Skip to content

Commit cc54fb5

Browse files
authored
docs: mark review-context G0 passed
Record the completed functional publishability gate, evidence level E1, and Phase 1 as the active benchmark-freeze work.
1 parent 2c56b10 commit cc54fb5

1 file changed

Lines changed: 32 additions & 34 deletions

File tree

.planning/ROADMAP.md

Lines changed: 32 additions & 34 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -25,14 +25,17 @@ New ideas go to **Backlog** unless they materially change the current gate.
2525

2626
## Phase 0 — Review-context v1 functional contract
2727

28-
Status: **IN PROGRESS**
28+
Status: **PASS — E1**
2929

30-
Current implementation PR: `#128 feat(review): add bounded review-context packets`
30+
Merged implementation: PR `#128 feat(review): add bounded review-context packets`
31+
Squash commit: `2c56b10ff32d588d9d660a586c0defee5a3d76d1`
3132

3233
Question:
3334

3435
> Can the public project reliably compile a bounded, versioned review-context packet from an exact committed git change without an LLM?
3536
37+
Answer at E1: **yes, functionally**. This does not imply retrieval or reviewer-quality value.
38+
3639
### Deliverables
3740

3841
- [x] review-context core packet builder
@@ -50,40 +53,37 @@ Question:
5053
- [x] executable-wrapper smoke test
5154
- [x] public review-context documentation
5255
- [x] autonomous product spec and gated roadmap
53-
- [ ] CI quality gate green
54-
- [ ] CI functional test gate green
55-
- [ ] squash merge to `master`
56+
- [x] CI quality gate green
57+
- [x] CI functional test gate green
58+
- [x] squash merge to `master`
5659

5760
### Gate G0 — Functional publishability
5861

59-
PASS only if all are true:
62+
PASS evidence:
6063

61-
- [ ] `pnpm lint` has zero errors
62-
- [ ] `pnpm format:check` passes
63-
- [ ] `pnpm type-check` passes
64-
- [ ] `pnpm build` passes
65-
- [ ] full test suite passes
66-
- [ ] executable wrapper smoke passes
67-
- [ ] PR remains mergeable
68-
- [ ] docs describe actual behavior and limitations
69-
- [ ] no performance/reviewer-quality claim has been added
64+
- [x] `pnpm lint` has zero errors
65+
- [x] `pnpm format:check` passes
66+
- [x] `pnpm type-check` passes
67+
- [x] `pnpm build` passes
68+
- [x] full test suite passes
69+
- [x] executable wrapper smoke passes
70+
- [x] PR was mergeable
71+
- [x] docs describe actual behavior and limitations
72+
- [x] no performance/reviewer-quality claim was added
7073

71-
On PASS:
74+
CI evidence: workflow run `32585647263` — Quality Checks **success**, Functional Tests **success**.
7275

73-
- squash merge PR #128
74-
- evidence level becomes **E1** for the review-context surface
75-
- move immediately to Phase 1
76+
Result:
7677

77-
On FAIL:
78-
79-
- fix only the failing G0 requirement
80-
- do not add features
78+
- Gate G0: **PASS**
79+
- Evidence level: **E1**
80+
- Phase 1 is now the only active flagship phase
8181

8282
---
8383

8484
# Phase 1 — Freeze the first honest review-context evaluation
8585

86-
Status: **BLOCKED BY G0**
86+
Status: **ACTIVE**
8787

8888
Question:
8989

@@ -506,14 +506,12 @@ Promotion rule:
506506

507507
# Immediate Next Action
508508

509-
**Do not start Phase 1 yet.**
510-
511-
Finish G0 on PR #128:
509+
**Phase 1 only: freeze the evaluation before tuning anything.**
512510

513-
1. make `src/review-context.ts` exactly Prettier-compliant
514-
2. get quality checks green
515-
3. get full functional tests green, including the executable wrapper smoke
516-
4. remove any temporary verification-only workflow/artifact before merge
517-
5. squash merge PR #128
518-
6. mark G0 PASS
519-
7. only then freeze the Phase 1 evaluation
511+
1. source candidate public review/bug-fix tasks
512+
2. select at least 20 tasks across at least 5 repos and 3 language ecosystems
513+
3. define ground truth and inclusion/exclusion rules without treatment output
514+
4. define the simple baselines and equalized budgets
515+
5. commit the manifest, scorer, limits, failure policy, and report schema
516+
6. fingerprint the frozen set
517+
7. only after G1 PASS may any claim-bearing treatment run begin

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)