[pm:seat] domain:ui @ objectui — 🟢 os-zhuang · session_01611D6ZaRaMmwTNQmSbk8MH · R1 seated 2026-09-09T04:19Z · refreshed at the R3 boundary 09:1xZ

[os-sales]

Seat registration post for the domain:ui lane — the objectui execution seat (maintainer ruling 2026-08-21, the three-way split of objectui cards into domain:devx / domain:spec / domain:ui).

Body is authoritative; title and assignee are derived views. Single writer: the sitting seat PM. Comments are audit only and never carry state.

1. 当前 PM

status	🟢 seated. session_01611D6ZaRaMmwTNQmSbk8MH, GitHub identity os-zhuang (id 277994282, measured with get_me). Seat taken 2026-09-09T04:19Z
how	Maintainer-ordered FORCED takeover of a live seat — 「强制接管 domain:ui」. All four mutex readings said stand down; the override is arbitration. Readings table in the 04:19Z takeover comment
batch	3, set by the maintainer verbatim: 「任务很多，并发保持3」 (2026-09-09 ~05:4xZ)
refreshed	R3 round boundary, 2026-09-09T09:1xZ

⛔⛔ TIER MAPPING — read from source, ⛔ never from memory

From objectstack:scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs (:10345, :10348, :10176):

TIER_FLOOR           = 'sonnet'            ← mechanical cards ONLY
TIER_DEFAULT         = 'opus'              ← M/L, rulings, ANY design judgement
CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER = 'claude-fable-5-1'  ← clause ①/② work

⛔⛔ CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER is MEASURED UNAVAILABLE — four readings on 2026-09-09, each by sending a request at that tier: req_011CesHk4obaXbWbyLv7N2N9 (05:1xZ) · req_011CesRvRDtifao1i75vuaXb (06:57Z) · req_011CesUrRmcy9cg6bJBcUXWo (07:34Z) · req_011CesaQjLmdhQoXPVgd31e7 (08:48Z). ⚠️ The message is "You've reached your Fable limit … manage usage credits" — that is an account quota, not transient overload, so it will not clear on its own until the usage window resets or credits are added.

⛔ Re-test only by sending a request at that tier. ⛔ Not by reading a session object, ⛔ not by inheriting any seat's note — including this one.

⛔⛔⛔ THE CORRECTION THAT MATTERS MOST — the previous revision of this post was WRONG

The 05:5xZ revision said: "Quota-exhaustion exemption is live: Clause-② review falls back to TIER_DEFAULT." That is false and it is now withdrawn.

references/contract-review.md line 60, verbatim:

契约复核 ⛔ 不适用额度耗尽豁免降档:豁免对象是派发,复核正为补偿低档派发而存在。

⇒ The quota-exhaustion exemption covers CONSTRUCTION ONLY. The review is the compensating control for downgraded construction, so downgrading the review dissolves the very thing the exemption leans on. ⛔ A downgraded contract review is never available, never a maintainer question, and ⛔ must not be offered as an option. This seat offered it to the maintainer at 08:4xZ before reading the rule; the maintainer answered 「等项目总监评审」, which matched the written rule while the recommendation did not.

And the gate is not who you'd think. references/contract-review.md:

• line 27 — 归属该卡派发席,交付后收集复核当轮席内完成 ⇒ the review is owned by the dispatching seat, in-round after delivery.
• line 46 — 外部评审链是可选事后审计:分诊定时轮与总监席召唤 ⛔ 不是放行必要条件 ⇒ the 总监席 summon is an optional post-hoc audit, NOT a release condition.
• 落地前检 ① — the gate is 席内契约档 PASS, a 达档裁决评论 on the card.

How to run it when the tier returns: launch a review subagent with an explicit model at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER, then verify by grepping the harness-stamped model field in its transcript — ⛔ 自述档位不是读数, ⛔ 传参只是配置不作达档读数. Feed it only the card, existing rulings and the PR; ⛔ never the dispatch brief or this seat's conclusions; brief it adversarially. Checklist is three items, per-item on the card or PR, ⛔ not prose: ① derived judgments named one by one; ② semver vs the changeset declaration; ③ every boundary flag and open_questions entry answered or escalated. Record the independence pair — Implemented-by: the branch, Reviewed-by: the ruling seat; same session ⇒ SELF-REVIEW, ⛔ does not count. On PASS: strip both carriers in one stroke with a provenance comment, then 落地前检 ②/③ (node scripts/pm/check-clause2-carriers.mjs --pair PR-NUMBER; 0 = clean, 4 = fail, ⛔ 3 is NOT clean) before ready/auto-merge.

⛔ Until then a Clause-② PR stays a draft with carriers hung. That is the named SAFE state, not a stall: 「标签在复核完成前原样留置,卡在队列外等待是安全态」.

⚠️ The exemption HAS been spent twice, on construction: PR #8768 (additive export) and PR #8779 (scaffolder behaviour). Both recorded.

2. Ledger

R1 — 4 dispatched · 3 MERGED, 1 closed duplicate

card	PR	merge
#8026	#8765	f84760f — object-calendar reads the allDayField it resolves
#8438	#8768	c03d03b — max_length honoured on every rich-content field
#8513	#8771	fb3a101 — $and/$or executed; $not deliberately still refusing
#8670	—	CLOSED duplicate_of #8451; the work had landed 19.9h before the card was filed

R2 — 3 dispatched · 3 MERGED

card	PR	merge
#8444	#8781	6fae5e2 — desktop viewport stated in 15 files
#8307	#8780	5591f03b — a windowed lane header says 77+, not 77. Needed a patch round: the refactor moved the literal objectui#7322's source-text pin greps for; spelling restored inline, ⛔ pin never weakened
#8041	#8779	6cc48c4 — licence prompt, default MIT, writes the text

R3 — 5 dispatched · 3 MERGED, 1 landing, 2 parked on the tier

card	PR	state
#8782	#8787	MERGED 793af39da — a 200 carrying no key stops reporting Request failed (200)
#8051	#8789	MERGED bc444b347 — a marked userMessage outranks the localized 409/403 copy
#8448	#8790	MERGED b6d07df4b — one horizontal axis for a swimlane board
#8449	#8798	ready + auto-merge armed — region owns the vertical scroll, header sticks
#8748	#8791	⏸ PARKED — Clause-②, awaiting an in-seat contract review
#7980	#8792	⏸ PARKED — Clause-②, awaiting an in-seat contract review

⭐ Every R3 dev either falsified a PM assumption or caught a false green. #8782's found the mint route cannot emit a keyless success (only 201, always with a key) — the arm is reachable through the consumer's .catch(() => ({})) instead, which is why its sentence quotes no status. #8051's found the mark is not readable at the arms (readEnvelopeFailureText collapses userMessage || message with no provenance) and had to carry it across the throw. #8448's refuted my "one shared scrolling ancestor" route mechanically — a wrapper becomes region.firstElementChild, so objectui#7303's pin fails either way. #8449's caught that its own first measurement pass was blind to the bug (see §5).

Cards filed this shift

#8782 (split out of #7980 per its own ruling) · #8797 (header-row scroll range 10px short of the lane rows') · objectstack#17054 · #8769 · #8770

3. 热文件串行队

Free: plugin-calendar · fields · plugin-form · plugin-detail · create-plugin · apps/console.

Held: plugin-kanban → PR #8798 landing, then #8797 (⛔ Blocked-by: #8449, edits the same header-row class list) · core/adapters + fields/widgets → PR #8791 · app-shell public entry → PR #8792.

Filter dialect is ONE region and serialises — convertFiltersToAST / filterGroupToMongo / ValueDataSource / FilterConditionField. #8513 landed, #8748 is in PR #8791; remaining #8568 · #8567 are different defect shapes ⇒ ⛔ not foldable.

4. ⛔ Fences

• finding(app-shell): hydratedMessagesToChatMessages keeps the three SDK approval states but drops the approval envelope and pendingActionId that make them actionable #8442 — ⛔ held. It is Clause-② on both limbs (adds approval to a published authoring type; narrows the state union — breaking, shipping as minor). ⚠️ Its old framing here is corrected: the hold is not "awaiting the maintainer's call on spending the downgrade exemption", because that exemption never applied to the review. It is held on the merits of a published breaking narrowing, and it needs a contract review like any Clause-② card.
• finding(plugin-chatbot): the nested (aiInitialMessages as any) is LIVE — it hides a real TS2322 from a parts builder that emits Record, not UIMessagePart #8426 — pm:blocked, Blocked-by: #8442. Ruled option A (batch Migrate to Tailwind CSS v4 PostCSS architecture #86).
• bug(plugin-kanban): the swimlane header row's horizontal scroll range is 10px SHORTER than the lane rows' — at the right end of the axis every title sits 9px off its column #8797 — ruled (equalise the horizontal padding; ⛔ not a scaling sync), Blocked-by: #8449. Dispatchable the moment PR fix(plugin-kanban): the swimlane region owns the vertical scroll, and the column header sticks (objectui#8449) #8798 merges.
• bug(plugin-list): a surviving groupBy in the kanban config OVERRIDES the lane ListView just resolved — measured active, and now unfed #8365 pm:retriage · finding(plugin-calendar): object-calendar honours a SECOND, off-spec spelling of data — the { provider, items } record-source config the contract refuses by kind #8348 ⛔ two directions a dev may not choose · filter-builder declares one operator vocabulary and renders another: the mirror refuses every dropdown id but three, and every id it accepts but three draws a blank trigger #7561 ⛔ pre-ruling · finding(data-objectstack): the object-schema SERVE path runs no parse, so FieldSchema strictness is not evidence that a refused key cannot reach a consumer #7650 ungraded · finding(data-objectstack): aggregate()'s spec-shape branch never reads filter/field/function, so an array groupBy on the LEGACY shape silently drops both the filter and the measure #6864 held on finding(data-objectstack): aggregate()'s spec-shape branch sends where unlowered, so one chart's filter is lowered or not depending on which aggregation shape it uses #6825 · createIdentityImportDataSource spreads a class instance, so listImportMappings (a prototype method) is dropped and the saved-mapping selector is hidden on sys_user by accident rather than by the design the file states #7740 needs-user-decision · When the @objectstack/spec pin moves to 17.3: PR #7510 / #7520's comment "repairs" become FALSE — rows and options[].description are now declared keys #7635 dead claim.
• docs(plugin-detail): README teaches a detail tab whose content.type is activity-timeline, which nothing registers — a reader gets the OBJUI-001 panel #8114 — suspected-abandoned claim, no remote branch. ⛔ Do not recycle before 2026-09-10T02:10Z.
• ⚠️ A list view's description is served but never rendered — ObjectView's relay drops it on the way to ListView #7199 / [finding] The object-view relay's viewDef is an untyped record, so a MISSING key rung is invisible to tsc — the same defect has now been fixed twice (description, rowColor) with a third half still open #7559 are NOT the same defect as Object-bound actions are hidden by the ADR-0066 D4 capability gate with nothing anywhere saying so — the relay carries actions and the button IS drawn (premise falsified); decide the requiredPermissions observability contract #7234 — ⛔ do not close them against PR test(app-shell): pin that object-declared toolbar actions reach the DOM (objectui#7234) #8123.

⛔⛔ Cards whose pm:queue label is NOT trustworthy — measured this shift

#4695 and #3988 were released pm:on-hold → pm:queue by the #8773 hold audit (2026-09-09T05:2xZ) on the claim «no Blocked-by:, no Restart-when:, no pending ruling». In both, that is false against comments in the card's own thread — each has a written Restart-when: (neither trigger fired, re-measured) and each has an unmade contract ruling. Releasing to pm:queue is also not one of the two actions #8773 authorises, and its scope says 「substance is not in scope」. ⛔ Neither is dispatchable. Recorded on both cards; escalated on #8773 (comment 5598111706) — 2 of 2 sampled, ratio unknown, whole batch worth re-checking.

⚠️ #6830 is not dispatchable either — this seat's ruling on it was withdrawn (comment 5597978179): arm A was already ruled 2026-09-04, its boolean half already merged (PR #8473), its field list carried facts the card's own dev had corrected, and its "#6620 is on hold" fence had been dead for 14h. The real remaining work is #8488 (the select half — a shared primitive, call-site count disputed 45 vs 61, ⛔ re-derive).

⛔ Owed to the maintainer

#8791 / #8792 contract reviews (blocked on the tier) · objectstack#16349 · #7188 / #7087 / #7712 (tier-blocked) · #7205 · #8044 · #7750 · decision box: #7621 · #6121 · #7479 · #7945 · #7946 · #7926 · #7499 · #7486.

⛔ The half-state patrol is DEAD here

scripts/pm/check-half-states.mjs exists; the anchor issue does not (#5986; #7852 records 50 consecutive red runs; #8740 carries the degrade-gracefully fix). Every round runs with that leg unavailable, ⛔ not passed.

5. 说明 — lane facts

⭐⭐⭐ A scripted scroll is NOT a reachability measurement. element.scrollTop = N and scrollIntoView() both succeed on an overflow: hidden box — hidden refuses user input, not script. #8449's dev built a first pass on those and it reported "6/6 lanes reachable" on the broken build — the bug reported as fixed. Drive the real input pipeline (page.mouse.wheel) for any affordance claim.

⭐⭐⭐ A PM landing and a dev's finalisation RACE, and the dev's write wins silently. On PR #8789: dev opened draft → PM flipped ready + armed auto-merge → dev set draft: true again to match its brief. A draft conversion drops auto-merge and merge-queue membership, and GitHub does not restore either on the next ready-flip. No error, no failure-shaped event. ⇒ after arming auto-merge, re-read the PR state; and every dispatch now carries: ⛔ never write the draft flag again after opening (⛔ not even while editing the body), and ⛔ report PR state you did not set rather than correcting it.

⭐⭐ A card body is a SNAPSHOT, never state. Three cards opened this shift carried a ruling in their comment thread the body does not mention (#7980 → 5583988475; #8051 → 5595068828; #8069 → 5594065532, which corrected this seat's whole tier posture). This seat ruled against two of them on a body-only read and caught it only on the post-claim race re-read. ⇒ ⛔ NEVER rule or dispatch on a body-only read: read the full thread and re-measure the card's load-bearing claims against origin/main with a lit control. That discipline stopped #6830 before a dev was spent and cleared #7980 for dispatch, in the same round.

⭐⭐ The pm:queue label carries two incompatible meanings — "triaged" and "ready for a dev". Measured this shift: 9 of 9 cards opened for dispatch were not dispatchable as labelled. objectui#8680 is the standing card; cost evidence posted there (5597643647, 5597997972), including that a stale body previously cost a full dev round (#8670).

⭐⭐ get_session not-found is NOT a death leg across identities — it resolves only the calling account's sessions. ⛔ Use it only within one account.

⭐⭐ The governed surface is exactly five paths, and it is the ADR/agent-instruction tree — ⛔ not the published type surface: docs/adr/** · .claude/** · skills/** · AGENTS.md · CLAUDE.md. Approvers os-zhuang, hotlong. ⚠️ This seat first ran the guard against packages/types/** as a "control", got NOT GOVERNED, and only a real control (AGENTS.md) revealed the set. ⇒ always run node scripts/check-governed-queue-guard.mjs --test AGENTS.md as the lit control before believing a NOT GOVERNED reading. A governed PR is parked as a DRAFT for a human merge — ⛔ never flipped ready, enqueued or auto-merged.

⭐ Presence in a list is not a reading of effect — a control must fire through the mechanism under test.

⭐ A zero needs a lit control every single time.

⭐ A ruling that names a dependency has not created one until the card carries it machine-readably (Blocked-by: + label). See #8426.

⭐ Landing verification is by CONTENT with a control proven to fire BEFORE the merge, ⛔ never by sha. Confirm enqueue by git ls-remote origin 'refs/heads/gh-readonly-queue/main/pr-NNNN-*' — positives only; ref-absent proves nothing.

⭐ Line numbers in a card are stale by default.

⭐ Live E2E (informational) is NO LONGER red-by-design — success on every R1–R3 PR. A red there is now that PR's until proven otherwise.

⭐ A workflow RUN's conclusion can assert the opposite of its JOB's. ⛔ Never read a run conclusion as evidence here.

Tooling traps — ⛔ pnpm --filter PKG build --concurrency=2 dies (CACError: Unknown option --concurrency); correct is pnpm --workspace-concurrency=2 --filter PKG build, flag BEFORE --filter (hit independently by two devs) · ⛔ pnpm --filter PKG exec vitest is rejected by the objectui#3378 guard, which names the false-green it prevents (vitest re-roots to the package dir and silently runs another project's files as a pass) — run from the repo ROOT · the shared verify lock is /home/user/objectstack/scripts/pm/os-verify-lock.sh; it does not exist in objectui — use the objectstack copy · ⛔ scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs does NOT exist in objectui — derive gate families by hand and say so in the claim · ⛔ @objectstack/spec is NOT resolvable from the primary checkout (no node_modules there), so spec-version and case-count claims can only be checked from a built worktree · check-governed-merges.mjs does not exist here — objectui enforces at merge_group with governed-surface-guard.yml, which refuses rather than audits.

Platform traps — a PR body edited via REST PATCH gains a second platform footer (create does not) ⇒ read back after an edit · an MCP issue_write-created issue body comes back with its trailing footer stripped · list_issues with two labels returns the UNION (#7582) · get_job_logs returns only the TAIL · enable_pr_auto_merge echoes an empty method even when it applied — verify by queue ref and parent-count = 1 · the skip-changeset label is inert here · this repo forbids major, so a deliberately breaking change ships minor · an empty-frontmatter changeset is the accepted form for a test-only PR · REST /search/issues is 403 by policy in dev containers, and this repo's search_issues returns false zeros — ⇒ quote a lit dedup reading (a positive control), never an absence.

[os-sales]

Audit probe — angle-bracket survival through this write path

Not lane state. Posted to measure, precisely, which angle-bracket forms survive a body written through the GitHub MCP tools, because the seat post currently asserts a mechanism ("the GitHub body sanitizer strips angle-bracket-delimited content") that a counter-observation contradicts: dependabot's PR bodies (#4945, #4958) carry hundreds of literal HTML tags intact. If those survive and mine do not, the variable is the write path, not GitHub. This comment will be read back and the result recorded; it can be deleted afterwards.

Five forms, each on its own line, each labelled so a missing one is identifiable by its label alone:

• A · HTML comment:
• B · JSX tag in prose:
• C · TS generic in prose: Array<{ a: string }>
• D · bare comparison in prose: a < b and c > d
• E · pre-escaped entity: <div>

Fenced block, same five:

A <!-- os-dev-report -->
B <div className="x">
C Array<{ a: string }>
D a < b and c > d
E &lt;div&gt;

Inline code spans: A <!-- os-dev-report --> · B <div className="x"> · C Array<{ a: string }> · D a < b > c

Control (must survive, proves the comment itself landed): ZZCONTROL-SENTINEL-5560.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-sales]

Audit note — round 7, cross-repo finding raised for the maintainer's attention. Seat post body is authoritative; this comment records one item ahead of the round-close rewrite because it names a production-affecting shape in the other repo, outside this seat's lane.

objectstack-ai/objectstack#10928, filed by the #4765 dev while measuring the installed spec. Unassigned and unlabelled — deliberately, because it is an objectstack card and neither the labelling nor the grading is this seat's to do.

The shape: UniqueScopeSchema's rejection message calls 'organization' "the explicit spelling of true" on both surfaces. Measured against installed GA 17.0.0, that is false on one of them — on a declared index, bare true is the positional spelling of 'global', not 'organization'. The helper readout is unambiguous:

value	isUniqueDeclared	isGlobalUnique	isOrganizationUnique
true	true	false	false
'global'	true	true	false
'organization'	true	false	true

Bare true sets neither scope flag, so no organization key part is prepended — which is precisely what makes it 'global' on that surface.

Why it is worth the maintainer's eye rather than the queue's. An author refused on that key is told by the error message itself to write 'organization'. Doing so silently changes materialization — the driver prepends the NULL-safe organization key part — on an index that may already exist on deployed databases. That is the unannounced reinterpretation the #8323 ruling and the #5082 sequencing exist to prevent, arriving through the error text rather than through a schema change.

Duplicate-searched before filing (two searches, objectstack repo). Nearest prior art is #8463 / PR #8512, which corrected the same field-vs-index divergence on a different artifact — isOrganizationScopedUnique's JSDoc in driver-sql — not on the shared error map.

Relevance to this lane, and why it changed a fix here. The same divergence is why #5614 does not uniformly rewrite unique: true: at field level bare true is not deprecated at all ("stays valid indefinitely … no trap" per the spec's own prose), so harmonizing both occurrences would have shipped a fresh piece of false guidance on a card whose entire purpose is stopping exactly that. The dev caught this by measuring rather than by following the card, and the card is better for it.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit — seat takeover, 2026-08-22 ~19:50Z. Body rewritten and compacted; this comment is the audit trail and carries no state.

In: session_01EuPCi56cnGyykygi3z9w4m. Out: session_012u2pRjcqAYtoEjgr3wwhnK, dark since its 11:52Z body write.

Mutex before the first write, so the next reader can re-check rather than trust it: last shift briefing in the body = 11:52Z (~8 h, many rounds stale); newest open-round marker = the same 11:52Z line; no Claim: comment from another session on any pm:dispatched card in this lane. All three clear.

The takeover's substantive finding: round 16 did not fail — it completed 5/5 and nothing recorded it. The dark session's body still reads "5 cards in flight". Reconstructed from GitHub: #5202/PR #5699, #5131/PR #5698, #5235/PR #5707, #5279/PR #5706 all merged between 11:59Z and 13:21Z, and #5401 closed completed at 12:05Z with no PR — correct, since it was the ordered survey leg and a PR would have been the wrong artefact. Ledger updated to 73 cards / 69 PRs.

Two items were parked for the maintainer that are no longer parked. A successor reading the old body would have re-escalated both:

• overrideNotice is produced, read, and declared nowhere — it blocks narrowing the param handlers' action?: any #5611 / PR Carry overrideNotice on a dispatch envelope at the seam, not on ActionDef (#5611) #5644 merged 18:12Z — and merged as the narrower shape, overrideNotice carried on a dispatch envelope at the seam rather than declared on ActionDef. That is the alternative the card offered, not the widening it was holding. Clause ② discharged; packages/core/src/actions/** released.
• The ADR-0080 page-source styling retraction reached 3 of 11 prose sites — 8 more still teach "JSX/HTML + Tailwind", in two spellings #5461's grep cannot see #5469 / PR Finish the ADR-0080 page-source styling retraction across the remaining 8 prose sites #5665 merged 16:04Z.

One standing prohibition needs re-reading rather than inheriting. The old body said "do not dispatch a card that must touch content/docs/** or apps/site/** until #5668 is fixed." #5668 is still open (domain:devx, assigned, pm:blocked) — but #5665, whose diff does touch content/docs/**, merged at 16:04Z, so the practical block has lifted. Both facts are recorded in §5 without collapsing them into each other; round 17's briefs carry a stop-and-report rather than an assumption in either direction.

Two corrections to inherited practice, both measured this round and both in §5:

1. scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs is the wrong tree for this lane. It lives in objectstack and derives against objectstack's workflows; objectui has no scripts/pm/ at all. Pointed at objectui paths it prints a confident, well-formatted gate list — check:slot-lookup, check-plugin-teardown-shape and four more — none of which exists in objectui. Its --tier line remains usable as a floor; its gate families are not. objectui's real gates come from its own 22 workflows and root package.json.
2. Clause ② trips on the SURFACE, not the package. Round 17 has one card editing packages/types that does trip (theme.zod.ts re-exports spec zod validators by reference — the spec-mirroring face) and one editing packages/auth that does not (an internal React hook no metadata author writes against). Published ≠ contract face.

Two maintainer instructions recorded in §1 as policy, superseding inherited lines: 「并发保持3」 (replaces the standing batch-5) and 「你虽然是 opus，但是可以派 fable 的卡」 — the latter is why round 17's clause-② card went out at CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER instead of below-tier with a compensating label, which matters here because needs:contract-review does not exist in this repo at all (ensure-pm-labels.sh:238 creates it for objectstack only).

Round 17 dispatched 19:58Z: #5710 (claude-fable-5), #5619 (opus), #5637 (opus), all mode:subagent, fences disjoint.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit — mid-round state changes, round 17. Body refreshes at the round boundary as usual; these are recorded now rather than held in session memory, since two of them correct the body I wrote an hour ago.

1. §6 was wrong about #5344 the moment I wrote it — my error, and the freshness gate is what caught it. I carried the predecessor's "awaiting the maintainer" entry forward without re-reading the card. #5344 had in fact been ruled at 2026-08-22T02:25Z in the 「接受所有」 decision-inbox batch: option D now, option A conditional on a legacy population being proven to exist. The predecessor's §6 had been stale for ~9 hours and I inherited the staleness instead of measuring it. The rule that would have prevented this is the one already in the notes — re-read comments later than the body before recording or re-recording a decision — and it applies to the body I am writing, not only to the cards I am dispatching.

2. The conditional is now closed. Maintainer, 2026-08-22, verbatim: 「无」 — there is no known population of pre-#4001 stored view documents carrying accessorKey columns. So D alone; A does not land, patchIdentity's writeback is untouched, and column-identity.ts:36-47 is not amended (that obligation was attached to A only). Recorded on the card with the consequences spelled out.

Stale-assignee repair in the same write: #5344 had carried os-sales since a round-12 dispatch whose dev correctly returned needs_decision with no PR. Back in pm:queue since 02:25Z but still assigned — a half-state invisible to candidate queries (which need pm:queue and no assignee) and to stale-claim reclaim (which keys off a live claim). Cleared, reason on the card.

⚠️ #5344 is a round-18 candidate, not a round-17 one: batch ceiling is 3 and its file sits under packages/app-shell/src/views/**, which #5619 holds. Whoever takes it re-reads #5619's landed shape first.

3. #5451 re-queued by maintainer instruction — verbatim: 「5451 重新入队」. pm:dispatched → pm:queue in one label write; it had no assignee to clear. ⛔ Still carries no domain:*, so it remains unclaimable by any seat until triage routes it; this seat left a routing hint on the card and deliberately did not apply a label.

4. Two cards became candidates mid-round, and a successor should not assume the batch was chosen from the current field. #5424 and #5034 both carried the non-agent assignee qq9340100 when round 17's candidates were read at ~19:52Z, so both were correctly excluded as claimed. Both are now unassigned (measured 20:0xZ) — the assignee was removed by someone outside this session. They are domain:ui + pm:queue Bugs and, by the age-ordered Bug tier, would have outranked at least one card actually dispatched.

⚠️ #5034 carries a label/body mismatch that must be settled before anyone dispatches it: its body opens with Blocked-by: objectui#4989, but it is labelled pm:queue, not pm:blocked. Under the standing rule a card with an unresolved Blocked-by: is not dispatchable whatever its queue label says. Verify #4989's state before treating #5034 as available — do not read the pm:queue label as clearance. Reported to triage; not relabelled here.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-warren]

Audit — seat takeover, 2026-08-24 ~04:00Z. Body rewritten and compacted; this comment is the audit trail and carries no state.

In: session_019ZyKZejBWZoCSj1NP35wcp, at the maintainer's explicit direction — verbatim: 「你接手」. Out: session_01EuPCi56cnGyykygi3z9w4m, dark since its 17:57Z body write.

The mutex readings, and the one that mattered

Recorded so the next reader can re-check rather than trust me. The three prescribed readings all read clear:

1. Last shift briefing in the body = 17:57Z (~10 h, many rounds stale).
2. Newest open-round marker = the R33 dispatch line, ~17:50Z — equally stale.
3. Newest non-self Claim: on a pm:dispatched card in this lane = none — there are zero pm:dispatched cards in the lane.

⛔ All three were clear and all three were wrong. Fourteen cards closed in this lane between 19:44Z and 02:51Z, and five PRs merged in a single queue trip at 02:50:2x–02:50:38Z — sixteen minutes before this session began reading. A session was working the seat the whole time.

Reading 3 is structurally blind to it. It looks for a claim on a card labelled pm:dispatched, and the working session never used that label: its cards went pm:queue → closed. So "no pm:dispatched cards" read as nobody home when it actually meant this session doesn't use that label.

What settled it was one read the protocol does not ask for: the claim comment on the most recently closed card (#4919), which says "dispatched by PM session 68ad4d1a-c111-591c-9633-f2fb64fa1803" at 02:09:40Z, with its dev's report at 02:41:26Z and PR #5941 merged 02:50:38Z. ✅ Proposed amendment to the mutex read, recorded in §2: also read the newest CLOSED card in the lane, not only the pm:dispatched ones. A stale seat post plus an unused status label is otherwise indistinguishable from a free seat.

This session therefore stopped short of writing on its first pass and put the collision to the maintainer rather than claiming cards a live session was holding. The takeover proceeds only on the explicit instruction above.

Liveness re-verified before writing anything

• git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/claude/*' — zero claude/issue-* branches for any open card in this lane.
• The only open claude/issue-* PR in the repo is test(e2e-type-check): bring the four root playwright configs into tsconfig.e2e.json #5948 (claude/issue-4477-…), another lane's.
• Last landing in this lane: 02:50:38Z. Takeover at ~04:00Z, ~70 minutes of silence.

Five half-states repaired

Every one was pm:queue + assigned with its PR already merged and no remote branch — the shape that is invisible to candidate queries (which need pm:queue and no assignee) and to stale-claim reclaim (which keys off a live claim). Assignees cleared on all five; details in §3.

#4015 got more than an assignee clear, because its label was actively lying. It is the maintainer's Option-C decision anchor; the objectui residue landed as PR #5907 and the enforcement lands upstream (objectstack#11437 / PR #11560, relayed by the spec seat at 03:28Z). It was advertising pm:queue — dispatchable — when nothing on it is dispatchable here. Moved to pm:blocked with Blocked-by: objectstack-ai/objectstack#11437 written into the body so the unlock scan can reach it.

⚠️ Two judgments left deliberately un-made, and flagged rather than silently resolved: #5674 and #5605 both landed stage 1 of a two-stage retirement, with stage 2 separately carded (#5892, #5919) and currently pm:on-hold — whose gating condition ("stage-1 deprecation shipping") has now fired. Whether the stage-1 cards should close and the stage-2 cards unpark is a triage grading call, not this seat's. Assignees cleared; state otherwise untouched.

One platform fact that reverses a standing instruction in §5

⛔ The REST channel the predecessor's notes tell the next PM to use is dead in this session. GH_TOKEN is set, but curl https://api.github.com/... returns 403: GitHub access is not enabled for this session. An org admin must connect the Claude GitHub App for this organization. The refusal is the agent proxy's, not GitHub's.

That instruction existed because MCP list_issues's labels parameter is an OR, not an AND — re-confirmed independently at takeover: domain:ui ∩ pm:dispatched returned 135 items against the lane's own 132, and a result wider than either input is the tell. With REST unavailable the working method is to request one label and intersect client-side over two pages. Recorded in §5 so the next session does not spend a round rediscovering a 403.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-warren]

Round-open marker — R34 dispatched 2026-08-24 ~04:08Z by session_019ZyKZejBWZoCSj1NP35wcp. Audit only; the body remains authoritative and refreshes at the round boundary.

Five cards, all mode:subagent, all model: opus (Fable quota exhausted per the maintainer's 2026-08-23 instruction — a tier fact, not a density one, so density stays at five).

card	surface (full path, verified before fencing)	note
#5522	apps/console/.env.production + packages/app-shell/src/observability/sentry.ts	Bug. ⚠️ a same-named branch already exists on the remote — dev told to read it and declare continue-or-replace
#5721	packages/data-objectstack/src/index.ts	Bug. Envelope shape for this route face is unmeasured — briefed as a measurement, not a spec
#5631	packages/components/src/renderers/basic/icon.tsx	Ruled (2026-08-22, option A). Clause-②: yes — see below
#5916	packages/plugin-detail/src/renderers/record-path.tsx	Bug. ⚠️ premise at risk — file rewritten hours ago by PR #5917
#5909	packages/app-shell/src/views/InterfaceListPage.tsx	⚠️ file moved twice today (#5860, #5908)

Fences are disjoint by full path, not by basename. #5522 and #5909 both sit inside packages/app-shell but in src/observability/ and src/views/ respectively — different files, different directories. This is the check the seat post's §5 exists to enforce, and it was run rather than assumed.

#5632 is deliberately held out of this round. The #5631 ruling's own sequencing note requires the ui:icon key change to land before the BARE_SPREAD_ON_SVG burn-down batch, or for that batch to exclude ui:icon's row. Dispatching both concurrently would have raced exactly the row the ruling names.

#5631's clause-② handling, stated openly rather than left as a gap. The card changes which authoring key ui:icon consults, so a node authoring name stops resolving — that is accept/reject behaviour on an authoring surface, and the honest declaration is yes. The contract-review tier is Fable and Fable is exhausted; needs:contract-review does not exist as a label in this repo. So it goes out at Opus under the recorded quota exemption, declared in the claim comment. ⛔ The exemption covers the tier, not the scope — the dev is fenced to the ruling's four parts.

Two cards carry an explicit falsification licence. #5916's file was rewritten by PR #5917 (which closed a different card, #5768) and #5909's twice today, so both briefs say premise_still_valid: false with no PR is a legitimate delivery. The predecessor's most expensive failures came from dispatching against stale premises; these two are the shapes most likely to reproduce it.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[yinlianghui]

Round-open marker — R35 opening 2026-08-24T09:5xZ by session_01CSoz9uGhaaSgiq3hshtN7L, taking the seat left VACANT at 07:30Z. Audit only; the body stays authoritative and refreshes at the round boundary.

Mutex — all four readings, including the one this seat added

#	reading	result
1	last shift briefing in the body	07:30Z, 2h13m stale — a clean, deliberate stand-down
2	newest round-open marker	R34 @ 04:09Z — older than the briefing
3	newest non-self Claim: on a pm:dispatched card	none — zero pm:dispatched cards in the lane
4	newest CLOSED card in the lane (this post's own amendment)	#4015, closed 08:08:34Z

⚠️ Reading 4 fired exactly as designed, and it is why this marker is worth reading. There is a write cluster at 08:08:00–08:08:41Z — eight cards touched 38 minutes after the seat closed (#5957, #5956, #5953, #5950, #5949, #5930, #5893, #4015). Under the three prescribed readings alone that is invisible, and it is precisely the shape that fooled the 04:00Z takeover.

It resolves clear, on evidence rather than on absence: #4015's closing comment is signed "Unlock scan (triage Routine seat, hourly round)" — the triage Routine relabelling R34's findings and closing #4015 because upstream objectstack#11437 landed. Triage never claims and never dispatches, so it is not a competing execution seat. Corroborating liveness probes, all negative:

• git ls-remote --heads origin 'refs/heads/claude/issue-*' → 29 branches, none for an open card in this lane.
• Open PRs in the repo: 4 — domain:devx fix(release): key the publish lane on npm presence, not on pending changesets (#5442) #5774, two dependabot, one release PR. Zero claude/issue-* PRs for a domain:ui card.

Seat taken. Batch 5, tier opus (Fable exhausted — a tier fact, not a density one).

Four inherited items corrected by measurement, not inherited

1. ⛔ The body's Console/app-shell Sentry: a live DSN with sendDefaultPii: true is committed in apps/console/.env.production and baked into every production build — the VITE_SENTRY_ENABLED switch is build-time and absent from the inlined env, so a shipped bundle cannot be silenced #5522 warning is half-wrong, and the wrong half is the actionable one. It says the pre-existing branch claude/issue-5522-sentry-disableable-telemetry "carries real work — declare continue-or-replace". Those two commits (e94b85847, f751c0288) are PR console/app-shell: stop shipping an un-disableable Sentry DSN, and make sendDefaultPii opt-in (#5522) #5559, which merged 2026-08-21. Verified on origin/main: .env.production carries no DSN (and now carries a long warning comment), resolveSentryGate exists, sendDefaultPii is opt-in, the ratchet test is in place. The branch is spent, not WIP — the next dev replaces, it does not continue.
2. Console/app-shell Sentry: a live DSN with sendDefaultPii: true is committed in apps/console/.env.production and baked into every production build — the VITE_SENTRY_ENABLED switch is build-time and absent from the inlined env, so a shipped bundle cannot be silenced #5522's real remaining scope is the consumer half, and its blocker is gone. objectstack#10805 closed 2026-08-23T16:57Z via merged PR objectstack#11382 ("serve a fail-closed SPA telemetry permission on /api/v1/runtime/config"). Triage released the card at 01:37Z flagged "P0-family security … treat as front-of-lane". Taken at front of lane accordingly.
3. plugin-form: narrow navigateOnSuccess to the ruled relative-only acceptance set and escape the interpolated id (point 3 — points 1 and 2 landed in PR #5558) #5034 is NOT available — it carries assignee qq9340100. The R17 audit note recording it as cleared is stale. Not touched.
4. Console AI chat (ADR-0057) — post-cleanup UX follow-ups #2477's item 2 appears already landed — packages/app-shell/src/views/studio-design/__tests__/studioChatDockPersistence.test.tsx exists on main. The card is the oldest in the lane and would otherwise have gone out this round; dispatching it against that premise would have bought a no-op. Deferred for re-scoping, reported to triage rather than relabelled here.

fold-or-serial, answered rather than defaulted

#5956 + #5957 — FOLD, pre-registered for R36 (both packages/plugin-detail/src/renderers/record-path.tsx). Five gates: ① same defect shape — both are accessible-name defects on the same stage readout, and #5916 already built the i18n seam they both land in (record-path.stageStateAccessibleName.i18n.test.tsx); ② one file, one changeset; ③ both graded by triage at 08:08Z, neither in the decision box; ④ independently checkable (state reaches the accessible name / labels localized + the role-less div given a role or its label dropped); ⑤ exclusion list — #5916 is merged and not a member.

⛔ Not folded and not co-batched: #3880. #5956/#5957 must add locale keys across packages/i18n/src/locales/*.ts, which is #3880's exact write surface. #3880 is 16 days older, so it goes this round and the record-path pair serializes behind it.

Also serialized, and why — both are surface collisions, not judgements about the cards:

• schema-catalog: all 9 plugin-dashboard examples are refused by the spec's DashboardSchema — the AI few-shot corpus teaches the pre-ADR-0021 widget shape #4600 (ruled, unblocked — see below) behind 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917: both write packages/types, and 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917 must edit packages/types/src/index.ts to drop an export. Different files, but "拿不准就串行".
• 观察:QueryParams.$filter 声明为 Record< string, any >,但仓内下沉口早已往里送 ObjectQL AST 数组 #3909 behind 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917, same reason (packages/types/src/data.ts).
• finding: phase2-schemas.test.ts imports 9 schemas no test uses — unused-import warnings overstate the file's pin coverage #5824 behind 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917 — 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917 must edit packages/types/src/__tests__/phase2-schemas.test.ts, which is finding: phase2-schemas.test.ts imports 9 schemas no test uses — unused-import warnings overstate the file's pin coverage #5824's subject.
• Reverse i18n sweep: ~384 confirmed-dead locale keys across 58 namespaces (workflow/BPMN designer entirely unwired, console.objectView oversized, more) #4730 behind [finding] 「同一 en 字符串必须同一译文」不能做成门禁:281 组共享 en 值里 164 组至少有一个包刻意分开译 —— 记下分母,并点出其中两组像是笔误 #3880 (locale packs).

Two cards were unblocked by upstream landings and nobody had noticed

• schema-catalog: all 9 plugin-dashboard examples are refused by the spec's DashboardSchema — the AI few-shot corpus teaches the pre-ADR-0021 widget shape #4600 — ruled by the maintainer 2026-08-14, verbatim 「同意你的建议」: option 1, an SDUI dashboard node validates against objectui's own component schema; the spec's DashboardSchema governs stored metadata only; metric-card joins objectui's closed enum. The ruling comment itself says the card "is now unblocked". It has sat in pm:queue for 10 days. Queued for R36 behind 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917.
• 文档教作者写的 ActionSchema.condition = { expression, then, else } 全仓零消费者:谓词被忽略、then/else 永不派发、零诊断 #3917 — ruled 2026-08-09, route B (enforce-or-remove retirement), under the maintainer's 「全部接受」. In queue 15 days. Dispatched this round.

Stale-claim suspects for the next round

#4795 and #3965 carry assignee yinlianghui — which is this seat's own GitHub identity, so the body's description of them as "non-agent assignees" is wrong; they are earlier sessions' claims under the shared identity. Both are >24h with no branch on the remote. They are stale-claim reclaim candidates; ⛔ not reclaimed this round (that needs the enquiry-and-silence window, not a same-minute decision).

---

Generated by Claude Code

[yinlianghui]

Round-open marker — R36 dispatched 2026-08-24 ~10:50Z by session_01CSoz9uGhaaSgiq3hshtN7L. Audit only; the body stays authoritative and refreshes at the round boundary.

Six cards, five dispatches (one folded pair), all mode:subagent, all model: opus. Dispatched immediately on R35's close — ⛔ a round boundary is not a wait-for-the-human point.

dispatch	cards	surface (full path, resolved before fencing)
1	#5930	packages/components/src/renderers/overlay/dropdown-menu.tsx + examples/schema-catalog/src/schemas/components-overlay-dropdown-menu/
2	#5956 + #5957 (FOLD)	packages/plugin-detail/src/renderers/record-path.tsx + packages/i18n/src/locales/*.ts
3	#4600	examples/schema-catalog/src/schemas/plugin-dashboard/ + packages/types/src/complex.ts
4	#3909	packages/types/src/data.ts
5	#5949	packages/react/src/LazyPluginLoader.tsx

Two collisions resolved by full-path fencing, not by basename: #4600 and #3909 both write packages/types (complex.ts vs data.ts); #4600 and #5930 both write examples/schema-catalog/ (plugin-dashboard/ vs components-overlay-dropdown-menu/). Both pairs fenced explicitly in their claims, and #4600 is told ⛔ not to add a catalog-wide gate — #4616 records 35 non-dashboard entries a wide gate would light up.

⛔ #5980 could NOT be dispatched, and the previous marker was wrong to promise it

The R35 close-out named #5980 "front of R36". It carries no labels at all — no domain:*, no pm-state. Under the single-producer rule, domain:* comes only from the triage seat and 未打标签的 issue 任何人不得认领. Claiming it would have been this seat producing a routing label.

Reported to triage instead; it goes out the round after it is graded. ⚠️ Recording the near-miss because the pull was real: the card is a doc teaching a shape #5981 just made refused, so it feels urgent — and that is exactly when a seat is most likely to reach across the single-producer line.

Two cards carry embedded judgements, and the briefs say which kind

#5956/#5957 both name a decision (what a won terminus should announce; whether the lost group should be announced at all). Briefed as accessibility/copy judgements inside the fence — make them and justify them, ⛔ do not escalate a wording choice — with a stop-and-report if either turns out to change what a stage means rather than what it says.

#5930 self-describes as a contract question with three options. Two are already settled by evidence on the tree (⛔ LazyIcon ruled out by #5622/#5633 — it degrades an unknown name to the Database glyph, trading a no-icon failure for a wrong-icon one; ⛔ retiring the key is the manual floor). So it went out as a ruling with a falsifiable premise attached: route is resolveIcon, premise is that resolveIcon is reachable from renderers/overlay/ without a layering inversion, and ⛔ if the premise fails the dev reports the fork rather than silently switching options.

🎉 The decision inbox is EMPTY — and that is new state this seat did not produce

needs-user-decision in objectui: 0. The maintainer drained it in a live PM chat between ~09:50Z and ~10:34Z; the triage seat recorded each ruling verbatim on its card. #5631 — this lane's one escalation — is ruled A′ (2026-08-24, 「5631 A′，按一次正经的契约迁移立项。」): the full chartered contract migration at its true measured price, ~29 files across four workspace entries, Clause-②: yes, and the #5632 SVG burn-down keeps excluding ui:icon's ledger row until it lands.

⚠️ Consequence for whoever dispatches next: five freshly-ruled, high-value cards landed in pm:queue while R35 was in flight — #5631, #5853 (canonical = the renderer's live read set), #5927, #5293, #5913. ⛔ Read each ruling before dispatching. R35's own lesson was that a ruled card and an unruled one are label-identical; these are the same shape, one day fresher.

---

Generated by Claude Code