Thank you for every idea. Some have been asked for more than once and won't be built, for the reasons below. If yours is on this list, please don't open a new request for it; if you have a new argument or a different way to do it, comment on the issue linked there instead.
Something missing here may still be a duplicate: please search the open and closed issues of Y2Linux and Y2Reborn first.
| Idea | Why not | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Battery percentage on the charging screen while the player is off | The Y2 can't measure the charge going in or out, so the percentage is estimated from the battery's voltage. While charging, that voltage reads too high; the running player corrects for it, a switched-off one can't. The number would be wrong most of the time. Switch the player on to see the level. | Y2Reborn #72, Y2Linux #109 |
| Stop charging at 80 % or 90 % | For the same reason the percentage isn't precise enough for a charge limit to mean what it says. | Y2Reborn #64 |
| Battery level of Bluetooth headphones | Most headphones report it only over the phone-call side of Bluetooth, which the player doesn't run: a second connection to every pair of headphones makes Bluetooth less steady. Without it only a few would show a level (AirPods never). | Y2Reborn #95 |
| A battery history with drain per mode and time left | The level is estimated from the battery's voltage, which swings with load; a history would look precise, but drain per mode and time left would be guesses. | Y2Reborn #148 |
| Idea | Why not | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Double tap on the centre button | To tell a double tap from a single one, the player would have to wait after every tap, which makes the button slower everywhere. Tap selects, hold opens the menu. | Y2Reborn #98 |
| Wake the player with the centre button or the wheel | Only Power wakes it, so it can't wake in a pocket or bag. What the other buttons do with the screen off is in Settings → Customize → Buttons → Screen Off. | Y2Linux #71 |
| A setting for the wheel's seek step | The wheel already seeks faster the faster you turn it. | Y2Reborn #50 |
| A setting for button debounce | If buttons bounce on a player, that gets fixed for everyone rather than turned into a setting. Send an error report if you see doubled presses. | Y2Reborn #54 |
| Letter scrolling by a double tap on the wheel | Telling a double tap from a touch needs a new wheel driver and makes every single touch wait. Spinning quickly already steps by letter. | Y2Reborn #88 |
| Fast scrolling by two letters (Aa, Ab, Ac…) | Most libraries have few items under each pair; a spin would step through dozens of tiny groups. One letter per detent, then row by row. | Y2Linux #114 |
| Keep the highlight at the bottom while letter-scrolling down | Each letter's first row goes to the top, both directions; the bottom felt clunky (Y2Reborn #91). | Y2Reborn #142 |
| Idea | Why not | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Reorder the rows of a menu | Every menu lists its actions in the same order, so each action is in the same place wherever you are. (The places on Home can be reordered: Settings → Customize → Home Menu.) | Y2Linux #66, Y2Reborn #98 |
| Play state and track time in the standard status bar | The standard bar stays clock, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and battery. A skin can show both anywhere: see the skin guide. | Y2Linux #69 |
| More Cover Flow and artist display modes | Different looks are what skins are for; the player itself keeps one. | Y2Reborn #65 |
| Sort options for Audiobooks | One order: in progress first, then new ones A to Z, then finished. | Y2Reborn #27 |
| A visual skin editor | A whole application of its own that would have to follow every change of the skin format. Start from a shipped skin instead. | Y2Reborn #115 |
| A timer or stopwatch | Reborn is a music player; the Sleep Timer covers falling asleep. | Y2Reborn #121 |
| Schedules for skins and brightness | Many settings for one use. A light Reborn skin is planned (Y2Linux #112); switching stays in Settings → Skin. | Y2Reborn #89 |
| The equalizer in the Quick Menu instead of the Sleep Timer | The Quick Menu holds what you change on the go; the equalizer is set once, in Settings → Sound. | Y2Reborn #159 |
| Idea | Why not | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| More volume or gain for Bluetooth, or with an equalizer profile | The player lowers the level just enough that the profile's highest boost can't distort. Louder would mean distortion; a profile with smaller boosts keeps more volume. | Y2Linux #80 |
| Playing above 44.1 kHz on the headphone jack (96 kHz and up, "bit perfect") | The Y2's chip sends audio to the DAC at 44.1 or 48 kHz only, and 48 kHz needs the DAC's PLL, which stopped the crystal on some players (Y2Linux #52); the stock firmware plays everything at 44.1 kHz too. Higher rates are converted down; 24-bit depth is kept. | Y2Reborn #122 |
| Crossfade or gapless on a manual skip | A skip should be immediate. Gapless and crossfade apply when one song runs into the next. | Y2Linux #65 |
| More Bluetooth range or steadier Bluetooth (dropouts in a pocket, at a distance or in crowded places; AirPods silent after a dropout) | Every Bluetooth report was checked again for Beta 9.3.34: the player's side is clean, and it already does what a phone does (adaptive rate, staying off the Wi-Fi channel, Wi-Fi resting while music plays, bounded catch-up). What remains is the Y2's one small radio, which shares its antenna with Wi-Fi. For listening without dropouts, use wired headphones. | Y2Linux #99, #129, #130, Y2Reborn #132 |
| A Shuffle of its own per list, or a default Shuffle per kind of list | One Shuffle setting (Now Playing's menu: Off, Songs, Albums) decides how lists play; an album always plays in order, and every list has Shuffle All for a shuffle just this once. | Y2Reborn #63 |
| Previous goes to the song above in the list after Shuffle is turned off | Previous goes back through what you actually heard, the History at the top of Up Next, the same everywhere. Turning Shuffle off changes only what comes next. | Y2Reborn #160 |
| A "random" button in the lists, and stop at the end of an album | Shuffle Albums plays whole albums in random order, each in its own order; Music's Recently Added, Recently Played and Most Played help pick something. | Y2Reborn #108 |
| Smart playlists with rules | A rule editor is a lot to work through with a wheel. Music's Recently Added, Recently Played and Most Played cover what they are mostly used for. | Y2Reborn #110 |
| One audiobook file longer than about 30 hours | Rare, and it would need a new way to read the book's index in pieces. Settings → Library says when a file is too long; books split into parts play with chapters. | Y2Linux #84 |
| Idea | Why not | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| WPA3-only Wi-Fi networks | The Y2's Wi-Fi chip is too old for WPA3. A "WPA2/WPA3 mixed" setting on the router works. | Y2Linux #91 |