100644 --- a/docs/server/capabilities.md +++ b/docs/server/capabilities.md @@ -1,9 +1,9 @@ # Server capabilities -Most tools just answer a request, so `serverLogic`/`handle` expose no context. A tool that needs to **push to the client while it runs** uses `streamingServerLogic`, which receives a `StreamingServerContext[F]`: +Most tools just answer a request, so `serverLogic`/`handle` expose no context. Use `serverLogicWithContext` to read the facts of the request (see [request facts](#request-facts)). A tool that needs to **push to the client while it runs** uses `streamingServerLogic`, which receives a `StreamingServerContext[F]`: - `reportProgress` — [progress](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2025-11-25/basic/utilities/progress) notifications, auto-wired to the request's progress token. -- `log` — [logging](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2025-11-25/server/utilities/logging) notifications. +- `log` — [logging](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2025-11-25/server/utilities/logging) notifications. For a modern (`2026-07-28`) request, chimp sends a message only when its level is at or above the [per-request log level](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/server/utilities/logging#per-request-log-level) in `_meta` (`io.modelcontextprotocol/logLevel`). If the request sets no level, chimp sends no messages. For a legacy request, chimp sends all messages; use `.withLoggingLevel` to receive `logging/setLevel`. ```{note} Pushing to the client requires an open stream, so a `streamingServerLogic` tool is registered with `addStreamingTool` on a `StreamingMcpServer`, and will not compile on the plain request/response endpoint. @@ -36,14 +36,49 @@ chimp is **dual-era**: it speaks the legacy handshake revisions (`2025-11-25` an The server answers `server/discover` automatically with its supported versions, capabilities and identity (`serverInfo` in `_meta`), so a client can learn them in one request without connecting. A request that declares a protocol version the server does not support is rejected with an `UnsupportedProtocolVersion` error (`-32022`) listing the supported versions, per the [versioning compatibility matrix](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2026-07-28/basic/versioning#compatibility-matrix). No configuration is required for any of this. -A request is **modern** when its `_meta` or its `MCP-Protocol-Version` header declares `2026-07-28`. A legacy client that writes a legacy version into `_meta` stays on the legacy rules. chimp checks every modern request before any tool logic runs, and answers a failed check with a plain JSON error and its own HTTP status: +A request is **modern** when its `_meta` or its `MCP-Protocol-Version` header declares `2026-07-28`. A legacy client that writes a legacy version into `_meta` stays on the legacy rules. chimp checks every modern request, `server/discover` included, before any tool logic runs, and answers a failed check with a plain JSON error and its own HTTP status. A `server/discover` that declares no version (or a legacy version) gets no checks, so any client can discover the server: | Problem | JSON-RPC error | HTTP status | |---|---|---| | unsupported protocol version | `-32022` UnsupportedProtocolVersion | `400` | | `_meta` has no `protocolVersion` or no `clientCapabilities` | `-32602` InvalidParams | `400` | -| the `MCP-Protocol-Version` header and `_meta` declare different versions | `-32020` HeaderMismatch | `400` | +| the `MCP-Protocol-Version` header is missing (HTTP only), or it and `_meta` declare different versions | `-32020` HeaderMismatch | `400` | | `Mcp-Method` / `Mcp-Name` header missing or different from the body (HTTP only) | `-32020` HeaderMismatch | `400` | | removed method (`initialize`, `ping`, `logging/setLevel`, `resources/subscribe`, `resources/unsubscribe`) or unknown method | `-32601` MethodNotFound | `404` | +| `tools/call` of a tool whose required client capabilities `_meta` does not declare | `-32021` MissingRequiredClientCapability | `400` | Over HTTP, a modern request must carry the SEP-2243 standard headers: `Mcp-Method` with the body's `method`, and `Mcp-Name` with `params.name` on `tools/call` and `prompts/get`, or `params.uri` on `resources/read`. Header names are case-insensitive, values are case-sensitive, and surrounding whitespace is ignored. chimp's own client sends these headers and the `_meta` when you give it a modern protocol version — see [client transport](../client/transport.md). + +## Request facts + +Each handler can read the facts of its request from `ctx.request`, a `RequestInfo`: + +- `protocolVersion` — the protocol version of the request. +- `clientCapabilities` and `clientInfo` — what the client declares in `_meta`. +- `logLevel` — the per-request log level from `_meta`. +- `progressToken` — the progress token from `_meta`. + +A modern request carries all of these in `_meta`. The server keeps no state between requests, so a legacy request gives only the protocol version (from the `MCP-Protocol-Version` header or `_meta`) and the progress token. The other facts are `None`. + +`serverLogicWithContext` gives the context to tools, prompts, resources and resource templates on every server. `streamingServerLogic` and `securedStreamingServerLogic` give it too, because `StreamingServerContext` is a `ServerContext`. + +A tool that needs a client capability declares it with `withRequiredClientCapabilities`. If a modern request does not declare all of these capabilities in `_meta`, chimp rejects it before the logic runs, with `-32021` (MissingRequiredClientCapability), HTTP `400`, and the capabilities in `data.requiredCapabilities`. chimp compares the capabilities key by key, also in nested objects. A legacy request has no per-request capabilities, so chimp does not check it. + +```scala mdoc:compile-only +import chimp.server.* +import chimp.protocol.ClientCapabilities +import io.circe.{Codec, Json} +import sttp.shared.Identity +import sttp.tapir.* + +case class AskInput(question: String) derives Codec, Schema + +val ask = tool("ask") + .withRequiredClientCapabilities(ClientCapabilities(sampling = Some(Json.obj()))) + .input[AskInput] + .serverLogicWithContext[Identity]: (in, ctx, _) => + val client = ctx.request.clientInfo.fold("unknown client")(_.name) + ToolResult.text(s"$client asked: ${in.question}") + +val server = McpServer[Identity]().addTool(ask) +``` diff --git a/server-conformance/src/main/scala/chimp/conformance/server/Main.scala b/server-conformance/src/main/scala/chimp/conformance/server/Main.scala index 848ed73b..f287803f 100644 --- a/server-conformance/src/main/scala/chimp/conformance/server/Main.scala +++ b/server-conformance/src/main/scala/chimp/conformance/server/Main.scala @@ -132,6 +132,19 @@ object Main: ctx.log(LoggingLevel.Info, Json.fromString("Tool execution completed")) ToolResult.text("logging complete") + private val missingCapabilityTool = tool("test_missing_capability") + .description("Needs the sampling client capability") + .withRequiredClientCapabilities(ClientCapabilities(sampling = Some(Json.obj()))) + .input[NoInput] + .handle(_ => ToolResult.text("sampling capability declared")) + + private val perRequestLoggingTool = tool("test_logging_tool") + .description("Emits a log notification at each level; a modern request gets only those at or above its _meta logLevel") + .input[NoInput] + .streamingServerLogic[Identity]: (_, ctx, _) => + LoggingLevel.values.foreach(level => ctx.log(level, Json.fromString(s"$level message"))) + ToolResult.text("logging complete") + private val staticText = resource("test://static-text") .name("static-text") .mimeType("text/plain") @@ -184,7 +197,17 @@ object Main: .handle(_ => GetPromptResult(messages = List(PromptMessage(Role.User, ToolContent.Image(data = pngData, mimeType = "image/png"))))) private val server = McpServer[Identity](name = "chimp-conformance-server", version = "0.1.0") - .addTools(addNumbers, simpleText, errorTool, imageTool, audioTool, mixedTool, embeddedResourceTool, jsonSchemaTool) + .addTools( + addNumbers, + simpleText, + errorTool, + imageTool, + audioTool, + mixedTool, + embeddedResourceTool, + jsonSchemaTool, + missingCapabilityTool + ) .addResources(staticText, staticBinary) .addResourceTemplate(dataTemplate) .addPrompts(simplePrompt, argsPrompt, embeddedResourcePrompt, imagePrompt) @@ -192,7 +215,7 @@ object Main: .withLoggingLevel(_ => ()) .withSubscriptions(ResourceSubscriptions[Identity](_ => (), _ => ())) - private val streamingServer = server.streaming.addStreamingTools(progressTool, loggingTool) + private val streamingServer = server.streaming.addStreamingTools(progressTool, loggingTool, perRequestLoggingTool) def main(args: Array[String]): Unit = val requestedPort = args diff --git a/server-streaming/server-ox/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxServerStdioTransport.scala b/server-streaming/server-ox/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxServerStdioTransport.scala index b52e692c..1492d751 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-ox/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxServerStdioTransport.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-ox/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxServerStdioTransport.scala @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ package chimp.server.ox -import chimp.protocol.{JSONRPCMessage, ProgressToken} +import chimp.protocol.JSONRPCMessage import chimp.server.transport.ServerStreamingStdioTransport -import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} +import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, RequestInfo, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} import chimp.transport.{StdioFraming, StdioLineReader} import io.circe.syntax.* import io.circe.{parser, Json} @@ -39,8 +39,8 @@ final class OxServerStdioTransport( val sink = new OutboundSink[Identity]: def send(message: JSONRPCMessage): Unit = outbound.send(message.asJson.deepDropNullValues) - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[Identity] = - token => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, token) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[Identity] = + info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info) reader.lines .filter(_.nonEmpty) diff --git a/server-streaming/server-ox/src/test/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxMcpServerHttpSpec.scala b/server-streaming/server-ox/src/test/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxMcpServerHttpSpec.scala index d958c82d..317c9423 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-ox/src/test/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxMcpServerHttpSpec.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-ox/src/test/scala/chimp/server/ox/OxMcpServerHttpSpec.scala @@ -40,6 +40,7 @@ class OxMcpServerHttpSpec with SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests[Identity] with SyncToFuture: private val clientInfo = Implementation("chimp-server-test", "0.0.1") + override protected val clientProtocolVersion: ProtocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest override protected def withServer(server: McpServer[Identity])(test: McpClient[Identity] => Identity[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = withStreamingServer(server.streaming)(test) @@ -50,8 +51,8 @@ class OxMcpServerHttpSpec withHttpServer(OxServerHttpTransport(List("mcp")).serve(server)): (port, backend, ox) => given Ox = ox val transport = - OxClientHttpTransport(backend, uri"http://localhost:$port/mcp", ProtocolVersion.Latest, ClientTransport.defaultTimeout) - try test(McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest)) + OxClientHttpTransport(backend, uri"http://localhost:$port/mcp", clientProtocolVersion, ClientTransport.defaultTimeout) + try test(McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = clientProtocolVersion)) finally transport.close() override protected def withSecuredServer( @@ -77,11 +78,11 @@ class OxMcpServerHttpSpec val transport = OxClientHttpTransport( backend, uri"http://localhost:$port/mcp", - ProtocolVersion.Latest, + clientProtocolVersion, ClientTransport.defaultTimeout, headers = List(Header.authorization("Bearer", token)) ) - try test(McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest)) + try test(McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = clientProtocolVersion)) finally transport.close() // 2026-07-28 requests over raw HTTP: chimp's client does not write the modern `_meta` or the SEP-2243 headers yet diff --git a/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/main/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoServerStdioTransport.scala b/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/main/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoServerStdioTransport.scala index ccc840f1..d181bf86 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/main/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoServerStdioTransport.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/main/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoServerStdioTransport.scala @@ -1,8 +1,8 @@ package chimp.server.pekko -import chimp.protocol.{JSONRPCMessage, ProgressToken} +import chimp.protocol.JSONRPCMessage import chimp.server.transport.ServerStreamingStdioTransport -import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} +import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, RequestInfo, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} import chimp.transport.{McpLineTooLongException, StdioFraming} import io.circe.syntax.* import io.circe.{parser, Json} @@ -39,8 +39,8 @@ final class PekkoServerStdioTransport( val sink = new OutboundSink[Future]: def send(message: JSONRPCMessage): Future[Unit] = PekkoOutbound.offer(outbound, message.asJson.deepDropNullValues) - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[Future] = - token => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, token) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[Future] = + info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info) val reading = StreamConverters .fromInputStream(() => in) @@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ final class PekkoServerStdioTransport( private def handleLine( handler: McpHandler[Future, StreamingServerContext[Future]], - makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[Future], + makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[Future], outbound: SourceQueueWithComplete[Json], line: String ): Future[Unit] = diff --git a/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/test/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoMcpServerHttpSpec.scala b/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/test/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoMcpServerHttpSpec.scala index f3c09448..e80782bf 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/test/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoMcpServerHttpSpec.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-pekko/src/test/scala/chimp/server/pekko/PekkoMcpServerHttpSpec.scala @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ package chimp.server.pekko import chimp.client.transport.pekko.PekkoClientHttpTransport import chimp.client.{BidirectionalMcpClient, McpClient} -import chimp.protocol.Implementation +import chimp.protocol.{Implementation, ProtocolVersion} import chimp.server.transport.SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport import chimp.server.{ McpServer, @@ -34,6 +34,7 @@ class PekkoMcpServerHttpSpec with SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests[Future] with PekkoToFuture: private val clientInfo = Implementation("chimp-server-test", "0.0.1") + override protected val clientProtocolVersion: ProtocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.LatestLegacy override protected def withServer(server: McpServer[Future])(test: McpClient[Future] => Future[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = withStreamingServer(server.streaming)(test) diff --git a/server-streaming/server-zio/src/main/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioServerStdioTransport.scala b/server-streaming/server-zio/src/main/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioServerStdioTransport.scala index dc3710ba..0c7cbefe 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-zio/src/main/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioServerStdioTransport.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-zio/src/main/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioServerStdioTransport.scala @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ package chimp.server.zio -import chimp.protocol.{JSONRPCMessage, ProgressToken} -import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} +import chimp.protocol.JSONRPCMessage +import chimp.server.{McpHandler, OutboundSink, RequestInfo, SinkStreamingServerContext, StreamingMcpServer, StreamingServerContext} import chimp.server.transport.ServerStreamingStdioTransport import chimp.transport.{StdioFraming, StdioLineReader} import io.circe.syntax.* @@ -36,8 +36,8 @@ final class ZioServerStdioTransport( val sink = new OutboundSink[Task]: def send(message: JSONRPCMessage): Task[Unit] = writeLine(message.asJson.deepDropNullValues) - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[Task] = - token => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, token) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[Task] = + info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info) def loop: Task[Unit] = ZIO diff --git a/server-streaming/server-zio/src/test/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioMcpServerHttpSpec.scala b/server-streaming/server-zio/src/test/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioMcpServerHttpSpec.scala index a500fa28..251b88c3 100644 --- a/server-streaming/server-zio/src/test/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioMcpServerHttpSpec.scala +++ b/server-streaming/server-zio/src/test/scala/chimp/server/zio/ZioMcpServerHttpSpec.scala @@ -35,6 +35,7 @@ class ZioMcpServerHttpSpec with SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests[Task] with ZioToFuture: private val clientInfo = Implementation("chimp-server-test", "0.0.1") + override protected val clientProtocolVersion: ProtocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest override protected def withServer(server: McpServer[Task])(test: McpClient[Task] => Task[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = withStreamingServer(server.streaming)(test) @@ -43,14 +44,14 @@ class ZioMcpServerHttpSpec server: StreamingMcpServer[Task] )(test: BidirectionalMcpClient[Task] => Task[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = withHttpServer(ZioServerHttpTransport(List("mcp")).serve(server), Nil): transport => - McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest).flatMap(test) + McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = clientProtocolVersion).flatMap(test) override protected def withSecuredServer( server: SecuredMcpServer[Task, String, String, User], token: String )(test: McpClient[Task] => Task[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = withHttpServer(server.endpoint(List("mcp")), List(Header.authorization("Bearer", token))): transport => - McpClient(transport, clientInfo, ProtocolVersion.Latest).flatMap(test) + McpClient(transport, clientInfo, clientProtocolVersion).flatMap(test) override protected def withSecuredStreamingServer( server: SecuredStreamingMcpServer[Task, String, String, User], @@ -58,7 +59,7 @@ class ZioMcpServerHttpSpec )(test: BidirectionalMcpClient[Task] => Task[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] = val endpoint = SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport(List("mcp"), ZioServerHttpTransport(List("mcp"))).serve(server) withHttpServer(endpoint, List(Header.authorization("Bearer", token))): transport => - McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = ProtocolVersion.Latest).flatMap(test) + McpClient.bidirectional(transport, clientInfo, protocolVersion = clientProtocolVersion).flatMap(test) private def withHttpServer( endpoint: ServerEndpoint[ZioStreams & WebSockets, Task], @@ -74,7 +75,7 @@ class ZioMcpServerHttpSpec .scoped( backend, uri"http://localhost:$port/mcp", - ProtocolVersion.Latest, + clientProtocolVersion, ClientTransport.defaultTimeout, headers = headers ) diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/McpHandler.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/McpHandler.scala index 38b066dc..fd598d48 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/McpHandler.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/McpHandler.scala @@ -63,15 +63,15 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD ) ) - def handleJsonRpc(request: Json, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C)(using MonadError[F]): F[McpResponse] = + def handleJsonRpc(request: Json, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: RequestInfo => C)(using MonadError[F]): F[McpResponse] = doHandleJsonRpc(request, headers, makeContext).map: response => logger.debug(s"Request: $request, response: ${response.statusCode}, body: ${response.body.getOrElse(Json.Null)}") response.withNullsDroppedDeep def handleJsonRpc(request: Json, headers: Seq[Header])(using m: MonadError[F], ev: ServerContext[F] <:< C): F[McpResponse] = - handleJsonRpc(request, headers, _ => ev(ServerContext.noop[F])) + handleJsonRpc(request, headers, info => ev(ServerContext[F](info))) - private def doHandleJsonRpc(request: Json, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C)(using + private def doHandleJsonRpc(request: Json, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: RequestInfo => C)(using MonadError[F] ): F[McpResponse] = request.as[JSONRPCMessage] match @@ -80,7 +80,10 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD case Right(JSONRPCMessage.Request(_, method, params: Option[Json], id)) => requestRejection(method, params, headers, id) match case Some(rejection) => rejection.unit - case None => dispatch(method, params, id, headers, makeContext, isModernRequest(method, params, headers)) + case None => + val isModern = isModernRequest(params, headers) + val info = requestInfo(params, headers, isModern) + dispatch(method, params, id, headers, () => makeContext(info), isModern) case Right(notification: JSONRPCMessage.Notification) => logger.debug(s"Received notification: ${notification.method}") McpResponse.EmptyAcceptResponse.unit @@ -93,7 +96,7 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD params: Option[Json], id: RequestId, headers: Seq[Header], - makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C, + makeContext: () => C, isModern: Boolean )(using MonadError[F]): F[McpResponse] = def wrap(cacheHints: Option[CacheHints])(message: JSONRPCMessage): JSONRPCMessage = message match @@ -152,9 +155,10 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD private def jsonResponse(message: JSONRPCMessage): McpResponse = McpResponse.JsonResponse(message.asJson) - // request methods a 2026-07-28 client may call (server/discover is handled separately as the era-agnostic bootstrap) + // request methods a 2026-07-28 client may call private val modernMethods: Set[String] = Set( + "server/discover", "tools/list", "tools/call", "resources/list", @@ -172,13 +176,30 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD /** Whether the request follows the modern (2026-07-28) rules: it declares a modern version in `_meta` or via the `MCP-Protocol-Version` * header. A known legacy version in `_meta` keeps the legacy rules; an unknown one is treated as modern, so it gets the modern `-32022` - * with HTTP 400. `server/discover` is the era-agnostic bootstrap and is never treated as modern here. + * with HTTP 400. A `server/discover` that declares no version stays legacy, so a probing client can still discover the server. */ - private def isModernRequest(method: String, params: Option[Json], headers: Seq[Header]): Boolean = + private def isModernRequest(params: Option[Json], headers: Seq[Header]): Boolean = val metaVersion = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("_meta").downField(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey).as[String].toOption) val headerVersion = headers.collectFirst { case h if h.name.equalsIgnoreCase(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader) => h.value.trim } val metaIsModern = metaVersion.exists(version => ProtocolVersion.from(version).forall(_.isModern)) - method != "server/discover" && (metaIsModern || headerVersion.flatMap(ProtocolVersion.from).exists(_.isModern)) + metaIsModern || headerVersion.flatMap(ProtocolVersion.from).exists(_.isModern) + + /** The facts a handler can read about the request; see [[RequestInfo]]. */ + private def requestInfo(params: Option[Json], headers: Seq[Header], isModern: Boolean): RequestInfo = + val meta = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("_meta").focus).map(_.hcursor) + def fromMeta[A: Decoder](key: String): Option[A] = meta.flatMap(_.get[A](key).toOption) + val headerVersion = headers.collectFirst { case h if h.name.equalsIgnoreCase(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader) => h.value.trim } + val progressToken = fromMeta[ProgressToken]("progressToken") + val protocolVersion = fromMeta[String](ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey).orElse(headerVersion).flatMap(ProtocolVersion.from) + if isModern then + RequestInfo( + protocolVersion = protocolVersion, + clientCapabilities = fromMeta[ClientCapabilities](ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities), + clientInfo = fromMeta[Implementation](ProtocolMeta.ClientInfo), + logLevel = fromMeta[LoggingLevel](ProtocolMeta.LogLevel), + progressToken = progressToken + ) + else RequestInfo(protocolVersion = protocolVersion, progressToken = progressToken) /** The rejection to send for an invalid request, or `None` if it may be dispatched. Runs no tool logic, so a transport can call it before * deciding how to respond (a modern validation error is a plain-JSON HTTP error, not an SSE stream). @@ -187,7 +208,7 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD val meta = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("_meta").focus) val metaVersion = meta.flatMap(_.hcursor.get[String](ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey).toOption) val headerVersion = headers.collectFirst { case h if h.name.equalsIgnoreCase(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader) => h.value.trim } - if isModernRequest(method, params, headers) then modernRejection(method, params, meta, metaVersion, headerVersion, headers, id) + if isModernRequest(params, headers) then modernRejection(method, params, meta, metaVersion, headerVersion, headers, id) else metaVersion match case Some(version) if ProtocolVersion.from(version).isEmpty => @@ -215,12 +236,15 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD id: RequestId ): Option[McpResponse] = val declared = metaVersion.orElse(headerVersion) - if declared.exists(version => ProtocolVersion.from(version).isEmpty) then + val overHttp = headers.exists(_.name.equalsIgnoreCase("Host")) + if overHttp && headerVersion.isEmpty then + Some(jsonError(id, StatusCode.BadRequest, JSONRPCErrorCodes.HeaderMismatch.code, "Missing MCP-Protocol-Version header")) + else if headerVersion.isDefined && metaVersion.isDefined && headerVersion != metaVersion then + Some(jsonError(id, StatusCode.BadRequest, JSONRPCErrorCodes.HeaderMismatch.code, "MCP-Protocol-Version header does not match _meta")) + else if declared.exists(version => ProtocolVersion.from(version).isEmpty) then val envelope: JSONRPCMessage = JSONRPCMessage.Error(id = id, error = ProtocolMeta.unsupportedVersionError(declared.get, ProtocolVersion.supported.map(_.name))) Some(McpResponse.JsonError(StatusCode.BadRequest, envelope.asJson)) - else if headerVersion.isDefined && metaVersion.isDefined && headerVersion != metaVersion then - Some(jsonError(id, StatusCode.BadRequest, JSONRPCErrorCodes.HeaderMismatch.code, "MCP-Protocol-Version header does not match _meta")) else if metaVersion.isEmpty then Some( jsonError(id, StatusCode.BadRequest, JSONRPCErrorCodes.InvalidParams.code, s"Missing ${ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey} in _meta") @@ -231,10 +255,31 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD ) else if !modernMethods.contains(method) then Some(jsonError(id, StatusCode.NotFound, JSONRPCErrorCodes.MethodNotFound.code, s"Method not found: $method")) - else if headers.exists(_.name.equalsIgnoreCase("Host")) then + else // SEP-2243 standard request headers only apply over HTTP (identified by the Host header); stdio carries no such headers - headerValidationError(method, params, headers, id) - else None + val headerError = Option.when(overHttp)(headerValidationError(method, params, headers, id)) + headerError.flatten.orElse(missingCapabilityError(method, params, meta, id)) + + /** A `-32021` with HTTP 400 when `tools/call` names a tool whose required client capabilities the request's `_meta` does not declare. */ + private def missingCapabilityError(method: String, params: Option[Json], meta: Option[Json], id: RequestId): Option[McpResponse] = + val declared = meta.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField(ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities).focus).getOrElse(Json.obj()) + val required = Option + .when(method == "tools/call")(params.flatMap(_.hcursor.get[String]("name").toOption)) + .flatten + .flatMap(toolsByName.get) + .flatMap(_.requiredClientCapabilities) + required + .filterNot(capabilities => declares(declared, capabilities.asJson.deepDropNullValues)) + .map: capabilities => + val envelope: JSONRPCMessage = JSONRPCMessage.Error(id = id, error = ProtocolMeta.missingClientCapabilityError(capabilities)) + logger.debug(s"Modern request rejected (id=$id): missing client capabilities ${capabilities.asJson.noSpaces}") + McpResponse.JsonError(StatusCode.BadRequest, envelope.asJson) + + /** Whether `declared` has every key of `required`, recursively for nested objects. */ + private def declares(declared: Json, required: Json): Boolean = + required.asObject.forall(_.toList.forall { (key, value) => + declared.asObject.flatMap(_(key)).exists(declaredValue => value.asObject.forall(_ => declares(declaredValue, value))) + }) // SEP-2243: the body field that the `Mcp-Name` header must mirror, per method private val nameFields: Map[String, String] = Map("tools/call" -> "name", "prompts/get" -> "name", "resources/read" -> "uri") @@ -289,19 +334,18 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD private def handleDiscover(id: RequestId): JSONRPCMessage.Response = JSONRPCMessage.Response(id = id, result = discoverResult.asJson) - private def handleToolsCall(params: Option[Json], id: RequestId, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C)(using + private def handleToolsCall(params: Option[Json], id: RequestId, headers: Seq[Header], makeContext: () => C)(using MonadError[F] ): F[JSONRPCMessage] = val name = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("name").as[String].toOption) val arguments = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("arguments").focus).getOrElse(Json.obj()) - val progressToken = params.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("_meta").downField("progressToken").as[ProgressToken].toOption) name match case Some(name) => toolsByName.get(name) match case Some(tool) => tool.inputDecoder.decodeJson(arguments) match case Right(input) => - val context = makeContext(progressToken) + val context = makeContext() tool .logic(input, context, headers) .map: result => @@ -335,10 +379,10 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD params: Option[Json], id: RequestId, headers: Seq[Header], - makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C + makeContext: () => C )(using MonadError[F]): F[JSONRPCMessage] = decodeParams[ReadResourceParams](params, id): params => - val context = makeContext(None) + val context = makeContext() resourcesByUri.get(params.uri) match case Some(resource) => resource.read(context, headers).map(resourceReadResponse(id, params.uri)) case None => @@ -383,13 +427,13 @@ private[server] class McpHandler[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](server: McpServerD params: Option[Json], id: RequestId, headers: Seq[Header], - makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => C + makeContext: () => C )(using MonadError[F]): F[JSONRPCMessage] = decodeParams[GetPromptParams](params, id): params => promptsByName.get(params.name) match case Some(prompt) => prompt - .logic(params.arguments.getOrElse(Map.empty), makeContext(None), headers) + .logic(params.arguments.getOrElse(Map.empty), makeContext(), headers) .map(promptResult => JSONRPCMessage.Response(id = id, result = promptResult.asJson)) case None => protocolError(id, JSONRPCErrorCodes.InvalidParams.code, s"Unknown prompt: ${params.name}").unit diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Prompt.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Prompt.scala index fa3264ca..5ad4eec0 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Prompt.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Prompt.scala @@ -38,6 +38,12 @@ case class PartialPrompt( ): ServerPrompt[F, ServerContext[F]] = ServerPrompt(definition, (args, _, headers) => logic(args, headers)) + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the [[ServerContext]], which gives the facts of the request. */ + def serverLogicWithContext[F[_]]( + logic: (Map[String, String], ServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[GetPromptResult] + ): ServerPrompt[F, ServerContext[F]] = + ServerPrompt(definition, logic) + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the principal; usable only on a [[SecuredMcpServer]]. */ def securedServerLogic[F[_], P]( logic: (Map[String, String], P, Seq[Header]) => F[GetPromptResult] diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Resource.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Resource.scala index ad645a61..57d001b9 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Resource.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Resource.scala @@ -54,6 +54,12 @@ case class PartialResource( ): ServerResource[F, ServerContext[F]] = ServerResource(definition, (_, headers) => logic(headers)) + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the [[ServerContext]], which gives the facts of the request. */ + def serverLogicWithContext[F[_]]( + logic: (ServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[Either[ResourceError, List[ResourceContents]]] + ): ServerResource[F, ServerContext[F]] = + ServerResource(definition, logic) + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the principal; usable only on a [[SecuredMcpServer]]. */ def securedServerLogic[F[_], P]( logic: (P, Seq[Header]) => F[Either[ResourceError, List[ResourceContents]]] @@ -120,6 +126,12 @@ case class PartialResourceTemplate( ): ServerResourceTemplate[F, ServerContext[F]] = ServerResourceTemplate(definition, UriTemplate.compile(uriTemplate), (vars, uri, _, headers) => logic(vars, uri, headers)) + /** Attaches effectful logic reading a matched URI, with access to the [[ServerContext]], which gives the facts of the request. */ + def serverLogicWithContext[F[_]]( + logic: (Map[String, String], String, ServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[Either[ResourceError, List[ResourceContents]]] + ): ServerResourceTemplate[F, ServerContext[F]] = + ServerResourceTemplate(definition, UriTemplate.compile(uriTemplate), logic) + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the principal; usable only on a [[SecuredMcpServer]]. */ def securedServerLogic[F[_], P]( logic: (Map[String, String], String, P, Seq[Header]) => F[Either[ResourceError, List[ResourceContents]]] diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ServerContext.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ServerContext.scala index ebcfa603..3a73c975 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ServerContext.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/ServerContext.scala @@ -5,28 +5,52 @@ import io.circe.Json import io.circe.syntax.* import sttp.monad.MonadError -trait ServerContext[F[_]] +/** What a request tells about itself. A modern (2026-07-28+) request carries all of it in `_meta`. A legacy request gives only the protocol + * version (from the `MCP-Protocol-Version` header or `_meta`) and the progress token; the server keeps no state from `initialize`. + */ +final case class RequestInfo( + protocolVersion: Option[ProtocolVersion] = None, + clientCapabilities: Option[ClientCapabilities] = None, + clientInfo: Option[Implementation] = None, + logLevel: Option[LoggingLevel] = None, + progressToken: Option[ProgressToken] = None +): + /** A modern request gets `notifications/message` only at or above its `logLevel`, and none without one. A legacy request gets all. */ + private[server] def allowsLog(level: LoggingLevel): Boolean = + if protocolVersion.exists(_.isModern) then logLevel.exists(minimum => level.ordinal >= minimum.ordinal) else true + +object RequestInfo: + val empty: RequestInfo = RequestInfo() + +trait ServerContext[F[_]]: + def request: RequestInfo object ServerContext: - def noop[F[_]]: ServerContext[F] = new ServerContext[F] {} + def noop[F[_]]: ServerContext[F] = apply(RequestInfo.empty) + + private[server] def apply[F[_]](info: RequestInfo): ServerContext[F] = new ServerContext[F]: + def request: RequestInfo = info /** A context which also gives the principal that the security logic of a [[SecuredMcpServer]] made from the request. */ trait SecuredServerContext[F[_], +P] extends ServerContext[F]: def principal: P object SecuredServerContext: - def apply[F[_], P](value: P): SecuredServerContext[F, P] = new SecuredServerContext[F, P]: + def apply[F[_], P](value: P, info: RequestInfo = RequestInfo.empty): SecuredServerContext[F, P] = new SecuredServerContext[F, P]: def principal: P = value + def request: RequestInfo = info trait StreamingServerContext[F[_]] extends ServerContext[F]: def reportProgress(progress: Double, total: Option[Double] = None, message: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] + + /** Sends `notifications/message`. For a modern request it sends only at or above the request's `logLevel`, and nothing without one. */ def log(level: LoggingLevel, data: Json, logger: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] -private[server] final class SinkStreamingServerContext[F[_]](sink: OutboundSink[F], progressToken: Option[ProgressToken])(using +private[server] final class SinkStreamingServerContext[F[_]](sink: OutboundSink[F], val request: RequestInfo)(using m: MonadError[F] ) extends StreamingServerContext[F]: def reportProgress(progress: Double, total: Option[Double] = None, message: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] = - progressToken match + request.progressToken match case Some(token) => sink.send( JSONRPCMessage.Notification( @@ -37,9 +61,11 @@ private[server] final class SinkStreamingServerContext[F[_]](sink: OutboundSink[ case None => m.unit(()) def log(level: LoggingLevel, data: Json, logger: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] = - sink.send( - JSONRPCMessage.Notification(method = "notifications/message", params = Some(LoggingMessageParams(level, data, logger).asJson)) - ) + if request.allowsLog(level) then + sink.send( + JSONRPCMessage.Notification(method = "notifications/message", params = Some(LoggingMessageParams(level, data, logger).asJson)) + ) + else m.unit(()) /** A context which gives both the principal that the security logic of a [[SecuredMcpServer]] made from the request, and the streaming * capabilities of a [[StreamingServerContext]]. @@ -48,11 +74,11 @@ trait SecuredStreamingServerContext[F[_], +P] extends SecuredServerContext[F, P] private[server] final class SinkSecuredStreamingServerContext[F[_], P]( sink: OutboundSink[F], - progressToken: Option[ProgressToken], + val request: RequestInfo, val principal: P )(using MonadError[F]) extends SecuredStreamingServerContext[F, P]: - private val delegate = SinkStreamingServerContext[F](sink, progressToken) + private val delegate = SinkStreamingServerContext[F](sink, request) def reportProgress(progress: Double, total: Option[Double] = None, message: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] = delegate.reportProgress(progress, total, message) def log(level: LoggingLevel, data: Json, logger: Option[String] = None): F[Unit] = delegate.log(level, data, logger) diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Tool.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Tool.scala index e6aecd3b..ca68baef 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Tool.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/Tool.scala @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ package chimp.server -import chimp.protocol.{ResourceContents, ToolContent} +import chimp.protocol.{ClientCapabilities, ResourceContents, ToolContent} import io.circe.syntax.* import io.circe.{Decoder, Encoder, Json} import sttp.model.Header @@ -66,7 +66,8 @@ def tool(name: String): PartialTool = case class PartialTool( name: String, description: Option[String] = None, - annotations: Option[ToolAnnotations] = None + annotations: Option[ToolAnnotations] = None, + requiredClientCapabilities: Option[ClientCapabilities] = None ): def description(desc: String): PartialTool = copy(description = Some(desc)) @@ -74,13 +75,35 @@ case class PartialTool( def withAnnotations(ann: ToolAnnotations): PartialTool = copy(annotations = Some(ann)) + /** Declares the client capabilities a call needs. A modern (2026-07-28+) request whose `_meta` does not declare them fails with `-32021` + * (MissingRequiredClientCapability) before the logic runs. + */ + def withRequiredClientCapabilities(capabilities: ClientCapabilities): PartialTool = + copy(requiredClientCapabilities = Some(capabilities)) + /** Fixes the input type, deriving its JSON Schema and decoder from the given instances. */ def input[I: Schema: Decoder]: Tool[I, NoStructuredOutput] = - Tool[I, NoStructuredOutput](name, description, ToolSchema.Derived(summon[Schema[I]]), summon[Decoder[I]], None, annotations) + Tool[I, NoStructuredOutput]( + name, + description, + ToolSchema.Derived(summon[Schema[I]]), + summon[Decoder[I]], + None, + annotations, + requiredClientCapabilities + ) /** Fixes the input as raw JSON, validated against the given JSON Schema. */ def inputJson(schema: Json): Tool[Json, NoStructuredOutput] = - Tool[Json, NoStructuredOutput](name, description, ToolSchema.Raw(schema), summon[Decoder[Json]], None, annotations) + Tool[Json, NoStructuredOutput]( + name, + description, + ToolSchema.Raw(schema), + summon[Decoder[Json]], + None, + annotations, + requiredClientCapabilities + ) /** A tool with a known input type `I` and structured output type `O`, ready to be given its handling logic. */ case class Tool[I, O]( @@ -89,56 +112,45 @@ case class Tool[I, O]( inputSchema: ToolSchema, inputDecoder: Decoder[I], outputSchema: Option[ToolSchema], - annotations: Option[ToolAnnotations] + annotations: Option[ToolAnnotations], + requiredClientCapabilities: Option[ClientCapabilities] = None ): /** Fixes the structured output type, deriving its JSON Schema from the given instance. */ def output[O2: Schema]: Tool[I, O2] = - Tool[I, O2](name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, Some(ToolSchema.Derived(summon[Schema[O2]])), annotations) + copy(outputSchema = Some(ToolSchema.Derived(summon[Schema[O2]]))) /** Fixes the structured output as raw JSON, described by the given JSON Schema. */ def outputJson(schema: Json): Tool[I, Json] = - Tool[I, Json](name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, Some(ToolSchema.Raw(schema)), annotations) + copy(outputSchema = Some(ToolSchema.Raw(schema))) /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the request headers. */ def serverLogic[F[_]](logic: (I, Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]]): ServerTool[I, O, F, ServerContext[F]] = - ServerTool(name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, outputSchema, annotations, (input, _, headers) => logic(input, headers)) + serverTool((input, _, headers) => logic(input, headers)) + + /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the [[ServerContext]], which gives the facts of the request. */ + def serverLogicWithContext[F[_]](logic: (I, ServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]]): ServerTool[I, O, F, ServerContext[F]] = + serverTool(logic) /** Attaches effectful logic, with access to the principal; usable only on a [[SecuredMcpServer]]. */ def securedServerLogic[F[_], P](logic: (I, P, Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]]): ServerTool[I, O, F, SecuredServerContext[F, P]] = - ServerTool( - name, - description, - inputSchema, - inputDecoder, - outputSchema, - annotations, - (input, context, headers) => logic(input, context.principal, headers) - ) + serverTool((input, context, headers) => logic(input, context.principal, headers)) /** Attaches effectful logic with access to the [[StreamingServerContext]]; usable only on a streaming server. */ def streamingServerLogic[F[_]]( logic: (I, StreamingServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]] ): ServerTool[I, O, F, StreamingServerContext[F]] = - ServerTool(name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, outputSchema, annotations, logic) + serverTool(logic) /** Attaches effectful logic with access to the principal and the [[StreamingServerContext]]; usable only on a secured streaming server. */ def securedStreamingServerLogic[F[_], P]( logic: (I, P, StreamingServerContext[F], Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]] ): ServerTool[I, O, F, SecuredStreamingServerContext[F, P]] = - ServerTool( - name, - description, - inputSchema, - inputDecoder, - outputSchema, - annotations, - (input, context, headers) => logic(input, context.principal, context, headers) - ) + serverTool((input, context, headers) => logic(input, context.principal, context, headers)) /** Attaches synchronous logic that also receives the request headers. */ def handleWithHeaders(logic: (I, Seq[Header]) => ToolResult[O]): ServerTool[I, O, Identity, ServerContext[Identity]] = - ServerTool(name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, outputSchema, annotations, (i, _, headers) => logic(i, headers)) + serverTool((i, _, headers) => logic(i, headers)) /** Attaches synchronous logic over just the decoded input. */ def handle(logic: I => ToolResult[O]): ServerTool[I, O, Identity, ServerContext[Identity]] = @@ -148,6 +160,9 @@ case class Tool[I, O]( def handleSecured[P](logic: (I, P) => ToolResult[O]): ServerTool[I, O, Identity, SecuredServerContext[Identity, P]] = securedServerLogic[Identity, P]((i, principal, _) => logic(i, principal)) + private def serverTool[F[_], C <: ServerContext[F]](logic: (I, C, Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]]): ServerTool[I, O, F, C] = + ServerTool(name, description, inputSchema, inputDecoder, outputSchema, annotations, logic, requiredClientCapabilities) + /** A fully-defined tool: its metadata plus the logic handling a call, in effect `F` with context `C`. */ case class ServerTool[I, O, F[_], -C <: ServerContext[F]]( name: String, @@ -156,5 +171,6 @@ case class ServerTool[I, O, F[_], -C <: ServerContext[F]]( inputDecoder: Decoder[I], outputSchema: Option[ToolSchema], annotations: Option[ToolAnnotations], - logic: (I, C, Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]] + logic: (I, C, Seq[Header]) => F[ToolResult[O]], + requiredClientCapabilities: Option[ClientCapabilities] = None ) diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerHttpTransport.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerHttpTransport.scala index ebc452f9..a317b178 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerHttpTransport.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerHttpTransport.scala @@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ final case class SecuredServerHttpTransport[F[_], S, E, P](path: List[String]): val (headers, json) = input given MonadError[F] = me respondToJsonRpc(server.originCheck, headers) { - handler.handleJsonRpc(json, headers, _ => SecuredServerContext[F, P](principal)) + handler.handleJsonRpc(json, headers, info => SecuredServerContext[F, P](principal, info)) }.map(Right(_)) } ) diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala index 5ba0d740..16d0df5c 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala @@ -1,6 +1,5 @@ package chimp.server.transport -import chimp.protocol.ProgressToken import chimp.server.* import io.circe.Json import sttp.model.Header @@ -46,8 +45,8 @@ final case class SecuredServerStreamingHttpTransport[F[_], Caps, S, E, P]( val (headers, json) = input given MonadError[F] = me respondWithEventStream(server.originCheck, headers, backend, handler.validateRequest(json, headers)) { sink => - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => SecuredStreamingServerContext[F, P] = - token => SinkSecuredStreamingServerContext(sink, token, principal) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => SecuredStreamingServerContext[F, P] = + info => SinkSecuredStreamingServerContext(sink, info, principal) handler.handleJsonRpc(json, headers, makeContext).map(_.body) }.map(_.left.map(Right(_))) } diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStdioTransport.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStdioTransport.scala index 619b91d2..cd4da85c 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStdioTransport.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStdioTransport.scala @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ package chimp.server.transport -import chimp.protocol.{JSONRPCMessage, ProgressToken} +import chimp.protocol.JSONRPCMessage import chimp.server.* import chimp.transport.{StdioFraming, StdioLineReader} import io.circe.parser @@ -49,8 +49,8 @@ final class ServerStdioTransport( val sink = new OutboundSink[Identity]: def send(message: JSONRPCMessage): Identity[Unit] = writeLine(message.asJson.deepDropNullValues) - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[Identity] = - token => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, token) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[Identity] = + info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info) reader.lines .filter(_.nonEmpty) diff --git a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala index d6529d44..cadf6428 100644 --- a/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala +++ b/server/src/main/scala/chimp/server/transport/ServerStreamingHttpTransport.scala @@ -1,6 +1,5 @@ package chimp.server.transport -import chimp.protocol.ProgressToken import chimp.server.* import io.circe.Json import sttp.capabilities.Streams @@ -45,8 +44,8 @@ abstract class ServerStreamingHttpTransport[F[_], Caps](path: List[String]) exte val (headers, json) = input given MonadError[F] = me respondWithEventStream(server.originCheck, headers, this, handler.validateRequest(json, headers)) { sink => - val makeContext: Option[ProgressToken] => StreamingServerContext[F] = - token => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, token) + val makeContext: RequestInfo => StreamingServerContext[F] = + info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info) handler.handleJsonRpc(json, headers, makeContext).map(_.body) } } diff --git a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpHandlerSpec.scala b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpHandlerSpec.scala index 5770649d..e2b51d03 100644 --- a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpHandlerSpec.scala +++ b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpHandlerSpec.scala @@ -178,7 +178,7 @@ class McpHandlerSpec extends AnyFlatSpec with Matchers: private def modernHttpCall(method: String, params: Json, extraHeaders: (String, String)*): McpResponse = val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = method, params = Some(params.deepMerge(Json.obj(modernMeta))), id = RequestId("h")) - val headers = Header("Host", "localhost") +: extraHeaders.map(Header(_, _)) + val headers = Header("Host", "localhost") +: Header(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader, "2026-07-28") +: extraHeaders.map(Header(_, _)) headersHandler.handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, headers) private def shouldBeHeaderMismatch(response: McpResponse): org.scalatest.Assertion = @@ -697,3 +697,216 @@ class McpHandlerSpec extends AnyFlatSpec with Matchers: featureResult("resources/subscribe", Some(params), "n1") match case Error(_, _, error) => error.code shouldBe MethodNotFound.code case _ => fail("Expected Error") + + private val seenRequest = new java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicReference(Option.empty[RequestInfo]) + + private val loggingTool = tool("logs") + .input[EchoInput] + .streamingServerLogic[Identity]: (_, ctx, _) => + seenRequest.set(Some(ctx.request)) + LoggingLevel.values.foreach(level => ctx.log(level, Json.fromString(level.toString))) + ToolResult.text("logged") + + private val streamingHandler = + McpHandler[Identity, StreamingServerContext[Identity]](McpServer[Identity]().streaming.addStreamingTool(loggingTool)) + + private def callLoggingTool(meta: Json, headers: Seq[Header] = Seq.empty): (McpResponse, List[LoggingLevel]) = + val sent = scala.collection.mutable.ListBuffer.empty[JSONRPCMessage] + val sink = new OutboundSink[Identity]: + def send(message: JSONRPCMessage): Unit = sent += message + val params = Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("logs"), "arguments" -> Json.obj("message" -> Json.fromString("hi")), "_meta" -> meta) + val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = "tools/call", params = Some(params), id = RequestId("log")) + val response = streamingHandler.handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, headers, info => SinkStreamingServerContext(sink, info)) + val levels = sent.toList.collect { case Notification(_, "notifications/message", Some(p)) => + p.as[LoggingMessageParams].toOption.get.level + } + (response, levels) + + private def modernToolMeta(extra: (String, Json)*): Json = + Json.obj( + (ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey -> Json.fromString("2026-07-28")) +: + (ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities -> Json.obj("sampling" -> Json.obj())) +: + extra* + ) + + it should "give a handler the facts of a modern request" in: + val clientInfo = Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("cli"), "version" -> Json.fromString("1.2")) + val meta = modernToolMeta( + ProtocolMeta.ClientInfo -> clientInfo, + ProtocolMeta.LogLevel -> Json.fromString("warning"), + "progressToken" -> Json.fromString("p1") + ) + callLoggingTool(meta)._1.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + seenRequest.get() shouldBe Some( + RequestInfo( + protocolVersion = Some(ProtocolVersion.V2026_07_28), + clientCapabilities = Some(ClientCapabilities(sampling = Some(Json.obj()))), + clientInfo = Some(Implementation("cli", "1.2")), + logLevel = Some(LoggingLevel.Warning), + progressToken = Some(ProgressToken("p1")) + ) + ) + + it should "give a handler only the protocol version and progress token of a legacy request" in: + val meta = Json.obj("progressToken" -> Json.fromString("p2"), ProtocolMeta.LogLevel -> Json.fromString("debug")) + callLoggingTool(meta, Seq(Header(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader, "2025-11-25")))._1.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + seenRequest.get() shouldBe Some( + RequestInfo(protocolVersion = Some(ProtocolVersion.V2025_11_25), progressToken = Some(ProgressToken("p2"))) + ) + + it should "send no log messages for a modern request without a logLevel" in: + callLoggingTool(modernToolMeta())._2 shouldBe Nil + + it should "send only log messages at or above the logLevel of a modern request" in: + callLoggingTool(modernToolMeta(ProtocolMeta.LogLevel -> Json.fromString("error")))._2 shouldBe + List(LoggingLevel.Error, LoggingLevel.Critical, LoggingLevel.Alert, LoggingLevel.Emergency) + + it should "send all log messages for a legacy request" in: + callLoggingTool(Json.obj())._2 shouldBe LoggingLevel.values.toList + + private def describe(ctx: ServerContext[Identity]): String = + s"${ctx.request.protocolVersion.map(_.name).getOrElse("-")} ${ctx.request.clientInfo.map(_.name).getOrElse("-")}" + + private val contextServer = McpServer[Identity]() + .addTool(tool("ctx").input[EchoInput].serverLogicWithContext[Identity]((_, ctx, _) => ToolResult.text(describe(ctx)))) + .addPrompt( + prompt("ctx").serverLogicWithContext[Identity]((_, ctx, _) => + GetPromptResult(messages = List(PromptMessage(Role.User, ToolContent.Text(text = describe(ctx))))) + ) + ) + .addResource( + resource("test://ctx").serverLogicWithContext[Identity]((ctx, _) => Right(List(ResourceContents.Text("test://ctx", describe(ctx))))) + ) + .addResourceTemplate( + resourceTemplate("test://ctx/{id}") + .serverLogicWithContext[Identity]((_, uri, ctx, _) => Right(List(ResourceContents.Text(uri, describe(ctx))))) + ) + + it should "give the request facts to tool, prompt, resource and resource template logic" in: + val meta = Json.obj( + "_meta" -> modernToolMeta(ProtocolMeta.ClientInfo -> Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("cli"), "version" -> Json.fromString("1"))) + ) + val calls = List( + "tools/call" -> Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("ctx"), "arguments" -> Json.obj("message" -> Json.fromString("hi"))), + "prompts/get" -> Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("ctx")), + "resources/read" -> Json.obj("uri" -> Json.fromString("test://ctx")), + "resources/read" -> Json.obj("uri" -> Json.fromString("test://ctx/1")) + ) + for (method, params) <- calls do + val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = method, params = Some(params.deepMerge(meta)), id = RequestId("ctx")) + val body = extractJsonFromResponse(McpHandler(contextServer).handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, Seq.empty)) + withClue(s"$method $params"): + body.noSpaces should include("2026-07-28 cli") + + private val samplingTool = tool("needs_sampling") + .withRequiredClientCapabilities(ClientCapabilities(sampling = Some(Json.obj()))) + .input[EchoInput] + .handle(in => ToolResult.text(in.message)) + + private val capabilityHandler = McpHandler(McpServer[Identity]().addTool(samplingTool)) + + private def samplingToolCall(meta: Json): Json = + val params = Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("needs_sampling"), "arguments" -> Json.obj("message" -> Json.fromString("hi"))) + val req: JSONRPCMessage = + Request(method = "tools/call", params = Some(params.deepMerge(Json.obj("_meta" -> meta))), id = RequestId("cap")) + req.asJson + + private def callSamplingTool(meta: Json): McpResponse = capabilityHandler.handleJsonRpc(samplingToolCall(meta), Seq.empty) + + it should "reject a modern call of a tool that needs an undeclared client capability with -32021 and HTTP 400" in: + val meta = Json.obj(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey -> Json.fromString("2026-07-28"), ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities -> Json.obj()) + val response = callSamplingTool(meta) + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + capabilityHandler.validateRequest(samplingToolCall(meta), Seq.empty).map(_.statusCode) shouldBe Some(sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest) + extractJsonFromResponse(response).as[JSONRPCMessage].getOrElse(fail("decode")) match + case Error(_, id, err) => + id shouldBe RequestId("cap") + err.code shouldBe MissingRequiredClientCapability.code + err.data.flatMap(_.hcursor.downField("requiredCapabilities").focus) shouldBe Some(Json.obj("sampling" -> Json.obj())) + case other => fail(s"Expected Error, got $other") + + it should "serve a modern call of a tool whose required client capabilities are declared" in: + callSamplingTool(modernToolMeta()).statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + + it should "serve a legacy call of a tool that needs a client capability" in: + callSamplingTool(Json.obj()).statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + + it should "check nested required client capabilities key by key" in: + val formTool = tool("needs_form") + .withRequiredClientCapabilities(ClientCapabilities(elicitation = Some(Json.obj("form" -> Json.obj())))) + .input[EchoInput] + .handle(in => ToolResult.text(in.message)) + val formHandler = McpHandler(McpServer[Identity]().addTool(formTool)) + def call(declared: Json): sttp.model.StatusCode = + val meta = Json.obj(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey -> Json.fromString("2026-07-28"), ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities -> declared) + val params = + Json.obj("name" -> Json.fromString("needs_form"), "arguments" -> Json.obj("message" -> Json.fromString("hi")), "_meta" -> meta) + val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = "tools/call", params = Some(params), id = RequestId("form")) + formHandler.handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, Seq.empty).statusCode + call(Json.obj("elicitation" -> Json.obj())) shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + call(Json.obj("elicitation" -> Json.obj("url" -> Json.obj()))) shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + call(Json.obj("elicitation" -> Json.obj("form" -> Json.obj(), "url" -> Json.obj()))) shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + + it should "serve a request whose numeric id is beyond the Int range and echo the id" in: + val json = parseJson("""{"jsonrpc":"2.0","id":1763561090000,"method":"tools/list"}""") + extractJsonFromResponse(handler.handleJsonRpc(json, Seq.empty)).hcursor.downField("id").focus shouldBe Some( + Json.fromLong(1763561090000L) + ) + + private def discoverOverHttp(meta: Option[Json], versionHeader: Option[String], extraHeaders: (String, String)*): McpResponse = + val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = "server/discover", params = meta.map(m => Json.obj("_meta" -> m)), id = RequestId("dv")) + val headers = (("Host" -> "localhost") +: ("Mcp-Method" -> "server/discover") +: extraHeaders) ++ + versionHeader.map(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader -> _) + handler.handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, headers.map(Header(_, _))) + + private def errorOf(response: McpResponse): JSONRPCErrorObject = + extractJsonFromResponse(response).as[JSONRPCMessage].getOrElse(fail("decode")) match + case Error(_, _, err) => err + case other => fail(s"Expected Error, got $other") + + private def discoverMeta(version: String = "2026-07-28"): Json = + Json.obj(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey -> Json.fromString(version), ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities -> Json.obj()) + + it should "answer a modern server/discover whose _meta and header are valid" in: + val response = discoverOverHttp(Some(discoverMeta()), Some("2026-07-28")) + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + extractJsonFromResponse(response).as[JSONRPCMessage].getOrElse(fail("decode")) match + case Response(_, _, result) => result.as[DiscoverResult].isRight shouldBe true + case other => fail(s"Expected Response, got $other") + + it should "answer a server/discover that declares no protocol version, or a legacy one" in: + discoverOverHttp(None, None).statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + discoverOverHttp(None, Some("2025-11-25")).statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.Ok + + it should "reject a modern server/discover with missing _meta keys with -32602 and HTTP 400" in: + val missingCapabilities = Json.obj(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionKey -> Json.fromString("2026-07-28")) + val missingVersion = Json.obj(ProtocolMeta.ClientCapabilities -> Json.obj()) + for meta <- List(None, Some(missingCapabilities), Some(missingVersion)) do + val response = discoverOverHttp(meta, Some("2026-07-28")) + withClue(meta): + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + errorOf(response).code shouldBe InvalidParams.code + + it should "reject a server/discover with an unsupported protocol version with -32022, the supported and the requested versions" in: + val response = discoverOverHttp(Some(discoverMeta("v999.0.0")), Some("v999.0.0")) + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + val err = errorOf(response) + err.code shouldBe UnsupportedProtocolVersion.code + err.data.flatMap(_.hcursor.get[List[String]]("supported").toOption) shouldBe Some(ProtocolVersion.supported.map(_.name)) + err.data.flatMap(_.hcursor.get[String]("requested").toOption) shouldBe Some("v999.0.0") + + it should "reject a modern request whose MCP-Protocol-Version header differs from _meta with -32020, even for an unsupported _meta version" in: + val response = discoverOverHttp(Some(discoverMeta("v999.0.0")), Some("2026-07-28")) + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + errorOf(response).code shouldBe HeaderMismatch.code + + it should "reject a modern HTTP request without the MCP-Protocol-Version header with -32020 and HTTP 400" in: + val response = discoverOverHttp(Some(discoverMeta()), None) + response.statusCode shouldBe sttp.model.StatusCode.BadRequest + errorOf(response).code shouldBe HeaderMismatch.code + + it should "reject a modern server/discover over HTTP with a mismatched Mcp-Method header with -32020" in: + val req: JSONRPCMessage = Request(method = "server/discover", params = Some(Json.obj("_meta" -> discoverMeta())), id = RequestId("dm")) + val headers = + Seq(Header("Host", "localhost"), Header(ProtocolMeta.ProtocolVersionHeader, "2026-07-28"), Header("Mcp-Method", "tools/list")) + errorOf(handler.handleJsonRpc(req.asJson, headers)).code shouldBe HeaderMismatch.code diff --git a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpServerStreamingTests.scala b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpServerStreamingTests.scala index da568d64..5c60540a 100644 --- a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpServerStreamingTests.scala +++ b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/McpServerStreamingTests.scala @@ -19,6 +19,9 @@ trait McpServerStreamingTests[F[_]] extends AsyncFlatSpec with Matchers: protected def withStreamingServer(server: StreamingMcpServer[F])(test: BidirectionalMcpClient[F] => F[Assertion]): Future[Assertion] + /** The protocol version of the spec's client. A modern client sets no `_meta` logLevel, so it must get no log notifications. */ + protected def clientProtocolVersion: ProtocolVersion + private case class NoInput() derives Codec, Schema protected def streamingServer: StreamingMcpServer[F] = @@ -36,7 +39,7 @@ trait McpServerStreamingTests[F[_]] extends AsyncFlatSpec with Matchers: yield ToolResult.text("done") ) - "a streaming MCP server" should "deliver log notifications emitted during a tool call" in + "a streaming MCP server" should "deliver log notifications emitted during a tool call, but none to a modern request without a log level" in withStreamingServer(streamingServer): client => val messages = ConcurrentLinkedQueue[Json]() val listener: ServerNotification => F[Unit] = { @@ -47,6 +50,10 @@ trait McpServerStreamingTests[F[_]] extends AsyncFlatSpec with Matchers: .onServerNotification(notification => listener(notification)) .flatMap(_ => client.callTool("noisy", Json.obj())) .flatMap: result => - waitUntil(messages.size >= 3).map: _ => - result.content shouldBe List(ToolContent.Text("text", "done")) - messages.asScala.toList shouldBe List(Json.fromString("one"), Json.fromString("two"), Json.fromString("three")) + val expected = + if clientProtocolVersion.isModern then Nil else List(Json.fromString("one"), Json.fromString("two"), Json.fromString("three")) + waitUntil(messages.size >= expected.size) + .flatMap(_ => sleep(50)) + .map: _ => + result.content shouldBe List(ToolContent.Text("text", "done")) + messages.asScala.toList shouldBe expected diff --git a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests.scala b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests.scala index 750f7202..17080f71 100644 --- a/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests.scala +++ b/server/src/test/scala/chimp/server/SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests.scala @@ -23,6 +23,9 @@ trait SecuredMcpServerTestFixtures[F[_]]: trait SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests[F[_]] extends AsyncFlatSpec with Matchers with RecoverMethods with SecuredMcpServerTestFixtures[F]: this: ToFuture[F] => + /** The protocol version of the spec's client. A modern client sets no `_meta` logLevel, so it must get no log notifications. */ + protected def clientProtocolVersion: ProtocolVersion + /** @param token * The bearer token the client authenticates with; defaults to [[validToken]] so most tests need not pass it. */ @@ -83,11 +86,14 @@ trait SecuredMcpServerStreamingTests[F[_]] extends AsyncFlatSpec with Matchers w .onServerNotification(notification => listener(notification)) .flatMap(_ => client.callTool("whoAmI", Json.obj())) .flatMap: result => - waitUntil(messages.size >= 1).map: _ => - result.content shouldBe List(ToolContent.Text("text", "employee@example.com")) - messages.asScala.toList shouldBe List(Json.fromString("employee@example.com")) - - "a secured streaming MCP server" should "give the principal to a streaming tool, and deliver its log notifications" in + val expected = if clientProtocolVersion.isModern then Nil else List(Json.fromString("employee@example.com")) + waitUntil(messages.size >= expected.size) + .flatMap(_ => sleep(50)) + .map: _ => + result.content shouldBe List(ToolContent.Text("text", "employee@example.com")) + messages.asScala.toList shouldBe expected + + "a secured streaming MCP server" should "give the principal to a streaming tool, and deliver its log notifications (none to a modern request without a log level)" in withSecuredStreamingServer(securedStreamingServer)(assertWhoAmIDeliversPrincipal) it should "give the principal to a streaming tool when the security logic is effectful" in