Skip to content

Clarification on nuScenes implementation details for reproduction #8

Description

@pirotyyy

Hi, thank you for the excellent work.

I understand that you may be busy, so please feel free to answer only when you have time.
I am trying to reproduce / port the SeerDrive nuScenes setting based on SSR, and I would really appreciate some clarification on the nuScenes-specific implementation details.

  1. BEV resolution

    • The paper says the nuScenes BEV feature is 100x100, while future BEV map prediction is downsampled to 8x8.
    • Is the current semantic map predicted from 8x8 features, or from the full 100x100 BEV?
    • Does the planner consume the 8x8 future BEV feature, the 100x100 current BEV feature, or both?
  2. Semantic head and semantic loss

    • Is the semantic head architecture for nuScenes the same as the released NAVSIM implementation?
    • Do you use CE or focal loss for semantic maps on nuScenes?
  3. Object detection

    • Are object detection losses / heads also used in the nuScenes experiments?
  4. Trajectory anchors and multimodality

    • The paper says nuScenes uses 6 trajectory modes. Are these anchors generated by k-means on the nuScenes training set?
    • Are anchors command-conditioned, or shared across commands?
    • Do the anchors include yaw / heading, or only xy trajectories?
  5. Reward heads and inference-time mode selection

    • Are imitation reward and simulation reward both used for nuScenes?
    • During inference, how is the final trajectory mode selected?
      • imitation reward only?
      • simulation reward only?
      • weighted fusion of imitation reward and simulation reward?
      • WoTE or another filtering method?
    • If weighted fusion is used, could you share the weights?
  6. Ego status inputs

    • Does the nuScenes model use ego status features such as velocity / acceleration / ego_lcf_feat?
    • Or is the planner trained only from sensor BEV features and trajectory anchors?

These details would be very helpful for reproducing the nuScenes results and adapting the model to SSR-style nuScenes data.

If it is easier for you, I would also be happy to check the nuScenes implementation by myself if you can share the relevant code or config privately. My email is: hhiroki1423@gmail.com .

Thank you again for your work and for any guidance you can provide.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions