Problem
@capyup/capy-tools registers all tools unconditionally. Several tools conflict with other community packages or pi's built-in tools:
| Tool |
Conflict |
todo |
Conflicts with @juicesharp/rpiv-todo and pi's built-in todo |
ask_user / ask_question / ask_questionnaire |
Overlap with pi's built-in ask / ask_user_question |
fetch |
Overlap with pi's built-in web_fetch / batch_web_fetch |
enable-builtin-search |
Redundant when fffind / ffgrep are already active |
sourcegraph |
Overlap with code_search / codegraph MCP |
A user who only wants read_block + symbol_outline + apply_patch + repo_map currently has no way to load just those four — the entire bundle comes in and causes conflicts.
Proposed Solution
Add a configuration option (e.g. in ~/.pi/agent/capy-tools.json) to selectively enable/disable individual tools:
{
"tools": {
"read_block": true,
"symbol_outline": true,
"repo_map": true,
"apply_patch": true,
"todo": false,
"ask_user": false,
"ask_question": false,
"ask_questionnaire": false,
"fetch": false,
"enable_builtin_search": false,
"sourcegraph": false
}
}
Also support this via /capy-tools-settings UI panel — add a "Tools" tab with toggle switches.
Alternative
Split into separate npm packages (e.g. @capyup/read-block, @capyup/apply-patch) so users install only what they need.
Environment
- pi: latest
- capy-tools: latest
- OS: Windows
Problem
@capyup/capy-toolsregisters all tools unconditionally. Several tools conflict with other community packages or pi's built-in tools:todo@juicesharp/rpiv-todoand pi's built-intodoask_user/ask_question/ask_questionnaireask/ask_user_questionfetchweb_fetch/batch_web_fetchenable-builtin-searchfffind/ffgrepare already activesourcegraphcode_search/codegraphMCPA user who only wants
read_block+symbol_outline+apply_patch+repo_mapcurrently has no way to load just those four — the entire bundle comes in and causes conflicts.Proposed Solution
Add a configuration option (e.g. in
~/.pi/agent/capy-tools.json) to selectively enable/disable individual tools:{ "tools": { "read_block": true, "symbol_outline": true, "repo_map": true, "apply_patch": true, "todo": false, "ask_user": false, "ask_question": false, "ask_questionnaire": false, "fetch": false, "enable_builtin_search": false, "sourcegraph": false } }Also support this via
/capy-tools-settingsUI panel — add a "Tools" tab with toggle switches.Alternative
Split into separate npm packages (e.g.
@capyup/read-block,@capyup/apply-patch) so users install only what they need.Environment