@@ -25,14 +25,17 @@ New ideas go to **Backlog** unless they materially change the current gate.
2525
2626## Phase 0 — Review-context v1 functional contract
2727
28- Status: ** IN PROGRESS **
28+ Status: ** PASS — E1 **
2929
30- Current implementation PR: ` #128 feat(review): add bounded review-context packets `
30+ Merged implementation: PR ` #128 feat(review): add bounded review-context packets `
31+ Squash commit: ` 2c56b10ff32d588d9d660a586c0defee5a3d76d1 `
3132
3233Question:
3334
3435> Can the public project reliably compile a bounded, versioned review-context packet from an exact committed git change without an LLM?
3536
37+ Answer at E1: ** yes, functionally** . This does not imply retrieval or reviewer-quality value.
38+
3639### Deliverables
3740
3841- [x] review-context core packet builder
@@ -50,40 +53,37 @@ Question:
5053- [x] executable-wrapper smoke test
5154- [x] public review-context documentation
5255- [x] autonomous product spec and gated roadmap
53- - [ ] CI quality gate green
54- - [ ] CI functional test gate green
55- - [ ] squash merge to ` master `
56+ - [x ] CI quality gate green
57+ - [x ] CI functional test gate green
58+ - [x ] squash merge to ` master `
5659
5760### Gate G0 — Functional publishability
5861
59- PASS only if all are true :
62+ PASS evidence :
6063
61- - [ ] ` pnpm lint ` has zero errors
62- - [ ] ` pnpm format:check ` passes
63- - [ ] ` pnpm type-check ` passes
64- - [ ] ` pnpm build ` passes
65- - [ ] full test suite passes
66- - [ ] executable wrapper smoke passes
67- - [ ] PR remains mergeable
68- - [ ] docs describe actual behavior and limitations
69- - [ ] no performance/reviewer-quality claim has been added
64+ - [x ] ` pnpm lint ` has zero errors
65+ - [x ] ` pnpm format:check ` passes
66+ - [x ] ` pnpm type-check ` passes
67+ - [x ] ` pnpm build ` passes
68+ - [x ] full test suite passes
69+ - [x ] executable wrapper smoke passes
70+ - [x ] PR was mergeable
71+ - [x ] docs describe actual behavior and limitations
72+ - [x ] no performance/reviewer-quality claim was added
7073
71- On PASS:
74+ CI evidence: workflow run ` 32585647263 ` — Quality Checks ** success ** , Functional Tests ** success ** .
7275
73- - squash merge PR #128
74- - evidence level becomes ** E1** for the review-context surface
75- - move immediately to Phase 1
76+ Result:
7677
77- On FAIL:
78-
79- - fix only the failing G0 requirement
80- - do not add features
78+ - Gate G0: ** PASS**
79+ - Evidence level: ** E1**
80+ - Phase 1 is now the only active flagship phase
8181
8282---
8383
8484# Phase 1 — Freeze the first honest review-context evaluation
8585
86- Status: ** BLOCKED BY G0 **
86+ Status: ** ACTIVE **
8787
8888Question:
8989
@@ -506,14 +506,12 @@ Promotion rule:
506506
507507# Immediate Next Action
508508
509- ** Do not start Phase 1 yet.**
510-
511- Finish G0 on PR #128 :
509+ ** Phase 1 only: freeze the evaluation before tuning anything.**
512510
513- 1 . make ` src/review-context.ts ` exactly Prettier-compliant
514- 2 . get quality checks green
515- 3 . get full functional tests green, including the executable wrapper smoke
516- 4 . remove any temporary verification-only workflow/artifact before merge
517- 5 . squash merge PR # 128
518- 6 . mark G0 PASS
519- 7 . only then freeze the Phase 1 evaluation
511+ 1 . source candidate public review/bug-fix tasks
512+ 2 . select at least 20 tasks across at least 5 repos and 3 language ecosystems
513+ 3 . define ground truth and inclusion/exclusion rules without treatment output
514+ 4 . define the simple baselines and equalized budgets
515+ 5 . commit the manifest, scorer, limits, failure policy, and report schema
516+ 6 . fingerprint the frozen set
517+ 7 . only after G1 PASS may any claim-bearing treatment run begin
0 commit comments